Лісовицький В.М. Історія економічних учень
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
71
%&%/& %'!$+,. ! '5 !%/&! !%&%/%(- #5 #&-
5#&$!%5 > +"$M %$!" !-,/#!M.
!% -$(% +,$&, N %C"& /!$(- C&%, !K-
",/(- %,%C$(%/#!, , /, &%$ K- &, C&#,/( )
! >$5), #* CK&K %'!$%/!&-,/C%/!&, 5&K C&-
% ,%C),: !$( *&//5 "!*!$ #C&%,#!/&%5 , C&,!
%)&. & %! !+# C!#!$& ,"&#K C$&#K
&/&' ,/C C/&, C!+,M&, +!, ) , -
%C*%/(. , #& %# ,&!$& #%$5 /&+!-
', "*,M&%( +!-!$(&& +,!& C /' ,), #
!C5, %'!$+,.
$& * #&$%5 #%-/!& !#!/& /> #C# !
C&/!5 C !K",/K %,%C$(&K ,%/K, #&5#$5$%5, N ) ,5#-
$5 )!!/&+,M/(%5 5%%/M "!-!/ # , %)* + ?!-
/!+5& ,/C%/#. !+#! # '(, #> ! + C+)
C!'( !%! «> » (1875), N 5#$5L
%"M +!,#!*5 C/, C-!& '( %'!$--
!/& C!/, , 5K %'!$+ #&+!!#%5 5 '#! /! -
"- ,),.
+&/&,#!#>& "",*,!+ ,5#$5 C %'!$+ 5
%,%C$(%/#, C!'#& ", /&,#!/& C#&K C,/ %#L
C!', !% #&%$#$ML 5 ,#!5 C /, 5& * C#&
",/& ' !K",/L %,%C$(%/#. !%!C, — C&> #, — #
* +’5#&/&%5 #!+, # -/#, #&-$5. /" %"$&-
#&K C)&K C, , !!) 5- C#&! ",/& C#!
&+! %'!$(-&) C/#( # C>, -, —
,%,%C$(5 +!%"# #&"&'/#! /! +$! %/! *!# !-
>&&. ! C/#5 C#& C#&/&%5 %# '$%C-
5#!, N C/",L /- ,C!#$5 +!%/%,#!5 !%&-
$(%/#!. !$+,#!/& ' * $&> *!#!, 5! #$L &/!/-
%(&& C##!*5&, — .
$ C%$5 +K%5 ")&) C/#( N #&&!L
+$ ,%/& %,%C$(%/#. :$5) (- — C'% /&#!-
$&K C"!!L C)*5 $() /!C# & ?!+. /
&%& #&N ?!+& C&%! %/!/( %,C +#, * )!!/&-
+,M/(%5 !M /%/M. '(, %,%C$(%/# C,-
/&# %&$& ",,/( +#&,/ !%/$(&, N «,% *$! %,%C$(-
- "!-!/%/#! C$$M/(%5 C#& C/», &#& ",,/(
«#%" +#&,/&&», ! )5 C!'5 C%/! ",/& +!%"
$5 *&//5 %/! C>M *&//L#M C/"M, C&'&C +-
C$, %/! C&'&C «*&K +! +"%/5), *, +! C/-
"!&». !, 5 ,%(- '(- %5-/&, 5 >$5)&, N #,/(
72
!%/$(& !K,* C%C/&#&,— ++,$. $&>,
N K C,L &*! ?!+! +#&/,, ! 5K %,%C$(%/# +"-!L
+! C*&/& CC( ?!' &, 5 #&%$#$ML/(%5
!%, +!$&>& ",*,!+- C!#!. <M ?!+, #&/(%5 )!!-
/&+,#!/& /)& $!>, %$(& C%C/&#& !%/!5
"!!/(%5 !%/$(& #!$&&, 5 #&N. ! — ?!+! ,-
%/& ?!' /, K C&/!! !K#!*$&#> &%& %'-
!$%/& &: +!-!$( #$5 +!%"!& #&"&'/#!,
$/&#%/%( !!$!, C$!!, %#! -!+!'5 #&"-
&'/#!, N #&$M!L " C,' 5 /#!!& C/#5
C!', #&/! ! ) #&"&'/#, , #!/%/(. ,/ &#,!$(-
! C!'5 ")& >$5), ! ! %,L 5 %$!#!
