Быков В.М. Проблемы обеспечения права обвиняемого на защиту
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
POCCVTCKAg
pq[lu![
y|o^oBHbrz
nPouECC
Na 1Ol2009
l.l
,ll
4l
ti
t6
.17
Ilv,rnrrcxr,"
B.K. lpaxaaHcKr.rii
rpouecc
CIUA.
M., 1985.
C. 17.
BHelteuxorlrpaxlaHcKoMnpouecce-BnporoKoJreorpaxarorcqHeBcexo.qararicrna;
cv. n.4g5afpaxgaHcroronpoueccy;Lrlbrroro
y,'roxeHur
lbplraxrn.
M., 2006.
Attr,nuiiCxttt"t
rpaxnaHcruii
npouecc
AonycKaer
yCrHoe
o6oCHOBaHrrc
peucHtllt
ripn
rBKe
cTopoH, HeuCUxur)i
-
no3Bo,,rrcr 14clcqIO,rriTr,
oflucaTcjlbHylo
Il
MoTl{BHpoBotlHyIo
qacTb.
eCJTLI ocHoBHatl
rlacTb
npoueccyturbHLIXIei'iCTBI4}.i
oTpaxeHa
B npoToKone.
Paccrto'rpeHtre
N{cJlK}.tx
HcKoB
Bo
<D_p_aHunr.r,
n lcpvaunn,
Btr4Tanvil, e.flnoHun,
B HeKoropbrx
urarax
n C1IIA,
Enponelicral njroueaypit
no
paccr'lorpcHurc
MeJ'rKt4x
ucxos
ESCP.
I)occur:icxa.q
ocrnut{n,
1997.
N9 6.
C.4.
Ilonr,rii
fIIK
OpaHuuu.
M.,
2004;
cN{. raKxe r.r3r{eHcHuq:
http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/homcjsp
B ancrpur:icroM
rpaxllaHcKoM
npoqecce
HeBo3r\'roxHo
(sa
ueroropurM r{cK,'rrcrreHileu)
o6parueHne
BTperr,ro
r{r{craH11firo noacr,ra},r
co
croilIlocrblo
I4cKa
ao
4 rr.lc.
cll-po.
Cv.: Ilponep_xa
cy.ue6nr'lx
nocraHoBreHr.rJ
B rpaxnaHcKoM
npoucccg
crpan
E,C u CHf
/
norr
pcl.
E.A.
Iioprlconoil.
M., 2007.
C. 26
(anrop
r,ranrr
rDpayerr6cprcp-[r$aii,rep
V,rrplrxe).
G.Lcbovits
Special
Procedures
Apply
to Enforcing
Judgments in
Small Claims
Courts
//NY
State BarJournal
1999,
January.
p.
30"
l locr,rpena
E.14.
A,rsrepHarfiBHoe
pa3pcueHue
cnopou
s C[IA.
Ar.rcc.
...
aoKr.
ropH,{.
uayr.
BopoHcx,
2001.
C.226_227 .
NPOENEMbI
OEECNEqEHNg
3) no,ro:rpe
naeMbl
ii, o6BuHfl
eMbri.i
n c il,ry
$u:lluecxu
x
I{-TI II
N C I1
XI4
LI
CC K I,IX H
ENOCTATKO B
H E MO)KCT
CAM OCTO'ITEJI b}I O
oc),uecTB_rtflTb
cBoe npaBo
Ha 3aur{Ty;
.1)
c),le6noe
pa36nparenbcrBo
npoBoAr.rrcrr
B noprrA-
Ke. Irperycr\{orpe
HHoN,r
q.
5 cr. 247
ynK
PO
(B
3roir cra*
'rbe
peqb
H.4eT
o c,[yqaflx,
KofAa
cyne6Hoe
pa36r.rparerrbcTBo
n
por
rcxonHT
B
orcyTcTRHe
no.tlcy-tt4
Mofo)
:
5)
noao:penaeMbrii,
o6susseurri;i
Fre B.rraaecr
rr3r,rKot\,r.
I.Ia KOTOpOM
BeAeTC'
npou3BoAcTBo
no
yroj'roBr{oMy
Aeny;
6)
,ruuo o6BnHrercl
B
coBeplrreHlltr{
rpeolvrr"rre
HwA, 3a
KOTOpOo
MO)K9T
6lrrl Ha:rraqeHo
HaKa3aHtle
B BUAe
,rrr{trre-
Hr,rfl
cBooonbr
Ha
cpoK
cBb[ue
nrTHaAuaTu
JreT, noxr43HeH-
HOe
Jl14llleHt4e
cBo6oAbr
t{Jrr4
cMepTHafl
Ka3Hb;
7)
yrononnoe
aero
noArexr4r
paccN{orpeuHrr
cy.[oM c
y9acTHeM
npHcrrxH
brx
3acenaTeneil
'
8)
o6nnulevbrii
3arBnn
xoAaraiicrBo
o
paccMorperruu
yfonoBHofo
Aena
B
nopqAKe,
ycTaHoBJreHHo\4
fnaBor.i 40
ynK
PO
(pevr
r.rner
o6
oco6orlr
ropqrlKe
cvae6Horo
Da3-
6upare.trcrna).
Kro
xe
orrJraqr4Baer
B Hacroflrrlee
BpeMfl Bce
pacxoAbr
tra
3aull{rrrr.rKa?
B
coorsercrBr.il4
c
rr.
3 cr.
5l
ynK
P(D,
ec,ru
3aur4THHK
He npnrnaueH
caMuM rroAo3peBaeMb|\,1,
o6Bu-
HgeMbtM,
ero 3aKoHHbrM
rpeAcTaBr.{TereM,
a
TaKXe
Apyrtr_
MH
JII{UaMI4
nO nopyr{eHvIIo
l4Itu
c cof,rtacug
ltoAo3peRa-
eMorO,
O6BI4IIfl
eMofo,
To
AO3HaBaTeJTb,
CneAOBaTer'tb I1,.t14
cyn o6ecneqr.rBaeT y(racTr4e
3arIIilTHt1Ka
B
yfonoBHOM
cyAo-
[por,r3r]o.qcrBe.
A
xar
ycrarragJ'rr.rBaer
q.
5
cr.
50
yflK prf:,
B CJ'ryqae,
ecJ'rr4
aABoKaT
yqacTByeT
B npor'{3BoAcTBe
npeABa-
pr,rTetr
blr
oro
paccneAoBaH
t4fl trIrul
cyAebHoM
pa36
x
paTeJr
b_
CTBO IIO
rIa3HaqeHfiIO
AO3HaBaTeJ-rq,
CIeIIOBaTe,tfl
tIItI4 Cy-
Aa,
pacxoAbr
Ha
onnaTy
ero
TpyAa KoMneHct4pyroTcr
3a crreT
cPeAcrs
OeAeparrnoro
6roAxera.
