Лекшас Й. Вина как субъективная сторона преступления

inoAcyAHMoft,

'geccnopiHo

AOKastiBaioT,

MTO

OOBH-

xipecjieAOB3Jia

u,ejib

y6nxb

CBOIO

pfmb

«

c

STOH

np'Ho'erjia

K

raK

iHasbieaeMOMy

nocpeAcxBeHHowy

BHHOBHHMeCTBy.

BCJIH

npH

HCOieAOBaBHH

MOM6HTOB

CO3IH3HHH

Cyfl

6yfl6T

HCXOAHTb

'H3

TOFO,

O

^BM

CBHAeTeJIfaCTByiOT

OOTjeKTHBHbie

(paKTbl,

TO OH

H6

OCyAHX

HH

OAHOrO

HCEHHOBHOrO

"H

H6

OH-

paBAaex

HH

OAHOFO

BKHOBIHOFO.

6)

BOJIH

npu

desycjioenoM

ymucjie.

Flpn

CesycjiOBHOM

yMbicjie

BOJIH

npecxynHHKia

HanpaBJiena

wa

ocyinecxBJieHHe

npecTynjieHiHH.

npecrynHHK

Hcejiaex

ocymecTBHTb

CBOIO

npe-

CTynHyio

nejib

naMeqeHHMM

cnoco'ooM,

c

noMombio

HblX

CP'CACTB,

np«

A3HHbIX

yCJIODHHX.

TaK,

nanpHMep,

A.,

noHMmnbiH

wapoAHHM1

Ha

MecTe

inpecTynjieHHH

np«

nooibixKe

BSJioMaTb

ToproBOH

opra»H3a-uHH,

>KejiaeT

HsSencaTb

3a^epH<aH'HH

H

c

3TOH

uejibio

npHMeHHex

iHacHJine

e

oTHouieewH

.noji'HueficKO-

ro,

KOTopfaiH

xo^eT

ero

apecToeaTb

(§113

YK).

BOJIH

B

3THX

cjiyqaax

oxBaTMaaer

see

HseecTHbie

npe-

cryniHHKy

ofi-beKTHBHbie

ycjiOBHH;

owa,

cjieAoeaTejibHO,

pac-

upocTpaHfleTCH

ne

rojibKo

Ha

caMo

o6"beKTHBHoe

npecTynHHXa.

nocKOjibKy

npecrynnHKy

HSBecTHu

HHC

o6cTOHTejibCTBa

H OH

B6A6T

ce6a

onpeAeJieHHHM

o!6pa-

SOM,

TO

oTMOAa

cJieayeT,

HTO

OH

xe/i-aer

coBepuiHTb

STH

flieflCTB-HH

HMCHHO

Hp,H

H3BeCTHbIX

6My

o6T»eKTHBHHX

yCJIOIB'HHX.

A.

SaMCTHJI,

MTO

B

OOC6AH6M

AOM6

B03HHK

HO>Kap,

OH

SHaer,

MTO^

B

STO

ispeiviH

B

AOMB

HHKoro

H6T,

TCM

ne

Menee

OH

He

cooi6iri;aeT

o

no>Kape

noKapHofl

oxpane,

H

AOM

oropaeT.

oSpasoM,

A.,

cosftasaH

see

ofiTjeKTHBHHe

o6cTOHTeJib-

ocTasaTbCH

naccHBHHM.

SesycjioBHOM

yMbicjie

BOJIH

HanpaBJiena

na

ocy-

npecTynHOH

UBJIH

npn

AaHHHX

oS'beKTHBHbix

6es

KaiKHX-jiH6o

oroBopoK

HJIH

orpaHHieHWH.

MHO-

rne

npecrynaHKH,

HHTaacb

npHTBOpino

ccbiJiaTbcn

na

'Heocro-

poJKHocTb,

yxBepjKAa'ioT,

MTO

OHH-AC

He

«»e;iajiH»

TCX

HJIH

HHbix

nocjieACTBHH

CBOero

inoseAeHRH.

ECJI.H

npecrynnHKy

BC6

o6-bOKTHBHbie

o6CTOHTejIbCTBa,

o6pHCO-

B

oocTase

'npecTynjieHHH,

iSbiJiM

eMy

HSBCCTHH,

H

B

TO

JKe

BpeMH

ne

AOKasano

y6e«HTejibiHbiM

o6pa30M,

ITO

npecrynHHK

paccHHTHBaji

ina

BosMOxcHocrb

npeAOTBpa-

meHHH

npeABHAeHHfaix

HM

npecTynHbix

nocjieACTBHH

caoero

noeeAe»HH,

TO TOT

<J)aKT,

^TO

OH fleikTiBOBaji c

60

21

o6-beKTHB'Hbix

oQcxoHxejibCTB,

HBJiHexcH

neonpoBepJKH-

AQKasaxejibexBOM

HajiH^HH

y

wero

npecxynnofl

BOJIH.

A.

CTaji'KHBiaex

B. c

Mocxa

B

rjiydoKyio

peicy.

A.

anaex,

B. He

yMeex

nji3B3Tb

«

ixo

'HQOJIHSOCTH

Hex

HHKoro,

KXO

6bi

ero

BHTamHTb

<HS

peKH.

C3M A.

ne

xejiaex

Bbixa-

B.

MS

peKH

H He

Aejiaex

aioro.

A.

B«HOBeH

B

yMbim-

(^,aeH«OM

ydHHCTBe

B.,

XOTH

6bi

OH

noxoM

H

ccbiJiajicn

Ha TO,

'

ITO

OH

xoxeji

xoJibKo

Hanyraxb

B.,

a He

y6nxb

ero.

ITpn

A3H-

',

Hbix

oScxOHxejifacxsax

y

BMCHHeMoro

lejicreeKa

ne

MOTJIO

6bixb

^

BOUIIH

TOJibKo

K

TOMy,

^xo'Sbi

Hanyraxb

Apyroro:

Hna^e

06-

l

CTOHJIO

6bl

A6JIO,

6CJIH

6bl

IB

9TO

BpeMfl

H3

p6K6

H3XOAHJICH

,,'

JIOAO^HHK

H A.

Kp'HKHyjI

6fal

CMy,

HTO6bI

OH

BblXaiUHJI

Ka,

ynaBuiero

B

pexy.

BCJIH

'6bi,

necMoxpn

na

sxo,

B.

TO

Bee

>Ke

o

xaKOM

cjiy^ae

A.

tie

6biji

6u

iBHHOBert

B

yMbiui-

•

JieHHOM

ydnftcTBe,

xaK

K3K

y

Hero

oxcyrcxBOBajia

BOJIH

K

3.

yMblCCJI

BHH3

B

dpopMe

ycjiosnoro

yMbicJia

H a-

•JIHUO,

ecjiH npecTynHHK

fi

p e

ASH

Ae

Ji,

ITO

nyTBM

CBO6TO

A6HCTIBHH

HJIH

6

3 A

6

fl

CTB

H H

'OH

Mo>KeT

ocymecTBHTb

on p e

A6Ji

e

H'HO

e

n

p e c T y :n

Ji

e H H e, c o B e p

HI

e H

>H

e K o T o p o r o

OH

.

we

CHHTHJI

H

eoi6xo

AHM

biw,

HO,

HecMOTpn

na

Ta«oe

np

eAifl

H

ASHiH

e,

ne

KCJISJI

OTK333Tb-

'

c H o T c B o e r o n o B e A e H H H.

np«

ycjioBHOM

yMbicjie

npecTynHHK

CTSBHT

ce6e

onpeAe-

jieHHyio

uejib,

KOTOpyro

OH

HcejiseT

ocymecTBHTb.

