Токарский Н.М. Архитектура древней Армении
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
0"
He
TO
u.epKOBHoro,
He
TO
CTpOHTeJIbHOrO,
H
3a
He-
MHorHMH
HCKJlIoqeHH
SI
MH
IIOBTOPHIOT
Illa6JIOHHhIe
<pOPMbI,
Tenepb
Bce
60JIee
H
60JIee
BhITHrHBalOlllH-
eCH
no
BblCOTe.
BblCOKHH
6apa6aH
H
IIpeYBeJIHlJeHHO
KpYTa5J
OCTpOKOHe'lHa51
KPOBJI5I
KYIIOJIa,
KaK,
Ba-
npBMep,
B
He60JIbIllOH
allITapaKCKOH
~epKBH
MapHa~
'
He,
IIOr.Tp.
B
1281
r.,
oco60
IIO)I,lJepKHBaIOT
STO
CTpeMJIeHHe
BBepx,
XOPOIllO
oTpameHHoe
TaK)I{e
B
HeCKOJIbKHX
)1.ByxsTamHblx
IIOcTpoHKax.
Ta-
KOBhI
~epKBH
EOrOpO)I.HIl,bI
B
ErBapTe
1321
r.
(Ta6JI.
88) H
HopaBaHKe,
IIOCTp.
IIpe)I,nOJIO)l{HTeJIb-
HO B 1339
r.
(Ta6JI.
89).
HH)I{HHe
9T
'8)1{H
HX
npa-
MoyrOJIbHhI
B
IIJIaHe
H
HecyT
Ha
apKax
R CBO.D,ax
BepXHlO1O
BblT5IHYTYlO
'laCTb,
KPblJIb51
KOTOpO~,
no-
KpblThIe
)1.BYCK8THhIMH KPOBJI5IMH,
3aK8H'lHB8IOTCa
Ha
<i>aca)1.ax
lIl,HnIl,aMH.
Y
3KHe
HeY)1.o6Hble
JIeCTHHUbI
CO
cTyneHHMH,
3a)I.eJIaHHhIMH
KaK
KOHCOJIH B
CTeHY,
Be)1.YT BO BTOPQH
9Ta)l{.
B
Hopa
BaHKe
J(Be
TaKHe
JIeCTHHUbI,
OXBaThIB81Ollllie
nOpTaJI
BXOJla
B
HH)I{Hee
nOMell(eHHe,
HalJHHaIOTC5I y
caMOH
3eMJIH.
B
ErBapTe
cTyneHH
BH.D,HhI
TOJIbKO
Y
IIJIOw;aJlKH
BToporo
9TaiK8;
BepOHTHO
K
HBM
nO)I,CTaBJIHJIHCb
)I.epeBHHHhIe
JIeCT-
HHIl,hI,
KOTopble
MomHO
6bIJIO
y6HpaTb
B
CJIYQ8e
B03HHKHOBeHHH
KaKOH-JIH60
onaCHOCTH.
CBoe06p83-
HhIH
KYIIOJI
B BH.n.e POTOH)I.hI
Ha
)I.BeHa)I,Il,aTH KOJIOH-
Hax,
COe)1.HHeHHblX
Me)l{.llY
C060H
apK8MH,
IIOKPhITOA
CBO.l{OM
noJl,
KOHycoo6pa3HOH
KpOBJIeit,
HMeeTCJI
TOJIbKO B
ErBapTe.
B
HopaBaHKe
pa3pymeHo
JlaiK~
oCHoriaHHe
KynOJIa,
HO,
HeCMOTp51
Ha
STO
06CTO-
HTeJIbCTBO,
KOMII03HIl,HOHHOe
CXO)I.CTBO
060HX
n8MHT-
HHKOB
HaTOJIKHYJIO HaC
Ha
MblCJIb,
lJTO
OH
TO)l{e
HMeJI
BH,Zt
pOTOH~bI,
OT
KOTOPOH,
HaAO
.lI.YM8Tb,
H
COXP8-
311
HRJIRCb
HeKOTOpble
pa3p03HeHHble,
HO
OqeHb
RHTe-
peCHble
)J,eTaJIR.
3)J,eCb
Cpe)J,R
06JIOMKOB
nepeKpblTRA
BepXHerO
3Ta*a
~epKBH
6hIJIH
Hafi)J,eHhI
TpH
KOJIOH-
'
HhI,
06paTHBIIIHe
Ha
ce651
BHRMaHHe
H3Ba5lHHbIMH
Ha
HHX
'
6apeJIbecpaMH.
HaH.rr.eHO
TaK*e
HeCI{OJIbKO
6a3
OT
3THX
KOJIOHH
If
CTaJIaKTHTOBaH
KanHTeJIb.
npH
nonbITKe
Ha6pocaTb
peKOHCTpYK~HIO
POTOH.rr.hI
HaJl.