Ha
naru
B3f,rIuA,
Bo Bcex
cJ'lyqaflx,
KofAa noao3peBae-
ulr11,
o6nnHqeMbr
ii flBrfl
er cfl
HecoBeprreHHo,TerHr,rM,
h,t 14
B cr{ny
$l.reuuecrlrx
tl,rrr,t
fic],rxr4qecKux
HeAocrarKoB
He r\.{o-
xeT caMocTorrTeJ'rbHo
ocyulecTBJrrTb
cBoe npaBo
Ha 3ax{r1Ty,
L1J1t4
He
BJraAeeT
g3brKoM,
Ha KOTOpOM
BeneTcfl nporl3BoAc_
TBO
rr0
yronoBHoMy
Aeny,
To r.r3
ryMaHHbrx
coo6pa)KeHui4
orurlaTa
aIBOKaTa
AOnXHa
npoI,I3BOAt{TbCq
3a crleT
cpeAcTB
Qe4epanrHoro
6ioAxera.
OqesraAuo,
qro
yKa3aHHa.s
Bbrure
Kareropl.ur
rroao3pe-
BaeMbrx,
o6Br4HfleN,{b1x
oco6eHuo
ocrllo
Hvx/'lzlercl
B
oKa-
NPABA
OEB14HgEMOrO
tl
HA
3Ar4UTy
B.\1.
EblKOB.
.roxrop rcpnlnqecKrrx
ua1.x, npoQeccop
K't
nqeeue
c.toe
a : odeoxam
-3(t
ulum
H uK, o6asu
mettouoe
yltoc-
nlue
3aL4umHuKa,
uHue
rtu40
KoK 3OU4UnqUKU,
OnKA3
Om 30_
ulumtruKo.
B cmamue poccilampusctomca
aKmyarwute
npo6iteuot
sa-
ttlu ttt t't
o 6e
u u st e a
o e o :
tt d e o rc
a m 3 a
u4 u m H u rc,
o6n sa m
et t o Ho
e
y
14
a c
-
tnue
3dtqumHuKa,
urrde
nu4a
KaK
3Ot4UmuUKU,
OmKA3
Om
3oulumttuKe.
Aemop
npedtaeaem
nymu
cosepwencmeo6anu,n
3q-
t(olt].
Tltere
are
considered
in
the orticle
lhe actual
problems
of cle-
fe.nlant
defcnse:
counsel
Jbr
the
clefense,
binding'participation
of
clefender,
other
persons
as
defenders
ond refusal
of ctefeider,
The
oullnr
proposes
the
ways
of low
improvement.
B
cr. 48 Koscrnryunu
PtD
yrca:urBaercfl!
rlro
KDKnbrr:i
3aAep)KaHHbrx,
3aKrroqeHHurfi
no4
crpaxy,
o6nunseutrfi
B
COBep[reHUr4
rrpecTyrureHr4rr
uMeeT
npaBo
ro,rrb3oBaTb-
crr lorvror.ltF,rcl
aABoKara
(:autrrulrca)
c voveHra
coorBerc-
TBCrIrrO
3a.4epxaHr{fl,
3aKrrnqerrr4rr
froA
cTpaxy
r{nr{
npeAb_
g
IJ.rreH
14l
06Bfi lteH
ut.
B
coorsercruill,r
c
groii
KoHcr],rryur4oHHori
HopMorl
B
rr.
3
.r.
4
ct. 46
l.r B
n. 8
\. 4
ct.
47
ynK
P(D
ycrauoureuo,
rrro
noAo3pegaelrsrri
n 06BuHqeMurii
l.ruercr
rpaBo
nonb_
3OBtlr'r,crj
anr
cBoet{
3atuxTbt
I]oMo[tbro
3auII{T]lr{Ka,
B
Tor\,t
rrtrrcr.re
6ecn-ryargo
B
cnyqaqx,
npeAycMorpegutrx
yIIK
lro.
B
.1.
I cr.
5l
ynK
P{D
ycranan,ruBarorcr
cJtyqar4,
KofAa
yq
acT il
e 3a[I HTHH
Ka
B
y
f on
oBHoM
CyAO frpor4
3 BOACTBe
TT B,'rfl
_
clcri o6q:lareJ'r
bHbtM:
l)
iloaorpeBaeusri.i,
o6snHser,{srii
He
orKa3rurcfl
or 3a-
u{nru14Ka
B nopqAKe, ycraHoBneHHov
cr.
52 YllK
PcD;
2) no4o:penaenrtri.i,
o6BuHrreN,{lril
ssnsercs
HecoBep-
IIJCI I }IOJ'IETHI,IM:
'
.*
Ne
10/2009
yfoAoBHbrr,l
nPouECC
ffitrg
3auvtu
l4M
HaAnexaueli
lpanouor.i
l.r
cor{traqtuoji
nouo_
u{r4,
Koropyro
oH14
He BcefAa
l,roryr
ce6e
o6ecnevr.r.ll
3a
cqer
co6crseuublx
cpeAcrB.
Kporr,re
roro,
(De4epulrrbHbrM
3aKoHoM
p<D
or 29
urcHrl
2009
r. Nq
l4l
-{D3
<,O
sHeceHt4t{
usN4eHeHr4i,i
n
Vro,ronulrji
KoAeKc
Poccniicroii
{Deaepauuu
u
Vrolorluo-rpoueccy_
a,t I
Hlrii
KoAe
Kc
POcgl
r)icxoii
(DeAepa4
r.1.r,t
u
poccu
iic
roe
yronoBHoe
cyAonpou3BoACTBO
BBeAen
HOSlrri
l.tHcTr{TyT
_
oco6rru
[opqAoK
rlprrHflrvfl
cyAe6uoro peueHr.rlt
np].r
3a-
Kn Ioq
0HI,I t{
AocyAe$Ho
rc
co UrarrreHlr{
o coTpV.[H
r4rtecTae
l.
B
yn
K P<D
seeaeHa
HoBa,r
rraBa
40.
l.
rbropafl
perJ.ra-
MeHrr.{pyer
oco6uil
nopqAoK
lpvHnrwr
cy4e6Horo
peue_
II14q rtpu
3a]a'rroqeHr.tt4
4ocyge6noro
cor,rralreHt{r
o corpyA-
HHqecrBe.
3ra
ra
caMarr
cAerKa
c npaBocynr.reM,
o xoropoil
aallHo
IIr{czulocb
B neqaTr4
t4 loBopr{nocb
Ha
pa3nr,rqHbrx
Ha_
yrlHbrx
(ropyuax,
no3ToMy
MHofr4e
cneqr,ril,'rr4crb1 yroxoB-
HOIO
npaBa
14
rrpouecca
c nHT.epecoM
BcTpeT[Jil4
rrpr,rHrTr4e
HOBOIO
3aKOHa.
