Губин М.Ф. Экономическая эффективность гидроаккумулирования в крупных энергосистемах

ctt

a

/

U

o

E

..r

F

UX

-

v

(

<-.

-

P

arl

A

-<E

==i

:

Y,='rl

= r'l

J

()

r-.;Y

al

.r

-

U

Y

,:

-

tC -a

IIJ

= I

6;il

j

I

ofx

he

'

YY.

I

=

{

(JY;

a.

gJ

H

' ' t H

r=

*Lrl<I

2

->r

\J]<\/ct

u

*

Cco

\/

*

(?)

Y

I'r I

I,J-.

r

|-*a

I'rl

rL

(o

c

o.

H.

Y

F-la

r*

U

p\

V

\---.---

=

1

o

a

v-

=r*

='/

Cts

cts

.JH

i)H

HX

--

/r'l

tf{

=t-

Y.

F-

*

t--

c\1

7,

\

-r

IH

'J

f-

I

'a,

=l-H

*H

{F'l

lllH

t-

/.

1-H

rn

JC

TJ

t"

npoQeccop

A.

H. Muxafraoa'

f,rasttu,l

peAaxrop

cePHf,

3BcJryxenrruf,

Aenrenb

nayxlt R Texttnxtt,

npo$eccop

E.

hl.

Tapeeo

BbINYCKH CEPIIII.

ONYEJIIIKOBAIIHbIE

PAI{EE:

Tor.

t.

l'xaporreprerxxr.

BoqoncnpoxBqtcr.tlc

,u.ua$parxu

Ht

n.tacrxtt-

Roro

6erolrr.

M.. 1973

Tot. 2.

frApolneprerrxr,

l'unporxxynytxpyKrulne

ereKlPocratlrtltH

(Oc'

HOBHbre

EOnpOCbr npoexTllpolaHHr,

HccJleaoBallHfl I

crpoHT€Jlbcl'

ua).

M.. 1976

Tor.

3. fxaporrreprerxxa.

I'xApaa.rtuxr

pcry.'txpylot{Rx

3-srBopoD

!blc(>

xouanopxHr

soAoc6pocor rxApocoopyncexxl.

M.. 1970

YAI(

62

1.3

t

t .21282L,22L,4

BBEITETIHE

Bropan

nononnlra X

X

DeKa

xapaxreptt3ysrcfl

urrreHcttnrtbrM

pao-

BtmHeM

gtrapr\onoTpcfnelnrn

Do

DceM

N{rrpe.

Buc.cre

c TeMr

B66Juo-

uaercft

PocT

croHMocrH

opI'Blnltlectrono ronnllBa,

B

cDgSll

c

qeM

gKOtlOrrtffia

euepFerllxll

npcrerrllcvl0

c)'ruccTDelll!)le

l'SD,ieH0IIIIR.

!,e,]rlrinrt

opnailnlrc€Koro ronnrna

nprlDontir K

tle€6xo[tt].{ocru

oTl-rc-

I.'

KAlrirR Hot:rtx,

6onee

Slioltc!.fil'Iln:IX

llcTo'Itllll{oB

aneKTpo?$eprIIR,

E

I

rov

rnrcJle

nrrr(onoll.

Crauonltrcs

oKotroMt:,Iecxu

6onco BHro,otn,tM

cTr)olrTeIbcTno

Gonr,ueno

qlrclla

f3C,

B

ToM

rIHclte

no

np,og1;ttt

,H

B TeX MOCTAX, KoTop!..!e clUe

lleCKonLrKO

nST

tIAgAA

XagAIgCb

9KOIIOhltItI

e'CK

lt

tleOnpnBg

flil

llbl!'lH.

'

Eone-e

ocrpo

cronr

Donl"oc

npoeKTrrpooatulg

g

crponrerr,crna

'IrHKOBrrtx

CTAllqlrfi.

Ilprir.relretrilo

rlr.g

aTtrx

uen€fi

TennoDbrtr

Er

B

rIocrHoerB,

ro3ory[-6il]ilrbtx

cratrunfl, BF-rllrMo,

[t€

cronb

affiet'run'-

t!o,

xan

npencTfllvltulocF,

panee,

B cuq-3lr c

STnM

Bce

oe.rHuoe

Eu|$,rfirilte

yacJrneTcg nFloffirrtFoBalnrlo

lr crpotlTe."rbcTl]y

rA3C.

O6trrrrtos

uoJrbtM

pnrtoM

TonlJio ]{h{

nprrc)qrrfix npei:}'{yr.u€\crE, fAOC

no3Donflror

llott6onee

SxoIroM:FIuo

o6':c[c'rtrrb

norPLITlro

6r,lcrpo-

pocryttllr

tnlKoD

rpa$:rxon

cyl'o,urofl

nnt'l)y3xB.

lloo{i>:on}rMcH]Tb

.ctpottrenbcTtlfl

6onr'ruofo

tlltcna

rAOC

rlpllnonlrT

E

crcI}oolr!:Io

p&-

Hgo

x63nDuIttxc$ He3Kollol,!lt!ilr1,!x

n.'Iorunnoxl ucno,'lb3oDnlttt)c

hfo,rll,tx

ttonopoB

tr

cTpcrtrTerlr-€Tr}y rA3c

cp$Llnrrr'(.JlI'tro

ue6oflL'utof,

GtrIlllIIl-

nofl

r,{crunoC't.n.

B

ttnCTOtrine},{

o6:oFro,

fltutqlouleMCn

Ifrcr16llpiclnleM

nepBr)I'o

no

aatuor,{y

rJorrf,ocy

[15.|r

crf>p611

11

nponrtanF:ilrpotrnu

N{arcpgaJI,

otty6rtrxt.rrriurr!.rf,

l}

t{lri)r:T[.rllnlroi

JtHTei)nrype

ltotttritof

r-

o

r)'f

('pofl

lrolrorrrrilr,l

I 1l'7.1 no

t f )'/

B

r'.

rit(,.':lo(r l:r

(,ut)t;c.

C6sop

cocTtll\,|eil

tJ

o(:tro:)li

irl Ir0 I

(,rrT

i

l:tn!rn!.t

'i-txt---ttprf

p-11

1:"lr-r[r\t,1unH'

(cepun

tf

rurpxr-ru

!prcr

ul-c') u

1'r'lrogrrrlrtutx)ro

x<) pIrlflo

tlllttlll'tl

'3iexrprcTe.\liltr(a

lt

gt;':"t-c

i

r:xot.

3

o

tiil!illTll,

1979

1-2

CoBPEMEHHOE

3t{At{El{HE

rASc

B SHEPT0CHGTEME

.. .:,

I

,-poflr

rASC

n

alrenl.Oql.ic.Tel'ts-

PaccuorPegge

Telulotuuft

pasottTllfl

ellepr\onoTpc6netttts

H

{iop-

MlrPoBciltnnrpafituoaHanpysKuallepnocHqreMnoKasb|Dngr'qTo

BoDceIp&SDIITbtx}tpo3BllDslotuttxcgcTpallaxoTMc*IaeT€qtlHTeIF

CFBHbrg

TeMn

pgcra

MaKcuMyMa

HanpysKlt

'l

eue

fuxse

6blcrpblA

orlrocsrorrl,trbrll

pocr

6aerrcuofi

tlanpysKH,

oco6eltHo

B

xoflontloe

BpeMs

t

olla.

flpu

aroM

SHAqelrue

IAec

llc

TonbKO

Co?(paH'Ierct{'

UO

EO

BCeX

Cny'IAqX

yBenH'lHBasTCg

B

CERAII

C

pocTol'{

ycTaHoE-

nernrof,

;,46rquoc,rH

TeC

E

oco6ellHo

AgC

tl--lt

,

6r7

r1O-12'251

'

Btrecre

c

TeM

OTl,tc{aeTcg

nepec(oA

o/l.

cxeM

|ASC

c

cyrolllblM

u.trKrroMpenyflHpoBatl]tflKgxeMaMcHeAeJrb[IblMllEKnoMaKKyl!{ynu-

poBaHRg,rlTogBn'IeTcgcJreqcTBtIeMHeTonbl(o}|3}'{eHgloue|lcfl

fop*,u

rpa{nra

cyro.I'oll

HAnpy3KH,

Ho

u

lleo6xotrE}'tocrH

3o11o11-

ueBBgEpoBalla}lanpysKgcHcTeF{l)IgKoltuepa6olell}teueJlH.