!%/&! %,,C C!' %,%C$(%/#!.
$ #!)#,#!/& &#,!$(&K #% *- #%-/!& -
"), #",#!L/(%5 ' # C'% +C$, %/#- C,-
/,. «* &K #&"&, — C&> !%, — /&,L !-
+! # %,%C$(%/#! + ,%! #!),#!5& # %/$(&, %$(&
%! !L K,». , /! #",#!L/(%5, # C5%ML, #&,
' C#’5+! + C"$M %/&,$# C!', 5, /! +#’5-
+!$& %'!$%/&: 5N #&!-*,#!/& *- #C#
K- /,#- #%,, / -,"&/(%5 +%/ %/!! ?/&#
"/&. $ / , C!'5 ##!*!L/(%5 «"+C%( %,%C$(-
M»? * /, C N C&> !%, L " ##!$/#, /"-
/ #&M +!M /#!- ",. %! ' #&+!L, $&
-#&/(, N C !% +C$, C/# %C*&#!5 +! %'!$-
+, C!,L /K * C&'&C, 5&K -,$ML " /#!#. $ #-
! !"+!'!& #&N # C&%!#, N #&"&& # '(, %,%C$(%/#
"MM/( %#) C,/#, ! )5 C!'5 ,/#ML #!/%/(.
C>,!) #&), + C/& !% +#/!L/(%5 / «-
"&) ->K», 5! !> & !+# &/&,#!$!%5. -
"/& «/&,L # %,%C$(%/#! #&/!'M C /, N & #&-
! /!,-/ $(%/( C!'..., +! 'LM #&/!'LM # /&,L +
%,%C$(&) +!C!%# 5,%( $(%/( C/# %C*&#!5, ! 5,
#&/! %/$(& * C!'». !&K C5, #&, C#&
#&+!!/& «"+C%( %,%C$(&K» )!!/ C!'. ! !L
%' " #&+! $(%/ C!' # K ? ! #, -
$(%/( C!' # >K, !% ##$5L/(%5 #&+!#!/& ' /#!-
& ", %$(& ! &, ##!$/%/( %5-!L/(%5 $&-
> # %(,, ! /,/ , *, , #&C!,. $ /
#&)&/(, N ",(-5! &#,!$(! C!'5 #&+!L/(%5 ")-
M %,%C$(%/#, /$(& /,, N #! #&/!! , %&%/ C$!-
-!+#!- #&"&'/#!. ! &#,!$( #&&
73
C!' 5% +, ! /, C#5: -&! C!' C-
-!%/! * #M#!/& -&& C!' %/$5! & %/!$#!-
!. W" #&,#!/& ?,'M &$!, C!'5 C#&! ",/& -
M, +#M 5-%( %C$(- +!&!. ,#!)
/#!- #&"&'/#! ' +!#!5, 5 #&# %! !%, #&>,L
&, /!%?,M& #&/!/& C!' , #!/%/(. "+/#!,
%,%C$(%/#, 5& ,5#$5L/(%5 %'!$+, 'M C!'M C"&/&
,, /, C!'5 * %$,*&/& &$ & %C*&#!-
5. !, , *! C&+!&/& , #&-$5 C!K!, 5&K C#&
/&!/& * #C# ,5#$( /&), )/ +C$5L "$!-!,
!$ / ,#!5 C #C#%/( & %C*&#!5 C!'
C+"!#$ %#.
!& &, 5 «"&) ->K» +!L C/&5:
#!),#!/& &#,!$(&K #% *- # C'% %,%C$(-
#/#5 *! /$(& >$5) /#!- ",. #! #
(- +!!L, N +C$ C,/, * +K%M#!/&%5 !" +!
+#5$(& C&'&C, !" +! %/,C "$&+(%/ /-, )/
+C$5L, !$ /$(& #C# /,#- #%,.
<&, #$!%, #&C,M/(%5 C-+& !%! N &
!K",/(- %'!$%/&- %,%C$(%/#!, +!$&>!M& %# C-
%$#&! *$&#%/( &%$M#!/& C!$(> )!!/&%/&-
& ) %C&/!$(, C#,.
