one can see a consistency in Breytenbach’s political
ideology: The oppression of dissident groups,
whether that of a minority holding a minority in
check or that of a willful majority, should not be
allowed to pass unremarked.
Critical Analysis
Breytenbach occupies a unique position in the
African literary tradition. Like André BRINK and Na-
dine GORDIMER he has often written of political op-
pression and his distaste for the apartheid regime
in South Africa. Breytenbach and Brink are also the
most well-known writers who publish in Afrikaans,
the language of the Dutch settlers, and those most
often, and sometimes unfairly, vilified for all of
apartheid’s wrongs. Like another countryman, J. M.
COETZEE, Breytenbach often plays with language at
multiple levels. Their willingness to experiment
with language, reveling in the multiplicity of possi-
bilities for confusion and misunderstanding, is re-
ferred to as “postmodernism”: a celebration of
fragmentary, rather than unified, meaning, the pur-
pose of which is meant to make readers think about
not only what they read but also what they believe.
This “playfulness” has often been criticized and
stands as one end of the spectrum of opinion on
Breytenbach. Ultimately, Breytenbach stands alone,
like so many of the protagonists of his novels. Isola-
tion, introspection, scathing self-analysis, and a re-
fusal to use fictions as a crutch for existence mark
both his poetry and his prose. For example, in Dog
Heart: A Memoir (1999), he writes that he needs to
see the child he once was to determine how he has
become the man he is: “Why, after all these years,
do I feel the urge to go and look for the other one,
the child I must have been?”
J. M. Coetzee has commented on Dog Heart in
his collection, Stranger Shores: Literary Essays
1986–1999 (2001). He sees Breytenbach’s text as
typical of those narratives which mine his, and
South Africa’s, past: “Like Breytenbach’s other
memoirs, Dog Heart is loose, almost miscellaneous,
in its structure. Part journal, part essay on autobi-
ography, part book of the dead, part what one
might call speculative history, it also contains
searching meditations on the elusiveness of mem-
ory and passages of virtuoso writing ...breathtak-
ing in the immediacy of their evocation of Africa.”
Even in what are recognizably novels, Breyten-
bach melds the real with the fantastic. For example,
Memory of Snow and Dust (1989) concerns itself
with fables of identity and the uncertainty that lies
underneath our solid sense of who we are. The plot
involves an Ethiopian journalist who meets and im-
pregnates a mixed-race South African woman while
they are in Switzerland for an arts festival, a “neu-
tral” cultural and political space carved out by both
custom and art. The journalist agrees to act as a spy
for an antiapartheid group and goes to South Africa
under an assumed name. But the identity under
which he is traveling is accused of murder, and the
would-be spy and absentee father cannot clear him-
self without revealing his own identity and betray-
ing his political comrades. Fictions such as Memory
of Snow and Dust call into question the seemingly
simple injunction that the lives and works of artists
are cleanly and clearly separate.
Breytenbach’s contributions and importance to
world literature are linked to the combination in
his works of the personal, political, and cultural in
ways that force readers to acknowledge the natu-
ralness of the connections.
Other Works by Breyten Breytenbach
In Africa Even the Flies are Happy: Selected Poems,
1964–1977. London: Calder, 1978.
Return to Paradise: An African Journal. New York:
Harcourt Brace, 1993.
A Work about Breyten Breytenbach
Jolly, Rosemary. Colonization, Violence, and Narration
in White South African Writing: André Brink,
Breyten Breytenbach, and J. M. Coetzee. Athens:
Ohio University Press, 1996.
Brink, André (1935– ) novelist, essayist,
playwright
André Brink, a white South African, writes in
Afrikaans, a national South African language de-
64 Brink, André