3xa

'

MOJK6T

HMBTb

WpeCTynHblfl

Xap3KT6p,

iHO

H6

'

npecryniHH'K

HaMeqaer

njian

ocymecTBJieiHHH

STOH

uejin.

OH

,

npeABHAHT,

TITO

ecjiH

OH

6yA&r

nocTynaTb

T3K,

K3K

OH

«a-

'.*"MeTHJi

B

CBoeM

njiane,

TO OH

AocTHirneT

em,e

iero-To

Apyro-

-tO,

HTO

H6

OTHOCHTCH

K

TOH

U6JIH,

p3AH

KOTOpOH

OH

}K6JiaeT

#

AeHCTBOIBaXb.

ripH

9TOM

MOPyT

HaCTyHHTb

T3KH6

tHO^OHHbie

,

ffocjieACTBHH

IHJIH

pesyjibTaxbi,

KOiopbie

HBJIHIOTCH

npecTyn-

'

A.

Kyraji

c

noApocTKOM

B.

O'6a

oTnpasjiHioTCH

a

nyTb.

JXopora

uuia

qepes

nycTbUHHyio

MectHocTb.

B ny-

B.

noTepsiji

coseaHHe.

A.

CTapajicn

npHsecxH

ero B

lys-

, HO

axe

eMy

ne

yAajiocb.

TorAa

OH

nonbixajica

ynecxH

AOMofl.

Ho

nocjie

TOFO,

Kax

OH

nponueji

KHJIOMCTP,

HOiina

CTa»OBHTCH

AJIH

Hero

CJIHLUKOM

THJK6JIOH

H OH

OCXaflJIHeT

B.

61

™~M

~''5*g

s

g

«

S

§353

-

i

PC

»•<

3

gill

S

*<<

E S

••^

***

^

C3

O

s^fs§

f

o S

f

-5

o

K

13

CO

13

g

«

co

sS

*"

I

rt^

S^

cog

.§sl^

g"s;!s

pill

H

°^

"

i

O

K ft) g

3«g8*

M<^

1

R^H

ft O

O\

<<?

3^E^

paBJienne

H

naeaxaeT

IHS

neiuexoAa,

KOTOpbifi

npn

naAe^

H

noJiyqaeT

corpaoeHHe

Moara.

P. He

npnxoAHJio

B rojiosy

o ero

qpesMepno

6biCTpaH

esAa

MOHCCT

noBJieqb

TaKHe

no-

c s

g,

>>s:

i-

eACTBHH.

B

oipoTHBoinojiojKHOCTb

yMbruiJieHHHM,

npH

HeocTopoJK-

[X

AGHCTBHax

BHHOBHblfi

H6

yqHTblBaeT

TOfO,

qTO OH

MO^61

A

S

yim,ecTBHTb

onpeAejieHiHoe

inpecrynjieHHe.

JIn6o

OH

nojiara-

^

0

,

qTO

ero

AeftcTBHH

He

npniBeAyT

K

npecrynjieHHio,

jinfio

OK

H

S

o6iue

He

AyMaeT,

HTO

ero

noeeAeHHe

MosceT

6HTb

npeciyn-

IM.

0

A

ft S

HMeeTCH

JIH

H3JIHU.O

«eOCTOpO»CHOCTb

B

OTHOUieHHH

HO-

eACTBHH,

BbisBaHHbix

B

KOHKpeTHOM

cjiyqse

uejieHanpaB-

HHbiM

AeficTBHeM,

ycTaiHaBJiHBaeTCH

npe^Ae

Bcero

nyTeK

aBH6HHH

OC03H3HHOH

H

>K6JiaeMOH

U6JIH

Aefi'CTBHH

C

T6M

cu

ex,

<=!

V

KHe

HSMeneHHH

IBO

BHeiuineM

Mnpe

qejioseK

(paKTHqecKK

CO

«

g §

ca

^

S 6.

>,

g

«

ca

gco5sgg3cua6«g

iI§aS"-5

Is

K

3l^°i|lKgx§Sg

ioSl^§

i§

g

ssgi^ii&^ss

ex,^(-gcx,«cu

"3

3 3

PSt-SSsyS

ifiPJi

»•

I

»m

ii

gl°!l|°

l|

l|l|ls«l!|p

ii

||||

1

1^

||;

M§

>,a8§

-S

S

«c,S^S^cS2

S

^&g

a

>>?,=s&SaJa.=s|S

gsSHmaJfeoSoSK§

BvS)

cugocosOcuS

Sftcxn33HssmC!S3

|S,^I§^§§§

.

§^^§§iab|§xl«_

o«|s55S^|5§

gSS&g:|s«0"agl¥^

a|g-o>^a«85g<g

g|a§^|s^6cl|x8^

gsgsnocucxu§

a^yn.4J§H'oa,ca-^>1cao

Sg^gagfife£>a

S^0^*^^!^^^0-^

Sg?0"i«^S^S&^gg»iSa§g-ga|*g

"SgffiSScO^cOCX,

pP

C3>5cucDaf,c3o£cpcn«cu

sCSSyK^wH^.wSmS

B^SocrtflJs.sa,

Ojspg»sca

cu

Vcu

co

«exoKa>coffiSaei

ex,

cuocucuQ'^c^

3

-ex,

ex,

w

O o

co

O

ex,

y

cu

K cu O

CeCs^e-fcCK^cr

\OC

G

OKp<«iMC!waS'l:!E

^

ITocTaHOBjieHHe

06

oxpane

paCoqefl

ciMbi

OT 25

oKTafipa

1951

r.

BI. S.

957).

O

p-

to

„••

o

x

s

'

K3E3«gO

^

>>S8

f=i

K

s

«

K

>"

.

ro

s

a

l-fe

CU

V

j)

P>>

S

SH

t-1

CO

,,

«gS

o S

X

H g

bos

£*

®

§^?§1

CQ

CQ 8

M

|

S

W

^

is|gp

«

>^b

1

w

s

S

n

Ps

CO cu

S

§

*

g

M^SS

sisigg

M

cj

CX.Q

s

g

a9°gg&

^,

„

-

>.

H

«

b

t3\O««yo<Utr,

~

>»

o

p^

H

a.

~

cx,ex,w

y

c

c cu

CX,

co

>>rfi

\

co

S3

W

P§

<

s

=o

S

o

a.

es

t-

o

u

=

S

MM

jqaHHJl

0

HCOCTOpOJKHOCTH

1.

O6mHC

3aM(

^

"

3

a

o

Q^

i*

Ztefi'CTIBHHX,

B

OTJIKWHe

OT

yMbli

fttHHKOM

uejib

He

HanpaBJiena

— Ha

ocymecTBJieHHe

onpeAeJ

»My

y

npecTynHHK3

HCT

BOJIH

;

X

3

1

o

f

CJ

O

CD

X

S

ex,

C

HHX,

OC03H3HHaH

IHpeCT}

ycjioBHO,

HH

6esycjioBHO

ro

npecTynjieiHHH.

HOSTC

«

*

£ §

s

£

y'cl

CM

-J"

*

g 3

?J

rynjieiHHH.