9TOA
nepKJBblO,
no.rr.06HOH:
erBapTCKOH,-pa3-
i.repbl
KOJIOHH,
6a3
H
KanHTeJIefi
OKa3hIBaKJTC5I
BnOJIHe
MaCIIITa6HbIMH
H
He
npenHTCTBYIOT
TaKOMY
pa3pe-
weHHlO
Bonpoca
0
KyrrOJIe,
TeM
60JIee,
l.JTO
If
BCR
CHCTeMa
y6paHcTBa
060HX
naM~THHKOB
npHHUHnH-
aJIbHO
O)J,HHaKOBa. *
4eM
*e
06'bHCHHTb
npHCYTCTBHe
15apeJIbecpoB
Ha
KOJIOHHaX,
KOTopble
MhI
CKJIOHHhI
DOCTaBHTb
Ha
CTOJIb
60JIbIIIylO
BhICOTy.
TyT
Ha
nOMomb
npHXO)J,HT
OHH
caMH;
Ha
Ka*.rr.oH
KOJIOHHe
HMeeTCH
no
O)lHofi
qmrype,
H3
KOTOPhIX
npH
COOT-
BeTCTBYlOmefi
paCCTaHOBKe
nOJIyqaeTCH
BnOJlHe
3a-
KOHqeHHan
KTHTopCKaH
rpyrrna:
nocpe.rr.HHe-Eoro-
Ma,.epb,
KOTOPOH
nOCBHlll,eHa
uepKOBb,
CTOHmaH
npHMO,
no
60KaM-MY)I{CKHe
cpHryphI
B ,
60raThIX
OAe
*.rr.a
X,
nOBepHYThIe
K
HeH,
npHqeM
JIeBaH
no.rr.-
HOCHT
Mo.rr.eJIb
U.epKBH.
TaKoe
pa3MemeHHe
KTHTO-
POB,
HaXO,lJ.HBIIIHXCH,
no
HaIIIeMY
MHeHUIO,
Ha.rr.
3a-
ni)lHblU
BXO,lJ.OM,
HeCKOJlbKO
He06hIQHO,
HO eCJIR
npHHHTb
"BO
BHHMaHHe,
l.JTO
II.J,HnUhI, r.rr.e
HX
06hIQHO
nOMew.aJlH,
6hI.im
3aH5ITbI
',
peJIbecpHhIMH
KpeCTaMH,
kOTOPblM
"H B
3TO
BpeMH
YKparnaJIHCb
CTeHbI
UePK-
*
Hallle
npelI.nOJIO>KeHHe 0 pOToHue nOlI.TBeplI.HJIO CnellHaJIb-
Hoe
o6CJIelI.OBaHHe
apnn.
JI.
Ca,J].Q5IHa.
Ha
3apHcoBKa
~
6apeJIb-
e4>oB
slCHO
BH.n.Hbl
KOJIQHHbI,
BeaqalOI.J..{He
Mo.n.eJIb
llepKBH.
812
/
J
/
~eA,
TO rrpH.n:eTCSI
rrpH3HaTb,
qTO
aBTOp
BbIllleJI
H3
~OiO)KeHHSI,
npOHBHB
60JIblllYlO
Ha
x O.n:lIHBOCTb.
'B
'CBSl3H C
rrOHBJIeHHeM
.lI.BYX9Ta)KHbIX
nepKBeA
OC06hlA
HHTepec
rrpH06peTaeT
,nByx9T3)KHaH
no-
CTpOHKa
B
HOp-reTHKe,
CTOSlIII.8H K
ceBepy
OT
60JIb-
illoA
nepKBH,
B
HH)KHeH
lIaCTH
KOTOPOH,
B03Be,neH-
~OH
Ha
,
60JIblllHX
e.lI.Ba
OOTecaHHbIX
KaMHeii"
HY)KHO
YCMoTpeTb
TO
MOHaCTblpCKoe
KHHrOXpaHHJlHIlle,
0
kOTOPOM
rOBopHT
K H P a K 0 C r a H J( 3 a
KC
K H H •
. B
1291
r.,
KaK
BH.lI.HO
H3
cTpOHTeJIbCKOH
HaJl~
~HCH,
HaJ(
KHHrOXpaHHJIHIII.eM
6b1JIa
rrocTpoeHa
KO-
JIOKOJIbHH C .lI.BYMH ·
qaCOBHHMH
B BOCTOlJHOY
KPblJIe.
