Шипицина В.В. Сообщение о преступлениях в СМИ: Процессуальное значение и способы проверки

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.

YTOJIOBHbIII

ilPO rIECC

xhBL!hece B

yronoBHo-npoueccyonbHoM

3oKoHo.qoTerbcTBe

crpoH, o6po3oBoBrur.lxcn Ho repprlropzflx

6brBlurlx colo3Hbrx

pecny6rhK

CCCP. Msr npooHonr3!1poBoflh

HecKonsro

YflK,

BKnpqoff MogenuHuri

YflK

nnq

crpoH

CH[. Ko.qercsr, nonoB-

uhe

B nore HoLlero

3peHhf, B KoqecrBe eAl,1HcTBeHHo

Bo3-

r'.roxH

p,r,lsr p

ccn

e4o

H r,t n n

ecrynn e

H r

eco

epur e

H-

HOnerHhx npelycMorphBo|or

npeABophrenbHoe

cneAcTBl.1e

{cr.

536 Mo,qen uHoro YflK,

cr. I 9 I YU

Pecny6nn<n

Kosoxcro H,

cr. l8l Yl-lK Pecny6nvtrn

Eenopycu rz

.qp.).

YflK Pecny6nzrN

Mongoao

(noxonyi,

couuri oprrnHonu-

nuil

ng Bcex h3BecrHbrx

no,u YflK nocrcoBercKhx

pecny6nhK)

roKXe

Aenoer

oKLleHr

oco6ou nopngKe

yronoBHo

npecne-

.qoBo

Hr,1e HecoBep[.ueH

HonerH

r.lx. [1

pra

aegeru

Sporr,^eur

cr.

YflK

Pecny6nrarz

Mongoao

(<OcyutecreneHhe

yronoBHoro

cy-

Aonpoh3BoAcrBo

po3yMHbre

cpoKr,r)):

<(3)

Yronoaroe npecre-

AOBO

Hhe x

Cy,qe6HOe

p036hporen

bcrBo

yronoBH

brM

.qenoM,

no KoropbrM

noAo3peBoeMsre,

o6ezHner.ade vnrl

nopcy.qhMbre

noABepfHyrbr

npe.qBophrenbHoMy

opecry, o ToKXe no KoTo-

pbrM

npoxoA9T

HecoBepueHHoneTHt,le/

ocyqecTBn9loTcf

B He-

oTfloxHoM n npxophTeTHoM

nopflAKe>.

[lpraegerrure

opryMeHrbr HoBo.qflr Hoc Ho Mbrcnb

roM,

qro

3HoqeH he

Sopr',rsr

npe.qBophren bHoro

poccneAoBo

Hhr He

BcerAo

AonxHo

hHrepnperhpoBorbcfl

cyry6o

npoqeccyonb-

HoM

cMbrcne.

flpN

nporuorzqHoM

B3rrrAe Ho Beulh

MoxHo

npuitri K BbrBoAy

o roM,

,lro

Her

oco6brx

npolleccyonbHbtx

or-

poHzveHzi

Anfl

Toro/

qro6sr

zcnonu3oBorb

Anq

poccneiqoBo-

Hhe

(HecnoxHbrx)

npecrynnexni

necoaepueuuonernnx

Qop-

Ao3HoHhq.

Zccnegoeouras

nocneAHhx ner noKo3brBoror, vro

KThLrecKr4e

Tpy,qHocTh, Ho

KoTopbte

yKo3

bt Bo toT

onnoHeHTbl

AO3HOHt4

9/ nerKO npeo,qonhMbr

nph rloMou{l,r

oproHh3oul4oHHbrx

rlHcrpyMeHroB

AononHt,lrensuoi

no4roroerz

cy6rerroa

poc-

cneiqoBoHhe. Eonee

roro, npoKypopcKhi Hogaop,

coxpoHhB-

Lut4icq

tonuro

Ao3HoHZeM,

Moxer

6urru

ncnonugoBoH

KoK

opryMeHT,qononHhrenbHsrx

ropoHrri

3oKoHHocl4

o6ocHo-

BoHHocrh

poccneAoBoH

ztoit

Korerophh

.qen.