TejiecHOM

noBpe>KAeHiHH

(§

Ha>np.H'Mep,

uejibio

inpoyqHTb

I

3TOM

OCHOIB3HHH

OH

XOieT

eFO

3i6«Tb

naJTKOH.

ripn

ineocTopc

T3KOH

U6JIH

y

BHHOBlHOrO

H6T,

1

3K,

BejiocwneAHCT

P.

xoqeT

C

bUIOH

CKOPOCTbK)

OH

C-b63>Kaei

HHH

Ha

HAyiuero

•qejioseKa,

meCTBJieHHK)

9TOFO

'HpeC

OpH

yMbfflJJieHHOM

cji.

YK)

A.

CTaiBHT

ce6e,

Topbift

ero

ApasHHJi;

Ha

POM

noAKapayjiHTb

«

H:

TejiecHOM

nospeJKAeHHH

SC6T

'6bITb

HH3H

U6JIb.

T

npnexaTb

AOMOH.

C

6oji

pbl,

H6

Ol6p3UI,aH

BHHMa

s

2

co

S a

g

c

ci2

5 § S

:Kau,HH

H

cflane

opyjKHH

H

Coesbix

CTHHK

KoHTpojibHoro

CoBeia

N°

6,

CT

falM

COB6TOM

B

TepMaHHH

B

1945

—

npaa

OKKynauHH

TapMaKHH

netbiphN

eftcTBHe

na

TeppHTOpHH

PUP.

CM.

c

CoBeTa

MHHHCTPOB

CCCP,

«Ms

[MenaHHe

K

pyccBOMy

nepesoiny.]

22

ripHKaa

Xa

2 o

KOH(J)H(

COB

OT 7

HHBapa

1946

r. (Be

[AKTbl,

H3flaHHbie

KOHTpOJIbH

B

nopsmKe

ocymecTOJleHHH

i

jKasamH,

npeKpaTHJTH

csoe

a

cTByiomee

nocTanosjieHHe

21

ceHTflCpn

1955

r. —

Hpw

ECJIH

ueJieByro

ycxanoBKy

BHHOBHOFO

npH

HeocTOpoJKHHX

npecxyn-neHHHx

paccinaxpHBaxb

B

CBHSH

c

inocJieACXBHflMH,

TO

OHa

BcerAa

HMeex

npecxynHbift

xapaicrep,

Kanoft

6u

nojioiKH-

TejibHOH,

B3HX3H

HsoJiHpOBaiHHO,

OHa IHH

inpeACxaBJi-Hjiacb.

PyKOBOAHTejIb

npeAHpHHXHH,

6yAy^H

HCKJUOqHXejIbHO

osaSoqen

BbinojmeHHeM

njiana,

He

AyM3ex

o

CBOCH

ofiHsaH-

HOCTH

«co3AaBaxb

xaicne

ycjioBHH

TpyAa,

npn

woxopbix

npo-

HBJiflJiacb

6u

nocTOHHaan

3360x3

06

oxpane

H

pado^eft

CHjibi*.

B

pesyjibxaxe

sxoro

B

npeAnpHHXHH

pnexcH

pacxjm6aHHOCXb.

TaKoa

pyKOBOAHxeJib

XOTH H

npecJieAyex,

ecjiH

ee

6paxb

Hso/inpoBaHHo,

nojio>KH-

'

TeJIbHyiO

UeJIb,

HO

BCJieACXBHe

HCAOOIjeHKH

H

H6C06jIK)AeHHH

npn

nocraHO'BMe

KOHKpeTHbix

uejieft

CBOHX

oSnaaHHOCTeH,

BfarreKaiomHx

us

riocTaHOB/ieHHfl

06

oxpane

padoHeft

CHJIU,

caM

yHHiTOHiaer

noJioscHrejibHyio

cropony

CBOHX

HeAocraTOHHoro

BHHMaHHH

BHHOBHOro

K

o6H3aHHOCTHM,

jm6o

BOSJiaraeMbi'M

na

Hero

KoHCTHTyuHeft,

3aKO«aiMiH,

nocnaHOBJieHHHMiH

H

pacnopHJKeHH'HMH

rocyAiapcT-

sa

'HJi'H

nepcoHajibHbiiMiH

nopyqeHHaMiHi

rocyAapcTBaHHbix

opra-

HOB,

JIH6o

B03HHK3K)mHM

H3

6FO

CeMeHHblX

OTHOUieHHH,

npo-

4)6CCHH

HJIH

H3

KOHKpeTHOH

o6-b6KTHBHOH

OfiCTaHOBKH,

6FO

KOHKpeTHbie

uejiH

npn

HeocropoKHbix

npecrynjieHHHX

npn-

o6pexaiOT

cneuH^nqecKoe

o6mecTBeHHo

onacnoe,

B

Mopajib-

HO-nOJIHTHHeCKOM

OTHOUieHHH

UpeAOCyAHTeJIbHOC,

UpOTHBO-

npaBHoe

H

HaKasyeMoe

nanpaBJieHHe.

HeocTOpojKHaa

xapaKTepaayeTCH

npe5KAe

Bcero

HeAOCTaxoqHUM

AOJira,

HeBHHMaxejitHocxbio

BHHOBHoro

K

CBOHM

CXHM.

SaAa^ia

cyAednux

opranoB

npn

SXOM

saioiioMaexcH

B

XOM,

qxo6bl

CO

BC6H

OqeBHAHOCXbK)

AOK33aXb

BHHOBHOMy,

no

HeocxopojKHocxH,

ITO

uoseAeHHe

ero

pesyjibxaxoM

xaKoro

neAocxaxoiHoro

cosnaHHH

cBoero

AOJira.

KpoMe

xoro,

cyAH

odflaaHbi

—

ecjin

OHH

XOTHX

BMnOOIHHTb

OBOK)

BOCIUHXaTeJIbMyiO

pOJIb

—

BCKpblBaTb

Cyfrb-

eKXHBHbie

npn^HKH

axoro

HeAocxaxo^noro

ocosnaHHa

CBoero

Ao^ra.

ripn

HeocTopo)KHbix

npecxynjieHHHX

B

oxHomeHHH

pafio^eS

CHJIH

AeficxBHH

BHHOBHoro

HBJiflioxcH

pesyjibxaxoM

Bcero

oxcyxcxBHH

AOJI>KHOH

CBHSH

BHHOBHOFO

c

pa-

KJiaccoM.

Tan,

BepxoBHbiS

cyA B

npnroBope

no

Aejiy

o

Kaxacxpodpe,

npoHcmeAuieH

B

KaMeHHoyiwibHOM

pafione

UB'HKKay

(LJ,BHKKay-npouecc)

yxasaji:

«...OxpHB

OX

TpyAHIU,HXCH

— BOX

^TC>

B

AeHCXBHTeJIbHOCTH

HBJIH6XCH

KJIIOMeBbIM

MOM6HXOM,

KOXOpHH...

paHO

HflH

H03A-

68

3>

HO.

K

HapyuieHHio

saKOHHbix

odflsaHHocxefi

H

K

BOS'HHKHOBe'H'HK)

OCHOBaHH'H

AJIH

yiXWIOBHOH

OXBCX-

,

'

24.

