Бернштейн Л.Б. Приливные электростанции

Tpar

Ha sKcnJr\/ararr.Hto

nlJC

s

reqeHue

120 .ner

(nr.nrcuaa

peMonr

H

ABJvKpar-

Hyro 3aMeuy

o6opyAoBaHlrf) nora3aJr,

qro

A,itn

BapuaHl'a

A orHoureHue

noJry-

qeHHofi

aHeprurr

K 3arpaqeusoii cocraB-

--^- l, n-t ___ _____-z

Jtncr

r.t,z:1,

AJIfl AItyxoacceltHOBOH

cxe-

MbI

C

yBeflHrIeHHbrM

BCnOMOraTeJIbHbrM

6accefiuou

(napnaHr

E)

-

12:l rr

A.rrfl

aseuruefi

oAHo6accefiHoeofi

cxeuur B

-

13,9:1.

Srra

AaHHbre

roBopflr

o6 or-

HOCsTeJrbHOft

aQSeKTLBHOCTU

BCeX

rpex

BapHaHTOB,

nOCKOnbKy KpHTH'-IeCKHM

AJrs

AAC csuraercn

orHoueHue

l0:l

(als

BerpoBbrx

3C,

HaxoAruluxcr

B

nyquHx

ycnoBHrx,

oHo

cocTaBJrfeT

13,5: I

u

p.Jtfl

Bo.rrHoBbrx

3C-rontxo

2: I

).

O4uaxo

noflyqeHHbre coorHoueHufl

eule He

no3BoJIflIoT

cAeJIaTb oKoHqa-

TeJIbHOTO

BbrBOAa

O

npeHMyrqecrBax

oA-

Hofi

He cxeM,

nocKoJrbxy B

npr,tFoAHMbrx

noKa3aTeIfx

He

yrruTblBaeTcq

KaqecT-

Bo

SHepfnr{,

T. e. ueo6xoAr.rMocrb 3arpar

AOnOnHHTeJIbHbTX

CpeACTB Ha

BnHCbiBa-

HHe

3HeprHtt

ngc

r

rpaSrar sHepro-

cHcreMbr.

B erou orno[reHHu npeAcran-

JIfleT

HHTepec

cpaBHeHue

pa6oru

raxofi

o,quo6accefinoeofi

n3C oAHocropoHHe-

ro

4eficrnilfl

flo npoeKry

1979 r. c

o6uq-

Hofi

fA3C,

Koropoe

npou3Berl

IIIoy

12671.

nnn

ar(KyMyJrnuHH sHeprnra I-l3C

B reqeHue

l0

q

cna6ofi

Harpysxu rpe61'-

ercs

o6teM,

coorBercrByroutrifi 50

fBr-

q

B

CyTKH,

HJIU, eCJIH npHHflTb

3a 3'.I,iJIOH

I.AOC

.[,aunopynx,

sro o3H8e?,rt, 6u

norpe6Hocro

B

nflrH raKux fA3C,

a

npu

yBenuqeHrlr

o6reua

ux

BoAoxpa-

HHJruul

Ha

60

o/o

-

pyHK,

rtTo

Ho eule

o

3,2 MJrpA.

Q.

cr.,

T. e.

Becb

KoMnJreKc .

oAuo6accefiHoeofi

n3C

-

|ASC

o6ouercs

6H

s

7,3 rrnnpA.

Q.

cr.

flpu

srou

xoeQQr.ruueHr

Harpysxu n3C

noAgffncfl

6:",r c

17

Ao

38o/o .

flpu

raxort

pa6ore

ilSC c |ASC

6onee 30 %

sHep-

run

(e

3aBHcHMocrH

or

paccrornnfl

Ao

|ASC)

6y,uer norepflHo.

B

nporuBono-

JIOXHOCTb

9TOMy aKKylrtyJIHpoBaHI{e

oHeprurr

oAuo6accefiHosofi

n3C

s cBoeM

6accefiHe

Aaer

He

vMeHbueHue.

a

yBe-

.IIHqeHHe

xoHequofi

gHeprriu

(<<HacocHufi

e@err>);

Ho oHo

BeAer

x cl6utefi

norepe

(ao

20

%) euepruu

IISC

3a

cqer nepuo-

AOB

OX(I|AAHVfl.

Burue

npu

paccMorpeHuu

4eyx6ac-

ceftHosofi

ngc

no BapnaHry E

6u.rro no-

200

KA3aHO

rITo

nnu ?Tr)u cxeMp n nnn.t.lrpri-

noJloxHocrs

oguo6acce

ir

H oeo.fr ec

n -aHep-

rHn

il3C norHocrbro

ncnoJrb3yercn

KaN

caMar

ueHHar,

T. €.

B nltKosofi

qacrH

rpaQHxa.

ilpu

3roM ll3c,

Ka3arocu

6sr,

BbrroAHo

orlnqaercn

or o6uqHofi

fA3C

roJr

bKo

xorQ$uuueHroM

aKKyMyJrHpoBa-

Hun (0,90

BMecro

0,75). Ho nocxorrbKv

'raKafr

nplrrlBHafl

|ASC

ocyulecrB--

Jrf eT

aKKyMyJrHpoBaHHe

npH

HH3KONI

Hanope,

oHa,

KaK 6u.no noKa3aHo

Bbture,

MeHee

gKoHoMHr{Ha.

HueHHo

noaroMv

npeAnoqreuue

6uno

or.uaHo

oAHo6acceft-

Hosofi

cxeMe

A

6.rraroAapr

ee sKoHoMHrr-

HocrH

t2631.

Taxum o6paeou,

Bepny-

JIHCb

K

peu3HHrO,

npHHrrToMy

B

npoeKTe

1945

r.

Kor.ta

3Heprr,rfl

oAHo6accefiHo-

sofi

n3C

HenocpeAcrBeH

Ho BntrcbrBaJracb

B

cucreMv

pa6oraroulux

Ha

yr.ne

TOC.

nnn

n3C

ocraBJtrJracb MaKcHMaJrbHo

AonycruMafl

Ao;lfl

yqacrHrr (20

%),

a

ee

peryJltf

poBaHHe

ocyulecTBJrff Jrocb

ilyTeM

nepeBoAa

B nHKoBVro

qacrb

rpaSuxa

rrlo-

pa.rrbHo

ycrapeBruax

TOC

(cu.

pNc.

16.3)

12421.

B coBpeMeHHbrx ycroBr.rqx

npu

6o.nee 6"rraronpuflTHoM

coorHoureHuH

MorrtHocrn

I-l3C ra

cncreMbr raKoe peue-

HHe

fle.ltflerct

rexHllqecKu

6o.nee

nptreM-

JIeMbrM,

nocKoJtbKy

Hoseliuue

arpera-

ru

T3C

o6.uaAapr

6onlruofi MaHeBpe-

Hocrbro

H HX

cJreArulag

cnoco6nocrr

Bbr[re,

qeM

cKopocrs

c6poca

lr ua6poca

Harpy3Kr.r

n3C.

