England and the Angevin dominions, 1137–1204 571
sheer talent of the administrators and barons upon whom Henry relied: their
capacity to take charge, the protection and control of transportation routes –
both land and sea – the loyalty of churchmen and townsmen, the ready wealth
used to hire mercenaries, and Henry II’s own renowned defensive genius and
quick-strike ability. Even so, the problems which had brought about the civil
war remained.
First, the estrangement between Henry and Eleanor offered no ready reso-
lution. Whatever the motives for her rebellion – anger at her husband’s affair
with Rosamund Clifford, a longing for real political power away from her
husband’s shadow, fear of the permanent vassalage of Aquitaine to the English
kings, which all have been suggested – Henry blamed her for the civil war and
never again trusted her, never forgave her. In 1175 he tried to talk a papal legate
visiting England or other business into annulling their marriage. After the an-
nulment, she was to be placed in seclusion in the nunnery of Fontevrault. Later
in 1176, the younger Henry, Richard and Geoffrey vigorously protested against
their father’s intentions. Even Rotrou, archbishop of Rouen, one of Henry’s
closest advisers, refused to sanction such an idea. Family and court opinion
aside, only Pope Alexander III’s rejection of the proposal ended the initiative.
What Henry decided upon instead was Eleanor’s continued imprisonment,
keeping open the wound occasioned by her rebellion. Secondly, Henry was
unable, or unwilling, to accommodate the reasonable expectations of his el-
dest son. Where after 1174 Richard was allowed a certain freedom as duke
of Aquitaine, and Geoffrey, following his marriage to Constance of Brittany
(1181), much the same in Brittany, Henry III, as the younger king was some-
times called, was never given a territory of his own to rule. He died in 1183,at
the age of twenty-eight, while in rebellion against his father, having recently
asked for Normandy and having been denied it one last time.
The young king’s death, far from settling matters, threw the Angevin
dominions into yet another succession crisis. It had been easy for the kingdom
of France. When Louis VII became incapacitated in 1179, his only son Philip,
ayouth of fifteen, succeeded him. Henry II, as fortune would have it, had too
many sons. And their hostility towards their father and one another had become
a common feature of Angevin politics by the 1180s. Even if Henry had resigned
one or more of his territories, there is little evidence that Richard, Geoffrey
and John could have co-existed for long in peaceful cooperation. Before Henry
would name Richard as his heir to England, Normandy and Anjou, he wanted
Aquitaine for John. Richard saw no real usefulness in giving up real power over
his duchy for the empty mantle of his elder brother, so he balked. Henry could
have gone ahead and declared Richard his heir anyway. The implication of a
permanent union of Aquitaine with Anjou, Normandy and England, though,
might have threatened the French monarchy, possibly leading to war, and
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008