Семененко А.А. Вклад антропологии и генетики в решение индоарийской проблемы
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
vAK
930.1
EEK 63.3
r55
Pe4axqzoHHa{
KorJlef
fi fl :
B. H.
ftresaea
(ore.
pe4axrop),g.B.Arcuuoe
(ore.
cexperaps),7-
B.
)Ktt(tpoea
Blac6
lr
o6ulecrno:
n:aruogeficrnun
r.r rcons,rrrrKTLl.
Marepuanrr
Tlsrofi
peruoHarr,Hofi
Hayuuoii
xoH$epeuqr,u
(r. BopoueN,
26 rirapra
20
I I r') i IIoa
o6q.
peg.
B. H.
fnasreea.
-
BopoHex:
rl3AareJrbcrBo
<I4croxa>,
2011'
-
408 c-
ISBN
978-5-88242-854-8
B c6opHrlx
BoIrIJrIt
Mareplranll
fl-groii
perl'IoHaJ'IbHofi
nayuHofi
r<on$e-
peHUp1Lt llCTOp].tKOB
n O6uleCreOgeAoB,
TeIvlaTI,Ilca
XOrOpOii
BKil]OqaeT
npOSlenalt
CTaHOBJISHu{
U B3agMooTHgurenuft
rOCyAapCTBeHHslx
n O6rqecTBeHHblx
I{HcTl4-
TyTOB
B OTeqecTBeHHoii
r,r eceoSqefi
ucropnu.
B xoucpepeHquv
ilpr4ljtlMailu
yqacTr4e
yr{eH},re H3
ropoAoB
I]eHrpa,nsnoro
IIepHo3eMbr:
BopoHexa,
JL.rneqxa,
Eenropo4a,
Kypcrca,
TaNr6oea,
Ellqa.
Crarua
fieqara]orc-fl
u
anropcroF
peAaKurrI4.
{nx
ncropnnoe,
o6u{ecrsoBeAoB,
BCeX
}.rHTepecy}olql4xct
aKTyaJIbHEIMI'I
np o6:reuan
r.t lrcro
p
14 lz tt o6ruecre
os Haltl4-fl
.
vAK
930.I
EEK 63.3
ISBN
978-5-88242-854-8
O
Ko,r"renu{B
aBTopoB,
20ll
@
lluare,'IbcrBo
<<llcrornu>>,
20 I I
BKIAA
AHTPO
nOJIOI'I4L{
14
rEHETI'|
Kll
B PEIIIE.HI4
E
I,IHAOAP'IiiCI{OU
ilPO5.IIE
MI'I
A.A. Ce-tr.etrcuxo
BopclHentc
ru
r'i rocyAapcrBeHuli
ii
y
unae
pcurer
l,IHloaprlricxar
npo6:renra
(nHeatuouu:*-rluwrvinrpaquoHu3r-
npoTllB
aB-
roxlountnla)
6srla
Crpopuynup6BaHa
,1HHrBt4c'raMu
B TO
Bpei\'It'
Koflla iillTpo-
no,'lorulr
u
feHeTHKH
el{e
He
cy[IecTBoBaIo
(l). Ceii'lac
BE]BOArI
3Tl4x
Aucqlln-
nr4H
rtrH6pttpoBaTl
HeBO3tltot{Ho,
}-l
dll:rolOranr
14 ucTopl{Ka}\'l
Heo$XoAllillo
npll-
BecT}lcBotIflocTpoeHuqBcooTBeTCTBHecAaHHb|MI,|ecTecTBeHHFIXHayK.
Anrpono,roruqecKoe
o6cneaoBaHr4e
rre"ToBeqecxr4x
cKeJreToB.
oSHapy-
xeHHbrx
Bo
BpeNrr apxeolorflqecKlrx
pacKonoK B 6acc€i.iHe
tr4una,
noxa:alo.
.rTo
B
4500-800
rr.
Ao
H.3.
B
perlloHe cyllecrBoRana
6HoIoril'Iecliaq
TIpeeMcr-
BeHHOCTT,
HaCereHl.rq
6e:
orqyuvoro
rlonyJ]rqHoHFtoro
BirurHLrr
Ir3BHe Cy6-
xoHTr,rHeHTa
(2).
?ror
BbItsO.{
npn3HaH
rMAepaN'tH
I'lHtsalUOH}l-
cToB/l4x,rMr.trpaur{oHrrcToB
KaK CpeA}r
JTHHTBHSTSB
(M.
Br,11qelr),
rax
n
cpelll
apxeororoB
(E.E. Ky:lirrrfla)
(3).
B
paHHnx reHerrrqecK,ax
Llccr'leAoBaHuqx
B fannorpynne
Rlal
na6:rrola-
-[OCr, CH]ixeHIIe
pa3HOO6pa3Mt
no HanpaBn€Hlllo
OT
tr4paHa
x L[n4an
I{ 3To Cr{fi-
Ta.1OCt, -[OKa3aTeJ]bct'ilotll
ABLI]K9HI,IS
feHeTl{qecKgfo
nOTOKa
B [4H.1HK]
14 BHe-
ApeHHrr
TyAa
trHAoeBponei.icxttx
t:ll'lKoB.
Ho uHnnfiUut
6lt,ru
npe4craBJ'ieHbl
of-
paHUqeHHofi BEr6opKofi
il3
fyA)iapaTa
-
rofo-3araAHoro
npuMopcKofo
[IraTa
L4HLutt.