PaccuarpuBafl

Bonpoc

o BXJrroqeHHH

n3C B aHrnuficryrc

sHeprocr.rcreMy,

KouHrer

no

CenepHcxofi fl.[ortrHe

orMe-

]i

ronbHb!-x-

-areK-rpoeraxunft

^

(2,8-3'8

neHc/xBr'u)

crouMoerb

I xBr'q

oaHo-

6accefinosofi

n3C

(cnHyrpenHrn

nrlo-

ruHa>),

paBuafl

2,5-3,5

neHca,

-rBJIfler-

cf

gKOHOMHqecKH

OnpaBAaHHOH'

qero

Herb3r

cKa3arb

o

Aayx6accefiH-osoili

na-

pHaHTe

H

BapHaHTe

C

(BHeUHeH

nJIOTH-

sofi>.

Hs

etoro

oqeBHAHo,

qro

PeanbHocTb

ocyurecrBJteHHfl

npoeKra

[l3C

CenepH

3aBHcHT

or

roro,

HacKoJlbKo

6yAer

yne-

rHqHBarbcr Aonn

A3C

n

eHepro6aaau-

ce

cTpaHH.

tl OT

CTOHMOCTH

n,4epuofi

9Hep

rHH.

ConpeueuHan

AorIfl

A3C

s

o6qetvt

npoH3BoAcrBe

sreKrpo3Hepru

u

(12,7

o/o)

eule

ol{eHb

AaJIeKa

AO

(OnacHoro)

AJIff

n3C

3Ha'{eHHfl

(75

o/o),

nocxo.nnKy

crpo-

rutnecf

A3C

x

l99l

r. JIHlIrb

yABoflr

coBPeMeHHyto

HX

MOIIlHocTb,

a

nJIaHb'I

Aalonefi

urero

crpoureJlbcrBa

A3C

nepe-

cMarpHBaloTcf

B cTopoHy

Hx

coKpaqe-

HHf

,

I{To

o6sqcugercf

gKoJIorutIecKHMH

npHqHHaMH.

t{ro

Kacaercr

crouMocru

3HePrHH

A3C,

To

npu

o6cyxAeHHH

B

napnaMeHTe

Bonpoca

o6

atousofi

enepruu

u ee

$ax-

ruqecxofi

crottMocrH

BbltlcHuJlocb'

qro

(crouMocrb

3HeprHH

A3C

6yRer

BHure,

qeM

ilpeAnoJlafarocb,

I'l

pa3!ry!

MeXAy

Heto

I't croHMocrblo

sHeprHI{

flSC

yrvreHu-

urHTcq) t2631.

Tax, ctonMocrb

eHeprHH

nan6olee

oKoHoMHqHofi

cefiqac

A3

C

Xu-

Hx.nr.r-flofi

Hr

paBHa

2,24

neuc/(xBr'

u).

Ore4yer

orMerl'trb

BJIIISHHe

Ha

sKoHoMHqecKoe

o6ocuosaHHe

flSC

pae-

Mepa

yr{eTHof0

lltsor\cH'ta.

r an'

EU"rn

rrPn

5%-Hofrt

v.IerHofi

craBKe

Arq

oAuo6ac-

ceftHosofi

cxeMbt

BuncoHa

(4,56

fBr

tt

10,5

TBr.u)

orHoueHHe

AoxoAoB

K

Pac-

xoAaM

cocraBrlrJto

1,4

(l.nq

A3C-

|

,7),

To

npH

noBbluIeHHH

YuetHofi

craBKri

ao

l0

o/o

ltSC

He

Moxer

o6ecne-

qHTb

AaXe

AonoIHHTeJIbHyI'O

npH6Ulr-'

nocJre

on.rarbl

npoueHroB 11881-

flosro-

My

Bax{HbtM

pe3epBov

yMeHbueHus

o6-

uefi

croHMocrn

tl3C

Ao!'txHo

rBtlrbct

coKpauleHHe

cpoKa

BBoAa

nepBblx

arpe-

raToB.

flps

oueHKe

nePcneKrHsHofi

3Ko-

rroMHt{HocrH

fl3C

Ceoepu

HaAo

ct{Hrarb-

cfl

TaKXe

C

nporHo3oM

yMeHb[IeHHf

K

2000

r.

s

3-5

Paa

.no6uun

ue$tu

Ha

ure.rruQe

CeaepHoro

MoPfl

.

Pnc. 16.9.

CpanHenHe

(Ha

ypoaHe

2000

r.)

croHMocrn

aueprfiH

fl3C CenepH c

anbrepHa-

THBHbTMH

HcroqHHKaMu

(e

xax,4oM BapHaHTe

aasa

l5

%-nas

(BHJIKat

or

cpeAHero

3Haqe-

nun).

Cronuoctl

I

xBt.s

AaHa

B

qeHax

1980

r.:

,

-

aJrbrepHaaHBHaq

croHMocrb

3HeprrrH

Lrc

n3C'

ecJrn 3aMeulaeMoe

roll.truao

yrorb;

2-ro x<e, ecJrr

3aMeulaeMoe

ronJI[Bo

yroau

(25

0S)

n

a4epnoe ron-

nnso

(75

%)

Kouurer

no CeaepHcroft

nJIorHHe,

cr{HTaf

,

qro

oKoHqareJlbHoe

cyx4euue

o6

oKoHoMHr{HocrH

n3C

Mo)I(er 6url nony-

qeHo

ToflbKo

rIpH

ToqHoM

yqeTe

Bcex

srnx

QarropoB,

Ho

noJlaraf

,

!lro,

KoI'Aa

crpaHa

crolKHerctl

c

3HepreTHqecKHMH

rpyAHocrquu,

IISC

6y4er

HMerb

6o.nu'

UIOE

3HAIICHHC,

CA}IHOAYIUHO

PCKOMCHAO-

BaJr

He3aMeAJIHTe.IIbHO

npHCTynHTb K

cJreAypqefi

cra4uu

pa6ot,

Arff

ToFo

tlro-

6H

s xoHue

80-x

roAoB MoxHo

6utlo

npn-

Hnrb

peueHlle

o Haqare

crpol4TeJlbcrBa

t24ll.

flpanureJlbcrBo

corJlacnJlocb

c

4a.nuHefiruee

QuHancupoBaHHe

npoeK-

Ta

qacrHbrM

KanHTaflOrtr.

Ha

gToM

oc-

HoeaHr.rn

6utr

co3AaH

KoHcopunyu

Qnpu

Severn

Tidal

Power

GrouP

(STPG),

no

npeAJroxeHurc

Koroporo

B 1986

n.

nn'rrd6 A?Aurf

qrtlnrttrrfi

Erqnt

qtr.n

nac.

lly nnn

I vrlvrr

1q

r

!9.!rrvrrr

c

nnoruHofi

B

crBope

KaPnuQ-Vec-

ron

A.nnuofi

16,3 xu

lI

KancyJIbHblMH

arperaraMu

BMecro

CtPaQno

(192

arperara

no

ff:37,5

MBr u

Dt:3,2

";.

floseusuancfl

npu atofi

saMeHe

arpe-

raToB

BosMolKHocrb

uacocHoE

pa0orbl

no3BoJrfer

noAHqTb

orrpa6otxy

Ao

14,4

MBr

npH

npexHefi MouIHocrH

7,2

lBr. Ha

coctaBJteHHe

npoeKTa or'

nyureHo

4,2

u.ttH.

Q.

ct.,-Il3C

npe4no.ra-

raercfl

nocrpoHfl'

x

2000 r.

[3041.

