Мартынчик Е.Г. Акты адвокатского расследования: виды, форма, содержание, значение
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
POCChhCKAt
locrtluilq
yfo^oBHbiz
nPouECC
Nr
9/2009
AKTbr AIBOKATCKOTO
PACCJT
EflOBAHUfl:
B l4[bl,
ooPMA,
CTPyKTyPA,
CoEEPXAH V1E
U
3
HAL| EH H E
;.f.
MAPTbIHT{I4
aoKTop
IopunHrrecKux IIa)'K,
rrpoSeccop
K,t
to,t
ea or e ci os a
:
)'eot
o s u ar
i
n
po
4e
cc,
y
?
o/t
o I
t
t o
-
| |
p0
Lle cc))
-
at an at it a rcnr,
ad eo xo ttt
c
tto
e
p
a cct e d o B o r t u e, o n ttt tr a
d e
o rca m
c
x o
-
ea
pocuedo60Hut
Ana.'tus
)rce ntaKoel
poda
uop,tt
),eoi06Ho-tlpollecc))u.'tbHleo
npo6o
nnso.lnen
o1pomunlb
lHuilaHue uo
ciedyrcqse.
I'lpuru-
tnue
u"4u c}ctnQsrlettue
npoLFCCyaJlUrbtx
QKn7B no
yeo.tOenoru
de-
.'ta.\l cocnaBnflem
npepoeamuey
cyda, cydau, nporcypopa,
ctredoaa-
me.ta,
dosttaaameln s
xode suno.irreHua
u,+ru ny6:tuquo-npoeosbtx
t!1,nr4ui.
llttottue ecmecmleHHo,
Lrmo
ocHolHbrc napailempil npu-
t I Ll.\4
O e N UX
U,tt U
p
e U e U u u
t1 C O C ffi A
6.4
fr
€ t\r U X
Lt It btx 11
p
O Lrc C C
V
An b H btx
a rcmo
e o n
pe
de:tfl e
m
y
eoi oe H o
-
n
p
o
4e
c c'), o.r bu ur i s orco
u.
7ba ae
uertee oH
He
ypeeynupoSe.l
noutmue
<yeon06Ho-npo-
\eccyalbttbtu
oKm>,
Q n|oKil{e
ocft1Q6u] sHe
peznaileHma4uu
tlol-
no,r'toqua
6cex
yqacmtruKo6
cm0poH6t
3auumu Ha npuqflmue
u.tu
cocntoSJle Hue t1
p0
4ecc):h1
bHbtx
0 Ktn06
n0
yeoroB
H 0,v), oe.1)"
code
p
-
tcoilue
u
rlop.tty
ux,
xomn
3m0 o4elb lo)ailo )ta souqutnu
u lxpa-
ltbt
npae, ceo6od,
3oKoHubtx
uHmepecol
J.lLtLtHocmLt.
Analysis of
the same kind
of rules of criminal
procedure
allows
lo tlrau,
attention to
lhe
following.
Acceptance or a
procedural
acts
in
criminal cases
is the
prerogative
of rhe
court,
juclge,
prlsecutor,
investigator, in the dischorge
of their
public
lau,functions. Natural-
ly,
the bosic
parameters
oJ'tlteir
decisiotrs ancl ntakes other
proce-
clural acts deterntines
the
Criminal Procedure Acl.
l{evertlreless,
it is not
settled notion of
<criminul
procedure
acl,>, ond alsl
left outside
the regulatory
outh0rity
of
all
porticipants
in
the defense
or
the
ldoptiln
of the
procedural
acts of a criminol
case,
lhe contenl
andform, though
if is
veryt
iryps,1n,tt to
pt'otect
and
safeguard the rights,freedoms
legitimate interests of the individual.
Pa:pa6orra
npo6.rre:u
npouecc-vanbHo-npaBoBbrx
aK-
TOB B HayKe
OTeqeCTBeHHOfO
yfoJ'lOBr-tOfO
Cy.qonpou38olc-
l'Ba Ilpou.rla
HeCKO;'lbKO
3TallOB, HO
lvtbl
He CTaBlll\.,l
3a,Iaqy
IlcecTopoHHe H lrclrepflbrBaroue
onpeIe.rHTb H
ocBeTr.rTb
I1x.
Bcero,r
uru r frpe,ilnpH
H I.t N.raercg
fl oII btrKa Hatrlerurb KoI ITy-
p
br nep[oaH3aut4
H
pa3BHTHfl
lr COBeplIleHCTBO BaHHq
TJCCJ'Ie-
,qOBaHfi
fi
naHHoir
npo6nel\,taTn
Krr.
llepnr,rii
3Tan cBr3aH
c co3.[aHueN.r ocr{oB
Teopt{x cy-
Ie6Hbrx
peueHnii
B
yfor.toBHoNl
npouecce n oxBart.r,'r 11c-
c,reAoBaHr.re troHsrnfl
lr
r,racclr$rr KaLIrnl Ha3BaHubtx
pe-
uer{rril,
octiosaHl.{ilt
ilptJHflT}Jfl,
@op:Vur
}t
colepxaHH.q nx
ll t'.r.
I
I-la
tranHont
3Tane B
ocr{oBHot\r
peqb
u.,ta ro-rrbKo o
pe-
IUCHHTX B
yror'rOBHOt\l
CyAOfrpot.l3BoAcTIle, xoTrr
npell\.reT
ilcc.rleaoBaHHfl
3Hflqt4]'€r'tbHo
Uil4pe, It6O BKrtrcqaeT H3yqe-
IrHe
aKToB B
vro.rroBHol\.r
npouecce. OrueqellHal oco6eu-
H OCTb I'r
pos
Br.rJ'rac
b B l,r
cctreao
BaH HH cy/Ie 6 H brx
pe
u e H t{ I:l
Ha BTOpOlvl
3Ta[e, KOrAa
yqel'lble-rcpfiCTbl,
c or],Ho]I
CTOpO-
rrbl, Haq&[u
pa3pa6a'rblBarr
npo6,reuy aKTou B
yfo,floBHo]\,1
fipouecce2, a c
Apyror:i
-
rro[]J'[] no nyTr.i
,ileT&rlr{3arl!.ll{
Hc-
c-q
eaoBaH !r i:i
yronoBHo-
frpoueccyan
bH brx aKro
B H
pa3pa60r-
KII Ottre.lbHblx
acnerros
Hrr,
llaxrto noAqepKHyrb,
Lrro
el[e
Ha nepBol'{ 3Tane 6brno
o6oc
HoBaHo KoHue nry&rl
bHoe il o,rtoxeHue,
coxpar{'I louee
aKTyiLIr b rr
ocrb n o
ce
i.'t
ne
Hb, co r;'r
ac Ho xoropot\t
y
y
roJ'l
o B H
br ri
npouecc
cocTaBtrrrroT
l{e To.rlbKo
.iier"rcTBtrfl
cyna,
npyfHX
op-
laHoB,
oTBeTCTBeHHbtX
3a
yfonoBr{oe,{e,llo,
HO tI
ftpOUeCCy-
aJ'rbHbre
aeiicTBHfl
il aKTbr
.[pyruIx
yqacT]tfiKoB
npouecca'.
Lauttoe
roJ'roxeHr{e
orHoct4Tcs u K aKTarr raKoro
cy6beKTa
yronoBrroro
ilpouecca,
KaK atrBoKar.