!aK
K8K
CBOJ(qaTOe
HepeKphITHe
neHTpaJIbHOii
qa-
~TH
cTaporo
3.lI.aHHH
3HaqHTPJJbHO
B03BbIIIlaJIOCb
HaJ(
eroyrJIaMIi,
TO
CHaqaJIa
HaJ(CTpOHJIH
ero
HapY)KHhIe
CTeHhI
HaCTOJIbKO,
IITo
'
6bI
CBeTOBoe
OTBepCTlre
B
CBO,iJ.e
HHlKHero
9Ta)Ka
paCnOJIOiKHJIOCb
Ha
ypOBHe
rrOJIa KOJIOKOJIbHH, a
3aTeM
Y)Ke
B03BeJIH
CTeHbI
ca-
MoA
KOJIOKOJIbHH
Ha
rrepeKpeIII.HBalOIII.HXCH
a
pKax
KHHrOXpaHHJIHIUa,
6JIarO.lI.apH
qeMY
rrJIaH
ee
rrpH06peJI
kpeCTo06pa3HYlO
<P0PMY.
KPIiIJIbH
HQBOH
rrOCTpOHKH
6hIJIH
rrOKphITH
.lI.BYCKaTHhIMH
KPOBJIHMH,
KOTOPhIM
Ha
<pacaJ(ax
OTBeqalOT
III.HIJUbI.
UeHTpaJIbHaH
qaCTb
eE'
aaBepIIlalIaCb
POTOH.lI.Oii
(OT
KOJIOHH
KOTOPOH
Ha
MeCTe
COXpaHHJIHCb
TOJIbKO
6a
:
~bI),
OCHOBaHHOH:
Ha
ToA
rrpeBocxo,nHOH
KOHCTPYKII.HH
H3
pHnOB
HaBHcalO-
lUHX
.n:pyr
HaJ(
.lI.pyroM
TIJIHT, C
KOTOPOH
l.JHTaTeJIb
6b1JI
rr03HaKOMJIeH
paHee
(Ta6JI.
65).
, 3.n:aHHe,
rrOJIyqeHHOe
B
pe3YJIbTaTe
Ha.lI.CTpoii-
im,
no
CBOHM
06III.HM
<popMaM
BeCbMa
CXOJ(HO ' C
nepKBaMH
B
ErBapTe
H
HopaBaHKe,
XOTH
B
HeM
tooTHoweHHe
BblCOT
HHIKHeii
H
BepXHeii
qaCTeH
813
(
HeCKOJIbKO
HHOe;
60JlbIlIaSl
BblCOTa
HH)KHerO
eTa-
·
)Ka
3,neCb
06'bSlCHSleTCH
He06xo,lJ.HMOCTblO
CKpblTb
3a.
CTeHaMH
CTapOe
06'beMHCT0e
nepeKpWTHe,
KOTOpOe
CTpOHTeJIH
peIlIHJIH
COXpaHHTh.
KOJIOKOJIhHH
6b1JIa
nOCTpOeHa
B
MOHaCTblpe,
nOJIh30BaBIlIeMCH
60JIblllOA
.
H3BeCTHOCTblO,
Ha
TpH~u.aTh-copOK
JIeT
paHee
Ha3BaH-
HhlX
u.epKBeH,
H
910
n03BOJIHeT
,nYMaTb,
lJTO
OHa
.
MOrJIa
HaTOJIKHYTh
30,lJ.lJHX
KaK
Ha
H,nelO
,lJ.BYXSTaiK-
Horo
U.epKOBHoro
3,naHHH,
TaK
H
Ha
3aMeHY
KynOJIa
.
POTOH,D.OH.
CpaBHHBaeMble
lIaMHTHHI<H
Ha
nepBhll
B3rJIH~
.
pe3KO
OTJIHqalOTCH
HapYiKHoA
oT,neJII<oA
•.
CTeHhI
nepKBeH
]!I
ErBapTe
' H
HopaBaHKe
H3yKpa-
IlIeHbI
KOJlOHKaMH,
apOlJI{aMH,
KpeCTaMH
H
pe3HblM.
opHaMeHTOM;
MOiKHO
nO,lJ.YM8Th, lJTO
3,neCb
MaCTepa
3a,D.aJIHCb u.eJIhlO
c06paT
.h BOe,D.HHO
Bce,
qTO
6blJIO
B,
XO,D.Y
B
y6paHcTBe
XIII-XIV
BB.,
Kor,na
60raTblA
•.
HO CnOI<OHHblR
apXHTeKTypHbl
.H HapSl,D.
aHHA-
CKHX
u.epKBeH
HaqaJIa
XIII
B.
yCTynHJI
MeCTO
,neKO~
paTHBHhlM
_
SJIeMeHTaM,
n,o,D.qac
6e3
OpraHHqe-
CKOA: CBH3H C
apxHTeKTypHblMH
JIHHHHMH
3anOJI-
BHBlllHM
nOBepxHocTb
CTeH.
B
Hop-feTHKe
CTeHbIi
KOJIOKOJIhHH
06JIHUOBaHhI
lJHCTO
TecaHWMH
IIJIHTaMR
6e3
BCHKHX
YKpallleHHA,
HO STO
He
HBJISleTCH
pe3YJIb-
TaTOM
TBOplJeCKOrO
3aMblCJIa
30,nlJerO,
a
npOH-
30111JlO
nponm
.
era
BOJIH
H3-3a
KaKHX-TO
nOCTopOH-
HHX
npHIlHH.
