Лісовицький В.М. Історія економічних учень
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
141
#C# 5&) #/(%5 -%C!%/#. C$&# *!#-
#/,!5 # , /"! #&+!!/& K- !%>/!"!&, !
5%/M. C#& /!/&%5 %!- - C'-
%,, !$ #&+!!/& -,$M#!/& ?&, , 5&) # C/!L. ,
&K C5 /% C#’5+!&K + *!#& %,%C$(&
C5!&. <5 «/C'5» (#+!L+#’5+) C5# L
#!*$&#& $/ #5 J!K",-%( >$&. $5 '/!-
$+#! #! & C&/!! !#/&/! ?&
*!# #$!&, %$(& $5 ") C5# )!!/! //!$(!
'/!'5 #$!&. !#C!&, L& '$ %/!#$5/( C#! -
,'5 !/5, %$(& %!! ,/! ! -
!/&!, /, N # K %C*&#!, /"/ #%( !, + '-
,/#5 -,$MM/( &K C'%.
5//5 ,/- C5, . K C#ML + C5/-
/5 C!## *!#&. C!##! *!#!, /! ,/&K
C5 C#& %/#M#!/& /! !&, , 5&) #$(! 5$(%/(
- &#! "*,L/(%5 %?M %#"& >-, ,!%$
- %?& %#"& $MK C/(%5 %/!, ##!-&.
$ - "!*!5 #%/!#&/& ,/&K C5 /!
%! %/!/(, 5 C%/- %)#!$5 C!## *!#& !"
L ! ! %/!#$5. E,& C/" ",,#!/&, ! C$!
K- ",#&'/#! %$ +"&/&. , ! *!#, C$!!L/(%5
"#’5+ #%/!#$M#!/& C/&,#!/& «%/&/,M» C&'&-
C& ,/- C5,: /!%/( C&#!/ #$!%%/,
%/!"$(%/( ->#- "-,, #&/%/( &#, %#", +!$M-
5 -##. -$# C$5-!L # /,, N" +!"+C&/& '-
#&K )!+ +!/%/M ?,',#!5.
G!C#!*5 /!- C5, L !K#!*$&#>M C,-
#M #&>5 %'!$(&) C"$. '/ ! %'!$(, C$/&-
, L #!*$&#M %"$&#%/M 'C' J!K",-%( >$&, 5!
!$! C%/!#, !+&#!/& /LM «%'!$(- &#- -%C-
!%/#!». ( !$*&/( '(, %/, . M$$-
!,). G%/ 'C' !%/ +#5/( C&/!( «%'!$(
C%!'», /"/ ")%/ C#&/& C$/&, C-
+C$, )#, %'!$(- %/!),#!5, %/#5 +#&-
%'!$( ?!%/,/,& /. C.
% ', "+,#, #!*$&#, !$ #&C,L, 5 C%$ML
. K, %'!$( %C5#!%/ ,/- C5,.
'!$(! C$/&! C#&! ",/& "+>/#& !/
C$/&&. E,(-5 +!)& , -!$,+ & !M/(
%'!$(&K %% %'!$( !%$&. !#&$( +/$,!!
%'!$(! C$/&! +!!L, !%!C, %/#5 ")&)
142
&) C,# #&>5 %'!$(&) C"$ # '(,
%% #! /&! C$/&& - C5, !" -
- %/&/,M#!5. N %,M&K &K C5-
* +!"+C&/& ?/&# #&"&'/# C,/, # -
$(%/, %/!/K $5 +!#$5 C/", / 5 +!)& N
C+C$, +! C-M %'!$( C$/&& !" !C$5'5
+!-!$(&) /%# C*,/( ,&,/& %K+&) C"$:
") +M#!/& &K C5. $(& " ?,-
',M&K ,/&K C5 * C+"!#&/& $M&,
/$(& # - %/!/,, !$ # +!-+& //!$/!&+,.
8.4.