PacunpeHne
r,rH;1uiicrofi
Bbt6opKr4
Ha
Apy|ue
urTaTbl
npuBe,ro
K Bo3-
rtr4KHOBeHttlO
flpOTuBonOno)KHOii
KapTnHbl.
Oxa3a.qocrb,
'111'r
ltHltti'tt1l't
oTp?lNa-
ro.f Sonee
BbrcoKoe
pa3Hoo6pa3lte
B
fannofpynne
Rlal
iltl;,xe
npu
conocraBle-
Hr{r{
c }o}KHo-
u BocrottHo-eBponeftcK}4rvr
naceJteHuer\r.
Heug6extultv
craHoBllJr-
C'
BbIBOA
O TOIVI,
LITO
HHAOEBPONCi1IIbI
BO3HI{KJIH
B
I4HAI'II'I
M
OTTYAA
PACNPO-
crpaHr4nrcr
e EaPonY
(4).
B
2006
r.
c
qe,'r6rc
u3yqeHl,lfl
npoucxo)fiAellufl
NllxcKl"t\
-tlllHl'lll
HacJlelo-
Ba1nn
y
rlHAtrilcKoro
HaceJleHur
6sr:rn
npoaHaJ.rlr3lrponaHbr
38
rvrapmepos
9ii6
Y-xpollOCol,,r
B
32
lrneMeHr{l,rx
l,
zl5
KaCroestx
rpyllfia\
qeTLIpe\
ocHOBrjLIx
IHHFBLICTIIIIeOKr,IX
ceMeil
trInnuu.
HeAaeHee
BHeLuHee
8,1]tB;1Hue
B
jlpilBtllo-
l'l
xtrH4l,lfoBoprulrJe
KacToBlte
rpyrrrrbr
oKa3aJiocb
c1a6brNr.
Pa.cnpege:reHfie
HeKo-
Topbrx
Y-xpotltoco\'IH6lx
ran,rlorpyfin
N{exAy-'
HaceJIeHaeM
I4ulun
u CpelHer:l
Aruu UauSOnee
3KOHOtuHIIHO
OSGtcHflnOOL
rny6OKuM
06ulfiM
po.{CTBON'I NJe;tiAy
gB)i
l,rs
perHoHaN{I,!
c
pacnpocTpaHeH'IeM
]IeKOTopIrlx
cneu]'ltill{a{eoKt{
LIHll4]"lcNII\
IrrlHr.rri
Hacjle-4oBal{rlt
Ha
ceBep.
Y-xpotitocoltHLle
AaHHble
vKa3I'lBaiiLI
Fra npe-
LrN{yrqeCTBeHHO
}o)KHOa3I{aT'CKoe
npo}.lCxox.4eHue
KacTOBt,lX
cOO6UIecTB
i4H,114t'l
I,l ?TO
TaKxe OnpoBeprano
BbtBoll
o
HaKOI4-JTI46o
npl4TOKe
fi3
pernolloB I( CeBepy
vt 3arrat.y
o-r l4Hllt1u
3eMJleAerrBqecKofo
ltrlr rrHAoapllt-rcKoro
}lace-rleHlLfi
(5).
Y-xpovocovl,l
l,tHAl4iicKorO
HaCeJreHur
c}T06pt:,xalr)T
OTHOCIITe-]bHO
He-
3HaqgTeJrLH-vIo
I-eHeTI,IqecKytO
llrlg'raHUn1l
OT
Y-xpOMOCOxf
3anaAHI'1X
eBpa-
226
3r4i41eB.3rO
Ogprtrne
[epBoHaqaJIbHO
yBq3bIBaIOCL
C
Ml4rpaqi4tltll
ttOCItre,refr
rHAoaptrffcKr.{x AnareKroB
B
l4HArIo.
lloct<o,rrry
rarjlorpynra
M17
(Rla)
le-
N{OHCTpltpoBaJra
cHr4)Karou-lyrocr
rracToTy
oT
cpeAHefi
Aaun
no HanpaBIeHuIo
K
Ioxnoii
Wttl4n,6ltl
CAe:raU
BbtBOA
O
TOM, OHa
tBIseTCt
[OTeHqI4aJI6HblM
Map-
KepoM
AaHHO|O
CO6rJTnt.
I.eHeTraru
r4cxoAl4i-rn
u3 cqeHapnt
(oAHa
ranjlolpyn-
[a
rrpr4paBHnBaeTcr
K
oAHOii
M]rrpaqr4u)
rr npeAnoaoxlr,,rl,I,
qTo
Ha6op
fa[nor-
pynr
J2,
Rla.
R2 14
L cBf,3aH
c Mr4rpar-p1eii
trH^4oeBponeiicKofo
Hace-rleHnt
t{
BHeApeHtreM
KacroBoit
crcreMbl
B
tr4HArlo
n3
CpeAHei
A:uu
(6)'
Ho
ecru.r
6r,r
zcroqslrr<oM
pa3HoBr4.tuocTu
Rla Bl4}]'!irlt
AeficTBI4TeJrbHo
6rr,ra
Cpegnrr
A3r4r,
'rorAa
cneAoBalo
6r,r
o)KilAaTb
OSHapy)KeHr4t
Apyrl4x
llpo-
r{cxoAf,Luux
l43
CpeAsefr
A:rn
ranlorpynn
(C3'
DE,
I,l',
l. G, N'
O) e
Ceeepo-
3ana4Hoii
kluguu
B npoflopqfioHaJlbHo
coo6pa3Hltlx
qac'roTax.