HCBHHMaHHe

K

JIIOAHM

HBJIH6XCH

CydlieKXHBHOH

n

-*-ocxopoJKHbix

HecnacxHbix

cjiyqaes

«a

xpa-HcnopTe.

Oxeyx-

BHe

Heo6xoAHMOH

rocyAapcxBeHHOH

AHcunnjiHHbi

BeAex

K

My,

ixo

pyKOBOAHxeji'H

npeAnpHHXHH

coBepmarox

Heocxo-

HapyuieHHH

npeAnncattHH

nocxaHOBJienHH

o

XOSHH-

npecxynjieHHHX.

BeAocxsxOTHaH

roxoBHocTb

oKasu^

BJISCXH

onoco6cTByex

•;

HeBbinojiHeHHio

no

Heocxopo>KHOcxH

odflsaHHOcxn

Aonece-

"

HHH,

npeAycMoxpeHHOH

§ 139

YK*.

TaKHM

odpasoM,

HeocxopoHtHoe

npecxymieHHe

HMeex

CBOH

KopHH,

Koxopue

cyA

AOJi^eH

BbiHBHXb

A-^H

TOFO,

^xodbi

on

MOP

oKaaaxb

BocnnxaxejibHoe

BOSAeficxBHe

K3K

na

noAcyAH-

Moro,

xaK

H

na

uinpOKHe

Maocbi

HapoAa.

Ho

xaKaa

cyAe6naH

«

pa6ox3

neo6xoAHM3

npe^Ae

Bcero

AJIH

xoro,

Mxo6bi

cyA Mor

,•

BCKpuxb

AeficxEHxejibHyio

cymnocxb

HeocxopoKiioft

BHHM,

s|

onpeAejiHXb

ee

xnacecxb

H B

COOXBCXCXEHH

c

axnivi

HasnaHHxb

npaBHJibHoe

HaKasanne.

ECJIH

cyA

6yAer

co6juoAaxb

axn

no-

JIO>KeHHfl,

XO OH

H6

OK3>KeXCH

BO

BJiaCXH

o6-beKTHBHCXCKHX

H

4)OpM3JIHCXHqeCKHX

M6XOAOB,

KOXOpbie

H3XOAHT

CB06

BHpa-

1

aceHHe

B

OAHOM

Jiinrab

ncHxanonraecKDM

cnoco6e

paccMoxpe-

HH

HHH

HeocxopojKHOcxb

MO^GX

fibixb

noApasAejiena

na

cosHaxejibHaH

neocxopoiKHocxb

H

HecosnaxeJibHaa

HC-

OCTQpOJKHOCXb.

yrojiOBHoe

yjioxeHHe

1871

ro^a

rae

Aajio

noHHxHH

ne-

.

'ocTopojKHocxH.

FIosTOMy

iMOH^HO

jiiHiiib

Aaxb

Hay^Hoe

no-HH-

THG

H&OCXOpOaCHOH

iBIHIHbl.

3a,KOH

«6

npOBOAHX

pSSJIHIHH

we)KAy

BHA3MH

neocxopoxcHocxH.

Bo

scex

cjiy^aax,

TAC

BOS-

'

HeoexopoJKHoe

ooBepuie»He

npiecxynJieHHH,

OHO

MO-

'f

kex

6bixb

coBepuieHo

Ka«

BCJieACTBHe

coanaxejibHOH

neocxo-

TH,

xaK H

BCJieAcxBHe

HecosHaTejibHOH

neocxopo*.

H.

B

npHHUHne

Heocxopoacnocxb

H3K33yeMa

xcwibKo

KorAa

otna

npaivio

ynoMHHaexca

saKonoM

HJIH

KorAa

BHxeKaex

HS

XOHHOFO

cMbicJia

saKona

(HanpHMep,

_

**

Ony6jiHKOBaHO

B

Neue

Justiz

1952,

Btin.

8,

crp.

370 H

cJi.

* § 139

VK

npeaycMarpHBaeT

OTBeTCTBeHHocrt

sa

HeaoHOCHTejibCT-

SaKJiioqaiomeecfl

B

HeaoneceHKH

opranaM

BJIBCTH

o

coBepmeHHH

HJIH

yKaaannbix

B

STOM

naparpa<})e

npecTyn^enHfl

HJIH

B

Henpeay-

jiHita,

KoropoMy

rposHT

onacHocTb

OT

raKoro

npeciynjieHHfl,

K

pyccKony

nepeBOfly.J)

69

70

n

e

b

r

l

=

!

wpg'riS»h«**

-»3orif»WffiN>

*gS*§og|g

-vjr-

•yCJIOBHbIM

yMHCJIOM HJIH

B

CHJiy

C03H3T6JIbHOH

H60CTOpO>KHO-

CTH,

peuiaiomee

3H3M6HHe

HMeeT

OTHIOAb

ne

CSMO

no

ce6e

HSAeeTCH

na

npeAOTBpaiu,eHHe

npecTynJiennfl.

B

STOM

H

sa-

KJiioMaeTCH

cymecTBeHHoe

OTJIHMHC

STHX

npecrynJieHHft

OT

npecTynjieHHH,

coBepuiaeMbix

c

ycJIOBHHM

yMHCJIOM,

upn

KOTQpWX

BHHOiBHHH,

'HeCMOTpH

'H3

C'BOC

JIpeAB'HAeHH'e,

ACHCT-

•ByeT

HaMCMeHHblM

o6p33OM,

nOTOMy

MTO OH

H6

>KeJI36T

OT-

KasuBaTbCH

OT

CBoero

noBeAeHHH,

XOTH

6u

B

pesyjibTSTe/

9Toro

ocyuiecTBHJiocb

onpeAeJiennoe

npeerynjieHHe.

J1.JIH

OOSHaTejIblHOH

WeOCTOpOJKIHOCTIH

MOSCJIO

npeAJIOHCHTb

cjieAyromyro

(popMyjiy:

H

nocTynaio

TSKHM

oSpasoM,

TaK

K3K

H

HaAerocb

na

TO, MTO

nnqero

HJIOXOFO

He

cJiyMHTCH.

STO-

My

cooTB6TCTByeT

H

BOJIH

JiHua,

AencTByramero

c

cosH3Tejib-

HOH

HeOCTOpOJKHOCTblO.

OcHOBHB3HCb

H3

B03MOJKHOM

H3JIH-

MHH

HJIH

H3CTynJI6HHH

T3KHX

o6CTOHT6JIbCTB,

KOTOpbie

n?eA-

OTBP3THT

npecTynjieHHe,

BHHOBHHH

no

co6cTB6HHOH

BOJIC

CTpCMHTCH

OTKJIOHHTb

TOT

HpeCTyHHHH

p63yJIbT3T,

KOTOpblfl

OH

npeABHAHT.

OH

xejiseT

ocymecTBHTb

CBOKD

orpaHHMen-

nyio

ueJib,

a

BOBCB

He TO

npecTynjieune,

KOTOpoe

OH

npeABH-

AHT

K3K

B03MOSCH06.

OpH

HCCJI6AOB3HHH

BOnpOCa,

ASHCTBOB3JI

JIH

BHHOBHHH

C

npeABiHAeHHe,

A'efrcTByeT

HaMeqeHiHbiM

oSpaaoM,

Ta«

K3K

OH

ero

noeeAe«He

MO^BT

npHBecTH

K

npeciynjieHHio,

OAH3KO

OH

paccMHTHBaeT

H.a TO, MTO

cymecTByloT

'HJIH

H'aerynaT

Ta-

Kne

ycJioBHH,

KOTOpue

npeAOTBp3THT

npecTynjieHHe.

