9–47 Section 9.5 Counting Techniques 807
College Algebra Graphs & Models—
EXAMPLE 4
䊳
Counting Possibilities for Seating Arrangements
Adrienne, Bob, Carol, Dax, Earlene, and Fabian bought tickets to see The
Marriage of Figaro. Assuming they sat together in a row of six seats, how many
different seating arrangements are possible if
a. Bob and Carol are sweethearts and must sit together?
b. Bob and Carol are enemies and must not sit together?
Solution
䊳
a. Since a restriction has been placed on the seating arrangement, it will help to
divide the experiment into a sequence of tasks: task 1: they sit together; task 2:
either Bob is on the left or Bob is on the right; and task 3: the other four are
seated. Bob and Carol can sit together in five different ways, as shown in
Figure 9.56, so there are five possibilities for task 1. There are two ways they
can be side-by-side: Bob on the left and Carol on the right, as shown, or Carol
on the left and Bob on the right. The remaining four people can be seated
randomly, so task 3 has possibilities. Under these conditions they can
be seated ways.
b. This is similar to part (a), but now we have to count the number of ways they can
be separated by at least one seat: task 1: Bob and Carol are in nonadjacent seats;
task 2: either Bob is on the left or Bob is on the right; and task 3: the other four
are seated. For tasks 1 and 2, be careful to note there is no multiplication involved,
just a simple counting. If Bob sits in seat 1 (to the left of Carol), there are four
nonadjacent seats on the right. If Bob sits in seat 2, there are three nonadjacent
seats on the right. With Bob in seat 3, there are two nonadjacent seats to his right.
Similar reasoning for the remaining seats shows there are possibilities
for Bob and Carol not sitting together (by symmetry, Bob could also sit to the
right of Carol). Multiplying by the number of ways the other four can be seated
task 3 gives 20 possible seating arrangements. We could also reason
that since there are random seating arrangements and 240 of them
consist of Bob and Carol sitting together, the remaining must
consist of Bob and Carol not sitting together. More will be said about this type of
reasoning in Section 9.6.
Now try Exercises 21 through 28
䊳
C. Distinguishable Permutations
In the game of Scrabble
®
(Milton Bradley), players attempt to form words by rearrang-
ing letters. Suppose a player has the letters P, S, T, and O at the end of the game. These
letters could be rearranged or permuted to form the words POTS, SPOT, TOPS, OPTS,
POST, or STOP. These arrangements are called permutations of the four letters. A per-
mutation is any new arrangement, listing, or sequence of objects obtained by changing
an existing order. A distinguishable permutation is a permutation that produces a
result different from the original. For example, a distinguishable permutation of the
digits in the number 1989 is 8199.
Example 4 considered six people, six seats, and the various ways they could be
seated. But what if there were fewer seats than people? By the FPC, with six people
and four seats there could be different arrangements, with six people
and three seats there are different arrangements, and so on. These
rearrangements are called distinguishable permutations. You may have noticed that for
six people and six seats, we will use all six factors of 6!, while for six people and four
seats we used the first four, six people and three seats required only the first three, and
so on. Generally, for n people and r seats, the first r factors of n! will be used. The
notation and formula for distinguishable permutations of n objects taken r at a time is
By defining the formula includes the case where all n objects
are selected, which of course results in
n
P
n
⫽
n!
1n ⫺ n2!
⫽
n!
0!
⫽
n!
1
⫽ n!.
0! ⫽ 1,
n
P
r
⫽
n!
1n ⫺ r2!
.
6
#
5
#
4 ⫽ 120
6
#
5
#
4
#
3 ⫽ 360
720 ⫺ 240 ⫽ 480
6! ⫽ 720
#
4! ⫽ 480
10
#
2 ⫽ 20
5
#
2
#
4! ⫽ 240
4! ⫽ 24
Bob
1
Carol
2
3 4 5 6
1
Bob
2
Carol
3
4 5 6
1 2
Bob
3
Carol
4
5 6
1 2 3
Bob
4
Carol
5
6
1 2 3 4
Bob
5
Carol
6
Figure 9.56
B. You’ve just seen how
we can count possibilities
using the fundamental
principle of counting
cob19545_ch09_806-817.qxd 1/7/11 8:05 PM Page 807