O4uaro
IeHeTI4-
qecKr4e
LlCCneAOBaHr4r
He
noATBepAr{Jrr4
?TOT
8618<1A.
ECIU
6r'i
Apyfue
raflro-
rpyfl[bt
5r,rla
yrpaueH],r
B
pe3ynr.TaTe
rr.tnoTeTr4qecKoro
eo$er<ra
fopnblfiKa
6yi"rnn"
(r.e. coprapoBKn
r,u,rHr4!{
HacJreroBaggt
cpeAu
npufiLlBtxl4x
B llHAI4ro
paHgr4x
[rHAoapr4eB),
TO
CJleAoBaJIo
6st
Oxu4arl
oqeH['
H143KOe
feHeTuqeCKOe
pa3Hoo6pa:tge
I4HALificKI4x
JIl4HI4fi
HacJIeAoBaHI4f,
R1a.
Ho cl4Tyal{ut
oKa3alacb
npoflrBofiojrox{Hofi:
raflnorl4noBoe
pa3Hoo6pa3fle
Ha 3aAHeM
nnaHe
Rla B
cpe4ueil
Azur.r,
u
Bocroquofr
Eepone
6nlo
Hzxe,
qeM
B
I4HAH|4.
T.e.
eHcoxas
qacToTa
BcTpeqaeMosg4
Rl*
ra Rla
y
cpeAHea3uaTcKoro
14 Boc'r'or{HoeBponeii-
cKoro
Hace.neHl4fl
(B
6orHuilHcree
cryrlaeB
6es
R2
r'r R*) 6oriee
sKoHoMr4tIHo
O6:b_scgrnaqg
.qB[)KeHHeM
reHeTuqeCKOrO
nOTOKa
B flpOTI4BOIoJIO7(HOM
HanpaB-
ile{|4|\aBo3Mo)KHt,IMI4cToqHuKoN4pacnpocTpaHeH['STltxranjlorpynncTaHo-
Brrac6
IONnax
A':rax
(7).
Ha
oonoeaHlal{
3TI4x
naHHblx
reHeruKl'{
npHuIJI}'l
K Br'IBoAy
o
roM,
qro
He-
O6r3aTerbHO
i4CKaTL
I{CTOqHI4K
My)KCKax
JIl,IHnit
HaCIeAOBAHvfl'
y
l4HAl'liiqeB
3a
[peAenaMr4
IONsofi
Asafl
e ?noxy
Bo3Hl4KHOBeHr4r
OCSAIOTO
3eMneAeJliia.
oHu
OTBepfn[r
TeOpI4]O
O COBMeCTHOM
npi46blTi16
HOBoIO
HapoAa'
fl3t'lKa U
3eMlene-
ilvfl
B vL]i.ill4lo
ltepe3
ceBepo-janaAHr,tii
KoplrAop.
TaKx(e
6rinn
or6poileulr
npeAcTaBneHr4r
o cB.s3H
fanJror.pyfin
J2,
L.
Rla
u R2
c o.4HoBpeMeHHbIM
BO3-
HltKHOBeHueM
MyrKc,KgX
KACTOBbIX
[r4Hnii
HacJ'leAOBaHUt
B L4HA412'
U3BHS
Cy6-
KOHTT{HeHTa.
Tolut<o
llsyrleHfle
pacnpocrpaHeHHOCTI{
rannorpynntr
J2 ronopu-
no o
HecoMHeHHOM
HeAaBHeM
BHerlHeM
npIlTOKe,
HO He
n3 cpe4He[,
a
u3
3a-
naAHoii
A3HIa
(8).
B
rou
xe 2006
r. aBTopr,r
Apyroro
reHeTnqecKoro
I4ccJIeAoBaHufl
3a&a-
Jttrcb
r.le;rbrc
o66rcHr.{Tr'
pe:Ko npoTnBopeqr4Bbre
cBeAeHr4{
o reHeTIrqecKoNI
npoucxoxAeHur4
n!.teMeH
u KacT
K)xsoii
AsHz.
feHeruKl4
cTpeMUJIrlCb
pa3pe-
urr4Tr,
3TO flpoTHBopeqfie,
I4CIlOJIL3yfi
B[,ICOKOTOqgbIe
AaHHI'te
I1O 69
I4HabOpMa-
TrzBHr,rM
Y-xporvocoMHltM
[4apKepaM
I4 10
conyTcTBytolql4M
N4l{KpoMapKepaM
H3 o6111fipHofi
Bi,t6opKtt
reo1pa+1aqeCK]i,
coll{4ailbHo
tl Jlt'IHTBI{cTsqecKI4
penpe-
39HTaTSBH6IX
3THtlqecKl{x
rpynn
torxHofi
Agnr'r. O6Hapyxn;rocb'
qTo
BJI}ttHI4e
Cpe4ueft
A:nlr
na reHeTnrtecKlli{
ua6Op
6uno
He3HaqI4TeJIbHblM.
3noxa
aKKy-
Myjlr4poBaHHoi
rrlrarcpoconyTcTByrc1r1ei.i
Bapl4aTilBHocrh
B 6onbUJHHcTBe
14Hnfifr-
227
-rr-_--<:5et
___l
cKr{x ranrorpynn
ilpeer,rruaer 10000-15000 ler,
tITo
coorBercrBoBaJro
ApeB-
Hocru
perrroHalrnoii
au$$epeuqzaqnu.
