Дизайн на западе (сборник)

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.

cF B O[r4H

143 KaHanoB,

Ulynaneq

nocrrHAycTpuanb'

Hoi c{creMbr-cnpyra.

CaMo

no ce6e

3To 6blno

6bl

u He

nnoxo

ro'{Ku

3peHl,F

COTTCaCCOBCKOi

KOHqenqXl,

peanl43Ma)

ecnh 6br nph

3roM

yrpatl4Banocb TBop-

'{ecKoe

nposeccl,,|oHaJlbHoe

caMoc1oaHue

(,,BblcoKoe

Aocrot4HcrBo

npodeccu14")

l,'1

He cny'{aiHo

fltrorap

yn0A06hn

nocrl4HAycrpuanbHyto

cl4creMy cnpyry.

,lMeHHo 3aecb

Mbr

cranKuBaeMcF

apyroi

cropoHoi

l4cKoMoro

cMbtcna

,.6enofo

t!yMa"

B ceMaHT[qecKoM

ypoBHe Uloy-a,l3atHa

npouc'

xoatrr

poKllpoBKa. MaHUMHh Onpeaenhn

ee KaK,,BHyT-

peHHe

nycroi

+opManr3M

pacnpocrpaHeHxe B Mxpo-

BOM

MaCUjTa6e

a6colloTHo uhHt4'{Horo

an3a

H'6u3He'

ca, KoTopblM

3aHlMapTcF

BCe,

KOMy He neHb,

HhqeM

He cMyulaffcb

x He o6peMeHnff

ce6f KaKvM!4-n!160

npo$ecc!4oHaflhHblMx

coo6paxeHl,FMx

Kprlrepl4aMh

Ka'{ecrBa"

[25,

c. 18]

. npunrvaa

K cBeAeHuto

3ry

pacnpocrpaHeHHyro B 3anaAHot

Kpl,lThKe

xapaKrepllc-

rrKy, TeM

He MeHee BpFA

MoxHo cornachTbcF

c Het

floJtHocrbro.

flpr cuttclogoi

poKhpoBKe

npoucxoal,lT

He crorhKo Bbrxonallll4saHhe,

cKonhKo

noaMeHa

cMhtc-

na:

3a 3cTerqvecKuM14,

TBopgecKxM14,

npoeKTHblM14,

ecTb co6cTBeHHo

noodecc|4oHanbHblMl,1

cMhlcraMr,

KOTOObte

AetrcrBhTenbHo

crpeMFTcF cTar6

nycTblM14

3HaKaMrl cMbrcnoB

{noAo6so

roMy

KaK aBropcKhi

xecT

nycTbrM 3HaKoM

aBTOpCTBa)

npOCBeqrealor

uHbre cMbrcnht

cMbrcnbr,

npvHaanexauve

c+epe

6 3Heca, Koropbre

qhHrlqHbr

poBHo

B Tot

Mepe, a Ka_

Koi

ulaHh,ieH

6h3Hec

no cBoei

npo$eccfioHanbHoi

npu-

poae,

noToMy r!oy-a

3a;H ecTb B

l43BeCTHOi CTeneHh

3CTeTl4qeCKOe_ U

3rl,|gecKoe

yBeH'{aH[e 14

OnpaBAaHUe

caMoro BracrHoro

u 3aBopaxvBapulero

u3 tlcKyccTB

XX BeKa

ucKyccrBa 6[3Heca.

KoMMepu,-apaMa

coBpeMeHHoi

Kytbrypbl

Paccvxaenra o

roM,

qro

3anaaHhte

xyaoxHl4Kt4

FBnFlorcF 3alloxHrKaM

Kanhran[crriqecKoi chcreMhl

npoh38oacTBa 14, B'racrHocTh,

KanuranrcrhqecKoro

pbrHKa,

ahKTara

KoMMepqecKlax

ueHHocrei,

aorroe

BpeMF 6hrnh e raurei crpane

npeporaruBoi

nrrepary-

pbl

onpeaeneHHoro

ToJrKa 14 BocnphHrMan[cb

pycne

MaccrpoBaHHoi n eyrurapnoi

vaeororr,lecroi o6pa_

6orKfi KaK He'{To

oaxo3Hoe.

B HaLUh

AHtr

nocreneHHo-

TO [AeOnOrlqecKoro

pa3opyxeHtlF

npeKpaueHhF

,,xonoAHoi

eoirsr", a raKxe urpFulerocd

npvqrua

pbrH09Hbrx

uael4 TaKl4e

paccyxaeHuF

npeacTaanFrcTca

TeM 6onee HeyMecrHbtM14, apxatiqHbtM!4,

ecn14

He npFMo

peaKqhoHHbrMr4.

o[HaKo

B3rrFA

nOAO6HyE

,,Kp!a'

Tl.1 KV

Kan[Tanv3Ma" n cooteetcteyoulue

rorlKoBaHfi a

MecTa xyaoxH[Ka

KanhlanxcT[gecKoM

o6ulecrBe

KaK Ha

perhKT

,,raeonorl

qecKoro

LUyMa"

BoBCe He

6eccnopeu t,l

orHKrah

He aBnaercn

caMo co6oi

pa3yMe-

roulxMcF. flprlHu n

[aeotorhqecKoro nnppaflfi3Ma,

MeHhuei Mepe, Tpe6yer

y,lrrbraar6 cyutecrBoBaHUe

aHarorr,rHoi,

3ai{acryro

ropa3ao 6onee

pe3Koi,

Kpx'

T[,{ecKoi no3xql4x Ha caMoM

3anaae,

oTH}oab

TOflbKO B apeare HeoMapKch3Ma,

Ho B aHTrlMapKclrcr-

cKl4x l,

npocTo

He3aBxcxMbrx

HanpaBreHhFX

o6u]ecr'

BOBeAqeCKOi

UUtCnr. BO BCFKOM

Cnyqae, UrHOpl4pO_.

earu noao6rlre

KphTlqecKre

KoBqenurtl

3Haqlro 6bl

BnaaaTb B r4Hyro, He

MeHee BynbrapHyto,

fiaeotorqlec-

Kylo KpaiHocr6.

qTo6bt

He 6ttrs

ronocnoeHutt'l, taMeer

cMblcn 06-

parhTbcF

K,.cBl4aerenhcKvM

noKa3aHhFM"

yL]acTHx-

KOB l4 HenOCpeACTBeHHbrX

Ha6rl|oAaTeneticoBpeMeHHoi

KoMMepq-apaMbr

3anaaloi

Kynbryprt,

o6parutucn

ofHtoah

paau

6ecuenbHoro

firl,

qeneHanpaBJleHHOrO

KOnJreKqHOHr4poBaHun

apryMeHToB

,3a"

Vnv

,,npoTt

6tasHeca

cgo6oarioro

pblHKa

Bcei Bhal,'lMocrh,

pbl'

HoK ecrecrBeH

He[36exeH,

paAta

o6pereH[F

Tpe3BOrO

peanlcTl.4qHoro

B3rnFAa

eTo

cneacTBla

gddexrut

Ana

Kyrbrypbr,

6e3 vnnK3vi,6e3

Heao6-

pocoBecrHbrx ueepauteHEi

ranfi

Ao6pocoBecrHblx

3a6-

nyxaeHr.li.

CBoero

poaa

o6pa3qoBblM

'{l'lcrore

xaHpa

cB/aeTelbcTaoM

raKoro

poaa

MoxHo

cqrlTaTb

cTaTsE)

Sennrnu

,,CrpaHa

'.ryaec",

<oropoia oH,

ocraBaFcb

B no3xul1l4

cropoHHero

H noroMy

3MOql4OHanbHO

aHTaxvpoBaHHoro

ua6nroaarenn,

o6uaxaer

MexaHtaKy

cloxeHhF,,MoAenbHoi"

(Enosnn)

nocrr'tnAycrpuarb'

roi

cpeaur

[14]

noHtiF.

orMeqaer

'l3BecrHeiull,li

l'lTarbaHcK14i

LA3aVHep,

nOTpFcaeT

oaHTaCThqecKoi

cTpou1enbHot

aKTTBHOCTbTO,

nOCTaBneHHOl.l

Ha uqpoKyto

npeanphHh-

MarenbcKvto

Horv. E[3HecMeHbt

caMofo

pa3HoTo lotl'

Ka, eule

HeaaBHo

noHFTHB

He fi^reeluhe

apxureKTy-

pe,

copeBHyForcF

cKopocrtl

MaculTa6ax

oTJroBa

3K3OTfiqeCKt1X

hMeH,

tjcnolb3VF

aIlF

3lOtO

KaK nocTo-

FHHo nonot

ulH

icn aJl56oM

,,roBapHblx

o6paauoe"

r<aAHoi

KVpbe3oB

H 6ecKoHe'lHo

npot(opnuBot

noeccbt,

TaK h

co6crBeHHbtx

are

HToB

_Bep6oBut

KoB.

Pexpyrcxui

Ha6op eapone;cKt1x

apxhreKropoB

KaK

npu3HaHHbrx

M3TpoB,

laK h

3eneHoi

MonoAext4,

KaK

npeacraBxrenei

t)xe

yKopeHhBtlJllxca

apxtlreKTypHblx

HanpaBneHxi,

raK H

aBlopoa

Mano

KoMy

h3BecrHblx

p14CKOBaHHblX

nHOHepCKHX

3KcrlephMeHToB

14Aer

LfeflbfMh

nolKaNl11

avgtl3t4o1a|r',r"

3aKtlaablBaF

ocHo'

By cBoe06pa3Boi

[€xtryHapoaHot

clrcreMbl

3Be34.

3ana,eaute,

nrpByro o'{epeab

eBponeicKhe

apxuTeKTophr,

np'1BblKL!He

K npaKT!4Ke

AnrTenEHOi

roaoAKr.r

cBoMx 3aMbtcnoB,

K ,l3HyphrenbHot

TaKTl4_

qecRoi

ahnnoNlaT

o6xoaHblM

MaHeBpaM,

noreto-

ul e Ha!

npoeKTa\lH

anB

KpynHblx

N4exayHapoaHblx

KoHKvpcoB,

reNl 9To6bl 3aBoeBarbl,1

yAepxalb

no3u_

ur.1h

,4 B HaAe>K,Ae

nOtyqHTb,

!<aK npaBhno.

Ml,',i3epHbli

3aKa3, BHe3anHO

OKa3blBaIOTCA.

CTpeMhretbHoMy

,,HacronTenbHoi\1y"

npllrrlaLUeHhrc,

a FfloHl4l'1,

coaep-

LIeHHO

HenpHBbrqHoM

oKpyxeBrH,

fae hx 6e3

acFKl4x

qepeMoH!,t;

noHyx-4arcT

h 3acraanF!or,

6blcrpee,

KaK

MoxHo

66rcrpeer

Bocnpoh3Becrtl

rl14Llib

ne14TMoTl4B,

,,Bl43XTHyro

KapToqKy"

CBOeTO

TBOp'{ecIBa

cfiJtbHhli,

3anoMhHaloutH;cB

y:naeaelasti o6pa3.

cBoero

poAa

,,Toprosyro

MapKy",

tr nELlb oqeHb

peAKo

oHl/

hMercT

Bo3MoxHocrh

AnB

noAnrHHo;,

VrnY6teHHoi

reop'lec-

roi

pa6orut.

Apxrle<ropor

pa6orapT

B anoHcKl4x

To-

poaax,

ou.lyua6

ce6F

Anhcoi B

CrpaHe

qyaec

[r'l

odopunrenaur

orpoMHoro

ropf oBo-3Kcno314Llr'loHHoro

3ana coBpeMeHHoi

apxvreKrypbl,

aurpl4Hbl

Koroporo

HaxoaFTcF

nocroFHHo;

pe3Kcno3!4u1,M,

6e3ycneLlHo

nblraFcb,

Kpa;Hei

Mepe HeKorophle, aocTHrHyTb

co3ByqhF

KoHTeKCTy,

BOnpeKh

roMy,

qro

vx co6cTBeH-

Haa KynneHHaF

caMo66trHocrb

np[3aaHa

ero

cMeuJarb,

cnyTaTb

co3Aarh

arccoHaHc.

Tpvaso. noqrr HeBo3MoxHo

yKroHl4TbcF or

yqa-

cThn B

3THX

,,6erax"

aapoaauui

h ranaHrog.

3ro He

yAaeTcF

Aaxe

caMoi

paal4KanbHoi'

y|HAVBUAyanUC'

TtlqHOi,l

B CBOHX 3KCnepl4MeHTaX

aBaHrapaHot4

Monoae'

xl,r, 3KcrpaBaraHThocrh

SaHTa3ri

Koropoi

coBepLUeH_

HO OTpeUJeHa

3a,qaqH

HX HenocpeacIaeHHoro

Bonno-

uleHra.

3aech, B FnoHhh,

3Tr4

MOnOAble

ropable

cBo-

HenparM arr,l

Hocrbp

3narepbl

noty'{atoT

6es

BcFK,ax

npoBono,leK

nepByKl

l4x xh3Hl,

BO3MOXHOCTb

BOnJIO-

Tt4Tb cgoH

caMble

OaHTacrlri{ecKtle,

Aaxe

6peAoaute

rAel,|

Bce

qaule

pa6ora

Beaerca He6olbLll!lM!.1

KoMaBAa.

M11

apxhTeKTVphrbtx

3HaMeH14cTocTei,

paccopTr4poB,aH

Hbtx no

reHAeHul4flM !4 noKoneHuFM.

TaKrle

KOMaH-

abt,

HepeaKo

csopMl4poBaHHble b oneKaeMble

l{ecT'

llblM KpeCTHblM

OTUOM,

npOeKTfipyloT

qent'le

Xl4nble

KOMnIleKCbl, aAM!4HHCTpaThBHble

KBapTanbl

pen-

pe3eHTaT[BHhre

3aaHfiF,

saTanbHo

oKa3blBaFcE

B CBO-

ux MeraHhFX

Nrexay Cqllnnol.a

,,apxrre<rypnoi

arro-

rorrt" u Xaprr64orl

.,Ar4cHeineHAoBct<oro

Kvrqa".