80- . XX %/. # !#!-! $"!$(- /!-
%/,C, C&&#%5 !C5, N /&!# !+#, , !K-
"$(> !/&#&& C%/!#&!& 5- %/!$& %/& &!--
%( >$& ! $ + C?% ,#%&//, . &!-
' % (1912—2006), $!,!/ "$#%(
C (1976), !#/ &%$&) "/, % 5&) !K"$(> #-
: «> » (1956), «J
) O, 1867—1960» (1963, , %C#!#/%/# + M
:#!'), «)! !» (1980) /! . C,$5%/( /!&%-
/# ",$! ",#$! !%!C /&, N #& #&%/,C&$& + &-
/&M K%!%/#! # C K- !K"$(> -%/ &+& +!-
CC,#!$& C!/& !', 5&& "+,%C>
%&%/!$&%5 5 %#!/&# ,5& /! *! -
-!+!'. /-, #& ,* !/&# CC!-,#!$& %#
, CL,M& C& '(,, +! %$#!& . !$!, «+!C!$ !)
)&%/&5 + C"&#M %&$M /-#'# + %%-!#M».
C&K5//M C>&M /!&%/%(&) K %C&5$! /!-
* #!#!! C%//! ) //&&) %/,'K /! C!/&&)
!'K. %M +!/%/( C&&, N C&+#&$&
%/!"$(%/, '&$&) $&#!(, C# +!K5-
/%/, #& +#&$& L&- ?!/! — ->#-, /&K, !
)M ,,, #-!L #&>!$(, $( , +!"+C ##!*-
%/ %&%/&.
&)& /$-& C%&$!5 /!&+, ",$ /#-
*5 C /, N &#! %&%/! +!/! !#/!/& ! %-
# %!-,$M#!5 C&#&/& %" %/!, ##!-&. !
!L #,/>K )!+, 5&K !/&+,L #C$&# +#>) &-
&#, -$#, $( # '(, )!+ #-!M/( '&, L-
143
/,M&%( ! 5, #&"&& #&+!!M/( "%5-& #&C,%, C,',
! %C*&#! — "%5-& +!,C#$(. $ %#& C!/&
L&& ?!/, N #&+!!L #( &!, ', L #$&&!
-># !%&, /"/ $(%/( ->K , "-,. /!&%/& /!-
& & #+5$& +! %#, %#L 'C' C%/,$!/& $(%
/ ->K, #&%,,/ N %/!M $!%&M >$M (. A,
. !) +#&,/ $!%&!& (. J>, . !>!$$).
$!%&&K #!!/ $(% / C%/!#$&K, !%!C-
, «#55 ",» !&!%(- %/! %-
(1867—1947):
MV = PQ,
J — ->#! !%!; V — >#&%/( "-, ->K; * — #(
'; Q — $(%/( C/&) ,- ,C#$-C!*,.
G '(- #&C$&#!L, N $(%/( ->K , "-, C5 CC-
'K! #$&& !'!$(- C,/, # ->#, #&!*
" CC'K! >#&%/ ) "-,. & '(,, ! ,,
J>!, +& -># !%& #C$&#!M/( "+C%( ! -
$(%/( ,-, 5 !$+,M/( !'!$(&K C,/, ! C&+#5/(
$&> CC'K +& '. W * %/%,L/(%5 >#&%/ "-
-, ->K, / #!, C&!K # #-%/#, C, ##!*!-
$!%5 #$&&M C%/KM # $&#!( -># !%& +!-
$*M.
!$+!'5 !'!$(- C,/, +!!L !%, #&/!/,
!'!$(- ),. , $(%/( ->K , "-, ", +!$-
*!/& # /-, 5 %,"’L/& ",,/( #&/!!/& %# -
)&. <K #+!L+#’5+ %$*,#!$& %/& "*%(
>$&, +"!+&#>& K- , #&-$5 #55
M = kPY.
«"*%(, #5» C5 + '!& ?-,,L "%5-
!'!$(- ), (Y) ?'L/ (k), N C!+,L, 5, !%/&-
, ), $M& #$M/( +"-!/& -/#M (%/!)#&K ?,
? !C&5). $( '(- ?'L/! !-!,L $( +-
V , #5 ",: # C!+,L, , %$(& !+# +>,L/(%5
!$(! C/"! # >/!) C&C,%!L/(%5, N # L #$&&M
%/!$M.
") #!!/!) $(% / %/#*,L/(%5 C5! ?,-
'!$(! +!$*%/( * ->#M !%M #$&&M !'!-
$(- C,/,, #- !'!$(, ),, , ->#,
#&!*. & '(, >#&%/( "-, -># &&' %/,-
/,! #&/!/ #&%/,C!M/( 5 C%/ ?'L/& ?,'.