OgHoro

ecrs

$orropur

hHoro

pogo,

Koropbre

nph

onpe-

AeneHAA

$opusr

poccneAoBoHzr

14fHopr4poBoru Hensgq. 3th

$orropst

MoxHo Ho3Borb zAeonofrlqecKrlMt4 vnh

nonhrhLrec-

rrr*r. flocpegcrso^

col oi cepuesHoi

$opr'aur

poccneAoBo-

Hhsl

Koropoil 14 rBflqercf npeABophreflbHoe

cnepcrBre,

ro-

cyAopcrBo noKo3brBoeT

oco6oe

orHoL.!eHhe K

npecrynHocTr.l

HecoBepueHHoneTHl,lx

H K

coMrlM

HecoBepL!eHHoneTHhM/ co-

Bepurl Bur riM n

pecrynneH

he. f

ocylo

pcrao

AeMoHcrph

pyer,

qro

HecoBeplueHHonerHhe

cneqnQrvecKoe

Koreropr4e

cy6h-

eKTOB

yTOflOBHOTO

npOqeCCOi KOrOpOg

AOnXHO

Bbr[enflTbcF.

!,ononurren

sH brMh ro

HThqM h Kornn

eHclJ

pyrorcfl Herorh BH ble

nocneAcTBt49/

cBR3oHHbre C

reM,

!ro B03pOCT nptBreqeHnn

yronoaHoi

orBercrBeHHocrh

Hhxe

Bc,3pocro

coBepLreHHone-

rzq.

Tercr

yt-lK

rro

rorbKo

npoKrhqecKoe

pyKoBoAcrBo,

h B HeKoropoM

poAe

rocyaopcrBeHrurfi

r'aourQecr.

Zmeuuo no)roMy, Ho HoLr

e:rrrg, reo6xoAhMo

BepHyrb

e YUK

PO npoBhno

o6 o6c:crensHo/n npoh3BoAcrBe npeABo-

phTerbHoro

cneAcTBrl9

I,efcr.l

npecrynteHhflx,

coBepuJeH-

Hblx

HecoBepL!eHHof

eTHr,...11 3i cHo,.1q B

MorIoM/ MoxHo noTe-

psrs

6onsLUoA

Cuqea A.A.

Cru.:CerasRsoeo 14.C.i

-,.--='.

co3epL!eHcrBoBoHhfl

poccne-

AoBoHhg

npecrylieF

/,:'

: : -

eHHorerurx

(oproHz3ollhoH-

uo-npoeoaoi

ocf

eKr,

:/:

(:-.:,.

rophA.

HoyK. Orucr, 2003.

38-55.

Moproorreeo

E.B. l:c.,:::::-.:

:o3HoHhr

AeroM

npe-

crynf

eHHflx

HecoBep*.-*l;.-*.,,.:

r nporhB

f f

Poccr,i,crnit

cfleAoBorenb.

2008. Nt

ffioofiueHne o

npecrynfleHnn

CMll:

npoueccyanbHoe

3HaqeH]re I

cn0c06u npoBepHH

loasoi

crorbe

oBTop

poccMorprlBoer

npo6neuuate ocneKTbt, cBe3oHHbte

npoueccyonbHblM

peorhpatsctt/eL',

u npuHFrheM

.3-?.zi

cBssoHHbtx KoK

npoBepxoi

coo6uJeuhn o

npecrynneHh4,

pocnpocrpoHeHHoro

cpeAc-rBox

t,taccoaci

unQopuo4un,

-A.-t'aeHheM

nOBOAO

K BO3OyxAeHhD

yTOnOBHOTO

AenO

YKO3OHHOM

CnyLlOe,

-'=

:'-''r,or considers

controversiol ospects

reloted

procedurol reoction

ond decision-moking connected

both

vttth

verificotion

-:':."-:''ctcboutocrimeondreceiptof groundsforinitiotionof

criminol

proceedingsinthesoidcose.*

Cao6oao

crooo

oAt4H v3

6osoeHx

KoHcrhryqhoHHbrx

:cflHlihnoB

npoBoBoro

rocyAopcrBo. B

Pocoaicroi Oe.qe-

pcqrr

ceo6ogo

cnoBo 30KpenneHo s n. I

cr.

29 Kouctnryuuu

PQ,

o rorxe e

cr.6

!,ernopour4z

npoB ra

cao6o4qenoeerol.

Peonr:oqrr

KoHcrhryqhoHHoro

nposo

ceo6oAur crroBo cocro-

rr a

cso6oguoM BbrpoxeHhz,

AoBeEeHZh Ao

cBegeHhr oKpyxo-

lou.lr4x B

ycrnoit

unn nzcsuetrorZ

Soprue

uurcneri n

y6exgeauit.

Hepegro

cao6ogo

cnoBo

peonz3yerce

nocpeAcrao,ra CMZ

(cr.

.[ernopoqrar

npoB

']enoBeKo]

Ceo6oao CMZ

sorpenneercfl cne-

uhonhHbrM

nofioxerir.leM

3oroso

CMZ

(cr.

1)'?. B zHrepecox

co-

xpoHeHh I r,azpo,

6esonocHocila esrpo60T0Hbt

onpeAeneHHbte or-

poHZqeHhr

peonh3ollzz

cBo6oAbr cnoeo.