KaKoBbt xe npehMyulecrBa

,1 KaKoBa nJtara

Hr4X B STOM apXUTeKTypHOM

pae?

SaAaercn

BonpocoM

Sennruu. Fcno,

irro

pl4cK

BeflrK u

rpe6yercn

6onuutaa

crna

ayxa

h TBepaocTb caMocToFHha,

qro6bl

He nore-

pFTb

ce6a, noaaaBLll4cb

a3apfv

rpbl 14 l'1cKyue8|4aM

3Tofo coBpeMeHHoro

BagunoHa. OAnaro

ctonu xe ore-

B!aAHO.

rrTO

OAHO

t13 OTBerAreHhi

tlYTV, nO

KOTOpOMy

aahHyncF

MHoro

BeKoB

Hasaa

3anaa,

nponeraeT 9epe3

oKeaH

h uMeer cBoe apoAonxeHne E

crpaHe. Koropoi

a 6nrxairueu 6ya1,rqeM cyxaeHo

crars

$rnancoeurv

HayqHo-TexH!4qecKHM

ueHIpoM

Mupa, a noToMy

HeMa-

floBaxHo nocneTb

rvAa K 3roMy

MoMeHly.

npH Bcei 6ecnoulaaHocrl,4

xapaKrep!'1crr

K Sennr

Hl,4

E CBOeM

3CCe

yXOAl4T

OT OAHO3HaqHblX

OKOHqa-

TeJrbHhrx

oueHoK

14 BbtBoaoB,

TeM 6onee

qTo

B Hap

co-

BaHHoi 14M Kapr He

rBopqecrBo h KoMMepulaF

coxpa-

HFIOT r3BeCTHbtt naphTeT.

B xaptrne,

pucyeMoi

apyrlM

KphrriKoM

rflaB-

HhrM

peAaKropoM

xypnana

,,Moao"

K. Mopoqqu,

3ro

paBHoBecEe

npeAcraer

yxe

HenonpaBrMo HapyuJeH"

H6rM.

qTO

BOCnpUHl4MaercF

aBTOpOM nOqrl'

KaK KaTa-

crpoda. CahaerenhcrBo roMy

yxe

caMo Ha3BaHue

crarcu:

,,HacrynarcT

TeMHbte

BpeMeHa", a

raKxe ee

nepeaa

$pa:a,

BbrKa3brBarculaF cepse3Hoe

6ecnor<oi-

creo

sa cyau6sr

14TanbFHcKoTo

atl3aiHar

,.lvlbt

AonxHbl

6parb

npriMep

SpaHqy3oB

FnoHqeB. ecnrl He xorhM,

q106br

Hac nepexBarrlnt nepBeHcrBo

B TBopqecrBe

3Tor cnoxHbri u

rnxeruri

nepuoa"

[29]-

Aarop !4Me-

er B Bhay

oTHroab

He BHe3anHblt

TBop.tecKhl, B3ner

opaHlltah

t1 Fnorur, xo

rverro nepexBar hHr4ufiarrBbr,

Koropbli Bo3Moxet

6naroaapq nyvruei, c

roqKt4 3pe'

Hl,4F

3aKOHOB

pbrHKa,

OpTaHh3aqkh

TBOpqeCTBa. Bo

opaHquu

3ro

Aocr4rHyro

Ha nyrh

MoulHoro rocyaapcr-

BeHHOTO npOTeKqfi OH143Ma HaqhOHanbHOrO

Al,l3aiHa,

Ue-

reHanpaBneHHoi,

apr Kyn|lpoBaHHoi,

MaccqpoBaHHoi

nponaraHAbt 14 nolaq4 ero

aocrhxeHfir,

a 3a']acTy]o

opraHu3auMh

3Tlrx

aocrfixeH|4i

He 6e3 orreHKa

6neoa.

TaK,

lvlopour]h orMelraer r4cKyccrBeHHoe

la306pereHxe

TeHAeHqhi !4 FpnbrKoB, oe3yaepxHyro

caMopeKnaMy,

qeM

3aH14MaeTcF

uenaa

apM14F

,HHrenneKTyanoB",

o6cnyxvBaou.ll4x

qH6pacrpyKrypy,

npaBAe

cKa-

3aTb,

He cnnuiKoM Bblaapu.lerocF

caMocToFTenbHoro

Spanqyacroro

arsaiiia.

06bearFttaB

nyqLrlre

ct4nht B

KyraK l,

He oco6eHHo

KoMnneKcyF no noBoay

HeMHo-

roqhcneHHocrl4

noan14HHo

xyaoxecrBeHHblx

BepulxH,

Opanuva

caerana

craBKy Ha,,uenocrHbrfr o6pa3

HauHo-

HanbHoro

Ah3afrHa"

4o6finacs

HeehAaHHoTo

KoMMepr.l-

KynbrypHoro

vcnexa.

HeqTo aHa|ofrlr{Boe

npoHcxoahr

,lcnaHqta

fepuanuur. npaBurerscrBeHHaF a,4M14Hrt-

cipaqyF

HaqhHaeT

noHltMaTb,

'rTo

t4Ml,1ax HaqrroHanb-

Hoi |,aeHlxqHocr,l

xopolu{fr 6h3Hec h

rapaHT

ycnexa

ire)KAyHapoaHor,r

psinr<e.

tl HeT Hyxabr,

.rro

3HaqlferlhHol4 cTeneHI cxMynvpyerca

BeAb

ycnex

HbtHe B

Moae,

KaKvMt4 nytEM!4

oH o6ecne,rtiBaercE

HMKOMy HeT

Aena.

,,Taxnr,,r

o6paaorr made

in ltaly

noa

yAapoM,

6ber rpeBory lviopor.lul.r,

vrdnbFHcKr,ii

al..r36;H

cbirpar

ponb

AeroHarcpa

n no6yarn

raururx <oirKypeHroB npea-

npxHSTb KoHconu4upoBaHHbte

opfaHx3aqt4oH

bte uaT14.

Mur

xe npo4onxaeM

aeicrBoBarb

Avxe

Hauero

06hrqHoro napThKynFprl3Ma

paccpeAoToqeHHocrx:

dapMbr

KoHKyphpyror

Apyr

ApyroM,

3a6htBaa,

qro

o6pa3

crpaHbt HaAo

Kyltbrr,lBl4poBarb

h co3AaBarb,

no-

croFHHo noAn

rbtBarb

ero". l\,4 bt Bce cule

AeicrByeM

t4H

AVBV

a ru cr vteec

Koi

nap aafi rM e, npoAonxaer

l\4o

por.lLln,

BepF

B cnoHTaHHOcTh

aBTOMart3M

yBeH'{aHUF

ycnexoM

noaIltlHHo

TBopqecKoro

14HAhBrlayan6Horo

ycutttc,

npoMbrujneHHqKa

lrrr

grsainepa,

Mex4y

TeM noKa

Mbt opraHl43oBhtBaeM

BhtcraBKh

Alr3aiHa,

cnoco6Hbre

np Bnelh

BHTMaHt,te

MllpoBoi

o6ulecreen.

HOCTTI

AbrCOKtlM TEOpqeCKhM

noTeHqrlanoM uTanbFH-

qeB,

BepF,

qro

B KoHKypeHTHoi

6oph6e

noSeAa

caMa

co6oi

HaM

o6ecneqeHa.

nuul 6ur

ne nepeBoAhrrhcb

ra.

flaHTbl, Mbr 6es

conporuenexrF

cAaeM no3[LlHr

MeHee

A1eaflAcrvlHo

HacrpoeHHbrM

x noroMv 6oree

aKTflB-

HblM crpaHaM rv'l'a

flno1y'tA,

KoropaF

Vxe AaBHo

fi c

6oncuJoii

crepruei

norpe6nner

6ecnpx3opH6r,

hranb-

FHaKv/.

AV3aiH,

a no cyrh

napa3hrl4pyerHa

HeM.,,fl noH

qbl

nphe3xarcT

B nranv@ yqrrbcF,

noAbruarb

Bo3Ay-

xoM rraJrbFHcKoro

rBopqecrBa,

Bo6paT6 B

ce6a |4Taflb-

FHcKr4i

BKyc,

,{To6bt

3areM

co3Aarb

ce6n

Aoua

uAe-

an6Hbte

VcnoB

AJta

Bocnpok3BeaeHtaa in

vitro reop-

qecrBa

all'italiano. Kaxguri

rs Hac no

oraenbHocrh

eu.le

Moxer

paccqrrbtBarb

no6e4y,

Ho Bce BMecre

KaK

(SfipMa

Vltanaa>

Mbr

craHoBxMcn

ace

6onee

rerKoi

406br,{e;".

Hacrynarcr

rFXerrhte, cyMepegHbre

BpeMeHa,

3aKIIroqaer

Mopouqh.

aJtF

Toro/

qTo

Bceraa

ctaelino L'lraryto

BHe KoHKypeHur.lt4,

,,Anr.

Ayxa

l4MnpoBx3au

Ana

reHxarbHbtx

o3apeHhi,

A'lF

Bpox-

AeHHoao

BKyca,

Orcyrcraue

crpyKTyp,

opraH|43a,

qr,114,

cnoco6HocTl4,

yMeHhF

14 roToBHocTq

BKtraabtBalb

cpeAcrBa

Moxer

cbtrparb

Saranunyro

pott"

129,

'18-19)

K. lvlopoqqr

xecrxo

$opnyrrpyer

ro,

qro

l\4.

Senrlrnr ronbKo

noapa3yMeBaer:

craBKa Ha noA-

nhHHocrb rBop'{ecKofo

BAoxHoBeHrF

(napa4rrva,,re-

Huanl{ocrv",

Ha Koropoi

B3poc 14TanbFHcKlai

.[14-

nhal

6waa Kapra B KoMMepqecKoi

,rpe,

Koropan

oaHa HblHe

onpeaenFeT

ycnex

pacnpeaenFeT

npx3bt.

Ho BMecre

c aroi

ApeBHei

fyMaHhcr[gecKoi

uAeer

cxoAl4T co

cUeHbt h npl4HUhn rBop,]ecKoi

h Boo6qe

nh.rHoi

cBo6oabr, flapagoxcan;rocru

3Toro

pe3vnb-

Tara

3aKnpqaeTcF

B ToM,

qTo

oH FBZUCA B 3Hart Tenb-

Ho14 creneHq

njroAoM MHororrerHei

6opu6ur

aHT!4MoAep.

Hl.4crcKoro

Aq3atHa

nporhB

Ka6anbt Meradh3!aqecK!a-

anphophcTcKlrx,

3aTeM

H BnoflHe

cbh314qecKux HaAn!tq.

Hblx HopM 14

cxeM npoeKT

poBaHhF,

np4'reM

aneflIlHpo-

Bar!4 B 3Toi

6opu6e nvenno

ceo6oAtoi

psnrovxoi

KoHKypeHqhy.

14cropnn

eroi

60pb6bt npoeKTHoro

aaaHrapAa

nporl4B FBHbrx.

o+fiufiatbHbtx

crpyKTyp

Bnacr'r

rocno,t14ThqecKot

a4v/,r1.l..crpa1t4q

unu

AUK-

TaTOpCKOTO

peXhMa

SKCnepTOB-TeXflOKpaTOB,

pexhMa

npoh3BoacTBeHHoh

paq

oHanhHocTl4

ecTh,

B cyu_lHo.

crH. hcropl4ff

sarq6anerra

cB0604onrc6hBoro

Au3aiHa

HeFBHttrM14,

6e3fl4,rHbtM14

crpyKTypaMta

enacrr ceo6oa-

Hofo

pbtHKa,

Koropbri

oKa3arca

B cocroFHh|4

He ronh-

Ko nepeBapyrb,,anrrnolpe6rrerucrre"

gc<anaAut

6vn-

Tapet, Ho

,1 flocTaBhTb

rx na

cnyxSy

co6cteeuuovy

npoqBeraHrn, paBxo

KaK

ta,,Bonto

K ceo6oae".

Fo napaAoKc

3lor

n|,ttllb

BHeuJHl4i.

,,He

tpe6yer

oco6btx

AoKa3arenbcrB,

cgr4Taer

B.[4. Tacanoe,

'rro

TaKre

(

aHTl,|6ypxya3H

bte )

r03yHrB J]eBopaAxKa'!b-

Horo

Au3aiHa

gnox|n

craHoBneHlF

nocrMoAepHr3Ma,

KaK

(crl4x14iHocrb),

(xaoc),

(cron

K HoBeH,,4E ) ta

(6opb-

crpacreiill,

rny6o,raiuJxM

o6pasoru

cpaulenur

c co-

u!,foreHHbf

M crarycoM Bcer

6yp)iya3Hoi

tlvlgultr.3aqyM,

c- KanrTaflhcTl4'{ecKxM

cnoco60M

npoh3BoacTBa

KaK

TaKOBbrM...

a CJleAOBaTenbHO,

c Hax6onee

Trnl4qHblMl4

ana

3anaaHoro

o6qecrBa

cnoco6aMu

npoayKTt4BHoro

TBoDqecraa.

3ro

nnax 3HTponxiHoro

pa3pyuJeBua

3acrbrrocrr4,

HenoABt4xHocTti

ycrapeBunx

$opM

co3h'

aaierunoi

Tl,inororuu,

nflan ux

crr,lxl,liHoro

pa3roxe'

HrF, nocKonbKy oHlt

BcrynarcT

nporrlBopeqhe

c 6ec'

npecraHHhrM

npoqeccoM

o6HoBreHhF

ToBapHo-xHAycr'

puanbHoro yKnaaa

xta3Ht4.

4...

