Щавелев Д.С., Васильев Ю.С., Претро Г.А., Резниковский А.Ш. и др. Гидроэнергетические установки
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
:l? -l:AoBbrp
a6orxa
3Hef
rr4r4
Hs-sa
cpa-
(r.rH
MelKeHHr4rfi
nepuoA-.
B
ueJroM-no
rrlepe
;:?.;ffi#J
il
i:ifi'
.h,l?t;*
;;;p;:
o6xoAuuo
orpeAeJrr4rb
3aBr.rcprN,{ocrb
3,1Noo
3,
+,D.L3rac
\------T---:
cpeAHeMHoronerHefi
elipa6orxlr
3Hep-
rHH
3,
H
o6ecneqeHuoir
MoulHocru
1/.u
B pacrIeTHoM
MaToBoAHOM
|OAV
OT
KO_
crBeHHoe.
3HaqeHHe
HMeer
HsMeHeHHe
| _
=-'--.i.
'----
rapaHTr4fiHoro
Hanopa
H
ru,
KoropbrM
o6uqso
cr{Hraercr
Hanop
3HM
'>i<
,H--^
i
i \
)KeHH
pacrlerHoro
MSJroBo[Hof
r
-4raa
i
r
3aeHcHlaocrrr
3r,
Noo
H
xoHeqHofi
rny6raHtr
cpa6orxr
xpaHHJrHUra
lrn,
T.
e.
or
ero
n(
eMKocrH
Vnoaesn,
rpeAcraBJr(
PI4c'
l8-l'
n:nr-'efiTrrrrv n
I
I
B
ocHoBy
Aa"r
suerituux
p
VH
t,
lvnorr",
unu
AoJr>r{Hbr
6urt
rrolox{eHbr
Kpi4BL
II_
BoAoxpaHHnurrta
npoeKrupyeuori
f3c.
llpnr
rexHuKo-sKoHoMHr{ecKoM
o6o-
cHoBaHHH
h* 14
Vnon""n
yquTbrBarcTcfl
Bce
nocJreAcrBus
yBeJrHr{eHHfl
cpa6orxu
rvrou{s6g1p1
npoer(rHpyeruofi
f3c;
vN
_ro
)Ke
1.nr
ncex
fOC
)a
cHHlKaeTcff
pacnoJrafaeMaff
MOUIHOCTb
Ittt.
f.nR
KoMrreuc
aLWu
cHHX(eH""lrenol
lMaTpHBaTb
YBr,.nuqeHr4e
1iHAMeTpa
BCeX
)JrHrIeHHe
3arpar
A3--,,
oueHb
qacTo
oKa_
ap
Horo
yBe"THqe
HHn
3arp
ar
no
fOC:
AS,-A3r*A3r*Age.
Ecnu
[eJrecoo6paeHo
yBeflr4r{eHue
ycraHoBneuuoli
MicrrHocru
HH}Ke
pacnofio-
xeHHbIx
f3c
KacKaAa'
ro
HaAo
yqecrb
npupaqeHue
3arpar
nA*..^^np'pailreHue
BblrecHfleuofi
I\IoIrIHocrt4
14
nupadorKu
TeIIJroBbrx
g/reKTp(icraHqrfi"eneproc'creMbr
onpeAeJlflercfl
yBeflHr{eHHeM
MourHoc
rH
.H
eupa6orx'
eHep
ruw
.npoeKT'pyenaofi
f3c
H
Bcex
ocraJlbHbtx
r,Apocranqnft
^u.iuau.'^iourrercrBeHHo
aKoHoMHro
SaTpaT
no
gHeprocHcreMe
o6oeHar{HM
qepe3
A3-..
u.
onruuaJrbHafi
r,rry6uHa
cpa-
6orxu
u
BeJIHT{HHa
noJle3Hol?
euxocru
BoAoxpa
HHnHrr\a
Moryr
6rrrl
onpeAeJreusi
no
saBucHMocrr{
(
I
B-
I)
anu
(
I
B_
I
a).
'
o6nrquo:
crpoure.trl'crno
r'Apocranura.l
1
acKara
npor{3BoAr.rrcff
B
onpeAeJreH-
Hblt
noc/leAoBareJlbHocr';
BoBMox{Ha
raKxe
pasHoBpeMeHHocrb
B
crpo'TeJrbcTBe
-l-
I
AJ*u.
H No6
*
I
nffnu.,
yrrr4rbr-
L
--y,-_-
i
Barorrlue
eeQexr,
noryqaenaufi
Ha
Apy_
rHx
rHApocraHUHflx
KacKaAa
or
cpa6or-
PHc.
l8-1.
3asncfl
Nrocrr
cDenHeM'oro.ner*pfi
333
f3C
H 3aMeHfleMorl
K3C.
I-loErouv
B
Sopru."-n'y
(
I
B-
l
)
Ao,rr>xHrr
noAcraBrrffrbcfl
Be.rrnqaHsl A3,
a n
QopMyJry
(lB-la)
Ar(
u
A,H,
noAcr{HraHHbre
c
yqerorvr
QaKropa
BpeMeHH.
flpu
oKoHrIare",'IbHoM
nlr6ope
h*
H
Vno-rye*,
neo6xoAra,r,ro
yqgTbrBaTb
[epcneK-
THBbI
CTpOHTeJIbCTBa
BepXOBbIX
BOAOXpaLTHJTHLTJ.,
nOCJre
coopylKeHHfl
r{OTopbrx
MolKer
oKa3arbcfl
UeJrecoo6pasHlrM
yMeHbIUeHHe
r"ry6HHbr
.cp
a6orxu
u
nonegHori
eMKocrH
BoAoxpaHH.,'rHuIa
npoeKrnDyevrofi
fAC.
E.
Bur6op
emrocrn
14 rnydrxu
GpaGorKH
BoAoxpaHnnnqa
npH
K0MI|AeKCH0M
Heno,|bs0BitHHr{
B0A0T0Ka
l1pr.r KoMflJIeKcHoi',:
\HcnoJrb3oBaHHH
BoAoroKa
ueo6xoAr.tlto
yqecrb
r-iocJIer-
crBHfl
yBeJrHqeHr4fl
r;ry6Huu
cpa6orxu
BoAoxpaHr.rJrHura
nnf
Bcex
vqacrHHKOB
KoMrJIeKca
.jleprerHKu,
HppHraI\HH,
Bo[Horrc
TpaHcnopra
H r.
A.
tlp6
aroM
noKa3are"rrn
f3C
no NIouIHocrH
H
Bblpa6orNe
oHr3prHH
6yAyr
HHbTMH
noroMy,
rrro
KoMnJIeKcHoe peryJII.IpoBaHI{e
croKa
6yLer
orrHr{arbcfl
or
aHeprerHqecKoro
pef
yJrHpoBaHHfl.
VsenHqeHue
3arpar
A3*
noAcqnrbrBaercfl
ro rHApoy3ay
(n.rrornHe,
BoAoxpa-
HHJIHuly,
fAC,
tu,,'llo3!
H
T.A.) u eceri,r
conyrcrB)/rouluM
coopylKeHnrM
KoMn.ryeKca
(nuuun
sfleKrponepeAaq,
MarucrpanlHufi
HppHraunogntrfi
KaHaJr,
HacocHbre
CTaHIIHH
H T.
n.).3xouoMufl
3arpar
yquTbrBaeTcfl
no
Bcei\,{
3aMeHfleMbrM
o6rexralt
c
Hx
conyrcrByrouluMH
coopy)KeHHflMH.
llp"paureHue
3r{oHoMr4r4
sarpar
no
3aMeHfieMoMy
3HeprerHqecKoMy
o6texry
o6osHarruM
rrepes
A3..
s,
a
AJrfl
ocraJrbHbrx
yqacrKoB
KoMrrJreKcHoro
HcrroJrb3oBaHr,rfl
-
r{elpes
A3.*,.
OnrHnaaJlbHafl
r"'ry6HHa
cpa6orxa
H
BeJrHrrHHa
no,reEHofi
eMKocrH
BoAoxpa-
HI4JIHllla
MolKer
6urt
oilpeAe"'reHa
iro
3aBHcHMocrH
(
18-2)
HIu4
(
18-2a)
B.
Bnnsnne
safineHlrr
B0[0xpaHHnnI4a
Ha
BH60p
ero
eMiloGTt{
BseerueHHble
H
BJIeKoMbte pexofi
no
AHy
HaFrocbr
oceAaror
B
BoAoxpaHHJrHU{e
u
3aHJIrIor
ero.
Ha
fopHbIX peKax
cpaBHHTeJrbHo
He6o,nlurue
BoAoxpaHHJrHUa
saHJlflIorcfl
olleHb 6ltcrpo,
I{HorAa B
Ter{eHHe
2-3
Jrer.
Ha
panHgHgbrx
peKax
c Ma/lbIM
o6teuoM
rBepAoro
croKa cpoK
3auileHuq
MeprBoro
o6reua
KpynHbrx
BoAoxpaHHJII4III
cocraBrlset
50-100 ra
6o.nee
Jrer.
flpr
ntr6ope
r,rry6uHu
cpa6orxu
BoAoxpaHH/IHIi\a
onpeAeJlflercfl
cpoK sauJreHr{fl
e:ro
MeprBoro
o6r6rr,1a.
flpu
Kopor-
KoM
cpoKe
3avJIeHHfl,,
HanpHMep
2-3 roAa,
H€ HMeer
cMbrcJra
sarny6nsrr
ebAo-
npI{eMHbIe
orBepcrufl
rLIApocraHWu,
raK
KaK
orreHb
cKopo
rrorpe6yercx
ttpuMe-
Hflrb
cnerrHaJrbHbre
Mepbr
no
yAaJreHHro
HaHocoB
ilepeA
BOAOIpHeMHHKOM.
