Дизайн на западе (сборник)
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
Kynbrypbl,
aeicrBylor
npfiMepHo
raK xe,
KaK
!'1 chtlbl'
oT
KOTOpblx
3aB!'lctiT
6upxeBoi
axhoTax.
,,ayx
Heo6a'
poKKo"
-
3TO
.,noBblUleH|,ie
aKuui"
TaKIX
dOpM
TBOp-
qecrBa
(!,|
-
u.lupe
-
cotluarbHoro
noBeAeHfif,), anF
KOrOpbrx
xapaKrepHhl
yrpara
qenocrHocrx,
rno6anbHo-
cTx,
ynopFAoqeHHoi
Cl4CTeMarUqEocTt'1
u
npoaBneHtie
BMeCTO
3Tl4X
KageCTB
HeCTa6la
nbH
oc1x,
HeoaBo3HariHo-
crh. Li 3Me
Bqll BocT!1.
Bxyc snoxtt
aHanv3l,pyercn
He
ronbKo
Ha
ypoBHe
Mop60norr'th
KVtlbrypbl.
Kaaa6pese
crpeMtirca
pac-
xpurrs
,,rny6txttyp
SopMy"
F.sne|ui.
a
o6Hapyxxrb
MeHranbHble
cTpyKTypbl,
onpeaenaoqlle
u npouecchl
dopvoo6pasoeaxlrn
B
L'lcKyccrBe,
r oco6eHHocrl4
Boc-
npxarl4F
xyAoxecrBeHHblx
npor3BeaeHxX
To ecrb
pe,ru
raer o6
$ccneAoBaH|,tl
ctlcreMbl
qeHHocrei:
BKyc
-
3To
He
,.coBoKynHocrh
dopM",
a
,.TeHAeHq[F
K
14H'
BecrxpoBaHrlo
[eHHocrefi"
(C.
25)
. ClcreMa
qeH-
HOCrefi
noapa3vMeBaer
onpeaeneHHhle
3aKoHoMepHoc_
Tu B3auMHoto
coorHouJeHuf
oueHortHblx
cyxaeHHt:
3CTeT'|qeCKhx,
3Tl4qecKrx,
asderrrerulx.
ly' aaecu
Kana6pere
Brar4r
caMoe
cyulecrBeHHoe
pa3nrque Mex'
ay
Knacc!4Koi
h 6apoKKo.
!,nn
rlaccllvecrcoro
exyca
xapaKTepHa
opveHTaqqa
Ha
cra6unhHyro
ynoprAoqeH'
Hocrb
roMotorllqHblx
pFAoB
(npexpaclo.e
-
xopo-
uee
-
nplFTHOe;
ypoan!4Boe
-
nnoxoe
-
oTBparr-
renuroe)
. Eapoltuti
xe BKyc.
HanporxB,
noapblBaer
ynopaaoqeHHocTb
cl4creMbl, aecra6[nti3xpyeT
ee,
pa3-
pyL!aeT
qeTKocrh
cooTBeTcTBlri.
Ha 3foi ocHoBe
aBTop
xa6oacttgaer
KaK
6bl Kapry
Knrc'{eBblx
noHFThi
Heo6a'
poKKo, KoTopaF
xnnrccTpr4pyer
KaK
yHl'rBepcanbHocTb
6apo,{Horo
BKyca,
raK !1 ero
oco6eHHocrl4
B coBpeMeH'
Hbtx
ycnoBfiflx.
Oarn
r: nprlsuaroB
HaLUei
3nox,
-
co3AaHHe
3c-
Terl4Kr
noBTopeH!1F,
OCHOBaHHOi
Ha
6ecKoHe'{HoM
yM'
HoxeHuh
Baptraqxi
Ha oaHy
|,t
ry xe
reMy'
Ha
np|,|Me-
pe
oaHoro
x3
xaHpoB
MaccoBoi
Kynhrypbl
-
npqKnto-
qeHqecKoro
rereShnbMa
-
Kana6pere
AeMoHcrpl,rpyer
B03MO}KHOCTt4
14CKyCHOTO
HaHh3hlBaHHF
CloxerHo'KoM'
no3l,tltloHHblx
3neMeHToB
-
y3HaBaeMblx l,
HeoxhaaH'
Hbrx,
qepeaytoulrlxcn
s
6etueHov
pl'1TMe'
Aocrhrae-
MaF 3aecb
Bblco.laiLuaF
crefleHh
noBTopf,eMocrl4
r
pa3-
Hoo6pa3fiF
-
pe3ynbrar,,perynupyeMoi
HeperyJlsp-
Hocrt4".
Ta
xe reHAeHura
K Bapb!4poBaHl.lo
npoFBnaeT'
ca u
B
MareprarbHoi
Kynbrype
-
cKaxeM'
B
npou3-
BoacrBe
aBToMo6xne;,
rae Ha ocHoBe
xe6onuuloro
KOIl4qeCrBa
6a3oBhlx
Moaeaei,
np{
BBeAeHx|,l
orpoM-
horo
gricna
perynl4pyeMblx nepeMeHHblx,
nocpeacT'
BOM
He3HaqrTetlbHutx
onrutlugaql4i
co3aaeTcF
MHO)Xe'
crBo
B BblcoKoi
creneHlt
nepcoHarfi3oBaHHblx
143aeflui'
,,3K3epcxcbl
Ha
3aaaHHVto
TeMy,
crl{nhcrl4'{ecKtie
Baphaqu[
-
nepBbti
npuHul4n
3crer[Kl'1
Heo6apoKKo"
(C.
44) .
ly'ccteaoBarefl!.
l,lcroplqecKoro
6apoKKo
Ha-
3hrBa|or
ero
npllHqunoM
Blrpryo3Hocrh.
B nP6oM
auAe
IICKyCCTBa
nonlBapxaHTHoc:rb
t
pa3Bull/e
BO3MOXHOC-
rei
xoM6l,|HupoeaHHa
03Hai{arcr
pa3pyuJetilae
KoHqeHT-
pxqecKoi
cl4creMbr,
crpeMneHl,|e
noaopBarb
opraH'13y'
louee BnvFHue
eallHoro
qeHTpa, yTBepavTb
non{qeHT-
pr4qHocrb.
C
SHnocodcKoi
ro'lKla
3peHlF,
3creruKa
noBToDeHuF
o6}FcHaercF
rs6utrroru,,yxe
cKa3aHHo-
ro"
l,
,,yxe
B
AeHHoro",
gro
BnonHe
oqegllaHo.
KorAa
oe'rb
haer
o
apeinutnoi
Maccogoi
Kynbrype
KaK
nr-
can
F.
Sarunnp,
npechluleHHe
pa3pyuJael
|,Aeto
rapMo-
Hnu,
yct
nu}ael
TFrOTeHfie
KynbTyp6l
K
apo6Hocl!-r,
KOPnYcKYnFPHocrl/l
'
B3rnaa
Ha
cucreMy
Kynbrypbl
KaK
tta
HeKyrc
npocrpaHcrBeHHYto
opraHu3aqla|o,
o6naAa|ouyto
cBoei
reoMerp[ei
ti ronotoluei,
Kana6pe3e
3a!'iMcrByer
y
10. florr'aaxa.
B
cra6rnttutx
3aKpblrblx
c!lcreMax
qeHTp
AoMr,lHt,tpyer,
a ixecrxocru,,nepullerpanslutx
nopu"
o6vcnogntreaer
Hen
poHl4qae
Mocrb
KoHrypa
-
rpaBll-
ubr
c
BHeuJHL'lM
npocTpaHcTBoM.
,o,nn
crcrer"r
runa
6a-
poKKo
xapaKTepHo,
HanpoTl4B,
cMeu.[eH14e
u'eHlpa'
Bo3-
pacTaHxe
Cl/|tl
3KCnaHCgit'1,
ycuneH,le
AaB'leHUB
Ha KOH'.
TVp, TO eCTb
Cyu.|ecrBylollllle
c'lcreMhl
HopM
nocroFHHO
noaBepTarcTca
ficnhrraHhto
Ha npoqHocrh.
[lphBneKa]ot
BHl,|MaHqe IBe
pa3HoBt4aHocrti
KytlhrypHoi
aeFTerbHo-
crx:
,,pa6ora
Ha npeAene"
(,,pacrnrlreaxne"
xortypa
6eg
xapyuJeHlaa
rpaxr,rqutl
h
,,3Kcuecc"
(paspyueHt,te
Konrypa,
Bbtxoa
3a npeAenbl
cucreuut
ttoptr)
Pa6oroit
Ha npeaene
aBTop
c'{l4TaeI,
Hanp[Mep.
3Kcnep[MeHru-
poBaHxe
c nrxeinoi
nepcneKThBo;
B
tl3o6pa3qrerb'
HoM
r4cKvccrBe
no3aHero
PeHeccaHca,
vaxuepuaua.
6a'
poKKo,
3a
npeaenbHblM
Bapb!4poBaHveM
ro'rKta
3peHua,
paKypca,
yrna
3o6paxeH[F
npeayraablBaelcn
vxeca-
Mopa3pyueHue
nepcneKTuabl.
Ta xe
nollrKa
np,ocne-
xriEraerc8
B coBpeMeHHoi
Kynhrype.
nocronHHo
l4cnbl'
TbtBarcuei
Ha 3Jlacrhqftocrb
rpaH[qbl BMAoB
u xaHpoB
14cKyccTBa.
Tenepb
BHoBh
coLUneMcF
Ha
BeHeLl|aaHcrcyto
6uel-
xane 1990
roaa.
Bor
oano
lr3 noacnyLlaHHblx
Kpl4Tl'lKoM
MHeH'u:
,,Xopourexrryro
nyranxuy
ycrpa Baer
Becr:
cryflbn
HanoMLiHarcT
qTO'TO
143
penepTyapa xxBontlctt'
a
cKynb'
nrvput.
nao6opor,
noxox[
Ha Me6enb,
Koropylo
He
Meuaer
nepecraauru"
[3,
c.78]
.
Pequ hAer o
pa6ore
aBcrDx;cKoro
xvAoxHtaKa,
aBTopa
o6uexroe
ta cKynhn-
lyp, B
-r<orophre
MoxHo
,,l4rparb".
MaHhnyntlpya
14x
KoMnoHeHTaMr.
l'loao6noi,,nyraHrqhl"
Ha BbtcraBKe
6srno locrarovro,
x
Aaxe
tacKyLrteHHsti
aputens, ala
KOTOpOI.O
U
O6berr,
l',t
lrHcrannauua
-
xaHpbl
BnorHe
npllBbrqHbre,
cronKHytcF
e
BeHeqtl|4
c
cppnpu3aMl'l'
l\4Horo
noBoaoB
ana
[poHl4k
aano,
HanpuMep,
pacnpe-
aeneHl4e
np!4308.
Moxno
nv
Ha3Barb
x14BonucqeM
nx.
AHceflbMo,
naypeara
xl,tBonrcHoro
fpaH-np!a,
Da3Bec'tguero
Ha creHax
tlTanhaHcKoTo
naB{nhoHa
nnocKre
KaMeHHbte
nntltut?
Vueet
nu orHoLleHtae
K
cKvnhnrype
cephs
sororpasrr
o6beKroB
npoMhlttl'
neHHoit
apxtireKrypbl,
BhlnonHeHHaF
cynpyxecKot
napoi
5, x X. 6exep
(OPf)
H
y[ocroeHHaF
TpaH{lpl4
aa c<ynunrypy?
B
rax<[ov
crylae,
KoHe'{Ho,
peuleHtie
xropr
6utno
MoTl4Bl4pOAaH
Hbl M,
!4
3TO
rOnbKO noAgep'
KvBaeT,-'{TO
,,nyra{V]3"
ctana
nopr''roi
B KoHqe
KoH-
lloB,
TpyaHo
cKa3arh,
'{To
abl3blBaer
60nbuJee
yahBne_
HUe: xyAoxecfBeHHaF
peanbHocTb, cMeuaauaF
BCe
Kaprbr,
un[
VcroiqhBocrb
rpaauuuoHHoi
xaHpoBoi
Knacc|46l4Kauhl,
ticKvccTBa,
KOTOpaa,
HecMorpF
Hl'i Ha
qTo,
Ao
cl4x
nop
cqhTaercF
eAhHcrBeHHO
HaAe)KHOl4'
Cpea!|
Ka3ycoB
,,YpoHuqHof
6LteHHane"
-
HeoxhaaH'
Hoe
arF
ny6ruKta
peuextie
SpaHuy3oB
,,o6otirucs
6e3 rcKvccrBa",
npeAocraaqB
3Kcno3xqlloHHyrc
nno-
qaAb
TpeM apx[reKTopaM,
y'{acrHl,lKaM KOHKypca
Ha
nooeKT
HoBOTO
naBtlnboHa
tDpanqllr'r.
Bo
+paHLty3CKOi
xyaoxecrBeHHoi
cpeae
3ra
BbtcraBoqHaa
nporpaMMa
Bhr3BaIa
aonHy
nporecTa
t1 cTana
npeaMeToM
6ypHblx
cnopoe.
Karre
6ut e
xrx
Hlr
nprBoafintacb
apryMeHrbl
c o6enx
cropos,
HecoMHeHHo
oaHo:
caM
(PaKT
BKnPqe'
Hha apxuTeKTypbl
a
xyaoxecrBeHHylo
BblcTaBKy
cBl'-
aeTenbcTByeT
o,,uJaTKOCTl4
CaMOCO3HaHnf
coBpeMeH-
xoro
rac<yccrea"
[12]
.
TeDaa
g
[3o6pa3tirenbHocrl4
KaK
TaKoBot,
rao6pasrrenrnoe
!4cKyccrBo,
KaK
6bl
B KaqecrBe
KoM-
neHcaur14,
aenaeT
cTaBKy
Ha 3penllulHocTb'
nplcBauBa'
er
ce6e
BpeMeHHoe
[3MepeHtie,
pe!.ul'lTenhHo l'136aBna-
10
r
I eTcF
oT crar['{HocTt4, He roBopa
yxe
o
aaBHhx
ero
npeTeH3rlax
Ha TecBbrh coro3
co cfloBecHbtMu
oopMaM|,l
BbrpaxeHxa.
CBoeo6pa3HbrM rearpoM
(npae4a,
6ea ar-
repoe)
npe4crar 3aBopoxeHHbrM 3phrennM naBxnboH
ClllA
Ha roi
xe 6rernane:
B
3areMHeHHoM
t4HTeobeoe
TO IaM, TO 3AeCb MOJtHt4FMrl
BCnhtXtlBarh ApKhe CBeTF-
u.lrecF HaAnxch
-
l4HorAa
6atalunute ceHTeHquu !i3
,,neKcrlKoHa
npon|4cHbtx t cft/l1", uHofaa
-
npoH3l4-
TenbHo-nfipxtecKgie
crpo<r,t. Pexrccep
3Toro BenhKo-
nenHo.o
$eiepBepKa
-
Ax.
Xonbqep, no BbtpaxeHrrc
aMeplKaHcKoro KpurHKa
n. llJen4ana,
,,florpeauon
I
nrporexHuK
a
oAHoM nriqe"
lS,
c,25l , BeporrHo.
AanbHeiLu4M
uLarol,t voxer
6ulrb ocBoeHne 3ByKoBoro
pFAa
u
ayaroBr4 3yanbHbrx
Moaenei KxHeMarorpada,
BO
BCfl
KOM
Cflyqae, 3TO npeAyCMaTprBaer,,CMeuJaHHaa
crparerxF, 14cKnrc'{atoulaa
rounaexcct", <oropoi
nphAepxtlBaercn
Tpynna MonoAhtx
{panuyscx[x
xy.