Co6paHHbre
AaHHr,ie
oirpoBeprnr4
Mo-
r.enb
HeAaBHero
reHerxqecKoro BJruBaHal
a:
Cpegneii A:ur.r
Aar
o6:r.qcHeui{x
o6napyxeHuoro
reHer[qecroro
pa:uoo6pa3r4r
B ]Oxnori As{n. -['an,rorpynnbr
Rlal
a R2 noxa:alu
4elrorpa$auecKyio
Kol{nneKcHocrb, HecoBMecrnMyro c
HeAaBHHNt egr4Hr4rrHbrM
co6urueu. Taxxe noJ'IyqeHHbIe
AaHHbre
roBopl,r-rrr4
o rro*
nyocrpoBHoll
npoHcxolMeHr{14
HocH're-rer"r
apaerranrlcrcux arra,reKToB.
a He o
cyudecrBoBanna
6lugnoro K
Ao.firtse
I4H4a iacro.rrrflKa 3Haqr4Terr,Horo
reHerrl-
qecKofo
BIruBaHur r,r3-3a
pacce,.reHr4r
3eMreAeJrrr{ecKoro Hacer'lesnr.
O6urlri.i
BbrBoA
cBoAr4Jrcr K cireAylorqeMy:
ornl4ql4Telr,srtii Y--xpollocolauuii
,ras"l-
uratlr
lOxHofi A:lnr
c{lopnaupoeanfi Mnrpaur4r4
ro,roueHoeoii
n npeAronoueHo-
nofi enox
(9).
B
2008 r. rpyflna
yueHrrx noc,re
o6:opa
uMercrq]rxcr reuernuecrcux
ny5-
:rlrxauufi
npnilna K cneAyrcunv o6o6qesragM
(10).
fanrorpynna Rlal. nepe-
gaeaeusril
no uyxcxofi
luunrl Y*xpor,rocounurii reserrlqecxllfi ivapr<ep. o6na-
pyxeuurrii
s 6orsuzx nponopllurx
y
cJraBrHcKofo u nH4oaplrficKoro r\4ylxcKo-
ro HaeeJreHar,
yKa3blBaer
na
o6rqzil
reneru.{ecxnii ucroqxuK 3HaqrdrerbHor-o
qr4cJra
Hocr{Terefi
c,raeqncrcux n uunufrcxt4x
t36IKoB. feueluqecxoe
14 Jrr.rHrBrrc-
TuqecKoe
poAcrBo
Mex{Ay Hocr{Te.irrMr{
au4oapuircxux r{ craBflHcKr4x
Ar4afleK-
ToB rroKa3blBaer.
qro
3Haqr.rre:rbHoe
qr4cJlo
r4x
npeAKoB
o6rara,ro coBr\recrHo.
l4r ne1aeltgq
Mi4rpauur c BocroKa npr4necna 6r,r ua 6a,rras6r rannorp)in-
ny N3,
nocKonbKy oHa irtupoxo
pacnpocrpaneaa
e Poccr4l.t
il ua YnpanHe
-
Mex(Ay
rlepHlrv
n Ean'rnficxzM MoprMu, rro
gror
reneru.{ecxuii MapKep
Ha
Eanranax
se Hari,les. T.e. nunpaqrq
Rlal na Ea,qxaurr
npou3orxJ.ra
Ao
roro,
KaK rannorpynna
N3 ilo.f,BftJ]acb e BocroqHori Eepone. lan,rorpynna
Ni
qaqe
Bcero BcrpeqaeTcx cpeAr{
Srarnon
(610/o)
u
paccN{arpr4Baercr
KaK
drr.ruuoyrop-
cnr,rii
maprcep. fanLrorpynna N3
rarxe
qacro
Bcrpeqaercfl y
cJraBrH e llpu6a,r-
TlrKe
a flpuvepuoraopre. Sror Mapr(ep, corocraBfiMbril no
4penHocrr.r
c
Rlal,
He
Mrrrpr4poBar s -[,IH,qarc. Cqnraerc.x,
uro
rlilrHuoyrpbr np[irlJu.r e llpra6anrany
5000-6000 rrer roMy
uara4. T.e. Mfirpaqru raflnorpyrrnbr
Rlal c BocroKa Ha
Sa,rrcasur
AoJ'llKHa
6r,rla
npolcoii'rn
4o
pacfipocrpaHeHn{
raflrofpynnn
N3 u
raxnlt o6pa:oNr
Hocr.{TeJru Rl al cvorrul ugOexaru KoHTaKTa c
goctarenrr,lra
N3.
CyrqecrreuHo,
qro
ranJrorpynna I-M I 70, cqurarou{arcs
6onee
4penHeri
no cpaBHeHr{ro
c fanJrorpynlofi Rlal-Ml7I4
pacfipocrpaHuBuraqcfl
ns
y6exiu-
ilIa Ha ceBepe
Ea,rras nocne fiocneAHefo reAHr4KoBoro
]\,raKculayua, He 6ur.ra
o6napyxeua
e l4ngun. fannorpynna I urapoxo
pacnpocrpaHeua
e Eepone
-
or
EpnraHlrra
Ao
Pocclrz lr oT Ealrlrxu
go
Fa:rxan. Tyr
oua Bcrpeqaercs
oco-
6euno uacro,
AoxoAr lo
-7lYi
y
xopBaroB Eocnrzr.r-fepueroBuHr-r.
