YOSHIDA EIZA I (1872–1945) • 435
males. In 1748, he was at the heart of a famous dispute over artistic
autonomy between puppeteers and chanters during the premier pro-
duction of Kanadehon Chu
ˆ
shingura, which led chanter Takemoto
Konotayu
ˆ
(later Toyotake Chikuzen no shojo
ˆ
) to leave the Takem-
oto-za for the rival Toyotake-za. In Act 9, the most challenging,
Bunzaburo
ˆ
was handling the puppet of Yuranosuke, the leading role.
Prior to a performance, Bunzaburo
ˆ
requested that Konotayu
ˆ
make a
change in his delivery at the place where Yuranosuke, having per-
ceived Kakogawa Honzo
ˆ
’s true character, reveals how the shutters
can be removed to allow access by the avenging samurai to the vil-
lain’s mansion. Bunzaburo
ˆ
felt it was necessary for the chanter to
alter his delivery by pausing so the puppet’s behavior could be timed
to it. Konotayuˆ refused. Neither artist would budge and manager
Takeda Izumo II, afraid of losing his popular puppeteer, sided with
Bunzaburo
ˆ
, asked Konotayuˆ to leave the troupe, and persuaded a
chanter from the Toyotake-za to replace him.
This incident was a symbolic victor y on behalf of the hither to
diminished authority of the puppeteer. Moreover, it led to the
increasing exchange of chanters between the Toyotake-za and
Takemoto-za, regardless of the past association of each theatre with
a specific musical style (fu
ˆ
). This, in turn, led to a mixing of the
styles and to their gradual weakening as distinct entities in favor of
the chanters’ individualistic approaches. Moreover, the increasingly
realistic puppet handling, which included borrowing kabuki stage
business, may have robbed bunraku of its uniquely romantic and fan-
tastical qualities. This, in turn, may have deprived bunraku of its
competitive edge.
In 1759, Bunzaburo
ˆ
and his son, the future Bunzaburo
ˆ
II, departed
to become freelancers in Kyoto, but he died a year later.
Bunzaburo
ˆ
collaborated (gassaku) on plays under the name Yos-
hida Kanshi, his best-known work being Koi Nyo
ˆ
bo Somewake
Tazuna, an adaptation of a well-known earlier play. The line ended
with Bunzaburo
ˆ
III.
YOSHIDA EIZA I (1872–1945). A bunraku puppeteer who debuted
as Yoshida Mitsue II in 1883, performed at Osaka’s Hikoroku-za
and Inari-za theatres, and joined the Goryo
ˆ
Bunraku-za in 1898, but
was forced by debts to moonlight at the Meiraku-za. From 1902, he
PAGE 435
.................15687$ $CH1 12-20-05 11:07:55 PS