144
! /!/,#!5 %/!$ C/ &/&& + ", K%!%(-
- !C5,, 5&K #"!!# , $(%K / C5# "+*
#& # +! 5, /"/ # *$&#%/( !#/!/&- ##$5
&# ##!-&. &, #C# $!%& $, +!-
)&/(%5 # ##!+, $& CC&/ ! -> #ML CC+&', !
-,#!5 , #&C!, #)&$( +K%MM/(%5 >$5) +& -
#5 '. K%!%(! $( C"!!$! >&K )!!/ #+!L-
+#’5+,. G- + /LM C#!-& $#%/, CC&/ ! ->
#&+!!L/(%5 /!%!'K& /&#, %C,$5/&#& /&#
/&# "*%/. G '(- #&C$&#!L, N ->#&K & %/!-
#&/(, + - ",, & -/#&, + >- — & "$-!-
'K, 5 !M/( #%/&. , CC&/ ! -> +!$*&/( 5 # #-
5 ),, /! , , "$(>K , # %/!#& C+&#- #%/!.
+ %/!#, #%/! +K%ML/(%5 #+!L5 ->#- &, +
& !C/!$#, & " %&$& /#!& &, /"/
C5#$5L/(%5 #C$&# ! #( #&"&'/#! +!K5/%/. /-
-, $&#!5 #%/# %/!#&, +MM& %/,/,, ->#-
- &,, #C$&#!M/( ! +& , >#&%/ "-, ->K, 5, -
+ ' *! ##!*!/& #$&&M %/!$M. N ' /!, /
C5&K +#’5+ * $(%/M ->K #$&&M !'!$(-
C,/, #%,/K, %$(& V * +M#!/&%5 , !C5,,
C/&$*, + J. G#%&, , %#M -,, #&C$&#!# #&%-
# C /, N ->#&K ?!/ #-!L #&>!$( $ #
, -,$M#! C C%5 '/, #!-& + -
&/--># ! "M*/, C$/&,.
<M /+, +"&$& "’L/ /!%/,C, /!&%/& &!--
%( >$&, C-$%&#>&, N «-> !M/( +!5» («money
matters»), %$(& #( -%C!%( !/&#%/, 5&K +!)-
&/( #"!*5 , #$&& , C5 +!$*&/( # &!&
"%5-, -># !%&. >#! !%!, , %#M -,, #&+!!L/(%5
#$&&M CC&/, ! ->, CC#!- -%C!%/#!&
?!&. , %#! +!!! //&- !!$+, C$5-!L #
+’5%,#! ?!/#, 5 #&+!!M/( #$&&, ->#- CC&/,
)!+ K- #C$&#, ! "%5-& /! &!, !'!$(- C-
,/,.
?!/#, 5 #&+!!M/( CC&/ ! ->, . J
#&$5L #&/!/& ! +"-!5 ->K, C!+& 5&) * ",-
/& %/!#! #%/! (+"-!/& ->, +!&/(, #/!!/& #%/),
+& !$(&) )#, %!& C#!-& %C*&#!#. /!#!
#%/! !L %//- #C$&#, ! &!, -># !%&,
%$(& $&#!5 #",#!M/(%5 !#$ C#- ##!*-
- #5 ",(-5 #)&$5 !#/!/& #$M!L C,$(%&,
145
N C#/!M/( '(- #5. $#&K ?/ #C$&#, ! --
>#&K CC&/ C#’5+!&K + ,#!M C&",/#%/M # +&)
!/&##. J %$*,L 'K ?/, H,/,M&%( ! #&%,,/K
'C' «C!/- ),». ), 5&K #&+!!L +&
%C*&#!5, %$!!L/(%5 + C!/- /&!%#- C-
/#. !/&K ) — /K, 5&K %C*&#! +!)#,L
/&,#!/& C/5- *&//5, #&)5& + %#- #,, %'!$(-
%/!/,%,, !C&- !C/!$,, ,%/!$ $ %C*&#!5.