9acro'ra
ee
pac[pocrpaHe*t4fl,
B Pcicclru u Ha Vxparaue cocraBJ.ner
-20oh,
Arrnnu
-
),8To,
fepuanura
-
20%,
fiauuu
-
39Yo. Hopneruu
-
40%.
roxHoii llleeuus
-
40%o u Scrosutl
-
l9o .llpe4no,raraevnii noepacr rannorpynnbr
|
-
22A00
JIeT, STOrO BpeMeH[
AOCTaTOqHO
AJlr
3KCnaHCfiI[, h OHA TaKXe HaNTHOTO
qa[te
Bcrper{aercr
n Eepone no cpaBHeHuro c rannorpynfloi
Rlal. Orcyrcrelre
ran-
228
d
i,
!.
ll
,l:
l
L
norpvrtnbl
I
a I'lutrlu
ucK-rlloqaer
Eepony
rl3
cnucKzt
npapoAllH
uunoapuee'
fa-
nnorpynna
l-M
I 70
6ltla
Hai:l4eua
e
llaxrc'raHe
e o6lene
0
'57oh
u
0'3%o'
xyaa
o'a
Nrorra
6ur'"
rrpuHeceHa
rpeKo-MaKeAoHqaMr{.
B
ueHlurux
KoJruqecrBax
ra-
nxorp.vnna
I o6uapyrxena
Ha
E'rnNHeu
Bocroxe'
Kaexase
ra
e Cpe'4neii
Auu'
Ho
Re
B
l4paHe.
V
sace'reHtu
Cpe4Heil
As[u
ee
qacrora
cocraBrfler
rurub
t t*',ru
npoucxol*AeHne
nHAoapueB
y^a3blBaer
eurd
oAua
rannorpynfla
K*-
l!{9,
rcoropal
urupoKO
potnpot"pt'n"1-u-:.1"0:"
oSuapyrreua
e
6orlrItilx
o6b-
dvrax
y
ropeirqee
(69%;,-;;;;;";'oe
(25
'
yr6eroe
(l59'o)'
Ka3axoB
(l l%)'
ra-
t"o
i;y"1,
irt.cKl4x
B
Taruxenre
(6%)
u
fipoclaune
(14%)'
llo
o4*rwr'r
AaHHI'IM'
e
tr4a\raltoHa
He
6lrra
o6napy)KeHa
Hl'l
y oAHoro
uz
728
MyxrttrH'
Ho
s
ilaxl4-
.t*;r:
oAnoro
vg
176
o6"leaouaT
nbIX
llirl{
:1
0'57"A'
Tlo
4p1'rutl'
ranlrorpynna
Kf
(ilc26-Ml1
u".yt.tuyttl
U""p*u6e'
Augxpa
flpa4eru
rT^Ha
lllpu
JIaHr<e'
Ho
B
ueroM
e
V7*tputt
npncyrcrByer
B
pa3Mep^e
0'8o/o
('3'2o/o
n
3ana4uoii
Benra-
tvnttt3.4Vor
I-y,axapare,
"
l4pu""
e o5'belue
3
6%)'
3to
cBt3l'IBaerct
c
MoHro-
,ToI,TAHEIM
cuuo-'ru6ercxI'INl
BJr''ItHfi
eM'
l'anlorpynnr'r
N3
u
I
He
Aorulu
4o
l4paHa
ll
tr{wgrrlt'
T'e'
ultrpa-
qullunrpaqul4,
pacnpocrpant{}oqaq(qre)
ranrorpynny
R1al
'
Haqa"Ir{c;
He
B
Erpone.
Cenepo-,
ueHTpa"lbHo-
uJll4
BoorotlHo-eeponeficxoe
npor4cxo)*('n'eHne
IannorpynnbrRlallrfiocneAyrcrqag3KcflaHcl{ft{l\'Il{r}]aq}Ifinepeuecnu6rtc
co6ofi
xporr'tocoN{61
rallrorpyfln
I
ra
N3
Ha
BocroK
no
HaflpaBJleHlt}o
x-
vIHI].r4rl'
Coqerantle
BblcoKoil
qacrorbl
BcrpeqaeMoc'fl4
rannorpyflnu
Rlal
u
6lrl:xoro
poAcrBa
c
caHcKptrroM
llpt{cyue
roJlLKO
CTaBqHCKUNI
Ll
[tHAOnpaHcK]rM
Hapo-
Aarl,t.
Ho
fro
cxoAcrBo
""
putnp""tpaHflerct
na
eeponeitcnue
l'IJIl4
BocroqHo-
eBpoileitcKlle
reHeruqecKt{e
NlapKepbt'
TaKHe
Kax
rannorpynnbl
I ll
N3'
xoro-
pbrx
Her
eVlu;rnu.
(Dax'mqecxoe
orcyrcrBue
ranflofpynnbt
K*
e loxuofi
A:nlr
,anno.ru"tCpe4HoroAsutovlCn6upul43cnl'IcKanpapoAl'lHllHAoaptreB-
Ha
ocHoeaHlil{
B},tueu3rro)KeHuoil
r.rH$opMau,fi
LI
o
reHerl4qecKux
ivlapKe-
pax
aBTopLI
cAerail?l
BLIBoA
o
roM'
qro'unnoipyt'no
Rlal
upn6ur:ra
n
Espony
qepe3
npeAKoB
coBp€MeHHbtx
claBflH
n:
tr4Hgnm
u
Aocrurna
Ea'nxan
Ao
roro'
KaK
rannorp)'nna
N3
pacnpocrpaHllracl
Me)KAy
Eanruilct<llu
u
9€pusttrl
uopr-
run.
Taxxe
Olt"no
:ra4ep;xaHo
pacnpocrpaHenne
us
EarxaH
ranllorpynnEr
l u
ona
He
Aocrnrna
r4u4nu.
