Origins of Hollywood Divided 221
dramatic project in a more traditional manner. The disagreements between
Forman and Wexler led to the cinematographer being fired and replaced by
Bill Butler. Thus, as it turns out, Butler was the director of photography on
the year’s most edgy counterculture movie and on the first high-concept film,
Jaws. Cuckoo’s Nest was shot in an empty wing of the Oregon State Hospital in
Salem, which had been built in 1883. Nearly all of the film’s action occurs in
a single room, and much of the filming was done with a handheld camera.
Cuckoo’s Nest won all five Oscars for 1975 in the top categories: Best Di-
rector for Forman, Best Actor for Jack Nicholson (as Randle Patrick McMur-
phy), Best Actress for Louise Fletcher (as Nurse Ratched), Best Screenplay for
Larry Hauben, and Best Cinematography for Bo Goldman. Forman had made
his fame in Czechoslovakia directing his own original scripts, but in Cuckoo’s
Nest, he was working from an adaptation of a popular novel about a rebellious
individual who is in a mental institution because he resists authority and not
because he is crazy. The editing team of Richard Chew, Lynee Klingman, and
Sheldon Kahn achieved a pacing that was vital to the kind of frenetic look and
feel that Forman wanted in One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest.
Marlon Brando, Gene Hackman, and even Burt Reynolds were consid-
ered for the role of McMurphy before it went to Nicholson. As for Nurse
Ratched, the part was turned down by five better-known actresses (Anne
Bancroft, Colleen Dewhurst, Geraldine Page, Ellen Burstyn, and Angela
Lansbury) before Fletcher took it. The cast included Danny DeVito, playing
Martini, and this screen veteran was joined by newcomers Christopher Lloyd
(“Taber”), Will Sampson (“Chief”), and Brad Dourif (“Billy Bibbit”), each of
whom was making his screen debut in a feature film.
Since the 1950s, the theme of nonconformity had been popular enough
in Hollywood film, from Rebel without a Cause (1955) to A Thousand Clowns
(1965) to Easy Rider (1969). Nonetheless, a number of critics attributed the
popular response to One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest to its timely release soon
after the military defeat of the United States in Vietnam and the Watergate
scandal, whose cover-up led to President Richard Nixon’s resignation. On
the other hand, the review in the industry trade journal Variety questioned
whether audiences would perceive the movie version of the 1962 novel as
topical and current:
Kesey, a major intellectual catalyst of the Beatnik era, is virtually an elder
statesman of the avant-garde. . . . Sadly, the ideas herein are today as earth-
shattering as the [birth control] pill, as revolutionary as pot, and as relevant
as the Cold War. Gladly, however, their transfer to the screen is potent,
contemporary, compelling. And so, the young in head like the young in age
can be drawn equally to this film. . . . Then, too, there is the idea, at least
prominent in modern fiction, that mental institutions are ideal as metaphors