TCo6creenno,

oxeprra

nocronHHoro

(Bbt6poca)

B npaKTuKy

14 co3HaHue

Kax'

abti

pa3

o6HoBnBeMbrx

14 Bce 6onee

al,ro$epeHqlapye-

Mbtx

(3neMeHroB

ana

co3xaaHxfl)

MofyT cYrTaTbca

crporo

roBops, Hax6oree

xapaKTepHblMl4

AnF

Mhpa

Kanurana

3Hepfuei u

SopMoi

pocra

npo!43BoAl4Tenb-

Hbtx

chn !1 npoayKTllBHbrx

cnoco6Hocrei

qeroBeKa.

h 3ToMy

coorBercreyer

coqroryncryproru

nnale)

npeo6naAatlre

coqxanbHo'3HTponhfi

Hblx,

crlaxxiHo-xH'

axBr4ayanl43hpytoulrlx QaKTopoB

npoqeccoB a

(npo-

rpecc[BHoM)

(ana

Kanl4Tana)

T[ne xyaoxecTBeHHoro

co3HaHxF

14 rpururu"

c. 67]

AeicrBt4TenbHo,

npocrexhBan

noa

3Tl4M

yrrloM

3peH!4a 3noneF aBaHrapAHoro

byHTapcrBa,

HerpyAHo

3aMeTi4Tb,

rcar,,aarunorpe6uTerbcKrie"

no3yHfla 060'

paqxBaoTca

no3yHTaMu,,6egoctaHoeoqxoro

npouggo'

AhrenbcrBa",

B 60-e

roAcr

yHx+riLll4poBaHHble, HaBa-

3btaaeMbte

Bnacfblo cTepeoT[nbl

noTpe6reHxF

u 3a€[_

cuMocrb or norpe6neHua

n0614Barrcb

tto3yHroM

,,cBo'

6oAxoro x

pacKoBaHHoro

rBopqecrBa

Macc".70-e

ro'

Aut

6urnr o3HaMeHoBaHbl

npeoAoneH,|eM a6crpaKTHo-

ro 3KcTpeM63Ma 3TUX nO3yHrOB

ycl4reHHblM

BHUMa-

Hl,|eM K 6brroaoi Kynbrype,

K apxerhnxqecKrM

ocHo-

BaM BKyCa

Atr6Opa,

LiHblMl4 croBaMr

K,,peaflhHoi

norpe6BrerbcKoi

Kynbrype".

K roHuy

70-x

ocgo6o-

autenrnurfi

Moayc ororo rutepeca

6utr c+opMyn[po-

BaH

nocTcTpyKTyparlucTaMh

ayxe

paA}1KanbHofo

nnloparu3Ma.,.KaxAoe

o6ulecreo o6F3aHo

o6ecne-

9t4Tb CBOI4M

rpal<AaHaM npaeo aut6opa:

'{rcno

f3blKoB

aonxro

6urrs

paBlo

trxcny

xenaHui",

KuHyn P. Sapr

o6HoBneHHbri

n03yHr

rBopqecKoro aHapx|43Ma;

npaB-

aa, ao6aanner

oH,

;,Hx

oaHo

o6ulecreo

noKa He corra-

Llaerca,

qro

xMgerca MHoxecrBo

xenaxrai"

[1,

c. 113] ,

B 80e roaur Ha BorHe nocrMoaepHxcrcKoi

peBonxlqt,lu

,,MHOXeCTBO

rKenaH4i." 6UtnO npUrntO

nOBCeMeCTHO,

c rof rltuJb nonpaBKoi,

qro

xoreH{e, BoreHl4e, xena-

Hl,te

grar'l

He aKToM

nuqHoro Bbl6opa, a np!4Hyaxrenb-

HbrM

3aKoHoM,

aaxe

o6a3aHHocrbo.

MexaHta3M

xcnon-

HeHra 3TOrO 3aKOHA

CTpOTnCF He Ha np8MOM nprHyx-

ae{t/|

Ho Ha coBpau4eHuu, coorasHe, npoBoKaqx!4

noc-

TOFHHOTO, HeHacbtTHOrO XeraHrF,

BraCTb

npFHhKaOKa-

3aflacb 3d6eKTrBHee Bnacr!4

KHyra, a anernFquB K noa-

co3HaHuKr

npoayKrxBHee,

9eM npaMoe

aaBreH4e

co,

sHaxne

(ecnoMHr,rM

arr6poc raefi

,,oceo6ox'aeHua

nv6n-

Alrrognoi

oleprlru" u rolqenuhta.,HoBoro

reAoHr43Ma"),

Henb3a cKa3arb,

qro

au3aiH,

oco6eHHo

ero

paAra-

KanbHbri

aBsHrapa, np€6brBar

HeBeAeHvtt/t

oiHocr.irerb-

MeXaHTKX l,l

BnaCTHOTO

nOTeHqnana,,pbrHKa xena-

Hrfi",

oAHaKo Ha nepBbrx

nopax

oH,

oAroi

croporrr,

ynoBan

Ha cBoo cnoco6Hocrb

ryMaHxrapHoro BbrnpFM-

neHtAA curya\uv, c

apyt-oi

yn4Bancs

ceoei nogfiqqei

cTopoHHero, npoHhqaTeJrbHofo, 14poHl1qHoro

xa6rpaa-

TenE

chryaqrh, KoTopaa

AetcrBrrenbHo

pacKpbrna

AnF

He[o

qenbre

3anexu HeBeAoMbrx KyabrypHbrx 3Heprut,

cxn, npoqeccoa, MexaHvr3MoB r

3aKoHoMepHocret.

Ecrecrgexxui xoa co6hrrlri

npeApeul[n

hcxoa. KaK

koHcrarlpyer 6enn6xn,

At4saiHep(apxxreKTop)

caM

B 6onbujrHcTBe

cnyraea

oKa3arc-a

He I cocToFHrg

yAep'

xarbca nepeA

co6na3HoM r, uraBHoe,

Bo3MoxHocrbKt

noflHocTbrc

pacKpenocTl4Th

cBolo,,TBopqecKylo

nyflbca-

ur4o",

TeM

6onee

qro

3To BnouHe oTBeqano

BoxaereH-

Hoi 14 Ka3aBuJeicF Heaocrl4xhMoi

Bo3MoxHocru

,,To-

TarbBoro uHcaiTa", eo:Moxroctn,

Hr1

qeM

He 3a6o-

TFCb, 9epnaTb ,13 3HepreTh'lecKoro ucToqHuKa

feHl,larb-

rocrr nonnoi

uepoi. Tet,r

caMuM

au3aiHep.

aaxe

6onbuJe, teM norpe6vrenb, nonan

B xecro'{aiulyrc Ka-

6any HeyronHMoro, crl4xrliHofo

BoxtreJteHrf. CTl,|-

xl.riHo-a3brqecKaa,,dHrocodxF x143H14", oAyr.t'leBnaB-

uaF MHOfOneTHee 83brcKaHre a6conlorHoi

Taoorie-

cKofi

cBo6oabr,

oKa3anacb co3By.iHoi,,tareHTHoMy

BapBapcrsy"

(X.

6oaprisp)

rpaxAaHcKoro o6qectea

r nplaBena K 3aKoHoMepHoi

pacnnare

nneHy |,t

pa6-

cTBV

IrhqHOCT14.

3To

BHyrpeHHee,

h3BecrHoM cuutcne

vera$u.

3u'{ecKoe,

pa6crao,

coceAcrByer c

ropa3Ao 6otee npo-

3au,{ecKoi 3aBhcHMocrhK,

60pMan[3oaaHHbtx

pbt-

HOLIHbtX CrpyKTyp 14 MexaH h3MoB.

Ilpexae

acero, 3ro o6HoaneHHhri

,,pex4M

3Kc.

neproB"

Bracrb

MeHeaxepoB. XapaKTepeH FBHbri

noAleM hHTepeca K MeHeAxMeHTy B

ax3aiHepcKoi

npecce nocneaHhx ner. B noao6nurx MaTepharax

noKa

eu.le oraalor

aonxHoe

6necrFruei

!4TanbaHcKoi Tpaa|4-

qhx,,npocBeqeHHoTo

npeanphHHMaTerbcTBa'" ocHo-

BaHHO|O Ha 6eCKOpbTCTHOM np6rlTenbcTBe r

TOTOAHO-

cTl4 noKpoBuTetbcTBoBaTb TaJraHTaM He

paafi

KoMMep-

'{ecKot

BbrToahr, Ho

paah penyraqxlr

[24]

O4naro

BCe OgeAHAHee,

qTO

A HaLlll,t

AHX

penyTaUlf,

CaMa

ce6e

roi<e Kapra

6!.traa, ToqHee, oHa

npeAonpeAena-

ycnexa,

Ho, Hao6opor,

ycnexa

3aBucr/tr, a noroMy

qaLlJa

BecoB KaqHynacb B cropoHy

,.npo6h"

orHocr4-

TenbHo HoBoi, no KpaiHe; lrepe

4rr

Eeponur, r no.nno-

uovxoi, rairo

ac€BnacrHoi cbyrypbr B npocrpaHcTBe

,,npoMhrr.!neHHmrb-

pbrHoK-ar3aiHep"

[22]

floeutuJeHHe crarvca MeHeaxMeHTa Beaer

t,,l3-

aecrHoMy 3aMeuteHH|o cBo6oaHofr KoHKypeHqtau

roBa-

poB

cEo6oAsoil KoHKypeHql4ei

MeHeA>KepoB t4

copeBHG

BaHra

KaqecTBa

copeBHoBaHI4eM

MaH[nynFTxBHblx

cnoco6Hocre;,

noBKocrH

pyK,

TeM 6onee

,rro

o6ullri

ypoBeHh

Ka'{ecTB€ roBapoB

He TonbKo BblcoK, Ho t4

npHMepHo

oAHHaKoB. Cneay|oU.lHi 3aKoHoMepHbti

gran

sTOrO npoqe@a

MoHononH3aqxa

pbrHKa

pacnpeae'

tteHue

eto

vexAv sadyaun.

KaK orMe,{aeT oAr4H t43

l4laJtbflHcKr,rx MapKeTonofoB,

paHhure

pbrHoqHan

KoH-

KypeHqHa HanoMrHara

cocrF3aHqe

6onee ru MeHee

6ecrcoptrctrsrx nrc6rrenei, rae, KoHeliHo,

6srrr

cgor4

nxAepbf, Bo K

QnHHuJy

nphxoavnvt

Bce

BceM

3aci{l4Thr.

Banca

pe3yrbtaT;

Teneph xe

3ro

xecTKaF

cnopTl4BHaF

6opb6a

,,npoo+{".

rae

HeyaaqHHK

BbrHyxreH

coiTx

avcraHuxl [3a,

c, 20]

. B 3roi ct4ryaqu!4 Bnon-

ecTecTBeHHbr 3TaTHCTCKrae HaCTpOeHHA

AaXe

CpeAh

nr6epanoe;

ynoBaHre

Ha rocyaapcraeHHyto

noaaepx-

Ky, r'oroBHocrb

noiTl

noKnoH

rar6onee

niresu-

paeMoi

aHapxFcrcrByroulHMH neBopaA!rKanaMx

OopMe

BIaCTH,

peKnaMhpy8

rocyaapcTBeHHyp

nole3HocTb H

npecrHxHocrb

paAsKanbHoro

aBaHrapAHoro

Ah3atHa,

TaiHoi

Ha.qexAe,

qro

rocyAapcrBeHHbri

nporeKql4oHl43M

oKaxeTca MeHee

qsHH'{HblM

l,r

KopbrcTHhtM,

qeM

slacTb

M€KpX03HbrX

3KOHOM h9eCKr.tX

CTpyKTyp.

lloA,reprHeu

eqe

pa3:

oxapaKTepr43oBaHHaF Bbt-

uJe atlacTHaF

cHcTeMa

ocHoBbtBaeTcF

He Ha

penpeccHB-

HOM MeXaHH3Me

npFMOrO nphHy4AeHr8,

OHa

He MeUJa-

,.6brTb

cBo6oaHbrM", Ho

oHa

npeBpaqaer c8o6oAy

KaK TaKoByE

e 6poaoecri ToBap. To'iHee, HaKpenKo

cef,3btBaer ceo6oqy

ycnexoM.

h3BecrHocrbro,

nony-

rapHocrbro.

ycnex

MoAeH,

orMeqaer

Mopor.luu,

ycnex

yHhBepcanbHb!i

Kpxreptafr.

YcraHaenrieaerca

aeoiHoe

TO)XAeCTBO: TanaHT

paBeH

yCfiexy, ycnex paBeH

TanaHTV,

Fctto,,tro KotltMepu!4anh3aLlfiii

Ax3aiHa

Henpe-

MeHHoe

3BeHo

oqepqeHHo, nornqecKoi

qenolK14,

l4MeHHo

oHa cKroHFeTcfl

Ha Bce naAEt coBpeMeHHoi

rcptrnxoi,

Ogttaro

npe4craenFerca,

9To Hhqero

cne-

qr@rvecrr

AeKaAeHTcKoTo

ri HoBoro

B KoMMepL{l,|anu-

3auI

He coaepx[TcF

14 He

oHa npeacTaBnFeT

TnaBHyto

yrpo3y

xyAoxecrBeHHo-Taop9ecKot

noAJI14HHocr14

nonHoqeHHocrt4

cdepbt

AE3afiHa.

Fopae4o

cepse:tee

,lBot

npoqecc, Koropbti ruoxHo

6trtro

6tt Hageatu

,,MeHeAxepu3aUhei

AA3ai,Ha",

BceMx

BbtTeKa|oulx-

M!t

orcpAa nocneAcreunvr,

[lpoqecc

3Tor

B Bbtcuei

cTeneH4

TUnXqeH

AnF

COBpeMeHHOTO

aBaHrapaa,. no-

cKolrbKy

aBaHrapahcTcKaa

3HeprhF

Bceraa

ycTpeMIa-

nacb B HaySonee

3HeproeMKue,

KpeaT14BHbre

3oHbt

KyJ]b-

rypsr.