TaXUru
o6pasona,
H& ropHbrx peKax
r.rry6aua
cpa6orxa
lr
no"rre3Has
eMKocrb
Moryr
orpa-
Hl4r{HBarbcfl
no ycJioBHflM
3aHJreHHn
BqAoxpaHHJrHUIa.
Ha
paBHHHHbrx
peKax
npH
cpoKe
3aHJIeHHff
MeprBoro
o6teua
50-10C)
ner
crrgTaror,
rrro
3aHJreHHe
He
orpaHurruBaer
r.uy6uny
cpa6orru
BoAoxpaHuJrurqa.
18.6.
ONPEIE'IEHHE
SK(IHOMHIIECKOf,
SOOEKTI{EHOCTH
IHIPOSJIEKTPOCTAHqHf,
SxouotuuqecKas
eQsexrnnHocrb
fOC o[peAeJlrercrr
\Jrr
BbrrcHeHHH
uelecoo6pasHocrr.r ee
cTpoHTeJIbCTBa
H
BblfBJIeHHf
Hanilyq[Iefo
cOqeTaHHfl
Te[JrioBbrx
H
rHApaBJrHqecKHx
SJIeKTpOCTaH-
uHfi
s
sHeprocHcreMe.
flpra
o6ocrroBaHuu
crpoare.nrcrea
fOC
onpeAe"rrflercr
3KoHoMgr{ecKan'aQeex-
TliBHocrb
KanHTaJlonnoxeHufi_
(,
B
ruApooHepferuKy,
T.
e,,
KanuTaJroBJro>xeHufi
B
nJIorHHy,
BoAo-
xpaHHJIHure,
3AaHI4e
l3C
c
o6opyaoraHl,IeM,
AepHBaIrHoHHHe
coopyxeHHfl,
H
T.
n.,
BKJrIoqafl
KanH-
TaJIoBJIox(eHHl
B BbIcoKoBoJIbrHbIe
JIHHHH sJleKTponepeAaq
H
noAcraHrIHH.
Kanura.noBJroxeHr.rg
B flocroflHnufi
noceJloK
LI
s
o6tertrl,
nepeAaBaeMbte
ApyrlIM
BeAoMcrBaM,
He
BxoAqr
B BeJrHrrHHy
Kr.
IIpu
onpeAeJleHItI'I
gKoHoMHrlecrofi
eQ$extunHocru
f_HAp0r3HeprerHriecKoro
crpor.rrenbcrBa
ireo6-
xoAHMo raK)Ke
3Harb
BertItIHHy
e>KeroAHbtx
H3Aep:xex
Hr-n;ru axcnnyarauuu
nepeurc.neHHbrx
Bbrrrre
coopyx{eHufi
n o6opyAoBaHlrfl
. flpn
KoMnJreKcHorv
ACJICHHC
MC}KAY
BCCMH
YI{ACTHHKAMU
KOMTIJICK(
rnApoy3Jra.
B arou
c,r,yvae
s ^(,
BxoArrr
r}nilb
qz
{uury
H
T. tr.,
?
B H,
-
cooTBercrByroqafl
tqacr
B
pacverax
onpeAeJrrror
cpaBHaTe.nliyro u o6uty
cTaHuHu.
334
cpaauureJlbHar
sKoHoMHqecKafl
aQ$exr.unHocrb
fOC
onpeAeJrsercr
no
cpaBHeHHro
c Hau6onee
axoHotrll't'{Hofi
saMeHsel}'{ofi
sJleKrpocranquer?,_a
KariecrBe
foropoli
oO-oiu"o'nf"i"*uara"
coBpe-
MeHHaq
KoHAeHcauHoHHatl
sJleKrpocraHuHs.
flo
cyueclBy
paciuarpanulorcfl
nBa
BapHaHTa
pa3-
BurHfl
3HepfocHcreMbl
-
c
f3C
H
3aMeHseuofi
K3c
-
npH
orlprHaKoBbrx
ypoBHsx
ad,re6rponorpe6-
JICHHg.
(oa0SuuHeHr
cpaB HHrerlbHofi
eSQexrHBHocrH
noAcq
urbrBaercH
no
Qopruy,re:
l,l |.r
E-t13.3-(13
- n
pEl-----l-=tril,
K^-k
r\9
r\3.3
rne
K,
V
H=-npHBeAeHHble
KanHTaJIoBJIo>KeHHfl
H
ex{erollrble
Ii3Aepx(KH
f3C
c JTVgHflMH
3neKTpo-
nepeAaq
H
noAcTaHqI{flMH;
(..
r
-
npHBeAeHHbIe
KanI'iTaJIoBJto>KeHut
no
3aMeHqervror?
K3C,
nL4-
HHqM
3JleKTponepeAaq'
noAcraHuuql'{,
TonJILIBHOi4
6ase
H pa3BHTHro
rpaHcnoprr{brx
nyrer?;
H".,-
rlpuBeneHHbte
elKeroAHbre
H3Ae_p_I(KH
no
K3C,
THHHqN{
gJreKTponepeAar{
H
noAcraHUHH.
B sroilt
cryr{ae pacxoAbt
KOC
no
ronJrHBy
noAcr{HTbrBa}olcfl
no
ce6ecrogMocrg
saMbrKarouero
ToIIJIHBa
u
ce6ecroHMocrH
ero
llepeBo3xtl.
genr
6onure
Be.rrHquna
xoaQQrauuenri
E, ffi-.rAp;-
sJleKrpocra
HuHfl
eQ$exrunHee.
Ecnu
pacxoAbl
no routt{By
[oAcri'TblBalorcq
no
pacrler]FlbrM
3arparaM
3aMbrKa'uero
Ton-
ilvBa,
a
ero
rpaHcnopr
-
no
rapuSy,
To onpeAe"rtsercs
roe$SuqueHr
cHulKeHr.rfl
npHBeAeHHbrx
pacqeTHbrx
3aTpaT:
(l
8-3)
(18-4)
(
18.5)
ErK,
*
k|,
<
1,0,
E
rR'".
,
*7
".
,
rAe
K3.
s
I]pHBeAeHHbIe
KanHTaJIOB'''IO>KeHI{fl
TOJIbKO
IIO
Sal\IeHgeMOIi
gr,teKTpoCTaHIIHH,
.11HHHqM
3JleKTponepe.{aqH
u
[oAcraHu
uav;
H'u.
o
npHBeAeHHbte
ex{eroAHbre
H3Aep)KKH
no 3ar,{eHfleMbrM
K3c,
JIHHH'NI
3JIeKTponePeAaq
H
noAcratllrHflIll
np'
noAcqere
pacxoAoB
no
ro[JrHBy
no
pacqerHbrM
3arpara[.r,
a nepeBo3oK
Ton.rrHBa
-
no rapraQy.
lulpocraHr\Htr
cqHTaercfl
reivr
eQQexranHee,
^r{eM
MeHsure
xoeeQiiqaenr
a
-.-
1,0.
O6uras 3KoHoMIzrIecKat
aQQexriroHocrb
fOC
xapaKrep"ey.r.ri
roeQ$uuui"io*,
peura6e.nr-
HOCTH:
rOC
B c'uyuae
HecoBepIIIeHcrBa
rapraQa
noJrb3yrorcff
yAeJrbHrbrMr.r
pacrrerHbrMu
3arparaM"
sj
Ha
sHeprHlo'
3allblKaloulyrc
s'nexrpo6aJlaHc
parloHa.
Be.rruuuna
,Sj
onpeAeJrrercs
xJrfl
HoBofi
i<gC
ilpll
noAcrlere
ee
H3AeplKeI{
no
pacqerHbrM
3arparaM
3aMbrKaroqefo
rorrJrHBa.
Cnoco6u
oIIpeAeJIeHIzff
exouotuuqecxoft
u44a^t"rHocrrr
AoJr]KHbr
coBeplreHcrBoBarbcfl
KaK
B oTHoueHI{H
MeToAoJIorHH'
TaK
I'I
npI{ yqere
pexuunblx
KarIecTB.cpaBH""uani*-inanrpo.rasqurl.
Hanpnltep,
Heo6xo4uMo
pelxuro
eonpoi
o6
onpe4eJreHxn
peH'ra6enbHocrg
np"uaaa"Hbrx
KarrHTa-
rroBrroxeHuir
K,
[cru.
Qopuynsr
(lg-lba)
u
1ta-tS; ].
oxoH'IareJlbHoe
peureHlre
o
crpo'TeJlbcrBe
rHAposneKTpocraHrl,H
rrp'H,Maercfl
flocJre
npo-
BeAeHHs
BcecropoHHero
aHa'uusar_flPH
sToM
cylqecrBeHHoe
3HarreHHe
HMeror
Bonpocbr
ocBoeHHfl
HoBbrx
pafiouon,
opoureHus
14 o6e.o4ueHun
saCyru"rruBbrx
paficlHon,
yryqilreHHn
LrJrH
yxyA[reHns
caHllrapHo-i.Hrl4eHHqecKHx
yc.uonutl
B
parioHe
3JIeKTpocraHr{au,
co3AaHHfl
H
O"traroycip'o-ri.r*
MecT_AJIr
OTAbtxa
HaceJreHHfl
Lr
cnopTa.
flpu o6ocHoBaHHu
crpoHTeJIbcrBa
HacocHo-aKKyMyJrHpyroqr:fi
u.nu
npHJrr.rBHofi
e.nexrpocraHrrHH
TaK>Ke
cpaBHHBaercff
ABa
BapHaHTa
pa3Bur?fl
sHeprocHcreMbt
--
c
npoexrnpyenrofi
ru4poeHeprer'-
'recxor:r
ycraHoBKolt
u
6es Hbe.
tlp^"
sroM
AOAIKHbT
yq,rbrBarbcfl
crreu'Qnxa
pa60rrr
npoe*r'pye-
t'tofi
f3V'
HanpHMep
pa6ora
HASC
Hoqblo
B
HacocHoM
pelKHMe,
qro
rroBbrrJaer
HorrHyro
Harpy3Ky
sHeprocHcTeMbr.