,LI.eJIO B
TOM,
qTO
Ha
.llByX
HHiK-
HHX
pHAax
06JIHU.OBKH
BepXHeH
KpeCTo06pa3HOH.
qaCTH
BH,nHhI
nOJIYKOJIOHKH
C
6a3aMH,
KOTophle
no
,
nepBOHalJaJIbHOMY
npoeKTY
1l0JliKHhI
6hIJIH
yl{paCHT~
CTeHbl
TaK
)Ke,
KaK
STO
c,neJIaHO
n03,nHee
B
Er
Bap-
Te
H
HopaBaHKe.
nOCTpOHKY
Ha
STOM,
BH,lJ.HMO,.
npHWJIOCb
npepBaTb
Ha
npOllOJIIKHTeJIbHO~
BpeMH
~
314:
nOCJIe
qero
B03MOiKHOCTH
1
KOTepbIMH
p3CnOJI3raJIH
t
~T
pOHTeJIH,
OKa3aJIHCb
60JIee
OrpaHHQeHHhIMH,
He
'
n03BOJIHBIlIHMH
,naiKe
6JIeCHY1lb
Ol')leJIKOH
BXO~3,
KOTOPhlH
CKPOMHO
06paMJlea
KOJIOHKaMH H
CJIerKa
·
Ha~JIOMJIeHHOH
ap01JKoH.
3KCKYPCHIO
no
naMHTHHKaM
uepKOBHoro
30)1.--
qeCTBa
XIII-XIV
BB.
MOiKHO
3aBepIlIHTb
03H!KOM
+-
JIeHHeM
C e,nHHCTBeHHOH B
CBoeM
pO)l.e
n,epKOBItIO,
aaxo,nHIIl.eHCH
Ha
XOJlMe
OKOJlO· CeJIeHHH
AJIaH3
B
:t
6b1BIlIHX
BJla)1,eHHHX
pO)la
Op6eJlBHHOB.
C BOCTOKa
:i!
OHa
HMeeT
06hIQHhIH
BHA:
nOBblIlIeHHhIH:
mHneu
Cpe,lJ.HeH
qaCTH
C
KPYTO
nO.lI.blMalOmeHCH
,nBYCKaTHOHi
]<pOBJI
'
eH,
o,nHOCKaTHhle
KPOBJlH
no
60KaM,
.n:~e
TpeyrOJlbHhIe
HHIlIH,
npope3alOmHe
qHCTO
TecaHYIO
'
rJlallb
CTeHhI.
C 3ana)1,a
iKe
MbI
OKa3hIBaeMCH
He
-
nOCpe)1,CTBeHHO
nepe,n
aJITa
peM,
.
TaK
KaK
nOMeIIl.eHHSI
)l.JI5I
MOJlHmHXCH
BOBce
HeT
H
era
3aMeHHeT
eCTe-
CTBeHHaH
nJIOma.n.Ka.
KaK
nOJlaralOT,
no.n.06Hhle
uepK':'
-
BH CTPOHJIHCb )l;JlH 06CJIY>KHBaHHSI
BOHCKa,
pacno-
-
JIaraBIIIerOCH
BO BpeMSI
60rOCJlYiKeHHH
n0,r(
OTKPbI-
ThTM
He60M.
TaK
KaK
nocTpoiiKa
3aKJlIOQaeT
B
ce6e
-
JIHmb
aJITapb
H
.llBa
npH.lJ.eJI3
no
CTOPOH3M-IlIHpHHa
ee
3Ha'-IHTeJIbHO
60JlbllIe
rJly6HHbI
no
HanpaBJleHHIO
'"
C aana,lI.a
Ha
BOCTOK (lO,6X5,.7).
AJITapb
COCTOHT'
H3
a6CH.lI.hI,
nOKphlToH
KOHXOH,
H
HerJly60Koif
CBO,lI.
-
qaTOH:
63MhI.
OB
He
OTKPhIT,
KaK
B
06hI~HblX
I(epK-
'
Bax,
co
CTOPOHbI,
r,lI.e
C06HpaJlHCb
60rOMOJIbUhI,
a
.J
HMeeT
aana,lI.HYIO
CTeHKY
C
l'P~MH
npoeMaMH,
ne-
'-
peKpbIThIMH
apKaMH,
qepe3
KOTophle
MOiKHO
6hIJIO,
CJIe,lI.HTb
3a
COBepllIeHlleM
pHTyaJla.
B
HaCT05lmee
~
BpeMH
YiKe
HeT
CTOJl6HKOB Me)K.n.y
npoeMaMH,
H OHH'
SI&-
"CJIHJIHCb B O)J.HY
rpOMa.nHYIO
6pelIlb
B
CTeHe,
Ha.l1
1{OTOpOA
BblCHTC5I
OCTpOKOHeqHhIH:
II1.Hnen
C
He60JIb-
=
mHM
OKOHneM.