201

x. |ASC

Aaptro-

TITJI,

tlro,

ecJIH

ToflbKo

AoJrff

A3C s

gH

AOnOJIHHTeJTb-

rocr4cTeMe

He

oyAeT

pe3Ko

Bo3pacTaTb,

coopyxeHHe

MOXeT npUBeCTH K

cnuxeHnro

o6qefi

crouMocru

gHeprHH

3a

crreT

yMeHbrxeHuf

SaTpaT no BbrTecHfl-

eMbrM

TenJroBbrM

SJreKTpocTaHrlHflM

12421.

kis npaQaKa

Ha

pr.rc.

i6.9

[263]

c;re-

Ayer,

qro

ecflr4

Ha

ypoBHe

2000 r. flSC

6y,uer

3aMeHrrb

gJreKTpocraHuuu,

pa-

6orarculue

ua 25oio

Ha

vroJrbHoM

H

Ha

750/o

ua flAepHoM

tonnre6,

To

cToHMocTb

I

xBt.q

gHepruu

sroro aJrbrepHarr.rB-

Horo

AJIn

n3C

ucrorrHnK

a

(l

,2-1,7

neu-

ca)

6y.uer

HaxoAHTbcfl

BHe

npeAeJror

gKoHoMHrrecxoft

KonKypeHrrr{u

nrc6oro

r43

BapHaHroB

npoeKra

IISC

Cenepu.

Ilpu

yrraeHbtueHun

AoJrH

A3C, uilH

sa-

MeHe

sHeprnu

fl3C sHeprnefi

roJrbKo

,

F

o

-

E

:t

It

nr

$

-

rt

.a

E

(r

5

E

\t

o

E

<r

+

J

3auennanerc

t6.5. nPOEKTb!

APy!-rlX

n?C

B

reqeHue

psAa

ner pa3pa6arHsaror-

cq

_rpoeKru

IISC

H

Nre

Apyr-Hx

paftoHon

no6epexrs

Be;rnxo6p

HTaHHH,

r,qe

nerrH-

qHHbI

npHJrHBa

MeHbr.ue,

qeM

B

gcTya_

puu

CenepH (6yxmr

Conysfi-<Depr,

Mop-

1au,

,U,n,

Xar*,r6ep,

Vou,

Crpinr-Qopg-

{lo*

H ?cryaptr

peK

Mepcefi,

Pu6u,

CurQop4

r.r

Ap.).

flpel.rrara.nocb

raKxe

coopyxeHre

He6orybrrrHx

onurHux fIOC

MeHafi

H 9ucrep-JlaHrcroH

[gl.

Pa-

Hee

3TH yCTaHOBKH

BBHAy

HX H3O'rHpO_

eaHHofi

pa6omr

npeAnaranncb

B

AByx-

6accefiHoBoM

BapuaHre

(Konnunsa),

bl-

HaKO

B

nocne,u,HHe

roAbr

noA BJTHflHHeM

npoeKTa

nOC

CenepH

H

Ha ero

ocHoBe

nosBu.rrucu

paspa6orxl.r

l9 npoeKToB

o4Ho6accefiHossrx

nOC o6urefi

MoutHo-

glbg

21,34

fBr

u aurpa6orxoft

oKqrro

25,5

TBr.

q/roA

(cr'1.

npruloxeHne).

Cp"a"

gTHx

npoeKToB

flMerorcc KaK

ruu

B

npuropoAax

MaHqecrepa u

Jlu-

Bepnynf

npeAOrpeAenr{ra

npHHffrHe

il98q

n,

peruenus

o crponrenbcrBe

Biincoiiov

a

1965

f.,

He

6i,i.rro peaxH3o-

..<^ ffa/.-

Ddn(r,

rluu I

t.7\_

He MOrJta

BblAepxaTb

co_

nocTaB.rreHHs

c renJlosuN.ili

3neKTpo-

cTaHqHgMHr

HCnO[b3ytOUIttMH,[euleBbre

(ror4a)

neQru

H

yrqrb.

l-Jo

noc.neAHeMy

npoeKry

npeAnara-

ercs

3ailHB

nnoula,(bro

144-92

KM2

nepeKpbrrb

nJroruHofi

Arulnori

12

xu,

s

xoropofi

_6yAyr

pacncroxenn

30 arpe-

raroB

o6ureft

MoulHocrbro

200

MBr

a

78

BoAonponycr(Hbrx

oraepcrnfi.

Aua-

Merp

arperaroB

npuHrr

paBHbrM

7,6

u

no ycnoBHrM

pa3MerrleHHf,

HanJraBHbrx

6roxos

6es

noAsorHofi

sHeruxll.

He6ons-

luafl

urHpHHa

cTBOpa

He

no3BonseT

HC-

noJrb3oBarb

gHepronoreHuHan

6acceft-

ua,

Ho

HacbruleHue

ero

arperaraMx

o6ec_

neqHBaeT

nonyr{eHge

aupa6orxa

0,575

TBr.q.

Crouruocrs

[I3C

334 r"r"rrs.

Q.

cr.

e

(qeuax

1979

r.),

I

rBr.q

-

3

neHca.

flsrr

n3C

6olruofi

MourHocru

3anpo-

eKTHpoBaHH

KaK

oAuo6accefi

Hosbre

o.rl,Ho-

cropoHHeno

4eficrnrfl

c npHMeHeHHeM

Ha-

nJraBHbIx

KoHcrpyKrruti,

acrBopbr

ux

nu6-

paHH

rax,

vro6u

MoxHo 6ulo

npHMeHHTb

arperarbl

c xau6o.nsunM

Bo3MoxHhrM

AH-

anaerpou

pa6ouero

Kqrreca

(9,1

v) 6e3

no4no4uoft

BbreMKH.,IL.nq

o6ecneqeHns

3anoJrHeHHr

npoBanoB

MoulHocTH,

H€-

Hs6exHHx

npH

oAHo6acceftHosux

ll3C,

npeAJraraercrr

Hcno[b3oBarb

cABH r

eaasr

npHilHBa

ua 6

q

B

crBopax

Voul

u

Xarra-

6ep

no

orHoureHnp

K

ApyrHM

crBopaM.

OAuaxo

BKJrKrqeHHe

Bcex

gTHx

nAC

o6urefi

MorrtHocrbro

27

fBr

(c

yqeroM

II3C

CenepH)

n o6teAuHeuHyrc

aueDro-

cHcreMy

crpanbr

AiDr(e

rrpu

ee cyuuapnofi

MorrtHocru

I l0

I'Br (Ha

yponHe

2000-

2100

rr.)

npeAcra&rsercr

-6o.nee

npd-

.rreMaTHqHbrM,

qeM

Ntfl

paccMoTpeHHo-

ro

BHtue

yqacrns

s erofi

cucreMe

oAnofi

IISC

CesepH MorqHocruo

7,2

fBr.

C;regyer

rarxe yqecrb

He4aBHee

npeAnoxeHHe

o

coopyxeHHn

rHraHT-

crofi

tI9C

c

roAosofi

nurpa6orxofi

140

fBr-q nyreM

orcerreuns

lOGxu.no-

Merpo_Bofi

n.norunofi

or

3HrneH

Ao

Eap-

\t^-

puy /1.eA

tsuc'r'ol|HoH

rIacTH

rlpnaHA-

cKoro

Mops

c

o6paaonaHHeM

6acceftHa

rnoutaAbro

14

ruc.

xrut

13051.

