
Section A.1.3: Examples of using the definition • 673
Tempting as it is to write 3
2
= 9 and declare victory, that doesn’t work
because the limit only depends on what happens when x is near, but not
equal to, 3. So, we have to play our little game. You choose your ε > 0, which
makes a little window (9 − ε, 9 + ε) that I have to stay within. Now I get
to pick my δ. Suppose that your ε is 8, which is humongous in this context.
Then your window is (1, 17). Well, I can easily stay in there by choosing my
δ = 1, which means that my window is (2, 4). (Remember, my window is
centered at 3, while yours is centered at 9.) Indeed, if you square any number
between 2 and 4, you get a number between 4 and 16, so my move is fine. If
your ε is even bigger than 8, well, that just widens your interval, but I’ll stick
with my δ = 1 and be just fine.
Now, if you choose your tolerance ε less than 8, I have to change my tactic.
My choice in this case will be . . . drumroll . . . δ = ε/8. That is, I’m making
my window eight times smaller than yours, no matter how wide you choose
it. To see that this works, we have to be clever. Basically, we have to take
any number in my interval, square it, and show that it lies in your interval.
My interval is (3 − ε/8, 3 + ε/8) and yours is (9 − ε, 9 + ε).
So let’s pick x in my interval. How big could it be? It’s got to be less
than 3 + ε/8. That is, x < 3 + ε/8, which you can also write as x − 3 < ε/8.
By the way, since your ε is less than 8, my x is less than 4. So, using both
inequalities x − 3 < ε/8 and x < 4, we get
(x − 3)(x + 3) <
ε
8
(4 + 3) =
7ε
8
.
Since (x −3)(x + 3) is just x
2
−9, we can add 9 to both sides of the equation
and see that
x
2
< 9 +
7ε
8
.
So we’re OK on the upper tolerance level (the upper of your two lines). We
needed x
2
< 9 + ε, and we have done that. How about the lower one? Well,
how small could my x be, given that it lies in my interval (3 − ε/8, 3 + ε/8)?
It’s got to be bigger than 3 − ε/8, so we have x > 3 − ε/8. This means that
x − 3 > −ε/8. Since your ε is less than 8, we also have x − 3 > −8/8 = −1,
which means that x > 2. Again, using both inequalities x − 3 > −ε/8 and
x > 2, we get
(x − 3)(x + 3) >
−
ε
8
(2 + 3) = −
5ε
8
.
Once again, (x − 3)(x + 3) = x
2
− 9, so we add 9 to both sides and get
x
2
> 9 −
5ε
8
.
This takes care of the lower tolerance level! We have shown that if x lies in
the interval (3 − ε/8, 3 + ε/8), then x
2
is in the interval (9 − 5ε/8, 9 + 7ε/8).
Since both 5/8 and 7/8 are less than 1, we can also confidently say that x
2
is
in the interval (9 − ε, 9 + ε); after all, this interval contains the other one.
Tying it all together, let’s set f(x) = x
2
, and we’ll justify the equation
lim
x→3
f(x) = 9.