AJITapHOe
B03BblUleHHe
npHnOJ.lH5ITO
. ua)J.
3eMJIeii
npHMepHO
Ha
1 M H
Ha
Hero
Be,n:eT
HP.-
60JIbma51
KaMeHHa51
JIeCTHHna,
paCnOJIOlKeHHa51
ne-
pe)J.
cpe,n:HHM
npoeMOM;
no
APyroH
JIeCTHH~e
B
TpH
.
CTyneHH,
CKPbITOH: B
aM6pa3ype
ABepH,
MOlKHO
no,n:-
HHTbCfI
B
aJITapb
H3
ceBepHoro
npH,lJ.eJIa,
nOJI
KO-
·
Toporo,
KaK
H B IOJKHOM,
HaXO)l.HTCH
Ha
ypOBHe
aeMJIH.
'
06a
nplf)J.eJIa
np5lMoyrOJIbHbI
B
nJIaHe
H
'
HMeIOT
B
BOCTOqHOll
qaCTl-r
He60JIbIIIHe
a6CH,lJ.hI;
BXO,n:bI
paCnOJIOlKeHbI
B aana,lJ.HOH:
CTeHe
no
60KaM
· COJIeH H
YKpallleHbI
CHapYJKH
CTpeJIblIaThIMH
ap-
KaMHHa,n:
THMnaHaMH.
Ha
BOCTOqHOR
CTeHe
,
HMeIOT-
·
CH
Ha,lI.nHCH,
H3
KOTOPblX
BHJ.lHO,
lITO
3Ta
nepKOBb
nOCTpoeHa
He
n03,n:Hee
1303
r.,
TaK
KaK
cpeJ.l11
lIJIe-
HOB )J.OMa
Op6eJIh5lHOB,
rrpl1qaCTHblX
K
nOCTpOHKe,
·
ynoMHHaeTC5I
CJOHl1llCKHH
MHTpOnOJIHT
CTenaHOC,
ci<oHtIaBIIIHHCH
B
1303
r •
.
SOJIee
paHHHx
nepJ<Befi
3Toro
BH,lI.a
(Hanp.
6arpaTH,n:cKoro
BpeMeJ-lH)
MbI
He
3HaeM,
-Aa
e,lJ.Ba
· JIH OHH
6hIJIH.
no
HalIleMY
MHeHHJO, K
TaKoMY
pe~
meHHIO
nepKoBHofi
rrocTpofiKH,
rrpellH~3HaqeHHOfi
:.aJI5I
BOficKa,
MOrJIH
npHJ.lTH
l1MeHHO
B
XIII
B.
B
·
caMOM
J.leJIe
ylKe
~
rrpH
SarpaTR,lJ.aX
HaqaJIa
HaMetIaTb-
-
CH
TeH)l.eHnH5I
K
COKparueHHIO
pa3MepOB
nepKBei%",
npHBellmaH
B
KOHne
KOHnOB
K C03,n:aHI1IO
HOBoro
THna
He60JIblIlOi%"
"KynOJIbHOH:
3aJIhI"
6e3
BOCTOq-
Hoa
naphI
IIHJIOHOB:
B
XIII
B.
60JIhIIIHHCTBO
HOBblX
:
nepKBeH
MOrJIO
BMeCTHTb
HeMHOrl1M
60JIee
COTHD
tIeJIOBeK
H,
KOHelIHO,
HHKaK
He
nOJ.lXOJ.lHJlO
J.lJl51
.
816
M HOrOJIIO,u;HbI X BOI-IHCKI-IX
qaCTeti.
H.
5'.
MappoM
~
Y)Ke
OTMetIeHO,
tITO
IJpe.lI.npI-IHHTaH
nOBceMeCTHO
BO'
'''
BTOPOH
nOJIOBHHe
XIII
·
B.
npMcTpoHKa
K
nepKBaM
:
06lllHpHbIX
npHTBopOB
OTtIaCnl
6blJIa
npO)1.HKTOBaHa
:'
cTpeMneHHeM
BOCnOJIHHTb
3TOT
He)1.0CTaTOK
uepKoB-
HOH nnorn.3,L:LH.
Ho
B
38KphIThJe
nepKBH
H
npHTBopbl
Mor
JIH HMP.Tb ,L:LOcTyn
TOJIbKO
nelllHe
BOHHbI,
-
.lI.JIH
'.
HanYTCTBHH
me
H
6JIarOCnOBneHHH
OT
npaBJIHBlllHXCSI
.
B
rrOXO.lI. BCa,I1;HHKOB
BMeCTe
C
HX
tIeTBepOHOrI-lMH
'"
60eBhIMH
cnYTHHKaMH
HY}I{Ha
6bln~
oTKphITaH
nno-
ma,L:LKa,
KaK
B
AnaH3e.