AoxHlrKoa,
Ha3btBapull4x
ce6E,,pexhccepaM!4 !4cKyc-
craa"
(TaM
xe, c. 48) .
TnroreHue
K
paculupenltrc
co6creenxutx
rpanr4
HerpyaHo npoqnnrccrpl4poBarb
u Ha npriMepe
apxuTeK-
Typbt,
rae cero4Ha
aBHo
Bo3pacTaeT 3neMeHT l43o6pa-
3qrenbHocTrr,
9To
no3BonFeT roBop!4Tb
06,,apxHTeK-
rypecrylunrype".
Moxxo
ecnorvrtl,4ru 3AaHhe
pecro-
paHa
B
+opMe
pur6ur
Q, Fepra t-lrta nnacruqecKue
06!-
eKrbrtrMBonbr
(.,nnava")
a coopyx6rrnx
O.
CTapKa.
O4noepevexno
aKTt,tBx314pyercn
cqeHorpaOt,tqecKoe
Haqano
B apxl,TeKrype,
l\4accy
pa3Hoo6pa3H6tx
oulyu]e-
Hhi
cnoco6Ho npo6ynqru,
Hanp[Mep,
TaKoe Heopar4-
HapHoe
deureHfie dacaAa,
KaK B
ranepee
ieeus
(floc,
Att,qxeaec) :
B nnocKocrb
creHbt
BoH3eH oqpehwhi
Hox, roroauri
paccequ
3AaHke nononaM. Aaropul
ero-
To
npoeKTa
-
cKynbnropbr K, Onuaen6vpr
ra K. Ban
Eprcrren
['10]
Kaxye ronrrco
accouqaqr,l4 3aecb He
BO3HXKaloT
-
OT
KynXHapHO.KOHAUTepCKI4X
AO
CaMhtx
MefloapaMaT4qecK
X, KOTOpbte,
BnpoqeM,
KoppeKTrl-
pyroTcS
cMyIHhrM
BocnoMt4HaHueM
o KapToHHbtx Me-
qax
B Tearpe rcaroro-ur6y4u
Kapa6aca
Eapa6aca. no-
Ao6Hbte
apxuTeKTypHbre
3Kcnep14MeHIbt,
aKTyan143hpy-
loulae
Kp14repfih
h306perarenbH
oc14.
ocrpoyMra,
OaH-
raa'l4
{evecro
BKyca, Mepbr, rapuouuul
,3acTaBnFoT
BHoab
pa3MhrunFTu
y
o6
ortocurenbHocr ToaHuuhl
Mex<Iy
BbrcoK!1M l4cKyccTBoM
'1 Kl4TqeM.
.
BepHeMca
K KHltre Kana6pe3e,
paccMarptaBato-
ulero
rHbre nprMepbr Heo6apo'rHoro,,TaToreHha
K
npe-
aerly".
K uHrepecHbtM 3aKIKrqeHuFM
nphBoauT
aBTopa
aHanu3
nonbrToK MaKcuManbHoto
noBbtueHl4a l,n!1
no-
H{XeHXA
nopora
BOCnpI4ATTF
BpeMeHll 14
ABl4XeHhf
B
MoMeHTanbHoi
Qororpadula
(ocranoenertoe
Larxoee,
.H e)
,
npx
ycKopeHHoi
ra,
tao6opor,
3aMeAfleHHofi Te,
ne.
,r Kr4HocteMKe. t1x
cnencTBreM
oKa3btBaercF l43Me-
HeHl4e
caMoro xapaKTepa
aocnpkFrl4F
BpeMeHr u
-
lu.rrpe
-
xapaKTepa
M14poB033peHhF
coBpeMeHHoro
qenoBeKa,
fleno
He rolbKo
B ToM,
'tTo
ycKopeH4e
reM-
na nepeAaqu |aH$opMaqla!4
Tpe6yer
Bce 6onbuei 66tcr-
porbr
peaKq|,r
14
QopMl4pyeT
coorBercTBytoulyK) 3pl4-
TenbcKyKr ycraHoBKy.
Eqe 6onee
cyuecrBeHHbtfi npla3-
HaK npeAnonaraeMoh
Myra\uv,
-
TolanbHoe
ocoBpeMe-
Hl/lBaHl4e
BCeX npOAyKTOB KynbTypht
E
genoBeqecKoM
co3{aP.uv,
npoxcxoAFulee rraBHhtM
o6pa3oM 6raroAa-
pa
Te'|eauaeHt4ro; [3aecTHo.
'tTo
anF
uKoJtbH14Koa HeT
o4yrrMoi
qcropx.recKofi
Aqcrauuvlu
uex4v
Aprcro-
TereM
14 lvla;KnoM
AxeKcoHoM.
Bropoe
aaxnoe rs-
MeHeHue
KacaeTcE,ryBcTBa
BepxQrlqxpyeMocTu
peanb-
HOCTl,l.
yBepeHHOCTb
A !1CTl4He
Aaer
He nU'tHLrX. HenO-
cpeAcrBeHHbri
onbtT no3HaHxF Mripa, HanpxMep
npl4-
cyTcTarle Ha cnopTxBHoM MaTge,
a
B03MoxHocTb
Boc.
np14HsTb TeneH306paxexre
co6urui
(saveanerxure
cleMKu, noBTopbt no3Bonapr
ynoB
Tb
.,He,{To
6onee
peanbHoe,
qeM
caMa
peanunocru")
-
,.HeBepue
cBFroTo
<Doi,rur
oroH,rarenrHo
npeoAoneHo. lvlhr
Bep'|M
B
qyAe-
ca,
He npuTpar[BaBcb
K H,|M; HaM
aoc1aToqBo
yBlaeTb
penoprax
o Hr4x. npeanoqTuTeflbHo
-
B 3aMeaIteHHoM
revne"
(C.60)
.
He06apo,{HaF
oco6eHHocr6
pa3nrlqHbtx
Br,lAoa no-
BeaeHrlF B Kynbrype,
npeTeHAyroulr4x
Ha
,,norpaH|/lir-
HOCTb",
-
!1X Cneqhol4qeCK,|
nOBepXHOCTHbri
XapaKTep,
opxeHTaqhF Ha BHeuJH4g cnol,l xyaoxecTBeHHoro npo-
u3BeAeHAF., ero,,Koxy".
$opvanunyro
opraBk3aqhp.
llo
cpaaneruto c aaaHrapaoM Tpr4AuarhnerHei
AaBHo-
cTrl B CefoaHfltllHeM [cKyccTBe
-
14
3To cBE3aHO,
nO'Br4-
a!1MOMy,
C Kprl3r4COM
,.Cr,rnUHbrX"
UAeOrOrfii
-
3aMeT-
Ho npeHe6pexeHne K coAepxarerbHo-TeMarr4qecKhM ac-
neKTaM, TAopqecKre nohcKx
cMeulaETca or 3T[qecKo.
ro,
3MotllroHanbHoro aapa B cTopoHy
aeKopaTriBr.l3Ma.
SCTeTU3aqUU CpOpMsl.
To,
,rro
MoxHo 6brno
6br KBanrdruupoaarh
KaK
gKcuecc
(HapyureHae
nopvur)
.
FBnFercF, cKopee, !,r3-
n14ulecTBoM
+opMbr,
.reM
KaKUM
-To,.peaon|oqIoHHbrM"
aKroM. XhBonrcb K.
XeiphHra, noKpbrBarcutero no-
BepxHocTb KapTrlHbt crycTKaM4 KpacKl4 u naKa, BHg|JJ-
He
HanoMlHaer
'3KU-lH.nei,HrvHf
",
Ho
g
Hei
HeT E HaMe'
Ka
Ha
rparu3M TBopqecKofo
xecTa. l\4exAy
ypoarltautv
14 npeKpacHbrM cTaBhTcF 3HaK
paBeHcTBa,
u
3aecb HeT
HU nOACnyAHO[O
ApaMaru3Ma,
HU XenaHr4F nepeOCMbrq.
rHr6 3Tl4 Kareaopl44.
SKcqeccbt
SopMbr
HaTrnAHee Bce-
ro npoFBnFrcTcF
B
qpe3MepHocTl,r
MacL!Ta60a npoh3Be-
AeHn;.,q,ocraroqHo
Bnevarnarcqhti np!4Mep
-,,yna-
r<oBK4"
Kpqcro; KaK
BbrFcH nocb.
,,3aBepHyTb"
Mox-
Ho 6yKBarbHo
Bce: HoBbri naocr e flapuxe,
qeluri
ocr'
poB
unI aBcrpanuicKyto n
ycrbrH
ro.
,.1\4
aHuA rpaHAuo3a'l
cKa3hrBaeTcF
u B npoBeaeH!,1x
BbtcTaBoK
{4 aaHToB, Te-
neMapa+oHoB,
MaccoBblx
poK'KoHqepToB.
cnopTl4BHbrx
spenrul.
3xaveratelbHo Bo3poxAeHrie nbruJHbrx Top-
xecTB
no cryqap KpynHbtx
co6htTt4i E nu9'l.oh )t<t 3Ht
npeAcTaBuTenei
BbtcL!ei
apucToKpaTIl,,
3Ee3A cqeHbt 14
r.
4.
fpar4rosr.iute
npa3AHecrBa, npeBocxoAaull4e no
pa3Maxy
nplABopHbre
MeponprFn F KoponF CorHqe,
Bhl3Ban4 K x<113Hl,1 HOBbre
npOQeCC14r,4: apXrTeKTop-
nl,poTexHr4K, apxuTeKTop npa3aHecTBa,
ah3aiHep
no
KyLlaHbF M l,1 T. n.
Cucreva
aeo6aporKo
ornuqaercn
6onuuoi 116-
KOCTbTO, 3nacTt,lgHocrblo
KOHfVpa, CnOCObHOCTblo Hei'
Tpanu3oBaTb
t1 xHrefphpoBarh
3Kcueccbr, np[aaBaF t4M
B14Al4Mocrb 14HHoBaqhoHHoi,,pa6orur ra npeAene".
Bcnxoro
poaa
eosaeicrBxF Ha KoHTvp cr,{creMbr, hcnbr-
TbtBaa,,hHdnauurc",
BbtHyxaeHht nocToaHHo MeHaTb
,,npuqen".
TaKrM
o6pa3oM, 6vAyqr
Artaunqnoi
cvrc-
retu,toi, reo6aporcro reM
He M.eHee He npeAnonafaeT
pe-
BonpquoHHoi
noMKr4 HopM. Heo6apo,rHbr;
BKyc
-
He-
npepbtBHo Kone6n|ou{l4icF.
ueHHocTHbte
KphTepun
6ro<npytorcn,,JtwKannlapf",
cABrtratorcn, Ho He
pa3pyua|orcF.
CneAylou.lri
npr3HaK Heo6apoKKo, no MHeH rc
Kafla6pe3e,
-
TpaHcdopMaquF
B3arMoAeicrBha
MexAy
qacTbro
14
ueIIbtM,
orpaxatou.laFcF B
nphHl]unax
QyHKul4-
oHl4poBaHla
aeraru
h
oparMeHTa
B crlcTeMe, B ToM
,,co-
6upannu"
n
wrvpolaluu
Sparverroe
npounoro,
Ko-
TopbrM 3aHUMaeTCfl
COBpeMeHHOe
14CKyCCTBO, HeT Hl/lKa-
Koi Hocranbrl4k,
nonaraer aarop. Tev
6onee te
nAer
peq4
o
peKoHcrpyKqrii-1
pa3pyuJeHHoro
uenoro
no
+parMeHry,
coBceM HanporrrB. l4cKyccrso npoliinoTo
B
AaHHOM
Cnyqae
paccMaTpuBaeTcE
KaK
,,cKnaa"
Heo6-
11
xoll4Mbrx
MaTephanoB.
Ho
qTo6bl
sx ucnorlb3oBaTb,
HyxHo
,,aHHYnupoBaTb
3$+€KT
yXe
co3aaHHOrO"'
,,Tonsro
pas6rean
Ha
SparMeHTbl
ro,vro
yxe
6utro
co3aaHo...
14
TOnbKO
aBTOHOMI'13l4pyg
opafMeHT,
MOXHO
ocvuecrBr,lrb
3ry
onepaqrlo"
(C.
90)
oparuenr
rax
6ur
,,aeap
xeonorl3[poBaH
",
pa3upBaHa ero
cBB3b
c
npexH14M
KOHTeKCTOM, UeHUTCF
!lMeHHO
l43nOMaH'
Hocrb,
cny,raiHocrb
ero
SopMbl.
flo6onutrHo.
qro
roq'
Ho
raKoi
xe
rorlaKoi
pyKoBoAcrByerc8
Tene3pllre'lb,
oAepxrMbti,.ct'tlApoMoM
rnonxr",
Bo3HhKatou'lxM
B
ycnoBuFX MBOrOKaHarbHofo
reneBuaeHrF
npl,
Haruql,lr
ahcTaHqxoHHoro
ynpaBneHl,|F:
nepecKaKrBag
c oaHoi
nporpaMMbt
Ha
Apyryp,
oH
KaK
6bt co3aaer
u3 cryqai-
Hbrx
6parMeHToB
KaKoe-To
HoBoe
Mo3arqHoe
qeroe'
Scterr<a
SparMeHra
noapa3yMeBaer
HapyuleHxe
,,qeHTpatt!t3oBaHHoro"
nopaara
BblcKa3blBaHtaa,
nepe'
Kntogaer
BHt,tMaHtae
c
qeHTpa
Ha nepxdepurc.
,,6eccess
-
Hocrb
npeano'lrlarenbHa
nopBAKy,
Koropbti
AeSopMtl-
pver",
rogop[n
A
Xha.
Eorce
pa3BepHyrylo
@opMy'
nripoBKy
aan
P.
Sapr:
,,flracarr $parMeHTaM[:
Toraa
doarMeHrbl
-
3To
KaMHtt,
opoueHHble
KpyroM;
F
pa3-
6oachrBa|o
ce6a;
eecu
Moi
MlapoK
pacKonor Ba
KycKl'l,
qro
xe B
qenrpe?"
(C.
92)
.
Cocpeloroqennocru
na
SparMeHre
orpaxaer
o6ult-li
.,saxat"
qenoctHoctt4
(Apyrne
ero
nposBneHuF
-
orKa3
or
,,cl4JlbHblx"
uaeo-
norrlqecKrlx
cLicreM,
or,,SpoHTaabHblx
MoAenei
"
Mo-
aepHng[4a)
.
tlacrb
3acfloHaer ueJloe.
aBToHoM[3aullF
6DarMeHTa
3acraBnaer
,,noreparb
tl3 Bt4ay..
KpynHhle
o6qegxaqrutte
nanopar'lur"
(C.
95)
.
Kro !43nlo6neHHbli
nepcoHax
coBpeMeHHoi
6en-
nerolcrtlKrl,
rtano,
reneorpana?
3ro
voacrp,
oreela-
er
Kana6pese.
Xyaoxecreelnute
npoE3seaeH{F
gcex
B!lAOB
Klrlll€lT
cTpaHHhlMtl
CyulecrBaM4,
OT
CaMblx
rHyc-
Hbtx ,lo
BnotHe
cuMnaTtlqHhlx
Bpoae
rHonnaHeTaHuHa
E.
