Гладышева О,В., Репкин М.С. Понятие и правовая природа розыскных действий следователя

yroJroBHbrft

[PorIEcc

1

. Kpz,r,rzronhcrzqecKoq

AeqrenbHocrb

KoK

SneMeHT

AeererrbHocrl4

cneAoBoreflR

zMeer npKo

BbtpoxeHHy|o

npa-

BOBy0

nphpoAy/

r.iTo

B ToM

rthcne

cBhAeTeIbcTByeT

o

B3o-

r.lMOCBe3h

KphMhHOnzcrhKt4

c Morep4orrbHbtM

h npoqeccy-

orbH brM

yronoBHbtM

npoBoM.

2.

3ovocryro,

oco6eHHo nph

coBepueHZZ

HeoqeBhA-

H

brx n

pecrynn

eH r ra,

on

pegenhrb

Ho

npo BneH H

ocrb

yMbtcno

BhHoBHoro

z

npoBhnbHo

reonrzSraqrapoBorb

ero

EeilcrBVA

B

o3Mox H

o

ror

bKo

6n

o

rogo pn

Aocrhxe

H

hfl M Kpv Mt4Ho

nvlc-

rkKl,,

ero

noArBepxAoer

He TonbKo

loprzAhqecKyto

nphpo-

Ay

KphMhHonv,crvKht

Ho

h

ee

B3ohMocBg3b

h B3OZMOO6VC-

noBreHHocrb

c

yronoBHbtM

npoBoM.

3.

fl peHe6 pex/ren

bHoe

orHolueHhe K

3neMeHropH

brM

peKoMeHAouvtat't

<put,tuuonhcrvKht

HonphMep/

Kocoro-

u]hMcg

nonHoTbl

ocMoTpo MecTo

npohcrlecTBhfl

A np4Me-

HeHVte

Kpt4 MVH

on hcrh

qecK

hx

cpeAcrB

e

vtKCotJt4A,

B

n

ocn e-

Ay|oqeM

nphBoAhr

K HopyuleHho

nopqAKo

h nphHqznoE

yronoBHoro

cyAonpoz3BoAcTBo/

rlro

CBhAerenbcrByer

o

Hepo3pbl

BHo i,

cessu Kpt4MAHanhcrhKk

c

yr

onoBHo-n

po-

ueccyorhHbtM

npoBoM.

4. B:orzlaoceq3b,

83ohMo3oBholMocrb

h

83ot4Moo6yc-

roBrreHHocTb

nepeLtzcneHHbtx

yronoBHo-npoBoBblx

HoyK

npoFBrfllorcr,

c

oAHot cropoHbt,

B ToM,

qro

MHorhe

no-

foxeHZq

KpvMt4HQtZ|crvKV

BOC1?ZIHZMOtOTCg

3OKOHOAA-

rereM

h nonyeoror

frpoBoBylo pernoMeHrol_{rzro.

C

.qpyroi

cropoHbr,

ocHoeoi

Ann

Bbrpo6orKh

roKrzqecKhx peKo-

,',re rpo

r1r.r i

no n

poh3

BoAcTBy

cn eAcTBeH H btx

AeicT

auit,

on-

rophrMoB

poccneAoBoHhe

sBneerce

npoqeccyonbHoe

pefr

oMeHToLlh9

AerTer

bHocTh

BnocTH blx yllocTH

t4 KoB yfo-

roBHofo

nPouecco

h

yfonoBHo-npoBoBoq

xopoKTepucrh-

ro npecrynreuzi.

5.

Hoz6onsLuee

npoKrhqecKoe

3HoqeHke

AnA

KpAMvl-

Honhcrt

Kt4 hMeer

HoyqHoe

o6ocHoBoHhe

nepexoAo

or

no3HoHl4r

MoTephorrbHbtx

h

h.qeonbHblx

cneAoB

B

MeXo-

HZ3Me

npecrynHor't

AenrenbHocTh

K

yronoBHoMy

npecne-

AOBOHI,IIO

h HO3HOqeHhto

BhHoBHbtM

cnpoBeAnhBoro Ho-

Ko3eHhr

nu6o <

orKo3y

or

yronoBHoro

npecneAoBoHze

HeBhHOBHbtx/

OCBO6OXAeH

VltQ vx

Or HOKO3OHhe,

QeO6nnn-

rotlzu

Koxporo,

Kro

Heo6ocHoBoHHo

noABeprcs

yroroB-

HoMy npecneAoBoHhro

(cr.

