-
As a painter he remained a draftsman, far less interested in color
than in line, seeking above all to draw an expressive form, to fix
in art some human attitude, or to convey through a design a philosophy
of life. The hand was that of Pheidias or Apelles, the voice was
Jeremiah's or Dante's. On one of his passages between Florence and
Rome he must have stopped at Orvieto and studied the nudes that
Signorelli had painted there; these, and the frescoes of Giotto and
Masaccio, gave some hints to a style that was nevertheless unlike
anything else that history has preserved. Far beyond and above the
others, even beyond Leonardo, Raphael, and Titian, he brought to his
art, and brought out in his art, nobility. He did not dally with
decoration or triviality; he cared nothing for prettiness, landscapes,
architectural backgrounds, arabesques; he let his subject stand out
stark and unadorned. His mind was caught by a high vision, to which he
gave form, as well as the hand could, in the shape of sibyls,
prophets, saints, heroes, and gods. His art used the human body as its
medium, but those human forms were to him the tortured embodiments
of his hopes and terrors, his confused philosophy, and his
smoldering religious faith.
Sculpture was his favorite and characteristic art because it is
the preeminent art of form. He never colored his statues, feeling that
form was enough; even bronze had too much color for him, and he
confined his sculpture to marble. `052368 Whatever he painted or built
was sculptural, even to St. Peter's dome. He failed as an architect
(barring that sublime cupola) because he could hardly conceive a
building except in terms and proportions of the human body, and
could barely suffer it to be more than a receptacle of statuary; he
wanted to cover all surfaces, instead of making surfaces an element of
form. Sculpture was a fever with him; the marble, he thought,
obdurately hid a secret, which he was resolved to extricate; but the
secret was in himself, and was too intimate for full revelation.
Donatello helped him a little, della Quercia more, the Greeks less, in
the struggle to give the inner vision outward form. He agreed with the
Greeks in devoting most of his art to the body, leaving the faces
generalized and almost stereotyped, as in the female figures on the
Medici tombs; but he never achieved- his temper would not let him care