868 Diesel engine system design
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
requires higher engine delta P to drive in HPL EGR. Modern diesel engines
need to drive a high EGR rate and sufcient air–fuel ratio from peak torque
to rated power in order to meet the stringent emissions requirements relating
to NO
x
and soot. If a xed-geometry turbine is used, with the lowest level of
EGR system ow restriction (i.e., with the EGR valve fully open), the turbine
area is usually sized small enough to drive the required EGR rate at peak
torque. The turbine usually needs to be wastegated at rated power in order
to avoid over-boosting the engine on peak cylinder pressure and/or exhaust
manifold pressure. The smaller the turbine area, the more wastegating is
required at high speeds. Compared to a VGT (without wastegating) to deliver
the same boost pressure, wastegating has to use a higher turbine pressure
ratio which compensates for the loss of the turbine mass ow rate in order
to maintain the same turbine power. This is the reason why wastegating
causes higher engine delta P and BSFC than VGT. Therefore, by the nature
of engine–turbocharger matching with a xed turbine area, there is a trade-
off between low-speed and high-speed performance in pumping loss and
system efciency. VGT may solve the dilemma by using exible turbine area
at different engine speeds, but there are often penalties in turbocharger cost
and durability as well as a reduction in turbine efciency at the very closed
or wide open VGT vane opening. The role of intake throttle is to reduce
excessively high air–fuel ratio at peak torque or high speed and low load, or
slightly increase EGR rate at a penalty of throttling loss. An excessively high
air-fuel ratio may cause high NO
x
and high engine delta P. This is usually
because the turbocharger efciency is too high. It should be noted that in
most applications the air–fuel ratio at peak torque is short compared to the
ideal requirement instead of being excessively high.
In summary, when the engine delta P is insufcient to drive EGR at low
speed and high load, the following measures can be considered: (1) reducing
the ow restriction of the EGR valve and the EGR cooler (e.g., using parallel
instead of serial EGR coolers); (2) using a check valve or a reed valve to
harvest EGR ow pulsation and prevent EGR backow loss; (3) using a
small turbine area or a VGT to raise the engine delta P; (4) using the intake
throttle to lower the intake manifold pressure; (5) using a venturi device to
locally reduce the static pressure at the EGR merging location in order to
induce the EGR ow into the intake manifold; or (6) using an EGR pump.
The weakness of the HPL EGR system in heavy-duty diesel engines is
that a large EGR ow rate often needs to be driven by the engine delta P
at peak torque. An improved EGR-driving system needs to provide a better
way to pump EGR in order to reach a lower engine delta P and higher
turbocharger efciency. One possible solution is to use the LPL EGR or a
dual-loop EGR system to help EGR driving at peak torque or low speeds
so that a larger turbine area can be selected in order to avoid high pumping
loss at high speeds. However, it should be noted that an excessively large
Diesel-Xin-13.indd 868 5/5/11 12:04:43 PM