Bc€
:ro
corracyercr
c
r{
noAAepx,Baer
reopn}o
ucxoAa
us
tr4ugvtr'tcareM-roBopsu{eil
eereil
uHqoeeponefi
clioii
q:stxoeoit
ceuln'
B2009r.KoJI-rleKTl,IBIeHeT'IKoBnpilurd:rKBl'lBoAyt)ToM.t'To$ax.ruue-
cKoe
orcyrcrBlle
xpollocou
VI458
(Rlala7)
3a
npeAenaMu
Eeponst
roBopnr
nporLIB
3Haqlrre,rllHoro
nepe'qaBaeMoro
no
lryxcxoil
JII4HIII'I
flpt{Toxa
reHoB
t{3
Boc'roqgoliBepcnstoA:ltro,BKrrorlattr'fH4xro'no'l'teHsureiiMepe'Haql'lHatco
cpeAHero
rolorrena
(1 l)'
Brolt;xe'o4y6u'ntony6ilnxonaHbrpe3ynbrarl'IreHe'r}'IqecKoroI4ccJle-
AoBaHrIfl
?809
\i-xpon'rocoNt
y
681
6pu*tto*taRblcurux
xacr
n 2128
qneHoB
pa3-
Hbrx
Kacr
u
nleueH'
Oqens
estcoxafi
crenellb
BcrpeqaeMocru
-6o-72'220/o)
Y-
fannorpynnLl
Rlat
y 6paxn'raHon
BHe
3aBl'lcul\focrrl
tlr
vlx
t3EIKoBofr,'I
reorpa-
229
(pavecxofi
npnHaArexHocru
yKar3ErB€rJIa
Ha
ro,
rrro
oHa
flB'rfiyrc
ocHoBo,,o,
roxnnqefi
rvrnnvt
HacneAoeaHu
e.roft
racrosofi
rpynnu
(rannorpyrmofi_
ocHoBarerrb'uueft
la'Hofi nonynxquu).
Coupncyrcren
"
.u.rrro.py.rurr
Rl
a I
r
pa3Hbrx
rrJreMeHax,
HaJrr4qhe
y-rannorpyunrr
Rla
y
npeAKOB
z
pacrurEpennrrz
sranorenerrarecrrft ana,rug
co"o*y.r"15"r"
.qaHHbrx
siO
ranalrrrle
e,
224
naxu-
crarrrleB
n276xurenefi
cpe4weft
Aswuu
erpasnfiqen-nocureneft
Rlal
noA_
rBgpAVtr'x
aBTOXTOHHOe
npoucxor(AeHvre
rrr4uvtyt
HacJreAoBaH[,
Rlal
n
Ioxsoi
Asuu
n
e€ rsreuennyro
cBr3E
c 6paxuauauu^ugun,
orrpo""p.rr"
*o.ru"ru*
HeAaBHefo
BH€ApeHr,rf,
ne
Cpe4neft
Asmu
w
enparuftcroro
,r*"ir^aB
KncroByro
cr'rcreMy
vw!.uu.
Arroprr yKa3rurr{
Ha
HacyrrlHyro
neo6xo4uuocrr
$uror:enern_
lrec*r'o.
r{ccJreAoBarruft
s
ca {rrx
ceBepH'rx
nparrauanafico*
p"rr&u*
Hwyvm,
KOTOp're
MOrJrr{
cJry/X(rrr
anry6aropor
atr"
MHOfrzx
nntrwfi,
HacJreAoBaHr'
ApeBHocrH'
uro6rr
nonyvn*
6onee
.rrcHylo
Kaprvr'y
3acer.reHr,r,
vr;A;;u
Erpa-
suu
(12).
Jlptrrsucraqecnaq
rmroricaa
o'pacnoJroxeHrrr{
[papoAr{Hbr
HHAoeBpo_
neFqer
B
ropHBrx
4onnHax cenepo-3ana4nux
firuanae"
6*
"ur"*a3aHa
eqe
s
1930
r'
(13)
Ho
ecan
zs*rficroe
npo'cxoxqqeH".
"ut.*-.o"o-p"roix
rurro-
enponeftqen-noca'rereft
raffrorpynnEr
Rlar
lroxr-ro
cqr,rrarb
,"eioo-y"ru"o"-
JT.HHBTM'
TO'
H'cMorpr
na
o6napyxenze
n fiauanaqx
r.,,oJrwpoBaHHOrO
KeHTyM_
3311
6amq*a
{14),
c resernqecrofi
roqKlr
3peHru
Borrpoc
o
npapoMne
KeH_
TyM-roBopsu{HX
r,rHAoeBponeftrlea-nocureneft
rarurorpynnrr
Rl
b nora
ocragr_
cr
oTKpLITLIM.
l.
celaeseHro
A.A.
,{re
"uo*.^,-
#ff"1f#ffi;n.-"0 npohneust
//
Bnacrb
14
Hapo,q
B
ycnoBufrx
BofiH
rr
corlr{afiL'r,rx
Kon$.nnrro,r:}Iarepzaurr r{emeproit
parro"uou"or
',ayq'or
ron0eperqrEu
(r'
Bopouex,
2
{erpanx
2010
r.)
/ no4
o6q, peA.
B.i{
fo*u"*u.
Bopor.*,
2010.
c.
242-248.
2'
Hemphill
B.E.'
Lukacs.J.R.,
Kemedy
K.A.R.