Oueau4uo,

raxofi

uacrura6

Hcnqrlb3oBa-

HHfl

npn.nueuofi

eHeprHH

Banaxo6pu-

raHHH

rpe6yer

HHoDo

peureHnfl

npd-

reMbl

(cu.

r"n. l7l.

r-rlABA

i7

ngc

[uo3E. Bo3MO]KHOCTU

nCnOnb3oBAHHn

nPnnnBHorl

SHEprnv

Ann

oEbEAhHEHHblx

3HEPTOCHCTEM

3AnAAHOfi EBpORbl

flpoextr.rpoBaHHe

n3C

B

pafione

Hopr'raH4cKnx

ocrpoaoa

([Ilose,

I-epHcu,

!,xepcu,

MeHxue)

B TerreH[e

pcAa

ner

Benocb

eo OpaHuHH

B

ue.'Iqx

co6crBeH-

Hbrx

HHTepecoB

crpanbr. OAHaxo

no cBoe-

My

uacurra6y

npo6ureua

Hcnorb3oBa-

HHfr

npHnuBHofi

sHeprun

B

aroM

pafioHe

BbrxoAHT

3a

paMKH

oAHOTO

rOCyAapCTBa

H

craHoBuTcs Mot(Hauuoua.ntnofi.

Ha cesep

or

r.

CeH-MarIo,

ofuIuan

flSC

Panc, BAqtIb Bcero

n-sa

KoranreH

pacKHHynocb

MeJtKoBoAHoe

no6epexue

sartBa

JIa-MaHru

(puc.

l7.l). I'.rry6n-

HH

3Aecb

He BuxoAsr

sa

npe4enu

20'

uerpooofi

Ngo6arH

(sa

ItcKJItoqeHueM

ceaepHofi

qacrH

MexAy ocrpoBaMu

.Il,xepcu,

fepHcu

u On.qepnu,

rAe oHH

AocrHrau

50

r'1,

H lox(Hee

o.

MeHrue,

rAe HMelotcn

rny6HHbI

Ao

30

rtr).

Hop-

MaHACKHe

OCTpOBa,

nepexoAtqHe

Ha

tofe

B MHoroqHcJIeHHHe

puSu

(Meu-

xre)

n

Fpynny ocrpoBoB

roA o6urHM

Ha3'

BaHHeM

llloae,

npuerlexnn

BHHMaHI'Ie

QpaHuyecKux

cnequaJlHcroB,

3aHHMaB-

uHxcq

npoeKrnpoBaHneM

n3C.

3auan-

queofi

npeAcraBJlffercs

HAet

nepe6po-

cHTb nnoTHHbI

Me)I(Ay OCTpOBaMH,

3aM-

KHyrb

ux Ha

MarepHK,

qto6u

Hcnotb-

3OBaTb 3HeprHlo

npHJTHBOB,

KOTOpHe

3Aecb

AocrnnaK,t

12 ru, a 3HepronoreH-

uHuM

Hx

oueHHBaercf, s 100 urn. rBt.

Eute

n

caMoM HaqaJre nropoft

urponofi

sofrHu 6ura ony6lruxoBana

3aMerxa o

rpaHAHo3HoM npoeKTe

MeJrq

r.

Ox

npeA-

JroxHJr nJrornHaMu

Annuofi

| l5

xu, onn-

papulHMHcfl

Ha

HopuaHAcKHe ocrpoBa,

orceqb Bcro MqrIKoBoAHyro

aKBaTopHK)

(4750

rM2) eAoru no6epexbfl n-Ba

KoH-

TaHTeH.

fl.noruHa H

gJleKTpocranuut

MorrtHocrbro 25 u.nu.

xBr

(2500

arpera-

roB)

rye6yer

200 u.rrH. us

6etoHa,

I ru.nH. r MeraJIJra.

fcHo,

qTo

npoeKT

2S-r'rurruouuoft nOC

He

Mor

HMerb

pe-

EtrlbHoro 3HaqeHHfl

B Te roAbl,

KorAa

MoulHocrb Bcex

sJleKTpocraHuufi

OpaH-

unrr

cocraBJIsJIa

l0

uln.

rBr.

flpoexru

Meubtuux uacura6oB

pa3-

pa6aiurna.rrncb

c 1942

no 1958

r.

Il16l.

Aaunue

no

grHM

npoeKTaM

npHBe,[eHbl

n

ra6ur.

17.l

.

r

Electrotechnische

Zeitsch rif t,

1940,

l& l.

Ctorxoctu,

xapl.

Op.

TaOanua

Ocnoanue

Aarnbre

npo€Kror

tlgC

Ulocc

c 1942

no t958

r.

[116l

n3C

Mepcefi

x

1990

r. Sroi,ry

peuernro

cHHxeHHs

crouMocrn

I-I3C

sa cqer

npn-

MeHeHHfl

rrpn

crponTeJrbcrBe

cnoco6a

(creua

B rpyHTo (croHrr,tocm

I rBr.,r

cocraBsr

2,77

-

2,88

neHca).

flpoexr

n3C

Crpanrgopa-Jlox

(Ce-

BepHar

ldptaaavsl

[lZ5,2Og,

2Og, 28gl

npeAcraBnfler

oco6ufi

HHTepec,

no-

cKoJIbKy

B

HeM

o6ocHosaHa

3KoHoMH-

qecKaff

qelecoo6pa3Hocrb

ero oc)rulecrB-

JIeHHS

npu

orHocnTeJrbHo

ne6otrruofi

BeJIHTTHHe

npHnr{Ba (cpe4necnsurllfiHuft

i A ^natrrr6rr6a nn a-.'^'.' 'i?

fl

^^^-""i',

_.r.!

llJvAnLA^cr^lAyar

yynDrn a, LpcAnnn

3

u).

!,oxasaru

9To

yAurJrocb,

orreBuAHo,

noroMy,

qro

80% 3Heprocua6xeHas

Cenepnofi Hp;ran4nn

6asnpyercn

Ha

HeQrn,

Koropas

croHr

3Aecb Ha l5

%

Aopoxe,

qeM

B Aur,nuu.

O.IesuAHo, tro-

STOMy

TaKoe

IIpeAJIox(eHHe,

cAenaHHoe

n2

flpoext,

roau

Bo.u,onpouycxnue

orlepcrfig:

qrclo

X

ra6a-

pflTH,

M

225Xt5X14,5

looxr5xl6

I l0 000r*.

130

000.*.

Het

352X8,5X7,1

35 000...

30 000.r.

r46xr2xl0

Arperatu:

cHcJro X

X

Moutaocrb.

MBt

Vctasoa-

TEBBA'

raoulBocrb,

IBt

6!(

to

c)\

It

c.

Ol.

Ila

trtF

r3

E

t5

24

l5

E(

G

5

Q.

5I

i

!!!

RE!:

FEE

(Jlt

Orepn, 1942-1947

Be;rp, l95l-1952

Be.np, 1953

6yare,

1953

Bean,

1953

SGEF,

1955

SGEF.

1955-1956

EdF.

1955-1956

SGEF. I957

REH.

t958

540*

730

7N

650

6m

680

7n

730

45

36

40

3:l

35

38

37

150x20f

.

300x10..

590x10..

452Xr7

800x10

t562)(7

t232X7

l200xl0

448X20

600x20

3

5,9

7.3

8

10,8

9,6

tz

g,g

t2

i2

t2

l5

r5

l0

8

I

5

l8

IE

l6

l8

|

.ll,nyx6accefi

xoaas

cxeMa.

r'

BeprrKaabxHe

rupoarperarH.