!,nn

coBpeMeHHoli 3noxh

KoMMVH'lKauxi

taKoi

3OHOh,

HeCOMHeHHO,

ABIFeTCA

pbtHOK

3OHa, KOMMy-

HIKaTXBHaf,

OnpeaereHyto,

oToaBhHyBua6 Ha

3aa-

Ht4i nnaH

Aaxe

npoh3BoAcrBo.

Cooreercreeruo,

r,r rau-

6onburnfi

TaopqecKtli

noreHuran

3aKnrcqeH

B no3ullt4i.1

MeHeaxepa-KoMMyHhKaTopa.

KorAa

B cepealHe

80-x roaoB

Monoaoe

noKone.

H14e

ah3aiHepoB

pl-lHynoch

B caMocToFTeIlbHyto

peKnaM-

HO-npeanprHl,lMaTenbcKyto

fleaTeIIbHocTb,

TaK

Ha3bt aae-

Mbtr,,npoHTl-i3M",

3To noHaqary

6btno

hcTonKoBaHo

KaK xecT

oTqaFHl4F

,,3a6poUJeltoi

r,aoroAexra".

rolo.

poi

ovenu-4e rpy4to

np06hrbcn

ro cBoHM14

KoHeqHo,

,,a6conrcTHo

HeKoMMep'{ecKuMt1"

np.ealv,n

B nnorHo

3a6hTbri M3TpaMr

Ebtcllui

nposecchoHanbHbr;

cnoi.

O4uaro

ecrope

Bo3H!4KIo

nepBoe

HeaoyMeHr4e,

3a-

TeM

h oTpe3BIeH/e:

fpynnbt,

KoTopbrM y[anocb

npo-

pBarbcF

crpaHhubt

cneurdnbHol;

npeccbt,

oAHa 3a

Apyroi

cTanfi

AeKnapupoBaTb

qhcro

KoMMepqecK[;,

TOqHee,

MeHeaxepcKt4i

l,lcToqHl4K

CBOeTO

BAOXHOBe-

ttra.

Sonee

ToTo,

oHx HH'{yTb

KoMnreKcoBalh

noBoay

oTcyTcTBrlA

OpHfqHanbHbtx npoeKTHbtx

Vaei,

noBoAy

,,HeKpyrrgecKoro

MaHbeph3Ma"

cBoet

npo-

AyKllula

(xapaKTepvcfuKa

ota 66tra

BbtHeceHa

B 3afo-

noBoK

oAHOt

r,13 nepBbtx

crarei

noxanyi,

Hah6olee

yAa,rflkBoi,

6hub

noBKoi,

hTanbFHcKoi.rDVnne

Ta.

Koro

ronKa

-,,3eec"

[28] )

Taopvecxoe

cavocroarue

opl4rrlHanbHocTb

no4cKa

BocnplHl4Manhcb

l4M14

KaK

araBt,t3M,

nepecranh

6ulru

qetHocturo:

raHbte

ueHHocrtl ,l

no33HA

OTKpbtnhcb

qeHHocTtl

no33[F 6tt3Heca.

9ro

6rr nr,r roaoplrn

Mapi,r

o.,npodeccuoHanbHoM

AocTouHcrBe",

l/|

oH co6crBeHHhtM TaopqecTBoM

pa3

aeMoHcTpt4poBan : HeT Hl4geTo

Mtlpe,

qTo

He Mor-

6bl craTb

,lcToqHhKoM

TBopqecKcro

BAoxHoBeHrra

aaaHrapaficTa,

oTTeHoK

,,HapyueHhF

aanpeta,,,

ecnu

He npaMorc,,KoulyHcTBa",

J|l4Llth

cT14i4yflxpyeT

TBopqe.

cKyto

3Heprttrc. B

<Onqe

rosUoe,

iieM

no33l,rF 6x3Heca

xyxe

no33Hu 6e3o6pa3Horo?

Coepevennan

KpMrr,tKa

o.arH

ronoc yKa3btEaeT

uhHl43M

qacrxocrH,

no-

{cruHe

KaracrpodhqecKre

MacuJTa6br

nollo6oena

cei-

qac

npo6neMa

sopoBcrBa lgen

[18] )

r rie6pexexre

xa-

qecTBOM

KaK Ha fnaBHhte

aoKa3aTenbctBa

nphHtll,r-

nqalbHol4

nopogHocTt4

MeHeaxepcKoro

An3ahHa

y'c-

KyCCTEa.

ABHMaTenbHO

Aq!4ThlBaFCb

B Kpt.l.l4'tecKqe

hHBeKTl4Bhr,

06HapyxEBaeu.!5,,]To

ropa3Ao

6onbuJ!ae

npereH314h

Bht3btBaeT

n6BceMecTHo

ccBepuaeMaa

3aecb

noaaenKa,

noaMeHa

qeHHocTei,

,ilo,

Bnpo.teM, roxe

ecrb npoFBneHqe

qhH

3Ma. TaK, yxe

qrrlpoeaaurricr

BbtuJe

CoKonaHcKliii

nuurer:

,,H

BoBce He

npH3b!Bato

o6brahrh

eoixy

pasenercarenhHbtM

arrpaKuuoHaM

MBulype...

Enolucte

urpyrurll,

creKrbtr!K!4

Kanei,qo-

cKona

t,l npo']ne

arpr6yrur

npa3AHHKa,

nerKoMbrcJtHF

|,4

gyr.!eBiloro

3aopoBba

nIleHl4Te,]bH5t

aparoueHHbt.

.Qo

rex

nop, npaBAa, noKa

x He nbrrarcTca

BbtAarb 3a

Hacrogulxe

aparoqer'trocrra"

[

1 0]

CoKonEHcKoMy

BTopxr

Apyroi

ore'{ecrBeHHb

rcprrnr, A. flarbrHlHa.

{Kcrati/,

eHeganHccrb

pbtHo'r-

Horo

rafiSyHa,

o6pyr.uuerueroca Ha Hauty Kynbrypy,

aoconl.oIHo K HeMy

He no[ToToBneHHylo

coBepuleHHo

nuLueHHyro

14MMyHuTeTa, BhraB14HyIra

oTe'{ecTBeHHVro

Kptlr4Ky

,.ryTb

nu He Ha n4aMpytou_lee

noloxeHtle B Mh-

ocrpore

pe+neKcltta.)

,,lzl

npex4e Mbr

pa3

3a-

Meqanh,

nrureT

oHa,

KaK

npl4 not\4oulh cpeacrB

MaccoBoii

r,rHdjopMaqxla

cyqecrBeHHo

B03BbtuJaflacb

npotraxHaF

ueHa

TaKoro

ToBapa, KaK tacKyccTBo...

AnF

3Toro Heo6xoArtMo

6hrno,

'{To6bt

(ToBap)

Haxo-

alncF

noa

BbtcoKhM

o+l4uhanhHbrM noKpoBl,tTenhcT-

BoM, HbrHqe )Ke

BnepeAx 6yAyr,

raxerca, Te, Kro npo.

FBrr

bonbtle TanaHTa h

h3o6oeTarenbHocrl,l

B o6nacTh

MapKeThHra. Fjo

Bonpoc:

coBnaaeT nq TanaHr npelnpu-

HTMaTeIE

TaIaHTOM

XyAOXHhKa?".

BO eCnrOV Cny-

qae.

npoaonxaeT

oHa,,,ceroaHF

cnoco6HocTx

B orina-

cT MapKeThHTa

O6Hapyxh'o Be To,

qTo

xopoLuo, a To,

qTo

He 6e3 aTpecc

BHocTH cnoco6Ho

aoKa3aTb

cBoro Ho-

BH3Hy. npx 3roM

npo6neMa

(xopou.lo

cAenaHHoro)

or-

naaaeT... HoBaTopcTBo

B l4cKyccTBe

cnyxrT

celqac no,

cpe4craenrocrra"

[6J

KaK

ee 3anaaHbre

rolneTn, Iarttrtttra

ttcxoavr

l,3 a6conpTHot

qeHHocT,,,xyAoxecrBeHHoro

Kaqecr-

aa",

ToxaecTBeHHoro,,xyaoxecrBeHroi

nopn40vno.

crh" 14

,,xyaoxecrBeHHoi

noanuHHocrr,4".

no33l4t4

6h3Heca 3Tta

ueHHocrfi

3aqacryro

noaKo cl,tMynhpyror-

cF, Ho

noAnfiHHocTbro

3Aecb

o6naAapr HHhre

qeHHocTl4

14Hbte KphTepul,l Ka'{ecTBa,

ecTb,,ycnexa

aena".

ca.

Mhti

nonynFpHbri

noBKocrb

pyK,

Kpqrepk;.

TaK

cKa3arb.

AnF

Ha'{hHarcuthx.

[-opaa4o

au6raqroenee

4py.

roi

Kp''tepvit,

xMetouhi

xoxAeH[e

B 3nqrapHoM

croe

aBaHTapa-HurhnlcToe.

$rrcrpyer

Bbrcrlyro

Ha Ha-

croFrqxi MoMeHT

orMerKy napaAoKcanbHoit

3Bon€|lH14

aBaHrapancrcKoro

aHapxl43Ma,

cnoBHo ToM14MoTo

.,3a14.

noBbtM

KoMnIeKcoM"

BoxaeneHha ToTo,

'1eM

oH Be-

AeT

6opb6y.

gTo

orropraeT

I ot

qeTo

6exrl:

3ToT Kpl4.

TeP[t

Bracrb.

Aocraro,rHo

orKpoBeHHo

BbtcKa3brBaerca

B 3ToM

Ayxe

oAhH 14s rnaaHerx

6opqoe c,.enacrurc

4ucrypcrn"

AeKOHCTpyKrOpOB,,AtaCKy

pcua

BnacTH" nonynfi

pHbti

SpaHqy3cK,ai ,,HoBhri

gfinoco$"

AeppuAa,

onr.

paacb

npH 3ToM

Ha,

Ka3anocE.

6br, cyFy6o reoper[qec-

Kylo nocTcTpyKTypan[cTcKyro

Mbtclb

o Ton4,

qTo,,Teo-

phfl

rhreparypbr

yirpaBnner

npou3Bo[crBoM

3Ha'{eH!,|i".

Pasenaan

ronqenqHrc

HoBbtx,

AeKoHcrpyKTriBHbrx

npo-

qTeH14i

nHTepaTypHbtx

TeKcToB,

npq3BaHHbtx

ocyulecT-

BXTb

AeKOHCTpyKf.lhro

cKphlToi

,,Bnacfvl D,AcKypct

u",

oH 3aMeqaeT:

,,...Koraa

3a'{hThtBarc

Ha ceMHHape

npea-

noxeH!4e

l43

aaHHofo

TeKcTa..,

F He

npocTo

BbtnonHato

yxe

cyulecrByroulhi

Aoroaop

y'le6Hurt4

saee,qeHHei,t

u c

o6qecrBoM !rl!4

rocyaapcrBoM)

a rarxe

nruty

r.1I14

noaroTaan14Ba|o

aIF

noanucaHl4F HoBbli

KoHTpaKT

H C CaMhM yVe6tutr,,r

saeeAenreM,

Mexay

HtiM

ao-

Mt1Hl{pyroU.ll,lMx

cunaMh

o6ulecTBa. lz1r,,,texto

sAect,

rcar

B nto6hrx

nepefoBopax

a neperoBopbt

no 3aKlro,{e-

Hl4lo KoHTpaKTa

BCefAa

h3MeHFtoT

npeAhtayuee

corna_

LlJeHhe,

HaAO

rCnOnb3OBaTb

BCeBO3MOXHbte

ynOBKtt

!r crparerxqecKrie

xvrpocry."

(Urar,

[12,

c.86]).

CToFulaa

ori.iM

BhrcKa3brBaHHeM

la3oqpeHHei.

uaa

$unocodcrcan ,,urpa

6ucep', npeKpacHo

yxr4sa-

eTcn

c HecKpbrEaeMbtM

npafMaTU3MOM,

ecn,l

He MeD_

KaHThIrh3MOM

MbtCtxTeJlbHotl

vcraHoaKt4.,,3ror

npo_

uecc

npenogaBaHra,

KoMMeHrhpyeT

ale,lecTEeHHbt;

nrrreparypoBea ta

dxnoco+

A, lvluxainog,

noaqrHeH

BenxKot

crrxl4h cMbrcna,

Koropoi nphqacreH

,leKTop... Ho oH,

HanpoTHB, noaql1HeH

flparMarrqecKoi

purrovtroi

ct rya\uq, KoropaB, oAHaKo,

cronb

rfly6oKo

(

nepexfiBaeTca

) ...

qTo

BocnpxHrMaeTcF

KaK HacToa-

uaF

cT'lx'lF

Hee >Xe BCe norpyxeHo

h B Hei

Bce

H€xoal,rr cBoe ocHoBaHhe

{ onpaBAaHxe.

nopaxaer

3Ta

yHxBepcafl

bHocTb

pbrHorrHo-KoMMepqecKoto... KoTopaF

AonycKaer

raxyn

Qopuy

BocxoxAeHra

K cMbrcny"

17 ,

c. 941,

aanbLue

lvlt4xainoe

naer

6necrnulhi

aHa-

n143 napaaoKcarbHofi

Bpat4 M006parl4Mocrh

cBo6oabl,

3a-

Br,rchMocrH

Bnacrr,

xapaKTepHot

Ann

KyrbrypHl4'{e-

crBa

MeHeAxepcKoro rlna.,,TaKaF

yHHBepchrercKaa

)Kt13Hb npOnUTaHa nparMaTx3MOM...