O6ulze

ocHoBoHhfl

roKrx

orpoHr4rreHnrZ

4ouur

s n.

3 cr.

19 Mex4yHopoAHoro noKro

rpoxgoHcKr4x

v nonzrhqecrzx

npoaox3.

Orponrrenrr

AonxHbl

6uru

ycrouoeneHbr

Hor-lhoHonbHbrM

30KoHogorerbcrBoM

t4 AsnA-

orcs

Heo6xoghMbrMh:

4nr

yaoxerhfl

npoB h

pen\,Toqh!4

Apy-

fl4x nA\;6)

anr

oxpoHsr

rocyAopcrBeHHori

6e3onocHocrr,

o6u1e-

cTBeHHOTO nOprAKO/

3AOpOBbfl Zrrh

HpOBCTBeHHOCTh HOCeneHhs.

Korcl,rryurn

PQ xourpelz3hpyer

3rh nofloxeHhfl, 3onpeu1ot

ponoroHAy

vnA otu1r

et!t4a,

eoa6yxao roulhe

couzonbHyro,

poco-

Byro/ HoLlhoHonbHylo

HeHoBr..crb h Bpoxiqy/ nponoroH[y

couhorb-

HOrO,

pOCOBOTO,

HOU|IOHOflbHO|O,

penhrho3HO|O

lnA tHOrO

npe-

Bocxogcrao.

3orosur

o ccvtilc<ol,

Oegepoqn

ycro

Ho Bn h Bo ror

oTBeTCTBeHHOCTbT B TOM

qhcne

yrOnOBHyrO,

HopyllreHhe

)ThX

3onperoB. BoxHur,r,r

ycnoBheM peonz3ourh

npoBo

cao6o4y

cnoBo fl Bnnercn Hepo3rfl

oueHke

rocy4opcrseHF{oti rorTusro.

Shipifsino

lnformotion

obout o

Crime in Moss Medio:

Procedurol

Siqnificonce

ond Meons of

Veri{icotion

CCilUCKII

I'I

CJIEIOBATEJIb'>

csere

KoHcrhryuhoHHoro

nonoxeHilq o cso6oAe

cno-

Bo BoxHbrM

BonpocoM flBnterce ony6nrroaouAe

CMh cee-

AeHri

o coBepueHHbrx

ilnH noAroroBnfleMbtx

npecrynneHr4flx

QopMox

npoueccyonbHorc

peorxpoBoHhtl Ho HHx.

cooreercrshy

co cr.

ynK

PO ocnosoxheM

Ane

Bo3-

6yxleHraq

yronoBHoro

Aeno

qBnttorcfl

cBeAeHhr

o coBeplueH-

iloM ]4nh

roToBfuleMcg npecrynneHhx,

nonyqeHHble

<(t4Hblx

rlcrorrHHKoB). 3orou

Aoer

po3l,ncHeHrafr no noBoAy

roro,

KOKhe hMeHHO hCrOrrHXKt,r

hHqopMouhtl o

npecrynneHhgx

cie-

Ayer

orHecrh

qxcny

uuux. C

yqeroM nonoxeHuil

't.2

cr.

144

ynK

qrcnv

MoxHo orHecrh

coo6uleHNn

e CM!4, co-

Aepxoulue

yKo3o

H r,ie Ho npH3Ho

K'4 n

pecrynn

htl.

.[,nn

eo:6yxgeHhR

yroJroBHoro

Aeno

seo6xoflrz,rao

Honhqhe

nogoAo

ocHoaoHhfl.

B xo.iecree nosoAo

poccMorphBoerct

coo6uleuNe

npecrynneHHh, nonyqeHHoe

H3 npeAycMorpeH-

HOrO npoqeccyonbHbrM 3oKoHoM

HcToliHHKo,

nphHgTHe

KoTo-

poro

o6r3brBoer oproHbr

poccneAogoHun

.qenoM

tloc-

rHoro o6shHeHht

cyAbro)

npr.rcrynraru

r npoqeccyonuuoi

IleqrerbHocrh.