.r.

fl-roUta.qb.

xr.

203

PHc'

l7-1.^B-a!^""11I

sneprera'{ecKoro

Hcnorb3oBanr{fl

sar.

Cex-MaJro

H

npHnenabrqHx

aK-

aaropnfi

[9,

l16,

156,263]:

5

L3?,

Tg,? +gf.f;I ,131?--t-nj1,,'r"-

Aoy,x6ac:"-njg??"...:.*gy",^.

r-T Bipr*r(anbnb,x

arperaroB,

.A,:

npoeKr

ran

rsss-rsso'_ri.,

-iaiioo-"di"fr*.i""""'^ii'J1"1'3ji;o'i-","i

i;"1-s-"i'.^I,"'ti:,r,'J"r%rlii:

:2E

TBr"f:

26

-ngc

Uoie,

-oarlca-cceiltio_"_r"

cxeMa.

lorrJCA--x*r3

H:Zo

n.

3-t.E

TBr.q;

J- ngc

Mexxre.

locr.u,r:G5

Kx;-_tI:30

_rt _g:Eo

lBl;1q'i'-'"p-.i[_n1+;

Lo"r-.or,:11s

*i]

.]:ezso

xu?;

5_

iriis""ft

"imlq'Jld:',fl;u**ini,j'lTxx;;8";J-".j"#Til#*m*f

i;"t,lni;,

.?-5,3

TBr.,t

n4

B arux

npoeKTax

paccMarDgBaJrocb

co3AaHHe

noqrn

npqMoyrolrtnol'o

6ac-

cefiHa

I-I3C

nyreM

Bo3BeAeHHfl

nJrorHH

o6ufefi

AanHofi

oKqrro

25

xu,

orceKaB-

R^^^^,",, E.Arr

Illnra

LraL\-GM lr.rrVU{aADIt,

(J

I

!,'f\J'

ao

730

xuz.

Ha 3anaAe rJrpruHa

npoxo-

AHT

or

r*r.

I'pyan

Ao

o.

IIIode no 6onuunu

rury6unaM, c ceBepa oT aroro

ocrpoBa

Ao

fpauaurr

-

no 6oree MeJrKoBoAHoMy

yqacrKy.

Tpaccu

nJrorHH

nu6npalucu

TaK,

qro6br

o6ecnequtr

MTIHHMaJIbHoe

BO3AefiCTBlre

Ha

arpenaTbr H BoAo[po-

nycKHbIe

orBepcrus nerponoii BoJIHbr,

Koropafl

Aocruraer

8 u.

B nepBbrx npoeKTax

Kopuonuca,

a

3areM

B 1921

r.

Mapa npeAJlariuracb

AByx6accefiHoBaff

ycraHoBKa,

ycoBep-

ueHcrBoBaHHaq

e 1942-1947

n.

Kaxo.

B 1955-1962

rr.

paapa6amrBarrucb

oAHo-

6accefi

uoBbre

ycraHoBKH,

Koropbre

pa3JIH-

TIATHCb

PACNOJIOXEHHEM

TPACCbI NJIOTH-

Hbr,

3BoJrroquefi

xancynbHbrx

arperaroB u

xoHcrpyxquefi

3AaHHfl

ll3C u

nJIorHH

(nonur rrcTcs

rop

H3oHTa.rrbHbre

Kancynb-

Hbre

arperarbr

runa

Pauc,

Koropbre

or

AuaMerpa

5,35

rr,r

AoruJIH

B npoexTax

1957-1958

rr.

Ao

8,2

v).

flpe4nararor-

cr TaKxe Ha[JraBHbIe

KoHcTpyKuI,IH KaK

nJrornHbr

(cna. puc.

13.8, 6), raK

I{

arpe-

rarHbrx H BoAonponycKHbrx

6.rtoxos.

3rr,r

KoMnoHoBKH 3HaqHTeJIbHo

onepe-

tnarr

TexnnqecKnfi

ypoeeHb roro

Bpe-

MeHr.r H npeAJraruurHcb

B

AByxttpycHoM

Hcno.nHeHuu

(pnc.

17.2) c

pacxo4orr,r

6e-

roua

0,5-l r'as/rBr

tl16l.

B

npoeKre 1957

r. 6uao npuHsro

coopyx(eHHe

TaK KaK B TO

BpeMs Cqr{TZIJIH,

qTO

STOT

BapHaHr 6y4er

BABoe

AeIueBJIe

Ha-

nJIaBHoro. flpe4noraraJlocb,

tITo

HMeH-

HO nepeMbrqKr.r

cnerlHaJrbHofi

xoHcrpyx-

I{HII

C OTKPbIBAIOUIHMHCff

BOPOTAMH

AN'

uponycKa

pacxoAoB

npH

nepeKpblTHH

o6ecne.rar

Bo3Mo)Kuocrb

no3TanHoro

BBoAa arperaroB

tI3C.

KoucrpyrqHr

nepeMblqeK

c LrcnoJIb3oBaHLIeM

KO'IOHH

HanJraBHofi

xoHctpyKunn

sBHJIacb

npo-

o6pasorra u.uen

Karo.

ocvulectsrenHoft

n

cenepHoft

nepeMblqKe

n3C

Pauc

(puc.

15.5). OAnaro

HMeHHo

nocJle

ero-

ro

orrblTa

HanJIaBHaq

KoHcTpyKIlHfl

BOC-

TOpX(eCTBOBaJra He

B nePeMblqKax,

a

B

3AaHHH ltOC

(cr'l.

$

12.2).

B noc.tleBoenublx

rrpoeKTax

IIIoge

ao

l97l

r. npeAJlarzulucb

BapHaHrbI

oA-

Pnc.

17.2.

,[nyxupyorue

KoHcrpyKllrrn

Ha-

nraBHblx 6Jroros

II3C

IIIose:

.t

-

3AaHBe

fl3C

-

6aox

na

qerupe

arperara

(78,4

MBr);

6-6aor

qerHpex

aoAonponycxnux

orrepcrnft

(400

r'rr)

Ho6accefiHosofi n3C

ABycropoHHeno

,qeftcreuR,

qro

flBJIrercr

orpaxeHHer\{

KoHuenuHH,

flpuHffTofi

SEUM H

peaJrH-

sosanHofi

B npoeKre

llSC Pasc.

B npoeKrax n3C

[Iose 1950-

1958

rr. Bsrro

(1950

r.)

6ruro

npeA-

JIOXeHO CAeJIaTb B

KOtIeHe OTCaChrBa|o-

urefi rpy6br

BepruKzurbHoro

arperara

or-

BepcTHe

AJrfl

flponycKa

pacxoAoB

BbrpaB-

3A

nepeMbIrIKaMH,

HHBaHHff TaK,

KaK

B

AOBOeHHOM

npOeKTe

Jlyr'r6oncxofi FI9C n

CCCP

(o't.

puc.

4.2, s). PaccuarpHBaJrocb

u

noA3eMnoe

pacnoJroxeHue

3AaHus IISC

Ha

o.

IIIoae,

a B npoeKrc

l95l

r.-

B noAseMHoM

ryH-

HeJIe

MexAy r'r. FpyeH

H o. IIIoge.

