Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
211
=!J%A * +D" !H?"+* !D=*+!&= !E%C"F E"#$&"
"#+?A= D&"$= <%+"& (= ).
K"EI'#$&', +' T+!!' +, «K! D#$!#*& %-
I#$$!"& !D=*+!&= !E%C"F * #%" $!@"&?", @!'#A+!-
@! =<*& $ E!#?*@» ! E&! E!&!$ !D=*+ @!-
$"&+!; "D #E!J&<' H%D &+!#$ $ " #E%C"+
*+C"!*& += *%'!J?&?;I !!'?% ' +!J!,
!E%C", +#!&' !%!' (E!J E!,D= " E%%&"D= !+*'%-
$"&; H"?%$"& %J&= ?!$%%F; +&$+"& &"&"*& +*?A$*-
!-#E!$&= " &!&M= D+?"& $!M!), !D&!?I$A#
!EH*$+!&*&$ @!$"&+* E+"C" !H!<!@! D #*+*E"#$;
!E%C"F * C"?!'* D !H!<F %A D !!'?%' +#!&' !-
+*'%$' " &"!HJ%' * &"E!&""F +D" !H?"+*.
*' @!$"&+, M! !EH*$+!&*;$A#, ';$A &"E!&"$ #*'',
&D<%' * &"E!&"= +#!&= (!D=*+!&=) !+*'%$=.
=!< D E!$%H E#+!% !H"@* @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& "
#&!I<#!@! ,= =!J% ! +# H+"& ? E"EI'#$&, M!
D"F#;;$A !E%C", D @!$"&+!; & C"!?A"F &?;$", *#$!&-
?;;$A# ?"'"$ +# $ #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&-
+) &"E!&"! ! &'!@ @?& 5 K!?!J%.
+' " E"EI'C' ?"'"$ +# $ #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!,
&*<+ (@!$"&+) % &#$!&?;;$A#.
K"EI'#$& '!J*$A $'$ & E!D!H!<F <# * #&!,= +-
#= @!$"&+!&* &*<+* (@!$"&+*) & '%J=, M! % E%%&M*;$A
*#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +#. !$"&+!& &*<+ (@!$"&+), M! E%%-
&M*I &#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +#, !H!&’D+!&! DI$A# ! H+"&
? ,, D=*& H+"&#A+" =*+. "!+%'?%" E"!D"-
? E"EI'#$& — ;<= !#"H '!J*$A D&$ @!$"&+!&* &-
*<+* (@!$"&+*) H%DE!#%%A! ! +# $+= ;<= !#"H H!
! H*A-+!@! H+* ? ,, E%%+D* " D=*& H+"&#A+"
=*+ DD<%= ;<= !#"H. T &"#*$!#$" H+"& @!$"&-
+!& &*<+ (@!$"&+) '!J% D&$# ! !E%$!"& E!R$!&!@!
D&’D+* ? ,, E%%+D* H+"&#A+" =*+ E"EI'#$&.
T& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) D"F#;I$A# #'!#$"F-
! H! <%%D &"E!&"" #?*JH, +' D@"! "D D+!!&#$&!'
+, ! E&! E%%&%D% &?;$= C"!#$%F $ "-
+#C"; +!R$"&.
T& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) '!J% D"F#;&$#
? D=*& H*A-+F H+"&#A+F =*!+ E"EI'#$&
(E"EI'C
) F!@! &H".
!$"&+!& &*<+ (@!$"&+) E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&), * $!'*
<#?" @!$"&+, !%J D H+*, &+!#$!&*;$A# ' ? D-
. .
212
H%DE%<% E!$%H, M! &+;$A * E!C%#" ,= *+C"!*&,
$+!J ? E!&%% !D=*+"& D H;J%$' $ %J&'
C"?A!&' !' D E!$+' " DH!' (!H!&’D+!&' E?-
$%J').
K"EI'#$& % E!&" +!E<*&$ @!$"&+!&* &*<+*
(@!$"&+*) * #&!,= +#= E! *#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +# ? D"F#-
% E!$"H= &$$ ! #$ #$!+"& C= &E?$.