5.5.
!%&%/%( #5, ! #, # "!-!/() >&)
&) 'C'K, %C# ",$ C$&! #&,#!/&
%/- #&+!, $-, ?,'M: %$,*&/& //&M "!-
+M /&) %,%C$(&) ,)#, 5 %/!#&$& %#LM /M #/$5 #
*&//5 %'!$%/& . ! C&+!5 ",#&$, + -
",, >&, CC,$5%/( !%&+, , #C#&) $!) %
?,'# %'!$-!/&&) "&) C!/K, + >-
-, — %C&5$ >#&, C/#M K- + !,# / #
/&,, /"/ # !" !/&#&) ?,$M#!( #&)
C&'&C#, 5 ") ",$ +!#!/&. !%?,M&%( # C-
-! ,%/!#&, /5 #/!!$! #$!%/&#%/ *&#- #5, 5
+#&#!L/(%5, ! #$!%/&# K %$!"%/ /! "& %#,#!$&-
%5, C/#MM&%( # "#’5+# $5 +!%#L5 /#*5.
$5 #5, N #% "$(> +",#!$ &%& %)$!%/&&) %&-
$-+#, #&5#&$!%5 # ,!) K- /C/!/#, 5 #$& &%,-
%M C /, !%$(& //& C",#& #&%#& %#C-
74
$*&# #C#!M/( !$(, ), %,%C$(&) C'%#. -
C%$#&# !%&%/%(&) C-$5# / #&+!&$&%5 #
/: #+%/%( K /%!$(.
>, +!K>#>& #&, #C#%/( &+& //&-
&) C+&'K *&//L#& !$5, !!-!$&%5 #%/& # /M 5
/&#&. !%!C, %,#, ",$ C! !%# #&%#&
C +%/!M, %/,C( %C$,!/!' C!' !C/!$ C C--
%,M +,"*5 "/&- $!%,. «G!-!$(&K +! !C/!$%-
/&- !C&5» C/#*,#!#%5 ?!/!&: /'5
,), !$(&) )# /,5N&) #&5#&$!%5 C/&$*M C-
-+#! !%. /- *, #%,C ,#!5, +!%/(
'/!' #$!%%/ # ,!) !C/!$%/#, C!$!%5 &?,+5 #
+#’5+, + +#&/ !' ?& !C/!$,. " #&"-
&'/# #&/%5$%5 #$&&, ! CL,#!$%5 + & !#/( ,%-
C> + & ,,#!$ # 5&) %?!), !C&$!, , %$(%(-
, -%C!%/#. 5#! #&) ? &# -!+!' —
!/$#, %&&!/# /! >&) $-C$(&) "’L!( — #%&$
$/& ,C5#!%/ # &#, %/&)M C*,#!$ !
! C’5>5 &) %C!#.
% ' %C",#!$& #!),#!/& K %&%$&/& //&& #+-
%/%(- !C5, # !%&+, % 5&) !KC/>&& ?-
-,!& ",$& '( %'!$%/& B# (1850—
1932) " "# (1854—1938), !#%/L'( # <-
(1887—1941). >,& C&& %/&# #&%## /-
!$( K%%/ -$& #&$&!/& %,## #%
%#5/!5 %#5/&) !%#- - #5 — / /,-
# #!/%/, + 5 #&#&$&%5 «%C$,!/!'5» C!', «+,"-
*5», # %/!/, +,$(/!/ ")%/( #$M'K&)
C/#(. < %,#& ",$& /& "$(> "H,/#!&&, N N
# 70- . XIX %/., +! *&//5 !%! -$(%!, ",$ +!CC#!-
C&'&C# #, 'C'M #!/%/, ! 5, #& C%/
+#,$& ,#!-&.
!),#!5 #&) ?!/#, "%/!#& //&&) C)#
C&#&$ #+%/# #&%#, C %// +& # -
K %&%/ !C/!$+,, #$M',#! # " /L -!%(-
-!+!', 5! ",$! /M %'!$%/&&) ,)#. G"->&
#%/( %'!$%/&, !$, 5 '#K / ,),, >$5)
(- #& #"!!$& # #$M'K, $!! %,M&) C-
5#, ! # C%/,C#, )(, ?,#!. ! ' C#&
",/& %C5#! +,%&$$5 %'!$%/#, N +!K>$ #"!*-
5 # $- /! C-!&) ,%/!#!) %'!$-!/&&)
C!/K.