T.
tas oaHorrMeHloro
Srnuva
Cnln6epra
3aecu
ut
nphurenbqbr.
!4 n€axfo6orbl,
x npx3paKx,
14 BcFKoro
poaa
HeqxcraF
cHna...
cTo6T
nOAyMaTb
O
HOAO'
TnaBe
e
uupoeoi
Teparonor/[
(Hayrca
o
qyaoauqax)
[lo-
cKonbKy
3ro
riaYra
coqranuraa,
B oqepeaHot
rnaBe
He o6oiTr4
Bonpoca
o
secta6untxoctl
a
aMop+Hocrt'|,
cBoicrBeHHbrx
npvpoae
coBpeMeBHoro
o6ulecrBa'
B caMoM
aene,
or ceonx
co6patueB
apyrux
Bpe-
uen
(cpeaxeeexoBbF,
6apoKKo,
poMaHTt,t3Ma,
3Kc-
npecchoHt4sva)
HbtHeuHUe
MoHcrpbl
ornu'{arcTca
pea-
KocrnbtM
AapoM
npegpaqeHui,
xaveneoHusL'lofvl
B ec'
ce
reparonora
P.
Axoeanlonr
,,Cltrrarcuc
vyxa<a"
oTMei{aeTcF,
qTo
noq1u
Bce coBpeMeHHhle
MoHcrpbl
rMepr
,,K
aHoHr4qec
Kyto
SopMy"
-
3nacrlqHyrc,
pac'
Ta)KxMvlo,
143MeH'{l4BYto.
3ro,,$rarypa-nonran,
cnoco6-
HaF HaAVBaTbCA,
pacuxpFTbcB,
yMeHbulalbcF'
l43Me-
HFTbca
no cBoeMv
xeraHr|o
14 B
KpaiHux,
Kpl43l4cHblx
curyau[Fx
-
nonarsca"
(C.
104)
. Ee
rnaBHbri
npH3'
sarc
-
6ecdopuexnocrb
hnl4,
apyrllMr
cnoBaMu,
3To
SopMa,
HaxoAsu.laFcF
B
nohcKax
co6crBeHHoi
SopMhl'
lvleratutopsosut
3arparnBarcT
u
Heo6apo'{Hylo
c|ac-
TeMy
qeHHocrHblx
cyxAeHaft.
lvlbl
AafleK!|
or
Knacc
'
qecKoro
psaa
coorBercrBvi:
6ec+opMeHHoe-ypoa-
nl,Boe
-
nn oxoe
-HenplarHoe.
Ho cronb
xe HeaKTya-
reHla
aHThKnacc4'.{ecKrli
paa,
xapaKTepu3yloullat
,,nonoxrrenenoro"
t,toxcrpa
Cyru
e
rou,
qro
,,qeH'
iocrHoe
cyxAeBfe
nepeHocllrca
c
Soptutrt
KaK
TaKo-
Bo;
Ha ee
axHaMll3M,
xa
ee cnoco6nocru
npoBoLlxpo'
Ba1b HeonpeaeneHHocTb,
HeoaHo3HaqHocTb,
n3MeHq14_
Bocrb
no3lrr.l!ai" {C.106)
3++eKr
HeonpeaefleHHoc-
Tt,
gecta6ungnoctr
14 ecrb
B
aaHHoM
cryqae
4cKoMoe,
qeHHocrh.
HoBaa
no3T[Ka
crpol4Tca
Ha
pa3Mblrocrl'l'
83a!rMOnepexoaHocrh
Kareropt'li.
l\4oHcrpbt
-
nxLuh
'{acrHbli
cny'{ai
Heo6apo'{Horo
deHoMe8a
necra6tnunocru.
B nnacruvecrrx
ucrycct-
Bax
gneMeHT
Hecra6unbHocrl4
Bo3HrKaer
Ha
pa3Hblx
ypoBHFX crpyKrypbt
npox3seaeH{F.
Hepenxo
xylox-
Hlrr14
pagpa6arutearcT
cneqqanbHylo
rexHorlol14lo'
ra-
paHrxpyloutYto HeaonroBe'{HocTb
npo[3BeaeH[F
:,,14C-
re:arculue"
$ororpa$ura
K.
Oa6pese, nocrenegno
o6ec'
uBe'{uBaroulaaca
xrBontrcb
O. naHceKh.
AonF
npoBo-
KauroHHocrl4,
VcraHoBKa
Ha 3narax
apurenn,
ceoficr'
BeHHbre
nep$opMarcy
(rax
xor4a'ro
-KolqepraM
dy-
ryprcroe)
,
BBoaFT
3neMeHT
Hedra6lanuHocru
B
npoqecc
Bocnpt,tnTris
(ecnovsttv
Kylca
-
capxaav
nnu
uc'
rpexnocrr?)
.
.;Cv
N4eontr'lec
rtai ", no
unettrto
Kana6-
pe3e,
npxMep
qeneHanpaaneHHo
cnnaHvpoBaHHoro
He'
cra6[rbHoro
noeea'eHlrn
3pllrenn
-
peaKqxa
ny6nrKh
Ha nudT,
coeAxHatoqli
nepecti
rl eropoi
eraxN
e
My-
3ee
coBpeMeHHoto
HcKyccrBa
r.
lllTyrrapra
lnpoeKT
Crepnurra)
,
BHeuHui
Bxa
ttr$Ta
HacronbKo
,'xyao'
xecrBeH".
'{To
nocerxren,
npEHl4MaloT
ero
3a
3Kcno-
Har
r BMecro
roro,
9To6bl
xcnonb3oBarb
ntl$T
no
npFMoMy
Ha3Ha'{eBxp,
TornFTcA
BOKpyr
unr
aaxe,
cnoBHo
B HaBaxaeHHtl,
6eryr
eaoroxry
no
cMexHoi
neCTHl,lUe,
BOCX4UIaACb
erO
ABI{XeHl/leM
'
B 1981
roay
C.
Aanra
cogaan
ceputo
p,lcyHKoB
,,KaracrpoStt",
r.r s
o6p
axato ult'l
x
npocrpaHcrao
cJlox'
Hoi
reoMerpl,|H,
3racrLlgHocKraA'{aroe'
14 nocBFTl'1Jl
ee
+paHuy3cKoMy
MareMarrKy
P.
Tovy, cnequaarcry
no
reophli
Karacrpo$.
Kana6pese
rpaKryer
3To
KaK
+aKT
npnMoro
HaBeaeHuF
Mocroa
Mexry
l4cKyccrBoM
14 TaK
Ha3hrBaeMoi
,,Hor'toi
HayKoi",
npeAnara|oqet
HoBhte
noaxoabr
K
,,Heperynn
pH
hl M
"
aanext,tai'l
Onpe'
aefleHHaa
43OMOp+HOCTb
HaygHhlx
!4HTepecoB
14 3cTe-
TtaqecKrx
BKVcoB
o6ycnoeneua
eataHcrBoM
rny6taHBhlx
MeHTaflbHbtx
crpyKrYp
B <pyre o6r.4t'lx
l'lHrepecoB
'lc-
KyccTBa
tl HaYK4
-
nepeocMblcneHue
noHFT,li
nopFA-
Ka
h xaoca.
Hoeeiu.tre reop[h
crpeMFTcF
o6napyxnru
,,no'
paaor
e 6ecnopaare",
sutasrru
3aKoHoMepH@T,
xa'
oca
xar
dopvut
cyuecrBoBaHhE,,cBepxcnoxH6lx"
deHoMeHoB.
OAtto
t/s Har6onee
FpKlrx orKpblrlat
B
3Toi o6nacrh,
npuHarnexauree
+paHuy3cKoMy
Mare'
uarury
5. MaxAenu6pory,
KacaelcF
MeroAoB
ti3Mepe'
Hra
dpaKTarhHbrx
06beKToB,
lritercullax
gpe3Bblqal4Ho
HepervnFpHyro,
h3pe3aHHyto
+opMy,
KaK,
HanphMep'
xnonbr
cHera,
uopcxoe
no6epexbe,
nyHHble
Kparepbl
xn[
abrpqaran
crpyKTypa
cbtpa-
K veroarxe
apo6sutx
!a3MepeH[i,
BblBoaaultlx
3a npeaenbl
3BKnxAOBa
npo-
cTpaHcTBa,
06pau.ldloTcF
l, l4ccneaoBarenr
3aBUXpeHV'i
(ryp6ynerrxocrra)
B
rt
aponorvu,
Mereopoflorr!r,
60-
l
aHVKe,
aHal OM1AV
t 1
A
3CrerU,{eCKlai
nOTeHq4an
BeflpaBlnbHblX
(D[ryp
aeMoHcrp14poBana
opraHtl3oBaHHaa
HeMeLlKtiM14
MaTe'
MarlKaMr
BhtcraBKa
,,Kpacora
dparranoe",
rAe
grb'
noBupoBan'1cb
OpaKTanhHble
ulo6paxental,
nony'ren-
Hbre
Ha
KoMnbrcTepax.
l\4xoxecraou
npvMepoB
He6a-
po,rHoi
xaoru,{Hocr14
B
llcKyccrBe
Kana6pe3e noA-
rBepxAaer
Mbtcrb
o roM,
qro,,Typ6yneHTHocrb
u
Hepe'
rynFpHocrb
ynpaBflFlor co3aaBueM
o6reKTOB
C aCTeT4'
vecroi
Sytrrcquei
npaKTtlqecKr
Ha Bcex
VpoBHFX
cnox-
HOCTT4
B
KynbType
-
oT
npoayKqtll4
Mea}4a
ao
caMhlx
t43btcKaHHbtx
o6pa3uoB
B
xyaoxecrBeHHbtx
ranepeax
14
KoHqeprHbrx
3arax"
(c.135)
.
Oco6oe
uecro
coBpeMeHHaF
Kynbrypa
orBoatrT
crpyKrypaM
na6l1p!4HTHoro
rtlna.
na6l4pxHT'
cKpblBa-
rculri
ea Kaxyul!4Mca
xaocoM
pa3yMHbli
nopFAoK'
FBrFercA,,TrnrqHo
6apo'lHbl;
S[Fypoi".
llocxolury
Maptlpy1
B
qenoM
BHe norF
3peHxa,
3aecb BcTynaeT
12
ts
c!,tny
,,6nr3opyKui"
uercl,
peureHrF
-
nooqepeaHoe
pa3aa3braaHhe
roKaflbHblx
yeaoe
npo6levtt. l,lrrepec
K
na6hpuHTaM
oxt4Braerca
B
gnoxl4,
KoropbtM
np[cy.
uirl
,.vyacrBo
norepFHHocrfi",
rb6oBb
K
ocrpbrM ou.ly.
uleHhFM
14
BKyc K ,r3o6perafenux
ocr r, Peutetre
aa6r,
prHra
cBa3aHo
c aM6rBareHTHbtM,
,,
xole6nnulrvcn',
c@ToaHreM,
c tepeaoBaHxeM,,yaoBoflbcTBua
noTe.
pattca"
u,,yAoBorbcrBra
Hairucb"
(C.
l40) .
CoBpeMeHHbt;
na6vpu9T
-
,,caMhti
6apovxuri"
H3
BceX
BO3MoxHbtx. B
HeM npeo6naAaeT
He
yAoBonb-
cTare
peuieHuF,
a
BKyc
K 3araaKe,3a6nyxaeHxrc,
He_
acHocrla.
Kana6pe3e
qrrl4pyer
A.
Sopxeca:
,.pa3peLue-
the
TaiHbt H[KorAa
He Bo3Bhtct4T
Hac Ha,0
caMo; Tai-
Hol;. TaiHa
14Meer
npFMoe
orHollleHl,|e
K 6oxecrBeH-
HoMy,
a ee
pa3raAKa
-
aaulb
TproK
doxyclllra,'
(C,
148)
.
,.@o<ycnuru"
3aun,
nepcei
r
Te3efr
Mano
claMnaT4gHht
neo6apovnovy
co3HaHulo?
npeAnogl4rarc-
ueMy
MoMeHr
,,hHreJlneKryanbHoro
prcrca"_
Ans
xe-
06apoKKo
xapaKTepHht
nonbtrK14
cKoHcrpyhpoBarb
yc-
/loxHeHHbr
i
na6\pnHl,
MaKcqManbH
o
3aTpyAHrlrh
ero
pelueHue,
Hanp[Mep,
B
paccKa3e
P, lljernq
,,|/lMnepa-
Top
nocfleAHhx
BpeMeH"
HeyF3BlrM@Tb
hMneparopa
o6bacHEercF
oco6oi rorcrpyxuxei
ero
ABopqa.m-
6EphHTa,
nocroaHHo
nepeKpatlBaeMoTo
crpohrenFMr.
34ecu
nenpunaexuuo
KracctlqecKoe
npaetno Apra4-
Hbr;
floT[Ka
14
naMaTh 6eccrluxst.
sFiaqeH
e l4[4ebr
nlulb
cKopocTb
aBqxeH
hF.
3crer[3auuF
cKoHcrpy!4poBaHHot
acucreMaruq.
HOCTI4
-
B
OCrOee
,,eara60HAaxa":
6poaaxHltecTBa
vnu
KoqeBHuqecraa
KaK
MoAen4
xylurypnoi
4enrelu_
Hocrta.
B
KHlre
X.,fl. Srne
.,6po4axxuvecxoe
reopve.
cTao
nocrynfipyloTcF
HeoaH03Ha'{Hoclb
n HeaocKa3aH_
Hocrb
nrc6oro
pelleHun
Tofi
cucTeMbt
ysnoe
u
na6upna-
roB,
KoropaF
cocraBrFer
,,oK
oHi{are nbH ht|;
fopl,l3oHT,,
Haurefo
66trl,tf,
,
HeAocTynHbtfi
Ana
HenocpeAcTBeHHoro
o6ospenrn,
To ecrb
KaK 6sr
ecrHoc!4[auti
HaM
3a cK06-
Kx.
,.TprcK
doKycHl,lKa"
orBepraercF,
l,
ocra|orca
,,6ny>KAaHue
u
Byt3oe",
TeM 6oflee
nphFTHbte,
qro
pe-
L!eHhe
,,TAe.ro"
cyulecrByer
(C.
149)
.
,,fia6rapranrxyro,,
MoAerb
coBpeMeHHoro
3HaHlaa crpoar
dpaHqv3cK(e
Srrocodbf
X.
,{ene:
u @. laarapu,
Ha3btBaF
3Ty
MOAerb,,KopHeBXU.le" (noaqeprchaarcTca
orKpbtTocTb
c4cTeMhr,
TeTepofeHHocTb
ee
3neMeHroa,
MHoxecT.
BeHHOCTb
npI
OTCyTCTBul,l
nopoxaatoulefo
earlHcTaa
!4 r.
a.)
.
flapa4oxca
nun sr v
o6pa3oM
BKyc K 3a6nyxae.
Hl4rc
npoaBlaeTcF
TaM,
fae, Ka3anocb
6tr, rocnoacrey_
lor
ynopaao'{eHHocTb
t4
clrcTeMaTu'{H@T6,
_
B
pa6oTe
c xounurcrepov.,{e,lo
a ToM,
'{To
oHa ocyulecTBnFeTcF
,,BcJtenyto l,
BceTAa
ecrb
pl4cK
,.or!16hrbcn
KHonKoi,,
Lr TeM
CaMbtM
cBeclu
pe3yflbTaT
Ha HeT,
EhtTr,
MoxeT,
hMeHHO plrcK,
yaoBonhcTBhe
oT Toro,
qTo,,nnaH
ueno-
TO"
ycKonh3aeT
or KoHTpOflA,
14
cocTaBJlFer
rI|aaHht,
ceKper
o6aFH
F
,,r
nynoit
uawuntf,,
npeAnonaTaer
aa_
Top
(C.