K"EI'#$& ';$A E&! DH%"@$ * #&!,F +#" @!$"&+*, !%-
J* & H+* ? &E?$, M! ?%J$A ! !* !E?$ EC",
$+!J E%#"F, #$E%"F, &"%"& (!=!*), E! *#$!&?%-
F ?"'"$ +# E!$@!' $A!= !H!<= "&, *+?;<;< %A
!%J @!$"&+ & H+*. ? E!&%% C= &E?$ EC"&-
+' &"?%= &"!+%'?%= E"!D"?"& E"EI'#$& D?"D-
<!@! $#E!$* $ '!#A+= E!$"& @!$"&+ '!J% DH%"@$#
& ,= +#= E! *#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +# E!$@!' E’$ !H!<=
"&, *+?;<;< %A !%J @!$"&+ & H+*. !$"&+, M!
!%J & H+* "R" &E?$, 'I &&$# E"EI'#$&!'
#&!,' EC"&+' * $!F #'F %A. *' @!$"&+, M! !%J"
& H+* " % &+!#$" D ED<%' E!$@!' *#$!&?%=
&M% #$!+"&, E!&%$;$A# E"EI'#$&!' ! H+* % E"D"R%
#$*E!@! !H!<!@! H+* H! '!J*$A D?R$# & F!@!
+#" (* '%J= *#$!&?%!@! ?"'"$*).
K"EI'#$&! 'I E&! DH%"@$ & +#" @!$"&+* ? &E?$,
+" ?%J$A ! !* !E?$ EC" $ D"F#;;$A# D =*!+
&*<+, E! *#$!&?%F F!'* ?"'"$ +# E!$@!' $A!= !-
H!<= "& D #$ #$!+"& C= &E?$ * #*'", M! DD<%-
& E%%= ! +# E?$"J= (!D=*+!&!-E?$"J=) &"-
!'!#$= (?" — &$+!&" &"!'!#$").
< @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& E" D&"$ H! &"J% (?" —
E" D&"$) D"F#;I$A# &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +,.
< @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& E" D&"$ D+*E"&?; #"?A#A+!@!#-
E!#A+!, E!*+C", $ D@!$"&?; &$!!, #!&, +"' '%-
$?!H*=$*, !D&!?I$A# #$!+ % H"?AR% 10 !H!<= "& &"
&<" @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& E" D&"$, &#" "R" &!H<" (@!-
#E!#A+") E!$%H #$!+ % H"?AR% &!= !H!<= "&, *+?;-
<;< %A !$' @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& E" D&"$.
[+M! E"D&"$"F !#!H" !!<#! & @!$"&+ + &"-
J%, $+ " ? &"R% & CA!'* &"J%" &!H<=
(@!#E!#A+=) E$A (* $!'* <#?" ? D+*E"&?" #"?A#A+!@!#-
E!#A+!, E!*+C", * #%?% $ D@!$"&?" &$!!, #!&-
), $! #$!+, +F & @!$"&+ E" D&"$ C" D&, '!J%
H*$ E!!&J%! ! D&%R% $%'"* &"J%.
213
< &"E!&""F !#!H" @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& E" D&"$ E!&!-
$A# D *'!& D&"$*& %; * &#$!&?%!'* E!+* D -
"R% !$'" E" D&"$ #*'.
T&"$*& D !%J" E" D&"$ @!$"&+!&" +!R$ D"F#;I$A#
&"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +,.
L"D<" !#!H — !&"%" !#!H E"EI'#$& (;<=
!#"H), +" &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +, !%J? @!$"&+*
D +$+!&!@! =*+* "D D#$!#*&' +!E!$&!, E?$"J!,
+$+ H! !#!H#$!, E?$"J!, +$+, &+!#$!&*;$A ,, D E-
D<%' H%D !EH*$+*& & +#". TD<%" !&"%" !#!H
E!;$A ! H*=@?$%", E"EI'#$& D&"$ E! &+!#$ +!R-
$"& D!' "D E"$&%' !+*'%$' & *#$!&?%" #$!+ "
E!+*, M! &D<%" ? E"D&"$= !#"H D+!!&#$&!' +-
,, $+!J !+*'%$ E! !%J @!$"&+ D +$+!&!@! -
=*+* (<%+ H+!'$, +!E" &$+!&!@! !%, !&"+ D &#$-
!&?%' !'', #?"E, +&$C" $!@!&%?A!@! $%'"?
$!M!) D!' D %&$<%' D?R+!' @!$"&+.