75
>&K, /%!$(&K, !C5 , !%&%/%(K /!&'
#%/M#!# %C!#$&#%/( +%/( #&%## !%! N
)!!/, - +#&/, !C/!$+, &,%/ K-
#$M'K $#!'. !&!$+ 'L / +!K># #"!-
*5 5 , K- //&, /!/,#! %,%C$(&) C'%#,
/! # C-!!) ,%/&&) C!/K, 5 #+5$& ! +"L5
'M $-M.
!K%//>&K #% , //& "H,/,#!5 C+&'K
!&!$(- !C5, !%&+, ",# #%&K C!'5& -
; (1870—1924).
;- %/!#$5 !%&+, )!!/&+,L/(%5, + - "-
,, C!-5 %/- %$,#!/& ",# /! ,), '(- #5, +
>- ", — / #&!*& C!-!/&+, 5&K C5#&#%5 ,
#&&%/! !%&%/%( /&& $5 #&C!#!5 %#)
#$!%&) ,5#$( C >$5)& +#&/, %,%C$(%/#! C /&
#&>5 +!#!(, 5 %/5/( C &.
%#) //&&) C!'5) . . 7 !!-!#%5 C!+!/&,
N #&/ !% +!& %,%C$(- +#&/, %/&, +!-
C K C5#$5M/(%5 , #%) !!), +!$* # %"$&#%-
/K ) !'!$(- +#&/,. K + !N&) &)
"/ «* *» (1899) # ! #$&, ?!-
/&, !/!$ #&/(, N #$&+!, "/5*! ?!$(-
&& C*&/!&, !'!$(&& %'!$(&& C/&5&,
!! +#&#!L/(%5 #C# /&) +!# !C/!$%/&-
&,, 5 ",$& #&/ K C&%! !% , «!C/!$», ! /*,
,% #&%#&, 5 #&C$&#!M/( + +"$- & !!$+,, %C!#-
$&# $5 %. ,/ !/&# ?,L/(%5 #,/>K &, #-
",#!L/(%5 '/!'5 !C/!$, C$/!&+!'5 %$5%(-
!%$5, %/ &%$ !K!&) "/&#, " #&"&'/#
+5L/(%5 #&/%5L/(%5 #$&&. +#&/ !C/!$+, %,C-
#*,L/(%5 +!-%/5 )!!/&) K, C/&, N # C%-
C/&# "#’5+# C#& C&+#%/& %'!$%/& #-
$M'.
%#&K #&%#, 5&K #&C$&#!# + '(- !!$+,, C$5-!# ,
/,, N C-+#!! !% C%C/&#! %,%C$(- +#&-
/, — ,) %'!$+, — C/#*,L/(%5 )!!/ C'-
%#, 5 #",#!M/(%5 , "!-!/() !!) (, /, &%$ # %) ,
#%) %/!) &.
! C-+ !%! C&C,%!# %5-5 !C/!$+
C#- #5 +#&/,, %/!/(- $5 C), ! !%/,C,
%/!M. &&!L C&/!5 C #&+!5 '(- #5 C #C-
#%/( %,!%- %/!, !C/!$%/& %&%/&. 7 ##!*!L,
76
N !C/!$%/&! ?!'5 #* %5-$! /!- %/,C5 +$%/,
$& # K %/#MM/(%5 C,#& $5 %'!$%/& #$M-
'. $5 !+, # +#/!L/(%5 %"$&#%/K /- /!C, +#&-
/, %#/# &, 5&K !%/!# !C&' XIX — C!/,
XX %/. < %"$&#%/ #&!+&$&%5 # ,/# #&) &#&)
%/,/,, 5 7 !+&#!# C$5&, # /!'!$+!'
#&"&'/#! !C/!$,, # ,/# C",# $!$(&)
CK. % ' !#!$ C%/!#, +"&/& #&%# C C)
!C/!$+, # %"$&#, %/!M, N %#&/( C K- «+$%/(
C+$%/(». "H,/,#!M '(- #&%#, C&%#5! "/!
7! «Q H » (1916).