B i952-1958 rr.

las

o6oenoBaHr.rn

npoeKroB

fI3C [Ilose 6urn

pa3BepHyrbr

o6uupnue

u3brcKareJlbcKue H HccJreAo.

BareJrbcKue

pa6oru.

fIoA aruAoft

SEUM

u SOGREAH u

Apyrnx

opranusauuft

3Aecb BeJIHcb rn,qporpaQuqecKue

H reo-

.rroruqecxHe H3brcKaHHr. 6ulu

pa3pa-

6omHu H Hcno[b3oBaHbr HoBbre npu6opu

MN

ABTOHOMHOTO

I{

AHCTAHIIHOHHOTO

Ha6.nrcAeHns napaMerpoB

BoJrH, Teqe-

Hnfi, cxopocrefi,

Mnrpaqnu

HaHocoB,

r@nauuecKnx

MeroAoB

3oHAax(a rpyH-

TOB.

205

f-lnnrruartat'.ra rtuulra Enrbn *

.vrrrruL

Aqrlttuv

rrvJpwlnJttl

DDI_

nq'THHTE

psA

licc"ieAoBaHii*

rHApoAH_

HaMHqecKHX

H

SHepreTHqecKHx

xapaKTe-

pHcTHK

[pHJIHBa,

nO KOTOpbTM

c

no-

MOUIbTO

SneKTpHrrecKofi

MoA€.lrH

npHnHB-

I_o,Lq

sBJreHHs,

npeAnoxe_HHgfi

ts

aHrpya

12751, 6uax paccru{raHbr

[90]

nepeAaBa-

eMHe

aKTHBHbre

MOITIHOCTH,

a

TaKxe

pacceHBaeMar

u

peaKTHBHar

3HeprHfl

(cu.

$

2.2).

tlo arHM pacqerau

6ur.nu yc-

TAHOBJIEHbI

OTHOCHTEIbHbIE

3HAqEHHg

pa3nnqHbrx

gHeprococTaBnflIorrlHx

6a-

raHca

npHnHBa

H OKa3aJIOCb

BO3MOX-

HbrM

onpeAeJIHTb

BO3MyIqeHHs,

KOTOpbre

BHecer

nOC

B sHeprernqecKHe

noroKu

(cu.

rn.

l0).

,{,.nx

onpeAeJreHuq

BJTHsHHff

Ha

npn-

n4Bg

xopr.rorulconofi

cnJrbr, pexHMoB

flSC

u rnApasJruqecxgx

yc;ronufi

npH

npou3BoAcrBe

pa6or

6nn

co3AaH psA

uoAe.tefi.

B

1954

r.

6u.na

cG3AaHa

Me

Aenb

Bcero

pafioHa

Jla-Maurua,

no-

crpoeHHafl

B

HaUUOUa.rlrHOfi

rHApaBau-

,Iecxofi

.rra6oparopnu

lllary, Ha

xoropofi

peruanncb

Bonpocbr

nepeKpbrruc

6ac-

cefiHoe.

3areu

6u.rra co3AaHa

MoAenr

Taxoro

xe

Macrura6a

Ha

apaularcueficn

!{alQopr're

pa3MepoM

14

u

(fpeuo6lr,

SCGREAH),

sHssunuas yMeHbrrreHue

Be.lturruHbr

npHnuBa

ua

0,5

u.

floc.[e

eu-

'ruqecKHx

uo4elefi,

noKagaJru,

rITo

rlpH

Moutnocru

n3C

5,5

fBr

Bqrrquga

rpu-

JruBa yr\{enbruaercs

ua

I M, a Bbrpa6orxa

Ha

l0

%o,

a

npu

Mou{HocrH ngc

22 tBr

aupa6orxa

cHnxaercfi.

Ha 20

o/o.

Kpoue

yKa3aHHbrx

B ra6.n.

17.l

npoeKroB

nOC

IIIose

s

19il r.

KepspaH

[peA.Ilo)rfi.n

[9,l9ll

coopyAurr

Ha n-oBe

KmaHreH

nOC

Jlecce

n

apyrue,

pa6o-

TaroqHe_

no

npHHqHIIy

AsofiHOro

npH-

JIHBa.

Hcnonrsya

pa3Hocrb

Qas

npn-

JtirRa rvn6r:rrrr ar^TosarDlauulra D wah6

J

VrstrvDrrutlllug D

rrLy!-

uefixe

noJryocrpoBa,

cMoryr

pa6omm

noA

HanopoM,

o6paayrorquMcff

npu

npHnHBe

c

oAHofi

cropoHbr nqryocrpoBa

u

orJIHBe

c

Apyrofi

cropoHbr.

floAeoAs-

IrrHe

H

orBoAsutue

KaHaJrbr

o6pasyrorca

pacuHpeHHeM

pycn

peK, reKyulHx

c Bo-

206

E^n ^o 16 t - l-I^ '.. W ^^ r-t^^

ArryoJAuro.

rrv

AannrlrJu

r\cpt'pdHa,

llJ(-

n-^^

.,/

LS\-LE

rvtlr/r\cl

AaDa.tD

IrcupcpDiltnyru

Mou{-

Hocrb

or

50

,qo

120

MBr

a

reqeHue

7GT0

rr

p_,Lo:Ay.

OAuaxo

ro

noAcqerana

Xu6pa

tl56l

Anfl

no.rryqeHus

AonycrnMbrx

no-

Tepb Hanopa

B noABoAflrrlHx

KaHa.rrax

HM

npHAercr npHAaTb

TaKHe pa3Mepbr,

nplr

KOTOpbTX npoeKT

oKa3brBaeTcq

HepeHTa-

6qrrHuu.

Bosnparrarcb

K npoeKry

n3C

IIIoge

no

o6uqsofi cxeue,

npuxoAnTcs

orMe-

rnrb,

r{To

c

1958

ao

l97l

r. no

HeMV

He

6ur.no

nogpo6nux

ny6.nuxauufi.

bro,

oqeBHAHo, o6ttcnflercr

cocpeAoroqe-

HHeM Bcex

cHJr

Ao

1967 r.

Ha npoeKTe

nOC Pauc, peaJrH3auur

Koroporo

no-

rpe6onala

HcKJrroqHTe.[bHoro

Hanp

rx(e-

HHfl,

u

peuaJra

6yayuree

acefi npodrrer*rur.

floc.ne

nycKa n3C'

PaHc

npoeKrHpoBa-

nne

fI3C

IIIose 6u.no

npeKpaqeHo

BBH-

Ay

nHqsr.rsueficg

rorAa

Bo3Molr(Hocru

crpouTerrbcrea

A3C

npu

MeHbrrrnx

Ka-

tIHTruroBJroxeHurx.

Kpoue

roro,

oqe-

BHAHo,

Aeficrsodaar

H

Apyrne

coo6pa-

)r(eHufl.

B

nepcnexrHse

l5-20

ner aHep-

rocucreMbr

crpaHbr

He MorurH 6u

npuHarr

fipepHBucryro

H

nynbcHpytoutyrc

or

4

Ao

12

fBr

Morrtuocrb

IISC

IIIose, raK

xaK,

HecMoTpfl

Ha

AOKa3aHHyrO

npr{

gKcnJrya-

Tsrrur.r

II3C

Panc

Bo3Mox{Hocrb pe€Mu3a-

IIHH

UITKNON

[r,r6PA,

B

CYIqCCTBYIOIIIHX

u nepcneKTHBHbrx

BOAOXpaHHIHUaX

fOC nesogMoxHo

6u.no 6u

ocyr4ecrBnTb

MelKcH3urufiuoe

perynupoBauae

nAC.

