1272 CHAPTER 19
cascading plates, etc. can be used for dirty service since they may be more tolerant
to fouling, avoid the accumulation of foulants, or may be easier to clean, but these
types of plates usually have much lower contacting efficiencies than the traditional
types.
It should evident that the correct operation of a fractionation column requires a delicate
equilibrium among all the flows and the pressure gradients across the trays. If, for
example, the liquid capacity of the column is increased, the quantity of liquid on the
trays and in the downspouts will also increase, and so will the pressure differential
across the plate. This may cause even more liquid to back up the downspouts and
the system becomes unstable. The outcome usually is that the column fills up with
liquid or, in common terms, it becomes flooded. It is, therefore, important to design
the column for operation at a point sufficiently distant from flooding—usually about
70% or 80%—that this situation will not arise. Flooding can be related to a number
of parameters: flow rate of the liquid or vapor is but one of them; another could be the
separation between plates that affects the static pressure head, and also the frothing
characteristics, if any, of the liquid. It is usually recommended to maintain a tray
spacing equal at least to twice the height of the liquid in the downspout, but these
rules are often violated in order to save in column height and cost. Other solutions that
allow for the reduction of the spacing between trays may include the use of multiple
downcomer trays, often denoted as MD trays (Figure 19.T.4).
MD trays may have different layouts with various downcomer arrangements available
that can vary from parallel to cross flows at 90
◦
angles. In the latter case, the trays have
two-fold symmetry around two centerlines, which intersect at 90
◦
. This symmetry
arises from the rotation by 90
◦
of the inlet downcomers with respect to the outlet
downcomers on the next tray. This rotation also forces the liquid to flow across the
tray in a 90
◦
turn. MD trays allow for relatively short tray-to-tray distances. Several
diameters up to 12–15 m have been commercialized. Multiple upcomer (MU) trays
also exist and are often used in liquid–liquid extraction applications.
In all of the above the separations are effected by contacting the liquid and the vapor
across mechanical (usually metallic) discrete units (trays or plates). Another possi-
bility is to contact descending liquid with ascending vapor over an extended surface
like that provided by the presence of a coarse or porous packing within the distillation
vessel. Such packings usually have uniform metallic, ceramic, or polymeric structures
like Raschig rings, or Berl saddles, or may even consist of rigid interlaced packing
structures (usually metallic but sometimes also ceramic). The number of stages in this
case is not discrete as in a tray column but, instead, is calculated on the basis of the
height equivalent of a theoretical plate (HETP) or the height of a transfer unit (HTU).
These columns usually have no upcomers or downcomers or other mechanical di-
viders (except for provisions to hold the packing in discrete segments for mechanical