
A.D.
1483. MURDER OF THE PRINCES. II9
an impostor counterfeited the younger; but even he, to give
credit to his pretensions, expressly admitted the murder of his
elder brother.
Nevertheless there have been writers in modern days who
have shown plausible grounds for doubting that _
r o ° Doubts of
the murder really took place. Two contemporary modem
, . , - , writers.
writers, they say, mention the fact only as a
report; a third certainly states it incorrectly, at least, in
point of time; and Sir Thomas More, who is the only one
remaining, relates it with certain details which it does seem
difficult to accept as credible. More's account, however, must
bear some resemblance to the truth. It is mainly founded
upon the confession of two of the murderers, and is given
by the writer as the most trustworthy report he had met with.
If, therefore, the murder be not itself a fiction, and the
confession, as has been surmised, a forgery, we should expect
the account given by Sir Thomas More to be in the main true,
clear, and consistent, though Horace Walpole and others have
maintained that it is not so.
The substance of the story is as follows. Richard, some
time after he had set out on his progress, sent a special
messenger and confidant, by name John Green, to Sir Robert
Brackenbury, the constable of the Tower, commanding him
to put the two princes to death. Brackenbury refused to obey
the order, and Green returned to his master at Warwick. The
king was bitterly disappointed. ' Whom shall a man trust,' he
said, ' when those who I thought would most surely serve me,
at my command will do nothing for me?' The words were
spoken to a private attendant, or page, who told him, in reply,
that there was one man lying on a pallet in the outer chamber
who would hardly scruple to undertake anything whatever to
please him. This was Sir James Tyrell, who is described by
More as an ambitious, aspiring man, jealous of the ascendency
of Sir Richard Ratcliffe and Sir William Catesby. Richard at
once acted upon the hint, and, calling Tyrell before him,