B
veu
cyrt
HoBoro:axoua?
l:rasHaq
r4ner
HoBoro
3aKo-
Ha,
Ha Harrl
B3rIrA,
3aKllr.OqaeTcs
B ToM,
rrTo
ecJIl,{
O6er4Hrre_
N,tr,rti
saKnroqlrr
co
cropoHor?
o6srlueHur
B nr{ue
lpoKypopa
coD'raureHtre
o coTpyAH
r.rqecTBe
B rrepr,roA
npeABapt{t.ejlbHofo
cJrleAcTBUq,
TO
Mepa
HaKa3aHU.q
npv
HuIVl.9t4Ll
CMflIqaruUI[X
o6croqrertcrB
B coorBercrBrdi{
c u. 2
cr. 62yK
p<D
ne
Nroxer
n
peBbtuaTb
IIoJro
Br{H
br MaKcr4Ma[
b]roro
cpoKa
H aKa3aH
Hfl .
B
csqsr4
c 3rtrM
cr.5
YflK
p@AorolueHa
n.61,
rco-
'ropbli.i
onpeAenser
HoBoe u
HanSo,ree
cyuiecrBeHHoe
Mfl
yfoJroBHofo
cyao[por.I3BoAcTBa
rroHrrT],{e
_
AocyAe6Hoe
cofnatueHr4e
o corpyAHuqecrge.
llo/i
3Tr,rM
Il HoBoM
3aKoHe
fi O HI'IM
aeTc'
<(cor,[alu
e HI4
e
Me)Kny
CTOpOH
aN.{]t
O6su He
H us
I,t
3a[lt4Tbt,
B
KOTOpOM
yKa3aHFIble
cTopoHbt
cof,.tacoBbil]atoT
ycnoBr4q
orBercrBeHH
ocrr4 n
o/Io3pe
Baer\{o
ro l4,r
lr o6sr4
tr fl e
_
Mor-o ts
3aBr.{cr,rMocrt4
or ero
AeiicrRni.i
nocle
noa6yxAeHut
yf
or't oBl{oro
nelra
u
ltr4 n
peAbqBJreHuq
oSnlr ne
H r,rx'>.
flo nonovy
3aKoHy
3arrIr4THHK
rroAo3peBaeMoro,
o6nu-
HreMoro
-
arllrnHltii
yqacrHr.tK
HoBoro
r.rucrnryra.
Tarc,
,r.
I cr.
317-l
ynK
P{D
ycrauauJ'rr.{Baer,
qro
xonarat4crBo
noAo3peBaeMoro,
o6Br.ru.aeMoro
o 3aKrrcr{eHr.rr,r
Aocyre6Ho-
ro
corJralueHr.rrr
o corpyAH14qecrBe
co cropoHoii
o6aHHeHilq
IIO.4III{CbIBAETCq
TAICKC
3AUTI4THI4KOM,
A
ECTU 3AIUI,ITIII4K
HE
n
pr.r
rJr
au eH
caN{r4
M rroAo3peBaeMbrM
tr,rr
r.{ o6ell
Hrr
etu ll N,r, ro
yq
acrlIe
3anInTHI4Ka
o6ec
neql.rRaercq
cr e4oBare,rreM.
B
coorsercrBr4r.{
c
q.
4 cr.
317-l
ynK
PO
3aul.lrHr,rK
floAo3pegaeMoro,
o6nuuleMor.o
[on)
j]4n
lpaBo
o6xa,ro-
Barb
rrocraHoBJ'reHlre
cJreAoBareJ.rfl
o6 orxa:le
B
yAoBnerBo-
pe
H r.r l,t
xogarailcrna
o
3aKr roqeH
l.r l,r,{ocyAe
6Horo
couraue
-
Hr4tr
o
corpyAHr4qecrBe.
3aulllrHnr
raKxe
noJ'ryrrr.tn
rpaBo
o6xa,ronauur
[ocraHoBJtel:an
rrpoKypopa
o6
orra:e
s
yAoBnerBopeHuu
xolarai4crtsa
o 3aK,q to9eHr.u4
4ocyAe6Horo
colraueHr,rfl
o
corpyAHr4qecrue (v.
2
cr. 317-2
ynK pO).
B
q,{.
I u
3 cr.
317
-3
yflK
PO
ycraHaBnr{Baercfl,
rrro
Aocy-
AeOHoe
coriraueHr{e
o corpyAHfiqecrBe
cocraBnqercn
rpu
y
gacrvv
3aur4TH
14 Ka
n oAo3pe
BaeMoro,
o6nuu
fl elr oro.
Stor
AOKyMeHT
3aUIr,rTHHK
TaKXe noArrr,rcbrBaeT,
HapflAy
c npo_
KypopoM,
rroAo3peBaeMbtM
urrr4
o6snur{eNltr
N,r.
B
Aan
su
eiiueM
3arur4THr,r
Ky
rroAo3peBaeMoro,
06 Br4 Hfl
-
eN,Ioro
.qoJ'rxHa
6rrrl
npyveua
Konl4fl
rrpeAcraBneHr4rr
ilpo-
Kypopa
o6 oco6ou
nopqAKe
npoBeAeHur
cyAe6Froro
3ace-
AaHHfl
n BbrHeceHr.rx
cyne6Horo
perueHlrfl
tro
yronoBHoM]i
)\eily
14 rlpe/locraBneHo
He MeHee
rpex
grreil
An.s
o3HaKoM-
IeHufl
c 3rl,lM
AoKyMeHroM
(.rv.
3 r.r 4 cr.
317-5
ynK
PO).
B Hosor\a
3aKoHe
yKa3brBaercs,
rrro
cyaesHoe
3aceAaHr,re
rrpoBoar4Tcrr
c o6qsare,rlHbtM
yqacrr4eM
noAcylu4Mofo
r4 ero
3autxrHr{Ka
(u.
2 cr.
317-7
ynK
PO).
Kax
nllAuo
I43
KparKor.o
atrar'tfi3a
npaBoBofo
Ilo,toxe-
Irr4l
3aururlrtrKe
rrpr4
oco6ol,r
[opqAKe
ilprrHtrrvg
cy4e6lo_
ro
pe[re
H r4q
ilpil
3ara,'lorleH
r4r{
AocyAe6soro
cor
ra[reHr,{rl
o
coTpynH
I4r{eCTIte, pon
b
3aut4Tl
il{
Ka BeCbMa
:lHarll4Te,rtbHa
B
AeJ're
3arrlr4Tbr
3aKOHHbrX
rrpaB
u uHTepecoB
nolo3peBac_
Moto,
o6BltHfieMofo.
3r0
Aaer
HaM
ocHollaFrur
rocraBu,rb
tsonpoc
o roM,
.{ro6uI
yLlacrtle
3arullrHilKa
B
3ToM HoBoM
tlllcrl4Tyre
ilo
3aKouy
.IIOJIXHO
6l,trr,
o6.q:are,rlbHbtM,
t{ 3a-
KoHonareJTn
c.ueAyer
BHecrr.{
o6
croN{
coorBercrltvl.ouue
AotroJrHenr.ifl
u
cr. 5i
yllK
P@.