Bor nouevy
oHo
3aHu-
N{ae'f rlo3H
Ur.rn
ucxoA]rofo,
KoHrlenTyan bIIofo
non oxe
I rr,rrr
B
I.Icc.[enoBaHHu
npo6.telrlr
npoueccyan
br.tbtx
aKToB aJIBoKar-
cKoro
paccJreaoBaH
t{fl
.
6,r aroAapx
H
ayq l{ br r\.1 r.{ccr'reloBaH
I,rrilvt
r.{ noTpe6
r{ocTfl
\t
n
parlo
rr
pr4
l\,re H r.rreJ'r br{
o it n
pa
KTH K I r, Ka K r\ttr e npeacra
oJI
g
er-
Ct,
yAa,rOcl
flpll BII ell b
BH
tl
NI al{ He 3aKoHOn aTe,{
bHO ii B,'l acTH
K
BOIIpOCaI{
HOpN{aTI.{
BHO- npaBOBO fO
pefy,l
fi
pOBaH
Ht
yro-
noBH
o- npoueccya-rr
bH brx
aKToB lloo6 rue, a TaKXe
frpoueccy-
&rl bLI brx
H
cyle6Hbrx
pe
uje r r H r:i n o
_vroJt
oBH
br t\t,Ie.[
a]\r. Il ol
ts
-
Tt{e H
cyrrlHocrb
prrjla
3rlrx
peueHril
pacKpbrn
rronr,rri Yfl
K
Pocc n n
c xori.r
(De,qe
pauu
r.t.
B
.tactnocrrl,
oH
BBer B HaylrHo-npaKTuqecKHrl 06o-
poT
HoBbre
|IpoueccyanbHbrc
aKTr,r,
HanpllMep
separrxr
(n.
5
cr.
5 YflK).
Brrecre
c ret\{ 3aKoH
pacKpbrn
noHrrr!{riHo-co-
nepxarenbHyro cropoHy raKr.rx
yfojloBHo-npoueccyanb-
Hbrx
aKToB, KaK
nocTaHoBJ,reHr4e, nperrlcTaBlleHI4e,
frpo[ec-
cyaxbHoe
peueHHe,
npilfoBop,
caHKurrfl
(nn.
25, 27,28,
33, 39
cr.
5
ynK).
Kpoue roro,
B 3aKoHe c$oprry,rnpoaa-
Hbt LI 3aKpen,reHrr
rpe6oBarrrrfl, Koropbn\{
no,'rx}{bt
coor-
IreTcTBOBaTb
OnpeaeneHt{t
cyaa, frocTaHoBJ'teHI4t
cyabH,
npoKypopa,
cIe/toBaTeJ.lrr,
no3HaBaTei'rq.
B cooTBeTcTBril{
c
np I,Ill
u
L{ fioM
3a Ko Hr{
ocTrl fr epeq H
c,.r e I{ H
bre npoueccya,Il
b
-
Hbte
peueHrifl
Aonxtlbr
6urrt :axouHbl\IH, o6ocr{oBaFl}rbr-
r\{uJ
NrorHBr.lpoBaHHblt!{H (v.
4
cr.
7
ynK).
B
cucrelry
npoueccya-qbHbrx
aKToB rto
y[o,qoBHbr]\,r
ae-
J'Ial\'l BXOntlT
3aKIIlOqeHI.{e
3KCnepTa, IIpOTOKOT'Ibl
CJe,{C-
rBeHHbrx
Aei{crBirr:i,
cy.ry,e6}tbrx 3aceAaHr{}"{
(cr.
83
yn
K),
xorrarai;icrBa,
xano6br
(cr.cr.
ll9, 123
ynK),
3arrB.rre-
HHe
O npecryn.ryeHull,
rrBKa
c noBnHHoi.i
(nn.
l, 2 cr.
140
yll
K),
panopr
o6 o6H apyxeH H r.r rrpn3HaKoB npecryn,TeH
ltfl
(cr.
I 43
yn
K).
3axouoaarer'r bH bre
perJr
ar\{eHraur.{!r
Ha3Ba-
Hiri;i,
tpop;vlr
rr coAepxaHnq
nepequc.qer{Hbrx aKroB
rro
yro-
"qoBHbtN{
Aenal\{
II03uoJ'tqtor Br,taeJIHTb
rperni-r
3Tau
B
pa3-
BIlT14r,r I{
riop},raT}1BHo-npaBoBoi\{
perynHpoBaHHr.{
Bcefo
l\'lacc HBa
npoueccya-rt
bH brx,:toKyr\.lerrTo
B
B
poccfi
fi
cKoNr
yfo
-
rlOBr{OM ftpouecce.
Aua,rus
xe raKofo
poaa
HopM
yfo,'IoBHo-rrpoueccy-
&IlbHoro
npaBa no3Bonqer
o6partrrb BHHNtaHt{e
Ha cneAyo-
ruee.
[lpuunTHe
vru
cocraB,teHr{e npoueccya-rrbHbrx
aKTor]
no
yfo.l'roBHbrI{
aeIraN{
cocTaB,'rqeT
npepomTtrBy
cyAa, cynb}.1,
n
poK-vp
o
p
a, c"t eAoBaTe,'l
9,,{o3 H a BaTe.rir B xoae Bbr
fron He
rJ H t
l1
N{ H ny6nrlqHo-
il
paBoBbrx
$yHxUH
ri. Bno:r
ue ecTecrBe
H I
Io,
tlTO
OC liOBHble
napa\.{eTpbl
np H rl I,l N{aeN{blX I.{l\,1
l.l
pe
LU e H
I I I'i I
I
cocTaB,{reN{brx
}r H brx
n
poueccyarr
bLt btx
aKTolt
oil
pele.[r
eT
vlo-Torl
r
o- fl
poueccyturr
bH br ir 3a KoH.
Tell
ue
r\reHee oH
rre
yperynl.rpoBarr
nor.rrrrrre
(yfo.qoB-
HO-npoueccyarlbHbUi
aKT)), a
TaKXc
ocTaBIJ.rt
BHe
perr'lalleH-
Taulltl
noJ'ltiol\{o(tt{fl
Bcex
}'qacTHHKoB
cTopoHbI
3ault,trbl
Ha IlpHHqTr.le
H,'rr.t
cocTau,'leHtte npoueccyarrbHbrx
aKToB
Ilo
.vfonoBHot\ry
nen)',
coaepxaHrJe n
Qoplty
I4x.
xort 3To
orrgnb
BaxHo
a,rrt
3a[IilTbr
u oxpaHbt
npaB,
cBo6oa,
3aKoHH],rx
I{H-
TepecoB
r'M!tHocrrr. I,llteguo
06 3Tot\,i u nori,rler
pertb
AzuIee.
Teoperuvecroe
ocr\l brcne
H He
fiepeq
ucr'IeH H
bIX rI
r{Hbrx
Bon
-
pOCOB
IIpenO
n
peAene
HO 11 l\.ferc ll{l{ lv{ llcfl
FIOBbll\t I{ 83 fntAa-
MH HA I.IHX.