&!%#&K C/ ), +!$*&/( "!-!/ # , # #&C!-
#&) ?!/#, #!* C"!,#!&K /, !L %K+-
#C$&#, ! #-%/#, %C*&#, C#,. ,#!&K )
#&5#$5L/(%5, /!& &, #$&&M %&/( C-+#!M,
?!/&, 5 K- #&+!!M/(, !$+, N K ",#$ML %/!-
$%/( CC&/, ! ->. $ 5N #>5 /&,#!- )-
, (Y) "%5-, -># !%& (J) L %/!$&, / >#&%/( "-,
->K (V) /!* ", %/!$M !" %$!" $!%/&M.
/K! ?,'5 CC&/, ! -> # /!&%/%(K $ -
")! $5 "H,/,#!5 /-, N !#/!/& C$!>/,#!5
' L !K#!*$&#>M $!M # C!#!$(, )!+ #
-># !%& "%5-, #&"&'/#! !'!$(- ),.
$ 5N CC&/ ! ->, ",#$&K +!!& &,, %&/(
%/K&K, / ->#! CC+&'5 +!$*&/( # >( , -!$,+ ?-
!%# C$/&& #+5L/(%5 !K(M #&+!%/M.
/!K #C#%/ #"!!$%5 -$# *$ &%CC'K
C,>( !$(- ), #/#M#!$(- C'%,. C-
"! +& -># !%& # +,$(/!/ &/ %C!%
"!#, !/&'&$&) +!)# *!#& #&$&!M/( #!K )#-
"$&#, !'M -%C!%( %&%/&. ,>5 ##!-& *
CC&/ ! -> ) CC+&'LM #&$&!M/( !" &+# C!-
5 #&"&'/#! , #&C!, #%/!#!5 -># !%& # C-
/"& # ->!), !" ?$5'K +%/!5 ' , #&C!, !-
-># CC+&'.
<M /+, J& !!-!L/(%5 C/#&/& C%&$!5& !
?!/& ! C #+!L+#’5+ * #$&&M -># !%&
&!M #!$#- !'!$(- C,/,. "/ «/!-
! %/5 : 1867—1960» !#/& #&5#$5M/(, N &+#&
%C!! '5 XIX — C> //&& XX %/., 5 C!#&$, C,-
#!$ C/ %5 -># !%&. '(,, +!, #"!-
!M/( #& C&&& $& C% 1929—1933 ., C&,
-$&"&! C!5 +"$(>&$!%5 #!%$ C&$# C$/&& J-
!$( +# %&%/& :, 5! /$(& C>&$!
%/&%!M -># !%& !C &+&, !$ %C&5$! C-
146
!$(>, %M ! 35 %. ! %# #&5#$&) +!$*%-
/K /!&%/& C-+,#!$& &+# %C!& K , 60—70- .
XX %/. 5 C-+& C/#&$&%5, 5 — . $!%/( C-
$5-!$! # /,, N * +!& "%5-, -># !%& #C#-
&& +!& -%C!%( ’M/,& %,M/( +! !%#
$!-& (+!C+M#!5), 5 %$!!M/( # %(, 12—16 %5'#.
/!K %&/,!' 5 C-+,#!5, /! C!/& !'
#&5#$5M/(%5 %C!#M ,* %$!M. % ' #&+!&$ %"$&-
#%/ C)# /!&%/# +!! /# C$-
/&&.
! &#, %&%/, /!&%/& ##!*!$& %/!/( %/K-
M +!/M %!-,$5', C/ C# +!)& , -!$,+ -
C$/&& #& #&+!#!$& ")&&. $ ! #,
# K%!'#, 5 #%/MM/( &%'K&K #!!/ -
C$/&&, /"/ ")%/( >#&- !-,#!5 ! +&
’M/,&, /!&%/& /&,#!$&%5 'C'
/#- ,%,, /"/ L/!' ! #-%/# /' # &-
!' $M#&) &) C!+&#. G#%& #&C$&#!$, N
, -!$,+ C$/&& %$ C!-,/& %5-5 -
+&) '$K (C#! +!K5/%/(, +-$!*,#!5 '&$, /! .), ! #&"&-
!/& , -$#, /, — '#, %/!"$+!'M, 5&K CC5-
#,#!/& #% > +!! C$/&&. < #&+!&$ #&" %#-
+!%", #&>5 ! +!! — «,C!#$5 ->&!» 5 $M-
#& ?!/ -%C!%(- )!+,, 5, C&$5$!%5
C&//! $( C C$% "M*/&) +!)#.