Kor npoerro,

hMeHHo c

MoMeHro noRBneHrn

noooAo

gnr

eos6yxgeHrff

Aeno

Bo3HhKoror

yronoBHo-npo-

ueccyonbHue

orHotueHHfl,

H Hoq!4Hoercfl

yronoauui npoqecc.

l-loaoa

ruroxer npeACToBnrrb coo6uleHre

o cosepueHHoM,

co-

BepuoeMoM

hnh roroaeuleMcs

npecrynneHtus.

floao.qbt K

Bo3-

6yxgeulro

yronoBHoro

Aeno

rro

l4crotrHhKh

lrxQopr.aoqrl

coBepueHHoM

Hn14 roroBeuleMcn

npecrynneHHH,

(olopblM

30-

KOH nphAOeT 3HOqeHHe

OpIAHqeCKHX

QOKTOB,

OOF3bIBOIOU-IhX

AO3HOBOTenq,

OprOH

AO3HOHHq

CtleAOBOTenf

B npeAenox.

ycroHoBneHHbrx YllK PO,

pocororperb

peuurb sonpoc

eo:6yxger-ru!4

yronoelroro

Aeno

npil

Honhqut,qocrorotlHblx

AoHHbrx,

yKo3brBoroullx

npH3HoKr4

npecrynneHHr.

[loeogbr

eos6yxreurro

yronoBHoro

Aerro

yronoBHo-npoueccyottb-

lroM

3oKoHe

o6ueAuHeuu o6ulnr,,,r

noHerreM

<coo6uleHue

npecrynfleHhh>6. OcxogoHtteM

nphHqro

Ho3btsorb

Honhqhe

AOCTOTO']Hb|X

AOHHbTX.

yKO3r,rBOrO|.rlr,rX

nph3HOKh

npecryn-

neaunT. OcHosoHhel

gnn

eo:6yxgeHhl

yronoBHoro

Aeno

nB-

ngrorcs

Qorrruecxre

goHHbtef

yKo3btBotoulue Ho Honhqhe

Ae-

efrHh npu3HoKos

npecrynnesus. ?tu

AoHHbte

coAepxorcq

nepBHriHbrx

AoKyMeHTox

(H B

HonpoBnceMblx

BMecre

c HHM'4 Mo-

ephonox,

noArBepxAo

roulrax

coo6ulexr,re),

coenogoloult4x

noBoAoMr4

gnn

ao:6yxgeHhe

yroaoBHoro

Aeno

3oqBneHkcx

o npecrynneHAA,

saKe

noanuuoi,

B Morepuonox

npoBepKh

coo6uteurai o

npecrynnexraRxs.

Coo6ueHrae

B cpeAcrBox

r'toccosoi

r.t lt$opt to

ornec-

rh K

rl4cny

noBo[oB r aos6yxgeuuto

yrofloBHoro

geno

npo6ne-

Mol4riHo. He cnyuoino 30KoHoAorenb

ynoMfiHyn

HeM.

KoK

noBoAe

x soa6yxgexNo

yronoBHoro

Aeno

cr.

140 YtlK.

l'lpoueccyonsHoe

peorhpoBoHr.!e

Ho coo6uteHNe

s CMiy' o

npecrynneHHH

HMeer

cBoro

cneqilonbHo

onpeAeneHHylo

npo-

tteAYPY.

COgepxoHile.

cocroBnfltor

geicraNr

npoKypopo,

oproHo,qo3HoHt4e,

Ao3HoBoTenq.

pyKosoAhTenq cneAcTBeH-

f ioro oproHc, cneAoBorene.

Cyulrocru

trrx

.qeicrstti

3ctKnlo-

eoercq

cne,qyoueM.

flpr

pocnpocrpoHeHlH B cpeflcrtlox

,,.roccosoi

ran$opr'aoqr,tr coo6ueHrn

roroBquleMcA

AnA co-

BepLxeHHoM

npecrynaelrrh

npoKypop

Aoer

YKo3oHHe

oproHy

iio3FroHfig/

pyKOBolhrenb

cfieAcTBeHHOrO

OproHo

cneAoBo-

renlo

npoBe[eHhh

npoBepKh. flpoeepro coo6ulexrr,

HcxoAn

co,qepxoHH

a,a.2 cr.

I 44

ynK

P(D,

.qonxuo

BKnoqorb

Hcrpe-

5osoxle

AoKyMeHToB

h HHbrx

Mcrrepkonos/

noATBepxlotclu1hx

:oo6uteHae

npecrynneHilh, o

roKxe

AoHHbte

nhue, npeAo-

:rostlaueM

rry

ruQop,raoqlro.

Pegorr{rn

B nhqe

rnoBHoro

pe-

-cKropo

o6qsoFlo

npeAocroBi.lrb

yKo3oHHylo r4Fr$opmoqraro.

/lcK;loqeHhe

Mo)Ker

cocroBnflTb

nhub

r,ru0opr.,loqtn o

ni,lqe,

:oo6u.ikeuer"a

pe,qoKqrito

rnu

po6orooueMy B

coorBercrBy-

':.ler.a

CMl4

xypHonhcry o

npecrynneHAu,

ecnu orHotreH!1fl

....copMoropoM

crpotrcfl

ycnoBxex KoHQHAeHqhonbHocr,4.