1501 . Korunurorep
poxAaer
oco6bt; rrrn
,,rfino.
TaKTq'{eeKoro"
MbtuJneHr.tF
Mal|btMri
6noKaM4,
noru-
qecKue
caa3[ Mexay
KoTopbrMk
BoccTaHaB|uBaoTca
nhlub
anocrepuopt4.
3ro
,,cao6o4toe
naaetue,,,
e rco-
TopoM
He
AaHo
3apaHee
HHKaKlx
raparnui
(C,182)
.
TexHl4,recKrlri
npof
pecc,
BHeapeH14e
cBepxroqHo,
annapaTypbt
co3aanh
xnnrc3h|o ynpaanFeMocTl4,
KoH-
TponlpyeMocrt4
uupa.
Bn4nuo,
neo6xo4rvocruo
r.rs_
6aa[T5cF
or
,,vnmg3vv
ro'lnocru.,
o6.bacHFercE
pea6h-
.ntaTaqha
noHFTr4F
nph6nh3qrerbHocr14
B HavKe.
B Ho,
Beiuefi
MareMarlaKe
roqHocrb
rpaKTyercF
KaK
,,Hy-
neBoi ypoBeHu
npu6nutureavuoctu,. (C.
l6b)
, Ile.
peA
nhlloM,,peayKqxoHr4crcKori,
ronrpoaIpyrou1eri,
o6tacgarculei
AearenbHocrt4.,
pasyr.ra
B.
FHKefleBh,{
+opMynlrpyer
cBoro,,+unoco+qto
HeyrtoBr4Mocl4",
ocHoBaHHyto
Ha
3TIqecKl4x
npl4Ht]unax
,,Heqro,, n
,,novrr",
Pe,.tu
vAert
no ero
cnoBaM,
o roM
He,{To,,,Ko-
Topoe
EBnaercF...
HecroKo;Hoi
coBecrbE
pau
oHanrc_
Tx,lec
Koi
Ao6pocoBecrHocrl4
ta nocfl
eAHhM
coMHeHUeM
crnbH6tx yMoa",
o ToM
HeqTo,,,KOTOpOe
ponqeT
aHyr_
pl4
Hac,
npoTeclyF
npoTlrB ycnexa
peayK4l4oHt43Ma,,
{c.
166)
.
O6pas
teerrpasnuocrl,4,
ycKon63aHhB
cMbrcra
HepeAKo
nepeAaerca
B
KrHeMarorpa6e
Meradopoi
, J
y
MaHa",
3aaonaK
t,tBarcqero
xa4p.
yrpara,
Ay
xa
ac-
Hocrl4"
B
xyAoxecrBeHHoil
KphrhKe,
HaA
Koropoi
qa-
cTo
t4poHl43l4pyroT,
a KoHTeKCTe
CKa3aHHOfO
AOn)<Ha
Bocnpr4HtlMaTbca
KaK
@O3HaHHbli
npfiHu!,ln.
KaK
of.
Meqaer
Kana6pe3e,
nphophrer
B
yrBepxaeHh!1
TBop-
'f
ecKoi
KoHl{enq[h
Heo6apo,{Hoti
KpuluKvl
npvHaane-
xtar A.
5oHtaro
Onrge:
ot
nocraBrn
KpurxKa
B oAl,rH
pFA
C XyAOXHITKOM,
AeKnaprpoBan
npaBo
KphruKa
Ha
3KCqeHTpl,l'{HOe
noBeAeHre,
BKntoqa|ouee
3IeMeHT6l
caMo3KCnOHUpOBaH|4Ft
rl
npoBoKa4hrl,
co3aan
HoBbli
Thn Kpurr4qecKoro
TeKcTa
Ha
ccHoae
nH@Ka3aTenb_.,
rurx,
,,6-ny>44arcu1ux"
d|4ryp
pe,{r.
Co3HaTenbHoe
KoH_
cTpy14poBaHt4e
HeOnpeAeJteHH
@r14.
HeToqHocT!4
_
oTJ]tl_
qETelbHaF
tepTa
TaopqecTBa
.,noeutx
loeutx,,,
aurtr_
pyrou.14x
HaxaHoe
,icKyccrao
(oaHaro
6es
BcFKo;
Ha_
BHocrr),
npeAcraB[Teneti
aMepkKaHcKofi
,,cKBepHoi
>NUgjnucu",
npr6nrl3hlenbHo
Boc
npor13
BoaF
u.lrx
nph-
eMbr
non{pTa,
3KCn
peccu
oH l43M
a r r.
a.
Ta
xe HanpaB-
neHHocTb
npocnexhBaeTcF
B
HapoqhTo
te6pextoi
{xarc 6cr
nocneujHoi,
pr,rcroeanuoi
}
pa6ore
.,rpa+dh.
TUCTOB".
C reMoir
,,He.tTo" aecbMa 6flr3Ko
coceAcrBveT
B
Kynbrype
6apoKKo
reMa
,,Hxqro,.
(Kana6pe3e
cchrra,
eTcF Ha
3K
K Ie3haCT
(tiecK
re MoTt4Btrt
cyeT6t
cyeT,
TUle_
T61
6brrt4a
e
6apolnoi
pe$nexcnra)
. 3noxa
Heo6aooK_
KO
AaeT
CaMbte
43orqpeHHhle
BapuatJw
3ro[
reMbt
_
Bnnorb
Ao
npFMot
aHrlrqnaq
h
xyAoxH14KoM
co6cr,
BeHHOfO
TBOpeHrF,
KaK
3TO
AeIarcT,
Hanpr4Mep,
HeMeu_
K
e xrBonhcubt
A. Kh$ep
u A,
paiuep
.
3a,{ep
K rBaro_
ulhe,
cocKa6ntaBarou]ue
r3o6paxeHr,4e,
npoxhratoutxe
cBoh
KapThHht,
Qunoco+cKoe
o6ocHoBaH{e
3ToTo
ac_
neKTa
coBpeMeHHoi
Kynhrypbt
Kana6peae
HaxoArr
y
X. SoAphiapa,
notarapulero,
'{To
cl4MBoroM
rlhBrnh,
3aquh
Moxer
6htrb
ronbKo
o6pa:
nycrrrur
(,,AMep11.
Ka"),
v
y
X.-O.
nxorapa,
TeoperhKa.nocrMoAepHu3Ma
q
opraHh3aropa
BbtcraBKrl
.,lzl|
u arep
laasuute,',
noxa_
3aBUei,
'tTO
3nOXa
KoMnhtoTepoB
npuae'la
K
aeMaTepr4_
anq3aul4h
lrcKyccrBal, poxAeHr|o gcrer|4rh
Hr.tto.
llo4eo4n
rrorr
cBoero
o63opHoTo
tlccneAoBa_
nrn,
Kana6peae
no4qepK4Baer,
9To HoBaa
HayKa
ta Heo-
6apoqHan
Kynhrypa
,lcnoBeAyrcT
ABa
ocHoBHbtx
o6ul x
nprlHqhna,
flepesrri:
orraa
or
yH4S[rthpoBaHHhtx,
yn_
pouteHHblx
MoAenei
h
B3||FA
Ha urp
xa<
ra
$parvex_
TapHyro
MHoxecTBeHHOCTb,
rAe pa3IhqHbte
Moaenh
npor,lBocronT
.qpyr
apyry,
copeBHyacb
vexav
co6oi.
Bropoi:
npe4craeneHue
o
roM,
'{ro
B Mhpe
npeo6la4a-
loT
He cra6[rbHbte
MoAenr,
a nao6opor,
MoAenB
crrox_
Hbte.
KoMnneKcHhre.
MHoroMepHbte,
4rnavtvtture. flo
aHanofvt4
c 3aaattaMr
ecTecTBeHH6tX
HayKi
aBTOp
A|4ATlT
3aaaqy
3apoxaalorueTocF,,He3BKn4AOBa"
ryMaHhTap_
HOrO
3HaHhF
B
OnpeaeneHh,
noruKl.l
,,HoBoli
KoHdoo_
Mallxh'
KynhTypHoao
npocTpaHcTBa.
oro
npe4craer
ceroAHF
KaK
npocTpaHcTBo
,,Myfa\nv
h vcKaN<eHVF,"
noaBepxeHHoe
Bo3aeicTBlrro
KaKhx-To
chn.,,KoTOObie
efo
crl,6arcT,
cKnaabrEarcT.
hcKpl/BnFrcT, pacTFfhBarcT,
cnoBHo
oHo srracrx,rHoe"
(C.
181 ) .
IJ
3ry
nnyro noruKy
xnnrccrplrpyer
ueo6apoqloe
oneohpoBaHre
Llxraro;
a
potrlaue Y.3<o,,1'1I,|n
posut".
llpese6peraa,,KnaccHqecKttM"
npHHqunoM
oaH03Haq'
HOTO BblAeneHl4F
Ul4Tarbl
B
TeKCle,3KO
CO3Aaer
,,nO3T14-
Ky
u3BpaueHHoi
ayreHTut{Hocru".
Tercr
povara
-
cnnoulHaF
14 Bt4pryo3HeiLuaF
Ml4cr14+LlKaql4F
: ntacarenb
To,,3aMeraer
cteAbt",
KaMy+nupyer
SaKT
q{ThpoBa-
H!aa, To
Sanbcfisuuhpyer
qxrary,
a 3areM
..pa3o6na'la-
er" ce6a,
ro eapyr,,npu3Haerca"
a noxhocrl,.
pa3o6na_
qeH[fl,
14 B
KOHqe KOHIIOB
CaM
.,3anyTblBae1ca"
B
3TOi
Hepa3peui ttM ocr14:
,,8
t4Tore
n
nojtoH
coMHeHl,F".
CoM
HeHl4to
noaBepTaerca
cMblc-n
rpaarqtaoHHhlx
npor14'
gonocTaBneHui:
xcTrHa-noxh,
HopMa--hcKnloqeHxe,
peryJra pH
oe
-
HeperynF
pHoe;
HaKoHeu,
cTupaeTcn
pa3-
nllgre
MexAV
peanbHbtM
l.'l Bo3MoxHblM.
,,Cnyvarctcn
MATl,I'{ECKUC
MOM€HTbI...
KOTAA
BAM
AAPYrcTCF
BUAEH4F
ntoAei,
Koropbtx Bht
3Hanu
B npounoM...
TaK
xe
Aapy-
roTcf
14 sl4[eH[a
eule
He HanrcaHHblx
KHrr",
roBopt4T
3ro
(C.
186, 187)
.
l-J,rrary
voxno 6utno
paccMarptlBarb npexae
KaK
cnoco6
co3AaBaTb
,,yTOnl,|to
npoulrloro".
To ecrb,,nepe'
Hocr4Tb
npouJnoe
BHYTpb
co6crBeHHoi
Kynbryp6l",
Boc-
cTaHaBn!4BaTb
efo
v nepeocMblcnFTb
B CaeTe
HoBoro
onrrra
(C.
188)
. CeroaHa
nporcxoal,lr
nonHaF
Aecra6u'
r'l3aq'lB
BpeMeHr
a ucfopt
t/t'
Haue BpeMf
He l4ueT
aoKyMeHTOB,
CBhAerenbcrB;
npounoe
npeacTaer
nxL!b
B
BxAe
,,cr4MynBKpoB",
KaK
'lt
craF
$rxuna.
B enoxy
ToranbHoi
B!43vanh3auuu al4craHurlF
Mexay
npoL!nblM
14 HacroaulrM,
rlo6aa
xpoHoror!4F
cBoAFTca
K HynP:
..BCe
COBepL!eHHo
chHXpoHHo".
coBpeMeHHhle
xyaox'
H,|K14
,,AenaloT
|43
npouJlloTo
al4cTonl/|lo,
TO eCTh
XCflOJlb-
3yFor ero
Aep3K!1M,
HeBepoarHhlM
o6pa3oM.
aHHynu-
pyn,
a
He nepeoqeHlBaE
l4cTopl,llo"
onl4
,,l4sepaulalor
BeKTOpbf
no3HaHuA
\CIO?AA",
yHl4tlroxarcT BpeMeH'
Hhte, nprtr14HHo-cneAcTBeHHhle
cBa3x,
co3AaBan,,Mera-
xcroouqecK[fi
clHreg",
Heo6apoqHoe
cMeu]eHqe
Bpe-
MeH nphH[Maer
xapaKTep
,,apeisa".
o6-uerrut.
nona'
aatouthe
B c$epy
neo6apo<ro.
npxo6perarcT
cBoicrBo
,,6brrb
BceTAa
3aecE",
a
,,3aecb"
o3Ha''laer
,,Heah$+e'
peHqhpoBaHBo
Bcto t4cTopl4lo
B
qetoM",
np[']eM
noapa_
3yMeBaercF
He
ron6Ko aKTyaflbHocrb
coanaaeHra
Bcex
BpeMeH,
HO 14,,COCyUIeCTBOAaHXe
BO3MOXHOTO
C
peanb-
HblM".
TaKoe npeAcraBreHue,
no
MHeHrto
aBTopa,
-
3aKOHOMepHbli
pe3ynhrar
cBoicrBeHHot
cpeacrBaM
Maccoeoi
[H+opMaquh
3aBblLleHHoh
oqeHKu
HacToF'
ulero
KaK Bepull,lHbt
l4cropl4x.
,,rlo3ToMy
Mo)KHO
6blnO
6br cKa3arb,
'{To
hcropl4f oKoH'{eHa...
l4n,1']ro
oHa
Apei'
dver B
norcKax co6crBeHHoro
HoBoro
3HaqeHrlfl"
(c.
190. 191).
Knrcqeaste
noHflTl4F
3noxu(Hecra6uflhHocrb,
143-
MeH'rr4BOCTb, nOnrUeHTpl43M
X T.
A.)
,
C
nOMOUlblO
KOTO'
pbtx
Kana6pe3e
onllchtBaer
c[MnroMarlaKv
Heobapoq_
HOrO CO3HaHI4A,
B OCHOBHOM
yXe
6Utnr
paHee
BbMeHe'
Hbt
apvrrMx
rlccreaoBaTenffM!1
COBpeMeHHOi
KynbTy-
pbr.
Kana6pe3e
cBoal4r
BoeA[Ho
lrrol-rl MHoroqrctleH-
Hbtx l43btcKaHl4i, o6o3peBaF
l4x
pe3ynblarbl
B HoBoi
nepcneKTrlBe.
orKpblBatoueicF
c
efo co6cTBeHHofo
Ha6flpaarenbHoro
nynxra.,,Snoxa
Heo6apoKKo"
-
csoero
poaa
KpaTKaff 3Hul4KnoneauF,
nyTeBoauTenh
no
na6upl,HTy
coBpeMeHHofo
ryMaHuTapHoro
3HaH14F
'
(Kcrar[,
oaHo
r,13
aocrol4Hcre
rcHtarta
-
Han[qr1e
ueHHoi
6!a6nhorpa6u,recKoi
uH+opMauhtr
no BceM ocHoBHblM
TeMaM |4 HanpaBreHunv
llccneaoaarun)
.