IOMHIICCKOI,I
O6OCHOBAHHH
CTPOHTCJIbCTBA
HACOCHO-
ff_
fff#
iall"
T'?,
iff
:,ffi
i,'#.,0#:
xff
f
:;
J_?{e!run
HASC
npn
pa6ore
ee
HacocoB;
{A3C
crpoflTcr
raabryp6r{HHbre
ycraHoBK
H,
a
AJtfl
py3KH
BMeCTo
BbrcoKoSKoHOMHrrHOfi
xpynno6.noq-
k,I.",'l?,i"'li#llffi
1."?#*#.lilililffi
;?;
acocHo-aKKyM'ynrpynqefi
sneKrpocr.anq,Ha.
335
'
18-?.
PACnPEIEIEHI,|E
SATPAT
B0.q0X03nnCTBEHH0r0 K0MnnEKCA
MEX.qY
ETO Y'{ACTHHKIAMH
Bce
BoAonorpe6nrenu
H
BoAonoJrb3oBareJrIi,
noryqaroturie aQ$err
or
KorunJreKca,
AoJriKHbr
n
ror?
uau
usoft l\{epe KoMneHcHpoBarb
sarparbr
KoMrr.rreKCuoro
r}tApo\'3JIa.
Kax
npanI.{JIo, B KoM-
n,rreKc
He
AoJrlKHbr
BKJrroqarbcff Te
orpac.[u, no'rpe6HocrH
Koropurx 6o,qee
gKoHol\{uqHo
yAoBJrerBo-
pflrorcfl BHe
KoMnJreKca.
BosnaoxHbr
ABa
noAXoAa r{
pacnpeAeJIeHH}o
3arpar
Kor\{nJIeKca:
l)
KoMn./reKcHlrfi
ru4poy3eJr
$uuaHcrtpyer
H
crponT
I\{r.rHlJcrepcrBo
r.rraBIIoro yqacrllul{a I{oM-
n"'reKca
u
npH
aKcnryararrLrrr
fntrpo!3",'ra
o6ecne.ruBaer 3a coorBercrBylor[yrc
nJrary
AJrs
Bcex
ocraJlb-
Hblx
yqacTrrHKoB
I{OMn,rreKCa
COf"rracoBaHHbre
ypoBIiH H pac}rollbl
IloAbl;
2)
Kax(Aoe
N,rr.IFrHcrepcrBo,
yqacrByloulee
B
KoMIL'IeKce,
npt.tHuMae'r
tta
ce6r
qacrb
I{anuraJlo-
eroxeHari
14 e){eroAHbrx
H3llep>Ker{ Korrn,IIeKcItoro
rHApo)i3JIa, coorBercrBytou{\rrc
noryqaeMoMy
HM eS$exry.
Bo
BTopoM cJryqae
Io,Tir{Ho
npoH3BoAHTbcrI
pacnpeAe,teHlie
KantiraJloerox{eHHll
u
elKefoAHbrx
H3AepxeK,
T. e.3arpar
Bo.loxo3flficrnensoro
l(oNlnJlexca
(BXI()
nrex<Ay
ero
yqacrHll-
KAM
I{.
Hau6o.nee
npocrbrM
oKa3btBaercfl ueroA
pacnpeIeJIeIIHff
3arpar Kotvln,'teKCHoro
f
IiApoy3,'Ia
npo[oprrHoHaJrbHo
HcrroJrb3yeMoruy
o6relry BoAbr. OAuaxo
3Tor I\,{eroA IIpHx{eH[{1\,r
JIHIU_I'
B
peAKI'tx
cflyr{arx,
KorAa,
Hanpr.rMep, fuApoy3e/r
crpollTcn
AJIfl
opouleHHfl
H
BonocHa6xeuHq.
Ecnu B Kol\4-
nJIeKc
BxoAr.rr
ruApogrrepferuKa,
To
yr(a3anHrtfi
MeroA
He luo;Ker 6urr
ilpHI\{eHeH, TaK KaI(
N{oulHocrb
u'
nrrpa6orKa
gJrer(Tpo3Heprura
f3C
3aBHcl.rr
He roJIbKo or
pzrcxora
BoAEI,
I{o
H
or
Hanopa.
Boaee
trrHpoKyro
o6nacrn
nprrrreHeHliq
Hr\{elor MeroIbI
pacnpeAe,,'IeHHq
sarpar
eo4oxosati-
cTBeHHOTO
KOMITJTeKCa
COOTBeTCTBeHHO
3riOHOMHqeCKOMli
eQ$eXry,
no.[yqaeN4or,Iy
efo
yqacTHHKaMH.
B
no4oxogqficrseHHsrii
Kor\{nJreric
Bxof
rtr
rHApoy3e,,r
H
conyrcrBy}oqIIe
coopyx{ellHfl,
Hanpt4r,rep
JrHHHfr,
gneKTponepeAaqH
or f3C
Ao
nprrei\ruotl
no4craHIIHH,
I\'IarucTpantuttft
HppHralll4ouHltft KaiIaJl
H.T.
n.
B
ru4poy3,'re
BbiAe"rrsror
o6u1ue
(nrorlrua,
BoAoxpar{HJrHure
u
r. n.)
tt orpacJleBble
coopyx<e-
HHq
(s4aHue
fOC, cyAoxoAHurrt
rii,trros
II T.
n.). Ey4eu
npul{eHtlTb
HHAeKcbI
AJlfl
Ko},:nJIeKCa
-
K, ruApoy3Jra
-
r, conyrcrByrotrruX
coopviKeHwit-
c. floxcuurarlHbre
c
)'qeroxr
cpaxropa
tspeMeIIt't,
T. e. npHBeAeHHbre
K
oAHorvry
roAy Kanr.rraJroBJrox(eHl4rr
K,
e>xeroAHbre
Ll3AepxiKtt
I,l
u
pacl{ernbre
sarparrr
3
6ylerrr
orMeqarb
qeproi'{
cBepxy.
llpu arux
o(5o3F{arreHHtx
Anr
BoAoxosfli'rcrneunoro
KOMn,'IeKCa
IIO,IIyr{HM
IIpI'IBeAerlHble
KaIl]TaJIOBJIO]KerIHtI:
K,,:,<r+X1f.'
nPIrBeAeHHble
ex{efoAHr,le
Ll3AepxiKl{:
H
npr.rBeAeHHbre
pacqeTHble
3arparbl:
3x:En,(n*H*,
Twi:
Hci
*
Hor
t *
poK-oA
t,
a:oTHOclIMbIe
H3Aepx(KlI ruApoy3ila
T'l*:l,trIDnrt
( I
B-6)
(
1B-7)
(
I
8-B)
(18'9)
(r8-
l0
)
rfie
:
E;
-
HopMarasFbrft
xoe$$uuueHT
cpaBHHTeJrbItofi e$rfexrHBHocrH.
,sKoHorutrqecxuri
eQ$exr BoAoxo3flficreeriHoro
KoMUIexca
(BXI()
saeucaT or
KanI:traJIoBJroN;e-
Ht't fi
e
rt{Apoy3eJr
rr
B corlyrcrByrourue
coopy>KeHltfl. lloerolay
pacflpeAeJreHurc
noA/re]Kar
noJrllbre
sarparr,i
BXK
3*,
T. e. noJrnbre Kaflvra.roB.Ilox{eHldfl
Kt<
fr
[oJrHbre e]KeroAHbre I{gAepxKI4 KoIII-
nJteKca
Err.
ParnpeAeJreur{e sarpar BXK
N4ox{Ho
npoHs_BoLHTb
no
ycJroBrrro
obecneqeHlls oAHHaKo-
nofi exoHor\{r4r{Hocr14
AJII
Bcex
yqacrHur(oB KoMIIJIeKca. Cor.nacHo
ororvry
}'cJroBuro
npHHI4ruarcT
oAI4-
HaKoBbrfi
AJrrr
Bcex
yqacrHr4KoB
KoMnJIeKca:
l)
xoeSQuquerlT
peHTa6e,uruocrH
3w
KaIIHTaJroBJrolKe-:
uufr unu
2)
r<oaQQHuueHr
cpaBHureJrbHori
eQ$exruBHocru
E* xanura.roe.rioxeHnfi,
Hnu
3)
xoe$-
QuuaeHr
cHl4x(eHr{fl
c[K
pacqerHbtx
3arpar,
orHocuMbtx
Ha
AaHHofo
yqacrHnKa,
no
cpaBI{eHHFo
c efo
3aMeHseMbrM
BapHaHToM.
I4uercrcs
H
Apyrue
npeAJloxeHafl, HanpHMep
oAHHaKoBufi
xos$Qrz[HeHT
yBerHqeHVfl.
KatrTaJroBJrox{esufi
no
cpaBHeHHIo c 3aMeHfler\IbrM BapHaHToi\r
pi
r.
rr.
Vcnoepre
oAHHaKoBor?
exosoMHqHocrH
il,tox<er
pacnpocrpaHflTbcfl
na
eSQexrHBHbrx
yqacrHHr{oB
KoMnJreKca,
xorfl
Ha
rIpaKTuKe
oHo
qacro
npllMeHflercq
6es
KaKHX-JIH6o orpaua'{eFlnft.