KOTOpblri, OAHaKO,

nonb3yercn

ana

aocrxxeHla

ceo6x

qeaefi

coaceM

nparMalhgecKl/|Mr

cpeacTBaMu: oTHouJeHrle

qenx

cpeacTB

(

llppaqroHarbHoe

noKa

npoQeccop-n|4Te-

paTypoBea... pa3BopaghBaeT

cBot4 cpeacTBa, oH

6e3yc-

I|OBHO

HaXOAT4TCF B CSO6OAHOM OT

nrc6hrx CTOpOHHIiX

coo6paxeH|,|f npocrpaHcrBe...

rAe aorhHo

pacnopFxa-

eTcF BCeM:

14 CMbtCnOM, 14 TO,lKOBaHl4eM,

U UCTO9v-er.

...Bce,

qTo

nonaAaer B

3To cBo6oaHoe npocrpaHcrBo, oH

aonxeH

nepeKpoxTb no-HoBoMy,

nepenlrcaTb, nepeae-

rarb, neoeronKoBars,

ece

ao'|xHo

6utTb noHFTo

KaK-To

,rHa9e,

iieM

paHbue.

BceM

pacnopFxaercF,

Aaxex

caMoi xcropxei... OH o6F3aH erc

pacnopsxarbca,

eMy

3a 3To

AeHbfn

nrarar, ri coeahHeHxe raKoi

nonHoi cBo-

6oatr

r <onratst> TeM Kopoqe, 6nrxe { Henocpeacr-

BeHHee,

qeM

6onuure

gra

cao6oaa

aeicrerre,lbHo

cBo-

6oaHa or BcaKoro nparvarusrua"

(Tav

xe, c. 95-96) .

Herpy4ro

3aMervrb,

.rro

3Toi1 KprruKe

He-

cKpbr BaeMof

npaf MaTr3Ma

coBpeMeHHof

KynbTypHo-

ro aBaHrapaa c rpaauu{oHHo-ryMaturapnutx

rpae-

creenrcrx) n03tauui x

qeHHocrei

coaepxarcg

aonF

Bocxl4utenua

'rncroroi

pa6otur

r aprrcrx3MoM,

c Ko'

TopbrM HaiaeH Bbrxoa

ri3

6e3HaaexHoi,

rasanocu 6ut,

ara

noKroHHr,lKa

cBo6oabr

cl,iryaqht,l, a raKXe cKphtraF

BO3MOXHOCTb CMl4peHrA

C flO33hei 6rSleCa

U npr,t-

3HaHl4fl ee

HOBbrM, Bbrctlll4M, cpaBHurenbHo

c Tpaax-

ql,lOHHblM,

XAeanOM

,,pa3BxTtl8

BCeX Ctirl U CnOCO6HO'

crei",,,gBo6oaHoro caMoonpeAeneH|,lr

geroBeKa".

noxanyi, Ha

SoHe

3Toi 6ecnpeaeflhHoi

cBo6oAbr

caMoBbrpaxeHl,|a, Koropaa

K ToMy xe

o6opaquBaerca

a6conprHoi Bnacrbo

rorbKo

HaA aApecaroM coo6-

uteHqa, Ho h

Haa

6yayulr4M,

nocKorbKy

opxeHTl,tpoBaHa

Ha nocToFHHoe nopoxaeHhe x HacaxaeHxe Bce

,,HoBo-

fo",

,,t

Hofo",1,1 Koropaa cBepx roro eu.le |,

xopoulo

onflaqrBaercF,

3a6orbr

neqanbHoi

yqacrr.r

xyAoxHuKa,

,,He

cnoco6loro nptrMKHyrb

r-rr

r raroi

rpynne unq

HanpaBreHhrc,

Aeifiaypull4M

KaK

pbrHoyHaF

MaS|,ls,

h He

o6HapyxxBaKruleMy

(noHhMaHhf,

no3Tt4,recKoi

nphpoAbf 6h3Heca), Koroporo KaK

paHbure

rec1$nu

Te, KTO nplcnoco6huca K raeonorfll4, TaK r

Tenepb

TecHFT

Te, KTo

nphcnoco6fincF

pbrHKy",

r,,r Boo6qe

nnaq Haa

,,noaJ|r,rHHbtM

ltcKyccTBoM" MoryT

paccMaT-

pnBarbcF

KaK TpaAuqlioHanl,lcrcKhri l4nx

Aaxe

peaK-

qlloHHbri

nepexrror

[6]

. 1,1

HaBepHsKa 3noxu

xyAoxecrBeHHbtx noateMoB He aBrFloTcf cBt4aeTefl bcT-

BoM

pa3Bhrocrr

quBuntA3atruu,

nao6opor, noKa3arenb

nocneAHei

KaK

pa3 pa3Bxrocrb pbrHKa,

np!4 ToM

'{ao

pbrHoK

BoBce la He

npr3aaH

3a6or{Tbca

Kynbrype

l/l

Al,lKTaT

ero, nO nph3HaH|/'rc Kp[Tl'lKOB,,,Ha HeCKOJIb-

KO nOpAAKOA,

HeCOh3MeprMO 'ryqUJe

ArKTaTa

rAeono-

rrr".

,,3arorcr

nphpoAhr

ABax<Abr aaa

qerbtpe,

Ka-

MeHHaa

creHa, ecnt-t

Bocnor]b3oBarucn

Aedrrtqrnulr

repoa

AocroeBcKoro.

nrurer flarsrxrna,

rar

BCe

Xe XOqeTCF BOCnOJlb3oEaTbCF

eto

COBeTOM

(He

npHMt4psTbcF

xr c

o4noi

,13 3Thx

HeBo3MoxHocTel4

KaMeHHbrx creH, ecnH

BaM Mep3rlT np[vfipETbc8)"

[6]

ly'rax, croao

cKa3aHo:

,,Mep3hr".

Becu

rparrau,

,,aeKaaaHc"

coBpeMeHHoro

KynbTypHofo

co3HaHuF

TOM tt COCTOhT,

tlTO

OHO

He MOXeT He

npI3HaTb eCTeCT'

BeHHOCTh, 3AKOHHOCTH

AaXe

nporpecclBHocr[

npo'

l4cxoAFUlero, He

Moxer

cocnarhcF

Ae+opMaqxlo

ttc-

xoaHbrx

[aeanoB, nocKonbKy Bl.1AtlT,

tlTo

IlOrUKa

gBonrcqhq

6eoynperna,

He Moxer HaiTH

Ko3na

orflyule-

nra

(xorn

l,'

ynopHo

ero t,luler, h

Aaxe

HaxoAttr,

ryr

x<e

o6HapyxriBaer

caorc our6<y)

;

oaHttM

cnoBoM,

peujHTenbHo

Bce noHvx4aeT

efo npb3Halb,

9To nony'

gl4rocb

hMeHHo

ro,

,,3a

qro

6opon[cb",

1,1 TeM He

Me-

Hee,

MoxeT 6rr'ru, rvexro no3ToMy...

Mep34T.

TaKO'

BO 3MOr.lliOHanbHOe COAepxanl4e

nOHFTUA,.CeMUOTITqe'

cKoe 3acopeHHe":

ayujHo,

uJyMHo,

TnxKo,

rpfl3Ho, Ha-

KOHeU npOCrO

OnaCHO,

KaK

3OHe 3KorloftrqecKoli

Karacroodhr.

,.Kynrrypa

npeaeJra"

rsnore3a

HOBOTO

OHTOJTOTHqeCKOTO

ropr3oSTa

npoer<flroi

Kynhrypbl

IleKa,qeHTcKoe

co3HaHhe

3To

He co3HaHre

Kpa-

A[eana, Ho

neaeHFulee

aytlly

napan[3ytoqee

Bonlo

flpv3HaHHe

B HAeane

o6oporHa,

H [MeHHo

B Tor Mo'

MeHr, KOrAa

p€ann30BaB

O6pel

cavocroareluHyto

xh3Hb h aracrb.

B HauJeM cny,lae

peqb

haeT o

ryMaHr_

TapHoM nasoce, H3Haqafla

oayuJeBrBBtlleM

nocTMoaep-

HTICTCKyTO 3nonelo,

TOM TyMaHrCTl4qeCKOM

[Aeane,

oaHa h3 nepBbrx

SopMyn!.poBoK

Koropoto npxHaane'

xr..1T

poMaH

Tra

Ko-n

poc

BeTxren

bcKoi

14cTopl4,lecKot

ulKone,

pa3afiToi

BnocneacrBl,t

np BepxeHqaMu

.,drinoco$Hg

xr:uu".

Fyt',lanrcJvsecKl^

vaean,

xa'

paKTepfi3yer

ero

l.-X.

Falauep,

Mblcn!1Tca BHe

cBa3u

c onpeAeneHHbrM

coaepxaHheM, B ocHoBe

ero nexlir

OopManbHa8

qaeF

BenEKoro

t',tnoroo6paaua.

...3ror

uaean

aeicTslaTenbSo vHrBepcareH.

TaK KaK

ero

nptHtlrne HeBo3Moxr.ro

pacL!aTaTb

HrKaK'tM l4cTop14'{e'

cKtaM

on6rroM.

HriKaKoi oL!enoMrFrou.lei

6peHHocrhlo

qenoBeqecKHX

aen-

14cropfifl

HMeer

cMbtctt a ce6e

ca-

Moi. HenocroaHcrBo

Bcefo

3eMHoro

noAn[HHoe

ocHoBaHHe.

1460 a caMoM npexoaFqeM

cKpbrBaerca

3Ta

TaiHa HeHcqepnaeMoi FpoayKTHaHocrx

qenoBe'{ecKot

x|,l3Hv. OoH fyM6otbAT, Bocx14u]aFcb

KnaccxqecKoi

apeBHocrbro.

cqHTar,

qro

60farcrBo

14HAr,lBr4ayanhHbtx

npoaBneHhH

3To He TonbKo oTn4qrTetbHaa

qepra

rpeqecl<ot xH3HH, 3To

ornM'[.rreflbHaa

qepra

l,lcropt4-

i{ecKo;

xH3HH aoo6ue, HMeHHo B

SToM 3aKnpgaeTcn

I{eHHocrb

cMhrcn

HcropHH, tl B 3ToM cMbtcr

3aneqar-

neHHoro B He;3pernuta 6recrnutrx

no6eA n npl,lcKop6-

Hbrx nopaxeHHi"

[3,

c.2501

noornxesrr XlX. a sareM XX BeKa una He-

yrxxalou{aA

6opu6a vexay

AeyMa

ryMaHhcrl,lrecKhMr.r

SpoHTaMH,

KaMHeM

nperKHoBenua e

<otopoi 6urna

crorbKo

cBo6oaa

rBop!ecKoro

caMoocyrqecrBueHua

,tcTophqecKoro

cTaHoBueHEF

qe'|oEeKa,

cKoIbKo

Mac-

u:ta6

aonycrrr,aoro

ur4rer4yanuroro 60rarcrBa l.i

pa3-

Hoo6pa3,lF

KynbrypHoro rBopqecrBa. B 50€

roAbt

Ha-

urero

BeKa

OpoHT

,,rAeanHsroa

aAenroB a6crpaKTHo-

rAearbHoro.,,noAnlaHHo

cBo6oAHoro"

qeroBeKa,

nbr-

TaBuJl,rxca Bbrpacrhrb ero KaK roMyHKynyca

np06xp-

TOTaflliTapHoro

@qtianbHoro npoeKT!4poBaH!4a,

Aan

nepByrc cepbe3Hyro rpeqxHy

{He

6e3 B'|HE8l,lF 3penHUla

npaKTfi Kn raKoro

npo6Hpo'{Horo

3KcneprMeHTa, nBneB-

Horo

roranhrapHbrMh

nonhrk'{ecKHMu

pexruatuu)

aaenTbr ecTecTaeHHoro,

,,pearbHoro"

qeroaeKa

x Heorpa,

HhqeHHoTo

pa3H006pa3hF

v 60rarcrBa

eTo

npoFBneHtl14

Haqan[

Ha64parb chny.

K Haqany 80-x roAoB

6hfEa 6bt-

6aKT[qecKh

Bbrr,trpaHa,

flepeute 6utnur

BblrecHeHbl

cSepy rocyaapcrBeHHo-nonqrEqecKoto

odxuto3a,

rconqy

80-x.

K€K noKa3btBaer

xorF 6br

+paHuy3cKq;

on6tT. norepFnh

h TaM Kpea

TAoBepra.

Bropute nory-

L]t1nh

HaKOHeq BO3MOXHOCTb

HacnaxAarbcF

3pen14ueM

6ecKoHe,rHoro

60rarcrBa

pa3H006pa3ua

qetroBeqe-

cKoi KVnbrypbr,

KoropaF

Aocrhrna

npaKT

qecKt

ro-

TanbHocTl,l cBoero

nphcvTcTBua ao Bcex

MblcnHMblx

143-

MepeHhFX, Ho, BcMorpeBLll4cb

B 3To 3epKarbHoe

orpa-

xeH

no6eahBuero

TyMaHvcrt4qecKoro

[aeana, oHh

noHFnq,

qTo

Meo3|4T.

Haao

cKa3arb,

qro

3HaqhrenhHaF, Har6onee

cepb-

e3Haa

qacrb

aeaHrapaHoi npoaVKr.I4x

80-x

roaoe KaK

6ur natesltto coaepxvr e ce6e

3Morlr4ro oMep3eHtrF

l4lrli.

no KpaiHei

vepe,

o6ecrcypaxeuHocl,t.3ro

ecrh

14-B

pa.

6orax

,,MeMSrca".

l\4eHA Hfi Bo MHorl4x Beu.lax

,,6a-

HarbHoro

UqKna"

x B

nep$opMaHc€

,,HHqTo"

14 BoBce

He cKpbrBaer cBoei

pacrepFHHocr[

nepeA orKphrBuiei-

cF eMy BHyrpeHHei nycToToi

v aTpeccl4BHocTbKt

qBe-

Tyu.lefr

pa3Hoo6pa3[eM

cpeabr, KaK 6br

yaocroBepFa,

'lTo

,,uloy-cTunb

3To crhnb nloaeH

pacTepFHHhrx

h3BeprBUJrxca,

eule o3a6oqeHHsrx

BaxHblMr4 TBop'{ec.