Oco6eH rr
o 3To orHocr4rcrr K
re$i,rH
u
ur{
r{ npouecc)iulri
b-
Hbrx aKToB,
no.[ KoTopbr\1il nortrrMaroT
.qeHcTBUe
yqacTHI,t-
Ka
vt-olI
o Brto-
npol
teccylLl
r,t {oii
-1ef
re.t bt tocrr
I, o6.re,te
H I I
oc
Np 9/2009
vfo^oBHbll/
nPouECC
POCChhCKAt
locrtlu}lR
B
npoueccyanlrryrc
Sopuy
(ycrairoe.neHHyro
3aKoHoM'
-
E.M.)
u 3aKpenJIeHHoe
B rlpoueccyarlbHolu
,toxyueHres.
Ta-
KOe
froHsrHe
yronoBHo-npoueccytu'ibHblx
aKTOB
nO3BOJ'Itl-
er
uaccll$uut{poBarb
ux
Ha nporoKottbl
ll npoueccyiulb-
tture
peuleuHfi6.
O,uHonpeuet{Ho
3aecb
yMecrHo
cae,'larb
aKueHT
l{ Ha
Tor!,t,
tlro
Il
pI{BeaeH Hal
neQt
t H I t ultfl
n
po
ueccyan
bH blx aKToB
pacnpocrpaHterctt
Ha rcex
cy6lexloB
yro,ToBHo-npoueccy-
a-qbHoii
aenreJTbHocrn.
flocrol;xy
B cilny
3aKoHa
aaBoKar
TOXe
BXOAI4T
B CHCTeMy
raKoBblxJ
a noroMy
coBepIUaeT
npe-
.[y0vroTpeH
H nre
vfl
K I
po[eccyan
bH ble
.n
elicTBi{tl
H BBI4Ay
fTofo
Ao.nxeH
oTpaxaTb
tlx B npoueccyMbHblx
aKTax.
MexnyreM
uMeHHo
no noBony
3Toro
H Bo3HHKalor
ca-
ir{bre
ocrpble
HayqHo-ilpaKTHqecKlte
npo6,leltu
peanl{3a-
ut4
H arBoKaroM
non Ho Mou
l'l i't co
nepru arb
ilpcueccya-rl
bHble
.nelicrgt,tit
u oco6eHuo
o6,'lexatl
IlX
B npoueccyarlbHble
aK-
rnr.
B
oruoueulll.t
cy6t'exroB
cropoHLI
3aluHTbI,
B
ToM
qilc-
,!e
anBoKara,
uonntti
VflK
Pocclliicroii
cDeaepauui'{
He co-
aepxHr
Heo6xoatttrl
ltx
pe
fr
aNl e H
rau14 I"l,
pefyn
upynuHX
cyunocrb
t4 conepxaHl{e
ilpoueccyanbHblx .[.eiicrBufi,
a
TaKXe
aKTbl,
B KOTOpbIX
OHH
OTpaXaOTCtl.
6o,ree
roro.
HMetoil{Hecfi
B HeM
pauuoHubHble [oJIo-
xelu{g
orHocttre,'IbHo
npoueccyanbHblx aeilcrntlii
n
npo-
ueccyanbHblx
aKToB
a,qBoKara
oAHocTopoHHH,
Heno,'IHbl
l{
Aaxe
frporl.{BopeqHB},1,
qro
AonxHo
6ltrl
ycrpaHeHo
B npo-
uecce
coBepIxeHcrBoBaHun Aeficrnyrcutero
rpeaepa;lbHofo
yforoBHo-npoueccyanbHoro
3aKoHa.
O6ocuonaHsocrl'
rlpl4-
BeneHHbrx
cyxaeuuti
noarBepxaaer
cpaBHHTenbHo-IIpaBo-
nori
a
ga,r
n: HopM
yronoBH
o-n
poueccyu
bH ofo
3aKoHa'
Bo-neprrtx,
s YnK
Ha3BaHbI
pa3nHqHble
npoueccyar'lb-
lrr)re
aKTbr
no
yfo,toBHblN{
aeraN{,
Ho noHffTHe,
@optrla
n co-
repxaH
He
I{x He
yperyn
HpoBaH
bl. Tarcu v l't
npoueccyaJ'l
bHbl
-
Mt{
aKTaMl.r
tBJIfl
lorcg:
}4Hoe
.[.eHcTBHe,
npeaycMorpeHHoe
yronoBr{o-npoueccyanbHblM
3aKoHoM
(n.
32
cr. 5 YllK);
xoAalaticrsa
(cr.cr.
I 1
9,
120 Yfl
K)
;
xalo6rt
(cr.
1 23 Vll
K)
;
.sBKa
c
nosnHHotA
(n.
2 cr. 140
ynK).
Bne
coltHeHNii,
'tro
Bce nepeqilcneHHble
npoueccyanb-
rro-
npaBo
Bbre
,[eIZcrBI,'lg,
H MenIuHe
cyu{ecrBeHHoe
3Haqe-
true
iLrls
oxpaHbt
ltpaB H cso6oa
tll'{tl}{ocrl't,
BoccraHoBtle-
HHtr
ee
3aKoHHbtx
HHTepecoB,
HenpeMeHHo
ao,TXHbl
6blrl'
o6;reqeulr
B IIHcbMeHHyro
Sopuy.
h oco6enHo
rorAa,
Koraa
oHH
ricxoarr
or
a.[BoKara,
nocKo:lbKy
nilcbrleHHafl
Sopva
fl
pOUeCC-Van bHblx
aKTOB,
COCTaBJIeH
H bIX l4lr'1,
Bn0.rl
He COOT-
ucrcruyer
rpe6oaaHrtlu
npoueccya[lHoti
$opull,
cocraB-
Ltrrouler'i
oalty
H3 ocHoBHblx
Kareroplli4
ylonoBHofo
cyAo-
rrpoH3BoacrBa.
llecuua
cyuec'IBeHHo
H ro.
rlro.q.etlcrsh.q
annoxara
(xo-
,ila'raricrsa,
xan
o6tt
).
llanoxe
H H ble B rl LlcbMeH
Hoi
Qopue,
1'O ecrb
B B'{tre
oTjle-lbHblx
npo[eccy&qbHblx
aoKyMeHToB,
o6.'raAarcr
x
rpyrHl{}{
BaxHbtMH
KaqecrBaMl{. Taruuu,
Ha-
n
pH
Mep,
xar o6ocrtonaH
Hocrb.
y6e.l.ure,rrHocrb,
noc,TeAo-
BaTe,'lbHOCTb
ll3tloxeHl'lt{
N{aTepl{.?-la
B
U9,'IOM
X OTneJIbHblx
aouoaoB,
B
qacrHocrll,
a raKxe
qerKocrblo
BblBo.{oB
H Tpe-
6ouattllli.
Moxuo
JrHlub
coxa--terb,
rtro
.laHHblH
acneKT
npouec-
cyanbrrbrx teilcrsHil
lt aKroB
a:noxarcxoij nefl'retlbHocr14
HopMarl4BHo
He
ypery,rlipoeaH
(
Kpolle aner'lrsul'lollHblx
l'l
Kaccallror{Hsrx
xa,ro6
aaBoKara.
-
E.M.)
}I, C,leAOBareJIb-
uo, rpe6yer
3aKoHoAaren
bHoro
yperynHpoBa
H H ff n
pocc
t't it
-
cKor\.{
yfonoBHo-
npoueccyarl
bHoM
n
paBe'
.