Coopyxeple

|AOC

c

HetreJIbHblM

UtIKnoN{

peranllPogollrrrt

T

Pe6Y-

g,T

Co3qAHRf,

sllaqBTolrbItO

6OneO

el'txtD(

BoUoXpallEntlutr

npll

sTOM

ffx

tICnOnbgOBAlIHe

nOnlKgO

6Utrf,

yBllSAllO

CO

BCel"tlI

CN'teri(ltL'll'tll

DO-

aononbSoBaTerrgtr{[.

flonoxcetttre

tlecKonl]Ko

o6nerrtoeTcfl

TeM'

tlTo

B

neTgrte

neptlonbl

cyTorrtlbte

H

lteqcvlbgble

fone6at{Hq

ypoaltell

B

6accefinax

c)nuecrBeHno

MeuHue'

flpolrcxongruoe

ll3]'legelilIe

B

pe-

tt(HMAX

paooTbr

rA3C

B

KpynHblx

SlteprocHcl"eMax

npnBotrltT

K lte-

o6xOItnMOCTB

HoEolt

oUeHKlI

eKoHoh{tttlecliofi

e"!{rextxn}lccTH

rASC'

Huxe

B

XAqecTBe

npilMepa

Ens

cpaBItlITeJlbtro

KpynHOfl

aHepl'o-

cHcteMbr

troKasatra

ornocnTeJlbtras

e,{x}rerrrlBllocrb

fA3C

npH

pnF

nlltlublx

peE(ttMax

trx

$cnoJlbSoBallllf,'

B

rabn.l

np'bene*',

cllottelllls

cyh{Map6611

\{ouHocrefi

xPY[-

Hotl

gHepfOCHCTeNttJ

C

pASAoJIelMeM

ll;

tta

nru(OB)'Io

H

6ogltcltyKt

l,tq,[HOCTI'

B

11e/Tlltle

B

3HN{}IHe

ncpggllbt

stlepfonorpe6nellttq'

f,lttn

aTtO(

nepHOqoD

no6o3allbl

BgIIII'IHtlA

Dc)3MOlKltgfi

K

Hcngnb3oDnltll6)

l.{otupocT6

fASCr

norpe$llos

ot"l5ocrl

6acce{lttog

IAOC

u

ce6o-

cToul"locTb

nIIKoDOR

an

eKTpOSttepnHH'

flprroenetlllble

D

ro6n'

t

.

trollttr'le

ncu)'tt

e-It:t^lpll

t-Hrr ila

soptra

1

lilbeltttttr/(rBr'q)

tt

npH

rL/ULt

tl

l"{OlIllOCTf,.

llA

OCfrOrJo|lil]r

Irnillll,tX

rnCur'1

tl{l

lrrrc'1

nptlDcneH

fpnt}rrX'

l.r("3-

DOnSKllllH[

yCrailol]ltTt'

3nDltcllhloc"rt'

\rcf(try

MolllIlOcTHo'

I'ngC

tl

noTpc6tn,tM

06r,er,.toxr

(rnccalllln

n

rlt5'ltxtttltt llSN{ellolttlf

rpa}tttxa

c}'-

To,protl

11a1.pyo6n.

[Jrytwttttta

tlao6ronilr{o[1

pc't'yflltp)rcttle{1

rtotllltocTv

3-

a

rl,

o

r{

FI

G

E

tr

I

o

F

-- ln l\l A a

-'-

rr\

l-

\J

t{

\1,

-

1[

l-.iO

1..d

F{

O

f-(0f-

r{

I

o

oo

o

A

(o

o(o

o)

o

v-

O

t@O-

<f

p

(o

u1

O

V11)f-

rf@ H

F.

O

toOV

-tF{

O

F{

oo)

v3.o'

c?',.{8

F{

CO

v

|o

oto

v

ov

ol

otoO

|o oNqd

tO

cr)c,l(o

o

oo

r) 'A

lI)

oto

{

6

q

c,t ,Of

q

olp

1(O

V

6'1

F.Of-

(oco

F{

I

V Nv{S

F{

I

o

9o

I o 'i

o

Ob

tOtl)

o)

u'

Fl

HOO

NN

t\

(o

v

ood

o,i

F.r

o

Nr{:nNEt

8q

r-F-v

gF{

d

o

F{

o

cf,

to

Ot/C

t-'

(O

-t

o) O@O.

o

C9F-r.

NFIrt

crollh{ocr}l

SlterF

IIC I I()J

I triju

lr.l

I

r

)t

gA

:E

'Q

F

0

E

a

U

o

l-r

ap

4

h6i

ux

ao

k

I

5

g

H

E

6

a

g

6be

fi

9,6i8

*n6 5

6L*bn

r6)'

lcr:r

h

o

E

T

o

b

lc

o

?

o.

o

rd ii

oF

^iJ

,..

fd

6v

O-

Ao

dr-

Erl

!l

5

F

qt

3

o

tr

5

i

o

D-

o)

r{

i

o

(o

o)

F{

PHc.l.

Coo llloulotltto

MCx-

Ily

l'loulllocrl'lo

rASC

6

Hoo6)cortlll'(l'lIl

o6t'o

t'tot"t

'

BOpXll{}r\J

Eaccoiltta

D

3{rB}t-

CttMOCTtl

()T

lt3l'teU{'!tlHIl

Fpo$rrxa

llarPy3Ktr

altept\o-

CHC'[el"t[,]

3A

nopllOq

C

1960

lro

19BO

r,:

t

]l6lll>lllrt

f]

XOn

HTonO&tlOll(O-

Hlls'

l'ttlpI(a

$Pf/rBti

2

-

p€nyntlpyrcunR

€MKoCTh

o6 ectte'ttI

D

aroulofl

Po6otY

fAOC

non$ofl

l'{oultlocrtror

qi

3

-

EOAoZPaltlUIBrUe

llcr-

neJI

bttoro

perynttpoB{ttlllni

4

-

EOAOXpfliriltrrlilrts

cyTotrlloro

poryflrpoD{rtcln;

5

-

HO}'{HIIOJIE'

HAfi

lroqtrocTr,i

B

npltlreP

p(lcrlgTai

7

-

IIIICJIO

tlficoB

HcgoJlI'-

soBagtlfl

MolIlHocTHr

c/roqi

B

-

rpt$lu(tr

cyTo'Itloil

HanpysKtt

s\epr\ocKcrel'br

sa

1960,

1970

u

19BO

nn.

nOKasatta

B

Bnne

er.'(l(ocTIt,

Tp€6ye1{Ofi

11nfl

OCreCne'regllg

paf)OTtrt

rAScnonHoil}'totLlllocTblo,HBblpax(eltaBqocax.oultoopeNteutloc

ygenurleggeM

$eo$xoqll:rtoil

eN{KocrE

6acceflttoB

IAOC

nbepactaer

O6uree

qtICnO

qAcoB

HcnonbsgBaltl$l

lD(

ttlo1qltocTtt'

flpnueUelUlble

tratilrbte

6nrntr

nonr{ellbl

Ha

octloBallufl

aHaI:I3A

Stta(It{-l'eJrbIIOno

qHo-

B8

peSnIFrtn,tx

npoel(ToD

rASC

c

Innopal'lllt

!t3ri{eli'qloull}'1llcf,

B

EHano3olte

or

zbo

tro

600

l'lr

g!)Jltcoulill'{1rcfl

Otlrllh{alrb]IblNtH

rultl

noAo6lihtx

cralfltlll

B ltBcrolluee

BpeNltl'

flo

tranHhtrvt

pitc.1

npoDeneB

aKotlolv{lr'{ecKlttt

AlIe-nH3r

noKa3bt-

Batomufi

gro:loltllltecKHe

IlpeU[{}utecTBB

fA3C

B

Karlc€TBe

IICTCTI-

EEXA

ntrxoBoa

Sllnprllll.

cnenyer

oThlgTllTtl

q'ro

nplt

eTaM

atlanE3e

Ue

!,r6f.Jlu

6Urr'

yrlTel(t.l

TaXlIo

nl)eIINtytUeCTDa

fAgQr

Ka!(

Br'lCOKAf,

Ea11el6BocTI,

pA6oTt'I

lI

nocTogllllafl

1.g.l'ogllocTb

fASC

npUHgTb

lta.

rpySl(y

gB3procllcTe!'lt't'

.

Ha

puc.2 npHBeneHlrl

SABHCll:\{OCTtt

ce6ecTolrMocr[

Bblpn6snbtB&-

eMofi

ane6Tposireprn:r

T3c

E fAOc

npn

po3rrgttublx

spaqoltll$x

rctroBbrx

oT.{

}rcfielslft.

3rg

gasItcHMoCTE

non)r'reEbl

[r-ifi

aiieplEc

go=

Tertbrr

sHMltH{l

y.p{u}HK

cyrelllofi

BarpysKIt

KoTopofi

naII

Ha

pnc'2ra;

Hapnc.z,6ttpttoclletlblp€oynljrATblpacqeTanp'il7%roAoBblx{Ha

ptrg.zrA

-

npg

9%.

B

o6orX

cnynlaf,X

DtlIlHOr

rtTO

MllltH!'(AJIt{16tl

CC'-

6ecrottr.{ocTb

Dbtpa6oT;,lsael'toll

nl{KoDofl

3noprpooltapntlll

6r'rna

no-

IlJ^{ella

npll

pa6oTe

rA3c,

rl:tutu

npn

RoapacTaHHtr

q$cJla

alacoD

Bcnonb3oBoriilfl

ycrallo&.leUHolt

MoulttocTg

c$btue

145C-15OO

Puc.2,

Ce6ecron!,roerr,

Dbrpo6orKrt

erleKTpoellopntttl!