Ha
KalKAoro
yqacrHr.rKa
i
ua^o
orHecrll aKoHoMI,IqecKHI
o6ocHoBaHHyrc
qacrb
KanHTaJioB.rrox{e-
HUtt
Kwt
U
qacTb
ex(eroAHbrx
r-r3Aepx(ex Hxi
KoMIIJIeKca.
X;,ts,
oflpeAeJreHufl
AByx
HeH3BecTHlrx .Kx;
ra
Hxr
B
Aorrod'rHeHHe
K
ocHoBHoMy
ycJIoBHIO
paBHOfi
3XOHC)I!IHqHOCTH HaAO
HMerb BTOpOe
yCJrOBHe.
B xaqecrBe
BToporo
ycaoBnrr
npl{HllMaercfl:
l) pacnpeAeJleHue
e}KeroAHbrx
rr3Aepx{eK no
orpacae-
aonry
Ha3HaqeHHlo
HJILI
2)
oguuaxosltft
AJIfl
Bcex
yqacTHIzXon
xoeQQHttfieHT
cHHxieHHfl
e]KerOAHblX
us4€pxex no
cpaBHeHHIo
c SaMeHflelvlbllu
BaplIaHToM H
T"
A.
D,ns.
ssauMopacqeroB
npH aKcnJryaraL..:*rLt
6o.tee
yAo6uuu
ctlI4Taercs
pacnpereJreHHe
e)KeroAHbrx
H3AepX(eK tio
orpacJreBoMy rra3Har{eHurc.
3ro
ycJIoBHe
r\rox(eT
npHMeHffTbcff B
no.nuofi Mepe
HJrr4
qacrnrlFro.
B
nepnoM
cfiyr{ae
Ha
KaxAoro
yqacrHuKa
,
orHocnTcq
rorHbre
ex{eroAHbre
HsAep>KKH
no ero
conyrcrByroqeMy
H orpac.qeBoMy
coopyxeHuflr,I
rHApoysJla u
qacrb
H3AeplKeK
no
o6u{urvr
coopyireHrrflM
rr,rApoy3Jra, npoltoptluoHaJIbHafl
orHocHMbrM
KanHTaJIoBJIo]KeHHflM.
Oruocutuue
e)KeroAHHe
H3Aepx(KH
KOMnJTeKCa
336
i
TIri:
klo,
r
*
poRoa
r,
fAe
Roat
-
:THOCHMbIe Ha
AaHHOTO
yqacTHHKa
KanHTa,rroB/rox(eHr.rf,
no
o6uuu
eoopJry{eHHf,M
fHApoySJIa,
Horr
-
noJrHbre elKeroAHbre H3Aep)I{KH
(npnurre
sKcn"ryarauHorrHbre
pacxoAbr
H
aMop-
ru3a[HonHbre
orqr4c.neuur)
no orpacrreBoMy coopy)KeHu]o
yqacrr{r,rKa
;.
KogQQHUHeHT
nponoprluo-
HaJIbHOCTH
po
MOIKHO
tIpHHqTb OAUHaT(OBbrM
AJIfl
BCeX
yqaCTItHKOB
KOMrrJreKCa:
'r4,
-
lrfu
o, ,
Po:
Kr-
I,Ia
Vc"[ouna
paBr{oi.i
axouomrlqHocru
ortIocI.IMafl
Ha
KaKoro-JIH6o yuacrttut<a i
qacTb
Kant{Ta-
,ToBJrox{eHHii
no
o6uluv coopyx{eHHqnr
ruApoy3Jla
MoiKer
noJlyqltrbcq orpr.iuareJlbHoi.r.
3ro
sHar{LIT,
rrro
ApyrHe
yqacrrlaKr4
AoJr)r{nbr
npHHflTb
Ha
ce6q
sce KanI{TaJI,oBfior{eHIiq
no
o6u1ul,r
coopyx{eHusM
ruApoy3/ra
H
qacrb
KanuTaJronnox<euufi
no
orpacJleBoMy
coopyx<eHulo
yqacrrl4r<a
l.
B
rarux c,Ey-
qaflx
Aflq
AarrHoro
yqacrHur(a
I orpuuare;rbFIoI-l 6y4er
BeJIHT.IIIHa exeroAllbrx
H3AepxieK
pKo6
i.
Apyrrae
yqacrHHKtr
AoJr>Kr{br
npHHrrb
Ha
ce6rr
Bce eiKeroAHbte
HBAep)KKH I{
Bl{ecrH 3a
AaHHoro
yqac'r-
HHKa
qacTHrIHO
HJIrr nOJTHOCTbTO
aMOpTH3aqHOIIHbte
OTr{IICJIeHHJ{ nO
efo
OTpaCJreBOMy
COOpy}KeHH}O.
Taxuu
o6paaou,
noJrHoe
orpacJreBoe
pacnpeAe,'IeHl4e
e>KeroI.HbIX
H3AeplI{eK
BXK npaKTHqecKH
He
MolKer
6ltrt
peaJlu3oBaHo
Bo BCex
rex cJlyqasx,
KorAa
AJIja
KaKoro-.rlg6o
yqacrHHKa
KoMnJIeKca
noJryqr.rrcfr
Koa;(
0.
3roro
HeAocrarKa
He
l{Meer
ycJIoBLIe
qacrlzqHoro
orpacJleBoro
pacnpeAeJle-
HHfl H3Aepxex-BXK,
Koropoe
ilor{Tr.r BcerAa
lvro}Ker 6rtrr
peaJrlI.r3oBaso.
CornacHo
SToMy
ycJIoBHIo
Ha
Ka>r(Aofo
yqacTrrHKa
I
oTHocrrTcfl noJurocTbio
elKefoAHble
,,HSAeplKKH
no efo conyTcTByloqeMy
coopy>KeHnto
Hs;
H npflNrbre
e>KeroAHbre
pacxoAvt
Hlp;
(sapn.naTa
3I{cIIJIyaTauHoHHoro nepcoKaila,
pacxbarr
no rer(yilreN,ry
pelvroHTy kt r. n.)
_no
gKcn.nyarawrr
orpacJleBoro
coopylKeHHff. rIpnrllrre
e>KeroAHbre
pacxoAbr no
3KCnJryararrliH
o6utux
coopyxertnil
rtlApoy3JIa
ol'Hocqrcs
Ha
fJIaBHoro
yqacrHuKa
KoMruret(ca.
I(oceeHHlre
ex<eroAHbte
HsAepx(KH_
rrtApoysila
pacnpeAerfllorcfl
nponop:
uHoHaJr
bHo
orHocuMbllll
Kan
I.'lraJIoBJl olKeH
Hsll f I'lApoy3JI
a
K
r
t.
'
OruocnMbre
Ha
yqacrHHKa I exero4Hble
H3Aep>KKII rHApoy3JIa
hri:frnpt*P.Kr;,
(18-ll)
a
OTHOC!i[{r,Ie
?l3AepX{KIl
KOMnJIeKCa
Il*:
Hct
*
LIri
:
LIci
*
Hnpt
*-
prKri.
Koe$QuupreHr
nponopuHoHaJrbHocrr.r
pr
nputr4[taercq
cpeAHLINr
AJrr
Bcex
coopy]KeHufi rulpo_ysila,
qTo
r\,tOX{HO
cqHTaTb
npl.leN,lJIeIvlbIM,
TaK
KaK
TOqHOCTb
IICXOAHbIX
AaHHbiX
He OrIeHb
BbICOKa.
Be.Uf-
qHHA
Ho6
Koo
1K"",
(
18- l2)
(18-r3)
Heo6xolnMo
orMernTb,
r{To
Bed'rHr{HHa
orHocuMblx Ha
AaHHofo
vqacrHnKa
H3Aepx(eK
Ko[inJIeKca
H6i nonyqaeTcs
IpnMepHo
oAHHaKoBofi xax npH
IIOJIHoM. TaK H npH
qacTur{FloM
oTpacJreBord
pacnpe-
AeJreHraH
r.r3Aep>KeK BXK.3ro
nporacxoAuT
noroMy,
qro
Hort) H"pi,
Ho
Kr;)
Ko6t.
flocne
noAcraHoBKH
B
$opiuynr,r
(lB-9)-(18-14)
SaxruuecKnx
BeJIHT{IIH KarrHrafloBJIo}KeHHi.r
H
eii{eroAHblx
H3AepXeK fHApoysJra
Mox(Ho
noJryqHTb
c
np?IeMJreMofi
ToqHocTblo
BeJrr4rrHHbr
oTHocr.rMurx
Qaxruue-
CKHX
ex{eroAFrbrx
H3Aepx(eK B
ycroBr4qx HopMaJIbHofi
gKcnfiyaTaqHH
rlrApoy3Jra.
VxasaHrmre
QoprtryJrbr
Moryr
6srru
HcnoJrbsoBaHbr
AJrff
pacnpeAeJreHus
e)KefoAHbrx
H3AeplKer{
npu npHMeHeHHH
noKa3areJrert rax
o6ueri, TaK
H
cpaBI.IHTeJIbIroft
eS$exrunHocru
KarrHTaJroBJro)Ke-
HHfi. 3asucHN4ocrH
>Ke
p.iln
pacnpeAeJreHHrr
KanHTaJroBJrolxeHuft
noflyqarorcs npHHunriHaJrbHo
pa3JIHqHblMH,
qTO
nOKa3aHO
IIHX{e.
-
OnpeAeJrHM
3aBHcHMocrH
AJrfl
pac[peAeJreHurr
KanHTaJroBJro)KeHHii
BXK npH
r{acrur{HoM
orpac-
JreBoM
paclpeAeJIeHHH
ex(eroAHbrx LI3AeplKeK KoMnJIeKca.