Bo-sropbtx,
A,ltt
cropoHbl
3aLlIHTbl
B
ytoJloBIJoNr
cyao-
ryoH3BOACTBe,
H
npe)KAe
Bcefo
&'1t
no!,o3peBaeMofo,
06-
Mofo,
noacyaltMoro
H
3aIuHTHHKa
oco6oe
3Har{eHI'Ie
npeAocraBJ'leHHoe
uM npaso
co6nparb
H npeacTaB-
Jrrrb
aoKa3arerlcrBa
(uv.
2, 3 cr.
86
ynK).
Pea,lu:auNq
ero
cBrr3aHa
c
coBepueHueM
npoueccya,lL'Hblx AeiicrBl4fr
H co-
craBJ'teHHeN{
npoueccyarbHblx aoK}'}leHToB'
a
3Ta
cropoHa
arBo
Karc
Ko
ii
aettreJl
bHocrl4
coBep
IxeH Ho
H e
ypery,{u
poBa-
Ha
yfonoBHo-npoueccyanbHblM
3aKoHOl\'{'
HeCMOTpfl
HA
ee
npaKTHqecKoe
3Har{eHHe
B Cl{ny
H3l\leHeHI'{fl
Hepapxul'I ueH-
uocret?
B
yronoBHot\.{
cyAonpou3BoAcrBe:
JTuqHocrb
-
o6-
uecrBo
-
focyAapcrBo'.
B
.{actFlocru,
n.32
cr. 5 YtlK
coAepxur
HoBylo
rpaK-
ToBKy
KarefopHi't
<ilpo
ueccyu
bHoe
Ae
il
crBlre>,
cocraBH
bl
-
r\,rx
KOTOpOTO
tlB,'ltloTct
cneacroellHoe,
cyae6Hoe
u l'{Hoe
AericrBlle,
npeaycMorpeHHoe
3aKoHoM.
floc,'IeaHHIi
xe
.u,o3Borqer
co6
npau
ne
aoKa3are,'l
bcrB
nlrelvt
n
po
I43Bon
crBa
.n
o3H aBaTe.qeM,
cJI
eil oBaTeneM
)
npo
KypopoM
l{ cyAol\'I
cn e.{c
-
TBeHHbrx
r.r
t{HbIX
rrpor{eccyanbHblx aeiicrBHit,
npeayct'lor-
peHHblx
3aKoHoM
('r.
I cr. 86
ynK).
Ilorilqecxoe
3aBep-
tlreHi{e
npfiBeaeHHoro
npeartHcaHlJfl
HaxoaHrcfl
s cr.
166
YfIK,
roropaq
onpelenser
o6urlle
rpeboeaxNa,
npeabt{B-
,'rteMble
K
n
poroKo.rly
c,r eJcrBe
H H o
fo
ne
fi cr BHq.
floAo6Hat
fiocreAoBare]'lbHocrb
ll crpot.lHocrb
per-
raueutauuli
He
co6ntoaeHa
B
orHolxeHlrH aeqre,llHoc-
Tlr
3aUHTlll{Ka-atrBoKara
Htt orHocllTeJ'IbHo
Ha3BaHI4tl
co-
BepuaeMbtx
HM
npoueccyanbHblx r,elicrBl4li,
Hll
[paBoBblx
aoK)ryeHToB,
B
Koropblx
Hailrlexllr
Qurcuponarb
llx
l'{Tof}4.
Tax,
u. 3
cr. 86 YflK
saxpennqer
cnenyiou{ue
HoBble
H orleHb
BZU(Hble
IIorToxeHI4t,
peulaMeHTHpylouHe co6npauue ao-
Ka3are,rlbcTB
nyTeM:
Onpoca
JIuu
c t'tx
coilIac]{q;
no,rlrleH}4t
npeaMeroB, noKyMeHroB,
I4Hblx cse.[eHuii;
ucrpe6onanHn
cnpaBoK,
xapaKrepHcrl{K, apyrt{x
noKyMeHToB
OT
OpraHoB
rocyaapcrBeHuofi
sracru,
opraHoB
MecrHofo
caN'loynpaB-
J'reHilt
u o6utecrseF{Hbtx
opraHH3auHt.
Onpeae,reHt{bte
3aKoHoM
nyri'l
co6tlpauul
.x,oKa3a-
TerbcrB
3auurHHKOM
nO CBOelz
npt'lpoAe
!l
cyulllocrr{
tlB-
J'rrrorc.s
npoueccyanbHbtMLl.
Kax
gHaxosble
oHll
rpe6ynr
a,[e
KBarHo
ro n
paBoBo
ro o6ecne']
eH
]'l r Bo3MoxHocre
i;i n
po
-
uecca
co6upaHwfl
t4 oco6eHso
Surcautlu
cobpaHuoii aora-
3areJrbcrBeHHofi
uu@opuauHu.
Mexay
reM
raKoro
o6ecne-
qeHufl
npouecca
co6paHHrtx
3arrllTHllKoM
AoKa3are,'Ibcl'B
yroJroBHo-
n
poueccyan bHbI fr 3aKoH
He
npeAycMarpH
Baer'
xoTr
B HeN{ H COAepXaTCtl
onpeaeleHHble
pernaMeHTautll{'
HMeroull{e
npfiMoe
orHoueHHe
K.[,eRcTBHtlM
fi aKTaM,
B KO-
ropbrx
Ha{JIexl{r
orpaxarb
yronoBHo-npoueccyanbHylo
ae-
qTEIbHOCTb
A.IIBOKATA.
3axos
n
peaycr{
arp}4
Baer
Bo3l\'r oxHocrb
coBepu
e }l
Ht
l4Hbrx
AeticTBuh
uapxly
co c,reAcTBeHHblir',ll4
H Cyae6HblMll
Aei;icruHqvU.
flpeAcran,'r'eTCr,
rrTo
HHbte
npoUeccyarlbHble
!,eilcrBns
-
3ro
H ecrt
npeaycMorpesHltill
VflK
nopla,or
co6lrpaHl.tr
r,oKa3areJ'IbcrB
a.[,BoKaroNt.
O,qHaro
cy[lecrBeH
-
Hstfi
npo6el
3aKoHo.u,arenbcrBa
KaK
pa3
I'I cocroxT
Il roM'
rrro
oHo
He
ycraHoBllro
flopqaKa
u cy6texrou
ux
npol'i3-
BoacrBa,
a raKxe
$opl.lu
I,t co.ilep)KaHutl
npoueccyaJ'lbllblx
aKToB,
B
Koropbtx
$ttxct'tpyerct
noryqeHHaq
aoKa3arei'Ibc-
rBeHHaq
l.rHSopuaurs
IIo
yroJloBHoMy
Aeny.
Bor
noveuy
xpailue
Ba>KHo
N seo6xoaulrao
Yfll(
Poc-
cu licxoii
OeAepauIlt
aollo,l
H
I'{rb c,leAynul't
M
14 n
o,'l oxe
-
HHrNr.{:
.t.
I
cr. 83
ynK
yKa3aHI4eM
Ha ro,
(lro
ar.BoKar
KaK
cy6r'exr
cropollbt
3a[Inrbl
BnpaBe
npoH3Bo.4HTb
]ltlble
npo-
ueccyaJlbHble neijtctBtlq,
HarlpaoneHHlte
Ha co6upaHt,te
ao-
Ka3aTeJrbcrB;
npofi3BeneHHble
anBoKaroM
HHble
npoueccy-
aJrbHble
neirctsufl,
orpaxalorcg
B nporoKollax
oilpoca
r'IHu,
npeAocTaBneHwfl.
rrJlrl
Bbu,aqu
[peaMeToB' aoKyr{el]Toll'
ApyrHX
o6r'exron;
nporoKoJrbl
npol'l3BoAcrBa
taHblx
npo-
ueccyaJlbHbIX
reticrBllfi
a.u,BoKarol{
cocramttorc{
no [pa-
BuJraM,
npeAycMorpeHHbllvr
cr.cr.