Ha
uaru
B3r,'rrrA,
rrollo3peoaeMlrii,
o6nuHlclltrii,
roraa
3aKlr
rorl
aeT
c rr
po
KypopoM
co
fJl
au
eI{ r.{e
o coTpyAH rl
rr
e cTBc,
t'o
reM
caMblM,
6eper
ua
ce6rr
o6l:laHHocrr,r
lo oKa3al{lrto
corei4
crBr.i rr
cropoHe
o6s
r H eH t4
q
B
ltoJ'r H oM
pacKp
br.r.t{ td
npecly[neHt{rr
u BbrrrB,rre}{uu
Bcex
ero coyqacrHurou,
"lar
KaK
3To
s
arlltuei.irxeM HepeAKo
Moxer
6lrrb
cnr:laHo
c
yf-
po:oi.i
ero
xti3Hll
I,t 3AopoBbto,
To
qeJ'IoBeK,
3ax,tto.g.tutut1.i
TaKOe
C0lnaueHue,
TaKXe
AOr'r)KeH
nonyqilTb
npaBo }ta
oft_
irary
3aruLtrr{r4Ka
3a cqer
cpeAcrn
$eaepa-nlHoro
6rcnxera.
lloarouy
Ha
3arur4THl.rKa
noAo3peBaeMoro,
o6nrrsqelrolo
l
3ToN{
cJryqae
Aon)KHbr
6urr no,ruocrbro
pacflpoc.tpatrerrbl
uopMbr.t.
5 cr.
50
yflK
PO
o6 onrare
3A[lllHnKa
3il crrcr
cpeAcrB
@egepa,r
luoro
6rcAxera.
Kro
urnle
no
4ei.icrnyroqeMy
3aKoHy
){o)rier
oc}xrecr-
BJ'Isrb
3aur{Ty
rroAo3peBaeMoro
ll o6nllrrqerroro?
uacrl
2
cr.
49
VflK PtD
ycraHanlrrr4Baer,
Lrro
B KalrecrBe
3aut{r}lll-
KOB
AoilycKaroTcrr
anBoKaTbr,
a fro
orpele-]eHilro
lr-ttr ftoc_
TaHoBJ'teHuto
cyla
r'rorlr
6trru
,1on)'uteHbr
Haprr-t\r
c a.ilBo-
KaroM
oIIUH
n:
6,q il:lrlrx
polcrBe
ri H
I r xos oSsrr H.qelroro
lr,rr lr
I4Hoe
Jnruo,
o
jtonvcKe
Koropofo
ro.talaircrtl,'er
o6suutre-
Itrtt:r.
tranee
3aKoH
\1Ka3brBaer.
qTo
|Io
),fo.]oBHbr\r
^ileJrat\{,
Koropbre pacct\rarpritsaer
utrpoBor:i
cyxbq.
).'Ka3aHHoe
nuuo
noilycKaeTcg
BMecro
axBoKaTa.
3 noc,rensee
Bpeiu.q
B
ropuJrlrte
cKorr .rlti.cparype
Bce
qaule
cTiutt{
IIoqB,rl'tTbct
npenno)KeHll'I
HeKoTOpbtX
ioptlc-
ToB
o roM,
.{ro6br
3aulury
B
c.vnax
ocyuecrBr'tr,'u4
ucK[]o-
qt4TeJlbHo
aABoKarbr.
Tarc,
uanpr.rl,rep,
C.fl. Xe,rro6pr.oxon
Ilo,Tafaer,
qro
uerecoo6pasHrrl,r,
<qro6br
B cyAe
uHTepe-
Cbl rIOACyAI4
MOto
3aull.l UIaJI
LIcKr'tIoLI
I4TeJ.r bH
O a4tOral
6e:
y\acrrrfl
6,rttsxt{x
polcrBe
H
H u KoB
I,L'II,I Lt Ft bt
x Heu3BecrH
bt x
nl{{
(uoxer
6rrru n
yqacrHilKoB
npecryrrneHfiq
u,[r4 }{Mero-
utlx
cyAI4Mocrr),
o
AolycKe
Koropbrx
Moxer xo4araiicrno-
BaTL
[OnCyAI4Mbtfi>].
Kax
sau
cJreAyer
orrrecrr.rcr,
K
arrlM lpe4.loxeuurna?
flpo6nerrla
Bcl,
KaK
MbI
ee roH14MaeM,
3aKrrrrorrerercr KaK
pa3
He
B ToM,
ulo
saruury
6yAy'r ocyuecrBJtlrb
KaKue
-ro
<<r.{Hbre
HerJBecrHble
rr,rua>>,
KaK tr14iuel06
oroN{ C.11. )Ke,rro6pro-
xou.
flpo6,reMa,
Ha
Haru B3m.rrA,
3aKJ'uoqaercrl
ts roM,
rrro-
6nt
cy4,
AonycKarr
r,rHbtx
J'rr.rq K 3aul{Te
o6nr.trsel,roro, l,rNterr
Bo3MoxHocrb
Bbtrcntrrb
u
y6eiluttcfl.
B ToM,
a o6,raAator
n L{
3Tx .rtl,t
qa
AocTaTo.rno
ir
rcpuA r{r{e
cKoii xnarruQlrxaU
u
e it
14
onbrroM
lopr.rAr.rqecKofi
pa6oru.
Anase
oHt{ B KaqecrBe
3arrr.{T
H 14 Ko B
6y
ny
t
wt
q
o6
s 14
u x e nr
o ro co Be
p
rx
e H H o 6 e c rt o
-
Jrte3Hbr,
r{
oH
prrcKyer
oc-rarbcq
npaKTl.tqecKu
6e: raxori-,rn-
6o
ropr.rglrvecxofi
novourr.r.
C
4pyrofr
cropoHbr,
He,rrr,3.rr
raKxe
ilrHopupotsa.rb 14
t.o
o6crolre,r
lcruo,
Ltro,TI,t
qo,
rpl4
n't a tttetlH oe o6
su u
ge
lt i,t I,t
B KaqecrBe
3arqt{lHt{Ka,
[onb3yercfl
efo oco6br\,r
noBepu-
elt.
Or sToro
nI{Ua
o5s}iHqeN,{lIti
paccquTbrBaeT
rrojtvrl4lb
He
cToJ-tbKo,
Mo)KeT
6ltrt,
rcpl.t4flqecKyto
ltoN,torub,
cKo,'tb-
Ko
q
l{cro
rrcr{xoJ'torr{q
ecKyro noaAepx
Ky. 14 me u no
yq
r4Tbr
-
Bafl
3Tl'r coo6paxeutrfl,
3aKoHonare,rlb
He
Ao,'txeH,
Ha ltarl
83fJ'ttIA,
JIII[rarb
o6suHqevoro
rpaBa
npxfnauarb B
3aqilT-
HI4
Kr4
poncrBeH
H r,rKotl,
3HaKoM
blx r4
6Jr r.r3 Kr4x ev
y,'r
rcAe ti.
f#:i,lrol
fi* r'
"'-
t!