A

-

nuK

rpa-

$nra

[urpy3Klr

B

golre

Me]KJry

MaKcrt.t&nHrotl HBnp]€Ko[

3a

cyrKn

f,

L{ilttlltlallbltofi.EarPY3Kofi

c

B

qo

2o.'lr

slrrl

t2

-

tracogan

30-

Ha

Earpyofifii

B

cpetrlgts

rcrlu

nonynllxoBarr

ltanpysxa

b

soue

MeiK[y

nHxoM a 6aaucou|

C

-

6osHcnaa uarpy3Ka

npoaonE(llrenrt

HocTb{o

24

rr

+

10%

aTon BeJtuqltllt,ti

a

-

pacqertnte rpaQtlKu

cyroqrtoll

Hanpyst(Hi

6

-

ce6ecTonrtocTl'

Bblpa6otrn

nrKoooll

aneKTposBeprHn

npH

7% reAoDbrx

ortlltcreHtttl;

B

-

to

Ke

npH

9%

retroDrrtxi

1

-

flttxoDbt€

TOC; 2

-

fAgC

npll

posMouenun

Ra

-, 2 - A h^ ,(- ^

CeOnAf'OffpIIgTBOfl

nnolllAtrKei

d

-

IAitL nPE

ptxtNleuleultn

uu

urrcn-

ronpgrrHoll

turouallKo

allepnnrr

Bbrpa6aTbtBaeMofi

lla

nHKor]bfx TOC,

Mo]KeT 6rtrt u+

cxontr(o

uuxe,

treM

tra

fAgC.

Ho cJrcnycf,

orlrerrTb,

qro

gror

po3ynt'T{tT

6ua noJr)rqo[

npH

onponeJtoililH

cedecro[]'tocrH

EltoPfEn

Ens

fA3C,

pacnonaraehrbrx

lut

sancr1oMo

nc6nar.onpttnr[brx

ruto-

trtBq6ga,

ir

00

E60

:tl

S

t{0

ct

-zo

al

6

t2 t6U?\

0tt

6l?

t6

70

Z\

6pcm

cymox,u

1000 t500

2cc0 500

1000

1500 zN|

1960c.

$

$i

€5

Bs

t\

81 3

FI

b:t

sa

EP

j

J

C'

q.

O

*;

ES

crt

\<

I r.r

E1

ut

Oo

EP

nl -

I

-500

t000

1500

?000

500

lucao

vacolucn

o,t os o 6 a

t!

tg

F

oL4Ho cm

u,

1970 z.

6)

t5

n

u

500

0l

1000

1500

?000

luuo

,aq.col

wno^osol

alui

tloLuHocmu,

u

/zo

d

a

?

I

t

I

t

I

r

,

i

I

t

i

'1

il

C?t

t---

.5

l_

\

-

f

-

-2

J

s

1

z

J

;#;f,['-non,,o-ur

D

Tc'reilre

Noropl,rx

ccdecrontvtocrb

nllxoooll

I'ltmnpce

npeqcrtrB'ltlrlT

Ttlx:{(o

npoDeAelnrulil

tlltfl'llr3

no

cpcl}}l}-

grrr.-r

fi\llc

u

".,-r.r"ypGltilrrotl

yCTBIIOBXn

(rry)

rox

llcTorultKoD

nuxoaon

grlrnr.rrH,

naxorrrurrrrrcfl

D

aturllor}I|tlrbtx

ycJloDtltrtr

npll

Ko*

TOrrr.rx

l,{ollttt(lcTr{

cl)rllJltlll\llcxlt,lx

crotr:ttrll

eocTnnnltrvr

5%

or

nlF

KOnolt

trflrtr)y3Klt

3lt(l[]I'(r-*tIcTolvtl,l.

l'lcxontu'te

nlulllble

cpaDlloltEfl

fi

€.*.o

l)r\:!ynrrTr'rr.rt

npurrgngur,l

n

rtr6lt.2.

H3

l(o(ropon

DItnllo',

tlro

ct{.rp.rqHN{oCT6

Bbtpn6sTr'rrrner'rotl

nA

[l''llC

oltoKrpoellepnlln

trn

441

Iletuo$ne

atleFl-l{tb

noll)HtreMo{l

c

ori)et'{rroD

rTy'

il1-riluenetrtrr,tc

npl(\{cpbl

noKr'l:Jt,tl\nl{tTf

',rro

fA3C

f,DngIqTcg

aKoroL(rnarr,rt"rrr

rr6,rcr{Hrr}irll,*r

1t]rKOrrofl

artcJ('1pogtoprg11

E

cfrnaq^xrr

ptlnor.,{

nl:}{:l{i!lyulr:{JTIJr

xoIuFt,lx

llo

Itl"tcIoT apyrttof

Do(I}Lto}t(lllJlo

Itr;'l'i)'illlllitl

erclll

3ltopnlIN.

IvltrJrcu4r,

a"o'ltr,ltt*o

noxoot,tltno'rf

rlro

n

6onr'rulntcrBo

po'x'-

FrrTt,tx

c.r.pllrr

D

ltnc-TOfllueO

Dl)fltvtfl

0'l'Ntotoc/rcn

innootrlle

roqobol\)

giropf()1(-rr:1,cdncttrtfl

3o

F.8:KOl,lo

tO 116'Tr

t(oTo[nO

Collpo11o]KnogTct't

Uenpepl'rtlttl"lt''t

DoSpocT{ltutoNl

lt{'-'l)/tl}ttot\t(r[)ll()(]Tll

cyTGllu'tx

E ucfltvllr

,*,*

r;lrol,rrrros

uorp)3Krr.

3rn

1s'1qr-.rnrrrfi

oco6eHrro

orqern''o

BbrnBfiJIc,rcot

$

cafl3lr

c

nrrel(clIDttr,rrlt

pooottrtteM

aToNrlloll

glleprcF

TtIKtt.

BIrtJt,lBnlotttell

11OnonlttIT{\Itt{ll'lC

TI)yqtlOCTtt

nOKpLfTlltl

nOpn$l1la-

Nreprro{l

rlac'r}t

rpr:rlritxa

ltarpyst(tt.

3r'rr

rpyAllosTu

Tats)Ko

nocTOflIr-

llo

Doopnc.r.ruoT

D

cDGlrt

c

JrBor*t'lrrDcror-uoficn

}routtrocrt'lo

onpc'-

nrrrot]

TOC

r

AOC.

llo

onpono[eugono

yponln

pa3t]llTlttr

allepr\onotpe$neullg

BO

[{HOrtcK

cTp{tllrf,{

c

yKa3.qlltlt'f}'ltl

61'1lllo

TpynllocTfilllH

y[aBanocb

cnp8DnnTr{:g

co3nalilIeh{

o6r,cnttttclltltrlx

9}lepr'octIcTeMf

pASBHTUOLI

rrorutrocru

fl3c,

nfreN{

cl'ponrenbcTBa

[3C

c 6onulnvtr

p€IPItl-.

pylournratl

Boqoxpstnrnuulal,rll

lt

prtAol't

trpyrnx.

cnocofrcB.

B uacro-

fllleeDpct.tnBceaTHcpeqcTl}aoKo3antlcbHeqocTaTottltbtMtltra}Ke

D

TeX

cTpallaxr

trA€

3JlexTposlrepneTllKa

643!tpyercfl

lla

ngnPoaUep-

r€T[Ke,

lranprrMep

B

CKatrnlrnaDct(trx

crpallox,

qTo

rTp]rBeno

E

B[l-

TeHcttBltoN,{y

pasDttTHI9

g"rpoltTeJlbcTBa

fAOC

npaKTtFIecKE

Bo

BceX

gKotlot"tllqechtt

pa3DllTtrlX

Crpoltex.

B

KoKOll-TO

Mepe

eroMy

cnoco6g.TByeyT

lt

TOr

qTo

Bonpocstvt

oxpallbl

oKpylKaFruefl

epellbl

c

KAlKnbtM

nOIlOl"l

yOe;1ReTCn nce

$oJrl,uiee

Dltrlrvtagng,

nO3TOMy

coaaallHe

rrco6xont$,{bt](

no

eNtKocTII

BOIIOXpAUltnIilI

Ll}lortoJlqTb

Heno

penynHpoDaHHfl

BcTper{asr

ace

6oJll'tu[e

TpyaHOCTH.

I

Cnenyen

orrrernrh

qro

sKouoN{rr{ecKafl

e{t}ertuDlloc.rb

fASc

noc.THnaeTcg.