CooPY)KeHHe
cne~HanhHoH
'
BoeHHOH
nepKBH
BO BJIa)1.eHHHX
Op6eJIbHHOB
B
MOH-
rOnbCI{Oe
BpeMH
TeM
60nee
rrOHHTHO,
tITO
3TH
3Hep-
-
rHqHhIe
KHH3bH
CTPOHJIM
6JIarOnOJIYtIHe
CBOHX
06-
JIaCTeH
Ha
lllHPOKOM
COTpY.lI.HHtIeCTBe
C
MOHronh-
CKHMH
npaBHTeJIHMH,
He
HCKnlOtIaSl
H
)1.eWreJJbHoro
·
yqaCTHH
B
HX
BoeHHhIX
npe,L:LupHHTHHX,
Tpe60BaB-
..
lllero
CO)1.ep)KaHHH
MHprOtIHCneHHoro
BoHCKa
•
.upeBHeHIIIHe
KOJJOKonbHH
OTHOCSlTCH K
XIII
B.,. ,
KOr)1.a
nOBH)1.HMOMY
HX
H
HatIanH
CTPOHTb
'
npa
.
uepKBax
H B
MOHaCThIpHX.
Eonee
paHHHX
nocrptieK
'-... .
HnH,
no
KpaHHeH
Mepe,
CBH)1.ereJIbCTB
0
HHX
Mhl
~
nOKa
He
3HaeM.
O)1.HHM
H3
,u;peBHeHIIIHX
yrroMHHa-
HHH
11.
A.
0 P 6 e JI H
CQHraeT.ZI.Ollle)1.IlIYIO.lI.O
Hac
'
Ha~rrHCb
0
nocrpoeHHH
KOnOKOJIbHH
y
nepKBH
Crra-
·
CHTenH
B
AHH,
npe)1.CTaBJIHIOll1.YIO
CeHQaC
rpy.lI.Y
pa3BanHH
(nYTeBO)1.HTeJIb,
CTp
• . 45).
OHa
6uJIa
coo-
'
pYJKeHa
B 1291
r.
(B
TOM
)Ke
ro)1.y,
tITO
H 1<OJIO-
KOJIbHH
B
Hop·reTHKe),
B03MO)KHO
O)1.HOBpeMeHHO
C
B0306HOBJIeHHeM
nepKBI-I,I-I
.
HMena
ue~bIH
Ha60p
KO~
-
/
JIOKOJIOB,
KOTopbIe,
no
MHeHHIO
H.
51.
.
~appa,
B
9TO
:
~
a
l
BpeM5I
em€'
6b1JUI
ripe.l(MC!TOM
BB033.*
B
XIII
B.
6hIJII!
(
Bo3BeA~HbI
KOJlOKOJlbHH
B
3HaMeHI1TblX
MOHaCThIpHX
CaHaHHe
H
AXnaTe.,
KOTopble
CT05lT
H
no
ceit
.n.eHI>,
.n.aBa51
rrOJlHOe
npe.lI.CTa
BJIeHHe
0
xapaKTepe
;9THX
nocTpoeK.
06e
OHI1
He
CBH3aHbI
C
nepKBaMH,
KaK
STO
MO)KHO
BH,L(eTb
n03)J.Hee
(B
XVlI
B.),
KorAa
KOJIOKOJIbHH
CTaJIH
npl1CTpaHBa
Tb
rrepe)J.
3ana.lI.HhIM
~XOAOM,
HcnORb3Y5I
HX
O,L(HOBpeMeHHO
KaK
He6oJlb-
,lllYIO
nanepTb.
CaHaHHCKa51
KOJIOKOJlbH5I
npHMhIKaeT
, ,K
ceBepO-3ana,u.HOMY
y~JIY
KOMIVleKca
MOHaCTfllp-
i
CKHX
nOCTpoeK,
a
axnaTCKaH
CTOHT
coaepllleHHO
IOT)J.eJIbHO K
BOCTOKY
OT
nepKBeH:
H
3~aHI151
AMa-
aacna.
KOJIOKOJl
'
bHH
B
CaHaHHe
KBa.upaTHa
B
nJIaHe
}l
JIMeeT
BH.lI. BhICO.I{OH .()alJJHH,
CTeHbI
KOTOPOH
3aKaH-
'lIHBaIOTCSJ
ll(Hn.n.aMH.
Ha
nepece4eHHH
.lI.Byx
c
KaTHbIx
.
KpOB~J1b
nOCTaBJIeHa
cTpoHHaSJ
POTOH.lI.a,
BeHtIaIO-
..
B
OTtIe
,
re
0
pacKooKax
1912
r.
(XI
aHHHCKall
apxeoJIoru-
qeCKall
KaMoaHHll.
leKCTbI
H
pa3b1CKaHHll
no
a
p
MHHo-rpy3HH-
:CKOH <jJHJIOJIOnm,
KH.