A,
Facnpe.qeneHIe
garpar
K0mfiilneKea
n0
yen0BH]o
o,quilaK0B0f
peHTaoenbHocTH
KanHTafioBfloxeHHil
B
paccMarpr4BaeMoM
MeroAe npou3BoAurcff
pacnpeAeJreHue
$arruqecKux
Kanr.rraJroenoxeurafi
H
ex{eroAHblx
HsAepx(eK HopMaJIbHofi
excn.nyaraIII{14 BXK. floaronay e
Qop*ry"rru
(18-12), (18-13)
u
(18-14)
no4craBJrfllor
QaxruuecKue
BeJIHquHrt
K
u
Z.
Koe$Qa:queut
peura6e.nbHocrn
rounnexca
3*
onpeAeJrflercfl
KaK
orHoueHHe
cyMMapHoro
rrHcroro
AoxoAa,ll,w
Bcex
yqacrHr4KoB
BXK K KanHTaJro-
BJrolKeHHflM KoMrrJrexca
,(x
:
Kr
+
>Kg;.
tlHctrtfi
goxoL
ilwctlHraercr
paBHbrM pa3HocrH
Mexqy
crouMocrblo
[poAyr[HH
Bcex
yqacrHuKoB
KoMIIJIeKca
B
orrroBbrx
ueHax
4r<
u
ex{eroAHbrMn H3Aep}K-
KaMI,I
KoMnJIeKca Hx: Hr*
)nrit
Pr:
(fr,
2H"r,)
lXr.
-
nn
4*-
H*
rK:
-R;
:
K*
(18.14)
(18-r5)
I(ounrexc
cqHTaercr
gKoHoMHr{ecKH
oSQexrunHbrM,
ecJrH erro xoe$Suur4eHT peHra6e.rruuocru
3*
6o.unue
Hoprvtarunuofi
BerHrrHHbr
3H.
Bce
yqacrHHKH
6yay'r
HMerb
o4uHaxoeufi
roe$Snquesr
peura6enbHocrll
3i:3*,
ecnu
Ha
KalKAoro
yqacrHuxa
oTHecrH
KanHTaJroBJrox(eHHfl
Korlrn.fleKca:
(18:16)
337
r, 4t*Hnpt-Hci*prKtt
Axi:+-
?x*h
'
n.nn
nonyqeHufl
HaAexHbrx
pe3vJrbraroB
pacqera
Hqo6xo4lrMo
noJrb3oBarbcfl
HayqHo
o6ocgo-
BaHHbll\{H
ueHaMH.
flpir llx orcVTcrBHI.t
npHMeHflror yAeJrbHbre pacr{erHbre
3arparbl
no savrensetrofi
npoAyKuHn.
06
I4x onpeAe,rreHut{
Iu'rfl
rHAposHepreruxr.r
6r,r.no cKa3aHo
B
S
l8-6.
flpH
pasnofi
Mepe
nJIarbl aa
$ongu
AJII
yqacrHI.IKoB
KorrrrJreKca
Mox(Ho
petrrHTb
3aAar{y
pacnpeAeJreHHs
3arpar
KoM-
nJIeKca no
yclloBl'llo
oAHHaKoBoro
xoeSQuUuenra
Aoxot(HocrH.
SroT xoeQSuUueHr
paBeH
pa3-
HccrH
Mex{Ay xoaQSHIIHeHToM
peura6enF,HocrH
r.r Hoprrroi.r
nJrarbr
sa
Qou4rr
1.
Mero4onorH'-IecKae 3arpyAHeHafl
B npHMeHeHHH yc.nonufi
o4uHaxonofi peura6earHocrr.r
unr
AoxoAHocrH
3aKJltoqatorct B onpeAeJreHHH
AJrfl
orAa"neuuo;ir
nepcneKTr4Bbr
crotirvrocru npo4yxunu
{
It
npHBeAeHvfl
ee
AJIff
pa3BI4BaIoulHXcn
o6rexroe
K
oAgoMy
roAy.f,.rrt onpeAeJreHr.{fl peHra6e"uuHocru
npHBeAeHHbtx KaIIHTaJIosroxeHLIl-'r
rvrolKHo
6sr"ryo
6or npH,MeHHTs
o6uvuyro
Qoprr,Iy"rry:
3*:
/I,*lK*,
(l8-l5a)
rAe
n,*
-
cylit',tapuutr?
npunegeuHrtfi
K
ycraHoBHBmeMy'cq
qucrurl
AoxoA,
noayuaevtili BceMH
yqacl'FlHKaMH
KoMnJIeKca.
Be"ntrquua
f[n
ytn>xsa
6rrrr
noilcrrHTaHa c
yqerolr
Qaxropa
BpeMeHH,
ArF
r{ero
Mo)KHo
6srno
6rr eocnoJrb3oBarbcn
Qoprr,ry,rroft:
E*:
X
0n,(1
+
E")"-i,
V,IacrFIHx
I
lonxeH
npHHflTb Ha
ce6q
qacrb
RanrTailosflox<eHHft
fu4poysra:
Kri:
(xi
-
/(c;.
(
r8- 17)
(18-18)
rAe0D1
-
npHparqeHHe
qHcroro
AoxoAa
B roA
I
no cpaaHeHHro
c npeAbrAyu{Hru
roAoM; EB-
xoes-
$uqueHr
yqera
Qaxropa
BpeMeHr.r; T
-
roA npHBeAeHHfl,
Koroplrr?
4onxes
6trrt
oAHHaKoBbrM
AJrrr
KannTaJroeroxeHnfi
r.r
AoxoAa
BCex
yqacrHr.rKoB
KoMnJrexca.
OAHaxo MeroA noAcr{era
npHBeAeHHoro
AoxoAa
eule He
noJryqu.n eceo6ildero
npH3HaHr.rq. Tax
KaK
ynoMflHyTble
MeToAoJrofLIqecKHe
TpyAHocTH noKa ellle He
npeoAo"[eHbr, To
jI,,rfl
pacnpeAeJreHHfl
sarpar
BXK
HctIoJIb3ytorcs
raKX(e
tioKa3areJlI4 cpaBHHT€JrbHofi
eQsexrlreHocrH
KarrHTaJrosroxeuHfi.
5. flpnmemeHHe
noilaaareneH
epaBHHlenbnoil
a$SerrHBHocTH
KanHTafl0Bn0)KeHHfi
flnfl
paGnpeflefleHHfl
saTpaT
K0tHilneKGa
flpu
I4cno,ab3oBaHHH
noxaeare.nefi cpaBHl4Te.nrnoil
sSQexrunHocru
Mo>KHo
qr.rcJreHHo
yqecrb
Qaxrop
BpeMeHH,
qro
otleHb
Ba)KHo
A,'rfl
BoAoxosqficreeHHbrx o6texroe,
I.rr{erculux
nJlureJrbHbre
cF,oKI4
crpouTeJlbcrBa
H
ocBoeHLIq.
PacnpegeJreHue
KanuTaJroaroxeHufi
BXK
paccMorpuM
npu npHMeHe-
HHH
AJ'II
eSQexrunHbtx
yqacrHHKoB
oAHHaKoBoro
xoeQQuu,ueura
l)
cpanHure.rlHofi-ssQexrnnHocru
KanHTaJloe.noxeuufi;
2) cur.rxeHran
pacqerHbrx
3arpar
no
cpaBHeHHro
c 3aN{eHreMbrM
BapHaHToru.
CpanueHue
Aor'rlKHo
upou3BoAuTbcfl
c
uau6o.nee
gKoHoMHrrHbrM
saMeHrervrbrM
BapHaHToru.
O err6ope
salueHseMoro BaplraHTa
B 3HepreruKe
cM.
$
18-6.
A.rrs apyrux
orpacaefi
HapoAHoro
xogqficrsa,
onpeAeJIeHHe
HaAelKHblx
iloKagarefiefi rro 3aMeHfleMbrM
BapHaHTaM
HHofAa
npeAcraBJrfleT
3Har{HTeJIb-
Hbre TpyAHocrH.
l. P
a c n
p
KOBOTO
KO
NI4TAJIOBJIO
rAe
>R"
v
>n"-
npI{BeAeHHbte
KanttraroBJlo}KeHurr H
ex{eroAHbre
H3AepxKH
3aMeHseMHx
o6texroe
scex
ytIacrHLIKoB
KoMnJIeKca.
fl,na
no.nyr{eHr.rs
oAHHaKoBoro
xoe@HrlrleHTa
eQsexrrm-
HocrH
Ei: E*
4nn
ncex
eSQeKTHBHbIx
yqacrHuKoB
HaAo
orHocnTb
Ha
Kax{Aoro
yqacrHuxA'i
qacrb
npHBeAeHHbIxKanHTaJIoeIox(eHHfiKoMnJIeKca'onpeAeJIfleM}"IoiloQopI\,IyIe:
Kxt
E*Krt
-f
H"r
-
Hnp
r
-
hct
*
prR"i
(
r B-20)
(18-l7a)
E**P,
flpH6nuxeHHylo
BeJIHqHHy
orHocHMbrx
QamuqecKHx
KanHTarosnoxeHnfi
Mox{Ho
onpeAeJrHTb,
nolb3yqcb cooTHoIIIeHHeM
MelKAy
QaxrHvecKHMH
H
npHBeAeHHbrilrH
Kanr{TaJroBflo}KeHHrMr.r
rHApo-
y3na:
eAeJreHHe
3aTpaT KOMrrJleKca
no
ycJroBHro
oAHHa-
oSQ
H
u
r{
e H T
a c
p
a
B H
HreJr
b
H o
rl aSQe
Kr
H
B
H ocrr.r
K
a
-
x
e u
u fi.
