306 Chapter 6
Using Entropy
the constant-temperature process is
1S
2
2 S
1
2
/
n 5 R ln1V
2
/
V
1
2 (6.31)
where n is the amount of substance on a molar basis (Eq. 1.8). Next, we consider how
the entropy change would be evaluated from a microscopic point of view.
Through more complete molecular modeling and statistical analysis, the total num-
ber of positions and velocities 2 microstates 2 available to a single molecule can be
calculated. This total is called the thermodynamic probability, w. For a system of N
molecules, the thermodynamic probability is w
N
. In statistical thermodynamics, entropy
is considered to be proportional to ln(w)
N
. That is, S ~ N ln(w). This gives the
Boltzmann relation
S
/
N 5 k ln w (6.32)
where the proportionality factor, k, is called Boltzmann’s constant.
Applying Eq. 6.32 to the process of Fig. 6.7, we get
S
2
2 S
1
/
N 5 k ln
w
2
2 k ln
w
1
5 k ln
w
2
/
w
1
(6.33)
Comparing Eqs. 6.31 and 6.33, the expressions for entropy change coincide when
k 5 nR
and w
2
/w
1
5 V
2
/V
1
. The first of these expressions allows Boltzmann’s constant
to be evaluated, giving k 5 1.3806 3 10
223
J/K. Also, since V
2
. V
1
and w
2
. w
1
, Eqs. 6.31
and 6.33 each predict an increase of entropy owing to entropy production during the
irreversible adiabatic expansion in this example.
From Eq. 6.33, we see that any process that increases the number of possible
microstates of a system increases its entropy and conversely. Hence, for an isolated
system, processes occur only in such a direction that the number of microstates avail-
able to the system increases, resulting in our having less knowledge about the condi-
tion of individual particles. Because of this concept of decreased knowledge, entropy
reflects the microscopic disorder of the system. We can then say that the only pro-
cesses an isolated system can undergo are those that increase the disorder of the
system. This interpretation is consistent with the idea of directionality of processes
discussed previously.
The notion of entropy as a measure of disorder is sometimes used in fields other
than thermodynamics. The concept is employed in information theory, statistics, biol-
ogy, and even in some economic and social modeling. In these applications, the term
entropy is used as a measure of disorder without the physical aspects of the thought
experiment used here necessarily being implied.
Some 135 years ago, renowned nineteenth-century
physicist J. C. Maxwell wrote, “. . . the second law is
. . . a statistical . . . truth, for it depends on the fact that
the bodies we deal with consist of millions of molecules . . . [Still]
the second law is continually being violated . . . in any suffi-
ciently small group of molecules belonging to a real body.”
Although Maxwell’s view was bolstered by theorists over the
years, experimental confirmation proved elusive. Then, in 2002,
experimenters reported they had demonstrated violations of the
second law: at the micron scale over time intervals of up to 2
seconds, entropy was consumed, not produced [see Phys. Rev.
Lett. 89, 050601 (2002)].
While few were surprised that experimental confirmation had
at last been achieved, some were surprised by implications of
the research for the twenty-first-century field of nanotechnology:
The experimental results suggest inherent limitations on nano-
machines. These tiny devices—only a few molecules in size—may
not behave simply as miniaturized versions of their larger coun-
terparts; and the smaller the device, the more likely its motion
and operation could be disrupted unpredictably. Occasionally
and uncontrollably, nanomachines may not perform as designed,
perhaps even capriciously running backward. Still, designers of
these machines will applaud the experimental results if they lead
to deeper understanding of behavior at the nanoscale.
“Breaking” the Second Law Has Implications for Nanotechnology
microstates
thermodynamic probability
Boltzmann relation
disorder
c06UsingEntropy.indd Page 306 5/26/10 2:41:03 PM user-s146c06UsingEntropy.indd Page 306 5/26/10 2:41:03 PM user-s146 /Users/user-s146/Desktop/Merry_X-Mas/New/Users/user-s146/Desktop/Merry_X-Mas/New