Gillespie picked up the rumor on May 29, Sutter recorded it in his diary on
June 3, and his biographer Al Hurtado concluded Sutter had a “sincere belief that
it was real.” Sutter checked attempts on his life, while Fre
´
mont’s men predictably
massacred five villages along the Sacramento River of innocent Maidus.
The alleged Californio threat, though, led worried Americans to look to the
army officer for leadership. Between May 3 0 and June 8, they gathered around
Fre
´
mont. Settler William Ide received an unsigned note reading: “Notice is hereby
given, that a large body of armed Spaniards on horseback, amounting to 250 men,
has been seen on their way to the Sacramento Valley, destroying crops, burning the
houses, and driving off the cattle. Capt. Fre
´
mont invites every freeman in the
valley to come to his camp.”
In this case, loose talk gave rumor credibility. On June 5, General Castro asked
General Vallejo for 170 horses to be driven to his headquarters in S anta Clara to
use in his co ming campaig n against Governor Pico. However, whe n L ieutenant
Francisco Arce crossed with the herd at Knight’s Landing (Grafton, Yolo County),
he made belligerent remarks about using them a gainst the Americans. Ferryman
William Knight rushed to Fre
´
mont’s camp.
Settlers badgered Fre
´
mont as to whether he would participate, and he gave dif-
ferent answers at different times. Recent biographer Tom Chaffin concluded he
was a “nervous prevaricator.” General Mariano Vallejo felt Fre
´
mont had a “very
elastic conscience,” while Ide suspected Fre
´
mont wanted “neutral conquest,” that
is, he wanted General Castro to begin hostilities.
With implied consent from Fre
´
mont, on June 9, Zeke Merritt left with a small
party of men, who surp rised Arce on June 10, and returned with the horses early
on June 11. Fre
´
mont “highly applauded” the act, according to Ide, but refused to
accept the horses for the United States. The raid, though, led the settlers to neutral-
ize the one Mexican settlement in the area, Sonoma. Merritt’s party of 33 started
that afternoon.
The set tlers arrived in the undefended town early on September 14, and began
spirited negotiations with the hospitable General Vallejo for his surrender.
Merritt began, Bob Semple joined him, and then John Grigsby and Sam Kelsey
came in. Finally teetotaler William Ide found that “The bottles had well nigh
vanquished the captors!” The victors finally marched Vallejo, his brother Salvador,
son-in-law and Alcalde Jacob Leese, and secretary Victor Prudon off to Fre
´
mont’s
camp.
Outside Vallejo’s Casa Grande, the restless settlers kept good order. Leaders
promptly squelched the one who wished to loot. However, the nature of their revolt
baffled them. John Grigsby asked if the leaders had “Captain Fre
´
mont’s name in
black an d white to au thorize you in this you have done?” When none could pro-
duce such a document, Grigsby declared, “I have been deceived. I resign and back
Bear Flag Revolt (1846) 335