K"EI'#$& (E"EI'C") E" <# D"F#% !D=*+"& "D
#E!J&<' D @!$"&+* D!H!&’D" EF'$ * #E?$* D E!*-
+C"; ($!&, !H!$, E!#?*@) H%D !H'%J%A H+!$ " '!%$
(* $!'* <#?" !H"@!&", E'’$", ;&"?%F" '!%$, D!R%" H+-
!$ $ '!%$) *#"= !'"?"&, +" &E*#+I C"!?AF H+
+, & !H"@, M! I "F#' E?$"J' D#!H!' " % &+?+;$A
#*'"&* & ,= #E&J!#$" $ E?$"J!#$". "' $!@!, E"EI'#$&
$ E"EI'C" ';$A DH%DE%<*&$ &"#$A * +#" H+!$ "
'!%$ ? &<" D<".
#!&" !E%C", !!'?;$A# +#!&' !%', &$+!-
&' &"!'!#$', !D=*+!&' !+*'%$', !+*'%$'
D !E%C"' "D D#$!#*&' E?$"J= +$!+, "R' +#!-
&' !+*'%$', +" D@"! "D D+!!&#$&!' +, E"$&%-
J*&? H +$ E!J* (E!&%%) $!&"&, E!#?*@,
!$' (E!&%%) @!$"&+!&= +!R$"&.
#" =!J% " &<* @!$"&+ &
C"!?A"F &?;$" E"E-
I'#$& &"!HJ;$A * +#!&"F +D". !J% E"EI'#$&!
(;< !#!H), M! 'I +#*, &%% !* +#!&* +@* ? !H?"-
+* !E%C"F D @!$"&+!; & C"!?A"F &?;$" (H%D *=*& +#
&"!+%'?%= E"!D"?"&). "!+%'?%" E"!D"? E"E-
I'#$&, +" E!&!$A !E%C", D EF' @!$"&+ D E!*
E!*+C"; ($!&, !H!$, E!#?*@) D !!'?%' ,, EH*$+!-
&' +#!&' !%!', $+!J D &<" @!$"&+ &E?$,
E!&’D" D !E?$!; EC", &!H<" (@!#E!#A+") E!$%H, "-
R" !E%C", D !!'?%' ,= &$+!&' +#!&' !%' "
. .
214
&"!'!#$', &%*$A +#!&* +@*, M! &I$A# " !!'?I$A#
E"EI'#$&!' — ;<!; !#!H!;, ! #+?* +!@! &! &=!-
$A. "!+%'?%" E"!D"? E"EI'#$&, #$=!&" @%$, H!-
+%, !DE!&#;J*&<" ?!$%%F, +" D"F#;;$A @!$"&+!&" !D-
=*+ "D D#$!#*&' H! $ &%%' (+@
!H?"+* !D=*+!&= !E%C"F), ?% % E!&!$A !E%C"F D
EF' (&<") @!$"&+ D +#!&' !%', $+!J E"E-
I'C" +#!&!, +@ % &%*$A.
$!+ D& E"EI'#$&' @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+)
? ,, D=*& =*+ & H+= &D<;$A# E"EI'#-
$&!' " &#$!&?;;$A# D E!@!J%' D &"E!&"' H+!' (*
+!'* &"+$! =*!+ E"EI'#$&, +F D=!&*;$A#
+!R$) &"E!&"! ! $+= &'!@:
) ? E"EI'#$&, M! !D$R!&" & #%?%= E*+$=, % I
H+, — M! (* %A =!J% @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&-
+) ! ,= +#);
H) ? E"EI'#$&, * += <# D+"<% !H!<!@! (D'"-
), M! &#$!&?%F E&?' &*$"RA!@! $*!&!@! !DE!-
+* " @"+' D'"!#$" &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +,-
, % I D'!@* DH%DE%<$ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+
(@!$"&+) & %A ,, =!J%, — #$*E!@! D %' =!-
J% @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) ! +# ;
&) ? E"EI'#$&, M! !D$R!&" & #%?%= E*+$=, %
%'I H+"&, — % "R% "J ! D E’$A !H!<= "&.
K"EI'#$& (;<" !#!H), +" D"F#;;$A #$=!&* "-
?A"#$A $ "?A"#$A D &E*#+* " E!&%% ?!$%%F, *#$!&-
?;;$A #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) ? #$=!-
&= @%$"& " !DE!&#;J*&<"& ?!$%%F, +" ";$A E"#$&"
*+?%= !@!&!"&, D *=*&' #E%C"+ ,= *+C"!*&-
(%J'* !H!$ * &%<"" @!, &="" $ #&$+!&" ") $
!H#@"& &*<+, M! DI$A#, ?% % "R% !!@! D* E’$A
!H!<= "&.