<uvr npo6revavu.

yxe

He craBaurux

nepeA co6oi

xq3HerBopqecK[x :aaav"

l1O]

. XapaKrepHo,

Kcrarh,

qro

ve6enu

,,1\ileMdrca"

,,AnxhMVu"

pacnpocrpa-

HeHH6ti arph6yr aMeprKaHcKl4x

Kr.1Ho

-Tpl.4rnepoB,

co3.

Aarcqlri

arMoc$epy Mr4crqqecKoro,

c orreHKoM

naro-

nor!414,

yxaca.

Hanovtuv 1,4

6yMe

,,abFBonl,aahl",

,,o6oporH[qecrBa",

,,BaMnrpl43Ma"

B 3Tl4

roabt

clo-

xeToB, KoTopbre. nepeKoqeBStBaa 3

Macc-Kynbra B

3rhrapHhre cnoh, KoHeqHo. Hecyr c co6oi

He'rro 6onb_

uJee.

qeM

uleKoTKy HepBoB.

Bce 6olee

1430ulpeHHbre non6rrKh

,,HoBbrx

+xno-

co+oB" cBan[Tb Bce Ha FBHbte

nr4

noraeHHbte

crpyK-

TVpbr Bnacr|4, nepeKpbrBapu]he

FKo6hr nyrh noan!,|H-

Ho cBo6oAHoi caMopeanr3aurl14, 1.4

BbrABl4TaeM6te

hMh

flpoeKTbt

,,BepHoro"

aoclr.4xeHlan

3loi cBo6oabl

(,,ulh.

3oa1anr13",

.,ph3oMarhKa",,,HeoHoMaAr3M"

npoqre

q.qe[

aeKoHcrpyKurotihsva)

aeno

cranKrBaEtcF

c o6HapyxeH[eM lax co6crBeHHoi Bonr

K anacr

npo-

FBrrFroueicF,

npaBAa,

He B rpy6oi npFMonraHeiHocrtl

aBTOpr,lTaph3Ma

,,cBepxy",

Ho B t43oulpeHHoi MaHhny-

nauuu

,,uzuytpu".

HaKoHeq, nohcKr4 noanfiHHoro,

{cKaxeHHorq cBo6oaHoro t4 Taop'{ecKoro

caMonpoFB-

fleHrF

9enoBeKa Ha

nvrl4 Teoperu9ecKofo

14 npaKThqec-

KOrO

,,aHtl4ryMaHr3Ma",

KaK Ka)KelcF,

3aM br KarcT KpyT.

florntro,

qro

3penqute

coBpeMeHHoi Kynbrypbr,

MaH(aKanbHocrbro

B36eo4BLleicF

MaLllxHbl L!TaMnv_

touei

oopManhHoe

MHoroo6pa3rle, Kotopoe

cocrol4T

He npocro B HenpecraHHoi

cMeHe Bne,{aTneH4t,

Ho h B

MTHOBeHHOi KaTanOT[3aU tr

!a MV3eeofiKaqUU O6pa3'

qog

Bcex Bneqarnenri

(oruernv,qTo

My3eiHbti

cr4HA-

poM

nepex4BaeTcE

ceroaHF He

MeHee cqflbHo,

'leM

cl,lHApoM 36eMeprocru),

nanoao6he

BonL!e6Horo

ropurKa h3-cTaprHHot cKa3K4,

KoTopbr14 HhKaK He

Mor

npeKparvTb Bap[Tb Kauy, cHaqana

napar43yer

Bon|o,

HO 3areM npo6yxAaer

hHcTl4HKT cavocoxpanenrn,

BbrpaxaercF

oH, KaK B

Toi

cKa3Ke. B Bonure6HoM

croBe

.,ocTaHoB!4cb!

A norouy 6onee vev

noHFTHo

yclbllarb

ycr

nph3brBaeMot

caMoBbtpa>KaTbcF TBop'{ecKoh flHqHocTr4,

a[3aiHepa

M. Maprarn:

,,Mrp

nepenonren.

3aabrxa-

elcF.

9enoBeK HacneArin

noac|oAy.

...5brrb iMo)<er, cro-

l,T

IIeT Ha

AeCFTb

BOBCe

npeKpaTuTb npoeKThpOBaTb

nocMorperb, vro

nporoori4er. Moxer

6srrs, saAo

noaHaryxllTbca

r3o Bcex crn,

vro6ut nepecrarb

ry_

xhTbca. BMecTo

Tofo.

qTo6br

xBaTaTbcA 3a

KapaHAau,

HyxHo no6onbure

aepxarb

pyKr4

B KapMaHax.

Haao

(cneahrb

pyranrr>"

[26,

c,59]

CToflb xe noHFTHo

yc']bttlarb

fi3

ycr

Kpl4T

Kai

.,Haao

o,.rl4u]arb

MopE,

peK!4,

ropoaa,

qerlbre

o6nacrtl

Bhrpa3rrTenbHhtx F3btKoB

a43atHa,

nl4TepaTypbl,

Mo'

ahr,

Kl,lHo r r.

flo cyrh

aena,

c[TyaurF

TaKoBa,

'iro

caMoe MyApoe 6brno 6br

npeKpar[Tb B 6fl4xaiuJxe

roAht npoeKTxpoBarh, nhcarb,

co3Aaaarb

HoBbte

+l4-

noco$cxre

KoHuenqhh,'{T06bt

Aarb

Bo3MoxHocrb'

garaxetttoi

np!-1poae orabtuarbcF".

KoHeqHo, TaKoe

nonHoe

vMonKaHfie

BpFA Jll4 Bo3MoxHO

BeAb Xlr3Hb

He npeKpaulaeTcF.

BMecTe c TeM

,.TaK

Ha3blBaeMble

np[nl,Bbr

oTnl,1Bbr

lacTopr,114

y']aT

Hac,

'{To

3a Kaxaot

peBon|oqhei

cneayer

pecraapauln

qro

3a KaxabtM

nepfioaoM B3pbrBa

3Heprxh cfleayer nep[oa o6ycrpo;-

cTBa, xapaKTeph3yrou-thicF

nonFTHblM

aB[xeHueM,

noroMy B TaKl4e nepuoabr oT|<ara B btxr.4aaTen

hH aa no-

3r1tMF

AnF

HeTepnen Bbrx. nbrIIKl4x 14

aearenbHbrx

Ha-

Typ

Hauny'{rlaF crparerqa". |/l

Bonpoc He B

roM.

oq[qarbcF

unt Her, a B

ToM,

qrobbr

3Tor

4crHTenb-

Hbri npoqecc

Bo3.naBvnh

Aocro;Hbre

Srryput,

rpo-

H14 cvAb6br, orMeqaer

Kpvrr,1K.

06br,]Ho

ror, Kro 60nb-

Lle

apyrhx

fpeu fl. oKa3btBaeTcF nepBbtM npeTeHAeH'

ToM Ha

pyKoBoacrBo

3Tori

aenrKarHo;

onepaq[ei,

RTO

nyqure

3Kc-rpeurHhKa 3Haef

rpex,

KoTopoM cne.

aver

noKaFThcF? Oara<o

eaecu ecrs

onacHocrb

h3nl4ttl-

HeTO

paahKanu3Ma

c npoTt4 BononoxHbr

M 3HaKoM

[35,

c. 35].

floerouy

6yaer neqanhHo, npoaonxaer KpfirrK,

eclt e 90c

foAbr Ha Mecro T|4nep3KcnpeccrtBHhlx

Be.

utei npxayr

6onee crporhe h npo+ecchoHanhHo

Bbraep-

xaHHbte, Ho xoloaHbre, aHoHhMHbre,6e3aYr!Hble

aKa-

[eMl4qHbte,

6vaer

netanuxo,

ecnla Bo3o6raaa|oT

nph3hl-

Bbr

,,He aenarb

Hr4qero HoBoTo B 6rrxaituqe

foabr, B

chfly

pxcKa

norn6Hyrb oKoHqaTenbHo",

cneacTBheM

vero 6yger KoMnneKc HenonHoqeHHocrr,t l, Bl4Hbr, oco-

6eHHo ry6xrenhHbti

aln

rex,

KTo ceroaHF

rtr.l uJb Bbtxo'

aqr

Ha nyrb

rBopqecrBa. 5y4er nevaruno, ecnu ao3o6-

naaapr HoBbte npaB na

,,HoBhrx

arcaaervtr,1xoe'J

lex

caMblx, Koropbre

6oponrcu co,,crapoi

aKaaevueh".

SyAer

ne,{anbHo,

ecn4 B KoHeqHoM

r4Tofe HauJe

cepA-

ue,

HeycraHHhri4

reHeparop xx3HeHHoi nVnt'cal\vt

3Hepr[[, 3aMean[T 6reHre fi HaqHeT neperoHFTb BoaF.

HhcTyro

po3oBaTyrc

KpoBb. ly'HhtMt4 cnoBaM14, 3aKnK,ga-

er Kol,lTl4K, xoTenocb 6bt araeTb cTaHoBneHxe

B38eureH-

Hoi,

pa3yMHoi

Kyflhrypbr caMooql4uleHlaa, 6es excqec-

coB,

AeKnapaqui.

3anperoB h

ApaMarh314poBaHHhrx

npu3hrBoB. r, tao6opor. He xorenocs

6bt

yBF3Hyrb

yHbrnoM,

nypt4raHcKoM

xaHxecrBe

{Tav

xe)

flp/BeaeHHbre

pa3MLruJneHhF

P. CeMnpr.Hu

yKa-

3brBatol

aBe

ocHoBHhre floByLlKI4,

B KoTopbre

MoxeT

yToaHTb

cronh xeraHHbri

cronb Heo6xoa[Mbti

npo.

uecc

ceMl,oTr,lqecKoro oql4uleHHF.

c oaHoi cTopoHbr,

3To

peAVKr.l

ero

'{14cro

crlnucrxqecKoi TpaHcdop-

Maq[h, K MoaHoMy noBerpr4ro,

qTo,

BnpoqeM,

Mbl

yxe

uornut

na6nrcaatu B

nxqe,,HoBoro

phropu3Ma"

KoHqa

80-x

roaoe,

3aKoHoMepHo

cBeauJeTocn K

qacrHoMy

aoBonbHo

noBepxHocrHoMy

$opvanunotly

reqexqto. C

Apyro;

AhcKpeAhTaquF

ero a HeKoi

3anpeT[TenbHoi

KaMnaHfiu. Hcro, vro

xenaHHaF

Kvnbrypa oquueHhF

HeBO3MOXHa 6e3 COOTBeTCTBytOulei

Cy6!eKTl4BHOi

npeApac

nonoxeH HocTr,1, 3Mor.|/oHanbHoi

co6creeHHo

Bhrpa3[TenbHo; ee nprBneKaTenbHocrH

anF

xyaoxHx-

Ka. To ecrh 6ee

,,aolu

crrrro",

a raKxe r 6eg coor.

BeTCTByloqero HpaBcTBeHHOTO UVneparnea, rcoroplrri

6hr

xrpah

ponh

o6beKTuBHoro

3anpera, npxqeM 3anper

3TOT

On!.ipanca

6br He Ha

EHeuJHee npl4HyxaeHfie,

a Ha

cy6beKTxBHoe

V6exaeH|4e,

AocrxxeH|4e

roro h

apy-

rofo

Bo3MoxHo

n|'lub

npx HanuqLtl4

TpeTbero,

crepxHe-

BOfO

saKrOpa

oHTOnOTUqeCKOTO

rMnepaTrlBa. nO

co-

aepxaHhrc,

3HaqeH14rc H Ma;tLUTa6y 3HagrreJtbHo n

peBoc-

xoasuefo

qacTHyrc

cuTyaql4rc KoHua 80-x

roaoB.

Ha npearrayueu 3Tane

ponb

raKoro rlMfleparrBa

urpana

Kareropqa 6e:rpanrlrocru, HenperKHoBeHHo-

cTu. flbrHe,

cyaF no BceMy, aKryaru3l4pyeTca

Karero-

pl4a

KoHeqHocTl,l, npeaefla, Mepbt. 3KonorhgecKnt xa-

paKTep

3Toi Karerop!1r4 caMoo'{eBr4aeH.

Mexgy rev,

noAqepKHeM, v npeabrayul14i urvtneparre

6urn

o6ycnoe-

fleH

3KonorhqecKoi

pedneKc[ei

o5na4afl,

xorb r He

aBHhrM, HO 6e3ycnOBHO

OHTOTOTh'{eCK14M

COAepXaHUeM,

no cyr[

Aena,

h B ToM 14 B

ApyroM

cny,{ae

SyHAa-

MeHT cocraBrFer nMnepaTl4B cBo6oAbt.