IIpH;'

C03H3TeJIbiHOH

iHeOCTOpOJKHOCTH

BKCHOBHHH,

HCOMOTpH

«3

CBO6

HeCMaCTHHH

CJiyM3H.

TaKHM

o6p330M,

npH

npecTynjieHHH,

coBepuieHHOM

no

CO3H3T6JIbHOH

H60CTOpO^HOCTH,

BHHOBHHH

npeABHAHT,

MTO

CBOK)

JIOBKOCTb

H

yBBpBH,

MTO OH

CMOX6T

npCAOTBpaTHTb

no

oxpane

TpyAa,

TOMHOB

coAep>KaHHe

KOTOporo

OH

ne

HOM-

WHT,

TI3K

K&K

paCCMHTHBaeT

H13!

TO, MTO

H3MHTb

nOJIHOCTblO

eMy

ne

HS'MeHHJia.

MOTOHHIKJIHCT

A.

Taxace

paccwnaBaer

Ha

ro

pesyjibTaTa

ero

noBeASHHH.

TaK,

B. B

npHBeAeHHOM

Bbinie

npHMepe

nojiaraer,

MTO

OH

Bee

me

cyMeeT

npSBHJibHO

BbinojiHHTb

RocTSHOBJieHHe

JIOBHH,

KOTOpne

BocnpensITCTByroT

HacTynjieHHio

npecTynHO-

syjibTaTe

ero

AOJIJKHH

HacxynnTb

yKasannue

«no6oMHbie

no-

cJieACTBHH».

Jlnuo

>Ke,

AeficTByiomee

B

cnjiy

cosnaTejibHOH

HeOCTOpOJKHOCTH,

H6

COPJiaUiaeTCH

C

T3KHMH

BO3MOJKHHMH

TiocjieACTBHHMH

CBoero

noiBeAenHH.

OHO^

paccMHTHBaer

na

yc-

CJieACTBHH»

H3MeM6HHOrO

HM

nOBCAeHHH,

HOCKOJIbKy

OH

H6

jKBJiaeT

OTK333TbCH

OT

STOFO

nOBCAeHHH,

A3>K6

6CJIH

B pe-

BHHOBHOFO,

MXO

OH

paccnaxbiBaji

na

xo,

ITO

odcxoaxejibcxea

npeAoxspaxHx

ocymecxB^eHHe

npecxyiuie-

HIHH.

CaM3'

oiScxaHQB'Ka

AOJi>K«a

fiujia

6uTb

xa«iofl,

tiro

BHHOBHblH

AeficTB'HxejibHo

MOP

paccHHXbiBaxb

Ha

3To.

B

npo-

XHBHOM

>Ke

CJiyiae

peMb

MOJKCT

HAXH

Jinuib

06

yMbicjie.

A.

c

6euieHOH

cKopocrbio

necexca

na

MoxoirHKJie

no

sa-

KpyrjieHHOMy

nyxn.

B 200

nexpax

BnepeAH

ox

ce6a

OH

BH-

AHX

codpaBuiHxca

Ha

yjinue

jnoAefi

B

KOJimecxse

OKOJIO

30

MejioBeK.

A.

CKOpocxb

ne

cdasjiaex.

B

noAodHbix

ycJiOBH-r

ax A.

ne

MOP

paccMHxbraaxb

na

BosMOJKHOcxb

Hs6e>Kaxb

He-

cMacxHoro

cjryqaa,

Aa>»e

ecjin

OH

axo

yxBepxAaex.

OH

.M

npecjieAosaxb

nejib

cnpuxb

CBOH

yMuceji.

He

BCHKoe

Jinuo,

npn

eajraMKH

BbimeyKaaaH-Hux

AeficxBosaJio

BHHOBHO

no

HeocTopoacHOCTH.

6bi

peib

Morjia

HATH

SAecb

o

BHHC,

neofixoAHMo

eme

OAHOFO

MOMenxa,

xapaKxepnoro

A^IH

cosnaxeJibHOH

ne-

ocxopo^HocxH.

BHHOBHHH

AOJIJKCH

6un

.rcerKOMbicJieHHO

HaAeHXbCfl

na

xo,

qxo

cymecxsyiox

HJIH

nacxynnx

xaxne

odcxoHxejibcxsa,

Koxopbie

BocnpenaxcxByiox

ocymecxBJieHHK)

npecxynjieHHH.

3xox

jierKOMbicyieHHbiH

pac^ex

aa

o6cxoHxejibcxBa,

KOXO-

pbie

AQJiJKHbi

npeAQXBpaxHXb

npecxynjieHHe,

BHOCHX

HCHOCXL)

B

CymHOCXb

C03H3XeJIbHOH

HCOCXOpOJKHOCXH.

ycxaHOBJieHHH

JierKOMbicjiHa

npecxynHHKa

HBAO

CJICAyiOIUHX

MOM6HXOB:

a)

npe>KAe

scero

HBAO

XO^HO

ycxaHOBHXt,

KaKHe

33HHOCXH

HapyiXIHJI

BHHOBHblH

B

A3HHOM

KOHKpeXHOM

SXH

06fl3aHHOCXH,

KaiK

yjKie

Bbiuie

yKasbiaajiocb,

Moryx

suxe-

K3Xb

H3

p'aSJIHMHHX

o6meCXB6HHbIX

OXHOUI6HHH.

B

KOHKp6X-

HOM

cjiy^ae

OHH

MOFJIH

BbixeKaxb

HS

nojioJKeHHH

BHHOBHOFO

KaK

rpa>KAaHHHa

Hamefl

pecnyfijiHKH,

H3

ero

no^HXHMecKHx

HJIH

'xosHHcxBCHHfaix

dpyHKUHH,

H3 ero

npotpeccHOHajibHoft

AeHxe;ibHOcxH,

ns.ero

noA05KeHHH

B

ceMbe

H.JIH

HS

HHUX

no-

CTOHHHblX

>HJI'H

BpeMCHHblX

CBH3CH

M6>KAy

JTMUaMH,

H3

UHH

rpaJKAaHHHa

B

Ka^ecxse

coScxBeHHHKa

HJIH

a

xaioKe

HS

xoro

oficxonxejibcxBa,

HXO

BHHOBHHH

cosAaJi

no-

^OHceHHe,

rpo3Hiu.ee

onacnocxbio

A-^H

Apyroro.

Hpn

SXOM

xa-

Koro

poAa

odasaHHocxH

Jin6o

Moryx

Sbixb

npHMo

npeAHH-

caHbi

saKOHOM,

Jingo

Aa>Ke

Moryx

npeAcxasjiHXb

HenncaHoe

npaso.