Ha HauJ B3rnFA, cpeah
[cro'{Hl,'rKoB
6apo'{Hoi
Teopl4x npeacTaBnEeT
[HTepec
nonbtTKa B3TnaHyTh
Ha
coBpeMeHHoe
lrcKyccrBo
c n0314tllri
xcTopl4qecKo14
peT-
pocneKqxh,
cAenaHHaF HecKonbKo
panuute
A.
Sogtro
OnrBoi,
BbrAB!tHyBL.ulrM,.MaHhephcruqecKyro
Bepchlo
TpaKToBKx
surxerunei
xyaoxecrBeHHoi
cutyauun
15 ;
6]
. Ynouvnan
I4MF
SoHuro
Onrgut
xar oaHoro
143
Bbl'
paaurenei xeo6apolnoi
MeHTafl
hHocrl,l B
xYAoxecrBeH'
noi
xplrrrre,
Kana6peae
o6xoAhr
sH[vaHueM
ero
ru-
noTe3y o
ToM,
qro
coBpeMeHHoe
xyaoxecTBeHHoe
CO-
3HaHUe COAepXl4T
3neMeHTbl,,l43MeHHh'{eCKOi
UAeOnO-
rHu" MaHbeDfi3Ma.
EBponeicKoe
ucKyccrBo
XVI
BeKa,
n14uer
SoHrro
On14Ba.
nepexrBaer
ApaMy
pa3oqapoBa'
HUA
B
peHeccaHcHblx
l4aeFx
ropxecTBytoulero
pa3yMa
u TapMoHr4x
u
raiHo
.,l43MeHAer"
!aM.
,,cy6-beKf
tll4-
Luvnca
ropAoi
yBepeHHocrl4 a co6creeHxoi
qerocrHo-
crr,
no6yxAaBuei
ero
yrBepxaarb, 6yAro
KaxAbli
Ky3Heq cBoero
c'{acTbF,
oH
yTparun naHopaMHbli
06-
30p
Mnpa, Koropbli
eMy
rapaHTIpoBana
noroqeHTp14qe-
cKaa
rpaauqtag"
[6,
c. 8]
.
Oponransttuti,
orKpblrblt
83TflAA
HA Ml/|P,
KOTOPOMY
COOTBETCTBYET
NPFMAF
nepcneKTrBa,
cMeHBercF
cKonh3auluM,
yKnoHql4BblM,
HevBepeHHbrM,
BMAFUIkM
noBooay
aBoicrBeHHocrb,
HeoIHo3Ha'{Hocrb,
secra6nluttoctl
l1o aHanorwi, orxoa
coBpeMeHHoro
t,'lcKyccrBa
or
MOAepHUCTCKOTO OnThMlr3Ma,
Bep6l
a npoeKTHytO
qeH-
Hocrh
ucKVccrBa
!4 s l4croph'lecKtli
nporpecc hHrep-
npeTllpyeTcF
-
BHoBb
B
TepMl'1HaX
B[3yanhHo-npocr'
oaHcrBeHHot
opqeBTaUhk
-
KaK
,,yrpara
qeBrpa
Xyaoxt[rx
oco3Haer
ce6F
BnacrenhHoM
,ruulb
B orpa-
Hfi'{eHHOM
nOOCTOaHCTBe
F3blKa.
oTKa3blBaFCb
OT
,,crnbHbrx
npoeKToB"
v
rapon
peo6pasoeat ufl, oH
netleer
Bcero
nhilb,,MarKui
npoeKr
Sopvanuxoi
pa3pa6or-
Kv"
l.4MMaHeHTHoro,
caMoaocraro'lHoro
npol43BeaeHl4F
,,HeoMaHbep'lcrcKaF
qyBcraxretlbHocrb"
BKnloqaer
cKnoHHocrb
K 6ecKoHeqHoMY
KoqeBH['{ecrBy
no
rep-
pr.rropuaM xcTopHr.4
!4CKyCCTBa,,,nOrlHOcTbo
pa3BepHy'
Toi no
ropu3oHTanh",
TaK
'rro
Hl4 o KaKoi
,,cron6oBot
lopore"
3Aecb
He Mo)Ker 6brrb
fi
pequ.
flrc6an
Haxoara,
nprBfleKUJaF
BHUMaHhe
XyaoxHuKa,
Koqytoulero
no
3Toi
,,paBHqHe,
yceaHHoi
pyHHaM|a';
Mo)Ker 6blrb BHoBb
,,3anyqeHa
B
MauHHy
asutxa",
llpu 3roM
coBepueHHo
ucKnrcqaeTcF,,p14TophKo-nareTrqecKaF
l,AeHThd14Ka'
qlta",
roropoi
rlporvaonocraBrlFercF',Henp,|HyxaeH-
HaF BTOpt4'iHOCTb
Ul,irl.l
pOB
aH
hF,
cnoc06HaF
npeo6pa30'
BaTb
ficToplrqecKyK,
rJly6HHy BoccraHaBn'lBaeMbrx
F3bl'
KoB
B
Tpe3Bvro...
n
oBe
pxHocrh
"
(TaM
xe,c.'17).
Onrcasue,,HeoMaHbepqcrvqecKoi"
(aM6t1BafieHT-
Hoi, Kone6ntoueicF,,,apeidyloUtei")
nosrtlt'tl't
xy'
loxHhKa
6oHuro
Onrebt KaK
6bl [HrerplpyercF
6a-
poruoi
rcotqenquei.
Pa3pa6oraHHaF
Kana6pege
reo-
phF
coBpeMeHHoro
Heo6apoKKo,
oxBaT[BLriaA
BCe Bfi'
a6r
!4cKyccrBa.
MaccoByro
Kynhrypy,
HoByp
HayKy,
oKa3anacb
6onee
BnharenhHoi
u
KaK 6bl
norrorrna
HeoMaHbephclH'{ecKyK)
r|4nore3y,
orpaHhqeHHyto
Tep'
pufopvei
xyAoxecTBeHHoro
egblKa.
OAHo
!43 npeuMy-
ulecre
o6pauleHFs
K noHarl4to
..6apoxro"
-
To,
qro
gro
noHFTue vMeer
rny6oKyto
rpaaxul4to
dxnoco+'
c<oi
unrepnperaqrn
B KaqecrBe
KynbrypHo-3K3t4creH-
q[anhHoi yH[Bepcarr'1t4.
B
oTnrqtle
oT
,HeoMaHbepr3-
ua",,,reo6apoxro"
ceo6oatto or
orreHKoB
Bropl4'{Ho'
crh
u nepexo[Hocrti.
flpoayrrveHocrb
KoHuenqhll
Ka-
na6pe3e,
no-a!4AxMoMy, o6ycfloBneHa
14
TeM,
'{ro
aBTop
crpol4l
oTKpbrryK) clacreMy
no npuHu[ny
,.KopHeBr'
ula", ocTaBrflF
Maccy
Bo3MoxHocrei
AnE
noflBreHl4f,
HoBblx
,,orpocrKoB".
Bnrraa
MHoxecrBo vAeh,
HocuB'
[.lJlrxcF
B
ao3ayxe,
Teopl4A
Kana6pe3e, B cBoto
o'{epeab.
Aana
o6hnbHbte
BcxoAbt, B
ToM
gl4cre
r
B c$epe npo-
eKTHoi Kynbrypbr.
K KoHqenurh Kana6pe3e,
B
qacrHocru,
Bocxoal4T
laHTepnperaquF,,MacLura6a
Heo6apoKKo" opraHl43aro-
't4
3aMH abrcraaKo 1988 roAa
B
OPT
,,A!a3aiH
cero[H8"
'-2,
c.73*751. Coeceu ne4aeno,
a
1990 roay,reva
6a-
SoKKo 6hrra
Bhr6paHa
Ana
BbrcTaEKr
An3aiHa,
nocBa-
..lgHHoi
Aecar[nerxp
VIA-
opraHh3aqx14 npl4
dpaH-
.ly3cKoM l\4!lHhcrepcTBe
npoMbrurneBHocT!r,
cTr4Mynri-
gy|ou{ei
!4HHoaaq|,rcr
B
Me6enbHoM
nporl3BoAcrBe. KaK
iroFcHFer
Ar4peKrop
VIA
X.K.
Moxrpap.
uq,ea 6apoK-
KO
B03H14KIta
.,He
CnOHTaHHO", a KaK CneACTBt4e
,,COB
na-
,treHHF
TOqeK
3peH'|fl A npecce", CgUAeTerhCTBytOU]ero
o ToM,
i{To,,Ha
HauL.rx rra3ax
o6pa3oBanocb }1 cTpyKTy-
pHpyeTcF
aBxxefl|,1e,
3it KofopbrM
Mbt
ao'|XHbt
npocne-
ahrb".
no MHeHxrc
Moxxpapa,
pa3pa6orKa
6apogHbtx
6ooM
Bo3MoxHa He ronbKo Ha
6a3e
HoBeiultlx
rexHo-
tlofuit, Ka.<
3ro npoxcxoArr B xraflbaHcKoM
Ari3aiHe,
50 h nyTeM
nepeocMbrcleHqF Hacneaxa
peMecen,
Tpa-
anlfioHHbrx
rexHrK
r varepraanoe
[17,
c.
83].
B3B!axpeHHoe,
VcKopeHHoe
BpeMa, !tcKaxeHHoe
npocrpaHcrBo,
Kote6npu.laaca
cxcTeMa
qeHHocTei
-
Bce
3To BHoBb HanoMqHaer
yxe
cKa3aHHoe
H.A,Eep-
AFeahrM
no
noBoAy
aBaHrapAa Ha'{ana
BeKa:,,He6btaa-
noe
Aa[xeHl4e
h He6brBaraa
cKopocrb Ha'{yHaprcF
B
tfly6laHe
6btrl4a
t.l... l4cToqftl4KoB
3Toro
ABuxeH|,'f,
tt
3roi cKopocrx
Hyxfto ltcKarb
BHyrpl,t
AyxoBHoi
xE3-
Hh. AnoKarrrnrxgecKhe
npopo'{ecrBa
roBopFT
06
yc-
KopeHuh
BpeMeH[.
ycKopeHHoe
BpeMfl,
B KoropoM
pa3aqBaeTcF
He6br
aanoe, KaTacTpoduqecKoe
aBl4xeHue,
ecr6
BpeMF anoKafl{nru9ecKoe...
Ho
e anorc'antanruve-
cKoM
BpeMeH14 Ber]x'{aiure
Bo3MoxHocTh
coeahHFroT-
cF c Berlqaiurt4Mh
onacHocrFMl4..,
B etov
anxpe lao-
ryr
norr6tyt
,t Ber[qaiuJhe
qeHHocrx,
Moxer He
ycToETb
qeIoBeK,
MoxeT 6brTb
pa3oapaH
B Knoqbs"
11 ,
c.221 .
ny6rxqxcrurrecKlai
na$oc aroro reKcra
Aocra-
roqHo
AareK
or
noAqepKHyro
o6reKT|,BHoro, 6e33Mo-
utloHanbHo.onucarenbHofo
ToHa Kana6peae, roropuri
co3HarerbHo
craBuT nepeA co6oro
qerb
6e3oqeHo,rHoi
KoHcrarau,l4l4
Ha6rpAaeMbrx
+aKToB.
EABa Kacascb
(E
QOpMe
npeanoJroxeHlra,
Bonpoca o Myraq[ri co3Ha-
nra,
o6ycnoenetnoit
paearrlrev
Macc-MeAra
l,i ToTanb-
Hoi
Bri3yan|,|3aqyei rynsrypsr, rranuarcrri
uccne4o.
BaTenh He
3aocTpaeT BHuMaHre Ha
Bo3MoxHbtx
onacHo-
crFX
TaKoi uyraqrr. Heur6exHbti
cxeMarh3M
Bceox-
BarHocTlt np[rnyuJaer
oT3ByKl4
peanhHoi
noneMuKl4
Mexay copeBHyrcquMficF,
KoHsnxKryx)ult4Ml4
Kynb-
TypHbrMli
MoAenFM14.
KaK npeAcraBnaercr,
gra
none-
Ml1Ka
npHHrMaer
ocooeHHo
ocrpbte
+opMht
raM, rAe
peqh
{aeT HenocpeacTBeHHo
o
(popMxpoBaHxh
oKpy-
xatoqei cpeAbr,
a
qacTHocTr.t
B cdepe apxuTeKrypHo-
rpaAocrpolrrerbHbrx
KoHqenqni,
B
arux
4rcrcyccuax
Ha
hepBbtit nraH
abtxoAFT TpeBoxHbte,
onacHhte acneK.
Tbt
MeTaMopso3bt
qenoBe'{ecKofo
co3HaHfis. 3Aecb
repvrtr,,xeo6apo<Ko"
npko6peraer
HoBylo oKpacKy,
npeBpau.laacb
B
AeBrl3,
HaqepraHHrri xa
6oeeou utran-
AapTe.
K npeAcTaBuTenEM
raKoro
noleMr4.tecroro
(cy-
xernoro)
noHt,tMaHt,ta
Heo6apoKKo
-
Ha3oBeM ero,,ro,
pBql4M"
6apoKKo
-
orHoct4Tca
Spaxqyscrrai
rprrtr
apxrreKTypbr
X.-n. fle
.qaHTeK.
Ha
aaHHoM
ypoBHe
paccyxaeHui
onpeaeneHhe
npo{3aeaeHt4a
KaK
6apoqHoro uoxer
6uttr
ocnopeHo.
Iluuua
orna,
pa3MexeBaBltiaa
no3xrll4l, npouJla
qepe3
cKyrbnrypy
A.
flh6ecKuHAa
,,Orxexxaa
nv{t d",
co3-
AaHHyrc
no aa<asy
Llerrpa
coBpeMeHHoro xcKyccrBa
B
Xexeee.
3ro
AoBonbHo
KpynHbti
(1
Mx'l M
B
pa3pe3e)
o6reKT
-
creKnflHHaF
nplr3Ma-na6upr,tHT. flprsnaean
nracT4qecKhe
aocToxHcTBa
cKynbnTypbt. fle
.Q,atrer
peuJl,lTenhHo
oTaepraeT
nonhtTK14
KptlTtlKoB
no'1,.tuc-
nrrb ee K coBpeMeHHoMy 6apoKKo. no eTo vxexrrc,
nx6ecK HAoBcr<14i
.,3t1r3ar"
Bonrou]aer Kapre3raH-
cKyro
14HTepnpeTaqhlo
npocTpaHcTBa, MoaepHl4cTcKoe
noHt,tMaHUe
Qoprvrur
r noroMy He ronbKo
qyxA,
Ho 14
,,aHTaroH[crl4qeH
6apolxoi crna4re"
[13,
c. 105]
.
LlMeHHo B Bo3Bpau.leHu|4 K MoAepHficrcKr,lM npxH-
qrnaM
TBopvecKoro
Mbrr.uneHlaF tle
AaHleK
BxA[r
BecbMa cepbe3Hylo onacHocTh
AnF
coBpeMeHHoi
Kynh-
Typbl
-
onacHocTb HanpaB[TbcF no Tyn4KoBoMy
nyTu.