B nepeov cnyqae

npeAcraer KaK |,|MneparlB

ecTecTBeHHoi cBo604bt

qenoBeKa

h B 3ToM

cMbtcne ero

cBoeBofl14F,

ycraHaBflxBatoqxi,

oaHaKo,

npeaenbt cBo-

eBonulo npoTl,rBoecTecTBeHHoMy

Bon|oHTapx3My

pa-

r.tr4oHanbHo{tporpeccrcrcroi oprarrrat\t

u >r\t 3Hn- B

pFAe

chryaq

i oH

npereHAoBan Ha oHToflorq,{ecKxti

craryc, Ho B KoHeqHoM rrore

Hocrn

cyry6o norfiKo-

rsoceoJrorrgecKui xapaKTep.

coorBercrBeHHo, raeF

ecrecrBeHHoi, crvxvifi]o.uppaquoHanbHot, caMoopra-

Hx3ylou{eicF,

pa3Ho06pa3EU.leicF,

14HAl4BhAyanbHo-He-

noBTopr4Moi 14 HeMbtcntlMo 6ofaroi xt4Boi

xri3H'l 060-

3Haqana u

vTBepxaala

npeaenbr

paqfioHanbHoro

Hop-

Mr{poBaHuF,

opfaH|,l'3aut4t,

vnpaBleHhF,

npofpaMMu-

poBaH,lF,

nfl aH!'rpoBaHl,F. Moaenl,lpoB aHuF,

cxeM af A3a-

qr{

npogr4x

npoqeayp

paccyaoqHo-TexHoKpaTrqec-

Koi

ycraHoBKtl,

ee npereH3rii Ha oKoHqarenhHoe

3Ha-

Hhe x noKopeHl4e ecTecTBeHHofo,

BTopoM

cnyqae !4Mneparl4B cao6oaur npeacra-

er KaK t,tMnepart,tB

ayxoBHoi

cBo6oabr, 14 B 3ToM cMbrc-

I]e

He cBoeBoI|r,tF,

BoJt14, noanuHHoe ocyulecTBneHl,e

KOTOpO' npO[CXOAl,lT He B

aKTe

CaMOBbrpaxeHrlF, a B

aKTe caMoorpaHl'{eHun

caMoo6y3aa+ua. Cvna

aonu

npoFannerca

e cnoco6Hocr[

no3Harb

cBoH

oHTonofu-

qecKl,e

npeaellbt

h cMr4plrTb

gonrcHTap143M

nepea ecTecr-

BeHHbtM 3aKOHOM t4 CBOeBOnl,le

nepeA

BbrCuJriM

3aKO-

tor'/.

Taroe

caMoorpaHh'{eH[e

cMl4peHl4e o3Haqaet

hccyLlJeHl4e xu3Hh 14

pa3xlxeHle

KpoBl4, Ho

npeoaone-

Hre cBoeTo KyrbTypaHTponoJroTl.rqecKof

ayuJeBHoro

Hapqxccx3Ma, npeanoflafaeT nocroaHHyro naMaTb o

cBoeM

ABoiHoM

chrHoscrBe: nphpoAHoM r/ cBepxnpu-

poaHoM,

r4HbrMl4 cnoBaMrl

nalrnrc raranuryrc

po-

xaeAuul

u naMflrh cMeprHyp, eo [s6exaHue nyru

MaH-

r<ypra

,r nyrx 6nyAHoro chrHa.

rcoe, rar Kaxerca, oHToloruqecKhi noreHqh-

an rMneparrBa

npeAena.

CyaF

aocrynHoi

HaM rlre-

parvpe,

ero oco3HaHle

ocM6rcleHhe, a reM

6onee

bryporBop'rec Kt,te BbrBoabr r43 Hero eu.le enea 6pes-

xar, Br'recre c tev o6HaAexheaeT HaMerhBuraacF

roaHF

peQreKchF

HoBoro KaTeropuanbHoro

14 npo-

6neMHofo Toplr3oHTa, cBtlAerenbcrBo

'tefo

noflBfle-

Ht,te

floHnruf

,,Kynbrypa

npeAe.na"

[25j ,

roropoe r,rt're-

er Bce ocHoBaHuF npereHAoearb Ha

ponb

+yHAaMeH-

TarbHoro

oHTonort,lqecKoro

!tMnepaluBa

KaK Bo3Mox-

Hocrh Ka(€crseHHoro

noBopora

npoeKTHoi

Kyrbrype.

pv6exe

eexos

B. PogaHoe

orueqan,

qro

,,cMpaaHoe

eyaoBuqe"

aeKaaaHca,..eHeTu'{ecK,

cBF-

3yeTca co

BceM

reHuaIIbHbtM 14

BbtcoKxM,

qTo

co3Aa-

Ho 6btno

(He

cBa3aHHoro nqqHocrbKt),

(cao6oAHolo

'{enoBeqHocrbro)i

3anaAHoi Kynbrypbr.,.

Bo3poxAe-

arz,a

?avcona; Hanporr.rB,

rpaHb,

ana

Hero Henpec.

TynaeMaa, Knaae1ca TaM, rae

qeloBeK

noHrMan

ce6a

Bceraa cBF3aHHbrM, rar urAeiro,

TaK x

oco6eHHo

SaK-

rvqecKu"

19,

c. 441a42], floeuarvot'ly, orutc<a-

Hlle TBOpgeCKOTO fi '1H'{HOCTHO|O CMblcna

3TOt

rpaH4

cTaHeT

oaHoi

t13 BaxHeiulr4x cTpaTerhqecKux

3aaa9

KynbTypbr

rpFAyutero Tbrcai{eneTr.1F, no

Kpa;Hei Me-

ee avernevoi

vacrr.

,lH16p.ryp!

56pr P. BcrynHrenbHaF

neKquf,

Ka46ape

nrrep€?yp-

Hoi

ceM,ronorHn //

CoBpeMeHHaF crpyKTypanxcrxqecKaF

xae-

onorrF:

TeHe3xc norrronors\ecxerx

KoHqenqri,

M.:

HayKa,

1984.

2 6ao1

P, Hvnesar

crenexu nrcsua//Cer'rxorl,iKa.

M.: Pa_

avfa,

'1983.

3 TaaaMep

X.-T. hcrvHa r ueroa: Ocxoert ibrnoco+cKoi

repvexesrnxr / flep. c nev.

M.: nporpecc, 1988.

Kypbeposa F.F,

,,H8eas

AoMaLlHFF

rtr,rBdnu3aqua": Hg-

Koropsre Bonpocbr

npoeKrrpoBaH,rf, xuno-

cpeabr

l4tanbFH'

cKoM

aH3aiHe

80-x roaoa//EblroBbre

noipe6Hocv

l'l

xrnai

npeaMerHaR

@eaa.

M., 1987.

{Tp.

BHrlriT3.

cep

TexHu'rec-

xan

ecrerrxa; Burn.53) .

KypbepoBa f,f. npoexrHaF

xoxqenryanucrrara

80'x

ToaoB: HoBoe

MbruneHxe H

,,vHoe"

MbrLjlneHl,|e//Tsoptl€cKue

HanpaBneHHF

B coapeMeHHoM 3apy6exHoM

3aiHe

1990.

(Tp.

BHhHT3. C+.

TexHH,recKaF 3crerhK6;

Bbln.60) .

flarbrHsHa

A-

tlio

sn4e4|a?//Jlt4reparypHaa

rabera

1991 .

23 nsg.

7 Mvxainos

A.B.

apyroro

6epera//Bonpocsr

nurepary'

pbr.

1990.

lf 1 1.

8 HeKpacos C.

H.. ColrHan bHEr; nporpecc

ti npo6teMsr

C€_

Tr,rruv3Ma. CsepqnoBcK:

H3a-Bo

ypaflbcKoro

VH'Ta,

1989

Po3aHos 8.8-

Aexa,qexrsr//Po3aHoB

B.B. CoqrHeBua.

M.:

CoB.

PoccsF, 1 99O-

10 CoxonFHc'or;

lllov-3Be3aa

nonbrHb//tlnreparypHaF

ra3era. 1991. lF 8, 27

+eBp.

Tacanos 8.14. raHc

3eAenbMafiep

aelneMMa

,,xaoca

l,l

,,nopf,

aKa"

B noqif,{oAepHH3Me 50-70.x

roaoe//rlcxyccraoee'

aeH

e 3anaaa 06 HcKyc{irse

XX BeKa. M.:

HayKa) 1988.

12 XHnnlac AlHnnep

Ix.

TpHyMO

reopxx

npo

3aoacr'

Bo 3Ha,{eHH* /,i

Bonpo6' nHreparypbr.

1990. N0

11.

Baudliltzrd J. I-a societa

de consommation:

Ses myths,

ses structules- Pa.ii i9_0.

Belini

\(.

:€ese

d.ile meEviglie//Domus.

1990. N ?18

l5 Bosoni

G. -{ipunti sugli

anni'so//Interni.

h rivista

dell'arredamen:c.

1 99,1. \.104.

16 Bosoni

G. Dov: la

cririca del design?//Inerni

rivista

dell'aEechmento

1990.

\ 405.

17 Casadio

\1. -\

groposiro

di spazi

simbolici//Interni

rivhta deu anedzneiio-

1990.

405.

l8 Casigiani

V. R,.1ollainpro

del

design//Modo

1990

N122.

Desigre: s

s"'ek

a ltilano//lnterni

rivista

dell'arre-

damento.

1990. \

J05-

20 Donh C.

-tlinio

molriplicato//Modo

1983

N 58

21 Doieil

Pei

uoa

nuova modernith/lnteflista

AIdo

Cibic//Modo.

199n. \ 12L

Finzio G- Lna

discipliaa

per gli

anni'90//Modo

1990.

N 124.

23 Garartoni

G.T. Drscoteche

e moralite//Modo

1990

N 124.

24 Kircherer S l'ar-re

del creare

stile di impresa

vera

sfida to d€sign

man€ementi

Domus. 1990.

N 719.

25 tr{aflini

posibitiri

dei

limite//Modo.

1990.

120

26 Marianj

v- Frogelto neo-tranquillo//Modo.

1989.

N 118.

27 Morozzi C.

Dalla

paJte

del

consumatore//Modo

1990

N 120.

28 Morozzi

C. \(anierismo

acritico//Modo.

1984 N'71112

29 Morozzi C.

\-erso

tempi bui.//Modo.

1990.

N 124

trlorleo E. Il de.i!'l

del

prodotto:

Braun

Prcis 1989//

Domus. 1990,

J\* 122.

Pergola C. La scena

deua notte//Modo

1990.

N 124

Rampa P. Papiri

di vero//Modo. 1989.N117.

33 Santachiara

Gli

immateriali

del

design//Interni.

dvista dell'arredamenlo

f990.

N 405.

34 Le

scelte del desiltljlfodo

1990.N 121

35 Semprini

R- tl cuore

pud

cambiar

colore//Modo

1990.

N 121.

36 Tempo

di musei Abitate.

I990. 1.I288.

M.A. Tr,rvo$eeea

tDerouex

crarAnxaecrcoro

4ueaita

KoHqa

80-x roAoB:

nonbttKa !tHTepnperaqrl,r

f, i/L

ycAorrrp.

KepaM3t{ecKxo

o6r€Krbr

,,Myx{l4H!

r| xe||-

ulnHa". llcraHAlaf, .

1984

Crcan4unaecxuri

AV3aiaH

He np[HffTo ceroABa

cqurarb

r!4AepoM

pa38epHyBLUetca

nocTMoAepH|4cr-

cKoi

+eeput4

xAei,

KoHqenuxi,

o6pa3oB

HeKoero

HoBoro npoeKTHoro

60-

u xyAoxecrBeHHoro

Mxpo.

TBopqecrBa.

Ero terpourlri

ronoc

x xapaKTepHan

AnF

ceBepHbrx

KynbTyp BHyTpeHHaa cocpeaoTo'{eHHocTb,

KaMepHocTb, r,tHTpocfleKTl,BHocTb,

Bo3MoxHo,

no cBoet

cyrl,l nporfiBo3Ha'{Hbt r4cKpoMerHoi cBo6oAe fi 6pocKo-

cTrr

riTanbnHcKoro

A[3aiHa,

rHTenneKTyanbHoi 3Kc-

npeccuv

oTqacTi4

arpecc[BHoi

nporpaMMHocTl4

,,Ho-

Boro HeMeqKoro

Av3ai'Ha"

ApyrHM

BeAyul[M aKq!4o-

HhCTCKl/IM HANOABNEHTFM.

Tev re vexee

@roaHff cKaHArHaBcKuil

Au3aiaH

KaK

B ero coBpeMeHHoi cvrya\t'1r4

laK u B 14cTopr4'{ec-

KOM

aCneKTe

nOUBfleKaeT nphcTaubHoe aH,|MaHl4e He

TonEKo

ce6F

AoMa,

CeBepHo; Eapone,

Ho 14 3a

py-

6exoM. Ha 3To

ecrb caor npr1g!.lHbt.

14croprrF cKaHAl,tHaBcKoro

Ala3aiHa AaBana

HeMa-

no npxMepoB ero

oco6oi

ponx

o6qeM

xcropr4'{ec-

KoM noroKe npoeKTHoi

x npoMbrLrJneHHoi Kynbrypbr,

KOfAa

BeX!| ero

pa3BxThF

cTaHogl4rr4cb BexaM[

pa3B[-

T,Aa

Au3a

goo6ule.

Taros H aqqoHan bHopoMaHn4

vecrri

npopcra

SxHcKoro

au3aiHa

Ha BceMhpHoi

flapraxcroi

BbrcraaKe 1900 foAa, errpasreLlLui crpev-

neHhe npoeKTHoro |4

peMecneHHofo

14cKyccTsa K uaee

HaqnoHanbHoi KoHconlaaqlll4. Taroerr

ycrnrn

cxax-

AhHaBcKoro AV3aiHa,

ynpogeHhp

cBoei coul4anb-

Hot

AerepMlHxpoBaHHocrr4

nplBepxeHHocr[

AeMo-

K'rlaTUqeCKrM

qeHHOCTFM

H B nepBble

AeCFTl,tteTtl8

gexa,

no3xe, Koraa

qaex

Eayxay3a 6brnh Henoc-

peAcrseHHo

a3arbr

aoopyxeH{E uBeAcKoi corMa'l-

AeMoKparqei:

BeAb

nphAa K Bnacrh

Ha,{ane

30-x

ro-

aoB,

oHa

npoBo3rnacqna

csoei

3aAaqet crpoxrenbcrBo

,,OyHKqxoHanbHoro"

coqxanu3Ma. Henh3a He BcnoM-

ar,rr6

B3rer cKaHAhHaBcKoro

ar43aiHa

B 5C-60€

foAbr,

KorAa

6brJr HaiAeH

B cnny

uenoro

pFAa

lacropxKo-

KynbTypHbtx, coql,larhHo{toJ

,lTl4,iecKvtx

14 14Hbtx npl4-

,|t4x

Ha[6onee oprarrvnuri cxHTe3 B

ax3aiHe

ryMaH-

Horo, npfipoAocBa3aHHoTo, sKoHoM14qecKoro, npo$ec-

cHoHarrbHoTo

rraKoHl4qHoi,

dyHKut4oHanbHoi

!1 Hcro-

pl|'iecKfi

onpaBAaHHoi

+opMe.