SXH

ofinsaHHOCXH,

HMeiomne

cymecxseHHoe

snaqeHHe

o6l>eKTHIBHOH

CTOpOHbl

npeCXJ'.HJieHHH,

BSJKHbl

A^IH

p33-

Bonpoca,

Ka«yio

EHnM^axejibiHocxb

H

npHHaxne

Ka~

Boro

peuie»HH

oxnocHxejibHo

npeAOXBpaiu,eHHH

72

OpH

o6a-

HblX

B03MOJKHUX

nOCJICACXEHH

MOJKHO

TpeSoBaXb

OX

BHHOB-

HOrO.

npH

3XOM

H606XOAHMO

npOBCpHXb,

H6

AOJIJK6H

JIH

6bIJI

BHHOBHblH

npH

336OXJIHBOM

OXHOLU6HHH

K

CBOHM

o6H33HHO-

CXHM

cosHasaxb,

ixo

B

AaHHOM

cjiyiae

OH He

Bnpase

nojia-

raxbCH

na

xo,

qxo

o6cxoHxe^ibcxBa

npeAQXBpaxHx

npecxyn-

TaK,

MOXOUHKJIHCX

A. B

npHBCAeHHOM

npHMepe,

B3H

CBOH

06H33HHOCXH,

BbIX6KaiOmHe

H3

ABHJK6HHH,

AOJI^SH

6bIJI

CK33aXb

C66e,

MXO

JIOBKOCXb

6FO

-

CJIHHIKOM

HenaAeJKHaH

Beui,b,

MxodH

MOJKHO

SHJIO

B

AaHHOM

cjiyqae

Ha

nee

nojiojKHXbcn.

BoAHxejib

aBxoMauiHHbi

B.

CAST

no

yjinue

c

paspeiuen-

HOH

SoJIblUOH

CKOpOCXbK).

OH

BHAHX,

MXO

H3

SOKOBOH

yJIHUbl

aBXOMOSHJIb,

C

KOXOpbIM

OH

MO>KeX

CXOJIKHyXfaCH,

BOAHxejib

SXOH

MauiHHbi

HapyuiHx

npaBH^a

esAM.

OA-

H3KO

B.

HaAeexca

na

AHcunnjiHHHpoBaHHoe

noBCAeHHe

BOAH-

Apyroro

aBxoMoQHJiH.

Me?KAy

TeM,

BOAHxejib

Apyroro

He

co6jiK>Aaex

npaBHJi

ABH^ieHHH,

MXO

B.

npeA-

B3K

BosMOJKHocTb,

H B

pesyjibxaxe

sToro

npoinc-

XOAHX

asapHH.

HeciwoxpH

na

CBoe

npeABHAenne,

B.

ne

cxBOBSji

c

cosnaxejibHofi

neocxopos<Hocxbio,

xan

K3K

B

HOM

cjiynae

OH

Bnpase

SHJI

paccHHXbiB3X6

na

xpaHcnopxHOH

AHcmmJiHHbi

BOAHxeJieM

Apyroro

6) B

CBHSH

c

HccjieAOBaHHeM

oSHsaHHOcxen,

Ha

BHHOBHOM,

M

npooepKOH

xoro,

ne

nojiarajicH

JIH

oe

BOnpeKH

CBOHM

O6H3aiHHOCXHM

H3'

HajIH^He

X3KHX

yCJIOBHH,

Koxopbie

npeAoxBpaxHT

npeAB'HACHHoe

HM

npecxynjieHne,

aeo6xoAHMo

noABeprnyxb

noApofiHOMy'

paccMOxpemiK)

KOH-

Kpexnyio

o6T>eKTHBnyio

o&xaHOBKy

cofibixHH.

C

yqexoM

o6n-

t

aaHHocxefi

BHHOBHOTO

H©o6xoiO)HiMo

ycxaooBHXb,

ITO

o6l>eKXHBHOH

feaxbCH

aa

xo,

MXO

«HHHero

ne

Ha

cnopxHBHOH

njipmaAKe,

TAB

HaxoanxcH

PHA

cnopx-

cMeHOB,

OAHH

HS

HHX

saHHMaexca

MexaiH«eM

6yjiaBbi.

OH He

iipeAynpejKAaex

ocxajibHbix

o

HeoSxoAiiMocxH

co^^ioAaxb

na

xo,

qjp

O»H

caM«

6yayx

«cjie-

OH

oxseqaex

sa

Hanecenae

xejiecnoro

.OnopxcMeny,

B

Koxoporo

nonajia

6pouieHHaa

«M

f*'EcjiH

we

npn

cocxasaHHH

pyKOBOAHxe/ib

ero

AaJi

BCCM

yM3cx-

*f'«HK3M

cocxa33HHa

cooxBexcTByiom,He

KasaHHH

H

ec^n

xeM

M€Hee

OAHH

«3

IHHX

eonpeKH

npaBHJiaw

BbiSeraex

na

JIH-

HHIO

MexaHHa,

xo

3xox

pyKOBOAHxeJib,

Aa>Ke

ecjiH

OH

ona-

C3JICH,

MXO

KXO-HH'6yAb

'6yA6T

B6CXH

Ce6fl

73

, He

oTBenaeT

sa

paineHHe

yqacxHHiKa

cocxHsaHHH,

KaiK,

CA6./I3B

cooTBeTCTByromHe

HiHcrpyKTHBHbie

OH

MOT

H

AOJIJKCH

'6biJi

-nojiaraTbCJi

na

TO,

qxo

ace

6yAyx

co6jiK>Aaxb

STH

yKasaHHH.

B)

B

CBHSH

c

npoBepKOH

TOTO,

He

noJiarajicH

JIH

IBHHQB-

Hbifi

jiencoMbicjieHHO

«a

xo,

qxo

upecxyruieHHe

ne

ocymecx-

BHTCH,

HieoSxOAHMO

XaKJKC

yHHXblBaXb

erO

JIHHHOCTb,

,B

OCO-

6eH«K>CTH

ypOBenb

ero

sHanHft

>H

otibixa.

HaAo

opoeepHXb,

H6

AOJIJKHO

JIH

6bIJIO'

HM6HHO

AaHfflOe

J1HU.O

B

CHJiy

OBOHX

O'SflSaHHOCTeH

H

OfybeKTHBHblX

OOCXOHTeJIbCXB

COSHaBaXb,

yxo

OHO

ne

MOJKCT

Ha,n,eflTbCH

«a

.H36e>KaHHe

npecxynjieHHH.

TaKHM

o6pa30M,

WpH

A3HHOM

HCCJieAOBaiHHH

H3AO

OAHO'Bpe-

M6HHO

OIieH'HTb

o6H33HHQCT>H

J1HU3,

o6T>eKXHBHyiO

oS'CTaHOB-

Ky, B

KOTOpOH

OHO

AeftCXlBO'BaJIO,

H

ero

JIH^HOCXb.

Pado^HH

-A.

xojtbKo

xpn

AHH

xoMy

inasa^.

na^aji

pa;6oxaTb

B

npe^'npHHXHH,

«3rOTOBJIHK>Ul,eM

KapKaCHbie

KOHCXpyKUHH.

FIoMoexbi

no

yKjiaflKH

HX

AOJIJKHU

nposepsixbCH.

IIoBpe)K-

aeraHbie

AOCKH

He

AOJUKHU

-Sbitb

«onojib3OBaHbi,

XOXH

6u

OHH

BHetune

IH

o6jiap,am

:6ojifaiuoft

npoiHocxbio.

A.

3x010

ne

OH

KJia^eT

xaKyio

AocKy,

nojiaran,

*ixo

ona

em,e

XCM

6oJiee,

qxo

OH

cam

mpOBepHJi

ee

xpenocxb.

Ha

UJ;HH

^enb

AOOKa

jioMaexC'H,

H B

pesyjibxsxe

TejiecHoe

noBexACHHe

B. 3a

Taxne

mocyieAcxEMH

A.