6

Yl-1K PQ).

l-lonoroe,ra,

qro

yror.rHeHhe

npeAMerHoi

c$epsr

yro-

noBHo-npoBo8brx

HoyK

nph

rz3yqeHh\

o$Hvlx

h rex xe

o6lerroe

no3HoHhr no3Borrhr

noBbtchrb

KoqecrBo npo-

BoAhMbrx

HoyqHbrx

hccneAoBoHhi

z

rQQerlaBHocrb npo-

BonphMeHhrenbHot

AerrenbHocrh.

Crvroxtun E.8.,

AoqeHr

KoOeApb, yronoBHoro

npo4eccd u

Kp

u Mn

H d n u

cJ

ra

Kn, ll x

cr

nryt

r

o cy

Adp

q

B

a

n n

p

c

a

o

ItoufY,

KaHAnApr

ropu4u.tecKux

HoyK

96noroe

H.ll. l-lpe.qhcnoBhe

K KH. f. fpocco PyxogoAcrso

Ar-rc

cyqe6r srx

cne4o sorene i Ko

K

chcreMo

Kpt4

MA Ho nhcr v,x t/. Ho eoe

h3A./

nepenelr.

c

hsa.

'l908

r. M.: Ierc3cr,2002.C.Vll.

Yxos.

coq. C. P.

Cr'l.: 6opLuea

t. Z. Oo.roeoH

he

yronoBHoro

cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo

c

npt

MeHeHheu

x

pocoricroMy

yro|oBHoMy

cyAonpoh3BoAc-

ray.

M.:Ierc3cr.

200.].

Cu., sonphMep:

To,ra

xe.

C. 97.

fpocc

[.

PyroeoAcrso

gnn

cyge6nsrx

cneAoeorenei

KoK

chcre-

Mo KphMhHonr4crnrr.

Hogoe

h3A., nepene!1.

c

f

sa.

l9OB r.

M.:

Ierc3cr,

2002.

C. XV.

6enxru

P.C. Kypc

rpltarHonhcrhK^

e

3

r. T. L

06ucr reopv,s

KphMhHonhcrhxr.r.

M.: lOpracrt,1997

. C.

'

'6.

loMXe.L.

I l6-l l/.

Kpr.tuunonv,ctvtro.:

Y.re6Hzr

arF

By3ots

,,

[lo;

peg.

P.C.

6e-

nrnso.

M.:

haAorenucros

rpynno

<HOpi,/rA

-

LIHOPA-M),

r 999.

C.

33.

Kopyxoa

fO.f. Kpr.ttiarro

nlcr^rec<cF

;/3-,ocrHKo

nph

poc-

creAoBoHt4h

npecrynneur i.

Hoys

-

3-^ 33

q-.:!ecKoe

noco6re.

M.: l4s4orenscKoe

rpynno

(HOPl.'A

-

tlHOPA-M),

.l998.

c. r02-103.

t0

tl

Apxraa

Touencroro

o6nocrHc-c

:,,:3

No 09/l

7-02.

Apxra

Trouelcroro

o6nocrtsc-.

:,,:J

YrofoBHoe

Aeno

YronoeFroe

.oeno

No 09/1

7-02.

l2

f'lpoeegexxoe

BoMr

o6o6uterre

-oa<',rK!

noKo3ono,

qro

cneAoBolenh

e

6onsujtll..tcree

crl'.g63

.,3-c:oBnHBotor

$oro-

ro6rrqur

-

nphnoxeHrln

K nporo<o.-:!,

ocr.lorpo Mecro npo-

hcr..!ecr8hs

Ho vepxo-6enoM

rDl-'e3e

Kovecrao nplno-

xerril

xporite

Hh3Koe?

!To ;-/!!ce-

c',:3o3r/oxHocTh

AoTb

o6terrraxyo

oL{eHKy

co6srrro

npec:r

^.-e

*ri.

-

[1puu. oat.