Oco6oe

Mecro s eroM

KpaTKOM

nepeqHe Bex MoxeT 3aHFTb

ata3aiH an8

hH-

aarlaoe

70-80-x

roaog, !4 npexae Bcero uBeacKr4i,

craBr.lri cnoraHoM a unpoeofi

ah3aiHepcKoi

npaKrx'

Ke x hAeonorrigr. l\4HoxecrBo

cKaHAlrHaBcKllx

Au3aiHe-

poB,

cBoero

poaa

Knacc[K14,

ocTaEl4nl,l

cBo4 nugHble

,,Bexfi"

a vcropnt'l

ArBai4Ha,

ux [MeHa

gourjlta

a coB.

peMeHHbre

ar3arHepcKre

3Hq!4K'|onea|411.

CyqecrByer la

uenbri

pEA

noHFTh;, orHocEu.u4x-

cyry6o

Arrafiry

Craxauaag!4r,1. OHq Bo3Hr4Krl4 B

pa3Hbre

nepfioabr

ero cTaHoBneHufl 1.1

qcnolb3yrolcF

ce-

roaHn

gaule

Bcero 6e3 rovuenraoueb, KaK noHFTHbre

BceM:,,urBeAcKaF rpaq|,F",,,ryMaHHbti

OyHRUlaoHa-

nh3M",,,cKaHAyHaacxhfi MoAepHt4av",,.cKaHAl4HaB-

cKtri crqnb"

Ap.

B nonbtrKe noHarb cKaHAhHaBcKri

Au3ariH

npl4.

MeqaTeneH ToT

+aKT,

,lTo

Hax6onbuJlafr vHTepec B Mr,4pe

A[3aiH

CKaHAxHaBhl4 Bbr3btBaeT He TonbKo Ha nuKax

cBoero

.,nuphqecKoro"

{optuoreopvecKoto

aprl4cTl43-

Ma,

a 3TO TOXe nOHFT|4e CKaHAhHaBCKO|O npOhCXOX.-

aeHxF,

Ho l/| oco6enno B MoMeHT

nepeBeca 3T[qecKoro

Hagana, 6yAb To

BHfiMaH,|e

cMbtcrly ,icKoHHo Halluo-

HarbHoro |,nl4

npqpoaooxpaHHoro, K coq[anbHoi

Han-

pasneHHocrl4

npoeKTupoBaHtaa,

x rny6rne ero

ayxoB-

HOTO l,,r3MepeH144.

Kaxoaa xe curyaqra

cerogna?

llnopanrcrrvecrri

KapHaBan nocrMoAepH 3Ma,

cBoeo6pa3HaF,,gcrenrqecKaa"

Sa3a

pasBurl1a

Ax3afiHa,

oxBarun ceroAHE 14 CKaHAl4HaB|a|o.

XapaKrepHo,

,]To

nplr

oqeHb BbrcoKoM

ypoBHe

Ax3aiHa

v3aenuh crto+<-

Horo rexHrlqecKoro

lrcnorHeHt,tn

(po6ororexHurca,

cpea-

crBa rpaHcnopra,

recorexHhqecKoe 06opygoaalu e,

6ut-

Top.q

rexHrlKa

gp.)

rpa4raqroHHo

dyHKl1r4oHant,tc-

npoKons.

Cepsns,,Pycxa"

l,l3 KaM€HHoi Maccbr.

O6pMa-l.3-

rotoBnrerb,,AF|a6ra",

npHMep,,KraccritscKoro"

cKaH.

ArHrBckoro

As3aiHa

60.x roAos.

OraHriHAN'

^c or

T{qecKofo

xapaKTepa

nonyraeT Bce 6onbuJee

pacnpo-

cTpaHeHle apr-a!43aiH

c ero cBo6oaoi nugHocTHoro

BbtpaxeHr!F, aHapx[qecKuMt4 3KcnepriMeHTaMtl

14 KoH-

qenTyanr3MoM,

npoBoKaTxBHocTbro

toMoRoM, B To

'xe

speMa nocrMoaepH!'r3M npeacraBneH

B cKaHAlHa-

B|,lx B 6onee

MarKrlx

ypaBHoaeueHHhrx

+opMax,

'{eM

apyrxx

cTpaHax.

Oano rg ero

rlant,lqHhrx npoFBneHui

peayKr.lua

OyHKr.thi

x3Aenhi, a B KpaiH[x

BhrpaxeHuFx

ee nor-

HOe

OTCyICTBI4e

r 3aMeHa UCKnloql,lTenbHo

,,3CTeT{qeC-

Koi4" unh ra*oir-nu6o

|,Hoi, Hocaqei xapaKTep

ucro'

prlqecKofi

vna ntilepalyp!{.ou

peM[H

l,lcqeH

qxH,

noxcKa

apxeTnna,

BbrceKaHrF

KaKoro-n1160

HeoxlaaHHoro

cMbrcna, Ho, KaK npaB[no,

Bcefaa

3HaKoBo'rrpoBot.

KoHeqHo,

3To

xapaKTepHo

ana

coBpeMeHHoi

ct ryawvl

At43a

He Boo6u.le,

Ho B CKaHArHaBx4,

c ee

rny6oKot

dyHKqxoHanhcrcKoi'

ipaAy.t]l et,,

laKoi noBopor Becb'

Ma cl4MBOnUqeH.

llonutrry,,pacKonaoBarb"

Syxrqrolanrcrcxyto

xecrKocfb H3aenui, co3AaHHbrx

tlBeAcKxMt4

at43atHe'

paMx,

caenan,

HanphMep,

Oexr,

ny6nuqucr

x 3Kcno-

3r,iuxoHHbfi

AV3a

Hep, Ha BbtcraBKe

,l4cKyccrao

aa'

3aiHa" B aKBapuyMe

6epnuHcKoro

Zooe 1989

ro-

ay,

3KcnoHarbr

nocyAa,

TKaHb, npu6opbl,

KoMnbo'

lepbr

14 T.,a.,

6bux norpyxeHbr

B BoAy l4rl1

nraBaJl[ no

noBepxHocrH coeah BoaHblx

pacfeH[i|

t't xl4BorHblx

npeacraBneH[e

tax B

HeoxhAaHHoi

cpeae, B

napaAoK-

canugoi crryaqur

aonxtto

6ctno BblFBl4Tb

llx 3crerl'

qecKvto

caMoaocTaroqHocrb,

nonHocrbto ocBo6oa14B

dyHKurar,

noa'{epKHyrb

cKynbnrypHyto

3aKoHqeH-

HOCTb h

TaKTglIlbHyE

nphBJleKaTenbHocTb

[4 TeM CaMblM

no3Bojt''Tb

3phTerlo

ynoBrTb

rlx

,,3Molll4oHarhHble

cur_

Haflbr 14 o4MBonuqecrre

o6eprorrt"

[1,

'11]

. Bepo-

aTHa 3AeCh h HeKOTOpaA anno3l4F

HaMeK 8a

AaBHO

qecrB

yroul!,r

crepeqrln BbrcraBoqHoro

npeAcraBJle-

H|,|F cKaHArHaBcKoro

Ah3aiHa

nepeKnlqKe

c npupoA-

uoi cpeAoi,

a raKxe

6onee

oraareHHaF

upoHl4qecKaa

aHarorl,lF c

HAeFMh 3KOAl43aiHa.

Ty xe rernly

,,ae4yHKr.luoHanx3aquu",

Ho KaK

6bl

[pyroro

KoHqa,

pa3BxBaeT

xyaoxecTBeHHoe

peMec-

ro,6nx3Koe

K rcKyccrey

ronqenryalutovy.

Ogna

Ha[6onee

Bpu

Me'{areJt bH btx fir'lHl.li

3aecb

co3AaBue

o6paea

gusaixepcKoro

14nu

apx{TeKrypHoro

06beKTa

9epe3 ero

sparMeHT,

HeoxraaHHo

xcnonb3oBasHbli

Mareplan u l.

Pasyueerca, raxoi o6text

n[ueH

BcFKoi

dyHRq[oHanbHocrl4

rpaax Ltl4oHHoM

noHu

Ma'

Hux

cnoBa. Oco6exlo ocrpo

3To

npoFbnnerca

Macre'

poB

cnaH,iuv.

Taroeur

repaurvecKre

,,cryJtbF"

,,K.pecna"

6. OcKapAol-rl4p, o6!eKTbt

113 crpol,trerbHblx

6noKoB,

BbtnonHeHHbte

u3 rtaBbl

14 cKoMnoHoBaHHble

c npec@BaHHbrM

ropsou

Po6eprcaorrhp,

Koropble

HeaaBHo

6brnx

noKa3aHbl Ha hx

nepcoHanhHblx

BblcraB-

ott

€s

'6-

Kax

[2]

. B nocne4xeu

cnyqas FBHo

l.rcnonb3oBaH Mo-

Tt4B

TpaAhqxoHHoro

ucnSHAcKoro x|/|nlrqa.

Boo6ule

neprpa

autlt

oHanu3M x cBoero

poaa

3THr,{ecKni peHeccaHc

BecbMa xapaKTepHbt

Ana

ceroA-

HaujHero

flxqa

cKaHAltHaBcKoro

Allaaixa.

[lpu srou

HeyTpaqeHHaF

peMecfleHHaa

lpaal4uxF

oqealAHo aBnF-

erca

HocrirereM BxranbHocnr

cKaHAt4HaBcKof npoeKT-

Hoi

Kyrbrypbr, rapaHloM

npeoAoneHra ..xr,iMepHbtx"

(fl.

fyuunee)

o6pagoaarri,

cnoHrlHllo Bo3nrKato-

ullrx

Ht cTbrKax

nroxo

coBMecTrMbrx

KyIbTypHbtx

ABneHui..

B 3ToM

pFAy

croaT

pacqBer

toBenxpnoro

Macrep-

crBa

pa6or

no xyAoxecrBeHHoMy

creKny, no!4cKl,l

Ah3atHepaMu-MoAenbepaM[ xAei

l,r

o6pa3o8 B TpaAx.

qr4oHHoi

ceBepHoi

oAexAe x

pa3pa6orKa

Ha ee

ocHo-

npuHqxnuanbHo

HoBot.

iTxrb Koropoi

uMeHyercF

,,xeoHopAnsM".

Orue,{arctca

Fgpur

cqeHorpa+uqecKo-

ro ,cKyccrBa

r ero ficnaHcha

B TpaArLll4oHHo

A%3ai-

HepcKyro

x apxlreKrypHyto

coepbt. npxHqunbt

rear-

panlr3oBilr{Hofo

npeacraBJleHrin

pacnpocTpsHeHbt

ax-

38'1H XHTepbepoB,

ruyseiturx

3Kcno3hqxi,

aaxe

HoBbtx

craHqxi

Merpo

vacrxoctn,

crorronrvcroro)

[l]

Tar

paspurxaaerc8

noqBa

{

+opMupytorcF

Ho-

Bbte nnacrhqecKfie

narrru.

npr,r 3ToM

Al,r3atHepcKaF

TpsAlrr4xa

e Craxglrxaerl

oKmanacb

aocraro'.*{o

rur.r-

poxofi

ann

caMblx

pa3Hbrx

noAxoaoe.

Tar,,,ryn

atHuri

dyxrqroHarrgv",

KoHeqHo

xe, He

yMep,

n MaccoBaa

npoAyK4HF

m3Aaerca

A!|3aiHepaMh

rMeHHo B

paMKax

3roi

KoHqenqxu.

Peanuxocru

3Toro

+aKTa

noarBepxAaer, Hanph-

Mep,

AeFTeIbHOCTb

Lul,lpoKo

x3aecTHOi B Mxpe

A{3afi-

HepcKoi Me6enbHoi

SxpMhr ,,l4rxoearop".

rcro-

pl4F

BO MHOTOM

OTpaXaeT

ICTOpr4lO 11 XapaKTepHbte

oco6eHHocrx cKaHAriHaacKoro

3aiHa

ceroAHfl, nog-

ToMy

HecKoIbKo

croB

o Fei 6yAyr Bnon8e

yMecT.

HbtM!t.

OupMa 6brna

ocHoBaHa

1969

roay

AByMF

TorbKo'rro

oKoHq!1Bull,.tMl4

o6yvenue

4raafixepau14

Xyns4rora

r,r F,,Qpanreporvt,

BHa'{are KaK

Au3aiH-

6ropo r

fl,r ujs 3areM,

B KoHqe 70-x

roAoB,

oHa coBMe-

crhna

QyHKqHx Au3arHa

nporgBoAcrBa

Me6erh.

Xynrgr u

llpaHrep

orHocxlr,tcb K ToMy

noKoneH!,

uJBeAcKr,rx

Au3aiHepoB,

KoTopbte

y'{acTBoBarx

,,A[3ai{epcKoi4

peBontoqltx",

KaK ee Ha3btBaFr

Cxax4utaerr.r.

e roxqe

60-x

roaoB,

pa3BeptyBuJe;cn

QOHe

lrl},|poKl,lx

CryAeHgeCKltX

Apyrhx

neSbtx

Alrl'x.ext'ti1-

cfrepe

auaaila

cryAeHrbr rpe6oaanr,l

ycrpaHeHla yxe

AocraroqHo

xecrKo croxhauJeica

cl1creMbr

a[3aiHepcKoro

xcre6nxuJMeHTa,

cBn3aHHoi

ycnexaMh

cKaHAHHaBcKoro

ar3aiHa

s 50-60+ ro-

abr

ero nocreneHHoi

KoMMepq

arx3aqxd. l4x

KoH-

qenuha

B rAeonoluqecKoi

c6epe

cBoAqracb

AeMo-