</!$(! 5 C!' — "H,/,#!5 /+& C «C&# &-
,», N %/!#&/( %,/( !C/!$%/& ?!'. $(! ,-
'5 C#%M +ML/(%5 C$+!'LM, 5! )C$ML #&-
"&,, ?!%#, %?&, #&)&/( +! !& !'!$(&)
-%C!%/# %/!L #&+!!$(& 5#&N , %#/#&K '.
C$5 #%&/( $/& #C5#!%/ # &#, %/&)M,
!!)5 #&"&'/#! +ML/(%5 *$&#%/M %#- -,$M-
#!5 ', "%5-# #&"&'/#!, !C5# /#!&) ->#&)
C/#. $ 5N #+%/%(&K !C5 !%&+, "&# +
'(- #&%#& C /!%?!'M !C/!$+, # !C5, %'-
!$%/&&) ? -%C!M#!5, / 7 C&)&# C5
C/&$*&) #&%##. #&N5 #5 ,%,%C$(5 ! %/!-
C!$+, #)&$ # C/&5 + C&#!/M ?M C&-
#$!%5, N, , '#, !),,, C&!$ #%M !C/!$%/&-
, ?!'M ! +!-&"$(. & #%/!5 # %'!$+
C#& ",$ %/!/& C%, +#&/, !C/!$+, ! K-
%/!K %/!, ! C%/!#! ! C5, , C&/!5 C
%'!$%/&, #$M'M. $(& #$M'K $!!5 %/!&)
C5# +!/ C&+#%/& %'!$+,, N #C#!$ C-$5-
! !%! -$(%! ! )!!/ +& %,%C$(-&)
?!'K.
G !&!$(& !C5 !%&+, C#’5+!! %C"! C!-
/& !C"!' '(- #5. !!), 5 +K%M#!$& «%'-
!$%/&&K %C&/», # %/!$ ?'KM *!#M -
$-LM, N #!+, C#$ K- + +5, !,#&) 'C'K
# "$!%/( ##(, -!/& 5- %$ #&/&, ! %C#,#!-
/&. ! # 'K 5%/, # C/C$ ?!%, !+ + !/!%/-
?M %&%/&, N, 5 ##!*!$%5, %/#M#!$!%5 ! %# K- "-
&%#. !+ + /& +K%&K !% //&&K !!$+
&) #%& !C/!$+,, "+,#, L #!-& #%
# , !,,. #5 !%! %/!$ $-&
77
+!#>5 /- !C5, $!%& >$&, 5&K +!%#,#!#
%#M %&%/, C-$5# ! 'C' /,# / #!/%/. E+
#%, !%! # 'M /M #! !",$! /L '$%%/, N -
+#$&$! " #&+!&/& %' # %&%/ &) K, *
*$&#%/K #+!L&& + >&& /5& '%/.
E+%,#M +!%$,-M L /!* #!$ CL!5 /, $--
- !!$+, + %/&& C), N !'/,L ,#!-, ! %C-
'&?' /!C# %,%C$(- +#&/,, 5 +MM/( & -.
!$ # ,%(, +"$ !% #&%#& C/#&$&-
%5, ! +-,/! & %&%/! !+# #&5#&$!%5 %/!/( C-
$&#M %/&$! $- C/&5. / !%&%/%(
#5 %/!$ #’LM !%/&M %,!%&) !,#&) ,5#$(
C %,%C$(%/# , 5 C&> . E$!,-, «/"! !/& %&/( %$!"
+,# +"%/, N" +!)C&/&%5 -M %C"M !-
%! !/& ,+!-!$( %&%/!/&+#! /$,!5 «+!# ,),»
%,%C$(&) ?!'K».
1. / !’"
?
2.
= -
?
3.
@ " ! ,
?
4.
/ ?
5.
/ #" «>» -
?
6.
/ J ( -
?
7.
/ # -
?
8.
= " J
?
78
.
x $ ((
.
x 0 " (.
6.1.
%/!K //& XIX %/. %&/,!'5, 5! %$!$!%5 #
K !,', #&$&!$! ")%/( #&"$5 C&'&-
C# #&) /$-&) C)# !!$+, #&&!M&) , --
%C!%(K C!/&' C"$. &#! !, 5! ?,'-
,L ! #$!%K !/!$(-/)K %#, C*,#!$! %$!-
, %&%/, #&"&&) &) +#’5+#, , 5K -%C!-
MM %,"’L/& C#& ",$& +!)&/& C/&!$( >5.