[+M! E"EI'#$& EC;;$A * &="" $ #&$+!&" " " %
';$A D'!@, <%%D &"#*$"#$A &"E!&"!, !'!&?%!#$" D H-
+!' "+#C";, D$ !%J* ' D C" " @!$"&+!&* &*<-
+* (@!$"&+*), $! &! 'I D&$# E"EI'#$&' ! H+* E!-
$@!' !E%C"F!@! <#* #$*E!@! !H!<!@! H+* $
E"EI'#$&.
#$!&?%" D@"! "D DD<%' &'!@' #$!+ D&
@!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) E"EI'#$&' *D@!J*;$A# D H-
+!' " &D<;$A# & !@!&!= H+"&#A+!@! =*+* '"J E"E-
I'#$&' $ H+'.
215
[+M! E"EI'#$&! & !+%'" " % 'I E%%&M% ?"'"$*
+#, $! $+% E"EI'#$&! '!J% & C" " % D&$ & *#$!&?%"
#$!+ @!$"&+*.
#$!&?% ?"'"$* +# E!&!$A# E"EI'#$&' #'!#-
$"F! E"#$&" !D=*+* &#$!&?% ?"'"$* D?R+* @!$"&-
+ & +#", M! E"E#*I$A# @!?!&' (#$R') H*=@?$%!' $
+%"&+!' E"EI'#$& (H! *E!&!&J%!; ' !#!H!;). !
!D=*+* EF'I$A# #$!+ D& E"EI'#$&!' @!$"&+!-
&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) ? ,, D=*& =*+ & H+=, &-
D<%F &"E!&"' !@!&!!' H+"&#A+!@! =*+*. ? +!-
J!@! E"EI'#$& $ F!@! &"!+%'?%!@! E"!D"?*
#+?I$A# !+%'F !D=*!+ &#$!&?% ?"'"$* D?R+*
@!$"&+ & +#".
#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +# D$&%J*I$A# &*$"R"' +D-
' (!DE!J%') E"EI'#$&. ? &"!+%'?%= E"!D-
"?"& ?"'"$ +# &#$!&?;I$A# " !&!$A# ! ,= &"!' &"E!-
&"' &*$"R"' +D' (!DE!J%') E"EI'#$&
— ;<!, !#!H.
K"EI'#$&, M! !DE!<;$A #&!; "?A"#$A, E%R"
$ '"#C" ,= !H!$ ?"'"$ +# &#$!&?;;$A &"E!&"! ! E!-
@!D= !D=*+"&. #$!&?%F D *=*&' E!@!D=
!D=*+"& ?"'"$ +# E%%@?I$A# D +$<' E!+D+-
' "?A!#$" &"E!&"! ! &'!@ K!?!J%.
"'"$ +# E"EI'#$& &#$!&?;;$A E"#$&" !D=*+*
#%%A!%!@! =!J% @!$"&+ ! +# H! ,, #%%A!-
%!, &<" D +#, D "R%' +%"&+ E"EI'#$& H!
*E!&!&J%!, ' !#!H.
!J% E"EI'#$&! &D<I ?"'"$ +# D *=*&' %J-
'* " #E%C"+ F!@! !H!$, &"?%!#$" &" H+*, !H#@* +#!-
&= !H!!$"& (=!J%A " &$+"&) D &#"' =*+', *#$!-
&?%= #$!+"& D& @!$"&+, $&?!#$" !E%C"F!@! <#*
H+*, &!#$" !'!&?%!#$" E"EI'#$& D H+!' "+#-
C"; $!M!:
x ? E"EI'#$&, +" ';$A #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*-
<+ (@!$"&+) & H+ M! (* %A ,, =!J% ! +#) H!
#$*E!@! &" ,, =!J% ! +#, — * !D'"=, M!
E!$"H" ? DH%DE%<% ,= !H!$ E!<$+* !H!<!@! , ?%
% H"?AR% !D'"* #%%A!%!@! =!J% @!$"&+ ! +#
(D $ H*A-+" '"#C" E!#E"?A D !#$"= &C$);
x ? E"EI'#$&, +" ';$A #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*-
<+ (@!$"&+) & H+, E%%H<%F E"E*+$!' «&» E*+$* 5.1
@?& 5 E!?!J% E! &%% +#!&= !E%C"F * C"!?A"F
. .