::ne

npoBeprr coo6ulesrafl o

npecrynneHhh

AonxHocrHoe

yroJroBHbrlr

nPoIIEcc

nHLlo,

BeAyulee

yronoBHoe

cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo,

o6fl3oHO

npH-

Hqrb

o[Ho

yKo3oHHbrx e cr.

] 45 Y[1K

peLuenrai.

Mu xorru

o6porNrs

BHhMoHhe

Ho HeKoropue

npo6nenr-

Hbre sonpocbr,

cBfl3oHHbre

KoK

npoBepKoi

coo6uleuNr

npe-

crynneHhh,

pocnpocrpoHeHHoM B CMh,

rox

nonyqeHx-

noBoAo

x sos6yxgenuo

yrotroBHoro

Aeno

yKo3oHHoM

cnyqoe.

OgHy

r,te npo6ner'4,

atrHctoulr4x

r$$errNeHocrb

npoBe-

po.ixux

geicrgri,

Ho Horx B3rneA, cocroBneer

yKosotlre

e YllK

P@ r-ro eosl

oxHocrb

coKpbtrun

ran$opr"touhN o

nhqe, coo6ulhs-

ueM

npecrynne+rlt'tt ecnn

6stno

nocroBneHo

ycnoBhe

roHQr-

,qeHuhonbHocna.

flpo6neuo lro

hMeer

HecKonbKo

ocneKroB.

l-lepaurii: roxrtu

o6po:oM

pegoKqr,tr

CMl,'l

raoxer

r'tnH

AonxHo

noArBepAhrb ro,

trro

lro

yclroBre

(ronQragerrquonsuocrra)

<6ur-

no BbrABilHyro>? Crorsq

4 i 3oroxo o

CM14 noArBepx,qoer

Bo3-

MoxHocrb

orKo3orbcn

BuAoqh

raHQoprraoqrN,

nonyleunoi

ycnoBhrx roxQr,rgenqraonbHocl4.

OArioro

yKo3oHo,

qlo

,qoflxHo

cJlyxxrb,qoKo3oTenbcrBoM

Honhqhg

yKo3oHHOrO

yc-

noaun. Bropoi:

yronoaHoe

cyAonpotr3BoAcrBo

cQepo

ny6-

nxqHbrx

orsoueHri.

Koropbtx

npuoplTeroM

Bblcrynotor

t1H-

repecbr

oxpoHbr

o6ulecreo.

Hocronuxo onpoBAoHHo

coKpblrxe

ceeAenli o

qocrHoM

nur\e, ecnu

peqb

t4Aer o6

o6ulecreenHo

onocHoM

Aenuuu?

Tperri:

npoBepKo coo6u{eurn

npecD/n-

fleHhil

npecfleAyer

uenb

ycroHoBtlrb

Hont4lHe

.qocrorotlHblx

ocHoeoHhfi, r.e. ceegeFrtti

HonhqHr

nra6o

orcyrcreilH

yronoB-

Ho HoKo3yeMoro

AeflHur.

flpu

Heeo:r'aoxHocrlt

Aocrxqb

coor-

eercrayroulei creneH

AocroroLl

Hocrt4 oproHH

npeABo

phren b-

Horo

poccneAosoHue

o6ssouu

nra6o

nperporxrb

npoBepKy.

nu6o ao:6y,qurh

yronoBHoe

Aeno

6e3

AocroroqHblx

K roMy oc-

uoaouuii,

qro

flsnqercq

He3oKoHHbrM.

9eraepruri;

o6ecneqe-

HXe npoB 14

3oKoHHblx

HHTepecoB

rpox.qoH

HenocpeActBeH-

3OS],rChr OT CBOeBpeMeHHOCTh

HOq

OnO

peABo

l4TenbHoro

poccfleAoBoHrn.

3orpygneHun

Ho nepBoM frone

yronoBHo-

npoqeccyonbHoi

genrenuuocrh,

cBtl3oHHHe

HeAocrorKoM

Heo6xo.qr,rr'aoi uHSopuoqr,rN,

BeAyr

cHrxexuo_e$QexrraHoc-

rh npeABopxrenbHoro

pcccneAoBoHuq, eau

oyAer

npHHqro

peueHue

o ero

Hqr{one.

flsruri:

KoKoi noBoA

r eo:6yxger-laro

yrono8Horo

Aeno

HoAo hcnoniloBoTb,

ecnh cfieAoBoTeflb

rtlH

Ao3HoBorenb

I npouecce

nopyvenHofi

hM npoBepKt'l

coo6qe-

Hxe

npecrynne+ul

B CMlrl

ycroHoBrr

AocrosepHocrb

Ao-

croror{Hocrb

lx$opr,,ror1ral?

qrureq

Bo3MoxHocrh

.0,oHHoi

crorbe orBerfiTb

Ho Bce

o6osHoqeHHue

Bonpocu,

o6porlv,cl

oAHoi lrx

Koreropr14.