KAX

9TO

6t

uto nOKa3otto

B6ttllol

np6

CpABHlrretrbllo

le( Htl13Kolt

cTpollTeIIr.,llofi

CToul,lostE.

ilprr

aToNt fras6onee

Dblr\otr-

Hbt)"tE

g.Bnntq/TCfl

notr3eNtltbre

fA3Cr

nOCKOnr,Ky

OHtr

OKa3blBalo|l

BatrNtettt

uee

DntlsJttte

Ba

oKpyxtlloulltll

tD(

nalqua&rr

R

O6rtaqaloT

EO.3MolKltocTL.,to

XocToTottltorto

Safny6ncttllfl

pAfuqefo

xoxeca

coB'-

peMetrtrblx

Bbtgor.oltan6pltblx

O6parur'6tX

fBApAlfltfleCXrQ(

Mautt11

noq

r\luluNtanLtlblI

yf)ODellb

tttrit(llcro

6aCCefttta'

Hegr-'Ctlro

faiiiKel

rITo

nF.lerrrro

nplti"teueitrre

Br.tcoKottonol)t!brx

o6parHltb[x

rlrnpoMaultnl

nL.lJte.rcl

onlItIt

It3 ccitoDrlLrx

nyre'l

ctIIDI(cllIlfl

crolt.\tocrll

crpolF

TenbcT$a

fA3C,

iJ

eror.r

oriloueililIr npoer(TlrpoDalll(e

tt

crpollrenbcT\-

,

so

I-A:rc

c non3et.nlt

rl.t

pacnDnor(elnrcl.t ltaurlulltoro

34rilttlflr

a

D cJrf

.qas[

fA3C,

coopyKellilblx

B

poftotmx

6613

xeo6XontlN{btx

€CTeCT-

lBetltlbrX nepellaqoD

]"tecTHOCT[Ir

-

Tot{]KO

E

C nOA3gMltLtM

HEtt(llltl"l

'

2-L

flox

asarelu

cPantteultfl

Mourttoc.tq

%

PenynltpyloutBf,

eNtKocrt'

Eoqoxponllnilut&t

q

LI

ncno

rta

coB

IICn

oJIbS{tBAIl[

fi

t!'tolu

llo

cTH

V

aenr'rr,r

e

KanlIT

anoBno)KeIIlIflf

l"lapKo

(P

Pf

/rB

r'

flpouenru

Ha

KanllT&nt

%

CFor

sKcnflYaraulllt,

Fotr

Ex

ertutllt

e

o

rtl

llcne

lllttl

c x'an

ur

aJlo

BIIo

)K3-

usilr

%

3 xcrutyar

alrllollur'Ie

Sarparbt

t

?r

Exel-oai&le

H3aePi(KH,

-%

Yrtenr,lole

nocrolllltuJe

Bon'epll(Kll'

MoPKa

OPf/

(

xBr'noq)

To

f,(€r

nfetrtltrn/(xBt"l)

Crouuocrb

slleprlnl

ga

oapffr

fAOCt

nQexnun/

(

xLlr.'{

)

Torrnrrutraet

cocraeJlruourafl

nPlt

15

MapKa'x

Q PI

sa

1

fxan,

ntletlu

mr/

(

n

Bt'q

)

Ce6ecrolll'{crcTb

nurpa6orxR

nilKonofl

gnexr

a llepl-tl

E,

n{eltlttrr/

(

rBr"r

)

5

4rO

415

7,/

50

7.2!

1rO

8,24

34f19

5ro3

1133

Ta6rIHua

2

rrv

350

7"/

L7

1o,21

t15

LL|T

4

41,O9

6,o5

4 -65

-t

-

1O,6I

F.

t

I

t.

I

dacceitttnt"t

na.lidoneo

s$$ernrnrro

b

paflounx,

rrarr6qfleo

6nncxo

trPBlttll(sr.r\Illlx

f,

pafionar,t

9)lroprQrroTpc$fleurul.

Hurotrcnnttoo

p&3tlttrne

arourroll

stropnmrrKx

D

grpolrru(

c

Morrl*

Fl,tt'{I(

olttll)rrocflcToMa[{E

llpnttonrr

x

lteKoTopor\ty ctrHx(r,rlrtrK)

rrre+lrtrinttlcrrra

It$rl)yoxr,

xoropu0r oAltaxo,

l,rou(gr

6tl,rr, nont,rurolt

nyTe\{

aKXyt{yJlltfruortlllltt

tt-:6ulrosuofl

atteprrrE

B

qacbt

npor14lna

n{tt.fly3Ktl.

IIprr

Iv)JNtc)}t(}ioc'rn

c'rpo}tTc\nrcraa

xpyu}n,tx

AOC crp)rr-

T€firct$o IAOC

N{ox(cr

ol(s3art'cn

uenecoodpa:r111,y1,1

tt

a

crpotmxr

gr{g

uo coo[oDujlrx MOilItU,rX

eileprgcugreM.

2,.O-nnoqelretllro a,rhh':5'tuonocqrr

nrnrcgerlnq lAgC

ri

coqran

.

netrepnpvrclgtx

uorlwlocrefi

ar:e,nrocsEreuu

I

Uenscoo6pacuocrb

crporrrenrcrBa

IAOC

onpe[enflercrr

nnag-

llr,ttlt

o6pacor"t

u{lntnrllet\t

rsErttosttofl

anexTpogttepnHu

B }rotgtoe

EpeM&

n)nrurrNt

trcrotrrrIlKoM

xoropofi sBnfi]orcn

A3C,

xapaKTe-

ptlSytoutttecfl

lrtrcxo{l

crottlrtocrbt<l

Tonfluga.

Peuetsne

eKotlotyr]rqec\-

xor\o

Bonrjoca

o

auloope coorBereTB)4oulo(

Apyr

[pyny

octroDrtbrx

u8paLterSno

A3C

H

fAOC npeacraBnsen

cyuelcrBellnu

ir Hrm

epec.

Paccucrpul't

slrepnerrrrr

ccxyto cucTeMy

o6uefl Nrorurrocrtro

6000

r\18r,

B

cocrao xoropoit

BxoqsT AOCI

TOCI

.[-Ty n

I?OC.

Ocxoenbre

r exnltKo-aKouolt

rn(ecK

tle

xapaKTepucl

Er(

rr

arxx clrarrulrrl

nplloefletu,r

B

ra6n.3.

Ilplt

pacct.torpeHllH

npitrrrrofi

alreproctrcreNrLr

npeanoJranasrcflr

qTo

rHnlFrlil,rft

npa]xr

npoAon*(uTetrblrocru

Eor.p)'3xn

Aocrarotnto

nonHo

orpali(aer

sH,epnocHcTeN{y

lt

xapaKTepH3yer

ee

B

Te.{e[rre

Bcer"o

paccMarpHeoeMoro

roqa.

FIa

pnc.3

uco6paxcen npa{rurc

npo-

.qorKlITSnbtrocrK

Harpy3KE,

nptlrrsrbrfl

s

ocuoDy

pacr{era.

I-lo ocu

Crolrtstocrb

I xBr

YcralloDJrolF

roft

tv{ctrullocrtr,

Q.ct.

3atpartl

ll{t

aMopTtl3nuttto,

96

Sxcrn

yaraulloltllblg ooTPor

Ltr

Eorlc/

(

xElr'q)

r\oToBttoqru

sneKT

npEilcTt|Io

rrarpJ€Kllr

npi{

xoe'${ruruelrre

100%

To

ll(or

0"6

Koafi!uurror,to,

*t

fo

fr

cs

0.c../(xBr'notr)

h $.

cr./

(

xBr'roq)

ttt

tr.

-

KoaftbltuuelmbJl

puoo,*"

;;,il:llll:J;

ronn'Ba

floxn:ratcntr

tttnjy"*n

Ta6nHua

3

rrv

rA3C

Or54

60

10

ort2

70

95

oro9

oo

11

Or20

2

tI

Koed$turnelrr

cTalnltrlt

r

-%:

80

t

125

o

12

7r8g

80

?s

1.3

-OrO

712

17

r5

l

ros

or3

B

4

16,2

47.3

1rt

I

o

8.O

1O,51

g

G

q

s

\

*

d

R

E

F

_g

6M

b

+

n

Ir

r

ll

p

o

loa

x

u

n

e

n

ut o c

m

b

pofona, u/e

od

1:.

Puc.3,

Pac*terEag

cra-

TErIecx{rf,

},ro.Qenb

npa$uxa

BanpysK H

aHepr\ocHcTeMbr

B Brule

rpxooll o6ecne.tep-

Eocru:

I

-

6a^cHcuas

rr&-

rp)€Ha; II

-

nonyn[r(o-

':':{-i-.

Bas

nar'pysrca;

III

-

11H-

rra

eAnHEUy

CpeAHerotroBo0

Ebl-

I

-

f'OIlODbl

e

aKCrulyaT

arllloHllble

Han€plKKH

BA

t

rBr

LroulroqrH.