XIII,
c-nerep6ypr,
1913,
CTp.
36 H cn.)
.H.
}l.
M a p p
BbICKa3b1BaeT
co06pa)l{e!HHll
0
TOM,
KaKOH
Mor-
JIa
6b1Tb
KOJIOKOJIhHll, 0
KoropOH
rOBopHT
Ha,nnHCb,
HaHJI.eHHaSl
<
npH
paCKonKax
OOJIbmeH
paCKonaHHOH
l..{epKBH B
KBapTaJIe
no,ll
aHHHCKHM
BbIWf.0P0JI.OM.
OH
ClJHTaeT,
tIro
,
3Ta
KOJIOKOJlbHSI,
~03Be.lI.eHDaSl
6paTbHMH
YKaHOM
KapHMaJI.HHOM
H
Ea6KaHOM
~axpallHHOM
H
)l{eHOH
nepBoro
llanTaxarYHoH,
JIIO.lI.bMH
60ra-
ITblMH,
nocrpOHBlllHMH
npeKpacHyIO
l..{epKOBb B
KapMHp-BaHlte
H
"-
l.e.JtaBlllOMH
I1l.eJI.pwe BKJIaJI.bI B
MOHaCTbIpb
OpOMOC.
OTHOCHTCSl
~
npH6nH3HTeJIbHO
K 1272 1'. H -
6blJIa
He
KanHTaJIbHbIM
COO-
PYlKeHHeM
(KaK
H
npH
l..{epKBH
CnaCHTe;ll5I),
a '
HMeJIa
BHJI.
3BOH-
.
HHl..{bl-MO)KeT
6bITb
HaBeca.
B
MOHdCTblpe
OPOMOC
KOJIOKO.ilbHSl,
..cY.llSl
no
HaJI.nHCH, OblJJa
nocrpoeHa
B 1286
r.
TaKHM
06pa30M
,
axnaTCKaSl
KOJlOKOJlbHSI 1245
r.
llBJIlleTCSI
.llpeBHeHllIHM
cooPY-
'
lII':eHHeM
3Toro
T'Hoa.
:818
m.aH
IIOMemeHHe
BepXHerO
9TaJKa,
Ky.rr.a Be,!J.eT
Y3-
l<aH
KaMeHHaH
JIeCTHHu.a
(Ta6JI.
52).
Y6paHcTBo
9TOH:
nocTpoHKH
BeCbMa
CKPOMHO
H COCTOHT
H3
.cTpororo
nOpTaJIa
)l.BepH,
npocTblx
06paMJJeHHR
OKOH
'"
H
OOJIbIIlOrO
pe3Horo
KpeCTa
Ha
3arra)l.HOH
CTeHe:
B
AxrraTe
apXHTeKTOp
MaCTepCJ<H
nepeBeJI
J<pecTo06pa3HhIH
nJIaH
HHJKHerO
9Ta>Ka B
KBa.l{paT
-co
cpe3aHHhIMH
yrJlaMH
HaBepxy,
rrOJIyqHB
- B
-yr
JIax
6a
IIlHe06pa3HOH:
KOJIOKOJIbHH
cBoe06pa3Hhle
'
HHllIH,
YBeHqaHHhle
rrpeBOCXO.l{HhIMH
CTaJIaKTHTOBhI-
MH
TpOMnaMH.
TaJ<oe
peUIeHHe
COKpaTBJIO
norrepeq-
'
HHK
nOCTpOHKH
no
JlHarOHaJIli
H
npH.l{aJIO
eH
oco-
'
6yro
CTPOtiHOCTb,
nO.ll.qepKHYTYro
TpeyrOJIbHHK
aMH
'
mHlluoB,
3aBepllIalOUlHx
CTeHbI
OCHOBHoro
MaCCHBa
H
rpaHH
IIleCTHKOJIOHHOH:
POTOH.ll.hI
(lTa6JJ. 54). MbI
Y>Ke
HMeJIH
cJJyqati
ocraHOBHTbCH
Ha
y6paHcTBe
,
~TOH
HHTepeCHO
pa3pa60TaHHOH
nOCTpoHKH.
OHO
B
'
BepXHeH
qaCTH
)l.OnOJIHHeTCH
napHhIMH
OKHaMH
C
KOJIOHKaMH,
qTO
c6mOKaeT
KOJlOKOJJbHIO C
rpynrrOH:
)J.BYX9Ta>KHblX
nOCTpoeK
B
HopaBaHKe,
ErBapTe
H
-
HOp-reTHK
.
e,
HaTaJIKHBaH
B TO >Ke
BpeMH
HCCJIe.ll.O-
-
BaTeJIH
Ha
MbICJIb,,-He
6b1JIa JIH
3aMeHa
6apa6a-
'
Ha
POTOH.lI.OH B
rrepBblX
)l.ByX
rrpOH3B
·
e)l.eHa
.lI.JIH
rro,n;-
~eCKH
KOJIOKOJIOB lia.ll. CaMOH:
uepKoBbro.