A.nrrepHaruBa

KpynHoMacurra6soro

uc-

nq,lb3oBaHr{g

SHepro[oTeHrII{aJra

tlpH-

1959-1961

m.

[4],

npu coBMecrHofi

pa-

6qre

nOC

KoraHren

(50

fBr,

120

TBix

x v)

c

f3C

IIIseqHu

u

Hopaeruu

(puc.

17.3)

ne

6nrra

ocytqecrB.,reua

or-

HroAb

He

no TexHHqecKHM

rIpHqHHaM.

OAnaxo

aHeprerr.rrrecxufi

KpH3Hc

BhrABHHyn

npoeKT,

B

KoropoM 6u.n

cAe-

nan flepBuft

urar B

HanpaBJrenuu

arofi

aJrbrepHarusril.

B 1974

r.

SHepreruuec-

Kas,

KoMHccHs

crpaH

O6qero

pHHKa

paccMqrpeJra

npoeKr

Kaxo [l

16l, Ko-

mnrti? nhail^hah'dF -.^..-..-:t

LvyDIr

rllrtA!raDJlrlJr

Dnr4ullSluctltiltlblltl

npoeKr

flSC

MeHKbec

nnoqaAbro

aKBa-

fi,pHu

I100

KMz

H

4nyx6acceftnosofi

cxeuofi

(puc.

17.4).

B

npoexre

Kaxo

l97l

r.

crBop nJro-

THHbr

npoxoAHT

Ha Klre

B BHAe

AyrH

oT

Ceu-Ma.no

Ao

o.

Menrue, T.

e.

gHaqu-

TeJIbHo

3anaAHee

crBopa

n3C

III6ss.

a Ha

ceBePe

oH

oTceKaeT

aKBaTOpHIO

HH-

3oBoro

6accefiHa

or

o.

Mesxre

Ao

M.

Kaptepe.

fl.rtoulaA+.

6accefiHo^s

.cocraB-

asdt

no

1500

xuz.

3AaHue

IISC

(200

ar-

peraroB no 30

MBt)

npeAn-oJlarzulocb

pac[oJlox(HTb

B

nJIoTHHe

MeHxle

-

IIIose.

Taxas

Asyx6acceftHosaq

cxeMa

o6ecnequ.na

6u

npH

uuKne ,llexepa

ro

nnur/rrr or-rnc6rtrrv 39 TBt.q nDH

KOIle-

ffiil;ti;;;'o's,s

r"

o rBt.

A'rru-

Ha rnyxoft

n.noruuu

35

u

BoAonponycK-

noft 50

KM

rPfi

PacxoAe

qepee

nocneA-

Hroro 500

rblc.

tr.t8/c.

Ha

uelxoBoAbe

Mex(Ay

o.

IIIose

H

fpaunuey^IpeAy-

cMarpuBanocb

coopyxeHne

AOC-

B

1974

r.

nPH

PaccMorPeHI{H

npoeK-

ra a

Snepnert'IqecKofi

xotrluccnu

crpaH

O6uero

pbIHKa

os

6nu

o[KJIoHeH

KaK

HeSKOHOMUqHufi.

Kporue

rofo'

HaceJIe-

HHe

npn6pen<rii,ix

pafioiion

onporecro-

BaJro

ero

Hs-sa

HapyueHufi

aroltornn s

p€ynbrare

ugl,leHeHufi

npH

4nyx6ac-

cefiHosoft

cxeMe

ecrecrBeHHoro

pHTMa

I'I

BeJTHqHHbI

rpHnHBa

(c

12

ao

6 u). flpu-

MeHeHHe

Asyx6accefiHosofi

cxeMbr

Ae-

KeDa

noBropuno

orun6xy

npoeKroB

nAC

Kioa,qH

tdZS

n

1963

rn.

(cu.$

l8.l),

KorAa

ot6op

sHeprHH

oKa3blBiulcfl

cy-

ulecTBeHHO

HHXe

TexHl'IqecKoro

noTeH-

qnana

ra

rpe6oaan

coopyxeHufl

Aonon-

Hure;rrsoft

pa3Ae.IIHTeJIrnoft

nJIoftHHbI H

207

)

Pwc.

17.4.I-Ipoexr

flOC

MeHxue

[263]:

,

-

3AaHHe

[ISC;

2

-

aoaonponycKxbre

orBepcrga

noqTH

noJrHofo

ay6nuponaHHfr

MOrrlHO-

CTH.

B 1976

r.

6una

cAeJraHa

erqe

oAHa

nonbrTKa

BepHyTbcfl

K

OAHO6aCCefiHO-

BOH

CXeMe:

[peAJraraJrocb

ocyulecTBr.rTb

ee KaK

nepByro

oqepeAb

npoeKTa

l97l

r.

c

coxpaHeHHeM

TOri x(e

MorqHocrr{

6 fBr.

Xu6pa

cqHTEUI,

rITo

raKafl,

HJ1H

AalKe

6dnrruas

Morr{Hocrb

rrpH

oAHo6accefi-

K eHeprocHcreMe

EgC.

flosre

3roro

nP_or{3ourJro

HeKOTOp

Oe O)rsBJreHr{e

HAeH

flSC

IIIoser

H B

1980

r.

6u.nu

AaKe

o6b-

lB_i-reHbr

ToprH

no

peanfi3arlHH

rrpoeKTa

[981.

Ho rr

aro

npeAnox(enne

rocrur.ra

VIIaCTb IID€TIITII|-IIIII nnalrrrr-t lt ^IIIrn-

ou.".f

"

o

i

;;-fr

di-' ;'

; ;;; ;;;

;"." ;'

:

npedrraAaHHeM

A3C

(n

1990 r.

rpeAro-

JIo)KHTeJrbno

74

%)

ueMoryra

6u 6urr

on-

paBAaHa

6es xoMneHcnpoBaHuoro

pery-

Jrr.rpoBaHufl

. OAuaxo, yquTbrBar

npeAno-

aaraeuufi

r

20i0

r.

pocr

enepronorpe6-

aeHas

crpaH

E3C na

ffi

o/o

[19]

u

uc-

qepnaflHe

perrHbrx

sHepropecypcoB,

BxrroqeHue

120

TBr.,r

npn.nunuofi

aHeprHH

HMqrro

6u

cyuecrBeHHoe

3Ha-

qeHue

Ans

o6ecneqeHus

6asucHofi

pa6o-

rbr

A3C

-T3C.

208

i4ueuHo

roeroMy

s lg82

r.

eHoss

6Hn

paccMorpeH

npoexr

IIOC

KoraHreu

_

I{enrp

no

MoAepHH3HpoBaHHoMy

uuKny

Kaxo,

B KoropoM

B rreJlrx

H3qrrsunu

no-

6epexrx

or Herarr.rBHbrx

eogAeficreur?

Ha

gKorrorHqecKyro

cHcTeMy

c [oMorrlbro

KoJIbrIeBofi

Aau6u

4.nuuofi

69 xr*l

o6pa-

3oBaJIHcb

ABa

6accefiua

[nou{a.{bto

tto

100

xruo

xaxAsrfi.