OpAlrUfiT npasrrXa

OTnolKelE

htglgllogTI'

alreprtocttcTeMb:,

nO

€B

a6crucc

-

{HCJlo

qacoB

pa6orur crartunft

D

roay.

I}aibnr

Mox(sT

6rrrr,

pa3ae11e11

Ea

TpH

3OHbr:

6aenetryro

I

t

B

rOrOpOfi

AnexTF

z^-^ i F^rrn rA ^in.r.u. nanvntffogvlO 3OIIlf II

E

lIIl-

gTaru{un

Palu(-rt'Irgl

lr\'Hrlrs'

s

vJ '

rs't

Eog)to aogy

IfI

I

noKpl'lTue

roropotl

ocyqecTRnseTcg

,rlPH

pa6o-

Te

aneKTSroctarutrfl

B

Tetlettlte

lte3ltaqttTonr-Hor\o

neptlo[a

c]'Tox'

flo

)rcJIoDtlst;l

aKoltoMs'tttoll

pa6otu BllepnocncreMbl

9rreKTpo-

craEuElt

Ea

aerueDoM

TonnltBe

noKpbtaarcT

HsnpySKy

B RXXEellt

6aSneuofi,

qacTtt

npoQurca

H

pa6ora$fT

B

T€rretlue

MaKcEMalPqOro.

EpeMetrn,

a

CTatUIItlIf

HcnoJrb3ytolUtle

nnq

pa6orUl

n6por€CTof,qee

TotuIBBq,

BKltrorl61qTcg

B

pa6Ofy

TOIE.,KO

TOr.nA,

EOfAa

OTO

Dbl3bf-

10

troBaE

EarPysxa

2-2

1r

EoeTcfl

Eo't'po6troJT

B:\ru 3

Ir Cpr

\..r.*ttL-I.

cl,fbtI

H

JrcnoDlrg,x

rlronyT

ue

-5xr6clruTb

coDceNt.

Iononng

croirr(ocTh

I

xBr

)tratronnetnro,l

l.torr{Itocrrr

TOC

b{o-

Kgr

6r,ltt"

Dl,tpor+(elul

cnenypuiolt

rlopr,rynoll:

nqe

c -

fOnOIJOf

qoJtfl

{r},tOpT.}U]OtUIII

XnIrtITO,,lt:Ht,t.t

Jfl.f[){U.

lt(l

I

rBr;

ll

-

noqoDllte

gr_CnflyoTar.ttroriltr,te

tl3qepx(EIr

ua

t

f t]r;

t

-

nPoAoJtxlITeJII,lloc'l't,

prt$ortt

cralurllt

D

Tc1relgre

noqn.

flo.t,Hxtl

ganlrctr\rocrH

rlcnHr(tttttrt

pu""

or

fr[]JAort]t(uT.:ltnllocrtt

pa6orbt

Jrnfl

pa3JtltqtlLrx

THrtor!

cl'artrurriJ

ilp,trroaorru,

Ba

prrc.4r

lra

f,oTOpOM

no

ocH

a6currcc

oTnox(6tra

npoAollli{rrrenr,trocrr,

padorul

cTa}ultUl, %,

Karc

DIlqHs

ti3

nptueaeurroro

npa{lrrxa,

crou},loqrr,

1

xBr

Mo[I-.

'HocTE

fTy

flo

cpaBHetIIIto

c

TOC

H

AOC

oxa^csrnoercrl

HarrNrenb..

tuefi

Ea

fracTr,e

ab

,

T.e..

npu

pa6oro

fty

nenpoqolr]r(rrr€Jtbtr]lo

qacTb

c)froK.

Ha

ytacrxe

bc

Ntegb{uy16

cTog}.{ocrFr

1

rBr

Hr,{e-.

m

TOC,

a

lta

}^{acTxe

cd

,

xapaxTeprnyroue}.rcfl

sr,lcoxoil

o6ec_

neq

eUHocTbIo

MorrlHocTtl,

Ha

Ir6oJrOe

gKotloNt6rt

Hbt

1-t

It

o6a3braaro,T

c

g

A9C.

flepeuecs

.qrlree

Bopurrrrrbr

r\flloroyronbur{Ka

abcd

rra ilpa{rux

IlpolloflxlrrenbltocTtr

narpy3r(H,

npotjeqe[{

r\oprr3oHTrvlbtrbte

nrrrililt

Bil

ToqeK

nepeceqe$Ig

oo[)TtrxaJIEilbtx

nttttttrl,

npoxonffltrrd

ttepoo

TotrKH

b

It

c

I

c npafrruor,.r

[poqonxHTerlblrocTH

IrBrpy3X[.

Orn

rtpllsolffAJlbEbte

oTpc{]tiH

ps3llf)Jtrllcrn

lrJtoularlr,

I.p3i]iilxrir

ltclxotrfF

uFocn noA

nIIlrttefi

rpcrlrnxa

npo^qonx{tIT€yrbircc.rH

}rcrpyoKrr,

tra rpg

Sotrbr.

B

gone

I

gaxSonee

gxoHol,{rrqHofi

6yner

axenflyaTautrn

Aec,

B solie

II

-

TOC

lla

opr-BlfinrocxoM

Tonrrrae

n

o aor;e

IIl

-

rTV.

c5ft'il"rapnag

nnoutanb

gTlrr(

Tp€x

gox

paBna

cyNrlroprroft

aulpa6orr(e

errepnsH

AOC,

TOC n

fTy.

Hantoxettlotfl

NteTo.q

Moxsr

6urr'

npgMeHerr

rutfl

onrlr],nroouurl

.qlrlraMrrrecxofi

Mo[,eJrE

Slrepnoc]rcTer"Gt;

[{cnonr^ryn

nocx,poerrru,re

MUOI'OyfanblIfixRr

rvfo)f(lro

onpe[enttTt'

nonoxcenne

roll

Rnlr

lUrofl

8'neXrpOCTAltrlEE

B

gueprocncTel,{e

D

pA3ntl$tbre

nepuonbr

ee

3KCTUI}I.

tratrrrt n -- -^'. ^-^ -!

erqsr'

,.\rrra

yuu,urlrltt{

itl9ll iJaIlBtIH

HgOOXOIlt{tlO

flpoqon)KIITb

B.ngBO

orpe."KH

MHOTOyTonbIIBKA

CtOH}.TOCTH

!O

nepeceqet$ts

c

aeprHxojlb-

uofi ocuro-

tronl'rogrnr

E

pesyJrr'Tero

qeno

6ynyr

nG'ryrrelbt

opqlF

Earbl

trlgt

Ml,

MZ,

,..

(prrc.S),

Koroplre

Moxrro

lt{reorrb

xa-

paKTepHcrrtqecxEr{E

lutn

paccMarptrDaevoft

SnesTpoc"TAtilIrilt

D nc,-

PEOru,r

epel.reuu y

t

y +

t

H

T.q.

STqroprKTeprrcTu,recKafl

op-

lllllaTe

Onpe.qeJulgf

Ilnq

cyrt€cTB)nouefl

gneKTpocTatnurit

Da.[[rr{H_

By

yaeflbHbtx

tsanET8.nOD.nox(etltrfi,

no roropbtM

oila

AonF(Ha

cpaE_

nP

tt

c ooT'rlc.rcTDyrotutrx

Pttc.4,

fpa$Hx

3oDttcll-

li{Oc-T

H

yCT

olto

L}rl

el{lro

tl

ft()uulocrn,

Pu", or

nfo-

n()rlx([T

cvlr'lldcT

tl

p.r6(}r

bl

I-l'Y,

TOC

rr A3C:

I

'

-

polrltNl

pn6otr,r I-TY;

2

-

polrtltvl

pn6()Tt,t T3C

lta

opr{$lltrl

cc

l(ol'l

tonrl

ilDc;

3

-

po)r{lrNr

prfotbt

A3C;

4

-

YcTsttoBnetF

H{If,

MorUllocT['

AOC;

5

ycTatloNlelllut

tl

NtoulllocT

r'

TOC

Ha

oprallurlecxot't

tOnnH[}el

6

-

YCtoHoe'lelF

llaq

MoutlocTr'

ITV;

!

-

'

dagrlcttac

ttarp$gra;

ll

-

nqnynlrKocl€rfi

llarp

)r3KB

;

Ilt

-

InlKoDafl

tlarpysKa

SAexnp0cnaHuuu

U.2

g'J

ar

G-

\

E

:

R

I

\

E

.E

q

€

.rt

I

t

I

llepuoflot

padornt

U*l

Puc.5. Pa6o'leo

noJloxelllte

paccMarpltBaeMor\ct

rll-

n{r oneKrpocratlunll

a

npa}trKe

HarpygKlt

ouepnocxc-

Telvtbl

B

po3Jrlftllble nef*lo&,!

eP

OKCIII|yaTAU'UH

Et!Barbcf

c

ltooof,,

gaMeltrrloqetl

eo

anexrfrocratItxetl,

rr.teroutefi

ter.Be

E(e,

xax

y

cyruecraytouefi

crallul{r,

aKcnnyarauHo}lllrrl€

H3-

!epE(KE.