CroAvn

eo:6yxger-rrn

yronoBHoro

Aeno

rBnqercfl

npo-

6neusum 3ronoM

yronoBHoro

cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo

B chny

posxoo6po:nbrx

nphril.rH,

rnoBHbtM o6poaorta

s oany

Qpor-

MeHropHocrh HopMorhBHoro

perynilpoBour'rr.

OrcyrcraNe

ueo6xogN,ttux

3oKoHoAoren

bHUX

npoB!4n BeAer

orpt'l

LloHh

npoueccyoflbHoi ssoqur'aocrr

AoHuoi

c-fo$Arl

HeKoropblMl4

yqeHbtMH.

flo

ur-rer-ruro lO.8.,[,epr.rueBo,

croAr.ln

eo:6yxgeurn

yronoBHoro

Aeno

ocyuecrBnnercs

o[MhHhcTporHBHOe

npoh3-

BoAcrBo no npoBepKe

$orroe,

cxoxt4x

o6terrusxoi

cro-

poHe

npoBoHopyueHllnMx:

Bo3H14KlioBeHHe

yrofloBHO-npo-

ueccyonbHbrx

orgouteunil

norBneHHn

npecrynfleHHtl

lro

ecrb

He3oKoHHoe

h Heo6ocHoBoHHoe

orpoHh(ieHke

npoB

nhqHocrh,

roKxe npoflBneHile

(npoqeccyorbuoi

pocrovi't-

tenusoqru>e.

I.M. Bonoarso

nonoroer,

qro

AeohcrgeHHoi

no-

3Huhx 30KoHoAorens

pernoMeHroqhh

poueAypsr

eos6yx'ae-

HXq yronoBHoro

Aeno

A,ru

o6nsoHbl

cnoxhBuleMycq

TeophH

HO npoKTHKe

npoTHBopeqho: c

KoKoro

MoMeHTo

HOtjhHoercfl

yronoeHui

npoqecc

c MoMeHro

nonyqeHhe

$rxcourr

nep-

et4qHofi tu$op,rloqr.ila o coBepueHHoM

npecrynnettun

nu6o c

MoMeHro nphHerhn

peueHxe

sos6yxgexr,th

yroroBHoro

Ae-

no.

[lpo6ner'ao 3To

Hochr He

ronbKo

reoperhrtecKhi

xoporrep

cryvoe

orKo3o

e aoa6yxgexrah

yronoBHoro

Aeno

Bo3HhKcer

BOnpoc,

vwen4 nh

MecTo

yronoBHo-npoqeccyonbHble

orHoue-

YTOJIOBHOE

NPABO

Hhs. OrBer Ho Bonpoc HoiTh HeBo3MoxHo,

hcxoAg

143

o6ulefo

nocryfioTo o

roM,

r]To

yfonoBHbri

npouecc Hor.rhHoeTcg

Mo-

MeHro npt'lHer[e

peu]eHhq

ero soqonet].

V1.8. lonogzHcros

ToKXe

crrhroer?

Lrro

pernoMeHTor1hq

croAAV

aos6yxgeHzn

yro-

noBH brx

Aen

HyxAoercq

Aol

uHeiLUeM

coBepueHcraoso

H 14 h'

Ter,,r He

MeHee Mbr nonoroeM,

qro

)To crogrlt

rBnsercr He-

o6xogzusnl )ronoM

npoh3BogcrBo

yronoBHbrM

,qenoM,

cnoco6crayroula,ra

o6ecneqeHho

npoB fpox.qoH nyreM Boc-

npenercrBoBotjhq

6egoorosorenbHoMy Horrony

npeABoprl-

TerbHoro poccreAoBoHh9

il nphMeHeHh|o

conyTcTByroulero

eMy

npoqeccyorbHoro

nphHyxreHhfl K rpoxAoHoM

rro6oi

Qopr',ae).