,[,nq
KoMnJ]eKca xoeSQrauI{eHT
cpaBHureasuofi
sQ$errunHocrr.r
Ex:
(Zn"-
fr")l(&
--X('),
(18.1e)
Oruocuurre npHBeAeHHbre KarrHTaJroBJrox{eHHfl
rHApoy3Jra
Kri:
Kwi
-
Kcr.
Krj:
O;r# (
18-21)
ycJroBLrrc
oII,rHa.
x
sarpaT.
2. PacnpeAeJreHr.re 3arpar
KoMnJreKca
no
KoBoro
KoaQSuqueHra
cHH>KeHr.rs piacqerHbr
lIIIaBeneB
A.C.O
?exHl{qecKoe
cTp
oHTeJrbcTBo),
338
pacrpeAeJreHHLI
1969,
Nb
10.
3aTpar
Bc)Aoxo3flftcrseHnoro
KoMnJreKca,
<fu4po-
Ecnu
KoMnJreKc
3KoHoMHrrecKH
a$$exrHne',
To
MeHbIxe
3arpar
3aMeHfleMbrx
o6texros
ilnn
noryqeHua
AJrfl
Bcex
yqacrHHKoB
oAHHaKoBoro
SaTpaT
di:
drc
HaAo
oTHocHTb
Ha
,nrc6oro yuacruaxa
i
onpeAeJrfl
er,ryro
no
Qopnayae
:
ero
npHBeAeHHbre
3arparbr
6yayr
y
lla*
pas
<
1,0,
tot
I3.
-
npHBeAeHHbIe
pacqerHbre
3arparbr
rro
BceM
3aMeHrreMrrrrr.o6lexraM
c
UIHMH
COOpy>KeHVflMt4.
(
I
8-22)
Prx
conyTcTBylo-
xosQrluuuenra
cHHAieHr.tq
pacqerHbrx
qacrb
rianHTa.'ron,roxeHuli
KoMn,rIeKca.
Kwi:
orHocltlttste
npHBerellHble
KanHTa,IIOBJTO)KeHHfl
fLrApo)r1r,ra_.onpeAeirffrorcfi
no
Qopuy,rle
(lg-l7a),
ryrre
(18_21).
Lr
BXK
NO
NOKA3ATCJIIO
AK
MO)KCT
6rIrI
NDI'IMCHCH
rrrHeHToB
CpaBHUTenr'ori
s$$exrueHocr'
KanHra-
pac,uefi
HapoArroro
xo3fliiciea.
rlo.nyuaeMbre
npH
B.
flpnnreuemue
n0rH0r0
oTpacneBoro
pacnpe.qe;reH1fl
elKero,qHhtx
HSEepH(eK
KOHnfleKGa
elKefoAHbre
r.i3neplKKr.r
onpeAe"ryrrorcrr
no
3aBHCr{_
HHeN,I
TOJIbI{O
O,IHOrO
ocHoBI]OrO
\/croBHF,
OAHHa_
BHHTei'IbHOrt
esQexrr.tBHocTir
i<a
n irra,roerox{eFir{fi
.
yqacrHHKa
i ua,ryo
orHecrrr
qacrb
Karrr4Ta,rroBJlolKe_
Ko6t:
(ExKzt
*
14st)
-
(Ew(ci
*
Hc,)
-
(E*Krr
i
!
Ho,
t\
a,<
(ErKst
+
H3L)
-
Enp
i
-
Frrr* p.K.i
-E;+
4
(
I
B-23)
Oruoc
litrtste
Kan Irra,rr
oBd,I
oxe
H
H
g
H
KOMN,ICKCA
En
_f
po
f HApoy3Jra
Kri:
Kori*
Ko6t
(18
24)
(
r8-2s)
(18-26),
K*:
Krti_
Krt.
r.
Mero.q
[n$SepeHqnpoBaHnoro
pacnpe.qeflexnn
saTpaT
KoilnteKGa
rreTbrpe
rpy[nbl
]'qacTHHKOB:
.ONOJIb3OBATEJI H;
:HHKH;
rxyAlxaroT
3KOHOMHTIeCKHe
noKa3aTe.ryH
KOMljIeKca;
bre yj-Iyqluaror
3r(oHoMHqecKHe
iroKa3areJlH
*Onnl
'
Ec'rrra yqacrH'Ku
nepnofi
rp.ynnbr
repnflr
yrr{ep6
or
crpo,reJrbcrBa
BXK,
ro
3ror
yrqep.
BK.nro-
qaercs
B
sarparbr
KoMrr"[eKca.
Ec.rrur
)Ke oHH
noryqarcr
nuioAu,
Tor
Hx
BKr]oqarcT
B
oAHy
H3
nocJre-
i:nff
f
;:f
::f
:,T:i".J.S"",."'S".ff;,"1rii""3;.,iiff
;
orHeceHHbrx
Ha
yqacrH'Koe
nropofi
u rperrefi
rpynn.
Hanpauep,
J(n.
ocr:
K*:
ER;:
ti;:
rAe
I
R,
-
Kanr.rTaJroBJro)KeHlrq
rro
3ar{eHseMbrM
B
3119.
f taea
0eef,mHa0agamaE
HAHBbIT(|IIHTfiUNT
PE}KHMbI
PAEtlTbI
r3C
}I
B(IIOXPAHHNHUI,
[HCnET'{EPCKHE
TPAOHKH
U
AtsT0MATH3A4Hfl
19.1. OCHOBbI
ONTHMHSAqHI,I
PEXHMOB
PAEIOTbI
rHIPOSJIEKTPOCTAHUHf,
Pexuna
pa6orr'r
f3C
Ao/tlxet{
6url
onrzMa,TbFrbrM
,{.,Tr
HapoAr1oro
xo3
nncrea.
tlp, 3aAaHHoM
3JeKTponorpe6"trelIHI4
14
Mar{cr4^,r\/Nie
Harp
}i
3
rr.r
3Heprocr{crer\rbr
I43MeHeHHe
pelKHlua
peryilHpoBaFlllfl
crol(a
I{ TeM
ca\{bri\r
peiKrri\,ra
pa6orrr
[poeKTli-
Pyenrofi
fOC
BJIeqer
ea
co6ofi
uevleueHr4e
ycraHoB,reuHor?
rtou{"b.r,,
Kar(
r1aApo-
craHr{I4H, TaK H TenJroBbrx
gret(TpocrauuHri
al{eptiocr{crer\rbr.
[]pu
3ToM
H3N{eHHTcfl
BeJHqHHa Kant4TaJIoerox{eI-IHr:r
H e}KeroAHbrx
r.r3Aep)Ker(
3ner<Tpocrauqur?
v
sHeprocHcTeMbl
B
UeJIoM.
lloeroMy,
I(aK^6uno
CKa3arro
B rJr.
5,npgrepuetr
a6Qer<-
rHBHocrI{ pex{HMa
npoeKrlzpyeMblx
f?C
crlnraercfl
MHHHMyM
npHBeAeHHbrx
pac-
qerHbrx
3arpar no
3HeprocncreMe
lcpr.
(5-
l3)-(b-
l6)
].
VcraHoeJIeHHyto
NlouIHocrb
HoBbrx
Ten,,'ror3brx
s"TeKTpocrauqufi
cHcrel,rbl
N{O}KHO yMeHbiIl4Tb
H
nOJIytIHTb
nO HHM
3I(OHOMHrc
r{anr.iTa,'roB,rroxeHafi
ilpH
yBe"rrH-
qeHHH
B
pacuerHlttt
MaJIoBoAultIi
roA
rapaHrHponauHofi
eupa6orNu
sHeprHr.r
H
MoulHocrll
npoeKrHpyenrort
rHApocraHI{HI{.
fonio,rHHre.tbHafi
Bbrp
a6orrca
3Hep-
r[{14,
KoTopylo Mo>KeT
AaTb
fHApOCTaHIIHfl
B MHOfOBOnHbre
roAbr,
fro3Bo,rrfleT
nojr,v-
qHTb
JIHtUb 3KOHOil,{HIO
TOilJIHBa
14 He
BJrHfleT
Ha ycTaIioB.'IeHH}/tO
MOUIFIOCTb
Te|I"'tO-
Bblx
3Jlel{Tpocrauqufi
cHcreMbt.
flosroMy
B
pflCtl€:T&x
o6uqso
BbrAenfipT
rapaHTH-
g9e_aHsYIo
H
AononHI{TeJIbHyIo,
ral{
Ha3bIBaeM}ICr
ce3oHHVto,
nupa6orxy
eHeprlrH
f3C. Ecnu I43MeHeFIHe
pex{piMa
pery.rrzpoBaHufl
croKa
e.te.{er
sa
co6oir
r.rsnleHbnlle
3KoHoMHqecKI4x
lloKa3are"rrett
norpe6ureaefi
gHeprHH,
To r(pHTepHeM
oilTnrualb-
HOCTH CtIHTaeTCfl
MHHIiMyM
CyMMapl{bIX
ilpHB€)AeHHbrx
pacr{eTHbrx
3aTpaT
no
sHeprocHcreMe 14
norpe6ureJlflM
sHep
rr4r4.
3arpartr
norpe6rarenerlr
3Hepf
HH
HHorAa
o(eHHBaloTcfl
lUIep6oM
oT
HeAoAaI{I,I
3,'IeKTpoaHeprHH
r4[rr4
cHH]KeHHfl
ee
KaqecrBa.
f]pu KoMIIJIeKcHoNI
HcnoJIb3oBaHHH
BoAoroI{a
Kpr.rrepr.ieM
orrHMz,TbHocpl
cqHTaeTcf
MHI{HI\'{yM
CyMMapHbIX
npHBeAeHHbrx
3aTpaT
BCeX
yqacTHHKoB
KOM-
nJIeKca.
flpornBopel{HBble
rpe6onauua
orAe.,TbHbrx
Bolonortgoearereri
v
BoAo-
norpe6urenet?