Eclu

Cyuua [ellcrBrrr

oJrbnr,tx

rapaxTepttcr]H

ecKtE

crott-

vocf,e:

tT.:,.

nepBollA.tanhgbtx

XanHTOJIOtr[O]Keltllfl

3a

D:'rle|rOM

aMoprl

.

Jt4{,:'16;X

or'rHc.neltufi

ga

nepnon aKcnnyaraulllt

cTatnrltl

;

-r)

12

(

lr

-.

I

t

I

t

13

.

lr

E

a

I

v

fl

po

d o,t

xu,n

e

lt

oH

o

tttt b.

P

6.e'19t

'

iiiimpocmarauu

I

zod,

%

116r.v

t?t]60\?,

-trl-f*T--

,,

|

,zJ

tt

5

Bpenn,v

?tt

Pnc.6.

Cyrorllr,rir

rpa'yirx

npoaofl)tfirrellbilocrH

Inrpyst(Ir

sHeprocltcTel"lbt

c

tltltoroyroJrbttltxo]tr

crotr].tocril:

I

-

A3c; II

-

T3c;

ll[ .

-

naaoryp6urruaq

oner{rlx>cr{rrurrrrj

,

IV

-

TA3C

HO

r

if

1

t

MZ)

... 6yuer

paBlut

cyl'{N,te

aeficrailTeJtbtrbrx

a}.ropTu-

rrnrlfl11

oilI)eqortnoT

onTflMallblloe

ltunoil(cltue

9T]rI

cTatgtttft nptl

-

:*.... ---"^,f,..-^ r'^Fh...u.r ^rrAnF.\ntrm6lrr-r ltfnrr rfr\l.a Trrnnrraa-

$ol([)tri

I

utr

l-PaJlPll^(|

lrqr

PJrAlr

elre'lrt

vr, t.u

. srr.e.. .

.lJrr

e

.

v.'.

..I&sr.r

16rBcTcg,

rtro

^ueurcByro

Bg6r,rro'rt(yro

attoprttto

A3C Molttro Hcnoflb-

oftt!{rTb

nnfl

saptuto

fA3C

lV

"

llo

rpr'fitKo

nlnnoJt]lilrTenbuocTn

uarpy3K[

nHltrtn cTotlMocTtl

OII){tfrCi

CJrOIlyptultt"tlI

no},t(lHbtMtt

nllltllJttttlt:

47'n'q'

-

gnf

It:V;

p'r'*

0

-

nrrn fAOc;

L'mh'Cit';

-

sns

T3C

s

,t$6n'q'

- gnnAOc'flprraro;lrottrtt

rl

tll;

qso

f,D-

nnt(')TctI

Depu,ltlltllttt

NlltonoyfoJlI,lItIt(o

cTOttt'locTH

Ha

pHC.qo,

A

crorrMocrtl

tta

ptlc.6rd

.

flnouaqu

OL;8,'m'n'n6r6'

thlpolKaer

CTOTII,1OCT'b

Cy'ro{}Ioil

BbtpobATbloaeNton

sneKTposltepftttt

BceMH

aJreKrpocrnHuHnNtu

cttsrer"tbl

(puc.6,

.t).

flptr

DDeneltllH a cocroB

relrel)tipyloulttx

sneKrpocTollltull

ctlcreNtlr

fAgC

$opug

npalrrxa

crotlhtocT6

(prrc.6,

a

)

6yUcr

onpcq(tltrrbcs

nttttttell

'E'r'"',

gantrcqurefi

or

Nlotultocrn

lt

pa3Meulcltttn fAgC

Ha npa+tlKe

nPo-

'nonH(nTeJIEttocTtt

t{flrp1lern.

CpaDllelltle ngltlrfi

E',

"

'

ll

,tm''n.',

DocJretrnrln

t{g

Kcrropbtx

cooroercrDyef

pa6ote snepr'ocncreNtbt

6e.e

pa6orul

B lrefi

fA3C,

noraobrgaer

gKouot\ttftlltocrt

BCIloJlbSo-

BAIIIIg

B

CIICTEME

TA3C.

AOC,

o6ecne.rnDrrn

snopruell

sapffI fA3C,

B Kottcxtno!"t

rrore

BttTecltfleT

t33

norrynllrcorlofi

3ollbl fpa,lnxa

rulfpy3xtl

MoqlrocTb

TOC.

I-lplt

aro[.{

B

3trepFocrrcreh{e

nonoJlsrc/Tcg lleKoropble

nonon-

uuTeJlbllbte

Sarparbt,

Koropbre

o61'cnoonenur

TeN{r

qTO

A3C

Hcnonb-

oyrorcg

B

Tolt

o6nacrtt

rvrlroroynoJll,HttKa

groul'tosrHr

B

xoropofl

TOC

6onee

eKouol'ttFtllbt.

llcnonr,eoDotrue

fly

B

arreproctlcrel'te

oKa3bln{r€/Tcfl

6onee

.sxonol,luqnLtM

no

cpfinttettfirc

c

fA3C

Ha

cFtenb

Ue6onbutol'{

y.laqrKe

nparfruxa

c.roHMocTtt

(prrc.6,

d

)1

Mo)l(t1y

ToqXal'rtl

gt

d

r'

,

Rclo

r't:rcrn$]nccg

qaclb

nHKa

rpalnxa

-

or

rotIKtI

nl tro

TotrtKtt

z1

(pHc.6,

c.

)

-

6onee

sKoltortlrqno

noKpt'tDorb

3a

cqerr

|AOC.

Ecnlr

npencraBlmb

nnqrtant'

nttxooofl

Sotltrt

rpalrrr<a

npo-

4oJIr(HTeJIbIIosrtI

llonpy3Ku

D DHne

XpHBoft

v1

(prrc.6r'6

).

To

Ber-

r$9

t

5

i\\)

\\.

N\r

DAeNron sneKTposlteprtttt

BceMH

r-r

r

|

_

..

Ti

zq

T

_-t--

'

gEePrpcucTel,{bt

D

uelroM.

B

xa'recrBe

nprrMepa

Ha

pnc,6

npxgeaerrbt

c)rroqru,re

nposp

xll

.npoAon)KltrerlbllocrH

Hsrpy3KH

E

N{Eoroyr\onblrrrK[

croulrocteft

AnR

alreprocHc'r'el'{bt,

B

cocraB

roaupoft

Bxolrrr

rry

lll

B

Kaqe-

crBe

nHKOBOII

CTalililrr,

'l3c

ua

opnarnt'recxoM

Tonnr{Do

II

H

,

Agc

I

s KaqecrBe

6acttcnLtx

cralqlHll

cgcreMLr.

IltrorulroJrbrnlr(

I|KH sroFo

ycJIoDtrfl

6yaen

Bl'InonuflTbcg

yeJroDne

orrrlllrrr3sug6

nnrBEa

rO,

6yaer

coorgc'Tcrooaorr'

NlaKclllvraJlbltofl

artpa6orxe

rreo6poxelra Xpurlss yZ

I

BbtpsKatorUofl

3grpaTbl alteprHll

Ha

3€F

psA

rASc,

'

AocrnroeMafl

npn

srol,r

gKouot{ttfl

E

ga

cqgr f,cnonh3oBautlf,

fA3C

D

sueprocHcreue

6yaur

paDtlsrbcn

ntrouaqlt

r'm'c'd'

fa

fpo,l6Xe

cTOHl,toCTA

(prf

C.6,

d

),

a

tronoJltlnTent*Ille

pilcxoqt)t

A

6ynyr

panttbr

@oTBc'TcTIletUto

nnouattn

n'b'c

'

,

Pa3ltlula MCX(-

uy

'iennriltraMu

arlrx nroulrr.qefl

B

r'torr'ef-6tiiu

uiiCiibria-

bi;troqJ

Eocrbro

fAgC

D

tra'Hltort

glteproclrcreMe:

14

t5

Q.cm/lexo

ll&n.r

F_f.6snamS4joo

B-E

-11

-(r'nr'c',j1-{n

'

lla

puc.7

trflrt

|cJlo611',1

rofl

o

6

9q

F99F

AEEts

5

rG|

jt

S.a

Ccr\{orplr uilelfo

il

grrepr\octrc-

to|'fb'rl]!rDtHocKt|no}iiL]atlo.xf...u6paloM6yrtettrclletln'rrcla/_1\

bentrl ttrta

B

o saurlcru..r<;crn

or

nr,r6opa

rrourrrocrrr

IAOC.

