CHAPTER 2
28
that the resulting position is compatible with the positions
of objects shown on modern charts (paper or digital) which
may have been established 100 years ago and not surveyed
since. The chart title notes and cautions and the source
diagram, which shows the ages of surveys, must always be
consulted for indications of limitations.
Positions from Satellite Navigation Systems
2.9
1 Positions obtained from the Global Positioning System
GPS (2.57) are normally referred to the World Geodetic
System 1984 (WGS84) Datum, whilst positions obtained
from GLONASS (2.59) are referred to the Soviet
Geocentric Co-ordinate System 1990 (SGS90) (PZ90),
whose agreement with WGS84 Datum is less than
15 metres with a mean average of about 5 metres. As a
result, at present, they cannot be plotted directly on the
majority of Admiralty charts which are referred to local
horizontal datums. The intention is to refer all charts to
WGS84 Datum, but this will be a lengthy process, and one
that can proceed only when the relationships between
existing surveys and WGS84 Datum have been established.
In advance of achieving this aim, all New Charts and New
Editions of charts on scales of 1:2 million and larger,
published since 1981, carry a note indicating the magnitude
and direction of the shift between satellite-derived positions
(referred to WGS84 Datum) and chart positions.
2 The latest wording of the shift note includes an example,
unique for each chart, which depicts how the shift should
be applied.
3 There remain many charts, some carrying a note stating
that a satellite-derived position shift cannot be determined,
where sufficient details of horizontal datum are not known.
It is important to note that in the worst cases, such as
isolated islands or charts of great antiquity, charted
positions may be several miles discrepant from those
derived from GPS. This means that approximately
1000 charts carry a note which, in its latest wording, states
that “mariners are warned that these differences MAY BE
SIGNIFICANT TO NAVIGATION and are therefore
advised to use alternative sources of positional information,
particularly when closing the shore or navigating in the
vicinity of dangers”.
4 However, the absence of such notes must not be taken
to imply that WGS84 Datum positions can be plotted
directly on a chart, simply that the chart has not been
examined and updated since 1981. Annual Notice to
Mariners No 19 includes tables which inform mariners of
those charts examined, but not yet updated.
5 Mariners who visit areas where the charts carry no note,
or have the note stating that differences cannot be
determined, are requested to report observed differences
between positions referenced to chart graticule and those
from GPS, referenced to WGS84 Datum. The most
convenient method of reporting such differences is to use
Form H102b (Form for Recording GPS Observations and
Corresponding Chart Positions) which is available from
HDC (Geodesy) at the United Kingdom Hydrographic
Office. The results of these observations are examined and
may provide evidence for notes detailing approximate
differences between WGS84 Datum and the datum of the
chart.
6 Most GPS receivers now have the facility to permit the
transformation of positions from WGS84 Datum to a
variety of local horizontal datums. The generalised
parameters used in the software may differ from those used
by the United Kingdom Hydrographic Office, resulting in
the possibility that positions may not agree with the chart,
even if the horizontal datum is stated to be the same.
7 It is therefore recommended that the GPS receiver is
kept referenced to WGS84 Datum and the GLONASS
receiver to PZ90 Datum and the position shift values
provided are applied before plotting on the chart.
Receivers capable of using signals from both GPS and
GLONASS are available and these combined sources of
positional information should lead to greater confidence of
accuracy and are capable of displaying the position in one
of several selected horizontal datums.
8 The chapters within Admiralty List of Radio Signals
Volume 2 on various error sources (particularly the section
on horizontal datums on charts and satellite-derived
positions notes) should also be consulted.
Differential Global Positioning System (DGPS) services
have been introduced for the British Isles and elsewhere in
the world. Mariners are warned against over reliance on the
quoted accuracy of the system when using some large and
medium scale Admiralty charts, both paper and ARCS
versions, particularly when closing the coast or approaching
off lying dangers such as wrecks.
9 Whereas GPS produces a quoted accuracy in the order
of metres, DGPS has the potential to produce positions
accurate to less than a metre when referred to WGS84
Datum. Admiralty charts are compiled from the best source
data available, but these sources are of varying age and
scale. Also, in different parts of the world, charts are
referred to a variety of different datums. These factors may
each introduce apparent inaccuracies between the chart and
the GPS if the mariner relies solely on GPS for navigation
and attempts to navigate to the quoted GPS accuracy.
10 In many parts of the world, including some parts of the
British Isles, the most recent data available may have been
gathered when survey methods were less sophisticated than
they are now and the sort of accuracy currently available
with GPS was not possible. In these cases, the absolute
accuracy of the positioning of this data to modern standards
is doubtful. However, where recent survey data exists (in
most significant ports and their approaches and in other
areas where modern surveys are indicated in the Source
Diagram on the appropriate chart) this should be less of a
problem.
11 Local horizontal datums are usually unique to particular
geographical areas and may have complex relationships
with WGS84 Datum. The available transformations and
datum shifts, when applied to the GPS position, may not in
every case achieve agreement to the expected accuracy of
GPS. A detailed explanation, “Horizontal Datums on Charts
and Satellite Derived Positions Notes” is given in Admiralty
List of Radio Signals Volume 2.
Graduations on plans
2.10
1 Graduations are now inserted on all plans, and on all
previously published ungraduated ones as opportunity
offers. On old plans, these graduations are often based on
imperfect information. Consequently, whenever an accurate
geographical position is quoted, it is necessary to quote the
number of the chart from which the position has been
derived.
Distortion of charts
2.11
1 The paper on which charts are printed is subject to
distortion, but the effect of this is seldom sufficient to