HcK"rlrcqalor
Bo3Mox(Hocrb
HaLIJryq[rero
]rAoB,rrerBopeHrrr
rpe6oea-
uptft
Kax(Aofo H3 HHX.
B yc"rronHflx
gKcnJryarauu;H
rrapaN{erpbr
coopy*e"rfi
Bcex
yqacTHI4KOB
KOMnJIeKCa
I,l3BeCTHbI,
V
KanHTaJIOBJIOIKeHHfl
Cr{HTaIOTCfl
nOCTOflH-
HbIMH. floarovry
KpHrepI4eM
oIIrHMaJIbHocrH
crilHoBarcfl
MHHHMyM
cyMMapHbrx
ex{eroAHblx
H3Aep)KeK
Bcex
yqacrHHKoB
KoMnJreK:ca
tlpH
BbirroiiHeHHH
o6ocHogaH-
Hbrx rapaurufi
ro
ypoBHrM
H
pacxoAaM
BoAbr.
_
npl^
?HepreruqecKoM
HCnoJIb3
oBaHuLr
BoAoroKa
onrr{N,raJrlurrfi
pe)KHM
pa-
6oru
f3C
onpeAeJlflercfl
rlo
MHHHMyMy
elKeroAHbix
r.r3AeplKeK
o6ieauHenHor?
SHeprocHcTeMbl
rlpH
BbInoJIHeHHH
6anauca
MoulHr)cTV
14
gHep
il4r4
H
nogeplK
aHHV
HaAJIe>KaIIIefO
KaqecrBa
sJleKrpoeHeprHH
nO
qacTOTe
H
Harrpflx{eHHro.
flp14
SaAaH-
HoM
sJleKrponorpe6neHHH
MI4HI4MyM
elKeroAHbIX
II3AeplKer{
cooTBercTByer
MHHH-
N'lyMy
ce6ecroHMocrH
eHeprHH
o6leAuueuuollt
aHeprocncreMbr.
B
pacuerax
c
HeKo-
TopblM
npulnulKeHHeM
crIHTaIor
nocroflHHblMH
BCe
sKcn,rryararl4oHHbre
pacxoAbr,
KpoMe
pacxoAoB
no rorIJIHBy.
TIlu 3ToM,
KaK
cKia3aHo
B
S
4-5.
KpHTepHeM
onrg-
MaJIbHocrH
pe>KHIrla
pa6orrr
f3C craHoBuTcfl
MI4I{HNIyI\{
croHMocrg
pacxoAyeMoro
TonJIHBa
Ha re[JIoBbIX
3neKTpocraHlluflx
3HepfocncTeN{br.
3ro ycJroBge
3angcbr-
BACTCfl
B TAKOM
BHAC:
Z
'B: MHHHMYM,
IAE
B
PACXOA
TO1IJIHBA,
A C
-
CTOH.
MocTb
ero eAr,rHHulr
Beca.
llpH oAr4HaKoBbrx
crouMocrr
Lr
Ka/ropufisocru
rorrJruBa
11
npHMepHo
o4uHaxoeofi
croHMocrH ero
clKHraHHff
Ha
Bcex
aJreKTpocraHUHrx
ycJIoBHeM
onrHMaJIbHocrH
cqzTaercfl MHHHMyM
lpacxoAa
ronJr
r4Ba,
T. e.
I
f
:
-
MHHHMyM.
B
npu6nulKeHHblx
pacr{erax
roAurlHoro
per)iJrurpoBaHus
croKa
cqr4Taror,
r{To
MHHI4MyMMcxoAa
roII"[I{Ba
coorBercrBye1npu6/r]asHre/rbHo
MaKcHMyM
ntrpa6orxu
3HeprHI'{
f3C
npl{
BbIrIorIHeHr.IH
rapg]ltufi
no
yqacruro
fOC
u
nonf"truu
MaKcH-
MyMoB
HarpysKl4
sHeprocl4cTeMbl.
Kputep
uft-
u;^axcaMyMa
etrpa6orxu
aHeprHH
340
rr4ApocraHur.rH
He lrox{er 6nrru npuMeHeH
AJrn
o6ocHoeaHufl
cyroqHoro
pexiuMa
pa6ornr
cHCTeMbt.
l4snecrllo,
qro
cyroqHoe
peryJrupoBaHue
o6uqHo Bbl3brBaer
norepH
3HeprHH
r.r no3roMy Mar{cr4MyMy
eupa6orKn
sHepr}ru
f3C
coorBercrByer
6aaHcHuft
pexun
ee
pa6orur
6es
cyToqHoro
peryJrl4poBaHufl.
Ho
np14 aror\,{
renfioBbte craHut4n
AoJrlKHbr
pa6orarb Ha nrrKax Harpy3Ku
c
6onb[IHMH
)/Ae.rrbHbtMH
pacxoAaMH ron-
ilvBa,
qro
B KoHeqHoNr
HTore noBfleqer
3a
co6ofi
yBe"rI4r{eHHe
pacxoAa ronJIHBa
B 3Heprocr4creNre.
K
rortry )Ke npH
6asucuofi
pa6ole
f3C
B
IvIaJIoBoAHttit
nepHon
rre
yAaercrr
Bbrnepx{arb
rapaHTHr4 MorrrHocrn
f3C,
B
pe3vJlbrare
qero
Mo}Ker
6urs
Hapytrren
6anaHc
rvroulHocrpr
clrcreMbr.
B
ycJIoBHflx
al(cnilyarauplpl
ortrttMl43attnro
cyloqFrbrx
pe>KHrroB
pa6oror f3C npoti3Boxnr
no
IutIHtti\,{yMy
crottt\locrr4,
vrrtw
pac-
xoAa
roil,'rnBa
B 3Heprocllcreve
(cu.
S
19-5
u
20-6).
flp"
npoeKrupoBaHua
f3C onruMu3ar{Hfl
pe}KHN,Ia
pa6oru
f3C B
pacqerHutli
Ma"[oBoAunrft
fo,I,
AoJr]KHa
npo]l3BOAHTbCff
no IVIHHI4Myl\{y
npHBeAeHHbIX
pacqeT-
r-rbrx 3arpar
noroMy,
r{To
npH
6onee nHKoBoM
cyroqHol\{
pe}KHMe pa6orlt rH;lpo-
craHur.rH o6trqHo
oKa3btBaercfl
aKoHoMuqecI(I4
BbIroIiHbIi\l
yBeJIHqeHHe ee
Ycra-
HoB"rreHHorl
MoglHocrH
v
coorBercrByroqee
yMeHb[IeHLIe
ycraHoBleHsofi
Ntol]l-
Hocru
HoBbrx
renJroBbrx
aJreKTpocrauuufi
oHeprocHrcreMbl.
B roAbt
v
ce3oHbl
c 6o,rnruofi
BoAHocrbro
HSMeHeHr4e
cyroqHoro
pex{Hlda
pa6ortt
npoerirupyel'roit
f3C Nrox(er
noB,tHflTb
roJrbKo Ha
pacxoA
Ton"rtuBa
TeIIJIoBbIX
craHuul:l
aueprocH-
creMbi.
floerolrt,
p.iln
TaKprx
[epI4oAoB
Npllrepnfi
oIITHMaJIbHocTH
oKa3blBaercfl
oAI4HaKoBbl\,{
Kaii
IJrfl
npoeKTHbrx,
TaK
u
L.nfl
SKcIIJIyaralluoHHblX
yc'nonut:t
tl
3a-
nr4CL,rBaeTcfl
B BIiAe
MI{HHN,IyN{a
CTO}IIVIOCTI,I
VnI4
paCXoAa
TOIIJIHBa
B
gHep|OCI4'
CTelvle.
19-2'
tlAt4Bblr0.[HEillullE
PE]tttlMbl HAn0nHEH[lR
t4
cpA60TK[l
B0[0xPAH14IlHul
A. 06qne
nonox(eH
HH
Pagflr.rqalor
rpH
Bv1.a HanoJrHeHvrfl
BoAoxpaHHJtHUIa:
1)_.nepBoHaqaflbHoe'
ocyqecrBJrreMoe
oAHH
pa3
B cBfl3H
c
rrocrpofixofi
nJIorliHbI;
2) sKcnJIyaraul{oH-
Hoe,
npou3BoAurvroe
nepuoAur{ecKu
B npoqecce
peryJllapoBaHHr
croK|,
H
3)
upes.-
strqarlHoe,
npoucxoAflulee
npH
rpaHcQopMauHH
KaracrpoQleuecxHx
noflosoAuft
I4
ilaBoAKoB
oqeHb
pe4rofi lloBropfleMocrH
(cvr.
S
3-ti).
IIepBoHarra"nbHoe
HanoJrHeHHe
ocyulecrBJlflercfl
B
nepl4oA
crpoHTeJIbcrBg
coopyxeHrzfi,
KofAa ueo6xoAnuo
3allo"rrHHTb
BoAoxpaHH"/'tr4ule
Ao
nycKoBoH
orn,tbixpr,
o6ecne.rusarouefi
pa6ory
nepnofi
ryp6HHsr
xorfl
6sr
c MI{HHMaJIbHbIM
HanopoM.