Peanuvauun
3Tr1x npuHl{xnoB
B
reopuv
v npaKThKe
ap.
xriTeKTypHoro npoeKTl4poBaHuF
n rpaaocrpofirenbcrBa
npaMo
yrpoxaer
q
MarepnanbHoi
cpeAe, x ncrlxo$t,,t3r.
qecK4M
ocHoBaM 9eIoBeqecKoro
6blTtla,
HhrHeuHee
Bo3poxAeHl4e MoAepHrcrcKl4x
ycra-
HOAOK
B apxITeKType, KaK X BO3BpaqeH!4e,,XeCTKl4X"
MOAene; B h3O6pa3hTenhHoM r4cKyccTBe,
n14uleHo Bo3-
MOXHOCTI.I
OnhpaTbCf, Ha
pa3BeHqaHHbre,.ClrJlbHbte"
|,J'aeonofvv,
Ha coqhanbHbre
yTonhE
[cTopt4qecKofo
aBaHrapaa.
ono npollcxo4ur B KoHTeKcTe HecTa6hlb-
Hoi
anox Heo6apoKKo, To
ecTr, ToTo Kpl43tca 3anaAHo-
ro
paqlaoHanu3Ma,
KoHTyphr Koroporo
B o6uleM o'{ep-
qeHbr
B l4ccneAoBaH[[
Kana6pe3e.
Ecnr e nepuogrt
Pe-
HeccaHca,
a6connrr13Ma, flpocBeuteHxF,
6ypxya3Horo
TyMaHk3Ma, MoAepHucTcKot yronftu
TopxecTEoBanq
hnnto3,114
oTHocrTenbHo 6yaTo
6bt
HaiaeHHoro
Bbtxoaa
a3 Kpt43VCa, TO
,,Ce|OAHF
nprXOA!4TCA
np[3HaTb, {TO B
Ae;crB[TenbHocrh
cla6 nbHoro
eutxo4a ner".
,,Oayc-
ToBcKaF aBaHnopa 3ana4a.
<oropuri r43o6pen
HayKy,
r4cKyccTBo
14
aeMoKpaThp
H BMecTe
c TeM nepex[n
yTpaTy
-
cMepTb
-
EoTa.
onnavera
qeHoi
HenpepbtB.
HOrO Kph34ca
U 6eCKOHeqHOro
p!,lcKa,
TaK
KaK [Ctte3
nocneAHhi
*yxAauenr,
3aKnrcqaBu.l4i
B ce6e 3aKoH",
nxureT fle,{aurerc.
3noxa,,nocne MoAepHh3Ma"
ecTb
He
iiTo
l4Hoe, KaK
3noxa
oco3HaH4a 3Toi caMoi,,hToro-
aoi
nycrorur"
[15,
c.
116J
.
B 70-e roAbt,
B MoMeHr,,ocrpoi"
$assr
r<pusuc'a.
KorAa
paaxKanbHo
noKone6anca
qerrocuurri
rplrre-
pl4
i
.,coBpeM
eHH ocru"
,
Hauerunvch
,,HocTarbTl4LtecKIe
co6ra3H6r"
B03poA,|Tb hAeto
paBHoBec!1F
B apxETeKTy-
pe.
OAHaKo HeoaKaAeMh3M
t4
nocrMoAepHrlcTcKoe
nacT,luj l,tpoBaHrre
D"rlcKpeaulapoBanu
ce6F, TaK KaK
coBep[!eHHo He
cooTBeTcTBOBanx
HeypaBHoBeuleHHo-
cTLr, TpeBoxHocTl4
MxpooulyqeHxfl
coBpeMeHHoTo
qe-
IoBeKa, r'lMeHHo
cTpeMneHrleM
tau6oree a4erearto
Bblpa314Tb
oulyuleH l.le
xaoca.
aucKpeTHocTt4
u HecTa6 hnb.
HocT[
6btrt4fl o6lacHFeTcF
Bo3H[KHoBeHue
AeKoHcT-
pyKTnBh3Ma.
cTaBuero 3aMeTBbtM
FBneHrleM
B 3ana,4-
Hoi
apxureKrype
KoHqa
80-x
roAots.
,Qexorcrpyrrnercrbl ABrlHyrxch,.no
3bt6KoMy
nyr|a,
yKa3aHHoMy
nocrcrpyKTypantcrcKoi
Sunoco-
$uei",
xorcrarnpyer
fle
AaHreK [13,
c. 101], Corc3
apxrfreKTypbf
tA
Qunocobva
nphHFn
SopMy
HenocpeA-
cTBeHHOTO COTpyAHt4qeCTBa
14 npkHec
BnonHe
peaJtbHhre
nnoabr:
napK fla
Bunerr B Tlaphxe.
Haa npoeKToM
Ko-
Toporo
pa6oranu
apx[TeKTopbr
n.
Ai3eHMaH.6.
qyMla
v1
A,
nr.6ecKu+A
BMecre
c r[AepoM
nocrcrpyKTypa-
nu3Ma
X.
AeppuAa.
[loqevy xe
Sparqyscxri
xprrrx
y6exAeH
B ToM,
qro
3To
nyrb He rorlbKo
3bt6Kui1,
Ho u
paapyurlrrencnlri?
Yxe
ucxo4rute
nocrynarbr
AeKoHcrpyKTr4B143Ma
coaepxaT
He
pa3petrl14Moe
B ero
paMKax
npoT|4aopeghe.
llo runerurto
rle
,{anrera, ann
apxr4TeKrypbt
cyutecrBv-
loT
TOnbKO.qBe
BO3MOXHOCTI4:
Jth6o CBeaeHl4e
ee K
npo-
eKry
{apxureKTypa-cKynbnrypa,
apxrrreKroH,
qeprex
|/|
T.
A.) .
nu6o
peanbHaF
xr3Hb
B Marephane
h B KoHKper-
Hoi cpeAe.
yTBepxAaF
np{opl,Ter
KoHqenra,
AeKoHcT-
pyKTr4Bt43M
B
CyUIHOCTT4
CneAyeT
,lorfiKe
,,cTpenht,
ny_
uleHHoi
!43 ryKa
!t 3aBi4cuJei
B Bo3Ayxe"[13,
c.
104]
.
A6conrcTx3auhF
KoHqenrlr
crpeMneHl4e
paculararb
,,onnoT
npxcyTcTB!1f",
KOlOpblM
BCerAa
6blna apxx-
TeKTvpa,
noa'lepKxBaoT
pa3pblB
Mexay
npoeKToM tl
ero
peanx3auuei
(xa
sro nporreope!lte
yKa3blBan
x
X,
AeppxAa)
. 6y4yvu
nopoxaeHxeM
coBpeMeHHoi
MeHTaIbHOCTl,t,
AeKOHCTpyKThBH3M
TeM He MeHee nO
cyrh
perpeccl/|BeH
KaK
B
nnaHe
xyaoxecTBeHHoro
F3bl-
Ka, TaK h c To'{Kt4
3pe8rF 3ThqecKoli
ycTaHoBKl4
TBop-
gecKoi
nuqHocTu.
Oco6oe
6ecnoKoicrBo
Bbt3btBaer
Bo3BpauleHre
K
xAeonorxu,,repolliecKoro
npp$erla3Ma"
oAl,tHoKof
o
reHl,|a. 14rHopxpyF 3T!1Ky
rpaAocrpol.lTenbcrBa, ocHo-
BaHHyO
Ha Haqanax
,,rocrenpu[McrBa"
u
yaaxeHl,|n
K
,,v{aKoclvt",
To
ecrb Ha ocMblcneH!lu
HenoBTopxMocTl4
KOHKpeTHOTO MeCTa,
AeKOHCTpyKTl4Brl3M
npoTtaBOnO-
craBnFer
efi npor3Bon
apxurerropa-x!4oxHr.1Ka,
npr,r.
3BaHHoro nt,tuJb
nplaarb
SopMy
co6creettutr'a
fratras-
MaM. CJroxr4BUeMyca
ropoacKoMy
KoHTeKcry npor14-
BOnOCTaAnFeTCF
CaMOAOCTaTOqHOCTb
l,l3oJlrlpOBaHSOrO
,rapxhreKTypHoro
o6terra,
npoerrupyeMoro
B Kaqecr-
Be 3rleMeHTa
ropoacKoro
npocTpaHcTBa, anp[opHo
MbrcnrMoro
KaK xaorhqecKoe".
flo
yreepxaeHtarc
fle
AaHTeKa,
KaKUM 6br crpaHHbtM
oHo
Hu
noKa3attocb Ha
negeuri earnaA,
3Aecb
aeicrByer,rhcro
Kapre3haHcKaF
norxKa.
AeKapry
npxHaanexxr
cneAytoqee
paccyxAe-
HXe:
,,...
npox3BeaeHfia, cocTaBneHHble
l43 MHorrx
qac-
Tei r co3AaHHbre
pyKaMx pa3Hbtx
MacrepoB,
JtxueHbl
coBepujeHcrBa, ornt,|qarculero
pa6orbl
oaHoro
rBopqa...
TaK,.3T[ crapq8Hbte
noceneHha, Koropbre... Bbtpocnx
B 60IbuJrie
ropoAa. o6btKHoBeHHo cnnaH14poBaHbr
Koe-
rcarc... fnnAn
Ha
3AaHua...
Ha rx
pacnonoxeHue:3Aecb
-
6otbuoe, TaM
-
ManeHLKoe,
BI4AE, HacKonbKo r,i3-3a
3foro KphBbr x HepoBHbr
ynl4qbr,
MoxHo cKa3arb,
gfo
pa3Mecrxrra
ux
raKrM
o6pa3oM
He BonF
pa3yMnbrx
n|oAei,
a
caMa
OopryHa,,,
3arpyaHrrerbHo
co3aarb Be'
u.lx coBepuJeHHbre,
npoAonxaa
pa6ory,
Ha'rarylo
Apyru'
ur uacrepaur"
(TaM
xe, c.'102)-
3gecu,
cqrraer fle
.qaHTeK,
3anoxeHbt 4cxoaHbte npxHu[nbt
MoAepHHcr-
crofi crparerur. Corracxo
r4M, ltcropkqecKr cnoxtaB-
uJlrica,,ropoA-npoqecc"
-
gro
npocro
xaoc.
CoBepureH-
HOe apxxreKTypHoe
npor3seaeHue KaK
pe3ytlbraT
H,|-
'{eM
He cKoBaHHoro, ceo6oauoro
paqxoBanbHoro
aea-
HttF xyaoxHfiKa
MoxeT 6brTb co3aaHo TotlbKo B
,,nyc-
ToM" npocrpaHcrBe
(g
[aeane ero
paenrxa)
n
e
,,oc-
TaHoaneHHoM", ocao6oxreHHoM or
xcropH14 BpeMeHx.
AnbrepHarxBa MoAepH[crcKoMy
contancx3My
cy-
uecrByer,
y6exAeH
fle
AaHTeK.
14 oHa 3aKnp'{aerca
B
norcKe
,,coapyxecTBa
c MhppM",
noH[MaeMbrM B Ka-
teropunx rr6rcoro,,6apo.rHoro" MbrLrJreHra,
onhpap-
u{eroca
Ha
onbrr noBoi
HayKu.
llnn
Toro,,{To6bt
r36e-
xarb nyraHxqbr uexay 6aporxo KaK [cropr4qecKxM
FBneHreM u KaK
yHr4BepcarbHoi
KynbrypHo-3K3rrcreH-
qranuroi
Kareropxei,
npeAnaraercF B nocneaHeM
cnygae
ynorpe6rFTb
repMhH,,6apoKh3r'1", Oopvoo6pa-
3oaarenbHbre npxHqxnbr 6apoKr43Ma
cBa3aHbr
c HeKap-
Te3xaHcKoi rparroe<oi npocrpaHcrBa
-
nnacrvqHoro,
TeKylero, HanorHeHHoro
ABxxeHueM,,3nacTx9Hot
Ma-
TepuE, c+opMupoaaHHoi
6ecKoHe,{HbrMr.1
cKnaaKaMq"
[15,
c.
114].
B
ocHoBe
raKoro
al,|HaMhqHoro
noHqMa-
BxF npocrpaHcrBa
-
He reoMerpha
AeKaprar
a
ronono-
rlaa
Amapra
-nei6nr.rqa,
onepnpyoulaa He Korl4irecr-
BaMx
(paccroFHl,{s
uexAy roqrcavr)
,
a orHoueHxFMrl
(a3al.1MHoe
HanpFxeHre MexAy noKycaMu, HaxoAaulx-
Muca B cocroaH'.1,r rpaHcdopMaulau) .
O6pas crJtaAru, Ha HauJ B3rrFA, oqeHb 3S+eKr-
Hbti,3aHhMaer
K'|toi{eBoe noroxeH14e B 6apo'{Hoi Mera-
Qr3r4Ke
npocrpaHcrBa(BcnoMHl4M
apanhpoBKx
oa
Hxa cBsroi Tepesu 6epxlaHu)
. Oltnoco+ha
cKnar
cdopMynt,tpoBaHa X.
Aenesour.
llo ero cnoeaM,
,,
pogHoe
HanpaBneHxe,..
Koropoe Morro 6br 06beAuHl
apx14TeKTopoB,
xyaoxHxKoB,
My3brKaHToB, no3T
+hnoco+oB,
npoxoAllT B ToqHocrl4
nq cxnaare"
I
c,
1141 . flporpar'arvra apxureKrypHoro
6apoKr.3Ma,
uJer
fle
AaHreK,
3aKrpqeHa
B ToM,
,{To6br
,,cr}r6€
pasrr6a'ru,
eHoau cru6aru"
[13.
c. 107]. Creaoeare
HO,
,,BHyTpeHHee
npocTpaHcTBo
aBnBeTcfl Bcero rt1
cKnaaKoi BHeuJHero".
yrIqa
ropoAa, TaKUM o6pa3(
He
qro
rHoe,
KaK
cKnaAKa.
,,EapoKr,r3M
craBhr r
Bonpoc
caMo
noHarhe
rpaHuqbr. h3onhpoBaHHbrx o
eKToB
He
6brBaer"
[15,
c.
116] . Fopoa vutcnnrca
r
TKaHb c nflorHbrM nepenJrereHreM, co6paHHaF B 6ec
He'{Hoe'{rcJro cKnaaoK. nto6oe,,toqe,{xoe",,,arynyr
fypHoe" BMeuaTenbcTBo B
fopoAcKyro cpeay oKa3bl
eT u3nygalou.lee Bnl4aHl4e
Ha
oKpyxaioulee
npocrpaHcl
aaneKo
3a npeaenaMri Henocpeacf BeHHof o Bo3aeicTB
CKflaAKa
-
cl4MBon
,,pearbHoro
pa3rlr,i'{ua
h
pa3aelbHocrr".oHa,,pa3aenFer,coeahHan"
(Tav
xr
Her rpaHliqbr, Ho ecrb none HanpFxeHuf,
Mexay npo
Bonofl oxHbrM14
nonpcaMr. B reryve-xecra6unurol,,r
portHoM
Mxpe xcqe3aeT Kjlaccl/|gecKoe, KapTe3laSct
npoTl,rBonocTaaneHl.|e cv6!eKTa
14
06heKTa,
axclaHL
Mexay ricKyccrBeHHbrM
h ecTecTBeHHbrM,
npaBAoi
urnrc3l,lei. B KoHqe KoHr.toB, He npfixoar4TcF roBopl
u o
,rerKoi
rpaH|,|qe MexAy 6apoKu3MoM
h Knacc
Hocrbro.