166,
190
ynK
(aaHsoe
POCCT4H'CKAg
"'
locrtlqnn
yfo^oBHbrz
nPouECC
Ne 9/2009
npennoxeHL{e no coBepueHcTBoBaHH}o
3aKoI{o.qaTeJIbcTBa
ocHoBbrBaercg Ha
aByx
r,reToaorort{qecKHX
noJIoxeHHfix:
npHMeHeHHe aHaJrorHH B
poccnllcKoM yroJ'roBHo-npouec-
cyilrbHor\,r flpaBe fi cpaBHHTeJ'ibHo-IIpaBoBoi
a]{aJt],l3
HopM
HoBoro YnK).
, B-rperllrx,
-ltpeaecraBr{B
3auurHl4fy.,npaBo
co6uparr
n.oKa3areJrbcrBa
nyreM
onpoca nHu,
yfonoBHo-[poueccy-
arrbHbrir
3aKol{
ocraBH,rr
BHe
perrar\{eHTauxH
pqA
oqeHb
Bax-
Hbrx BonpocoB,
nprMo 3aTparl{BarouHX
r'ra3BaHHoe npouec-
cya,,rblroe
.u,elicrene.
Hanpuuep,
xax 6rrrr
a!.BoKary,
ec,'t14
oH onpaur4Baer fnyxoHeMofo, HecoBep[reHHoJIerHero,
He
BnaAelouefo ff3blKoM, Ha
KOTopOlvI
orlpa[JHBaeTctl IL{UO,
H
AP,
Bse colrseulrri,
,rro
Ha nepequctreHHbre
!{
npyrHe
no-
lo6r
r
sre cjryq aH
pacn pocrpaHqercq
ae
ii crnlle npeln
u caH Lt i1
crcr. 18,59,69, 169,
l9l YIIK. Tarcnv o6pa3oM,
orpoc an-
BoKaroM coorBercrByrorul4x J'rHu, o6naAanunx
ltH$opua-
uueii,
nuenueil sHa.reHHe
iurq
3aurr4Tr,t
noao3peBaer\{oro,
o6st{HReruoro 14 npeacraBure,'rbcrBa IIorepneBrlero,
rpax-
IaHCKOfO
r{CTUa H fpaXnaHCKOrO
OTBerqHKa,
AOTTXeH
npo-
l13BO,IHTLCII C
yqaCTUe]U
nepeB0Aql'lKa, ne/Ialofa,
3aKOHHo-
ro npe!.craBt{Te.[ff HecoBepueHHonerHero.
B cBl3lt c 3TuM
rr
pe.T.n
af ae[,f
bl
\r n Ho Bat]r.{.sN{ r{
uen
ec006pa:uo
Aono,'I
H
HTb
Yfl K PoccNncxoir @elrepaurlr.
B-veraeprux,
ogo6oro BHlrr{aHI{q
B rraHe ocHoBa-
ui.rll
:t
l'rpcuel!?
no,]l4{€H1{ff npe-}rreToI 3ac,lp{(}{BaeT
3aKo-
li*:atr-r bri&-c
p€
f :: 3-we HTaLI:{fi
-
cof,lac H 0 KoTopo
i 3 a uI
t{T-
H,t K s;lpesg c*6x
parra
:oKa3&Tg:i
bcr
ga
tilre!{
4
nojl
}.*e
H
}lt
r;Ix*i"lde'r.*e.
3cxl.r*er:To*
H
llrf b{x
cge:exxii*
in.
I
,r.
3
cr. 86
\ tlKi-
Fla-:c
nsxararn,
a 3aKolrf
p€{rb
K-aer Ka( o ilpe,1lue-
1an. *r\!elo$ifir SHaqeHX€
il:tt
scyulegTe'leH!{t{
3auIl{TL'I,
TaK
r{ B
us:s}r
no
}TonoBHoHy
ner}i
B cB5r3!{ c
qeu
€ure 6orlrue
*c3pacrrler 3HaqeHHe rrpoueccyill
bu o fi cropoHbt
pean
H3a-
UHH
Ha3BaHHOTO npaBa.
Hx
po,rr
He
yl\.{anrercrl
Aaxe
rorna,
Kofaa
rpax!,aHI,rH,
npeInpHtrHe, opraHr.r3auHs ilo co6crseHuoMy BoJIet{3T,-
fl
BJr
e
H
n
ro
[epeaa]or 3a[II,tTH H Ky flpeaMer,
r"l o ry ut nii u
u erl
3HaqeHr,re
Mn
peanv3auxH
npaBa Ha 3aufiTy.
B noao6Hrrx
cnyqagx
BaxHo
co6,rrocru noKa He
ycraHoB,rleHHyl.o
3aKo-
HOM npo
UeAypy
I onyqe H r.rq coorBercTBy]oull4x
flpe.4l\{eToB
c reM,
,{ro6H
u 6ylyuleu ncKJil.oqHrb Bo3MoxHocrb
Bo3HHK-
HoBeH H.rr Bonpoca
o Hen eIZ crB
[TeJr bHocrH
aoKa3areJ]bcrB.
Be.u,r cor.nacHo n.
3
.r.
2 cr.75 YflK
x Henonycrur\{blM
oTHOCtTCg
TaKXe I't I4HbIe
AOKa3aTeJ'tbCTBa,
no.Ilv(leHHbIe
c
HapylxeH !reNr rpe6onaHl.ni
ltor'roBHo-
npoueccya-ry
bHoro 3a-
xoHa. B
pacc[rarpuBaeNro\i
c,ryqae oH Boo6ue
He onpeae-
,IIfleT
HI{ fl0pflIKa nOnyqeHHt aTIBOKaTOIU
flpe.4}r'teToB.
Hl'l
frpotleccya1bHofo,loKyueHTa, B KoTopoM
.{aHHoe
yro,rloB-
Ho- n
poueccv&r
bHoe
.te
ir
crs
rr
e
c-Teityer :aSn
rcnpoearl.
fi
pe;cre
ar r ercs
ue.:r
ecooSpa:
H ur rrl
Y
fl K
.lon
o,'t HHTI n
pen-
fi
,{caHNq}{r,r
cneJy}ouefo xapaKTepa: ilo.rryqeHXe
3auuT-
Hr{r(ox
npe.:Ijr{eToB i{
xoK}'L{eHToB
oTpaxaeTct
B [poToKone
{axre)
rx BbL{aqH,
xoropuX
oH
cocraB,rrfler
B npnc}TcrBl4lt
BbljlaBUII{X npejtr{erbr }.r
aoK}ueHrbl
,1Hu,
noHsrblx; nporo-
xorr
(axr)
BbIAar{H npe.u,I{eroB H
AoKyMeHToB
cocraBrqerctl
[pHMeHnrenbHo
K npaBr,rJraM,
ycraHoB,rleHHbIM
cr. 182 YflK
Poccu ilcxofi
tDeaepaunu.