216
&?;$" & +,", — * !D'"=, M! D?%J$A &" *#$!&?%=
#$!+"& D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+) $ ,, #*', ?% %
H"?AR% E’$+$!@! !D'"* #%%A!%= =!J%A @!$"&-
+ (D $ H*A-+" '"#C" E!#E"?A D !#$"= &C$);
x ? E"EI'#$&, ?"'"$ +# +' *#$!&?;;$A# D@"! D
+$<' &$$' @!$"&+ (+"' &E?$, E!&’D= D !E?-
$!; EC", #$E%"F, E%#"F, &"%"&), — % H"?AR% !D'"*
#%%A!%!, &<" @!$"&+ (D $ H*A-+" '"#C" E!#E"?A D
!#$"= &C$).
K"EI'#$&, * += &"E!&"F #%%A!%F E!+D+,
!H<#?%F E"#$&" +#!&= !H!!$"&, !"&;I *?; H! %
H"?AR% %#$ %!E!$+!&= '""'*'"& !=!"& @!', '!-
J*$A &#$!&?;&$ ?"'"$ +# & !D'"", M! E%%&M*I !H<#?%-
F #%%A!%F E!+D+, ?% % H"?AR% %#$ %!E!$+!-
&*&= '""'*'"& !=!"& @!'.
M%DD<%" &'!@ CA!@! E*+$* % E!R;;$A# %-
H+"&#A+" "#!&" *#$!&. %H+"&#A+" "#!&" *#$!&
#'!#$"F! &D<;$A E!!+ !D=*+* ?"'"$* +# D *=*-
&' !#!H?&!#$%F "?A!#$" $ %J'* !H!$ C= *#$!&,
!H#@* @!$"&+!&= =!J%A (&$+"&), #$!+"& D& @!$"&-
+ $!M! " E"#$&" DD<%!@! &#$!&?;;$A !D'" ?"'"$* +-
#. H?C; «#!&" !H!!$», DD<%* & !$+* 2 ! K!?!-
J%, %H+"&#A+" "#!&" *#$!& % DE!&;;$A.
K"EI'#$&, M! &!H?;$A $ E%%!H?;;$A #"?A#A+!@!#-
E!#A+* E!*+C";, "D= !@"DC"F!-E&!&= !' (+C"-
!%" $!&#$&, @!"' $!M!) '!J*$A *#$!&?;&$ (E%-
%@?$) ?"'"$ +# E%"! D@!$"&?" $ E%%!H?%
#"?A#A+!@!#E!#A+!, E!*+C", D@"! D +$<' E!+D+-
' ,= +#!&= !H!!$"& (=!J%A H! &<" @!$"&+) D H*A-
+" $ '"#C" #%D!* &!HC$& (E%%!H?%) #"?A#A+!@!#E!-
#A+!, E!*+C", E!E%%A!@! !+*.
"'"$ +# E"EI'#$& #% @?A!@! H"D%#*, *+?;<;<
@?A" H*+, +D!, "@!&" &$!'$ D @!R!&' &@R%'
$!M!, *#$!&?;;$A D *=*&' !#!H?&!#$%F "?A!#$" $
%J'* !H!$ C= D+?"& &"E!&"! ! E%%?"+* $ E&? &%-
% D$= "@! " D$&%J%!@! E!?!J% E! ED!&F
!, + E&?!, * '%J= &"E!&"!@! #%%A!%!@! E!+D-
+, &D<%!@! D@"! D E*+$!' 5.3 @?& 5. T "R%' +%-
"&+ E"EI'#$& #% @?A!@! H"D%#* H! *E!&!&J%-
!, ' !#!H !D&!?I$A# &#$!&?;&$ ?"'"$ +# D
E%%&M%' &D<%!@! #%%A!%!@! E!+D+, ?% %
H"?AR% #*' '+#'?A! '!J?&!@! &@R* +?"I$.
217
%?"@"F' !@"DC"' (%?"@"F" @!', *E&?" "
C%$, '!#$", %?"@"F" H$#$&, '"#"!%#A+" $!&#$&
('"#",), *=!&" &<?A" D+?), +" % D"F#;;$A &!H<!,
H! "R!@! &* E"EI'CA+!, "?A!#$", ?"'"$ +# $ #$!+
D& @!$"&+ % &#$!&?;;$A#.