OXBC-

ECJIH

xe

ASCHTHHK,

HMeiomHH

AOJiroJieTHiOK)

npaKTHKy,

oxAaer

pacnopsmeHHe,

ixofibi

IB

B-HAS

MOKjuoqeHKH

Honojibso-

B3JiHCb

H

noepescAeHHHe

AOCKH,

xaK

KBK

nnaqe

npHocxano-

BHXCH

pa6oxa,

a

npn

SXOM

inaaeexcn

ina

xo,

qxo

HH

oAHa

HS

3XHX

AOCOK

He

cnoiwaexcH,

xo OH

AOJiscen

6yAex

-necxH

ox-

•BexcTeeBHocxb

sa

opH^HHeHiHe

xejiecnoro

noBpejKAeH'HH

no

co3HaxejibHOH

Heocxopo>KHocxH

a

cjiy^ae,

ecji'H

xaKaa

AOCKB

H

pafio^cMy

'6yA6T

.npHHHHeHo

xeJiecHoe

noBpe>K-

6bi

CTHxarb

jierKOMfaicneHHbiMH

Mepbi,

np«-

HHXbie

MCAHUHHCKOH

cecxpofl,

KOxopaH,

HanpHMep,

B

rjiyxofi

MecxHocxH

OKasbiBajia

«nepByio

noMoiu,b»

B

cepbesMOM

cjiy-

^ae,

ne

xepn»uieM

oxjiaraxejibcxBa,

npaqew

ona

caMa

ona-

cajiacb,

HXO

Mo>Kex

AonycTHXb

OHIHQ'KH,

«,

xaiKHe

ouiH'fiKH

coBepuiHJia.

OAH3KO

xaKHe

xe

Mepu,

HHxue

BpanoM,

cjieAoeajio

6u

npHsnaxb

jierKOMHCJieHiHbiMH,

rax

K3K

B.

iKaiecTBe

oieuHajiacxa

OH

'OfijiaAaex

6oJibiiiHM'H

'ITOSHaHHHM'H.

74

*-

FIoAo6Hoe

no/iojKeHHe

OTHOCHTCH

«

K

xoMy

cjiynaio,

KOF-

Aa

pe^b

HAex

o

cnenHajiHcre,

pa6oxa«>meM

B

coBepuienHO

HOBOH

AJIH

Hero

odJiacTH.

TaKHM

o6pa30M,

nejibsn

npeAJioscHTb

KaKyK)-JiH6o

oiSmyro

4)OpiMyjiy,

Koxopan

oxBaxbisajia

6u

see

cjiynan,

a

HiaAO

y:Ka-

3aTb

Ha

HBOfixOAHMOCTb

TIU,aTejIfaHOrO

HOCJieAOBaHHH

K'35K-

Aoro

iKOHKpexHoro

c/iyqaa.

He

BcerAa,

oAHano,

He,nocxaxo:iiHoe

snaeHe

HJIM

Heonux-

HOCXb

OCBoSO'JKAalOX

,QX

HaKa:3aiHHH.

CKOpee

XOJIbKO

B

HCKJIKD-

iHxejibHbix

cjiy^anx

HesHanne

Moxex

HCKJHo^nxb

Heocxo-

poxHocxb.

B

npHHUMie

KaHiAfaiH

ofi'HsaiH

ycBOHXb

nieodxoAH-

Mbie

nO'3H3HHH

A^H

XOFO,

qxo6bl

6bIXb

B.

COCXO'HHHH

K3K

cnpaBHTbCH

co

CBOHMH

o6mecTBeHHbiMH

saAa^aMH.

xapaKxepHsoiBaji

9x0

noJio»:eHHe

BHUIHIHOKHH

B

e^H

mo

Aejiy

o

m6eji.H

napoxoAa

«CoBex-

OKHH

A3ep6a§AJKaH»:

«3naH

aScojiioxiHyK)

onaoHocxb

«et|)xeAaraKOH

He^TH,

SaHbKO

H6

MOJK6T

H6

npH3HaXbCfl

B

TOM,

qTO

OH

H6

'HMeJI

AO-

cxaxo^Horo

npeAcxaBJieHHH

o

pasMepax

SXOH

o-nacnocTH.

OAHO

y>Ke

HBJinexcH

npnsHaHHeM

ero

xsJKejioro

npe-

mepeA

rocyAapcxBOM,

noxoMy

HTO

MH

ne

MoxeM

cxaxb

ma

xaKyro

TOHKy

spennfl,

qxo

pas

H

ine

anaji,

xo

aaa-

qnr

H

ne

oTBeiaio.

MH

xpe6yeM

oxBexcTBeHHocxH

IH

sa

ne-

snaHHe,

MH

xpe6yeM,

qxoifibi

Jiaua,

BoarjiaejiHioiuHe

xe

HJJH

•HHHe

ynpaBJieH'HH

HJIIH

Aa«e

OTAeJibHHe

qacxn

ynpaiBJieHHH,

3H3JIH

TO, qxo OHH

AOJI>KHH

SlHaXb,

a

6CJIH

OHH

STOFO

IH6

3H3-

JOX,

XO OHH

AOJDKHH

OXBCqaXb

33

3TO

H63HaHHe,

6CJIH

3X0

(HesnaHHe

BBiwocb

npnqHHOH

passajia

eceii

nopyqeBHOH

HM

paOOXbl

HJIiH

SUBHJIOCb

npHqHHOH

KaKOfi-JI'HOO

K3TaCTpOt})H»

25.

3.

HecosHaxejibHafl

neocTopoiKHOCTb

HecosHaTCJibHafl

HeocTOposcHocxb

HMeeT-

C

fl 8 A e

H

C T B H H X T

O

T

0, K X O H

6

C 0 3 H 3

6

X, q X 0

nyxeM

ceoero

ASHCXEHH

HJIH

6esAeHcx'BHH

OH

MOJK6T

ocymecxBHTb

inpecxynjieHHe,

XOXH

no

CBOHM

O'6LU,eCTBeHHHM

o6fl3aiHHO-

CTHM,

HO

0

6CTO

HT6

JI

bCTB

3 M C B 0

6

T

O

H

O-

cxynK3

H

no

CBOiicTBaM

CBoen

Jinqnocxw

M

o r H A o

Ji

IK

e H 6 H

ji

370

c o

s

H a B a

x

b.

25

A. J.

Wyschinski,

Gerichtsreden,

Berlin

1951,

S.

259.

[PyocKHH

TeKCT

flaeicH no

HSflanmo

«Cy«e6Hbix

pewefl*

A. 51.

BUUIHH-

CKoro,

TociopHaaaT,

1955,

erp.

200.

—

npHMeianne

K

pyccKOMy

nepe-

75

I

W»

Of?

™

a ...

w

§ a a

alili

OCOOeHiHOCTH

B

T6X

CJlyq3HX,

FA6

CyilieCTByex

BOSMOmHOCXfa

xoro,

qxo

coBepuieHHe

npecxynjieHHH

no

HeocxopojKHocxH

78

npecxynjieHHH

paiBHUMH

HaKasanHHMH.

3xo

HMeex

Mecxo

B

OAH3KO,

iBHOJIIie

paBHOCHJIbHO

6FO

yMMIUJICHHOMy

COBepIUC-

HH,K>.