:

E -.-ti+fl | \ .-ltlr

KAK nrrurn rrr

prrc.?,

rrarr6ortr,ulof,

orun,lrurn

arcoiir:r.i*rriocr ii

-

>4li _l# I

-

\

------

"

-'!L

rll

:.IL

gllol]rocrrcr?n

tr.l

nocrlrroercfl s

rorlt

cfl]^toe,

ec.{u r}ecr,

nrfi or

,

-

---

ilt=:-.itZn | \

_

lt

,

rI

.no

z

I

nol;Fr,rnaorcn

3{r

c,rer fA3C,

-<L---

-ot

;{1. f----_

___::,{!_jl

I

B

pacc r,ro

rprrurrorlr

nprNrcpo 3tropnsfl

ans

s{rprula

IAOC

6epen-

^-h-

l=_-*-_-._-

-

-_-

_\t!t

I

cx

3a c{rcT

ya(l,lrlrclurrr

rr

ol

tocTH n3C,

llpH sro].r acn 6o3l|cnnc

| |

nN.

lpi

I

ilacrl,

rpo,lrrxa

Harp)BKx 3rrcpr\ocncr

oN{bl

(irxrro,ran

sHepn$rl

3opn-

'

6l

| |

\-f-}r\

i

T*:3 H:^T::--"jol'"3151,-11:".iir::-T."i:: I I-,

e6

rpa{niro

-

po6ornnu:n.rrr

I-l-Y n

Lrl3C,

nprererr rrouuocrb

fA3C

|

nl

('-

nPs'tlMaorctl l"ttrxc

tll'ton r'ltol1

l(cxoatt tt3 rpe6onaHttil

3

Kollo.ttltllocr

pxc.?.

llgf-retretro

Ecrrr.I'lrbr

g

a.lrn

paccvanp-o"*,of,

"uf

TH 3nepnocrrqr

er,rlr. l-lpr elor,r

xgo6xoarrr,rocrr,

a T3C,

pa6oran

,-,.,o....,r., M b.,Fh^,-.^^

rccEc..TellEl

D on-Dfic|lrrocTlr

m

ouEpounoll

voruuocr

n

fA3ci

Iq,eft

Ba

OpnallH.leCKOIt

Tonnrloe. ttoIHOCTbto OT[aIa€rr.

A

-

tt3l'terronlte

DLIpA6OTKT!

fAgC

;

flpu

peurc'uu

sa-ca.tu o6

onperc{rou'u sr!}exrrrnnocrrr

pa6o,rrr

Boftle'rrol

r\roruro€Tr.

6

-

r?6.11o.

"rrj;;}#]l$

T

.TF

lA3C s 3lrepFocrrrr er:e

!\ror{gr npencraBtrrr,cn crrJ"rallr

Konno

:

rocficrelte

Mor.ttxoqrb

fA3C

nonnercn ranepel 3a[aHnofr

(uonpxlrep,

no

yo-

ll8rn.,r

JIoBlt

art

a(rr.ro)t{rpr-o crporrreflr.ctga

fA3C D

qarulolt

pafrolre),

_-;|,l-T

"9,-

nn|6\?

d,

flpu

ycaoon.,r,

qro

r\rorulocrb rar<of,

fA3C rrerrbure roll

Dcriryuul,r

'rr

_,!f'19--llG:------_:-

-=Ao

Iff."J;il'1""1J':ff;J:":L'.'#"##1,,:"T:..'"trffi'j1;iffi

,|r#.Jsji,.Rffik=wf4flryVT

cucreMbr

o

npa$ruce cyro'lroll

rrarpy3nu

cucrerlrbr

r npn noKplrrulr

;d"#r'uuH-+-=!---r--})I.sa<--:<'-!r--1f00

uvx

rparlr:ura

nponolxirrejr r,nocrrr

rranpy3Ku,

nr!=..-

-l--lj-1-

-i

-

--r.i**,#i

llnn

pouetntn

3Toii

ga[a.rlt

Mox{llo

Docnolt\3ooarbcn

trocrfro e.

.l

Htts[*t, rrp]taeaetulrrl]"r]r

Ila

prIc,8,

,flycrr

fA3C

r.rourxocrno Pl

-

ad

1l

o6ecntrrrrsasr

noKpbrruo

corur ad1<;,d

rpo{rxa

puc,8,

a

.

H

eoi6xo-

,;!

Fl-

-

- -

aHMas

B

eToNr cJrr{ae

3H?pflrfl 3apflrra

lls

np€'+rrr(e

ptrcr8r

6

uur-

-

| |

t

pfi.3llTcfl

nnoutnEbto

erfjh

1

Ann

nofl)^tetrtrfl

nJlcllI€Luil

g]lepfHtl

i !

saprratr

Bocnonb3yel.rcrr

nocrpoellxcr.t,

IlprrDenelilrbr!.r

Ha

pHc.g

! |

flocrpoxo

tla

rp{lrirre

puc.g

nprnroynorlr:nbrft

rpeyr\onbrrrlK abc

1

'

, , ,tii,lnt

y

Koropono cropoln i?6-

\,v

paalu

Benrrrutte

Morutrocr]r

fA3C a I

|'#+:g

!r4LLl--------

-

.0

60

\0 20

0 0tZJt15

,

trp?l'r,t

y

xurolxrt-o c]-ulxrrrn i?o

-

\.v

paalul

DenlrrElte

MolullocT[

lAJ(' B :

-fin-;i"AO-iO'fi--d

trti;i-- . i

l:':T':":l:::1..Y:illi:-

".."j?1,l-lu':!!-t::1"

:"P1Yl-"-^-

i"',irri,i,l"t

"

ii'i'i ./ r

; fAOC

a

rcqsure cyroK, ronyqxvr

jtlUli*j-lf:.ffi

.

-

n*---

-#-ts

rrpe-qe,rau,

DLrure rqropono

pacnoJraraercn

IASC

g

npa{nr<e

npo-

E

soli i ,l

_-l

"

$'

.

aq[

xrrr

c-Jl

r,rrcc r$

rarpy3rifl.

Ha rprr']rrxe

ptc.9

nocrpoerra

Dcnolro-

S,ro

,

raTetrbnaF

upuoan

".j

.

npoaBar-r:uraf,

n(tporulsnr,tro

""u".1-

!? ! E

oTcronruor

or

rree

lta

pacc

rorlrrtrr

z2'z'{- iN .

ilnr

nonylenrrn

ao-

e

ltbl3rlpf!l.rD\3Ctrcnrtrncycrcarovila-o2IlcrpcceqeltiIcKpxDL|x

.

r.,

rl

y.i'

o

xn'tecroe

orlroll

tr3

lr'prullli.rpcyrun

blrrrKa at6.)c,

!

p,

2l

EP.rt..

oo

crolroH.r..{rr

a)hAa..\p-1,1lrr

62c1

-Ep-Eg.

i

P..-

8'

rno'Dtl'lccr<oc

onpe-qerronte

omf,MaJrb[or\o

pac[on(>

i

13rrqncr,,,a to-r, tnr o6pa3or.r

olu,eo,ore

srepnur 3opr*a, Iro*rro

r

*

jji.rlT-llllloxnrll

'T:'!5:

Iurrorrx

rrsnblrocrn

Ha-

vur*runl

!'rurYt)',ru r'relx-,''

"i'l"srd'

Dru*rre

|

:-_ysxx

srropr.oc[creMbl:

t

-

agc; ri

-

;"';.-;,

-

t t",

,

16 .

i

,v

-

r^ec

!l ! t 5.

lt

ti-rr_L

E.

E

f,.

l.

I

c\.

fIl-Affilwa'.

I

r

'ffiil5Ofidnr-\

l-rJ

l==

k

R

Pnc.9.

fpo$trrecKoo

nocr*

poeHH e

lutfl

onpetroJlellllf,

BenFlHtrbl

aHepnHH

saps"qa

rASC

Onponc\n

l{T b

Dt'lf\JIlltOCt

b HC

no,'l

b.?t}-

--- Ff

^l/^

N^rt

B{Iltll.g,

S

rt

f

1*

E}

:tlIt:Pr\JUrlL

I uilrv

rr}'t}

ffinuol'{

ee

ps:]Mcll(ellutr

a FluubllNo

ilfrOtltr'r]l(tt'.I'eilhl{O(:l'tt

ltafp}l3KH.