3axos
yperynnpoBan
JTr,uub
orHH,
[pl4qeM o.{eHl
6,qa-
ronp xrITHbl
fi
AJ'I
fl
3auHTH
L{Ka, BapH aHT
e f O
yro,'l
oBHo
-
npo
-
[eccyturbHbrx
.uejlcrsr.rii.
oAHaro B ero
aeflTe,'lbHocrll
Mo-
ry"r
6rtrr u uHbre, 6o.nee croxnbre xu3HeHHbte
cl4TyatrxH.
Hanpuuep,
Koraa,rI{ua, o6lanapruue
npe.qMeraMH
u
AoKy-
MeHTaMr,r,
uMeloru}4MH 3HaqeHHe [o
yfonoBHoMy
Aeny,
[pe-
aocraBr.{Tb
nx aABoKary He xenaor. B raxr.rx cnftalx
y
aaBo-
Kara Hrveerct
nBa
BapHaHTa
leiicrnlrri.
Ilepnlrii
yperyn?rpoBaH
3aKoHoM l'r cocrol,tr
B roM,
ttro
aaBoKar
BnpaBe o6parnTbcq K
ao3HaBare,'rro
HJIH c,'teAoBa-
Terto c xoAaraiicrgorv{
npon3Becrll
o6trcx
}{ Bbtet\,tKy
npeA-
MeroB B
coorBercrBr.r!r co cr.cr. 182. 183
VflK.
nansrte
c,reacrseHHrre
aerlcreus
npouenoalicr no
peileHilrc
cyla,
K KoropoMy
HaaJre)KHT o6parnTbcfl
ao3HaBare,'Iro
HJttl
cJIe-
aoBaTeJ'rro
c
xonaTaHcTBor\{,
[oInepxaHHr'rM
npoKypopo]\l
(nn.
5, 7
cr.29,.r.
2
cr. 164,
.rq.
1,2cr.165
ynK).
floaaH-
Horr{y Bapi{aHry
Aeiicrauii
Ha
o6rrcx r.r BbreMKy
npel]\,reroB,
AoKyMeHTo
B n o xoAarafi
crBy anBoKara c,rr encrBeH
Hbl l\l
l'l
op
-
raHaMr{
norpe6yercx
MHoro
BperlteHr,I,
B
TeqeHne
Koropo-
ro
Ha3BaHHbre
AoKa3arerbcrBa
Motyr
6rrrr
nonpexneurt,
yHHqTOXe
H
br I.{,'rr4
cnpqTaH bt 3ar.rHTepecoBaHH
brM H,'l HUaM
}l
r.{JrH
rro ux
npocr6e.
Eo,ree
o[eparr4BeH nropoil BapHaHT
nei4crBnti
aaBo-
KaTa,
[oKa He
yperynHpoBaHHbn4
yronoBHo-npoueccya[b-
HbrM
3aKoHov. I,lveercq B BHAy o6pauteHne
aaBoKara
Il
cyil
nO MeCTy
npo I'{3BOACTBa
ilpeABap
}rTeJ'l bH O ro
CrTe,lICTBlltl
I'1r'l }{
no3HaHr,rs
c xoAaraiicrBoM npor.r3Becrrl oobrcK
H BbleMKy
npeAr\{eroB,
AoKyr{eHToB
y
nr4u,
Koropbre Hl\{u
pac[orafa-
nr.
B
c,ryvae
ynoBnerBopeHHs
xoAaraiicraa
a!,BoKara
cy-
,lbq
npr{Hr4Maer rrocraHoBJ'reHHe o npou3Bonctse
o6ttcxa
}a
Ha.rlOXeH
l.{ H apeCTa
H a IIpenM
eTr'I,
AOK}t!'leHTbl,
npo
BeAeH
Ue
Koropbrx
Bo3namer Ha
cyne6Horo
np!{craBa.
flpe,uaraelrbre
no,'rHoMoriHg c.rreayer
npeaocraBHTb,
c
o:xoli cropoHbr,
al,BoKary, rpeaycMorpeB
HX
B cr. 53
ynK,
l{Met B
B}r!,y,
qro
c xoaararicrBaivtn oH Moxer
o6pauarlcn
KAK K
Cre:r,OBare,rrlo H
rrpoKypopy,
raK H
n cyl
(v.
2 cr,
119
ynK).
Pe.rb r.rner
o KoHKperu3auru
Lr
pacuHpeHlILI [o,'IHo-
HoqHit
a,4BoKara no or,qeJrbHbrM BonpocaM,
C
lpyrotl
cro-
poHbl,
cr,
165
YllK
aononHLtrb
Hopr\{oi;i,
npe,l,ocraBJlglo-
ueir
cyAre rrpaBo
paccMarpHBarb
xoaaraticrsa
3auHTHHKa
o lrpor,r3BoncrBe
rrpoqeccyan uulrx
neiicrsnli,
I,t N,te Fo
ulflx
ue-
;tu.o obecneqeHue
coxpaHeHHq I,r BbIeMKH
AoKa3aTe,lbcrB,
r,{ M ero
lut.r x
3
H aq
e
HHe
Ir o
yIoJ{
o
B H o rvl
y
.qeJly.
B-n.arux,
paccMorpeHr{e
Bonpoca
o
lpaBe
aABoKara
o6paruarrcr
B cyA
c xo.rtaraitcrBarlru o
pa3peueHun
[po-
t{3BoacrBa
npoueccyanbHbrx
nefrcrBHfi
n
npoueaype
HX
co-
BeprrleHHrr
3arparxBaer rnrub
qacrHsrfi
acnexr
npo6leuu
aa,soxarcxofr aerrreJrbHocrlr
u cyne6Horo
KoHTpontt
Ha
ao-
cyee6uov
npoH3BoAcrBe.
3Aecr
HMeiorcrr ri
Apyrl{e
cyuecr-
BeH Hbre HarrpaBJ'reHHr,
rpe6ynuHe
HopMarnBHo-
npaBoBo-
fo
yperynHpoBaHr.{.r.
B
Hacroqulee BpeMs, KaK K3BecrHo,
yronoBHo-ilpouec-
cyantH
rr
ii :axou cyle6Hlui xoHrpoJ't
b
orpaH
Hq HBaer
r
Hlrl b
no.q HOI\.{O![
I{fl
N{ l.{ cyAa, Kacarcluulv{ l{Ct
AetlTeJI
bHOCTIi
npo-
Kypopa, c,'reAoBarerq,
ao3HaBarenfl
Ha
aocytre6uou
npo-
H3BoncrBe
no
yronoBHbrM
,rre,'raM
(u,
2
cr.29
yflK).
9ro
xe
KacaeTcrr
Apyrnx
)
{acrHHKoB
yronoBHofo
cyAollpoI43BOAC-
TBa, To
cya npaBoMoqeH B xone
aocyAe6uoro
fipou3Boac-
rBa
paccMarpxBarb
xa,ro6u
Ha
neiicrBng
(6eeaeitcrsile)
H
perxeHus
npoKypopa, cJ're.[oBareJlrr
H
ao3HaBare:rs
('].
3
cr. 29
VflK). 9roro flBHo HetrocraroqHo
n,rq
o6ecne.{eHuq
npan,
cno6o.u, H 3aKoHHbtx HHTepecoB J'IHqHocrH,
Koropatl
xael
uro6rt cy,u,e6Har 3a[ir4Ta
crMa rlpocrblM
H I]oHsrHbll\{
cpencrBoM
orcrorrb
csofi
saxoHHltii
l.rurepeco.