*

Glodyshevo

O.V., Repkin

M.S.

Concepl

ond

Legol Noture

of

Investigotor's

Operotionol

Seorch Activities

oHflTHe

n npaBoBaf,

npnp0fla

po3btcHHbtx

[eHcrBH[

cnefioBareflf,

llo

uuesup

oBropoB,

a n.

38

cr. 5

Yt-\K

PQ ueo6xoahMo

BHecrh

pe1oKllhto,

roK KqK

cqhrotor

HecoBepLueHHoi

Hbt-

H

e

Lu H io to

Q

o

p

uyn u

po

a xy.

The

outhors

believe thot point

3B of

Article

5 of

the

Criminol

Procedure

Code

of

the RF

sholt be omended

because

the

current wording

thereof

is

imperfect.*

b

xoAe

npeABopHrenbHoro

poccneAoBoHZq

Aeqrenb-

HOCTb

CreAOBOTenfl

hMeeT

cBoZM

ocHOBHbtM H03HOLleHheM

ycroHoBfleHhe

h

oTbtcKoHZe nhL{/

nphqocTHblx

K

coBepuleH-

HOMy

npecrynreHhto/

o

roKXe

nonyqeHhe

!oKo3oTerbcrB

r4x

BZHOBHOCTh,

nOCKOIbKy

ronbKo

B

3roM cnyqoe

6yAyr

AOrxHbrM

o6po3oM

3ou-lhuleHbt npoBo

h

3oKoHHbte hHTe-

pecbr

flhl_l

h

oproH/3ol_lhl, noTepneBllhx

or

npecryn,le-

aui,.

C 3roi

qenbro

rocy.qopcrBo

Aenerl

pyer

crreAoBoren|o

LrocTb

cBohx nonHot'ao,]hlz,

B

poMKax

KoTopbtx

yKo30HHbti

enocrHsri

cy6beKr

AocyAe6Horo

npoh3BogcrBo

HogeneH

npoBoM

npoh3BoAcTBo

cneAcTBeHHbtx h hHbrx npoqeccy-

on

bH blx

Aehcr}/;1.

C.

6.

Poccrr-rcKh

i

Cn

paBeAr

h Bo

yrBepx-

..

poccluicKr,rn

ttanobATr

rrb"

yroJroBHblr{

[PorIEcc

_

AOer,

qro

coAepxoH heM npeABopr,lren

bHoro

poccneAoBo-

HhR BBnqloTCr

(po3nhqHbre

caeAcTBeHHbre

AeicTBXg,

hHbte

npoLleccyonbHbre

Meponp|./'qr|/|fl v1

peueHhe

oproHoB

Ao3-

|

Qtlv1e,

n

peABophrenbHoro

cneAqrBhe

h n

poKypopo)

r.

K vracny

cneAcrBeHHbrx

AeXcrBHi

yronoBHo-npoqec-

cyonuuuti 3oKoH orHocvr

n7|u)b ry

trocrb

npoueccyonb-

rrurx

geicrsril

Koropoe npeAHo3HoqeHo

Anq

co6vpoHAe

h npoBepKr-1

AoKo3orenbcre.

Anq

cneAcrBeHHbrx

.qeic-

reri xoporrepHo

AeronbHoe

npoLleAypo npoH3BoAc-

reo

z oSopuneHAfl,

o6ecne,{eHHocrb

yronoBHo-npoqec-

cyonbHblM nprHyxAeHheru2. PogsrcxHue

EeilcrBt4l

-

3ro

rr

ocrb

h H brx

(H

e cne.qcreen n urx) n

po

ueccyon

bH brx

Aeilc:.

Buil,

ynoMhHoeMbrx

3oKoHoAoreneM

B

,{.

I

cr.

|52

ynK

PO.

B

n.

38 cr. 5 YI-IK PO

pocrpusoercr

noHqrhe

po3brcKHbrx

r'aep

(r-ro

He

neicrari)

KoK

Mep,

nphHHMoeMbrx

Ao3HoBore-

neM,

cneAoBoTeneM, o ToKXe

oproHoM

Ao3HoHr4e

no no-

pyqeHhlo

Ao3HoBoTenfl

hnh

cneAoBorene

Ane

ycroHoBfle-

HVn

nhu\o,

noAo3pe8oeMoro B

coBepueHhh

npecrynneHhe.

ilpz rror'l h3

reKcro

3oKoHo

HeflcHo,

ynorpe6nner nh

30-

KoHoAorenb repMhHbr

(po3brcKHbre

Aeicrshq))

h

(po3brc-

KHbre

Mepbr) KoK

chHoHhMsr.