%J&% +D<%F#$&! +, #'!#$"F! &D<I E!!+
*#$!&?% ?"'"$* +# & F!@! +#" $ +#= H;J%$= *#$!&
" !@"DC"F, M! ' !H#?*@!&*;$A#. $!+ D& @!$"&+ D
+# %J&!@! +D<%F#$& +, $ H;J%$= *#$!&
*#$!&?;;$A# &"E!&"! ! &'!@ E*+$* 5.1 @?& 5.
[+M! E"EI'#$&!' ?"'"$ +# % &#$!&?%! (%D?%J!
&" E< $+!@! %&#$!&?%), $! ?"'"$ $+!, +# &&JI$A-
# *?A!&'. CA!'* D" &# @!$"&+, M! E%%H*&I & F!@! +#"
+"%CA !H!<!@! " % D E"EI'#$&!' &"E!&"! !
&'!@ CA!@! K!?!J%, &&JI$A# E!?"'"$!;.
[+M! ?"'"$ +# &#$!&?%! D E%%&M%' @<= !D-
'""&, &D<%= E*+$!' 5.4 @?& 5, $! &" *&JI$A# &#$!-
&?%' "&" DD<%= @<= !D'""&. CA!'* D" #*-
' DD<%= E%%&M%A *&JI$A# E!?"'"$!;.
!$"&+!&" +!R$ % &&J;$A# E!?"'"$' & %A ,= -
=!J%, +M! &! H*? D" & #*'", M! E%%&M*I &#$!&-
?%F ?"'"$ +#, ! !H#?*@!&*;<= H+"& % E"D"R% #$*E!@!
!H!<!@! H+* H! H*? &+!#$" E"EI'#$&!' (H%D E!-
E%%A!@! D& ,= ! H+* " !!<#!@! !$' D +#
H+* DD<%" E!$%H) #$*E!@! @!#E!#A+" E!$-
%H.
% &&J;$A# E!?"'"$' & %A ,= =!J% " $" @!-
$"&+!&" +!R$, M! "FR? ! +# E"EI'#$& * &="" $ #&$-
+!&" " $ H*? D" & #*'", M! E%%&M*I &#$!&?%F ?"'"$
+#, ! !H#?*@!&*;<= H+"& #$*E!@! !H!<!@! H+* $
E"EI'#$& H! H*? &+!#$" E"EI'#$&!' (H%D E!E%%-
A!@! D& ,= ! H+* " !!<#!@! !$' D +# H+*
DD<%" E!$%H) #$*E!@! !H!<!@! @!#E!#A+"
E!$%H.
K"EI'#$&, +" &#$!&?;;$A #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!,
&*<+ (@!$"&+) &"E!&"! ! E"E*+$* «&» E*+$* 5.1 @?-
& 5, ';$A D&$ E!?"'"$* @!$"&+* ? ,, D=*&
=*+ E"EI'#$& & H+* % E"D"R% #$*E!@! !H!<!@!
%D?%J! &" *#$!&?%!@! #$!+* D& @!$"&+!&!, &-
*<+ (@!$"&+).
#$!&?%F ?"'"$ +# $ #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<-
+ (@!$"&+) '!J*$A E%%@?$# * D&’D+* "D D'"' D+!!-
. .
218
&#$& +, H! D &!#$" &"E!&"= +$!"&
!H’I+$&!@! =+$%* (D'" & =!J%=/&$+= @!$"&+,
&*$"RA!@! $*!&!@! !DE!+*/@"+"& D'"!#$" $!M!).
!+*'%$ (!'$&!-E&!&" +$, &*$"R" !+*'%$ (!D-
=*+) E"EI'#$&, M! D$&%J%" (E"E#") +%"&+!'
H! *E!&!&J%!; ' !#!H!;), E"#$&" += E%%@?*$!
?"'"$ +#, #$!+ D& @!$"&+!&!, &*<+ (@!$"&+), !-
;$A# ! &"E!&"= +D"& (!DE!J%A), !@!&!"& H+"&-
#A+!@! =*+* E"EI'#$&.
T$&%J%" H+' ! H <!#$" K!?!J%' D@-
?A" ?"'"$ D?R+* @!$"&+ & +#" E"EI'#$& $ #$!+ D-
& &*<+ <" ! ,= E%%@?*, +F D"F#;I$A# D '%$!;
DH%DE%<% &"E!&"!#$" C= E!+D+"& <' &'!@' *
E!+*, &D<%!'* C' K!?!J%'.