CornacHo a+oph3My
+paHqy3cKoro
ygeH(
A, MarbA[He,
,,R
nacc[tu3M
-
caMaF TyraF
crpyHa
poxxo"
{Taru
xe,c. 113)
.
l\4oaepHla3M,
6a3lapyroulrl i
Ha npocgeuleHqecKoM
paql4oHant43Me
x cor.ll/|arbHoM
T,lMt43Me,
B CBOHX OCHOBaX KnaCCl,,|r.lt4CT14qeH, nOnaT
fle
,qaFrreK.
BHyrpH
,,cospeMeHroro
Aeuxextan"
6a
K113M 6brn
yAenoM
,,Ben14K!4x
MapruHanoB", TaK
KaK A. Aanro.
Ox
uor
ao3xurarl
,r
,,Ha
nonnx" TB
'{ecraa
oproAoKcanbHbrx rr,lAepoB
(Kanenna
PoHu
fle
Kop6rcase) . TaK xe u
BHyrph
6apoKx3Ma cerol
MOXHO
OTMeTBTb CrpeMneHXe K npOCTOTe X 3KOHON
cpeAcr8. K
,,Knaccr'{ecKoMy"
6apoK[3My ne
AaH]
orHocl4T TBopqecrBo
Ar4o,
flop:arunaprca, Fo4ena
To BpeMF KaK
,,3M+arr'{ecKxfi"
6apoKh3M npeAcr
neH XonnaiHoM, rpynnoi
CAIT, Fepu, Kanarpae
OyKcacoM.
OopMaflu3oBaHHbr
i
reoMerpx3M F3hrKa
AeKoH
pyKThah3Ma
npoAl4KToBaH
crpeMneHueM
la36aBuTl
oT TenecHocTr Mfipa,
oT MaTeptau
-
tartx ee cgoic
KaK
Taxecrb, nnorHocrb, rny6uxa. B
groM
-
orKJr
AeKoHcrpyKTHB!43Ma
Ha [AeKr X. EoApl,iiapa o,,Ae
anr3aLlu?l
peanbHocrr4".
ToranbHoi,,onpo3paqHeH
crq" Mupa, cssgasxoi
c aKpaHHoi
ql4Bhlr3aurl
,,KoHqenr".-
no usesrp
fle
.{aarera,
-
,,TepMuH..
ByuJKa", KOTOpbTM onep!,ipyeT sce roT xe
peayKq
Hh3M, npx3Hapu.lr,ri
nuuJb npaBa [HTenreKTa. B npo
aononoxHocrb 3ToMy
oAHa !a3 fnaBHbtx
reM
6ap(
KO
-
AOnflOUIeHHOCTb.
T4HKapHXpOBaHHOCTb TBOpeH
(,,14
Cnoeo craro nnorbro".)
,,14cryccreo
pa6oraer
c Ko[cM,
a co cnoBoM",
6naroAapF
'{eMy,,Mr4p-nprl
crBre
BonnoulaercF
B npou3BeAeHxh-co6btrl414", no
raer
KpuruK
(Tau
xe, c. 116),Kotqenryoxnporueo
cTaanffeT
QopMy
-
KaK HeqTo
yHrKaltbHoe,
Bnot
ocn3aeMoe
r
,,HeBhrpa3rMoe"
a repurnai taor,qen
arbHoi rorhKx.
fle,[arrex
Bo3naraer 6onhulfie
Haaexabt Ha
al
co6Hocrb 6apo'rHoi
Mbtc'|u
peuJlirb
oAHy
r43
caMbtx
I
re3HeHHbtx
npo6neM
coBpeMeHHoi
quBl,t'|t43aquh
npo6relay
Aerpaaaux!l
rodoaa.
CeroAra
aanero
16
;ceH
oTBeT Ha
BOnpOC:
ABIAeTCA
nU rOpOA
6aKTOpOM
5yAyutero?
He
rcqegner
nu
oH
-
,,KaK
noKyc,
KaK
-opMa
14
KaK
yMF",
KaK
cneqla$xL]ecKas
npocrpaHcr.
SeHHaF
OpraH[3auqa,
B
ycnoBrlFx
BecbMa
oulyTl4Moro
:ihpaHhF
TpaHet
Mexay
fopoaoM
cen6cKoi
MecT_
rocThro,
B
pe3ynbTare
KoToporo
nocTeneHHo
o6oa3veT_
-
yHh+rqhpoBaHHaF,,cnIoru6
yp6arnsrpoaanran,.
-eppelrophn?
[14,
c, 100J .
flpuraru
ueovogeprncr-
-^Ky|o
apxhTeKTypHyto
cTpaTeTrlo
_
3HaqrT
oKoHqa_
;eirbHo
nory6rrb
ropoa.
ljlexay
reM
ceroaHn
hMeHHo
:aKaF
crparerra
norb3yeTca ycnexoM,
,{To
o6.bacHF-
:rca
oxqB.neHl4eM,,aHrpenpeHepcKoro
Lyxa"
sB/'Ay
-oFAyulero
o6LeAlaHeH{ff
EBponbt.
KoHKypeHqrF
ropo_
loB
crqMyrl4pyel
pa3pa6orr(y
cynepnpoeKToB,
KoIo-
3bre,
KaK
npeAnonaraercF,
o6orarar
ropoA
6pocKt4Mt
e
pxrlTe
KTypHbtM
h
cltMBonaMu
u cael|arcT
ero
o6nxK
reoTpa3r4Mo
np14BneKaTenbH6tM.
HeManoBaxHo,
oaHa_
<o,
B nofoHe
3a ,1Ml4AxeM
He
norepFTb
,ruqa,
Bor
no_
:eMy
MoAepHucrcKt,le
Meqrbr
(cxaxev.
cAeraru
ua
5eprxHa
eBponetcKhi
FoHKoHT,
KaK
npeanataeT
KorsxoS)
He Bbt3btBarcT,
MFrKo
roBopa,
coqvEcraxF
y
SpaHUy3cKoro
KplaluKa.
ABropbt
noAo6Hbtx
cynepnpoeKroB,
KaK
npaBr.t.
to,
o6pau.lapT
cBoe
6naTocKJloHHoe
BHuMaHqe
K ro_
:c4cxoi
nepr{ephvt
Koropan
FBrfler
co6oi
noqrli
,'AeanbHyro,,nycrory",
3To
6othulei'{acrbo
nrueH-
'1oe
KaKhx-nh60
npu3HaKoB
KoHRperHoi
MecTHocTl4
''rpocTpaHcrBo,
Koe-TAe
nphrcTr4aL!ee,,ocTaTK14
MOAep_
aA3Ma"
-,,reporqecKI-oalrHoKhe,'
MoHyMeHTaI6Hbte
!6heKT6t.
LlMeHHo
B TaKoM
npocTpaHcrBe
,,Hepacqre_
ieHHoi
yp6aH
l4cTl,
q{ocl
u',
,
fAe
nrc.4x.
yTpar4Bt!te
:noco6HocTb
npocTo
chAeTb,
xop.ulb
vnu
6eceAoaart.
3brHyxaeHhl,,t{14pKynqpoBETb,'
Uny,,noaKnloqaTbcF
< KOMMyH14Kaqhh",
|4
nllaHhpyeTca
Bo3BeaeHl4e
oqe-
ceAH6tx
rqraHTOB
-
naMATHUKOB,,KOHUenTVanbHoi
:oruKn"
v,.neAaHoro
ctaMBonx3Ma,,
(TaM
xe) -
Ho,
co6creeHrio,
TaK
rh
y)l<
Heo6xoAhMo
coxDa.
lieH!4e
ropoaa
B ero
TpaafiqhoHHofi,
ucTopr4qecKh
cno_
-i<'ABuehcq
+opMe?
HepeAKo
roBopl4TcFt
o roM,
lTo
rnorHag
crpyKTypa
eeponeicroro
ropoAa
_
apxata3M
,j
He cooTBeTcTByer
,,repeuofi
3cTeTr4Ke,
qvBcTBqTenb-
eoH
K KnhMaTy
3noxh,
B KbTOpOi
UapFT
3neKTpOHhKa.
roroK!a
hH6opMaq'th,
HeycroiqhBocrh
ueHHocrer, He-
;i36exHaa,
Ho
nnoAorBopHaa
A/,crapMo1ul".,,Aepea-
r'rH3aqha
peanbHocT14",
KOTOpytO
KOHCTaTnpyeT
X.
60a_
:tq;Fp,
crana
ocHoBaHreM
AnF
KoHqenu[r
,,KoHua
ro-
ooAa
"
pa3B'|EaeMOi
ft.
BUpnnuo.
oH
abtaBhfaeT
Te3!.ic
o HoBoM
BOCnpxFTl4h
npocTpaHcTBa
_
,.CBepxBe3.qe_
cyu.lHocrl,t",
o6ycnoenetuoi
oror<AecrBneHBeM
Dealb_
Hocrl4
h
ee
,,ct
Myna\ku".
noHFTlae
ropoAa
KaK
Mecra,
,roKyca
TeM
CaMbtM
al4cKpeahTt4pyeTca,
nocKonbKV
ieopeThqecKh
MoxHo
xt4Tb
B ,rp6oM
npocTpaHcTBe,
norHocTbro
oTropoahBLut4ch
oT Hefo
3KpaHHhtMl,
x3o_
6paxeHuFMx
(Taru
xe) . OsHa,raer
nr
Bce
3To,,{ro
ap-
xqTeKlopy
He
ocTaeTcF
H14qero
ApyToro,
KaK
cM14pt4Tb-
cn
c
,,4arcrarypoi KoMnbprepHbtx
v3o'par(e|ui
t4
3c-
rerL4Koh
KnunoB",
BMecro
Toro.
lro6sr
Sopurpoearu
pean6Hyro
cpeay,
B Koropoi
Mht
xuBeM,
cnpaurrlBaer
,4e
lanrer
[15.
c. 116]
.
Ocraeaacs
BepHhrM.AoH
Kr_
xoToM
TopoAa,
oH
yTBepxAaeT. ,{Io
roBopl4T6
o,,np43.
paqHocTh
ropoAa
v ero
r<vrele6,'_
3Haqhr
nooooq[Th
r
6en6
,{enoBe.fecKoh
qnaunusaqun,
HeMbtcnhMol,t
6e3
fopoaoB.
Bonpocbt
..qro
raKoe
ropoA?,,
14,,qro
raKoe
qero-
B€K?"lr4gH1tiqH61,
KaK
3aMerun
nrcaTenh_+aHTacr
K.
Caiva<.Teopra
,,Aepealt
3aqt4u pearbHocrl4.,
Ecrpe_
vaet
cepuesreirure
MopallbHbte
BO3paXeH4F,
noAqeo-
rfieaer
fle
,Qarrer.
9eaoeevecrBo
nepex[no
Benfiqai-
LU'le
TpaBMbr
-
OT MaCCOBOTO yHhttTOXeHhA
nrcAei
{AyL!Bl4q,
fyrar,
KonoHr{arbHbre
BoiHbt)
Ao
ropa3Ao
MeHee
cTpauJHofo.
Ho cTonb
xe
pearrbHoro
pa3pyuJeHl4a
ropoAoB,
nprHeceHHbtx
B xeprBy
MoAepHucrcKoi yro.
nut
.
,,HenpucrohHo" 6btno 6bt
conocraBnFTb peanb,
HOCTb
3TOrO
OnbtTa
c MHhMocTbro
3KpaHHOaO
Ml4Oa. BO_
npeKu
tlo6hrM TexHoJtoTt4qecKhM peBonrcurFM
t1 KaKo-
vy
6ur ro
Hh 6btro
reopeT[3t4poBaHhrc
He[3MeHHbtM
ocTaeTcF HauJe
Teno.
h
oHo HenpenoxHo
HanoMhHaeT
HaM
o
pearbHocrti.
.,Be4s
cvepru
ectu
peanonocrs..,
ly's6aehrgcs
or MarepyarbHocrt4
Tera
HeBo3MoxHo
rHa-
qe,
KaK
pa3pytul4B
ero. Telo
FBnaeTcF
h
Mep[noM
KoHKperHoro
npocrpaHcrBa.
Oao rpe6yer
Mecra
ArF
xt 3Hu,
a He
(KoHTr4HyyMa),
B KOTOpOM
MOXHO
(r.ll4p-
KyJlt4poBaTb)
h
(BKnrc'taTbcF).
Teny
Heo6xoal4Mbr
He
TOnbKO
(O6pa3bt),
Ho 14
ou]yuteHl4F,
ro._qTo
MoxHo
He
rolhKo
B
Aefb,
Ho
14
oca3aTb,
To,
qTo
MoxHo
HeHaB4_
aeTb
l4nl,4
o6HFrb. Teno
Bceraa
n4TaeT
HOCTanbfl4Kr
no
qpeBy.
OHo BceTAa
xpynKo,
npecneAyeMo
6onbto
h
cTpaxoM.
t4. MoxeT
6brTb. MoaepH
cTaM cToHT
BCnOM-
Hqrb
c}6 3Txx npocrbrx,
Ho
peularculrx
Beulax.
l\,4oxer
6urrc, crour
noayMarb
HaA
crapoi
hopMynoit
Ounv-
6epa
.Qenopva:
apxxreKrypa
uyxna,
vro6sl
(lrcuenarb
or MenaHxolr4l4).
He
cKa3aHo
nl4
3To o 6yAyurx
ropo-
aax?.."
[14,
c. 100] .
,,8
coepetrerrola
HcKyccrae
Ayx
KaK
6yAro
6bl
!4Aer Ha
y6btnb,
a
nnorb
AeMarep[an
h3yerc8,,
[
1
,
c.
g]
.
H.A.
6epgaee
cBa3btBar
3Tor
npoqecc
c nocneacrBlr,
EMr4
TexHrqecKoi
peBonrcq4fi.
Ha Hoeov
3Tane
aeMa_
rep!,1anu3au\nu
,,n'|oTv
Mt
pa"
Mbt
He cTall14
cB4aeTenF-
Mu rny6oKux
AyxoBHbtx
np03peH|,i
ocBo604hau]eTocE
oT MaTepr4l,
TBopvecTBa,
KOTOpbte
B T4noTeTi/qecKoM
6yny,,le"
fpe3vnvcb
$rznocoSy.
ltpn4et
nn l,,|x
BpeMa
14fl14
'./eroaeKa
Ha
3TOM
nyTn
ox[aarcT
nhu]b
noTep
_
Bce
3To raK
xe raAarenbHo,
KaK
a 1917 aoAy,
Ho
rpaHb,
3a Koropot
-
cpbtB, pacnaAeHhe,
.,pa3oApaH_
Hocrb
B Knottba"
.leroBeqecKoi
ncl,xl4Kt4,
KaxercF.
npl,6nh3u'l
acb BnnoTHyro.
EMKtlM
nnacrrqecK
M KoMMeHrap[eM
K
3ThM
pa3MbtLlneHhFM
npeAcTaBnFeTcF
OAHa '43
pa6oT,
3KC-
noHt poBa
B L.tl rlxcE
Ha
nocneAHel;
6reHHare
B BeHeul4r.
_
BhAeocKynbnrypa
aBcrpvicKnx
xyAox<Ht4u
f.