B

rroM

crlfte€

Di-Ei-Ai, nrle

Ei

^rrhonnrrrrnTr^(r nnn rnrtttrnft nrrr)urnnfl

vrll,l-.4rr.4u.

vrr

ot6trlll1t

na

prtc.Br6

r

a

Ai-

nnor'!tanl,K)

n)v'ut

ltononlll(Tenr,Inle

a ---- -

pACXOIfbt

^i

B

g]-oNt

cJlfrue

-l.tr|1'rt\tt

^-J<.,^..^* .t?r^Etrt^tttt^1, lrnltL

llrJLJrt,Mr3lr-Ol

JE

(rrr.'r\;lllrErq

rrvt4--

HosrH

AOC

n

pacnpocrpallolElel'l

AgC D

ootly, B

Kcrrofron

6oneo

oxo-

Bovtrlltoli

nniltlerctl

odunrtlan

TSC,

OlrrwttanL,tloe

lloflo]Kellrre

fASC

SA.UAIIIIOII

l'{Outttocru B

npe}lrxe

npo-

uoJlli(IrTenbuocl'H

llarpy3Kl{

N{oKer

6urrr

onpetrenetD

cJrenypurllM

06-

pa3ot!(.

flepoueufan

souy

ablc

1d

I

no

BePTHX€urH

D

nPeAenaX

oT

rl

.uo

zl

r

Ilrlfl

KAlKqOro

nGrlolKelntf,

onpenertt{roT

cooTBeTcTBylol.uHe

sBEF

qegBil

Bi-

OntuvantrEoe

noJro)Ke-

BHe

fAgC

6yuer

coorBercreoBarb

UonOlKelUnot

nplt

KoToFroLt

sllorlelllle

B

aocrHrHer

cBoers

l'taj(cIll'{yu{4.

Ha

octtoDatllttt

npoBeqeliltrrx

npe-

Quxecrnx

pacqe'roD

l'{o'ri(lto

ycrat{o-

Btmbr

qTO

BbII'OAIIOCTb

UCflOJIE€ODal-

utls

FA3

C

s

g

lteprer

tlq ecxoll

c Hcr +'

Lde

Bcel.Ila

BoopacTaer

c

yBeJltrqeulleM

ee

]'toxlltocTH.

B ooutelt

cny{ae

BeJlsqHIra

Dbtr€iuiocrn

RcnonbsoBallltff

fA3e

3€DircllT

oT

ee

MouHo6:rn

r{

pagMeueglrg

craHuwu

e nparfrrrKe

npotroJI)l(lITeJIbF

BOCTE

HArpy3KH,

A TAKIKe

oT

cooTttouetlHfl nnfl

paccNlaTpllBaeltofi

aHepltecHqre-vbl

3_H8{eu!!q

}'tottrlloqrefi

T3C

n

A3C.

Vs tmureag

npR

aTgMr

rtTo

B Hacrofiulee

DpeN{a

HMeercg

ycrofl'tHBas

reluleltrllls

JrDeJrtryellEE

qTotIMoCr

E

opnal{tf'Iecxofo

ToruruBar

Bblr.l^:

}!(rc'r-r

l!(lr

-)JtbgogaHug

IASC

6yner

rett

Bbttuer

tIeM

funbuat

':

ft

SU

rtr'enepnocrrcreMbt

Docnpurrnrvtaercg

pafotarouttL\tlt

E

reMs'fgC'

ftpn

oupeaqnenHH

Moutuocrx

A3C.

B

cocraoe

atlepr\ocHcre!'tul

cne-

.

lycT

npesycMaTptEaTb

Tarylo

tD(

Morutlocrbr

KoTopog

nosBontula

:6U

rlon}/ttaTr,

Korrrn|i]eidd.gBeprH]r,

nec'6XonnMoo

A'tg

3ap'na

UMF

Dtuttxcf,

B

cHcreMe

IAOC

.

HancxerrHslil

Msr\tq

pacqera MoruHocrlt

E aKolroMKqecroll

a+-

18

.)ii !

oenr.XuiiOCrrr

npllN{eHoHltfl

-B

allepneTll'teCKlO(

CltcTohtaX

rASC

Cy-

Tott'efp

penynltpq66lttrfi

MoliiC'F

6ult=i,

TAi(riie

iiFiit'iCEiCiE

!!p!t

On-

pellOIlClltnl

]'tC]tUlloCTtt

fA3C,

Xtlt(]tolqtD(

3lto(It(TGnblU'ltl

nO

o6t"rt'ty

6accelitttt

nnn

6a.y1r1*lCTrinrrtrtrsr

trn tttoc

cronee

qllHTfilll,ltoFo

[)erynl(-

DODAIiltfl,

T.

e'

co3asltllll

3{ltl{tcot'}

Dollt'|1

nosBoJtfltoulllx

o6ncttL\{tlF

'

z -- r!A -/- <^ar rrraft r t^rnrr^F'rt-tn rr r{Anf)rronltt,to n(\I)ltoI\1,'l

BOTL

pnOOf

y

l

/l\'\-

Lr-'Jrrrrrrrr

r'\'rrr'

lf

nepttonbr

11616oJlbtuItX

ltflt'l)yJol(

sltoJ)nOctlcTel'(l''l'

fllrrr

e1'()l't

Cflo-

AyeTtIN|CyrbDDI|AYlrlTonoJlyrloC}N|I,|eptrc{eTo}'t3llo(Icltlll|Nto|'lt-

l'eTetl

ngnx{ltLf

6urtt

ylJent1rletllrl

c

}

leTohi

iiegf*Oi-tiiiliOCTii

OCT*

BOBKII

qacTu

al'per-{rToD

iia

nix;}piinaKTilliccKlto

lt

NnllllTBlIL'!!!'!e

per\{otrTt,l,

aBoptlllltble

OCT6IPDKIt

lt

ntrxrcrott'

C

frq'rO}'t

Xoetlx}rrUttetr

Ta

pOTOLI1IOCTtI

c.TBtl1tlfl

r

npttaMy

tl6fpy3KIl

Sllepf6CtlCTol'lt'I

DenIF

.,Hga

cyt'o,tttoll

cTotr[tocTll

1 xllr

ycTotlotuenHoll

hlolUllocTtl

3llefF

r\ocHCTel"fbt

n'Ifi

SneKTr]oc.ratulltfl

BCeX

Ttlllot]

N{o}KeT

6uttr,

onpe'-

Aeflelta

no

cneqyplueil

{npr-rytte:

P.,^-

-

[(fn

+

f.t)

c

+

Er]365.

J|Jr

r,t

i

flpnnenetlttt,tfl

aBaIIttil

nOKaSgrr

qTo

npHMelreltHe

B

KoqeCTBe

ucrortlutKo

nI{Kopoll

atrepntlg

fA3C

B

gllepreTRaIecKtD(

ctlcreMox'

B

KoTopr,tx

6&sucBaq

qacTtr

rlarpy3oK

noKptrtBaeTcfl

pa6otofi T3C

H

AOC,

sDnnercn

sQ{ext}lBHblNl'

B

-arnX yqtogtttl1

Cneqytoqrllt

eTanol't

npoeKTltpoBalltls

IAOC

sBnfiercg

onpe[eJlelore

Ben]rqlltbt

ycralloBnelltloll

]'toulllocrrr

FA3C

B

ryp6gtglgM

pelt(ti\te

ee

padoTblr

Belltl'lHttbl

yCTatloRnellltoll

llolll-

ltocrg

B HacocHoM

pelrtrMe,

Maxcllrv(oJrlttoil

eNtKocrH

Bepxtler''o

6ac-

cellHa [nf

non]^{eutIf,

treosxoAlB,loro

KoJllftlecTBo

nHKOBOII

sllerF

flrr,

3lratrenge

rtlttl

sHepnocltcTe!'{bt

paC}oTbl FASC

Kax

panynflropa

rraqfoTbt

ToXa

U

6urcrpoAeftqrDylqueno

peoepBa

B

lulqrotuuee

Bpe'-

Mi

pac.reTaM!{

r{Tetro

6r,rrr

He

}'lo)l(sTr

noeTo}v{y

npH

onpellejiF

BIilr

DbrrueyKa3AtrIU,rX

napaNlerpoB

rASL^

6epyr

B

pacqeT

nHulb

$yrrXrtrrtr

fASC

Kai(

llcTot(ttnKa

nHKoBoR

3ttePI'HH

H

aKKyt'{yrifrTopa

ggepnru

B

qacbt

npoBanog

npar}*lKa

Cyroqllofi

Hal'pyslill

cHcTeNlbl'

.

3;

Otrpeqe:TeftHe

fiKottohtiflrecKlt

HGHI$lrl-ElOe$+egUlllX

saoaMe€!|oF

fASq-tt

Hx

sneMel$oD

Ans

onpellenclnlfl

ogTHNla.nblrbtx

nopal'IeTpou

rASC

U

RX

a'ID-

MolrToD DDeqel,t

Cnellyrcullle

Oc]o3lla'tglllfl

:

ycTaltoenetlKafl

lrlOltl-

FOCTb

rASC

O

ryu6xuuoM

peli(uN{e

-

Prypir

TO

t(e

E tlococlloM

pegllr{e

-

Pt,o.,

-nP.

I\loxctlN(afibll^g

3llchneTlnte.Katl

eMKocrb

BepXIrenO

B6goipallluritqa

Moxcvr

6l'trs

Dbtpax4eHa

KOnffi€'CTBoi'l

qaco6,

D

T€Hegre

KO/rOpbtX

MOx(evt

6strt"

O6eCneqet6

po6Ora

3-2

.

r9

Губин М.Ф. Экономическая эффективность гидроаккумулирования в крупных энергосистемах

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.