Ha nyrN K
,4ocrr,r)KeHHro AaHHoi4 ueJ'rH,
KaK
N.IHe
npeA-
CTaBi'Ifl eTCfl
,
IIpeACTO
I'lT
yCO
BeplUe HCTBOBaTb
KOH
UenTyaJI
b-
Hbre ocHoBbr
cyae6Horo KoHTponrr
ua
AocyAe6xoM
npo-
I,r3BoacrBe.
B Hacroqu{ee BpeMfl ero
ocHoBy
cocraB,'tfier
pa3peul{reJrbHo-orKa3Hrtfr
npuHuun rrpl,rutlrul
peue-
rullii
cyareii,
c$opruy,rllponasultfr lr 3aKpen,tteHHttii
s
'{.
4
ffi€w
vfo^oBHbll4
nPOTECC
POCChhcKAg
locrlr4hfl
N;9/2009
cr.
165
ynK.
B
ueii
cxa:aHo,
tlroi
paccMorpe
B
xoaaral'Jc-
TBO,
Cyabs
BbIHOCUT
nocTaHoB'rleFlHe
o
pa3peueHuil
npo-
r.r3BoacrBa
crencrgeHHoro
tr.eiicrsutl
I't'ltlt
o6
orKa3e
B
TaKo-
IloNt.
flpnne,leuHaa
pernaN'lellrauHfl
rpeIu
ilT
oaHocropoH
-
Hocrblo
KaK
B n,'IaHe
cy6'sextoe,
HaaereHHblx
npaeou
o6pa-
Ularbcfl
B
Cya
c
xoaaraitcrsoM,
TaK
l{
B
n-[aHe
npl{H}'lMaeMblx
peiueHuit:
o6pauarlcl
B cyA
c
xoaaralicrsoNi
o
pa3peue-
r r I.il,l
cJ'l
e,[.crBe
H
H
blx'[e
it
crsH
il
i\{
ofyf
Ton
LKo
cI
en
crBe
H H
ble
opfar-rbl;
cy.[,
fipl4Hll]\'faer
o,il'Ho
143
AByx
peueHul'{
-
pa3pe-
IIll4Tb
IlpOl'I3BOACTBO
!{r'I14
OTKa3aTb
B
FIeN't'
Becuua
y3Kas &rlbrepHarxBa'
B
Bl'lr'y
qefo
cneAyer
ao-
no,'IHHTb
3aKoH
ptaoll{
}{oBblx
noloxeHnit'
B
qacrHocrl'l'
nperocraBt'lrb
cyay
tlpaBo:
paccNlarp14ears
xoaaraiicrsa
He
'to,rbKo
cneaoBarerg
u
AO3HaBare"Ig'
HO
ll lto6oro
HHOfO
yqaCTHHKa
Cy/l'OilpOI{3BOACTBa,
B ToM
qlrCIe
3alUHTH
HKa-a'{-
BOKa'la
11
ilpeacTaBl',rTe'Iq
-
a'[,BoKaTa;
np
H H
I4 M
aTb
pe
il
e H
utl'
pa3peuanuHe
npo!13BoacrBo
npoueccya"IbHblx
neiicrettir'
a l{tv,Ie}{HO,
C,leACTBeHHblx
t',t
14Hblx
geiicrnuii'
o
npoBe'ileHHI4
Koropbtx
xoaaraucrBylor
norepneuur
nii,
non'o3pe
Baell
bl
I"l'
o6sr,rF{qeN'ltll.{,
3aI{HTHHK,
[peAcraBuTe'lr
(Hanpuuep'
Bbl-
er\{Ka
ilpejlN{eroB,
noKyMeHroB.
HatloxeHHe
apecTa
Ha
Kop-
pecnoH!.eHrlHlo,
c,'IeacTBeUHt'ttl
3KCneptlNleHr)
I
pa:pe
uarl
lyoy
np""utn,'arb
KaK.pa3peuarcurle'
raK
ll
3anpeulaniul{e
De[Jent4fl
no
xoAarailtcrBy
yqacrHilKoB
npollecca'
B To]\1
e nc,'r
e aABoKara
(
Hanptl
uep,
3attpeuarcul4e
Hanafarb
apecr
na,[e
H exH
ble
Blcqzul
bl
noAo3pe
BaeN{
oro
lL'I
14
o6n
l't
Hfl
el\'{o
ro'
rteo6xoAttllsle
a,'Itl
coaepxaHHg
ero
cel{bl'l'
orcrpaHRrr
o6-
Br.rnrel\.{ofo
or
Aottx}{ocru)'
I'Irar,
apcerlail
ci'4e6ttutx
pe-
uresHfi
,
nptlHi{MaeMblx
Ha
aocyae6Hol't
npoH3BoacrBe'
!.OnXe
H
BICI
]Oq
aTb
p
a3pe
Ui
al'OIItHe'
OTKa3blBalO
lillle'
tI
paBO
-
o6q:rtsaiouile
l'{
3anpeuan[II4e
aKTbl'
B
sarcnrcqeHlre
ocraercn
!{3J'loxuTb
Hat't6olee
cyuecr-
BeHHble
BblBoAbl
I{
ilpex,noxeHul:
1)
B 3aKOHe
onpeAenurb
$oprrly,
coAepxaHue
tl
crpyKrypy
npoueccyanbHblx
aKroB'
ocTaM
fl
e N{
blx a'['BoKaTo}v{
(xoAaratl crs,
Xa,'ro6,
n
poTo Kono
B
)
;
2)
nepeqilc,.Il,ITb
B
3aKoHe
aKTbI'
KoTopble
aABoKaT
cocTaB-
;;.;;
nHcbMeHHori
6oprue;
3)
nuclueuHble
xoaarar"'rcrBa
u
xano6rt
aABoKara
AoJIXllbI
cocrotlrb
!I3
Tpex
'lacteil
-
BBoaHoil,onucareJ'lbHoiiunpocure'llnoti;4)'vxa:arln:a-
KO
He,
tlro
nporoKox
bl
14
HbIX
npo uecc)Ia-q
bH
blx ,[e
r"{crBrl
I"l'
n
pO
il3Ben
e
il H bl
X
a,il
BO
KaTO
N{ B
XO!
e
a"{BO
KaTC
KOf
O
pSCC;leJo-
BaHl{tl,
cocTaerl.qloTcfl
no
aHailor}tt{
c tlpoToxo'1a'\{l{
glc]c-
TBeHHbtx
AeiicrBfi'YI
(ltuea
B
Bl{']}i"
qro
aJBOKgrtKoe
pa{-
cxejloBaH},{e-3ToB}|.1.Iocy]e6Hot0'{Ir}e.1Bap,{Te]b}f0|{}
npou3Bo,4crBa;
5) lono.:ixrlrl
Y[iK
H*p-rto'ri
rJ rs]4'
"rro
3"1-
BoKar
BnpaBe
o6paruarrcs
B c-v'L
c
xs:arailcrsalii!
e
Fa3!€-
ue
il
l{}{
eMy
xn
H
C'IeIo
Eartjl
}0.-L03HaBATe"1
to
Ilpclr
380']lirb
cooTBeTCTByIoilltf
e
c,1 e:
crBe
lI Fi
o
-
npouecc]'a'l
ru
lle :e
fic
-
TBi{q
il
TaKlt}',i
n}Ter{
pacul{p}lTb
npe:lleT
tl
npef,e']bl
c}'-
.le6goro
KoHTpO-rfl
Ha roc-vle6H0i\{
npo}'l3BO'lCTBe
no
-!ro-
iou"o'"
"..rur,;
6)
q.