. *t"; :
FOCCr-1hCKA9
locT${_l,ltl
yfonoBFrbrt4
nPOL}ECC
:l; ii),'20(19
Orrra-ro
H KaqecrBo oKa3btBaeMoi4
npt'l 3ToM
Iopl.ri1il-
,rccroi:r
nr)Morril{ TaKXe He
Ao,ryxlio
crpa.[.arb,
l,I 3Ta K]pt4-
JlrdrregKaJl
froMomb
aoJlxua
6r,trr
loclarorllJo
rnalltrflt-
rtr'rponanuoii, r{Harre o6surrrrerMrlii
pucryer
oc'rartcfi
6e:]
pearlrroii
ropxrr.r4(recKoir
:laulu'rsr. A
g'roro
cyA
HUKaK Ile
.rl0,rtxc
Fr
Jl0rr
yc
K:trr,.
llaccnarplrnaeruax npo6leMa
Moxer 6u rt
peureua,
ec-
Jl14 3aKOHO/IaTe"[b
8OCIIOJIb3ycrcrr rreKOTOpbtMl.I npeAJIOXe-
lJ
H fl l\.r
14,
c/Ie,'iarlrr
br M r..{ B
oAHofi
I{3
3alrll4
ulel{ H
br
x
At{ccep-
'iartur:i
.
'lar<,
A.B. Op:rou srto,rHe o6ocuoBaur.ro,
Ha LIaII
rJrr-rrrjr. nperiraraer,
'lro6r,r
cy,t,
perrrart
Bonpoc o
ronycKe
||ilhrx
.rttllt B KarlecTfle 3aIIII{THHKoB, t4HTepecoBa,rlcq
TeM,
xuxoii x-rplr:tu,recrcoii norrororxoir u xua,rurfnrauneii o6-
_rii
i3e
i -!ilrl(i. riDeTeH,rt)'niltee l{a
po.jfii
3aulHl}r14Ka, IrMeeT
,nr
l
ro .-rrrrio <nroii-r'o
onbrr
rop14trr{rrecKoiit
pa6orutr.
i:c.rrr
xe
frpercHiteHT
B 3atilurl{uKn
Hc 14Meer I{r.r opt.{-
.-urrrccKoro
o6pa:ouaHun, Hr{
onbrra
K)p}Jrr4rrecKoil
pa6o-
rr,r
.
'ro
c-vil
aojrxeH
6yler raxorily nuuy B ero HarvrepeHr,rflx
oC!llIe C'IIl:'lIIrb 3aillxTy IIO
yrO.rlOBHOMy
Aeny
OTxa:ars.
!,y-
t\'t aet'cfl
.
rt'Io
3aKoH ojlaTetr
n cn eayeT Ilu ecTH cooTBe'rcTByto-
nre e
{o6an,reH!{e
B
tr.
2
cr" 49
yn
K PO. },{uaqe ur{L,re
Jlu[a,
xo'ru
14
r,oilyrrleHHbre
cyAov
K 3aurure o6nilHrreN4oro, rro rre
oevtruranulne
.[ocrarortHbtM14 3rlaur4tMr,r
s
o6lacrn ilpaBa u
orrblroM rcpr4/lr4rrecKoii
pa6oru
KaK
3aulllrHt4Kl4,
rre
cN4oryr
c
lloc
l\{v [Iolt3ailI}4Tl I
otvty oKa3aTb
pe
a.rl b}tytQ tolll.il1 14
q
e
c KV ro
uo\,iorrrb, r.r
6olee ro[o. ng
cNiof_v'r tIpe.rlot-Rparll'rb t]brriece
.
IIltc t:),Tlorr He3aKor*Iofo.
trco6oe nogaHr{or{l n }tecftpar:ie/I-
.IIIIiOICr Ilpr.rfOBirpa B
Orl{OLUe HntJ ltx n0:l3airli1'rHOfo.
NIoxe-r -qH o6n[Hqe].rtrii
noo6ue
orKa3arbcs
or
3arrIHT-
rmKa, ll KaKHe flpu
3ToM B 3aKoHe
Ao,'r)otbr
6srrr'
yxalaurr yc-
,'lonHn? 9ra errte orna npo6neMa
o6ecfleqeurR
pezuiluori
.larrtrl rbr o6BrtHreN4olo
B
ylonoBHoM
cyAonpou3BoAcrBe.
l(parxo ona:raK-irruuaercr
B c-rre;IymileM. Kax t3necruo, n
coorBerclBr.lr c
q.
I cr. 52 VIIK PtD no,rio:peBaeNrnrii,
tr6-
ni.rttqe
ur,tt? BnpaBe u
rxr6ofi Mol{etir npou3tsoAcltia no
yro-
-iro rlrr
0lrl v
^eity
oTKa3a'r'bcrr
(lT
llcl\.loutl 3atl
IuTIJu
Ka.'lhxoit
o'r'Ka3
l1orrycKac'fcrl
To.rtbK()
n0 ult t4rIHaT14
Be IIor'io3peltaeMo-
lo ir.irlr oeislrHRelrolo.
Orxat
or 3aulllrH14xa
ro,rxeu
6url
.JaxtJ-,tclt
g
nucr,\reHlto\t
Blt
te.
Ec.'rtt
or
xa t
or 3auu.trut,tKa
3aa B_1e
H
U0 Bpe \Dr n
p(rr.t
3
BoltcTBa
cIe.[cT8e H rJo
|o
jle
H
cTBH
n.
'i
o o6 :roirt
ile,'Iaerctt
ortverKa
B ItporoKo;Ie
narlHoto
c,IIeIc-
T Be I r lroro,rlei;icrBriq.
K coxure nrrFo,
3aKoHo.aare,rr',
$opvy-lrlpylr
rropvy o6
ot Ka3e o6nuHseluolo
or 3aru[,trH14Ka, coBepuleHHo npont'-
t I oll 14
po
Bart
ry cy,qe6tt
yK,
npaKru K-v, Koropafl cy[tecrBouilrr
a
u
Poco.rr.r e[Ie
r1o
npr4Hqrr,rrr
Hor]oro
ynK
PO n
200 I ro,ry,
l]'foN{
rlilclle,
u B coBercKoe
BpeMl. A:ra rrparrr4Ka
cyItoB
npe)KHrrx
;ler o6 orKa3e
OOBI4HqeMofo or 3auIurHt{Ka
flRtro
3acJlyxHrJaer roro,
,Jro6tt
o rter,i
cei.iqac HaM BcIIoMI{l,ITt,.
'lax.
rranplrl{ep.
B oflpenereH14tr
BoeHHoi.r Ko,.tJrerMH
Bepxonrroro
Cy4a CCCP or
9
varr
1963 r
no
ne,ly
P. r.{
Jlpy-
r-tJ
x
vKa3
br Bz]-rroc u:
<,cot,t
acl4 e II oacya,.r M
ofo
Ha
pacc
il{oTpe-
l I re
re.rta
6c:t
l,vacrurr
3au{t4THI,r Ka, Itbt Hyxrerr }roe HeR
sxor,i
3arnnrrrrdKil n c_v,te6Hoe 3aceaaHne,
He Moxe'f
paccMarpl{-
tr,l I
r,Clr
KilK
oTK;l J oT laIlLlfl slo;.