Kpo,rae roro, B Y[lK PO ue

Ho3BoHbr BhAbr

po3brcKHsrx

geicrerrZ,

He

pocrpblBoercn

npoueccyonbuuri nopngo< hx npoh3Bo,qcrBo, He

ornhrro-

ercn

ToriHocrbro h nonHoroi

QopruynrpoBKh

coMo

noHfl-

rhe

yKo3oHHot po3HoBhAHocrh

npoqeccyonbHbrx

Aetrc-

tanil,

o

Ho npoKThKe Bo3HHKoer npo6nel,ro

onpeAeneHht

rx

npoaoaoi nphpoAbr.

YroaosHue

o6croqrenscrBo cronv

npeAMeroM

Avrc-

Kyccvt

yqeHbrx

no

:roi

rer,ae3

r cBhAerenbcrByfor 06 oKry-

ofibHocTH

HoyrrHoro

hccneAoBoHhr Bonpoco o noHATnv

h

r

po

eo

ao i n

p

h

poAe po3

brcKH brx

Aei4cr

Bh;1

cn eAo

Borenfl .

Poasrcro,rl

H03brBoercr

AesrenbHocrb

KoMnereHrHbrx

focyAopcrBeHHbrx

opfoHoB/

HonpoBneHHor Ho

ycroHoB-

neHVe Mecro Hoxox.qeHhfl

h

o6HopyxeHhe

o6BhHeeMbrx,

cKpbrBurr]xc9 oT

cneAcTBhq

v

cyAo; ocyx,qeHHbrx,

yKnoHqlo-

u.lhxcn

or

ncnonHeHte HoKo3oHhq nrz6o

6exoauhx

h3 Mecr

30KnloqeHxfl; nhu, nponoBrurax

6e:

eectu. Ecnh

HeH3Becr-

HO nhuo/

coBepujr,rBuJee npecrynneHre,

To Mepbr no

erc)

ycToHoBneHhlo

BXoAFT B noHFrhe He

po3brcKo,

o

poccne-

AoBoHhfl

h

pocKpbrrxn

npecrynneHhra.

9ro Kocoercq

po-

3bfcKHblx

Aeitcteuil,

To !4x

cMbrcno8oe 3HoqeHhe o6brqHo

cBq3brBoerce c

AefrenbHocTb0

oneporhBHblx

noApo3Ae-

nerNi rocyAopcrBeHHbrx

oproHosr

ynonHoMoqeliHbrx

3cr-

KOHOM HO

npoBe.qeHhe

OnepOThEHO-pO3brCKHbrx

Mepon-

pnntuit.l-locxonuxy

e YtlK PO He

pocKpbrBoercn

noHqrhe

po3brcKHbrx

EehcrBV;1,

B

nhreporype

6srno

BbrcKo3oHo

npeAnonoxeHhe

o

roM/

Lrro

oHo

fBnqeTc9 ToxAecTBeHHbrM

oo3brcKHbrM

MeooMs.

Msr nonoroeM,

flpoBoBon Korerophq

(Mepbr>

hMeer

6 o

n suuit

co,qe

pxoren

bx ur i

o6r,e,ra,

qeM

Kore ro

p

un

<<

ge

i'rc-

rshr).

flo

cBoeMy cMbrcny

Aehcrl'z,q

npe,Qnonoroor co-

RepureHhe

oKTHBHbrx

nocrynKoB

(B

HoureM cnyrroe

B

poM-

KOX npOH3BOACTBO nO

yTOnOBHOMy

genY

v B HOnpOBfieHhh

IlocrhxeHhr

yKo3oHHoi

B

3OKOHe

Uenra).