& +>/#),#!$&%5 + C"$M !$(/!/&#- #&", + -
$() #!!/#, 5&K ") ",$ +"&/& # !!) C#&)
"*(, !%!C %,%&).
+#’5+!5 /!&) +!! + C+&'K $!%& >$&, !#/(
&?#! %/!& C> C$#&& XIX %/., ",$ -
*$&#&, %$(& '$(# C&+!5 %&%/& #! #"!!$! ,
+"$(> "!-!/%/#!, 5 L ?,'LM !-!*5 !C/!$,
&%$(%/ C!'#&#. "$! ?/&#- +C$, -
%,%# C>,, !K"$(> #!$- #!!/! ) "!' +!$&>!-
$!%5 ! +!(, C$!, %$(& ##!*!$%5, N # %5-!L/(%5
!#/!/& # C'% &# ,'. & !% # ,#!)
",)$&#- +%/!5 !%>/!"# #&"& 5$(%/ %! '5
C"$! %/!#!$! !K"$(> -%/M K !/,!$(M.
!"$&+&$&%5 +#’5+!5 &/&& $!%& >$&.
+5#>& C %,# 5 C%/,$!/& C)& $!%&- !C5-
,, #& +-$& +!CC,#!/& '$% /! C$&# -
'C', 5M *! ",$ " ,#!/&%5 # -%C!%(K C!/&'.
%/&! >$! !'/,#!$! ,#!-, ! %"$&#%/5) * !-
'!$( &, !"%$M/&+,M& ) ,!$(%/( /& %!-
& C+"!#$5M& %" *$&#%/ "&/& ",(-5 ,+!-!$(5,
C&!/ $5 #&&%/!5 C !% #&"$5 &) -
>(. !%&+, )! %/!#&# %/!/( '$%, 'C'M,
79
%C5#,#!# +,%&$$5 ! C/&+!'M ?,',#!5 -%C-
!%( %&%/&, ! ! C>,& !+# &,- !),.
/!&) ,#!) ",$! !-!$( C/"M +!-!$(! /5, +!-
/! +!CC,#!/& !', 5 "H,/#,M/( ,
C#, -%C!MM&) %,"’L/#, N C!-,/( 5!K!N
!$+,#!/& %# /%&. !! /5 #C# )!!/,
+!!, N #&!-!M/( >5, C#&! ",$! !'/,#!/& ,#!-, !
C##&) !%C/!), #&5#$5M& /&#&, 5&& ,M/(%5 -
&#,,& C& #&" /- & >- #!!/! -%C!%(&) K.
"&K C) C&'&C# +M#!# / - !!-
$+,: "’L/&#+ $!%&#, 5 C!-,$& #!K/& +!%/,
N ,M/( -%C!%(&& C'%!& +!$* # #$ /!
%#%/ $MK, C%/,C!#%5 %' #&5#$M %,"’L/&#&)
%C,!( -%C!MM&) !-/#, 5 C&K!$& -
>5. "’L/ # %/!L C%&)$-5 -%C!MM- -
&#,,! + /M #&+!5 +!%/K ?,#!5 -
/&#!' K- #&# , %? 5$(%/.
!& &, !’"- %/!L !K#!*-
$&#>& /$-& C&'&C #- //&- !-
C5, # K !,'.
+/!>,#!5 , '/ !!$+, C%&)$- -%C!MM-
%,"’L/!, C#! 5- #&+!!$! %,/( C'%#, N #",#!$&-
%5 # ', ",#&$ #(, 5& "*,#!$%5 %$-
*5. < ",# C), +! 5- "’L/ !!$-
+, %/!#!# +$(#! -%C!MM&K &#,,, 5&K C!-
!$+,#!/& %#K &K /%. ! # '$, ,5#$5-
$!%5 5 C%/! %,! &#,!$(&) -%C!%/#, +!%/,
5 #&+!!M/( C#, &#,,!, ##!*!$&%5 %C!#$&#&&
$5 C5%5 C#& ) %,,C%/K ($!%#, !'K).
