uniform throughout the product. This is true if
products are dipped or injected with the liquid
smoke, but not if liquid smoke is only sprayed on to
the product surface.
0050 The composition of commercial liquid smoke can
vary widely, depending on the method of manufac-
ture. Natural smoke extracts, synthetic smoke flavors,
and substances unconnected with smoke, such as yeast
derivatives but with a smoky flavor or smell, are used.
0051 The use of liquid smoke also reduces the undesirable
PAH levels in smoked foods. The European Scientific
Committee for Food, in its Directorate-General Indus-
try Guidelines (1995) established that smoke flavor-
ings (liquid smoke) added to a food product must
assure a level lower than 0.03 mg of benzopyrene per
kilogram and less than 0.06 mg of benzoanthracene,
another PAH compound, per kilogram.
0052 In the meat industry, liquid smoke is commonly
used in place of traditional smoke. However, smoke-
flavored fish represents a small percentage of the total
smoked fish industry output.
Smoked Food Products Quality and Safety
Microbiological Safety
0053 The intrinsic microbiological stability of smoked
foods is dependent on the ingredients, additives, and
processes. In one extreme are traditional products
usually heavily cured and smoked, which can be
stable for many months at ambient temperatures; at
the other extreme, there are lightly cured and smoked
products, whose stability is dependent on extrinsic
factors such as refrigeration, vacuum, or gas packing.
0054 The length of the smoking process for cold-smoked
products is much longer than for hot-smoked prod-
ucts, but a pasteurization temperature is not achieved
in any stage of the process. Thus, the temperatures
and times used in processing cold-smoked products
are very favorable for the proliferation of food spoil-
age and food poisoning types of microorganisms.
0055 Most of the commercialized smoked products in
Western countries are sold vacuum-packed and stored
at refrigeration temperatures, and so spoilage and
food poisoning flora of the finished products are
mainly anaerobic or microaerophilic, and psychro-
trophic or psychrophilic.
0056 Cold-smoking, or any smoking process where tem-
peratures in the interior of the foodstuff do not reach
50
C for a significant period of time, will have a
different residual postsmoking microflora than those
hot-smoked products where a high internal tempera-
ture is reached.
0057 The temperature achieved during hot-smoking kills
vegetative microorganisms but not all spores, so the
most probable spoilage agents will be spore formers or
postsmoking contaminants. Refrigeration of hot-
smoked fish greatly reduces the number of organisms
able to grow and lengthens the shelf-life of the product.
0058Cold-smoked products will contain a microbial
flora representative of that of the raw material. The
salt in the water phase must be high enough to inhibit
the growth of Clostridium botulinum (3%), but
this will not stop the growth of spoilage bacteria.
Immediately after vacuum packing, bacterial counts
in cold-smoked salmon, commonly range between
10
4
and 10
5
g
1
, and at the end of the shelf-life (6
weeks), the product typically contains a microflora
dominated by lactic acid bacteria at levels of 10
7
–
10
9
g
1
. The use of drying and/or salt to lower the
water activity and smoke to add chemical preserva-
tives limits the types of microorganisms capable of
growth, and the production process affects the micro-
bial flora present on the product; therefore, both of
these affect the spoilage patterns. Spoilage needs to be
defined carefully for each product.
0059Listeria monocytogenes has been found consist-
ently in smoked fish products. Nitrites, usually
added to smoked meat products, are known to inhibit
growth of C. botulinum and also can inhibit L. mono-
cytogenes growth. (See Listeria: Properties and
Occurrence.) Nitrites also can be added to cheese to
prevent very late fermentation and gas production by
Clostridium tyrobutyricum or C. butyricum.
0060For C. botulinum, levels of salt higher than 3% in
the water phase together with refrigerated storage can
prevent growth and toxin production in cold-smoked
fish products, even when nitrites are not added. How-
ever, with respect to L. monocytogenes, which is able
to grow at salt levels up to 10% and temperatures as
low as 1
C, when nitrites are not allowed in fish
products (EU) there is no step in the cold-smoked
process that is able to prevent its growth.
0061The International Commission for Microbiological
Specifications for Foods recognized that numbers of
L. monocytogenes not exceeding 100 g
1
at the time
of consumption are of low risk to the consumer.
Therefore, for ready-to-eat, not heat-treated, foods,
where the presence of L. monocytogenes cannot
be fully avoided, the critical points are to limit the
occurrence of L. monocytogenes in foods but, more
importantly to control its growth and survival in
order to keep levels below the 100 g
1
at the point
of consumption. This policy is followed by some
European countries but is considered a hazard
by USA, which maintains a zero-tolerance policy
regarding Listeria incidence in ready-to-eat foods. If
a zero-tolerance policy were to be established in EU
countries, where nitrites or other antimicrobial addi-
tives are not allowed to be added to fish products, this
SMOKED FOODS/Production 5307