4
cr'
165
YflK;iono'rHl{rb
Hoplloll
o
Tolt,
qro
B
pe3y.[brare
pacc]uorpeHllt
xo'4araiicrBa
c-vlbff
flpilHr{N{aeT
TaKXe
IIOCTaHOBTeHl{s
o
3anpeueHrlll
npolt3-
BO,itcrBa
onpeAereHHblx
npoueccyarbHblx
AeiicrBHii'
yKa-
3AHHbIX
B 3AKOHC.
'l
EaxaHos
N{.14.
3axouHocrr
rr o6ocuoraHHocrb
o:!oi"^'1',v.1:::.::-.,::::,'^::i'trff.',{:H:ifft:ti,"^1i:JlX'.Klli;.i"t"tti*'
ff#l:i#;1",T?il:'iil::ff:'1??ifi?:ll.!!ir
1' l.#1'1'iir.",":tf::;i:in3;;ru::#:lmo'co'repxaHrre
u
rfopva
[ucc.
...
aoKr.
]op]lA.
HayK'.XapbKoB'
t'"
llll)l:lt:T:'
I
t '^'
r
"
'
' *'-
ou"oni
npou.r...
Xapsxon,
1979.
il-1s;A"d;"tluor'i
rcj.rvl.
ivurHocru
cvae6Hutx
peueHtrii
t-t?:tl,tl-"y^[:i.
.. -^ ^, roRo c ?R-']0:
yro,roB
X;
'iil;',i^i#lt",li*'r[i'r1}i"'#ffiffi;.:
i
"*";;;;.
n.*.
KapHeenori
".qp.
Ml,
re80.
c.
28-30;
vro,roauurri
npouecc
/
noa
pen
:
Crr..
HannlllteP:
coBercKHll
Yro
K.@.
I-Yuerrxo.
M..
2000.
C
24'
5
ffi;l;-"i;X,#;3131;!"il'noou.."r-bH,.rx
peueH,{i':":1":::'i::::.T""-'-','.'":^".t#::;i:::;,f
iiT?ffi:3.
X':?
't*
illffiffii'l,
#lil#?:"i:
nil'";'^'i;;11i*;;Ti'*;::-:**3'l*'i:T";.Tl'P^,';"o""
N{
'
reTe
c
,i#JJ,llrl';J;";..';;;r,,
/
noa
pea.
3.@.
Konp'ru,
H.'.
KveHeuoua.
BopoHex,
2003
c'
14'
---^^^ - lr. VF^i^Du^-nnnlI
V:il::::l,;
li:il::
i::ilj]
llii
l.i
i"{, ryd*il:
,;
'i *;;;;;;;
6*i+'
v'o"o'Ho-npoueccvarbHoe
npaBo
PoccHircroir
@e'ne'
Yro.ronuurii
npouecc
Po-ccurt
/
noa
p,tf
1;?"TofL'ttn'
pauntr
/ non
pt'A.
fl.A.
,lynuHcxof
M''
lyv
I L
'+u
tiXfiL!"tr'fir:if.i::X:7;:;j:;":;;,i.li-o"o,u
KoreKc
poc'rircxo,i
@eaepauun.
Ku'
r'
BopoHex'
2002'
c'
5'
3
Tarr
xe.
C.
7
HATPAXEEH14E
,\NEKCAHTP
OEIIOPOB
Yxarorl
flpe:urletira
Pocclnicxoit
(Fe':epaunrt
'1"
Me'useaeBa
Harpax'{e}l
op'q'eHor{
no'lera
3a
3acnyril
B
yKpenneHill'l
3aKoHl{ocrrl
r{ i\{
HOTOJ1
e'rH
iolo
n,loaoTllop
Hyro -lefiTel}'HocTb
/,lrreK.aHlp
Bsqec,raBoBtl.l
Qe:opoa
Fls.ul'ilcf,
2?
Uapra
1956
ro'q'a
a JleuttUrpaae'
.lpyaonyro
aenr.no"o.ro'n.u-
"
iq::'*rr,"uropr**.,
HHr'1
:e]g9ir
*opo,
np,
,IleHllurpaacxoM
focyaapcrBeHHoM
yHtlBep*Irere'
c
lg74
no
lg:lcxyxH.q
e BoeHHc-lopcxox
6ire.
c
l97?
no
2000
npoxo.[r{n
ca1x6y
"o
porn"u"oi*,llorlxHocrsx
e oprarrax
Kf
5
CCCP
u
QCE
Pocclllt.
n^ar^rqEurcf,q nnerr.ireHTa
PoccHiicxoli
(De.u,epautrl1
c
2000
rola
-
3aNtecrl're.i'b.
a c
2{.hl
I
-
negear*
3*rtsc:"!t{e1t
noIHOMOqHoro
npe'[cTaBuTe',rn
flpe:llaeura
Pocctliicxori
(De',
n
Cesepo-3anaaHoru
Se,uepa'rbHov
oKF!)'re'
B
urc,re
2003
roaa
Ha3HalreH
crarc-€f
Kpu.!?p*$
-
$rrd..rc;r{Te'ew
npe.q"ce.xarert
loc-vlapcruenHoro
KoMHrera
Poccniicxoi-"i
Qeaepa-
urrr
no
KoHrpo.,rrc
:a
o6opororr
'iapKcrr'l.,ecr*3
e*Ssr*
-ir nr&xs''polrirr.
**aaro,
i
nripto
2004
ro'u'a
-
3aMecr'{Tenb
axpeKropa'
a
c
.lexa6pr
2005
rola
-
crarc-ceKperapb
-
3a\'s{:x"*ir".*rr.**r*
se:*pa:luoir
c,'ryx6sr
poccnircroi
@eaepauuu
no
KoHrpor'ln:a
o6o-
t'"J
fff;:j|Xl'n.ouo,r,
3aI{ecr're.rb
b{:*xx*.*a
srrw.'?4}$
Faccs.;1cxop
se:eparlun'
A-ncKcilH,lp
Bs.rec,tanosti.i
{Deropoe
-
x3}i.1}..:3:W$u.Fqc{KJ{4
**i*
*;G;;;;'-3"'y*t""olti
topucr
Poccur'icxoi;i
{DeAepaurttt'
_flu.nse.Lcg
aBTopoM
6o-lee
250
HavlrHbry
pefc: *o
efi"*R!*
,'?s6ert'-{tis
npana-
-ororo"Horo
npouecca
u
onepar'BHo-po3blcKHofr
'1e-
,r.reJ,rbrjocr'r.
Jraypear
"p;;;;
np.unr.rorrw
Fweex*ex-r:t&
@cry*!-*e*
p
s6:r&c'r-*
ei6paroaaxnx
:a
2003
roa'
'fls'qsercs
qJIeHoM pea-
Ko.n,IIeftll-I
p'I!.a np}irlHqecKliX
x).pH,&.IoB.
:1<.'.r!9F.'
i.it.ii.]1:;r4'98"t€€1il::ix'i:l]f.14
'*f.$}cY*F
Peccuu.
j