B
lpyrou
nocralJoBreHnu
ilpe:nnnyva Bepxonno-
ro
Cy.ria
tle.relio-14uryrucxoii
ACCP
or 29
aexa6ps
1975 r.
rro
aeJry
C. 6suo
yKa3aHo:
<Orra:
or 3atuHlHHKa, Korrla efo
yrl
ac'n4 e r
cyne6r
rolr
3aceaaH fl il
oeiq:larel uuo,
AonycKaercq
]{).rtbKo I10 t{Hilut4aTuBe
caMofo llollcyAt{Mofo rrpl4
ycnoBt4t4,
,n'o
cyiioM IIpHI{tt'I br
Mepbr K o6ecne.{eHr.ro ero lauln roi,i"5.
14
eute oluo cy,te6Hoe
peueHue
Ha 3ry xe reuy. Cy-
.ite6lrafl
KoJr.lerfir no
yronoBHbrM
AenaM
Bepxonnoro
Cyaa
f']CQCP ro
reny
Eiaparioea, ocyxnerrrJoro ro
rJ.
2
cr. 147
u
.r.
2 cr. 144
yK
PCOCP,
yKa3ana,
ttro.
K;lK
Bt4/t,lio
tl:l llotr-
TalroBlrerlr,rrr
cyIl,brr o
ilpeAar{ur{
Hapattonir c.\'r.Y
/i.eJlo
6t,ulo
Ha3rjarrerro K crryuaH14r0
c
rracr[e]\{
np0KypOpa
J.i
:lililllll-
HnKa. O/IHaKo B
Aerre
orcyrcrBytor
llaH]jble
o6
o6ecttc'le-
rtl1I,l
cyAoM
yqacrl4.g
B cyAeorloM
pa3oi4pare-rlbcrlle
salllt4l-
Hr.rKa.
B MaTepiltuTax
AeJr
Her opAepa
aIBoKaTa
Ha Yrl;lsrrc
ero n cy,le6uoM 3acelaHHu.
B
cBr{:ll4
c 3'rt4\'r
flptrroBop
Ha-
poAHofo
cyna v KaccauHollHoe
oupeileilelllle
0'fl\{ellsHi'l
BBr4Ay HapyueHr,tfl npaBa ocyx4eHHofo
na 3alilrry0.
A nor
npuuep
cyge6uoii npaKruKl4
yxc
uaruur
/lrreii.
B onpeAeletrun
Cyae6uoli
ro,r.nernu
no
.vt'oitountllt
/'ic-
nau
Repxonr roro
CyAa
P<D or I 4 nrapra 2007
r. l\'q
I 9-O07-9
yKa3bIBaeTcg,
rITo
<<oTKa3
0T 3aulH'll{HKa
r,loxer
uNleT'b N'tec-
TO rUlub npr4
ycnoBr4r,r peanbHofo yqac'rug
3ailll4l
lll4Ka Il
Jle-
ne, npt4 HaJ'il,lrlltH B MaTeputuax
Jlena
TaKOfo JtoKa:]arejlbc-
TRa,
KaK
Op,lep allaoxalaoT.
IVIlr
cnerIualbuo trp14r]e,rr14
lIecKoJIbKo ItptrMep{,rl
t43
ory6luronaurroii cyre6Hoii
flpaKl'uKl,r,
rrro6br
troKa3arb,
'iro
cy4e6uaq npaKTLIKa.IlaBl{o I,r BIro-rHe o6ocHoEaHHo
clo-
ilT Ha TaKHX nO3HIlllgx:
l)
.rro
o'rKa3 or 3aIIILITIIHKa IIe \.{oxer
(ilrru
Rur
rr1';r-
aerlHI)1N.1
14
TaKt{M OH
Ilo,l)<eil
Cril.ITa'fbc'| ttCg<i.tii
pa3,
Kol--
Ila
B
3a-rye
cy,[e6]roro 3aceraHr4E
r4-rrn
Mecle
npor,r3noiiclBa
cn
elcrne
t{ Ho ro
rre
i.t clu il rr
pean
bir o orcyrc nlvel ajt BoKar
:
2)
.Jro
orKa3 or 3arulrrlru{Ka.uoJrxcH
6r,r
rn c,vry6o,ro6-
llo
Bc.i1 b r r bt
M t'r 14 MeTb MecTo'toJtbKfJ IIo tt t I H t[I4 itTH
Be
ga]vl
o I.o
o6riHuqeN{oro,
a
r{an14caHue
o6
glorrl
co6c'rneuuopyqHo
3a-
fl Brelt
uq o6st4Hfl elalt v
rol x H
o
6
r,rtr.
odgta
re,'l bH I.t t\.{
:
3)
uro orKa3 or 3aruHTHuKa Moxer
6srrs
rrpllrui'r'c-qc-
AOBaTeJIeM
Unfi
CyAOM
TOJ'IbKO
npr{
yCnOBI4r,l.
eCIU
ZUlllOKitT
pean
bHo npr4cyTcTB-ve'r'
B MecT e n
por43BoncTBa
c"rr
efl(:rBcr r
-
uoro
Aeiicrgvir
L4JrLl
cyAe6Horo
pa::6r.rpiu'e,rr,cruit.
{r'ro
I,t
aoJrxHo
6lrrr nolrsePxneso
HaJruq14ervr B Marcpilzurax
y[o-
J'roBr{o|o
aena
opaepa
aABoKaTa"
Ka:a.nocl
6rt,
.y1g
3Ta
Bcrr MHoror-terrrrrit cv,{e6rtart
npaKTI,lKa
cror,rr rra coBepueuHo
obocHouanirbrx.
3aKor!-
IIblx l,l cnpaBeA.[I,tBbIX
no3HtIt{{x, fipuqeM ?Ta IrpaKl'HK?l
uulpoKo rl3BecrHa
MHorr{M rop14craN,r Poccl,nr. Ho rioqe-
My xe 3aKouoAarenb
He orpa3l4n 3'rr{ nofurlr.u4 n YllK
Prtl
200
I roita
l,r, B
qacrrrocrrl,
B
q.
I cr. 52
yflK
PO o6
orxa-
se or:aLuHrHHxa'/
B
cRq:n
c
paccMarpxBaeMoi.{
uaur npo6reNrori A.A.'l-e-
perylona
o6ocuoBauHo rrperuamert
rrro
<<B
yn
K PO
cncJly'.
e'r
BBecrr.r
HopMy. corJ'racHo
xolopoil orKa3 noAo3peBacMo-
fO OT
yqng114fi
B
AOnpOCe
:lalIII4'tHI4Ka Ira npel|BApuTe,IlltrllOl\'{
c,teAcrtsH14
14
Ao:lgaH14t4
uor
6lt
6ttru crlelarr rolbKo B lrpu-
clTcTBfl H
3arui4Tri 14 Ka>)d.