B(nbq
,1
P.
llJrenns
,,f
pywa".l\4ou.lH6ti
KynaK
6oKcepa
nDqro,
ToBhncE
araKoBaTb,,rpyu.ly,'
_
3KpaH
noABeLUeHHoro
Ha
npy>khHax
MoHrropa
c
r3o6paxeH[eM
FpKo_cl,1He_
3eneHoro
3eMHoro
ruapa. [lporneocroaHre
ropntiero
r
XOnOAHOTO,
xt4BOt
nroTt4
r vepreOi
Berqh,
HO
BeLrlh
oco6esuori,
4eyauarnoi,
He
npocTo
KocHoro
npeAMeTa,
orpaH14'{eHHoTO
rpexMepHbtM
npocTpaHcTBoM,
a
eu]e
q
nocpeaH
Ka
Me)KAy
qetoBeKoM
|4
np 3paqHhtM
MlrpoM
14Horo
h3MepeHuF,
M14poM
?,crMynFKpoe.,. 9ro
xe
npour:ofr4er?
Yaap?
TorAa
,,rpyula,,BepHercF B hcxoa-
HOe
nonoxeHr4e.
ocranetcn
I HeBpeaxMbtM
,{enoaeK?
9ro
coxpyLlrr
oror yAap:
Ha.l:tlt
urtrlg3l,a
o caMhx
ce-
6e,
unnasuu
o co3AaHHoi
uaun
quantnusaguu?
Moxer
6lrlu,
nanpaxentocrh
groro
He
pa3peL.leHHoro
KoH.
+rhKTa
h
cocraBnFer
repe rcole6nouleica,
yKnoHgt4.
Bo-HeonpeAeneHHoi
3noxu Heo6apoKKo.
nureparypa
I
5"pa""u
H.
Kph3Mc
,cKyccrBa.
lM.: 14HrepnprHr,
1990.
2
KoH4parbeBa
K.A.
,,HoB6ti
HeMeqKy;
Ax3aiH,,
B KoH-
reKcre
npoeKTHoi
<ynurypsr//Taopvecxhe
HanpaBreHuF
B
co_
BpeMeHHoM
3apy6exHoM
Ara3a;He.
|\4.,
1990.
lTp.
BHrjLtT3.
Cep. TexHh,{ecKaF
3creraKa:
Bbrn.60)
.
3
Alla
Biennaie
ho
ascottaro/L
L.p_//Dorlus
i990.
N;18.
1'7
4
Barilli
R., Ponti
L.L.
XLIY Biernalei
,,Barocco
freddo"//
Domu\
1990.
N 716.
5 Bonito Oliva A.
L'ideoloeiia
del traditore. Milano: Feltri-
nclli, 1976.
6 Bonito Olivl)
A.
Minori maniere. Milano: Feltrinelli,
1985.
/
(alaDi(',ic0.Lelancobaro\(a
Ronra-Bari:LrIerza,l987.
8
Capretti L.
Ecco
a
voi
la
porn-art//Euopeo.
1990. N 20.
9 Dossier: Biennalc
de
Venise//Art
pless.
I990.
N
14?
l0 Garcia-Marques F. Oldenburg/Van
Bruggen. Il collello
rffcttd-muro//Dornus.
1990.
N ?
16.
II Huser
F.
Les marchands du Temptc//Nouvel obse ateur.
1990.
N
1342.
12 Kipholf P. Vollc
Bildcr.
lccre
R5ume//Zcit. 1990. 1YL
N
23.
13 Le
Drntec
J.-P. Le ddconstructivrsme: Les rnisaventures
architecturalei dc la
philosophie
de
Derrida//Arcitecture
inte'-
rieure.
Crc-r 1988. N 226.
14 Lc
Dantcc
J.-P. L'Europc dcs
villes
en mal d'images//
Architecture interieure.
Crid. 1989.
N 230.
15 Lc Dantec J.-P. Vive lc
baroquismc//Architecture inte-
ricure
Crdc 1989.
N
228.
16
XLIY Esposizionc
.Internazionale
d'arte, la Biennale
di
Venczia:
Catalogo
generale
1990. Venezia-Milano: Edizioni
La
Biennale
di Venezra
Fabbri Lditori,
1990.
l7 Le VIA, le bilan d'une ddcennie//Architecture interieure.
cr66. 1990. N 234.
lu1.B. Kor<ltxa<u
Mysei
Ansaira
B floHAoHe
flerov 1989
roaa
B
IoHAoHe 6brn orKpbtr
My-
3ei
N^sait{a,
Ha ropxecree npvcyrcrBoBana
l\4ap.a-
per
T3rqep. Hoetri
ueHrp
Kynbrypbt
pa3Mecrr4tcF
B
3AaHrlh 6brBLllero
cKiaAa
Ha SarnepcKoi
npucraHh
B
noKflaHA3e.
3ror
paiox
floxAoHa [saaeHa
6hrn roproBbtM
(aocrarogHo
BcnoMHr4Tb onhcaHue
AoKnaHA3a
a
po.
vaue
9.
flrrrenca
.,Orueep
Tetacr")
. Ha
MHor[e
Kta-
noMeTpbr
BAonb 6eperoe
Ten:ut, sHr13
no
TeqeHtrc
or
Tay3p6prax, TnHynrlcb
nplcraHu
c
aoKaMtl
!4
rop-
t'oBbtMl/l cKnaaaMh. oaHaKo
oKono
20 ner Ha3aa Bce
pa6orbr
no
pa3rpy3Ke
roproBbrx
cyAoB 6blnfi
nepeHe-
ceHbr
B
ycTbe
Tel4sor. C
rex nop xn3Hb B
!,oKnaHA3e
clara nocTeneHHo
vracaTb,
60nbL!xHcTBo
aoKoB
1.4
cKnaaoB 6hrro
3aKpbrTo
(nhuth
r43peaKa oHl4 ucnonb.
3oBanhc6
KaK K HonaB nboHhr), 3AaH[F BeruraJM
r,4
pa3pyuran14ch.
BeoHVts
xugHu
B
gror
HeKoraa oxtaBneHHbri
paioH
peluhna
co3AaHHaF B 1981
roAy Kopnopaqxa
no
pa3Bhr4lo
Aornanaaa.
[1pr
perorcrpyrcqlru
6ar.
nepcKoi
Ha6epexHoi
apxhreKTopbr
v npoeKTxpoBU.l14-
KH
peur.nx
nphAarb ei oco6sri o6pa:
a
,,coaepxaqt
e",
Koropbte BbrToAHo orrhqanh
6br ee or
Apyr
x
pereHe
p!4pyeMhrx
KBapranoB
patoHa
npexae
acero
xapaKTe
poM
3acrpoiKl4: BMecro
cKonreH/F
HoBhlx o(pl4coB,
KOH K
ypl pyrou.I4x
apyr
c
apyroM
B cTpeMleHt4l4
K
pen
pe3eHTaTrBHOCT|4,
hnfi Xe
CTpOrlenbcTBa,,KBapTanoB
cnaneH" B 3Tot nnorHo;3acrpoiKe
Ha rcxHoM 6epery
TeMsur
6urao
peueHo
MaKcqManbHo coxpaHurb cno.
xt4ButyrocF
cTpyKTypy KBapTaJra
er MacuTa6bt ero 3a.
crpoiKr4
l, co3Aarh MHoro$yHKtllroHanbHyto
3oHy
c
pa3BtarbrMt4
06ulecrBeHHbrM14
npocrpancreaull. B
pe.
3ynbrare
peHoBaqqh
KBaprana saecu 6yayr
coceacr.
BOBarb x4nbre
aoMa.
oskcbt,
rocr14Hr,4ubr,
[eTcK!ri
rearp, cryileuvecrue
06ulexhrrF, cryAnr,l.MacrepcKfi
e,
pecropaHbr,
xyaoxecrEeHHhre ranepex,
Mara314Hbr, My.
3et, K14HOTearp.
no MHeHtato
apxHTeKTypHbtx KpxrlKoB,
6arnep.
cKaF
Ha6epexHaa
6'aroAapF
TaKoMy
peuJeHfirc
3acr-
poiu.l14KoB
6y4er
,,no4o6ra a6rxaHurc
cBexero Berpa"
B cpaBHeHhu
c
apyr!4Mr4
KBapTanaM[
AoKnaHA3a.
Oa.
HaKo,,pex[ccep"
Bcex npoeKTHo-crporrenbHbtx
pa6or
B 3ToM KBaprane, hH14qharop co3aaHlaf, l\4y3en
aLl3aiHa
(h
oAHoBpeMeHHo
-
rnaBa npoeKlHoi
SrapMbr
,.KoH-
pan
Pou-r")
cap T3peHc KoHpaH cnpaBeanhBo
3aMeqaer,
'1To
uAea cMeueH F
dVHKqrli
BoBce
He nBnaerca coB.
peMeHHbrM
+eHoMeHoM,
KaK
cql4TaloT
apxhTeKTophr 1,1
nnaHupoBu.lhKx, Ha
caMoM
Aene
oHa rxurb cneAyer 06-
pa3Lly
nto60ro eBponeicKoro ropoAKa.
Csp i. Kor.rpan
yxe
HecKonbKo
aecnruneryi
co
AeicrByer
pa3aurxro
aHrrriicKoro
guaaina.
On
-
ela-
LeJteq
cer[ Mara3hHoB
KoHropcKoi Me6enu, a raKxe
Mara3xHa Me6enh
h
AoMauHe;
yrBaph
,,Xg6urer",
cblrpaBuxx 3aMeTHyro
ponb
B MoaepH[3aquu cTI4nF
6pyraHcKr4x
ooficoB 14
xunurx rnr'epcepo8.
,qnF
npo.
oyxAeH!4n
o6utecrBeHHoro r4HTepeca K
Au3aiHy,
pac.
KphrT|4F
ero
pon
B
pa3BuTr414
KynbTypbt,
npoMbtLu,leH.
Hocrl4, ToproBnu BenuKo6p[TaHn14
Koapan
ocnoean
npocBerurenbcKylo
u 6rarorBopl,rrenbHylo
opraHx3a-
qurc
-
Oona Koxrpana-Kpgi,le
roro.
oH
cran cnoHco.
poM
ranepex
flpoMbrru6erroro
4naaira ,,6o
nepxaye",
18
E
ffi#ffi
pacnoraraBueicF
B Te roaht
B
6btEUei
KOTenbHOt;
lVysen
Btxroptau
u Ane6epra.
Bvecre
c
Atpercrooonl
,,6ohnepxayza"
CrhseHoid
Eeirnfi
(enocreAcrerh
nep_
BbrM
AupeKropoM
My3eF
Ax3aiHa) oH
opraH!43oBan
B
80-e roAgr
MHoxecrBo
npo6neMHbtx
BbtcraBoK,
cnoco6_
cTByhoulyx
noHriMaH14K, pa3'||4'{HbtX
aCneKToB
coBpeMeH_
HOrO
npoMbtulleHHOrO
AV3ai,Ha,
sOpM[poBaHhho
KoH_
qenqrlh
u
SoHAoB
6y4yu1ero
vyeen.
_ 9t""ar""""
4ln
Myeea
Ax3aiHa
nocrpoiKa py-
6exa
50-60-x
roaoB
-
npocroe
rpex3raxHoe
3aaHhe
_
HeBbrFoaHo
oTnrttalacb
oT cBol.4x
Bt4KTOp14aHCK14X
l7|
34aapAraHcKt4x
coceAei,
nogroMy
6btna noABeprHyra
AoBonbHo
peLurrefl
bHoli peKoHcrpyKu14h.
npx
coxoaHe_
Hl4h
crpyKTyphr
6eperoeoro
+acaAa,
cocroFBuJeTo
,13
cTyneHqaTblx
Teppac,
x cxeMbt
nIIaHa,
,,nponvcKapule_
To"
cKBo3h
nepBbli
3Tax
crapyrc ynoqKy
[.lea Tevs,
Kopnyc
6bln
,,pa3Aer"
Ao
6eroHHoro
KapKaca.
AnE
Ao_
cruxeHha
onTl4Mar6Hoi
Bl,tcoTbt
gKcnc|3hrll4oHHhtx
no.
MeqeH4i
nptunocb
pa3pyLul4Tb
nepeKpbtrl4e
Mexlv
BTOpbfM
h TpeTbtM
3TaXaMt1,
v Haa
3TtnM,
eahHbrM
Te_
neph,
06beMoM,
Ha
npexHei
xputute.6srl
ao:eeaen
cranbHoi
KapKac,
ganonserrsri
nerKrMh
naHerFMh,
c4opnupoeaeutui
noMeuleHlae
BepxHefi
ranepeh.
KpoMe
HoBoi
qeHTpanbHoi
recrHlrtlbr
_
cBeroBo-
ro
,.Konoaua",
aatoulero ecTecTBeHHOe
OCBeUIeHl,e
oK_
pyxatoqhM
npocTpaHcrBaM
Ha
BCeX
ypoBHax,
KoMno_
3hLll4F
3AaHUF
6srna
4onorteua BhtcTynaptul4Mu
necT.
Hl4qHbtM4
6aL!HAM[.
oAHa
l43
HXX,
MaCKUpytoqaF
60_
KoBoi
OacaA
coceAHero
crcrala,
6urna
o6rrrqoEaHa
cTeKIIO6nOKaMU,
Ha Hei
BepT'|KatbHo paglonoxeHa
HaAnrcb
c
Ha3BaHueM vy:ea.,flpyraa
6au.lHa
-
dnaHKt-
pyroqaa
rraaHbth
BXoa,
aeMoHcTp!4pyer npa3aHxgH6te
aKceccyapbt
l4HTepHaql4oHaIbHOfO
CTl4,lF:
HaBec,
aBa
6arKoHq
Ka ra
$raruro<.
Boo6ule.
crhn
crl4,{ecKaff
6nta3ocrb
HoBoro
rroHAoHcKoto
My3el
MexBoeHHoMy
,,fepol,rrecKoMy nepxoay"
apxxreKTypbt
npoaEnFeTca
noBceMecTHo:
B
xecTKoi
TeoMeTprl,{HocTl,l
Ky6uqecKhx
o6leMoB
14
rop43oHTanFx
rnaBHoro,
,,peqnoro,, 6aca-
aa,
e 6enusHe
creH
(cHapy>Kt,
ra
enyrpra)
.
noronKoE,
oKoHHbtx paM,
BHyTpeHHrrx
q
HapyxHbrx
orpaxaeHui.
B
OTKpOBeHHO
MOpCKOM,,,rOpa6enutov"
xapaKTepe
coopyxeHrF.
Eeflr3Ha
cKpoMHo
aononHeHa
cepbtMx
roHaMh
rpaH
Ta
Ha BXoAHoi
nnardopMe,
MpaMopHoro
nola
B BecTq6rc'le
k KoBpoBbtx
noKpbtll4i
B
HeKOTO-
pbrX
noMeuleH14FX.
E4raucteernuri
XpoMaT14ttecKhli
3neMeHT
B KOnOp[Ie
3AaHIF
_
CaMsti
vouttturi
a
Espone
rpyaoeoi
nu$r.
<oroprri
noAHrMaer
no
BOCTO'{HOMy
dacaay
IFxerbte
3KcnoHaTbt
B
86rcTa_
Bo'rHbte
noMeu.leH[F
BepxHt4x
graxei.
C rerKo;
pyKh
oAHoro
q3
pyroao4rlrenei
+upM6t,.KoHpaH
poul,,
oH
6brn
Ha3BaH,.3
r,E
nucv\Kui1
KpacHbli".
-
no
nepeotavanbHoMy
3aMbrcny
co3Aarenei
My_
3et4
AOIIXeH
6btn
Bo6paT6
B
Ce6n
,,vl,eu
14
O6teKT6y',
ah3aiHa, HO
OpqeHTrrpoBaHHbte
Ha MaccoBbti
npoMb[u-
19