,[,nn

roro

Llro6bl

ocyulecrBhrb

rorue-nra60.qetcrBhe B npoqeccyorbHoil

Ae-

qTeflbHocrr4,

Heo6xoAhMo B

ycroHoBneHHoM nopfAKe nph-

riqrb coorBercrByroulee

peueHBe. Tox, s

,r.

I

cr.

2i0

ynK

P(D

npegnNcurBoercs,

rlro

ecnh MecroHoxoxAeHhe

noAo3-

peBoeMofo,

o6ehHge^Aoro

Heh3BecrHc,

ro

cneAoBoreflb

nopyeoer

ero

po3brcK

opfoHoM

Ao3HoHr,lel

o

qeM

yKo3br-

Boercs

B nocToHoBneHVV

o

npnocToHoBneHhH npeABoph-

TenbHoro

cfie.qcTBhf

nnh BbtHoct4Tcfl

orAenbHoe

nocroHoB-

neHHe.

f1o:ro,ray poabrcKHbre

Mepbl

cneAyer

poccMorphBorb

ror xerri

KoMnneKc, erntoqotourai KoK

po3brcKHbre

Aeic-

TBhq, ToK h

peueHhfl

o6

rax

ocyulecrBneHVA.

YcroHoaneHre npoaoBo; nphpogbr

po3brcKHbrx Mep

(neicrer,ri

n

peueHzi)

cneAoBorenB

nBnqercn BoxHeiLUei

reoperhqecKoi

h npoKr14.recKo; npo6neMoi, or

po3peue-

Hhfl

KOTOpOi

30BhCgT

MHOrre

OCneKTbr

AeqTefibHOCTh

B

CTO-

Ahh

npeAeophrenbHoro

poccneAoBoHhn.

OrHochrenbHo

STOrO BOnpOCO hMeeTCr

ABO

npOThBOnOflOXHbrx

MHeHtlfl.

Tor,

A.H. 6onoLuoe nonoroer, ero

po3brcKHbre

AeicrBhe

He

orHocrrce

K

qhcfiy

npoqeccyonbHHX, npoBoAe

noponnenb

MexAy

po3btcKHbrMh

r

oneporhEHo-po3brcKHbrMH

Aeic-

tennMr46.

fl

porr,rsononoxHoro

MHeHhfl nphAepxhBoercq

B.A.

CerureHqoB, no3hLplro Koroporo Mbr

po3AeneeM

B chny

cneAyrou{hx

o6crosrenucre.

Bo-nepeurx, yronoBHo-npoueccyonbHbri

sorou

npn-

MO

HO3brBOer

CneAOBOTenR,

KOK, BnpoqeM, H.qO3HOBOTenF,

B

KoqecrBe

cy6r,exro,

ynonHoMoLreHHoro

ocyulecraflFrb

po3brcKHbre,,aepsr.

6yayvN

cy6rerrou

yronoBHo-npoqec-

cyonbHbrx npoaoo-ruoLreur,ri

cneAoBorenb

BblnonHser

$yHrqNro

o6auaeuua,

Ane

Lrero

ocyulecrBneer

npegBoph-

renbHoe

cneAcTBHe

no yronoBHoMy,qefly, nphHhMo9

peuje-

Hhs h npoh3BoAe

po3nr4\iHbre

npoqeccyoflbHbre

Aeilc-rBr1e,

B

roM

qhcne

po3brcKHoro

xopoKTepo.

A aor

nonso,raoqri

no

npoh3BoAcrBy

oneporhBHo-p03brcKHbrx

ueponprnrri

y He-

ro

Her h

6urru

ue Moxer, ToK KoK HeAonycrhMo coBMeule-

Hhe B

oAHoM

nhqe npoqeccyonunoi

SyHrrlNra

o6anneHhq

ra

$yxrrlr,tr

onepol,rBHo-posurcruoi

AeflrenbHocrh.

B

ct.

2

3oroso o6 OP.[ B KoqecrBe ognoi ns

3oAoq

sroro

BhAo

AerTenbHocrh

npoBo3rfl

ouoercff ocyulecrBneHre

po3brcKo

n[Ll,

cKpblBruhxcf or oproHoB

Ao3HoHhqt

cneqcravn

v

cYEo,

yKnoHrroulhxcn

or

yronoBHoFo

HoKo3oHhR, o

roKXe

po3blc-

ro

6e:

eecrh nponoBrrlr4x, Ho

3ro 3oAorlo

peuloercfl

30

poM-

KOMh yronoBHoro

cyAonpoH3BoAcr8o

h He cfleAoBoreneM.