TOFA3

33KOH

o6jI3F3eT

O6e

(pOpMbl

COBep'UieiHHH

3XOFO

Heocxopo>KiHoe

coBepiueHHe

npecTynjieHHH

MO>Kex

6bixb,

JiHBaex

sa

Heocxopo>KHoe

ero

cosepmeHHe

MeHwuee

naKasa-

MHe,

qeM

sa

yMbiuijieHHoe

(§

212,

222 yK;

i.

1

IH

q. 2 § 1

Ho-

cxaHOBJieHHH

o

xosHHCTBeHHbix

npecxynjieHHHx,

§

306—308,

309

yK).

2

lESgQs-^

^Qisj^fafaea

Q a fa ft ft a

M

^^v;

SaSlP|g|H«|||lPlM||M|S|

—

1

s

>o

a

s

g fa°ftt53afaaaa

a=i3

."jfBSi-pfcifHfe1—

NS<S

%*

P

if

?§S»1s

2|3

i

III

-B

i

1

i

If

"1

^ilss^iisisiiBs^i^fpiii

Si|8.8*^gxi»|3g

p-f

|S

s3sSSliP||

III

11^

*

firMipt

fsll^lisH^tiii-ll

Sl^gijl

PpllJi!

g"g

ro-o

ft

"*

o

q

|

o g

fa

g

a

ro

gg

«

^

3

w

E

a

co

SHfa

?oro

aro

gg

x^Yg^gs

s|g^gcg^g|

AiapCTBeiHHoro

oprans

H He

BfaixoAHJi

»a

STH

npeAejibi:

xaKOB

g

£53

W

C53

a

ro

ft

•a

1

03

ro

a

X

ro

a

S

£

g

a

s

1

tr

a

o

-i

o

§

><

B3MH

npecxynHoro

inoBeAeHHH

H c

yqexoM

JHH^HOCTH

cy6i>eK-

xa

npecxynjieHHH,

qxo;

yMbiceji

QUJI

HanpSBJieH

xoJibKO

Ha

•

OKpyjKHOH

cyA B

Fajuie

npnroBopHJi

npecxynHHKa

Xopcxa

Sennejibxa

33

npnsbiB

K

SoiiKOxy

H

HaniroiHSJibHofi

Bp3>K-

Ae

coFJiacHO

ex.

6

KoHCXHxyuHH

K

AJiHxejibHOMy

saKJiioqe-

HHK)

B

KaXOp«lHOH

TIOpbMe.

B TOX

MOMOHX,

KOFA3

H6O6XOAH-

AHIU,KXCH

B

CBH3H

c

AaHHHM

npecxynjieHHeM.

ov

E

tr

ft

03

a

CO

1

o

ft

1

03

£53

a

ro

03

ft

ro

X

o

OV

ft

3

a

H

ro

fa

_w

a

»

9

CH

oca

yqexs

Apyrax

sjieMeHTOB

npecxynjienHH;

OHO

AOJI»<HO

Lov

o

a

13

S

ro

a

ro

a

K

S

H

a

03

a

E

a

ro

g

0

K

ro

a

1

CO

03

O

>

a

tr

nojiomeHtHH,

npeACxaBJiHiomHX

np3KTHqecKyio

nenHocxb;

see

33BHCHT

OX

o6cX05ITejIbCTB

KOHKpeTHOFO

CJiyq3H.

g

£53

tr

a

tr

X

L<

a

£53

ro

ta

a

tr

CO

a

13

i

1

a

tr

a

K

£53

S

X

Q

OV

B

a

x

npecTynjieHHeM

H

noaxoMy

sa

Heocxopo>KHoe

npecxynjieHHe

cjieAyex

iHasnaqHXb

Menee

xn^ejioe

eaKasaiHHe.

/IJIH

ecex

snaxb,

qxo

npn

npoqnx

paiBHbix

ycjioBHHX

y

HeocrapoKHocxH

MeHbiuaH

cxeneHb

XH^KBCXH,

qeM y

yMbicjia,

H qxo

HB>HAy

sxO'FO

TH^ecxb

npecxynjieHHH,

coBepmeHHoro

no

iHeocxopo>K-

HOCXH,

HBJIH6TCH

nOHHJKeHHOH

OO

CpaBHeHHK)

C

yMblUIJieHHblM

a)

ECJIH

33IKOH

npeAyCMSTpHBaeT

OAHHaKOBble

H3K333HHH

33

JMbHUJieHHOe

H

H6O'CXOpO>KHOe

COBepIU6HHe

KaKOrO-JIHSo

AeHCXBHH,

TO B

KaqecTBc

o^mero

nojio>KeHHH

MO>KHO

npn-

2.

BHHS

npecTynHHKa

B

saBHCHMocxn

ox

nojiomeiHHH

Be-

meft

MO'jKex

npeAcxasjiHXb

pasjinqayio

xH>Kecxb,

xo

ecxb

ncHxnqecKoe

oxHO'iueHHe

npecxynHHKa,

Bbicxynaioui.ee

B

c})op-

M6

yMblCJia

HJIH

HeOCXO'pOJKHOCXH,

MOJK6X

iHMCXb

'SoJlbUiyiO

HJIH

MeHbmyio

cxenenb

o6uiecxBeHHOH

onacnocxH

HJIH

MO-

pajibHo-nojiHXHqecKOH

npeAOcyAHxejibHocxH.

Tn>Kecxb

"

BHHbi

HeO'6xoAHMo

ycxaH3BjiHBaxb

B

Ka>KAOM

oxAejibHOM

cjiyqae,

xaK

K3K

B

OBS3H

c

ApyrHMH

3JieMeHxaMH

npecxynjieHHH

oiia

Boo'Sme

onpeAejinex

cxeneHb

o6mecxiBeHHOH

onacmocTH

H

npeAocyAHxejibiHOCTH

npecTynjieHHH

H

noaxoMy

oKasbisaex

cymecxBeHHOe

BJiHHHHe

na

onpeAejieHne

Mepu

HaKassunn.

rioaxoMy

HccjieAoiBaHHe

BHHH

B

npecxynjieHHH

He

MOJKBX

OFp3BHqHB3XbCH

XOJIbKO

perHCTp3U,HeH

nCHXOJIOFHqeCKHX

MO-

M6HXOB

H

COAep>K3Xb

XOJIbKO

FOJiyiO

KOHCT3X3U.HK)

TOFO,

qxo

T3Koe

ncHXHqecKoe

OTHOmeHHe

npeAcxaBJinex

oSmecxBeHHyio

onacHocxb,

a

AOJIJKHO

xaK>Ke

moKasaxb,

.KaKOBa

cxeneHb

SXOH

BHHbi

B

A3HHOM

icjiyq'ae.

BbisoBex

xe

>Ke

HJIH

Aa>Ke

eme

Cojiee

onacHue

nocjieACXBHfl,

qeM

yMbruijieHHoe

ero

coBepmeHHe,

H

FAB

npecxynjienne

co-

BiepuiaexcH

BBHAy

HeAKCuHnjiHHHpoBaHHocxH

(n. 2 § 7

rio-

cxaiHiOiBJieiHHH

o

xosHHCTBeHHbix

inpecxynjieH^Hx

H § 45

noexa-

HOBJICHHH

06

oxpane

pa6oqeH

CHJIH)

.

Лекшас Й. Вина как субъективная сторона преступления

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.