%"&+ E"EI'#$& %#*$A &"E!&"?A"#$A D !$'
&'!@ K!?!J% M!! &#$!&?% ?"'"$* +# $ D !#$!&"-
"#$A &"E!&"= E!+D+"&, M! DD<%" & !D=*+* &#$!-
&?% ?"'"$* D?R+* @!$"&+ & +#".
§ 3. 0
*
" *"
"E!&"! ! E*+$* 2 <#$ 1 #$$$" 11 T+!*
+, «K! %J&* E!$+!&* #?*JH* & +,"» +!$!?A
D !%J' E!+* E!&%% @!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& D
$!& (E!#?*@) * &#$!&?%!'* D+!!' E!+* D"F#;;$A
!@ %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH.
K%"!<"#$A E!&%% C= E%%&"!+ $ #$!+, E!$@!'
+!@! &! D"F#;;$A#, &D<;$A H%DE!#%%A! !@
%J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH.
K%%?"+ E"EI'#$& (
E"EI'C"&), M! E"?@;$A DD<%-
' E%%&"+' D +!+%$" E%"!, &D<I$A# D *=*&'
!H#@"& D"F#;&= ' !E%C"F D @!$"&+!;.
K" <# E%%&"!+ D’#!&*;$A# #$*+$* E"EI'#$&, +"?A-
+"#$A &"+$= E!$!<= =*+"& E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C) *
H+=, &"#$A * E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C) E!$+!&!@! H!-
@*, %D*?A$$ "R% D"F#%= E%%&"!+, !$' '
E!+* &%% !E%C"F D @!$"&+!;.
219
@ +!$!?; H%*$A *<#$A * E!&%%" #E"?A= E%%&"!+.
K%%&"+ H%DE!#%%A! D '"#C%D=!J%' E"EI'#$&
(E"EI'C) D"F#;I$A# E"#$&" !+*'%$"&, &D<%=
D+!!&#$&!' +, D E%&F E%"!, — +&$?, E"&"<<,
"+ $!M! (?% % '%R% "J ! D $ '"#C").
"E!&"?A"#$A D !$' E!+* &%% !E%C"F D
@!$"&+!; E!+?I$A# E"EI'C"&, +%"&+"& E"EI'#$&.
#!H, +" &" & E!*R%" E!+* &%% !E%C"F D @!$"&-
+!;, E$@*;$A# ! &"E!&"?A!#$" & *#$!&?%!'* D+!!-
&#$&!' +, E!+*.
D" &&?% E!*R%A *#$!&?%!@! E!+* &%%
!E%C"F D @!$"&+!; !@ %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH +,-
D#$!#!&*;$A ! E!*R+"& R$" #+C", E"#$&" E!-
!@"& +!$!?; D@"! D D+!!&#$&!' +,.
[+M! E%%&"+!; E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C) H*?! &&?%!
E!*R%, $! D ,, %D*?A$$' #+?I$A# +$ E! E%%&"+*
!$' E!+* &%% !E%C"F D @!$"&+!; (?" — +$ E!
E%%&"+*) * $A!= E'"+=, * +!'* &+?I$A# D'"#$ E!-
*R% D &"E!&"' !H_*$*&'. +$ E! E%%&"+* 'I
'"#$$ &#!&+ E! %D*?A$$ E%%&"+, $+!J %+!'%C",
+%"&C$&* E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C;) M!! *#*% &&?%-
= %!?"+"&. +$ E! E%%&"+* E"E#*;$A #?*JH!&" !#!H, +"
E!&!? E%%&"+*, $+!J +%"&+ $ @!?!&F H*=@?$% E"-
EI'#$& (E"EI'%CA). K%RF E'"+ #?I$A# !-
@' %J&!, E!$+!&!, #?*JH +, D '"#C%' %J-
&!, %I#$C", E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C) ? &J$$ D=!"&,
M! E%%H<%" D+!!&#$&!' +,, *@F — E%%I$A-
# H%DE!#%%A! &"E!&"!'* E"EI'#$&* (E"EI'C;),
$%$"F E'"+ D?RI$A# & !+*'%$= !@* +!$!?;.
[+M! E!*R%A % &&?%!, $! #?*JH!&" !#!H, +" E!&!?
E%%&"+*, #+?;$A !&"+* D !&"?A!; !'!;, * +"F D-
D<;$A# D& E"EI'#$&, M! E%%&"?!#, $%'" E%%-
&"+, E!#? D+!!&#$&! +,, D@"! D +' E!-
&!?# E%%&"+, E$, M! E%%&"?#. TD<%*
!&"+* E"E#*;$A #?*JH!&" !#!H, +" E!&!? E%%&"+*,
$+!J +%"&+ $ @!?!&F H*=@?$% E"EI'#$& (E"E-
I'%CA).