IpegocroareHhe

30KoHoM

npoBo

orpenbHbrM

Kore-

ropztM rpoxgoH

orKo3orbcs or

npeAocroBleHhfl BoxHoi

Anfl

npoBepKh

coo6uleHr,lfl o npecrynneHrzra rnQopmoq^h Mt>t cev-

ToeM He

coorBercrByrou.lhM 06ul/M L1enflM h 3ogo{.roM

yronoB-

Horo

cy.qon

poh3BoAcrBo.

locyAopcrao h 06uecrBo 3ohHrepe-

coBoHbr

a ror.a, rro6ur

Hh oAHo npecrynneHhe He ocronocs 6es

BHT1MOH h9 npO BOOXpOH r,1Tefl

bH brx

OpfO

HOB Z nOryq hnO

OUeHKy

cyAo. Oco6eHHo oKryonbHo

peoKqhe

rocypopcrBo Ho

coo6-

qeHhe

o npecrynneHufx,

cBeAeHh9 o

KoTopbrx nonyg|/'n4 |'].lrl-

poryro

o6ulecrBeHHyro orrocKy, HonphMep, s CMZ. lpox.qoFl

BOnHyer ro/ KoK rocyAopcrBo

orpeorzpyer

coorBercrByro-

ulrae

coo6ulennn.

Peorqzr

[onxHo

6urru

oneporrauoi

r$-

$erlaaHoi.

BocnpennrcraoBoHhe

npoBepoqHbrM

Aeicrehql

HHoM

cnyqoe

HellonycrhMo. Ycnoere roHQra4eHqraofl bHocrl4

npegocroBleHran

rHQop,vorlr la

He Moxer cnyxhrb ocHoBoHH-

eM.qne

oTKo3o

B npeAocToBneHhh

cBeAeHhh o

nepBorlcTorrHh-

re. Torrm

o6poaoru, Morephonbr

npoBepoK cnegyer orHecrh

Korerophh

AoKyMeHroB,

Ho Koropbre

pocnpocrpoHfercF

cne-

uNonuHsri

pexhM

oxpoHbr, nphpoB t4M rpl+

[oKyMeHroB,

co-

croBrerou-lhx rocy4opcrBeHryro roiHy.

3rz

uorepronsr ue ny6-

rllKyrorcq,

K Hr.1M Her

Aocryno

nocropoHHr4x nhq. BpqA rtz

ecrb

ocHoBoHhe

onocorbcfl

Toro,

qro

oHh

cnoco6Hbr

cKoMnpoMerz-

poBol,

rlcror+1HK

cee,qeHrli.

or4ensusrx cryrroRX

(xorgo,

no-

phMep,

ra nQoprao r1z ro

npecrynneHr

npeAcro Bnr tor

qreH

npecTynHbrx rpynnhpoBoK/ noTepneBuJre/ l,lMeloulhe

ocHoBo-

HZ9

onocorbcq 30 cBoro

xrzsHu)

cnepyer

npeAycMorperb

Bo3-

r"4oxuocrb yqocrl4r

3Trx nhu no npoBhloM, onpeAeneHHsu.a

cr.

166 YtlK, r.e. noI

nceBiqoHrlMoM.

lonoroera,

qro

pe3yrrbro-r

npoBepKh

coo6uleHhr

npe-

crynne+url, KoK no.qrBepguawnil, roK h

onpoBepruyeurufr

ero,

.qonxeH

6srru onv6nNroBOH

B roM xe

cpeAcrBe

MoccoBoi hH-

Qopuoqrar,t,

B KoropoM

6srno

pocnpocrpoHeHo

L1 co06uleHhe.

Toroe

peueuze

pege

cnyqoeB 30croBZr 6onee

oc,raorpr-

TenbHo

orHocl4Tbcq < ony6rzxoaoHhto HenpoBepeHHbrx

coM-

HilTerbHbrx

AoHHbrx

npecrynreHhfl x.

Wnnu4unaB.B.,

nPenopi(IBorenb

KoQeAPbt

yfonoBHoro nPctBct,

npoqecco u RpuMuHdnucruKu blxanryra

?KoHoMuKvt,

npoao n

ry'|/.aHnfdpHtrx

cne$uo,nbilocfefr

KpocHo4op

Cu.:

.Qernopoq/F

npoB z

ceo6oA

LrerogeKo

(npNxrro

CtesAo/ul

HopoAHblx

Aenyroroa

CCCP 5 cerrn6pn

99.l

r. Ns 2393-\

/ /

BeAouocrr

Cle:Ao HopoAHbx

aenyroroB

CCCP

r Bepxoauoro

Coeero

CCCP.

l. Ns

37. Cr.

I 083.

Cr.a.:

3oroH PQ ot 27

4ero6pn

l99l

Ns 2124-1

cpeAcrBox

r,aoccosoi rH$opr,aoqNr>

r:u. r

D^an)

//Begouocrr

CuesAo

HopoAHbrx

AenyroroB

Poccricroi

Oegepoqr,rr r Bepxoaroro

Coaero

Poccnitcxoit

OeAepourar. 1992. Ns

7. Cr.

300.