Bo-aropurx,

po3brcKHbre

Mepbr no

ynK

PO ocyulecr-

Bnqorce

Anfl AocrhxeHhn

cneuh$hqecKo;

uenu: Ann

yc-

roHoBneHhe

nhqo, noAo3peBoeMoro

B

coBeplrjeHhh

npe-

crynneHhR. Acxogn h3

3Toro

MoxHo

cAenorb

BbrBoA,

'.rro

peqb

hAer

o

uenh,

hMeouei npoueccyonbusri

xoporrep,

ceqsour-roi

c

pocKpbrrheM

KOHKperHoro npecrynneHhq

h

ycroHoBneHhe,ra

o6croqrenbcTB,

xMelou{rx npoqeccyonb-

HOe

3HOleHhe, O

B

pnAe

CnyeoeB

Bbrcrynotou.lhx

npoqec-

cyonbHbrMh

.qoKo3orenbcrBoMh.

.fl,ocruxenqe

roKoi

qenh

HeBo3MoxHo

rsuru

cnoco6oM,

KpoMe KoK nyreM

npu+nrvll

peruexNi

h ocyqecrBneuun

geitcraui,

raraeoulzx npouec-

cyonbHyro nphpoAy.

B n.

38 cr. 5

Yt-lK P(D

yro:ouo

nhlxb oAHo

Llenb npq-

MeHeHhfl

cfieAoBoreneM

po3brcKHbrx

Mep

-

ycToHoBne-

Hhe

nhuo, noAo3peBoeMoro B

coBepueHhh

npecrynne-

r.rNn.

Buecre

c

reM

oHonr43

n.2,r. I

ra

q.

5 cr.

209

ynK

PO

y6exgoer

B roM,

rrro

po3brcKHbre

Mepbr Moryr

6urrs

npeA-

nphHnrbr h

B

oTHoueHhh cKpbrBuerocq

noAo3peBoeMofo

nnu

o6suusemorr:

nu6o,

ecflh

Mecro

ero

HoxoxAeHhn

He

ycroHoBneHo,

no hHbrM nphrlhHoM.

3aecs cnenyer

yKo3orb

AononHhrenbuuri

opryueHr

e nons:y

ltonoBHo-npoueccy-

onuuoi nphpoAbr

po3brcKHbrx

Mep

-

npegycMorpeHHyro

B

3oKoHe o6qgoHriocru

cne.qoBorenq

nphHqrb Mepbr

no

po-

3brcKy

cKpbrBtxerocq

nogo3peBoeMoro hnh 06e!4Hqeriloro

nr,r6o

ycroxoBneHhto

nhuo,

coBeplxhBlxero

npecrynneH,4

e

AO

npl,1ocro

HoBfl eH

hq

npeABophren

bHoro

creAcrBHq.

Yrolonnrrfi

nPorlEcc

Pogutcrzeoe^

btMtz

nhuoMh

laoryr

6utru

He

rorlbKo

no-

Ao3peBoeMbte

14 o6ehHnet'

ble,

Ho

t4

xeprBbl

npecrynneHzi,

HonphMep,

nph

noxruleHhh

qenoBeKo

(o' 126

YK

PO)

ny-

reM 3oxBoro

A t43blrvl

ero

h3

ecrecrBeHHoi

Ml4Kpocol-th-

onuHoi

cpegbr,

nepeMeu{eHheM

c

Mecro

nocroeHHoro

hnh

BpeMeHHoro

npe6uteoHrn

c

nocneAytoull/M

yAepxoHtaeM

noMhMo

ero

Bonh

B

ApyroM

Mecre'

Tepr'azu

(po3blcKhBo-

eMbre

n14qo)

yxe

ynorpe6ntercr

30KoHoAorener'a

a

'r'

l6

cr.

l82

ynK

PO

KoK

oAHo

hs

uenei

o6urcro'