%"&+ E"EI'#$& H! !#!H, M! F!@! D'"M*I, E"EI-
'%CA 'I E&! E" <# #+? +$ E! E%%&"+* % E!@!-
$# D %D*?A$$' E%%&"+ " $ M!! CA!@! &"E!&"" !H-
_*$!&" D*&J% (E!#%) * E#A'!&"F !'", +"
!;$A# ! +$ E! E%%&"+*. %D*?A$$ E%%&"+ !$-
. .
220
' E!+* &%% +#!&= !E%C"F !D@?;$A# +%"&-
C$&!' E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C%'), + E&?!, * $%F
#$!+ E"#? ,, D+"<%.
T?%J! &" #E%C"+ *+C"!*& E"EI'#$& (E"E-
I'C), M! E%%&"I$A#, $ D&A !@"& +!$!?; E"
<# E%%&"+ '!J*$A !D@?$# F "R" E$, +" %
&+?;<%! ! C"I, @?& 7 K!?!J% E! &%% +#!&= !E%-
C"F * C"!?A"F &?;$" & +," $ &+!#$!&*&$#
"R" !' +$"&.
K" <# E%%&"!+ D"F#;I$A# +!$!?A D &+!' E"E-
I'#$&!' &'!@ K!?!J% E! &%% +#!&= !E%C"F * -
C"!?A"F &?;$" & +,", M! E!&’D" D &%%' +#!&!,
+@ $ !!'?%' !E%C"F D EF' $ &<" @!$"&+ D
+#, &%%' &"E!&"= +#!&= !+*'%$"&.
K" <# E%%&"!+ D’#!&*I$A# &"#$A * E"EI'#$& +#!-
&!, +@, $+!J &"E!&""#$A ,, !!'?% &'!@' D+!!-
&#$& +,. "' $!@!, E%%&"I$A# E&?A"#$A &%%
+#!&!, +@, !!'?% & "F +#!&= !E%C"F "D EF'
$ &<" @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& (* $!'* <#?" D #$!+'), &"E!&"-
"#$A DD<%= * "F #*' EF$!, ! +# H! &!, D %, @!-
$"&+ ' EH*$+!&= " &$+!&= +#!&= !%"&, +"#$A "
#&!I<#"#$A DE#"& +# D@"! "D DD<%' & +#!&"F +D"
+#!&' !+*'%$', &"#$A E"E#* H*=@?$%, +F E%%-
&"& DE# & +#!&"F +D" D +"?A+"#$; !$'= ' +#!&=
!%"&, E&?A"#$A E"=*+* & +#!&"F +D" +$<= D-
?R+"& @!$"&+ & +#" +"%CA $!M!.
K" <# E%%&"+ D’#!&*I$A# E&?A"#$A DE!&% &#"=
%+&"D$"& EH*$+!&= " &$+!&= +#!&= !%"& $ &$+!-
&= &"!'!#$%F (E!#$&?% E!$"H= $, !'%"&, #*', DD-
<% E"#$& ? ,= &E#+, &"#$A E"E#"& #?*JH!&= !#"H "
!%J*&<"& +!R$"&, &"H$+"& E%<$!+ $ R$'E"&, E"E#"& E!
!$' @!$"&+, E&?A"#$A !!'?% %E!!&= #*'
$!M!). T !+%'' &$+!&' &"!'!#$' '!J*$A &H"+!&!
E%%=!&*&$# #*' &E?<%!, @!$"&+.
K" <# E%%&"+ &#$!&?;;$A# &"#$A * E"EI'#$&
J*?* %I#$C", EH*$+!&= " &$+!&= +#!&= !+*'%-
$"& $ +@ !H?"+* EF$= $ &= +#!' @!R%F " E-
&?A"#$A ,= &%%, $+!J E&?A"#$A &"!HJ% & +#!-
&= !+*'%$= !'%"& +!%#E!*;<= =*+"&, &"E!&""#$A
'"J +!%#E!%C"I; =*+"&, &%#%= ! +#!&!, +@ $ D-
D<%= & +#!&= !%=, &"#$A E!$"H= &E&= !-
+*'%$"&, M! !;$A# ! +#!&= !%"& (D&, +?", -