rll
I
e\l
a
\
\c
!
FI
qD
SJ
qJ
C:
s
a.
l\<
I
I
t
rcHngd^r
ilHI
Exbrrg
EHHmlfoJ
eg/tdr
s
xohrlg
an
udoe,{Q
-Qav
ruv
ltaeYou
q'ld
8
3
8
REAEOES
.E
+NcOtr)tOO'+OcO(O
oi
"i
ci
rl-si
ai oi
oi
oi
oi
rtltllt
poeH,Hbrx
HJrH 3anpoeKTr{poBaHHblx B nocJr,eAHHe
roAbr,
trpH-
H,HMaloT,cfl TaKlKe Tpy6br
BbI,coTot:I
h:2,2:2,3Dt
(Hanpn-
Mep,
JtJb
9, 12,23
puc.
2-7) .
AnnHa
orcacbrBarorr{Hx
rpy6 TaK)Ke
'I,t3MeHfiercf
,B
,Becb-
M a
IXHpOKHX npeAeJrax
n
O6UqUO
,OOCTa-BJrfl€T
OT
-
3,5
AO
6,0Dr. Hara6oJree
KoporKr{e
rpy6br ocyqecrBJreHbr Ha
rn.{,p,oi
crarHrluflx CCCP.
Ta,x,
Ha
Bepxue-Crnnp,cr<ofi
14 Pn6nncrofi
fOC
npr{
iBbl,core
or,ca,cbrBarouert
Tpy6br
h:1,915Dr
AJTHHa
'coorB,eT'cTBeHHo
paiB'Ha
3,43 vr 3,37D1.
3a
rno,c.neAHl{e
roAbl
Ha6JlroAaer,cfl TeHAeHr-(Hfl K
HerrcTo-
poMy yBefiHqeHHro
AJr'r{.Hbr
orca,cbrBarorrlHx Tpy6
(Ne
4, 11,
2I
u
23,
puc.
2-7)
,
Ho
rBce
x{e
oHa ocraeicfl
Me'Hbrrre,
rreM
Ha
MHofHx
3apy6ex(HbrX
f3C.
Eonrruoe
pa3Hoo6paene,napaM,erpoB
npH,MeHfleMbrx orca-
cbrBaroilrHx
rpy6
Lrrn
THApocTaHrIH,rl,
cTpoflultrxcfl
B
BecbMa
6nusrux neoflorllqecKux
ycJloBuflx,,cBu,{,ereJlb'cruyeT,
no-BH-
AHMOMy,,O
He',COBep[reHCTBe,CyIlleCTByrOrlIHX
Cef,rqaC
frOprrr
o'TcacbrBaroqux rpy6 H,HeAocrarorrHocru
pa3paboTaHrrrblx
H
npuMeHfleMbrx
B
HBCTOflUIee
lBpeMfl
MeTOAaX SKOH'OMHqeOnOri
oueHKH HX eSQe'xrrlBHocrn.
Bo
M,HorHX cflyrlafx
r,r3-3a He-
IIp aBHJrhHro
lcr?,HoBJreHHbrx
p
a3M epoB
orca,cbrBarouefr
rpy6br
rHApocraHqHH HeAoBbrpa6aftr'saroT'3HaqHTeJIbHoe
KoJIHqecT-
BO sJreKTp O,3He'p rr{H.
(Dopuu
r{3orHyrbrx
orcacbrBarorllHx Tpy6,
rrpnMeHflsMbrx
3a
py6ex(oM,
qacro
Bo
MHoroM orJnrqHbr or
npuMeHrreMblx
y
Hac.
3ro
pagflHqHe
3aKJlroqaerct KaK
,Bo
,BHettIH'Hx,
TaK
H
BO
BHyTpeHHHX
pa3Mepax
KaIKAOTO
gJreMe:HTa
rpy6rr.
HopnnaJrr43oBaHrrbre
orcacbrBarcuHe rpy6br .IlM3
xapaK-
Tepl{3yroTcfl oTHocI{TeJIbHo BbIcoKHMI'I
HarraIbHbIM?I I@HyCa-
MH
H Hr{3KHMH
KOJIeHaMH,
TOfAa XOK
,rrPaKTHrKa
CIIIA Bbrpa-
6otana rz,n
rpy6br
c
6onee
KoporKHM
KoHy,c'oM,
H,o s:na.ur-
TeJIbHo 6o.nee
BbIcoKI,IM KoJIeHoM.
Tax
xax nau6onr[rue
ruApatsJrl{qecKne
norepr{
B H3or,Hy-
TbIx rpy6ax
HMeror Mecro
B
KoJreHe u
BbIpaBHHBaHHe rroTo-
Ka
HMeer
3Aecb
oco6o Bax(Hoe
3HaqeHLIe,
Qoprvra
r{oJreHa
orcacbrBarouerl rpy6br raKlKe
pasrurrHa-_KoJreHo
ryy6nr
.IlM3 no
A/rHHe
HMeer B
,cpeAHeM
or{eHb
MaJryro
auQ$yeop-
H,o'crb,
TorAa
KaK 3apy6ex{une
$oplrbr
oTcacbrBarou?rx
rpy6
r{acro
HMeroT
rro
AJTHHe
:KoJreHa
nor{TH
Ty
x{e
AHOQysop-
HocTb,
r{To
u B
KoHyce
HJru
ar,r$Sysope
(,no4po6H€€
oT
sroM
B rJr.
5
u 7).
Ann
eue 6onruero
BbrpaBHl{Barur{fl
nmoKa
B KOJreHe B Sapy6elKHorl
rnp?KTHKe
CpaBrHHTeJrbHO
rraCTO
rrplrMerrfler'cfl ropH3oHranuuufi
paaAeJlurenluutt
6orqox.
47
li
t
lN
HH
l*J
t\
'-rA
'
.A
I I FEFF
I
io'NF
6l
t==5F
tF
l<hLi
ttlll
r UIr t
I
rn Q
|
|
F\o
rrttt
lllll
cQ
l\
ttlll
*[d
-fo
eHuaordo'1
oorr)ocjF-co@
-orooscooY
@ro.+(o(orr)rr).d
F-
t-
ro
ro.dooroaA
N66rbF-.roor:€
I F...
c-l
c.l
o.l
rF
rH rE
g
(O r.()
cO
(O
ocq(ol
cO
.O rO
E
E
E
F,FFERE
E
:l36tR9\90)6
n
ovF
(|Jo
h
Hnwl90'u
F-
c7)
rO
+
+
rJ).a(^Ol.-@
(o
O)
rI)
$
tO
(-n
(O
.+
F-
(l:)
cO
cO
rr)
w,h'cBdH
w
,t^^H
tnr
'o\t^H
rr)o(otooooolf-ol
lO
= \ e :RefrE39
R
O.+rO
It-lll
llo)lllt-R
c\i
rl-ll
ffi
*"r'9d[tN
qreJllsoroJ€H
-(er{duQ)
vose€
4
14
c-)
h
ts
O.
is
t1r
a.
>+
XJi
elsH
6F
.:
H AF
*!(J
g
iE rif
8ge
;Xle
I
E{{
#EB
trt
F-
d
I
r|
'l
*
46
-or E
eE
troOO)Ool9Q
io(c)C)(of.-F-N