3ano".rHeHue
BoAoxpaHIaJrHUla
npoHgBoAHTCfl
B
crporoM
coorBercrBHH
co crpoi4reJrbcrBoM
rHAporexHHrrecKHX
coopyxesnfi.
flp"
3roM
B
cJlyqae_
seo6-
XoAHMOCTH
CHHXaTOTCfl
rrOilyCKH
kr3
BOAOXpaHHJIHU-{,ZI
AO
MHHI',lMyMa,
HeooxoLH-
Moro
flo
caHr.rrapHbrM
ycJroBr.rflM kr
no
ycJIoBHflM
ApyrHX
BoAonorpe6nrenefi
u
BoAonoJrbsoBarenefi,
fannuefiuee
3arroJrHeHHe
BoAoxpaHHJrHUI
npoucxoAplT
tIpH
pa6orarcIllHx
arpefarax. CpaeHureJrbHo
ue6onourue
BoloxpaHHJIHuIa
foAutlHoro
peryJlHpoBa-
Hun
o6trqHo
yAaercfl 3ano,rrHnTb
Ao
Hny
B
TeqeHHe
oAHoro
ttaBol.'r<a.Bo4oxpa-
HHJrHilra
MHoro.ryerHero
peryJrupoBaHufl
o6rt.Iuo
rpe6ynr
HecKoJIbKo
JIer
Anfl
sarrofiHeHr4q
Ao
orMerKH,
rro3BoJrfltouefi
nepefira
Ha
HopMaJIbHyro
orAaqy.
3xcnnyarauuoHHoe
HaroJrHeHHe
qepeAyercfl
co
cpa6orxofi
BoAoxpaHH"IIHuIa.
O6a
srg npouecca
coBMecrHo
AoJrlKHbt
o6ecnel{HBarb
HaHBbIroAHeIiurHt't
pex(HM
peryJrHpoBaHHfl
croKa H
6egonacHocrb
coopyxenufi
ruApoy3Jra:
[JIorHHbl'
snaHvn
f3C, [IJIIo3a
H
T. n.
CoeperraeHHbre
rHApogJreKTpocraHrIHH
pa6orarcr
B cJIo>KHbIX
sfleKTpoeHep-
rerr4qecKux
cr4creMax,
orflHr{urennsorZ
oco6euHocrbro
Koropblx
flBJIflercfl
Hapa-
crarourar
ueHTp
ailH3ar\ur
yrpaBJreuun
pa6orofi
cucleM, BblcoKan
Ar4HaMI{qHocrb
HX
p
a3BHTHfl
u
ycHJreHHe
cesgeft
MeN(Ay
orAeJibHbIMH
y3JIaMH
Lr
s,rIeMeHTaMH
CI{CTCMbI,
AnnauvtqHocrb
SHeproct{creMbt
npoffBJrflercg
B'roM,
t{To
K HHM
IIOCTOflHHO
npHcoeAHHflrorcfl
r{oBbre
rrorpe6HTeJIH
sJIeKTpoSHieprHH;
B
cBR3H
c
srHM
341
B
CHCTeMaX
n/IaHOMepHO
COOpyX(aIOTCt
HoBbIe
9JI€KTpOCTaHUHH
,
JIHHHH
aJIeI(Tpo-
nepeAarr,
TpaHcsoprraaropHbre
rroAcTaHuHH
14 T.
lt,.
------'t
Onruuu3arrufl
pex<uMoB
pa6orbr
BoAoxpaHH,rirfiru
cBoAHTcr
K
orblcKaHHIo
raKoro
pacrpeAe''IIeHHfl
ertpa6orxu
gHeprHH
H
3apery/rHpoBaHHofi
MouIHocrH
rI4ApocraHuLIfi
eo
BpeMeHH,
Koropoe
nosBo
JrkrJro
6ru..nonyqurb
MHHHMyM
cyMMap-
Flblx
3arpar
npH
yAoBrlerBop_eHHH
PnAa
rpe6onaH:r-rfi
(oipaHHueHufi)
i"epietgqe-
cxorl
v
BoAox03sficrseuFIoI?
cucienr.
Tpe6onaHun
3HeprocucreMbr
cBoAflTcfl
x
o6ecneqeHHIo
c saAauHoli
HaAexHocrbro'(o6ecneqeHHocrnro)
Hexoroporo
MHHH-
MyMa
gupa6orKH sHeprptpI
14
HeKoropofi
onpeAeJrennofi
pr.noru.u.ro;
MoulHocr'
B
"trrc6or?
MoMeHT
BpeMeHH,
Koropbre
o6ecne,{
vr,aJrl
61,
6anaucal
MoulHocrg
r.r
aHeprr{H
aHeprocprcreMbr
(url.
rJr.
b).
B
Karacrpo(ttauecxu
MaJIoBoAFIbrx
yc,rroBr.rflx,
BrirxoAquIHX
3a
npeAe/rbr
3aAaH-
Horl
o6ecne.reHHocru,
Bbrp
a6orxa
H
MorrlHocrn
ru,Apocr
auuufi
Motyr
6tnt
cHH_
x{eHbl
ToJIbKo
Ha BnoJIHe
onpeAeJreHHyro
BeJrHrIHHy,
r{oropafl
Mo}Ker
6rttr
Kor\{neH-
cHpoBaHa
pe3epBaMH
Cr{creMbr.
Tpe6oaaHun
BoAoxo3sficrnenHoro
KoMn",'reKca
cBoAflTcff
K yAoBJrerBopeHr4ro
c
3aAaHHofi
HaAelKHocrblo
onpeAeJIeHHbIX
lpoBeHHrrrx
ycnonufi
H pacxoao"
"oao,
B BepxHHX
u HIIXHHX
6leSax
rHApoysJIoB
r4JtH
rHa
ilHMlrlpyrour6x
yrracrKax
peKH_
AJrff
o6ecne.reHufl
cyAoxoAcrBa,
BoAocua6x<elHuR,
HppHrarrpru
vr r.
n.
HaHsrlro4uefiruue
pe>r{HMbr
HanoJrHeHHfl
H
cpa6orx"'
IJao*fun"n"ur
BbrflB_
"rlflIorcfl
B
pe3yJlbrare
pacqeroB
pefy-nupoBaHHfl
CTOKa,
H3
OCHOBaHHH
KOTOpbrx
crpoflrcfi
AHcnerqepcKHe
rpaQuxu.
Ec,ru
AJts
on'ruMr43
ag:zv
pa6orsr
roaoipu-
HHJTHUI
HcnoJlb3ylorcfl
BbIqHcJIHTeJIbHbIe
MaIUHHbI,
To
Ar.rcneTqepcKHe rpaQHxH
Moryr
6lrrt
MeHee
Aera,TbHbrturu.
5'
0nrnmn3auftfl
pex(tdma
pa60Tbr
KaGKa,[a
Bogoxpa66rf1lrl,
pacnofloxeHHbtx
Ha
pagHb!x
E0[0T0KAX
3a'4aqa
oIIrHMI43
ar\HH
pe>I{HMoB
pa6orn
KacKaAoB
rHApooJrer(TpocraHuufi
H
BoAoxpaHUJIHIII
cBoAHTcfl
: l)
x
nocrpoeHulo
MareM:araqecxort
MoAeJrH'rrocrynJre-
HHn
sHeprerHqecKoro
pecypca
cucreMbl
-
rvroAeru
peqHofo
cro
"u)
i)
;;";;;;t
la6oru
ee
BoAoxpaHHJrHirI;
3)
K
paspa6orxb
,
crparefHr{
ynpaBJreHHfl
H K
rrocrpoeHHro
peueHHfi
B
npouecce
3KcnJr
yararruu.
r{ecrBe
MareMaruqecxor?
MoAeJrH
peqHoro
Hbre,
KOppeJrHpoBaHHbre
Bo
BpeMeHH
14
_IeHepHpoBaHHbre
Ha
Bbrr{HcJrHTeJrbHbrx
pnAoB
nrr6upaercn
raxor?,
uro6rr
oHa
xi3ff;r#1iltJ"t&"tffru"fJ.t;H;5#:i#
NEPHOA
PA3BHTHfl
CHCTCMbI
I{
PABHflJIACb
BOAOXOSgfiCTBEHHOMY
I{HKNY
PC'YJII,IPO-
BaHI4fl
perrHoro
croKa,
t{ucno
HccJIeAyeMbIx..
Bbr6opor<
nrr6upaeta"
'1u*uu,
uro6rr
noryrrHTb
HCKOMOe
pelxeHr{e
c
Heo6xolur*,rofi
roqHocrblo.
Onruuu3arIHfl
pex{HMoB
pa6oru'BoAoxpaHHJrulrl
[poH3BoAHTcs
c
ueJrbro
noryr{eHI4
ff
MHHHMyMa
3arpar
no
3Heprerra.recxorl
cr{creMe,
a
npH
KOMUIeKCHOM
ljl""*"-ioBaHr'rH
BoAoroKa
-
no
BoAoxosqficreeuHori
c'creMe
B
rlerroM,
BK/rror{afl
eHHo
onrHMH3Hpylorcfl
pelKHMu
pa6oru
aqFibrx
IIo
cBoHM
pefyJrHpyrorrlHM
Bo3_
AJIbHO
BO3MOX{HOE
ZCTIOJIb3OBAHHC
NPHTOKA
K TH.
ApoerleKrpocraHqHH
ArIn
Bblpa6orxa
ua
Heft.."g.iltru
rru^rpHrrecKofi
euepruu
npu
yAoBJIerBopeHI4H
3aAaHHbIX
orpaHuqeHl'll?
ntffi,nu
ynpuBJreHr{ff
HrrH
A1crrer-
rrepcKHe
rpaQuxu
yilpaBrreHHfl
pi6orofi
no4oxpaHrr,rrHrrl
rHApoe.neKTpOCTaHUUfi
342