!&K C) ",#&# N , /$-, %"$&#%/(
# / — '/!'M ! !!$+. %$*,-
#!&K "’L/ +-$5!#%5, 5 C!#&$, +& , !%. /%
#&$&!# C'% +, N #",#!M/(%5 # (,, ! %/!, , 5-
, # ?,',L. !&K %/! )!!/&+,#!#%5 !%!C -
%5-5 ##!-&, N "&/( "’L/ %/K& +&) +",-
(. &!! ,), %&%/& ,5#$5$!%5 5 C%$#! +!
%/!/&&) %/!#, 5 C) # - #5 ##!-& -
>-.
$, !",/(, !K"$(> %//& ###5 , %? /-
$- %/!# C) . %$*5 C#-
& &) %,"’L/# C!+!$&, N $5 C&K5//5 >5
!L +!5 +!-!$(! )!!/&%/&! 5#&N!, ! / !/#
80
"%/!#&&, N C&+#$& +*,#!5 %/!,, 5&K !# %'
>5, %/!, C%$5 K- C&K5//5. &C,%/&, &!
#&>&$! ,C&/& /$#+. G!-!$(! ")%/( '(- "$!-!
#&$&!L %,##. $ %!! C %" C/"! # (, N +!-
!L, N # C&"!&K. $5 /- N" ' #",$%5, ") C-
# !/# ,#&, !C&$!, *!5 %,& ->K, 5&)
#&%/!!$ $5 ,C#$, !" +&*5 '&, 5 +"&$ *$&#M
,C#$M +! #* !5#, %,,. !& &, * %/! ,C#$
C%$5 C$5-!L /! -!&'5, C5#! 5 (/"/ %! >5
C ,C#$M) ",#$! #&&5 5 !/# "%/!-
#&& — /&!M %,M ->K !" +&*M 'M. ! "-
%/!#&& C&K5/ !+&#!/& -!&&& (marginal) #$&&!&,
#& %/!$& -$#& "’L/ %$*5 #- !C5,
!,', N C&$ +#% # *$&#%/ !!$+,
C&%, C'%#, 5 #",#!M/(%5 # '. G! C-M -!-
&&) #$&& )!!/&+,#!$!%5 C#! %C*&#!#, #&-
"&#, -!+!'K, K >&) &) %,"’L/#. :&
#&&%/!5 /, -!&- !!$+, !$ !K"$(> !%/
#*&#!, !+#, #, !C5, — .
G#5 '(- /, +#$&$ /!* >& #&-
&%/#,#!/& !/!/&&K !C!!/ $5 C&%, C'%#, 5 #-
",#!M/(%5 # ', +!, C5//5 -!&' ?,'. -
+#’5+& C!#!$&%5 , #&-$5 ?,'!$( +!$*-
%/ * "!*!& $5 - %,"’L/! +,$(/!/ ('-
$(#M ?,'LM) %C%"!& K- %5-5. !-,&
!%&+!' '$(# ?,', %,"’L/ >,!L C/&!$(&K #!-
!/ #&>5 +!!. %$(& C>, #",#!L/(%5 # ,#!)
%,%&) "*(, %&/,!'5 L +#’5+!5 +!! ! ,#-
&K %/,.
!*&!$%/& #&$& >$5) !/&#, #C#!*M !-
/!/&&) /# # %$*5, +,$(/!/& 5&)
+",#!$& /C "$(> / /! %/- ?,$M#!5, #/$M#!$&-
%5 , ?, #5(, ?,$ -!?#.
%>& %,//L# +& # /$-M %$*5, !*&!$-
%/& C/ +"-$& %,,C%/( &%, C&/!!&) /!&'KK
$!%&K >$. $!%&&, #& +-$5!$& , %&%-
/, 5 %!-,$MM, +!/, !#/!/& ##$M#!/& C-
,>, ##!-,, N "&$ '$(& !/&# #/,!5
*!#& # C'%&. $$M C#& # -%C!-
%(K %? +!$&>!$!%5 «! $M&!» — !'!$(&K
%,"’L/, 5&K C!- !%&+!' %#L #&-&, ! ,#M "+-
C>- %5-5 K- '$K ",$! #$(! ,'5.