lntroduction
Discussion
2 Put the learners in groups
of
three
or
four
and
ask them
to
share their
ideas.
Remind them to use'must' and'mustn't'.
3 Tell
them
to prepare Ten Rules for Learning English
and
to
write them down on a sheet of
paper.
4 When
all the
groups have finished making
their
rules,
collect
their ideas and write them up on the board.
The most
obvious difference between the two activities is
in
the
way they are organized. In Activity 1 the teacher is talking, first to
the whole
class,
then
to
individual learners. In Activity 2
the
learners
are talking to each other
in
small
groups.
This
type of
learner-learner
interaction in
pairs
or
groups provides
far more
practice in
using the language than the more traditional
teacher-learner interaction. In a class of twenty learners, a
twenty-
minute
activity where
the
teacher asks the learners
questions
will
give
the learners a total of only about ten
minutes'
speaking time,
i.e. half
a
minute
each.
And
the teacher
(who
doesn't
need
the
practice!) gets
ten whole
minutes'
speaking time. In contrast, a
twenty-minute activity where learners are working in
groups,
asking and
answering
each other's questions, will give them many
more opportunities
for practice.
Both activities
provide
a
lot
of repetition of the structure'must
(+
verb)',
and
both do so in a fairly controlled way.
In Activity 1,
the control is provided by the teacher who tells the
learners
what to
do.
In Activity 2, control is
provided
by the example sentences on
the board. However,
Activity I provides
repetition
with no
context.
The sentences are random and unrelated. Such repetition is
virtually meaningless: the
learners are
simply
repeating the
structure.
They have no idea why they are saying the sentences, and
in fact it would be
possible
to do the activity
without
understanding a word!
In Activity 2,
there
is
a context-making
rules for learning English-and all the communication
is
related
to
this context.
This makes the
activity
much more meaningful for the
learners.
In Activity 1, the learners have no sense of
purpose
in
producing
their sentences;
they
are
merely doing what the teacher tells them,
and
the
only
purpose
of
their repetition is to
practise
the structure.
In
Activity 2,
however, the
learners have
a
goal-making the
rules-and the language
is
used for the
purpose
of achieving this
goal. This mirrors real-life situations much more closely, as well as
making the activity
more interesting
and
motivating for
the
learners.