Cr'a.: MexgyropogHsrir noKr

rpoxAoHcKr4x h norhrvlLrecKhx

npoBox

(Huro-Zopr,

sero6pn

)966 r.l

CnC

CflC <Asonral.rx>,

2008.

Cra.:3oroH PO

or 2l

rronq

1993

Ns 5485-l

rocvAopc-

rseHHoi

roiue>

r:u.

gon.)

/ /

Co6poane 3oKoHoAorerbc-

reo

Poccr;cxori Oesepoqrr. I 997. Ns 41. Cr. 4673

Cr'l.:

CurzpHoa

A.8., KonrsoecxrrT K,6. YronoeHsti npouecc

yve6Hrar

noa o6Lu.

pea.

A.B. CurpHoeo. Cn6.,2006.

Yronoauo-npoLleccyorbHoe

npoao Pocczicroi @eAepour.la :

yve6Hur

ora.

peg.

fl.A. ,fiynrrlcron.

M. :

lOprcru, 2004.

Ct'l.: YronoeHsti npoqecc:),qe6sqK

nog o6ut.

pea.

B.Z. Poa-

qenro.

M.,

2006.

C^a.: YronoeHsri

nporlecc :

y.e6rr<

nog o6u1.

peA.

B.M. Ie-

6eAeeo.

M.,2004.

.[epraLuea

lO. Cro4rr eo:51,xgerrn

yronoBHoro

Aero

pe-

rr,1Kr

(collr'4

on14crr,r,recxo; 3o(oHiocrh)

f f

Poccnilcron

tocrhuhs.

2003.

Ns 8. C. 36.

Cr'l.: BonoAvtHo l.M. Hoese npo6neusr so:6yxgeHrn

yrofloB-

Horo

Aero

Mexay:oacxrri c6oprr< Hoy.inbrx

rpyaoe. YSo :

PhO 5outY,2003.

Cr'a.: lonoahHcror Z. B. I

xrrz,lecrre n

po6neusr

ao:6yxgeu

yrofoBHblx

gen

f f

PoccuilcKh;

cf eloBarerc.2007.

C.2.

""""'ffiffi

,no n*

B a H I

c H 0 r0 T

ir : a HTya[ b H

n n

oTp e 6

B n3MeHeH[[ 3aHoHo[arelbHox

HopMbl

po6ore

,qoercfl

oHonhs

cr.

I 27.2 YK P@

<hcnonsoBoHue

po6cKoro

rpyAo> B

ocneKre ocyuJecrBneHhe

npaBa co6crBeHHoc-

ru. O6ocHoalBoerce ueo6xoAuuocrb

t43MeHeHhn 30KoHo\orenbHo,

HopMbr

The work

onolyses orticle 127.2

the Criminol Code of

the RF

<Use

of Slove Lobor> in the

ospect

of execution of ownership

right. The

outhor substontiotes the necessity

chonge o{ the

legislotive

norm.*

flocne pocnopo

CCCP Holrro

crpoHo

nepexrzno rny6o-

,ror'wuit

Kpvsv c

npne

guu

il K Ko

pAh

brM non u rh

ecKhM,

tKoHoM'.1LrecKhM 14

couhonbHbrM

l43MeHeHZrM B

pocchicKoM

06-

ulecrae. Ho

QoHe

)Thx

h3MeHeHili Ho,rono cKnoAbrBorbcn

yc-

roi,ihsoq reHAeHqhe K

noxhur,eHheM

nogei, ToproBne ntr4bMu,

o6poqeHhlo rx a

po6creo

h nphHyx[eHhro r

po6crouy rpyay

He rorbKo

e cexcyonuuorZ

cQepe,

Ho h B

cQepe

npeAnpzHhMo-

TerbcrBo u

6nsHecc,.

ro xe BpeMfl

orcyrcrBhe

He.qoBHero

BpeMeHh B

poc-

ct4ilcKoM 30KoHo.qorerbcrBe

yronoBHoi

oraercreeHHocr.l

t1cnonb3oBoHhe

po6cKoro

rpyAo

nphBeno K Bo3MoxHocrh

6esFf orosor-rlro coBepuorb

n0A06Hbre

AeAHl'A.

Burnanrrs

$or-

Tbr, cBfl3oHHbre

c o6poueHZeM

qenoBeKo

po6crBo

l/ hcnonE-

3OBOHheM

pO6CKOTO

rpyAo, HO repphrophl4 POCCuu

6urno

Ao-

croroLrHo cnoxHo/

ycyry6nnnocu

3To

14 BbrcoKot

roreHTHocrblo

.tloHHOrO

9BreH11n.

Popov V.A. Use

of Slove Lobor:

Topicol Need for Chonge of

the Legislotive Norm

<POCCIIIICKIII,I

CJIE.iIOBATEJIb>