$/&! «>#&- !-,#!5» #&!#!$!%5 %C*M,
)! " /,, N %,M/( +! $!-& , C5# ?/, # +!)# ,
-!$,+ C$/&&. 9) !5#%/( +!!L, N +,$(/!/&
#*&/&) +!)# C5#$5M/(%5 + "!-!/ %5'# C%$5 ) C&-
K5//5 #* # >K "%/!#' /! # >K ?!+ '&$,. , +!-
%/( -,#!5 $&> C%&$ML/(%5 %/!"$+!'5 %&/,!'. E!-
-!/ &) -!!+# 70—80-) . /!&%/& C#’5+,-
#!$& %! + &/&& /&!5 K%!%(&) -
!'K !!,#!5 CC&/, ?'&/- "M*/- ?!%,-
#!5. G!%/( -,- -,$M#!5, 5 C&+#&/( +&)
+ ,%, C$/&& +!$* # ’M/,&) -
$&#!(, $/ J CC,L /&,#!/&%5 «->#-
C!#&$!», %,/( 5- , #, +"$(> -># !%&
! C#, #$&&, (3—5 % , ) +!$* # %/!, ’M-
/,&, ?!+ '&$, /. C. <K C/&!$(&K C&%/ $(%/ --
>K #&#&/(%5 + #-%/#&) /'K %/, >#&-
%/ "-, ->K. % > ! C!+&&, , /,
147
&%$ #( +!K5/%/, +& #%/&'K, C#& ",/&
"’L/!& -,$M#!5, ! ",,/( !#/!/& C$!>/#,#!/&%5
C #( ', 5&K C/&,L/(%5 /$ ! ->#M
!%M.
/& +"& /!&%/# #%$& +!&K #$! , -
+,5 C'%# ?,',#!5 &# &. & +!-
CC,#!$& 'C'M $ C!#!$(- )!+,
#C$&#, ->#- "-, ! C'%&, 5 #",#!M/(%5 # !$(-
, %/ &. E,$ #%/!#$ !5#%/( %,//L#, $(
# !!$+ ’M/,& !%#&) $!-# * +!& /-
C# +%/!5 -># !%& !' ! &) %&%-
/& # '$,. <!#M L -C/+! C $( ?$5'K&) ,-
#!( -%C!MM&) %,"’L/# , )!+ #+!L ?$5' /!
"+"//5, ! /!* /!! #%5 -%C!%(- '&$,.
!$&& #&5#&$&%5 5 C!/& !' /!&%-
/#, +! C-M 5&) #!#!$%5, +!, C&+,C&&/& +,-
,#!5 ?$5'K %C!$. ,#!) C->5
’M/,& !C&' 70-) — C!/, 80-) . XX %/. ,5&
</!$( "!& 5, ! ##$& "*5 ! C&%/ ->-
# !%&, /&,M&%(, /!& &, 5 C"& «->#-
C!#&$!». !/&# /!&%/# *! +!C&%!/& ,%C>, !$-
+!'M C-! +#$5 &$, +!$M, 5&) !+-
!/%(&) !. 9) !' C&#!"&$& /!* ?!/# ,
!!) + C)M &, M, !%!C, %#LM
#!#!M C%//M %/,C%/M: #!/ $&> /$M#!/&
+& -># !%&, ! > & +"&/( %!. ! , '(,
#&C!, +,$(/!/& #&5#&$&%5 > #!*!M&&. )!
! +! %#LM %,//M %/!"$(! #&+!!, , /K !% 5
#&)& C$*5 /!&%/%( 'C' L %/!"$(%/(
+%/( %&%/&. %&$, '(- /!&%/%(
'C/& +-$& C-/& , #&> #%) %$!&) %,C-
$&#&) C"$ C)- C,. ! K , !!) +#&/-
&, "%/( C), /!&%/# #&$&!$! %C!#$&#,
&/&, %C,!$! C>,, "$(> -,&) C$&#&)
#!!/# $"!$( /&&.
8.5.
G '5 70-) . XX %/. # K !,' ?,L/(%5
!C5, N C/,L ! >&> /!/,#!5 C"$ -%C-
!%(- +#&/,, 5 "!+,L/(%5 ! %#&) C%/,$!/!) $!%&-
148
'C'. + ' +-!!&K !C5 /&!# !+#,
. #$M&# 5 /K, !K"$(> #-
&& % 5&) %/!$& / CC+&' /! !'!$(&) -
,#!(.