B rroi

xe

HopMe

yKo3oHo eule

oAHo

qenu

o6ulcro

-

o6uopyxexrae

TOVNOB,

Po:urcrnute

Mepbl

npeAnphHhMororcn

pnn

o6nopyxe-

Hrlf

npeAMeToB,

nhrlHblx

h

hHblx

AoKyMeHToB,

KoTopble

nph-

o6peroror

B

yronoBHoM

Aene

3HoqeHhe

BeulecrBeHHoro

AOKO3OTenbcrBo,

HOnphMep,

noxhuleHHble

L\eHHOCTh/

nh-

6o

goryr.aeurbl,

c

yLleroM

nphcyu-lhx

hM

nph3HoKoB'

YrosoFrHste

o6cronrenucrBo

cBhAererbcrBytor

o

He-

coBepueHcrBe

3o

KoH oAoren

uuoi

Qopruyn

r

poeKh

po3hlc-

KHblx

Mep/

Lrro

Bbt3btBoer

Heo6xogz,rlocrb

h3MeHeH/9

pe-

DoKwA

n.38

cr. 5

YnK

PO, o

hMeHHo:

<38)

possrcrHble

Mepbl

-

peueHhq

h

Ae'crBht

Ao3-

HOBOTeTTR,

CneAoBorerq,

o

ToKXe

oproHoB

Ao3HOHhfl

no

nopyqeHzlo

AO3HOBOTeflR

hnl

cneAoBorenn/

nphHhMoe-

Mbre

h

ocyu{ecTBnfleMble

Ann

ycroHoBneHhF

nhqo/

noAo3-

peBoeMoro

B

coBepueHhh

npecrynneHVA,

AnA

o6nopyxe-

AoKyMeHToB/

hMerou-p4x

3HoqeHhe AtlR

AoKo3blBotlus

o6-

crotrenbcrB,

yKo3oHHbrx

B crorbe

73

nocroqulero

KoAer-

co).

lnoAilrlu'eaoO.B.,

AO$eHr,

KoHAnAat

r,Pnpln'recKnx

HC,yK'

scrae4yrotl4an

xa$egpofi

YnonoBHoro

nPoqecco

,o

P

n

An

q

e cro

ro

Qo

xY n

tr et

a

Ky 6oxcxoro

rocy

AaPcraerroro

yHnBePcuter

o

;

Penxun

M,C.,

gt

cn

up

crrt

Ky 5

o

n

cxo

r o t o

cY

Ad

P

qa

e

H H o

r o

yHnBePcerferC,

Poccrrcrri

C.6.

Yronoensri

npouecc

Poccun'

Kypc

nerqrta'

M..2006.

c.245.

b; ,

C;;*u

B.A.

Cn"s.rBeHHbre Aehctev'n

e

nocyse6-

HoM

npoh3BoAcree

(o6ulhe

noroxeHhe

reophh

h

npoKrflKrlJ'

Moroipodtas.

Erorepu+r6ypr,

2006.

C 26

Cr,l.:

Kocenro

A.C.

Posurcxnute

Aeicrehq

B

coBercKoM

yro-

;;;";

"p;;".i",

y*0.

noco6r,.e.

Xo6opoecx,.

1.989;

oH

xe.

OoroHhsoul'le

h

roKrhKo

po3blcKHblx

Eei'ctenir''

Y're6

no-

co6re.

Xo6opoecr,

1992;

CereHuoe

B

A

Po:src<nure Aeic-

ir* .n"oot,j.

ena

i f

Poccracrri

cneaoeorens

2004

Np

l

2'

C.2-5;

n

sp.

Cr,a.:

6onuruoi

toprArqecrri

cnoBopb

/

l-1oa

pea' A9

Cy-

xopeBo,

B.E.

KPyrcrnx

M,2003

C 534

C,ti., e"""-u"r'B

A Cn"a.-ue4Fbe

ae;c-Bhn

C

ll7'

Cr,a.:

6onoLuos

A.H.

BaoNruoaeicrehe

cneAoBorerlF

14

opro-

HoB

Ao3HoHhe

nph

poccneaoRotsHf

npecryn

nesuil'

M

'

1979

c.20

Hhr

po3blcKl,lBoeMblx

nl4q

h TpynoB,

o

ToKXe

npeAMeroB

h

ffipoaneMbt

trHocoqilarlbnofi Aerepu

r HaqH

]l

yroflo8H0-npoqeccyarlbH0r0

[0Ha3blBaHHf

Hct ocuoae

AhcceproLJhoHHoro

hccneAoBoHhs

B.A.