Biologicar
Adaptations
and
Afrnities
of
Bronze
Age
Harappans
//
Hanppa
Excavations
1966-tleoo,
a
ilortrair"4r*u.yipprou.h
to
Third
Millennium
urbanism
I Ed.
by
R.H.Meadow.
Monographs
in
woirto
a'.cnaeotogv.
No.
3.
Madison
wisconsin,
1991.
p.
lli-fi+;Kennedy
K.A.{.
Huu.
a.y*,
ueen
loentinea
in
the
prehistoric
skeretar
record
from
South
Asia?
erotogical
antl*opology.and
concepts
of
ancient
races
//
The
Indo-Aryans
ofAncient
south
Asia:
la:nguage,
material
culture
and
eth_
nicity.
Berlin-Ny,
1995.
p.
49
and
54.
3.
witzel
M.
Early
Indian
history:
linguistic
and
textual pararneters
//
The
Indo_Aryans.
p.
113;
Idem.
Autochthonous
Aryans?
TG
Evidence
rrom
ota Indian
and
Iranian
Texfs
//
EIec-
tronic
Journal
of vedic
studies.-7-3.
2001.
p.
9;
Kuz'mina
B.B.
rt"
origi,
"irrr"
mo"_
Iranians
/ Transt.
by
S.pirina
*9
|
Irulorrg.
fa,
t/
l.r.vr"fforv
/ reia.fioJo_iu.op"un
Etymological
Dictionary
Series.
Leiden,
2007
.
p
.
345.
4'
Kivisild
r.
et
ar. The
Genetics-of
Language
and
Farming
spread
in
India
//
Examrnrng
the
lryjpng+lge
dispersal
hvpolhesrs
l i3.*6v
p.
n"r-r*ooa
*
c. Renfiew.
cambridge,2002.
P'
215-222'
cu'
'raxxe:
Kivisild
r.
et
al. The
Genetic
Heritage
of the
Earliest
settlirs
pers-
rsts
Both
in
Indian
Tribal
and
Caste
Populations
//
American
Journal
of
Human
Genetics.
2003.
Vol.
72.P
313---332.
5.
sahoo
S. et
al. A prehistory_of
Indian
y
chromosomes:
Evaruating
demic
dif.fusion
scena-
rios
//
Proceedings
of the
National
Academy
of
Soiences
of
the
united
States
of
America.
Ianuary24,2006.
Vol.
103.
No.4.
p.
843.
6.
Ibidem.
230
'11
7. Ibid
P. 845-846
8. rbid
P 847.
9.
Sengupta
S. et al. Polarity
and Temporality
of Higir-Resolution
Y{hromosorne
Distribu-
ttons in
India Identi$,
Both
lndigenous
and
Exogenous
Expansions
and Reveal
Minor
Genetic
Influence
of
Central Asian
Pastoralists
// Tlie
American
.Iournal
of Human
Genetics.
Vol.
78.
Fctrnrarl
2006.
P. 202---221.
10.
Skulj J. et
al- Indo-Aryan
and Slavic
liriguistic
and
genetic
affinities predate
ihe
origin
of
cereal fatrnittg
// Proceedings
ofthe
Si.rth
lnternational
Topical
Conference
Origin
ofBuro-
peans,
t.jublana.
June
6'r' and 7ft 2008.
Ljubljana,
200g.
p.
5-39.
ii.
Underhill
P.A. et al. separating
the post-Giacial
coancestry
ofEuropean
and
Asian
y
chromosomes
within hapiogror-rp
Rla
// European
Journal
of Human
Genetics.
2009.
p.
1-6.
12.
Shanna S. et
al. The
Indian
origin ofpaternal
haplogroup
Rlal
substant'iates
the autoch-
thonous
origin of Brahmius
and the
caste
systeln //.tournal
of Human
Genetics.
2009.
54.
p.
47-55
13. Lachhmi
f)har
I(alla.
The
Florne
of the Alyas
// The
Delhi
University
Publications.
No. 2.
I 930
14.
Elst I(.
Update
on the
Ar1'an invasion
debate.
New Delhi.
i999.
p,
122-123-
Idem.
Lin-
guistic
aspects
of
the Aryan
non-invasion
theory
//
The lntlo-Aryan
controyersy:
evidence
and infbrence
in Indian
historv.
L." 2(J05.
P.
Z4l .
rIorHTu
rr
E
CKI4R
Kpr{
3l{c B
cKr4
acKol,i
AEPXABE
KOHTIA
rV
BEKA
AO
H.3.
KAK
OXUH
A3
(pAKTOPOB
EE
CKoPoTEqHof
o @I{IIAJIA
B.A. I.Ieauoe
llparrarelrcreo
BoponexcKoft
o6nacrr4
Bonpoc
o rtr6err4
Cxr.r$ci<ofi
Aep)r(aBr,r
-
oAnH
r43
ueHTpanb'rrx.
uo ece
eqe
BecbMa
cra6o
pa3pa6oraHHbrx,
B
npo6neMarr4Ke
r4ccreAoBattuii
s o6,racrH
ApeBHefr
vcropr4r4
r.{ apxeorofr4r.r paHHero
}Kene3Horo
BeKa
rofa BocroqHofi
Ee-
ponrr
(1).
Llcroprz.a
."zyqe*W':rofi
npo6nevbr
Hacqr4TbrBaer
y'.e
floqrr4
Tpr4
crone-
Tuq. OrHaKo
rojr6Ko
Bo BTopofi
no,toBr.rHe
80-x
npour,roro
BeKa
oHa
npuo6pena
caMocrofreJrbHbrfr
xapaKTep.
