although these substrates can easily be accommodated in the pores of MCM-41. No
mechanistic interpretation for this surprising observation was offered by the authors.
Another variation on this theme involves straightforward doping of methyl-
modified silica, referred to as ormosil, with tetrapropylammonium perruthenate
via the sol-gel process [57] (see Table 5.4). A serious disadvantage of this system is the
low turnover frequency (1.0 and 1.8 h
1
) observed for primary aliphatic alcohol and
allylic alcohol respectively.
Little attention has been paid to the mechanism of perruthenate-catalyzed alcohol
oxidations [58]. Although TPAP can act as a three-electron oxidant (Ru
VII
! Ru
IV
),
the fact that it selectively oxidizes cyclobutanol to cyclobutanone and tert-butyl
phenylmethanol to the corresponding ketone, militates against free radical inter-
mediates and is consistent with a heterolytic, two-electron oxidation [58, 59].
Presumably, the key step involves b-hydride elimination from a high-valent, for
example, alkoxyruthenium(VII) intermediate followed by reoxidation of the lower-
valent ruthenium by dioxygen. However, as shown in Figure 5.12, if this involved the
Ru(VII)/Ru(V) couple, the reoxidation would require the close proximity of two
ruthenium centres, which would seem unlikely in a polymer-supported catalyst. A
plausible alternative, which can occur at an isolated ruthenium center, involves the
oxidation of a second molecule of alcohol, resulting in the reduction of ruthenium(V)
to ruthenium(III), followed by reoxidation of the latter to ruthenium(VII) by dioxygen
(see Figure 5.12).
More detailed mechanistic studies are obviously necessary in order to elucidate the
details of this fascinating reaction. It is worth noting, in this context, that the reaction
of TPAP with 2-propanol was found to be autocatalytic, possibly because of the
formation of colloidal RuO
2
[60]. Another possible alternative is one involving the
initial formation of oxoruthenium(VI), followed by cycling between ruthenium(VI),
ruthenium(IV), and possibly ruthenium(II).
We note, in this context, that James and coworkers [61] showed that a trans-
dioxoruthenium(VI) complex of meso-tetrakismesitylporphyrin dianion (tmp) oxi-
dizes isopropanol, in a stoichiometric reaction, with concomitant formation of a
dialkoxyruthenium(IV)-tmp complex (Eq. (5.8)).
O
Ru
VII
O
H
O
O
O
Ru
VI
Ru
VII
or
H
Ru
V
OH
2 Ru
V
+ O
2
Ru
VI
O
2
+
+
Ru
III
+
Ru
III
+ O
2
Ru
V
Ru
VII
O
Ru
V
O
OO O
O
OH
Figure 5.12 Proposed catalytic cycle for reoxidation of perruthenate in the oxidation of alcohols.
160
j
5 Modern Oxidation of Alcohols using Environmentally Benign Oxidants