[-]ououqpeHKoBa,

YronoBHoro

3oKaH9aorenbcrBo

h

BbtcKo3bt

,ni

suAuttx

ytteHux

ouroi

u:ori,

6onee

AerenbHe

,43yqoer

npo6neuoruKy

irHocou,rlonauod

+erepMhHQut4h

yronoBHo-

n

p

o

rJeccYo

n bH o

ro

AoKo3

bt BQ

H he.

On

the bosis

of

V. A.

Ponomorenkov's

dissertcttion

reseorch

of criminal

leqislotion

ond

observottons

of

leoding

scholors

the outhor

qives

t detoiled

study

of

ethnic

socioil

dJ"riiiitii,

of

proving

ii criminol

procedure'*

B Hocroqutel

hccrleAoBoHhx

tusr

o6porrfl'1cb

K

poc-

cMorpeHt'1to

reMbt,

HecMorpfl

Ho

nonBrleHhe

po6or,

npeg-

MeroM

Koropblx

yxe 3qnBnnflocb

poccMorpeH'e

Morlo-

h3yLreHHblx

B

TeopeT/LlecKoM

h npoBonp/MeHHTenbHoM

nnoHe 3oKoHO,r,tepuocrei

lrHocouhonbuoi

perepmruo-

uh14 AoKo3brBoHZr

B

c$epe

yrorloBHoro

cyAonpo/3BoA-

ctaol.

Butcrynon

HeoSrulonuHblM

onnoHeHToM

nph 3ou1h-

re orMeqeHHoi

gzcceprollhh

Ho 3oceAoHhh

Ahccepro-

uhoHHoro

coBero

tr229.004.01

npu

QeaeponbHoM

rocy-

AopcrBeHHoM

o6posoeorelbHoM

yqpexAeH/'1

BblcLuero

n

p

o

d

e cc

I

o

r-r o

n b

H

o

ro o 6

p

o s

o

a

o

H r'r

n

<

Bn o

gra

u

r

p

cru

i' a

p u

-

aveecKlil

uHcrtrYr

Oegeponsnoi

cnyx6ur

h cnonHeHhn

roro3orui>

17

uon6pa

2008

r', oarop

o6porzn

BHhMo-

*

Ziukov

A.M.

Problems

of

Ethnic

Sociol

Determinolion

o{

Hhe

Ho

ro,

ttro

npeAMer

!4ccneAoBoHhn

He Obln

pocKpblr

B norHoM

o6le,r,re

B.A

llosouopeHKoBblM

B 3oeBneHHot

Ahccepror.lhoHuoi Po6ore.

Kor

hgeecrHo,

geicrayrou'lee

yronoBHo-npoueccyoJr

b-

Hoe 3oKoHoaorenbcrBo

e cr.

73

ynK

PO

so<pennner

o6-

crogTen

bcrBo,

noAnexo

ulhe

AoKo3blBoH

l'1

to'

ziraeiruo

Ho :rr

o6croFTenbcrBo/

30KpenneHHble

B 30-

KOHe,

HO HOt!

B3rnfA,

h creAoBono

onzporbcfl

oBropy

Ao-

KTOhHOn

bHOro

hccneAoBo

Ht'I9

Bon

pocos aru

ocouhon

uFlo

i

AerepMhHol-lhh

yronoBHO-npoLleccyorlbHoro

AOKO3blBo-

srs.

Teu

He MeHee

Hh oAHo

h3

nonoxeHhi,

estueceuuutx

HO 30u-lhry,

He

pocKpblno

nepeA

HoMt1

oBropcKyo

n03h-

uhlo

roro,

qro

cneAyer

oTHOChTb

K 3OgBneHHoMy

npeAMe-

TV l,lCCrleAoBoHhR.

Proving

in Criminol

Procedure

<.

pocclilicKufr

CJTEAOBATEJTb>

Гладышева О,В., Репкин М.С. Понятие и правовая природа розыскных действий следователя

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.