B
sro BpeMr
cepbe3Hofi
KoppeKTrrpoBKe
noABep-
t.fiac6
xpoHonorrlf
cKr4(po-capMarcKr4x
ApeBHocrefi.
Er,rn etl-reaeH
apxeonoflt-
qecKr4fi
(xr4aryc>
III
e.
ao
u.r.
e Ceeepuolr
llprauepuoN{opbe.
Kpove
rpaAuqrr_
OHHOI,
rOCnOAerBOBaBUeii paHee,
capMarcKoil
KoHltenuuu,
noffBr4Jr}rcb
HoBbre
rr{rore3br,
oo:u.rcurrorque
cKoporeqHbrft
Qznan
cra{rzr.r
z cxradrcrori
apxeono-
rr4qecKofr
Kynbryp;r:
nplrpoAuo-KJrr4MarlqeeKar
I4 sKororrdqecKas
(Z).
Tell
ue
I\{eHee,
B
IIOCneAHUe
AeCflTHJlerUf
6nnu
nonyveHll
AaHH6Ie,
KOTOpbre
no3BoJu-
rcr nan6onee
floJrno.
B
paMKax
KoMnJreKcHOrO
nOAXOAa, peKOHCTpynpoBarb
rrc-
TopnqecKyro
Kaprr4Hy
drr.fra:ra
cru$croi
AepxaBbl
u
cBr3aHHrJrx
c
HLrmi Kpr4-
3rlcur,rx rBrrenrii
B CeBepHoM
llpuvepuouopbe
KoHr,(a
IV
-
flI n.
go
H. s.
(3).
14 nucrnaegnrte,
n apxeonon4r{ecKr{e
r4crolrn[Kr4
Iro3BoJlttor
cAera:r-b
oA-
HOgUaqnHil
BbrBo.q,
qro
B IV B.
.4O
H.3.
AaHHOe
gTHOnOJrr{Tr{qecKoe
o6prBoBa-
231
J|aenuucxu[r
C.l.
HeSoprvaJlbgble
o6gIecrseHHO-[oJII4TI{qegKI4e ABI4)I(eHLtf,
B CoBercKoM
Coro:e
70-x
rogon....
..."'.'....."""""
208
Cuupnoe
A.B. Oxrr6pl
1993
r. KaK
3aBepilIeHI'Ie
coBercxofi
3noxu."""""""
214
PA3AEI
IV.
Bceobulaq
ucropnfl.
Snoxa
ApeBrrocrrr
u CpegHeneronre
Medeedea
A.IL
Apxerrm
(Hartara
rocyAapcrBD)
14 I'tcropfiqecKne
cy4l6rr
ero
lro.qnaHHbrx....................
............224
Ceueweuxo
A.A.
Br<na!,
al{TporroJlor[[
14
reHerHKI'l
B
pelrreHl'Ie unaoapwfr'
crofi
npo6nen4bl
...................
""""""226
l4aauoe
B.A.
flonuruqecru.rii
Kpl43l{c
n
Cxnrpcrofi
.qep)KaBe
Kouqa
IV
e'
Ao
H.g. KaK
o.qrrH
r'I3
iparropon
ee cKopore'{Horo
$nHa;ra
"""""""'23I
LLIa,mee
o.o.
flotrwluil
o reppuropr4cul;HoM
cnope
Puua c
Kap$areHout.....235
Eona.oe
H.H.,
Eoneoaa
A.M.
flexlauaqlrn
Xopuxlu
fascroro
KaK
3aBep-
ueHr4e
as:rnqnofi
prITopI4KI4.'...
"""'236
Patutxoecxan
A.IO.
llttcanteHHar
Tpa,4r.rqur
o xeHqltHax-MoHaxnHfx'l
cBercKl4xBllacrtxpaHHeBll3aHTniictcoftllarec:runr'r
""""""""'242
3onomapee
A.IO.
Cotryasn,nrre
xourpnuKrr,r
B
paHHecpeAHeBeKOBo[
Arr-
rrv114....,,.,,......
""
""
"""
245
lne1oe
A.l.
Brlacrs
u oSrqecrro
B
paHHecpeAHenexosofi
AHrlnra:
6ypro-
Barr
crlcreMa
Anr$pe4a
Be:rnxoro..... """""""""'
248
conodoanurcoea
o.c.
Ilpr,runnr,r
r.r cJleAcTBr4r
BbicTynJIeHI4t
6ocnr.rficrofr
Brracrerlbl
nporlaB
Baxa
Teprra
I e
1366
roAy
........".''
"""""""253
Myxateaa
M,A.
Asrtto-wo.InasAcrcr.rii
AoroBop
1586
r.: npo6leua
Tl4rorlo-
rnlI
...............
"""""""
258
PA3AET'I
V.
Bceo6qas
rrcroprfl.
Honoe
r
Hoseiiuee
BpeMs
l4aauoe
lo.B.
flopryrarr4fl:
nojllrTHqecKr{e
Il coqflaxlHble
nocIeAcTBHfl
paanaila*ono""arritoii
nn'rneplrtl....
""""""""""'264
Tpyxauee:a
[.8.
BoccTanrae
Po6epra
Slnrera
e klpflauauu'
Ealanc
nporl4-
uo6op.t"ytorql4x
QIIJI """""""""""270
E z op
oe
M. B.
fiauwe
n
O'Kouue,u-
"
Ocn o6o4urenb
"
:
noruTu
qecrHe
esrrt-
nr,l
.............'..
"""""""275
5.i:'
:
405