, (supply-side economics) #+5$! +! %#, %#L
'C' /#*5 $!%& >$& C /, N '/!$(-
M +!!M ",(-5 & L ?/&#! !$!'5 #&&-
%/!5 %,%#. G#%& #&C$&#!$, N $5 !$(- ?,'-
,#!5 & -$#, ,#!-, C/" +%&/& !
+!"+C ?/&#- CC&/,, 5 ##!*!$& K%!', ! !
+>& CC+&' ?!/# #&"&'/#!. "$! CC&/,
#&>,L/(%5 !#/!/& >$5) #%/!#$5 ! &, #-
#!*&) ', +!K5/&) %,%#, C&!K # #-%/#K
C%C/&#, ",/& *. , $5 +!"+C5 -
+%/!5 ") +"$(>,#!/& CC+&'M !C/!$, C!',
,%,#!M& C>& ! '(, >$5),. %/! #&&!M/(, -$-
#& &, 5 +,$(/!/ !/&# ?%!$( C$/&& *!#&,
C# +- + K%!%(&& !'5&. +C-
$ +! !%/&& !'!$(- ), + "M*/, N C-
*,L #&%&K #( C!/#,#!5, C&#!L, ! ,, %C-
$!K%!K#, %/&,$& C!' !C/!$#$!(. G!N!*5,
5 L *$ #%/&'K, #&5#$5M/(%5 %/!/&, %$(&
+!! !%/&! C&",/, #&$,!L/(%5 >$5) C!/# #&&-
%/#,L/(%5 ! C,/&# '$. ",#!L/(%5 #&/&%5 C&-
#!/&) #%/# + &, !C/!$#, N # %5 C-
C+&' %/!) %C#$(5 - +%/!5.
W %/%,L/(%5 CC+&' C!', / /,/ #&% C!/& #-
-!M/( -!/&#, $(, %$(& ?!/& +>,M/( +!"/,
C$!/, "$5/( C!'M > C&#!"$&#M, +!),M& "&/&
#&" ! &%/( +#$$5. '(, * !C5, L %&%/!
*!#&) %'!$(&) C- /!%?/#. *!# #&/!/&
! %'!$( C/"& C&#!M/( %/&,$& C>,, "/&, +"-
$(>,M/( $(%/( "#$(&) "+"/&), N C&+#&/(
#)&$5 #5 +!K5/%/ # K- «C&» &. GM-
L/(%5 %/,/,! #&/!/, %$(& C!'#&&, +!)#,M& !
C-, *!#&, +"$(>,M/( !%/, C/- %C*&#!5 +!
!), +!N!*(, %,M& /& %!& !%/, %/!) ,
%,,C, ). G>,L/(%5 "%5- &/&) %,%# 5
*$ #%/,#!5, !%$ - %/!L C!5 "%5-# #&"-
&'/#! %5 +!K5/%/.
&% C!/# %/!#& %/!M/( /!* *$ C"!-
?$5', %$(& +"$(>,M/( #&/!/&, ! /*, C#,M/(
149
+%/!5 '. /-, ,5 +! !), C!/#&) !)-
*( %,"%&,L !!L C$(-& & -!$,+5 #&! 5$(%-
/, >/, C#&N,M& CC&/, N /!* C&+#&/( +%/!-
5 '.
G- + '&& ,5#$5& C&)&$(&& / CC+&' -
,M/( +>&/& *!# #/,!5 # , +! C-
-M !/&# "M*/ C$/&&, $5 - %// +&+&/&
%/!#& C!/#,#!5. < C#&N&/( C&",/#%/( !C/!$-
#$!(, ", %C&5/& +>&M #&"&'/#! %/#M
#&) "&) %'(. G&*5 C!/#, ! ,, %C$!K%!K-
#, C#& C&+#%/& #&&5 "M*/- ?'&/,,
%$(& CC#5 "M*/, +! !), +%/!5 C!/# !L
%# *. %,M/( -!& C!/# %/!#&, C#&N5 5&)
#C$&#!L ! #$&&, !)*( , "M*/. <5 +!$*%/( ",$!
%$*! !&!%(& C?% ,#%&//, >/!/, #-
! !$! $# ; -!? +"!*! , #&-
-$5 /! +#! «&# 7!??!» (&%. 8.1).
