34 1 Introduction to Quantum Information Processing
precise, continuous eigenvalues. However, for two qumodes, we need two such
eigenvalues, corresponding to two nonlocal observables with ( Ox
1
Ox
2
)jΨ (u, v )iD
u jΨ (u, v)i and ( Op
1
COp
2
)jΨ (u, v )iDvjΨ (u, v)i.
Expressed in terms of the WH shift operators, we can equivalently write for all t, s,
e
2itu
e
C2it( Ox
1
Ox
2
)
jΨ (u, v)iDe
2itu
Z(t) ˝ Z
†
(t)jΨ (u, v ) i
DjΨ (u, v)i ,
e
C2isv
e
2is( Op
1
COp
2
)
jΨ (u, v)iDe
C2isv
X(s) ˝ X(s)jΨ (u, v)i
DjΨ (u, v)i . (1.97)
In other words, for the unphysical, infinitely correlated CV Bell states, we obtain
the nonlocal stabilizer generators
he
C2isv
X(s) ˝ X(s), e
2itu
Z(t) ˝ Z
†
(t)i . (1.98)
Note that for v D 0, this would be a unique representation for the famous two-
particle state presented by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen (EPR) which i s quan-
tum mechanically correlated in the positions (x
1
x
2
D u) and the momenta
(p
1
C p
2
D 0) [23]. In the optical context, a physical version of the EPR state corre-
sponds to a Gaussian two-mode squeezed state in the limit of large squeezing (see
Chapter 3). Moreover, similar to the two-qubit stabilizers, the two-qumode stabiliz-
ers here are useful to construct so-called entanglement witnesses. These witnesses
would enable one to detect the entanglement of the physical, finitely correlated, and
possibly even noisy mixed-state approximations of the EPR state. How to find such
witnesses for qubits and qumodes will be discussed in Chapter 3. At this point, we
shall proceed by looking at the entanglement of mixed states, inseparability criteria,
and the definition of entanglement witnesses.
Given an arbitrary two-party (e.g., two-qubit or two-qumode) density operator,
how can we find out whether the bipartite state is entangled or not? For this pur-
pose, first of all, a definition of entanglement is needed which goes beyond that
of pure-state entanglement expressed by the Schmidt rank and so is applicable to
mixed states as well.
1.5.2
Mixed States and Inseparability Criteria
A mixed state of two parties is separable if its total density operator can be written as
a mixture (a convex sum) of product states,
25)
O
12
D
X
i
η
i
O
i,1
˝O
i,2
. (1.99)
25) Corresponding to a classically correlated
state [37]. For instance, for the qubit or
the qumode Bell states, the nonclassical
character of entanglement is reflected by the
nonlocal stabilizer generators simultaneously
in terms of X and Z. However, note that
this notion of nonlocality is weaker than the
historically well-known notion of nonlocality
that refers to the inapplicability of local
realistic models. In fact, Werner’s [37]
original intention was to demonstrate that
quantum states exist which are inseparable
according to the convex-sum definition and
yet admit a local realistic description.