The sculptor toiled on the refractory material for two and a half
years; with heroic labor he drew from it, using every inch of its
height, his David. On January 25, 1504, the Operai assembled a
council of the leading artists in Florence to consider where Il
gigante, as they called the David, should be placed: Cosimo
Roselli, Sandro Botticelli, Leonardo da Vinci, Giulano and Antonio
da Sangallo, Filippino Lippi, David Ghirlandaio, Perugino, Giovanni
Piffero (father of Cellini), and Piero di Cosimo. They could not
agree, and finally they left the matter to Michelangelo; he asked that
the statue be placed on the platform of the Palazzo Vecchio. The
Signory consented; but the task of moving The Giant from the
workshop near the cathedral to the Palazzo took forty men four days; a
gateway had to be heightened by breaking a wall above it before the
colossus could pass; and twenty-one additional days were spent in
raising it into place. For 369 years it stood on the open and
uncovered porch of the Palazzo, subject to weather, urchins, and
revolution. For in a sense it was a radical pronunciamento, symbol
of the proud restored republic, stern threat to usurpers. The
Medici, returning to power in 1513 left it untouched; but in the
uprising that again deposed them (1527) a bench thrown from a window
of the Palace broke the statue's left arm. Francesco Salviati and
Giorgio Vasari, then lads of sixteen, gathered and preserved the
pieces, and a later Medici, Duke Cosimo, had these fragments put
together and replaced. In 1873, after the statue had suffered
erosion from the weather, David was laboriously transferred to the
Accademia delle Belle Arti, where it occupies the place of honor as
the most popular figure in Florence.
It was a tour de force, and as such can hardly be overpraised; the
mechanical difficulties were brilliantly overcome. Esthetically one
may pick a few flaws: the right hand is too large, the neck too
long, the left leg overlong below the knee, the left buttock does
not swell as any proper buttock should. Piero Soderini, head of the
republic, thought the nose excessive; Vasari tells the story-
perhaps a legend- how Michelangelo, hiding some marble dust in his
hand, mounted a ladder, pretended to chisel off a bit of the nose
while leaving it intact, and let the marble dust fall from his hand
before the Gonfalonier, who then pronounced the statue much