&%. 8.1
/&!$(! #%( Y C!+,L +& C!/#&) %/!#: # 0
100 %. ! -&+/!$(K % X #"!*!L/(%5 #$&&! C-
!/#&) !)*( , "M*/.
G -!?! #&, N + +%/!5 C!/#&) %/!# C!/-
# !)*5 ",,/( +"$(>,#!/&%5, %5-,/( !%&,, #
/' $, C%$5 - C!$(> C#&N5 %/!# C&+#
%5 !)*( !* ) C#- +&5 +! 100-
C'/ %/!#& C!/,. &&M '(- ", /, N C-
#&N5 C/&!$(&) +# C!/#,#!5, 5 #C#!-
M/( /' ! &#K 7!??!, "&/( #&-& !$(,
"/, C&+#&/( +!&//5 CC&L%/# !" #), ) ,
«/(». G#%& #&C$&#!L, N +&*5 C!/# !L %/&,$MM-
150
&K #C$&# ! CC&L&'(, 5$(%/( ! "!*!5 C!'M#!/&
"$(>. & '(, "M*/ - #/!/&/(, %$(& C!/-
# !)*5 +! #&% %/!#&, 5! #C#!L /' ! &-
#K, +! &+(, N #C#!L /' G, ",,/( !#&&. E-
$(> /-, !)*5 *,/( !#/( +%/& + +>&5
C!/# "!+&, #&$&! +%/!5 #&"&'/#!, "/5*-
- #&%&& C!/!&.
!' C&)&$(&# / CC+&' ",$& !$+-
#! K *!$& !C"!'M # +!)!) C$/&& -
5&) ! , C>K C$#& 80-) ., 5 +#!*&$&%5 ! %//-
+&*5 C!/#&) %/!#, %5 %'!$(&)
C-!, !!5 C!/#&) C$(- #%/!, %5 /-
# !/&+!' ,%/!/,#!5. !/&! C/#&$! !5#-
%/( +!$*%/K, C 5 -#&$& %C$!K%!K&, !$ "$&+(-
%/( '&) +#’5+# +!$&>!$!%5 C/ &%,%K. !, %/&,-
$MM&K #C$&# +&*5 C!/# - C5#&/&%5 # /&#!$K
C%C/&# #&5#&/&%5 +!& , !K /K %&/,!-
'. G!$&>!$%5 %C& /!* C&/!5 C /, ! N "$(>M
M #C$&#!L +&*5 C!/# — ! CC+&'M !" ! C-
C&/. N #C$&# ! CC&/ #&5#&/(%5 %&$(>&, ' * C&-
+#%/& +"$(>5 "M*/- ?'&/, C%&$M -
?$5'. /-, C&)&$(&! / CC+&' #$%5
#&+!/&, N C+&/&#&K ?/ ) !' *,/( C&%-
/& $&> , CL! + >&& +!)!& #C$&#, ! ,
’M/,,, +!, + "*5 -># !%& +- -
'C/, /!&%/#.
! #% ' C>&$ / CC+&' %// #C$&-
,/& 5 ! )!!/ //&&) ,5#$(, /! ! %C5#!%/(
C$/&&. K +!K>$& #"!*5 C"$&, +
5&& #$%5 +>/#),/&%5 ', N !/&# #&&%/-
#,#!$! /& *!#- -,$M#!5, ",$& +!CC#!
#!!/& #&>5 '&) C"$ >$5) "$+!' C,/&#-
&) *$&#%/K &# %&%/& -%C!%/#!.
>&K #!!/ # $!%& !& — -
— !'/,#!$! ,#!-, ! N , #!*$&-
#, C%/,$!/ $!%&& — !'!$(%/ C#& -
&) %,"’L/#, 5! %5-!L/(%5 >$5) C/&+!' C&K5/&)
>(. &K %,"’L/ , $!%&K $ !# C#,
?!'M C C'%&, 5 #",#!M/(%5 # ', , +%/!#-
$5M& #&/!/& #&-&, #&"&!# !K!N&K $5 %" %C%" K.
GK%&K #&" / +"-!#%5 + ,#!& +,$(/!/. %-
$5 #)&$5 # C/&!$(%/, #&$&! #&+!%/M,