KOJIOKOJIbHH,
KOTOPbIE'
HeCKOJIbKHMH
CTOJIe-
'
THHMH
n03>Ke
CTaJIH
npHCTpaHBaTb
K
.l{peBHHM
'
nepKBaM,
HMeroT
Y>Ke HHOH BH.rr..
OHH
COCT05IT
li3
.llsyx
9TaiKeH:,
H3
KOTOPbIX
HH>KHHH
npe.ll.CTaBJI5IeT
OTKphITbIH
CBo,n;qaTblH
nopTHK
Ha
qeTblpex
Mac-
.cHBHbIX
YCTOHX
B
yrJIax
KBa)l.paTa,
a
BepXHHH-pO-
1'OH.ll.Y C
OCTpOBepXOH
KpOBJIeH.
Bce
coopY>KeHHe
6bI~aeT
w.e~po,
a TO H
CB~PX
MepbI
YCHameHO
pe3b-
319
60ti,
B
KOTOPOit
MO)l{HO
CIO)I{eTOB,
3aHMCTBOBaHHbIX
XRTeKTypbI
6e3
BCHKOro
CTBe
cRyqaeB
nO~06HhIe
BCTpeTHTb
COqeTaHHe
H3
Cpe~HeBeKOBOH
ap:
paa60pa.
B
60RhIIIHH-
npHCTpOHKH
BOCnpHHH-
MalOTCH
KaK
~Oc.a,lJ.HbIe
nOMeXH,
B~3hIBalOw.Re
HCK
'7
peHHee
)l{enaHRe
OT
HRX
R36aBHTbCH.
3HaKOMHC
h-...
C
naMHTHHKaMH
CaHaHHa
H
AXnaTa,
BhIPOCIllRX
3a
TpR
BeKa
B
KpynHble
apXHTeKTypHble
KOMnJleKCbI,
HeJIb3H
n
POHTH
MHMO
He60JIbIllHX
~
CKPOMHhlX
nOCTpOeK,
B
KOTOPbIX
6blJIO
HaH1teHC)
npeKpaCHOe
OcpOpMReHHe
BO~Opa360pHbIX
TOqeK
..
n
por
RaBJIeHHhIe
MOHaCTbIpH
npHBReKaJIH
MHOrOtIHC-
ReHHblX
naJIOMHHKOB,
KOTOPhIM
6blJIO
HY)l{H0
~aTb.
B03MO)l{HOCTb
OCBe)l{HTbCH
qHCTOH
pO~HHKOBOii
BO-
,lJ.OH
H
OT~OXHyTb
nOCJIe
.u.o.,'lroro
nyTH
B
ReTHHH
3HOH.
3a,ll.atIy,
KOHetIHO,
MOmHO
6bIRO
peIllHTh
YCT
-
POHCTBOM
cpOHTaHa
no~
C~HblO
TeHHCTblX
~epeBbeB,.
HO
30.u.tIHe
npe.u.nOtIJIH
BBeCTH
BO.u.y B
KphITbJe
ra-
JIepeH,
r
~e
nyTHHK
MOr
HanHTbCH
H nOCH,lJ.eTb
Ha
KaMeHHbIX
CKaMbHX.
CaHaHHCKaH
nocTpoAKa
BeCbMa
nOCTpa,lJ.a
11a
OT
BpeMeHH
H RIO,lJ.CKOH
He6pe)l{HOCTH,
H
aTO
Cll.llhHO
OCRO)l{HHeT
Bonpoc
06
ee
nepBOHatIaJlb-
HOM BH,lJ.e.
OHa
COCTOHT
H3
llByX
CBOlltIaThIX
He-
epOB, OTKPbIBCiIOIlI.HXCSl
Ha
cpaca.llax
60RhIllHM~
npoeMaMH,
nepeKpbIThIMH
apKaMH,
KOTophIe
onH-
palOTCH
Ha
CTeHbl
H
npH3eMHCTYIO
KOROHHY
f CTOH--
mylO
ueJK,lJ.Y
HHMH.
OT
nOCTaMeHTa
3a
KOJIOHHOit
K 3aJ.{HeH
CT~He
nepe6pOlIIeHa
apKa,
HeCYIlI.aH
no~
nepetIHYlO
CTeHY,
Ha
KOTOPOH
nOKOHTCH
CBO.llbl
060HX
HecpOE.
B
AxnaTe
npSlMoyroRbHaH
raJIepeH
:
orpaHl.{qeHHaH
C
Tpex
CTOPOH
rJIyxHMH
CTeHaMH,
OTKpbIBaeTCH
Ha
cpac'
a,lJ.e
TpeMH
npoeMaMH,
paa,lJ.e-:-
8~