Mst
6sr K
3roMy npe/LrroxeHlrK)
ro6aBr.trtr{
ettte
oA}ro:
<,8
c,ty.{ae
orKa3a or 3a[lHTHxKa
I]
Marepl.{aJrax
yronouuofo
nena JloJrxrbr
Haxotrr4Tbcs
co6crseHlropyr]Ho
rrailr4carr]roe
3atl BJ'le lt }'
e O6nu n
geuo
ro 14 opAep anBOKa ra,).
llatu
aua,rn:r npoueccyiurbnoii
uopnru o6 orxa:e o6ur-
HteMoro
or
3auHTIJr4ra
6yler Henorltbll\1, eclr4
Mbr He t{c-
cneAyeM
TaKoii Bonpoc: a KaK orra: o6siluseMoro or 3aruul-
III{Ka OTpa3r{'!'Cfl rra
Cylrr,6e ItIloI0,II{tIa, TaKxe
JloryrrleHHollo
cyAou
B KaqecTBe
raulursnxa?
Sror nonpoc
6rr,r
y)Ke
nperMeror\{
paccN,rorpeur,Ix
B
flocraHoBJreuuu l3epxonuoro
Cyaa PO N9 I ol 5
vapr-a
2004
r.
<,O
rrpuueueH1414
cyaaNrr4
Hoplr
Yro,roBrro-rrporlec-
cy€ulbHoro Ko.qe Kca Pocc u r.i c xoi.i Oenepa
uu
r>e.
B
n. 3 sloro rrocrar{oB,rrerrnn flleuyl,ra Bepxoorroro Cy-
aa
P<D
yKa3brBaercr:
<llocrcolrxy
u
coo'fBerc-tBt4tl
c
(iacrbro
2
qarr.u
49
ytlK
P@ olnn u: 6ln:lxux
poAcrBeHl{r{KaB
vrn
t{Hoe r''n{uo,
o llorlycKe Koroporro xoaaraficrayer o6BuHric-
::t"..
::::::.j
a:-7
Nq
10/2009
tt,rbr17,
Moxer
6trrl
AonyuleHo
cyAoM
B
Kaqec.fBe
3arutrrr{r.rKa
TOJ'IbKO
Hapnny
C
aABOKaTOM,
npl4H.qTr.Ie
OTKa3a
OT a.rIBOKaTa
B,rreqer
sa
co6oi{
r4
rrpeKparrleH
u.e
y\acrwfl
B
ne,Te
groro
Jnlua
(:a
ucrcrnueHt4eM
tlpor.t3BoAcrBa
y
Mr4poBoro
cy4lr.r),>.
3ra
no:l.rur,rlt
BepxonHoro
Cyaa
y
Hac
Bbt3brBaer
rreAo_
yMeHr4e.
floveuy
Btrcorl.rji
Cy4 npoqeccyaJrbHyro
cygt6y
oaH
oro
yqacTH
LrKa
yIOJTOBHOIO
CyAOnpor43BOACTBa
CBg3br
_
Baer
c
cy4l6oii.{pyroro,
HecMorpq
Ha
ro,
qro
r.tx
yqacr[e
B
yf
onoBHoM
CyAOn
poI43BOnCTBe
OCHOBaT{O
Ha
pa3J,l[rrH
brx
npaBoBbtx
ocHosaHilqx?
B
ilAl,trr,ro,
rrcro
Krl
ou l.t
6xn
aBTopoB
aH an
[3r4pyeMo_
IO
HAMI,I
NOCTAHOBIICHI,I'I
3AKIIOTiAIOTC,,I
B
TOM,
IITO
OH],I
IIeBepHo
floHflII,I
I,t 14CTOJIKOBaII'I
C,rtOBO <<HapgAy>,
14C_
Ilonb3oBaHHoe
3aKoHoAaTeJreM
B
,t.
2
cr.49
ynK
p<D,
rarc
<(COBMOCTHO)>,
BTO
BpeMt
KaK
HaCaMOM.II0Ie
OTO CItOBO
O3Ha_
traer -
<<oAuHaKoBo,
HapaBHer>I0.
Thxul,r
o6pa:olr, ynorpe6lan
c,rloBo
<<HapflAy)>,
3aKo_
HoAarenb
noAqepKr.{Baer,
qro
3aurr,rrHr,rK
B Br4Ae
6,rlr:roro
pol{cTBeHHhKa
I4J|LI
t4HOrO
,rrr4ua,
o
AonycKe
KoToporo
xo_
Aaraiicrsosan o6su
Hqer\.{brii,
6ylyun.[otryueHH
brMrl
cyAoM
K
yqacTr{ro
B
3auluTe
rro
yroJroBHoMy.[eny,
npuo6perarcr
o,qr4HaKoBbre,
paBHbte
npaBa
c 3auIr.{THtlKOM_aABOKaTOM.
Vl
eclu
ro
KaKrlN,t-To
rrr.rrtHbrM
r4nl{
ApyrtrM
npllvuHal.r
o6_
sr,rHrreN,rtril
orKa3arcq
or
3arrlrdrHrrKa-aABoKara,
To
3To He
AoJlxHo
BJ'rer{b
3a
co6oit
aBToMarr4qecKoro
npeKpatueHr4q
yqacrr4r
B
yfoJ'roBHoM
aele
B
KaqecrBe
gautrnlrra
6.nn:_
KOrO
pOACTBeHHT4Ka
r4).r14
r,rHot-o
nltua,
AonyrueHHofo
cyAoM
no xoAararicrny
o6ntrHleuoro.
lpyrax
npaBoBarr
no3r.rut4q
B
3roM
Bonpoce
nel.r:6exHo
BeAer
K r{apyruer{
r4ro
rapaHrlrpo
Baun
urx l(oH
crr.rryuu
e fi
p{D
Itpan
o6nlluleMoro
Ha
3aul4Ty.
C,reAyer
ilN{erb
B
BHAy,
r{To
aABoKar-3arqfiTHr4K
Moxer
6arrl
s
yronoBHot\{
.ueJie
_rrefKo
3aMeHeH
Apyrr.rM
aIBoKaroM.
VcrpaHeurre
xe
rr3
yroJoBHo_
fo
npo(ecca
3aurr4THr4Ka
B Buae
6,qn:roro
po,tcrBeHHrrKa
!i,'ru,t
r{Horo
nHua,
AonyueHHofo cyrot\t
no xoraraircrn-v
o6_
Br,rHqeMoro,
Moxer
6ttrl
A,'rs
Hero
rpynHo
:auegnrro.
Bce
ACJrO
B
TOM,
yqacTHe
3Tr4X
Jrr4U
B 3aur.tTe
o6sHr,rreN.roro
oc_
PocckhcKAs
pcrlq!-{tl
l{oBaHO,
KaK
npaBI4JIO,
Ha
,rILlrIIlbrx,
aoIlepI,ITeIbHbtx
oTIIo-
IUeHIlrx
c
AaurrbIN{
o6sr{Hrret\4stN{,
or
Koropol.o
oH oxnIlacT
He
ro,rlbKo
loptt4nqecKoit
nouorqu,
Ho
u ncr.JxoJror]4rrecKorJ
noAAepxKH.
iloHarHo,
rrro
ec,rr{
cy4lr
6y4yr
crporo
cJ,reAoBarb
B
oroM
Bonpoce peKoMeHAauilflM
rrocraHonj'rer{t{q
flteH},rra
Bepxonnoro
Cyaa
PcD,
ro
oJIHoBpeMeHHoe
llpeKpauent{e
yqacTr.lfl
B
)'roJroBrroM
Ae,rre
3auluTI{UKa_aABOKaTa
il
Apyfrrx
3illr{14111y
*OU
-
6,rl.rgroro
poAcTIteII
it
LIKa U,rt
Jl rJ
HOfO,q
lI I
Ia.
lt:6paHrtttx
u nptrDrarusH
ullx
o6Bilnrr
eN,rbrl\{,
npaKTrrrrcc
Kr I
ocraBJ'rfler
ero
6e:
nclroii
rcprlArlLrecKoii
:aulrrru.
Ha uaru
B3r,lqA,
rlpaBoBbre
ocHoual{ut
y(racrrJfl
argo-
KaTa-3au{rrT}il{Ka
B
yfonoBr{oN,I
Aene
il
yqacTr{s
B
3a[tr.r.fc
o6Br.{H.qeMoro
6,rn:roro po,qcrBeH}ujKa
lr H}{oro
nllua
cy_
LuecrBeHHo
pa3nr{qarclcx.
Ecnn
yqacrile
3aurHTHr,rKa_all_
BOKaTa
B
yronoBHoM.4ene
ocHoBaHO,
KaK npaBl4J.ro,
Ha
CO_
rraneHr{r{
Me)Kny
o6nl.rHrrer4rrN,{
}I
aABOKarON,r,
TO
yqacrrJe
B
3arur4Te
6,rl.rsroro
poAcrBeHHr4Ka
I4 r,rHoro
nriqa,
AonyLuerr_
Horo
K
yrracrr.{rc
B
3au{HTe
no xoAaraitcruy
o6ullulel.roro.
OCHOBAHO
I,ICKIIOTII{TEIbHO
HA
UX
II,ITIHbIX
I{
IOBEDTITC,IIJ-
HbIX
OTHOIUEHH,'IX.
Kponre
rofo,
cne.rlyer
rrpr,rHrrb
Bo
BHrl\raHrr!-.
rrro
lro
BfroJ'rHe
caMocroqrerbHbre
rpoueccyubnbte (trrrr.pr,r.,r
r;o_
TOMy
oAt,rH
yqacTHuK
yfoJtoBHofo
cylonpoil3tsofcrB.i
i]:-
Aon)KeH
c,IenouaTb
3a
npoueccya-tbHol
cr-tuiro;l
_t!\
I Lt-
ro
ero
yrtacrurrra.
C
lpyroii cropor{br
. cc.ti:
(riFt,ri;;'\t!r,,
orKDKerct
flo
KaKut!{-,ttt6o
.,tu.ttrr,ttl
nplrlilHLt\r
or
\c.-ii
r-
cBoero
6nu:roro poAcrBeHHII
KA
I1.1
II I1 1{oro
.-l I I
ui1.
npII
f.'ta-
IIEHHbIX
IIM
B KAqCCTBC
3AUIIlTHIlKOB.
TO TiIKOII
OTKIIJ
HC
Ao,rt)KeH
B.qe!tb
3a co6oii
aBTo\rarrrqecNoro
)crpaHeHltc
II3
yf
o-'ro BHofo
fr
po
uecca 3a
uI r ITII I
r Ktr-a-tBoKara.
Mrt
paccrtolpe-tn
ro.tbKo
ueKoropbtc
aKT)
iLtbllbre Bon-
pocbt
3aultrlr
o5Brtutertofo.
cBt3auHbre
c
\ltiicrlte\t
Il 3To\t
3aurltrrurKa.
O:uaxo.faxe
u3
o-tHoii
KparKolr
crarblt rJll.l-
Ho,
r{To
B
3a[Inre
o6grtu.serroro
o6lexrlrsuo
c]'uecrBvtor
HeKoropbre
npo6,reirrlr,
Koropbre
Ao,'rxHbr
cBoegpei\reHHo
pa3pe
uaTbcq
3aKoH
onaTeJreM.
7
t
il,
Pocciliicxar
raeera.
2009.
3
urons.
Xe'rro6proxon
C'fl'
O Heo6xort'tvocrx
ycrpar{cHl{,
uHc'nfiy'taAorrorlHr{Te,.rbHoro
3a[trlrHrlra
//poccvtiicKas
r]ocrrur{.q.
2009. Na 7.
c.
50.
op'ro,n
A'B'
KoucrnryuuoHHble
HopMbl,
o6ecneqnsarcurl.rc
o6srrFrqeNroMy
npaBo
Ha
3ailrury
B
pocciltcKor.{
yro,,roBHolr
npouecce.
An-
'rope@.
gucc.
...
KaHA.
ropr4a.
HayK.
Caparon,
2004.
C.
g.
C6opH
ur
nocraHon,renut?
[,reHyIa
I'I
onpege,reHuri
ror,qerfiii
Bepxonuoro
Cyaa CCCP
no
yronoBrJblM
ne,rav.
I
959-
I
971
rn M.:
IOpN-
.quqecKaq
nxreparypa,
1973.
C.
323.
6xt,r,rereHs
BepxonHoro
Cyaa
pC@Cp.
1976.
Ne 6.
C. 15.
flocraHos,reHtrt
u
onpcle,'lcHt'l'I
no
yfoJloBHbrM
AcJ'raM
Bcpxoenoro
cyaa
PC@GP
(1981-l9gg
nr:)
/
nol
pca.
E,.A. crro.,reHueErr.
M.:
foprgl.ruecraa
nr.rreparypa,
1989.
C. 369.
En,rnereut
Bepxonnoro
Cyla
Poco.riicxoi;i
@eaepauuu.
200g.
Ns
l.
C.
32.
Tepery'r^o^na-AA.-flpaeoroe
noJ'IoxeHue
noao3peBaeNroro
B
yronoBHoM
npouecce
Poccul.r.
AnropeS.
nr4cc.
... KaH.u. ropxr.
Hayx.
ge,rfl-
6nncx,
2008.
C.
I 1.
Poccur.icxas
rasera.
2004.
25
uaora.
Oxeron
C. l,l.
C,ronaps
pyccKoro
s.:srxa.
Ox. 57.000
cros
/
not,pet.rrn.-Kopp.
AH
CCCP
FL IO.
llJneaosor?.
l7_e r{3A.,
crepeornnHoc.
M.:
Pycc.
q:.,
1985.
C.
Jlj.
:ttt::::::::::::::::::::::t :::::]t\l
_-,*;- _.-"-
yfo^oBHbrul