Ha

yvacrKax

coeAH-

HeHHff pa3AeJlr{Tgrruofi

flnoruHbr

c

xo.nrqenoft

aana6ofi

npeAnaranocb

pac"

no,roxr.rrb

ABa

3AaHHq

n3C,

oKpyxeH-

HHx

[JrorHHaMH

AJrff

KoMMyraunn

6ne_

Qon.

B srux

nJrorr.rHax

AoJrxHbr

6urs

pacnorox(eHH

BoAonponycKHbre

coopy-

xeHuq.

B

o6oux

flSC

pa3Meuraercs

-56

arperaroB

o6rqeft

MorrlHocrbro

1,44

fBr

u

ro4onofi

nnrpa6orxoft

5,3

TBr.q

13021.

floHeruo,

,{ro

Hens6exHufi

npu arofi,

KaK

v npH

.nro6oft

4nyx6accefiHonofi

cxeMe,

nyJrbcupyrontufi

rpaQux

MoutHp-

CTH

HE

IIO3BOJIflET

BKJIIOqflTb

EC

B

CHCTC.

uy

o6qeHaquoHaJrbHono

sHepronorpe6-

.,IEHI,I'.

Tax,

yr

B

coBpeMeHHbrx

ycnoBHrx.

rroArBep)KAaercr

peuenue

196l

r.

[9],

B

KOTOpOM

npeAnariMocb

ocyqecTBHTb

MexcH3Hruftsoe

penynHpoBaHHe

IISC

Koraureu B BoAoxpanuJrHulax

cKaHAH-

HaBcKHx

f3C.

PaccnorpflM,

HacKorrbKo

gra

coBpe-

MeHHas

CHTyarIHs

onpaBAblBaeT

TaKoe

pelueHr.re.

C.negyer

yqecrb,

qro

onbrr

n3C

Pauc

u

Kuc.nory6cxofi,

a raK)r(e

npoex-

MeHHbrx

ycnoBucx

Heo6xoAHMo

vqecrb,

qTo

K 1980

r. nHKoBaq

MourHocrb B

qacbt

norpe6leHhfl

crpaHaun

CKIIfI9

(Coroa

no

KoopAHHauHH

npoH3BOACTBa

H nepe-

AaqH

3Hepruu 3anaAHofi

Enponsl) coc-

TaBItAra

140

I'Br.

Ha

arofi MourHocru

vqacrBoBaro

B MexHaunoHd.truou

o6-

r,reHe

36 I-Br

(no

nupa6orxe

71,5 fBr'u),

B

ToM

qHcJIe

ao

OpauuHH

H3

nupa6orxu

258

TBr.q

n o6ueHe

yqacrBoaaao

12,5.

gror

o6r"reu

3aKflrcqaJlct

ruIaBHblM 06-

pa3oM

B

aKcnopresIlranuro

H

lllsefiua-

ilnro

na6uroqHofi

Ho,IHofi

eHeprHH H B

HMnopre

nHxosofi

AHeenoii

3HepFHH,

a

TaKxe

B Mexce3oHHoM

o6ueHe.

Kpo-

r',re

CKflflS

s

3an.

EaPone HMeerct

odreArEseuue

HOPAOJI,

s Koro-

poM

cocrorr

,[.auut,

[IIneqHr,

Hopne-

rus

H

@HHlgHAHq,

HOPASJI

raKx(e

yqacrByer

n o6ueHe

c CKflllS.B

1986 r.

tlponoxeHbr

xa6e.nssue

JIHHHI{

qepe3

JIa-MaHru

nponycxnofi

cnoco6Hocrurc

2

fBr.

O,resuAHo,

r{To

yxe

AocrgrHyrble

uacrurd6u

o6uesa

aueprnefi

AoKa3bIBa-

IOT

TeXHHqeCKyIO

BO3MOXHOCTb

H

pea.Ilb-

nocru

o6ueua

n3C

Korasrcu

-

cKaH-

AHHaBcKHe

f3C,

xorq

3To H

notpe6yer

yBernrreHus

paccronHufi nepeAaqu

Ao

1500-2000

ru. OAHaKo

onblr

npoeKrn-

poBaHHs

nepeAaqH

nocToflHHoro

roKa

rrloulnocrsrc

6

I-Br

npu Harpflx(eHHH

1500 xB or 3xu6acry3a

B l{enrp

(CCCP)

na 2414

KM

noATBep)KAaer

peaJlbHocrb

aroft

uAen.

Ocraetcs

paccMorperb Ha

coBpeMeH-

rueHHH

f3C

Lllneqnu,

HoPeeruu

s lllnefiuapur.

3ru crpaHu

o6qa,qarcr

6o.nruruuu

rAApo3HepropecypcaMlr,

Ko-

Topbre

B sHaqurenuHofi

Mepe

yx(e

Hc-

nqrlb3oBaHu:

n

HopBerHH

no

MourHocrH

,ro IQA rr^nn 'Lo^oo-n IOA TRr

p

fflnari-

nJ ruv

IllllvdlDJvpqlrv

Ivv LU

rr

e

ssvrr

uapuH

no nupa6otxe

Hcnoflb3oBaHo

37

TBr.

q, r{ro

npu6uruxaercs

K

l@

o/o

3KoHoMHqHbIx

pecypcoB,

s IIIneUHH

no

nupa6orxe

HcnoJrb3oBaHo

62

us

85

TBrxc*. 3Ha,IeHHe

Anq

perueHus

AaH-

Hoft

sagauu

3THx xe HcnoJIb3oBaHHbIx

H

OCTapulHXcs

rHAp@HepropecypcoB

cocroHT

B

ToM,

qro

oHH o6,.na,u,arcr 6onl-

*

Bce

AaHHbIe

no Hcno.ttb3oaaHrp

3KoHo-

MnqecKoro rHAposHepronoreHllnaJIa

npHqe-

AeHhr

no

crarncrHqecKnM

exeroAHHKaM

OOH.

14

gar.

tazl

ITIHMH

BO3MOx(HOCTflMH

PeryJlHpOBa-

Hns

(o6utr.rii

o6ter'r BoAoxpaHnauut

i-3C

arr.rx crpaH

coorBercrByer

33 TBr.

q

aHepruu),

6raroAapx

KoTopbrM

oHH Mof-

JtH

6u

ocyut€crBuTb

MexcH3unufiHoe

penynHpoBaHue cBepxMoulHoro o6reAu-

HeHHq

KoTauteH

-

n3C Be.nHxo6pura-

HHI{.

fIoHHTno,

qro

ycraHoBKa

AononHH-

TqrrbHblx

arperaToB

lurfl

Hcna[b3oBaHH

ff

BOAHbTX

pecypcoBi

c3KoHoMJIeHHbrX B BO-

AoxpaHHnnutax

cyurecrBylou[.rx I-3C,

npeAcraBJrsercfl c.lroxuofi H

Aoporocro-

qlr1efi

eaAatrefi

B Tex cJlyqasx,

KorAa

HMeercs

noA3eMHoe

3AaHHe

I-OC.

Ho s

sTHX

yCJTOBHflX MO)I(HO 3aMeHHTb rHApO-

arperarbr

Ha o6parnrraue.

Kpor're

roro,

ycraHoBKa

AonoJIHHTeJIbHbIX

arperaToB

BO3MOXHa

C MeHbtxHMH

3arpaTaMH

Ha

BHoBb

co3AaBaeMsrx

f3C.

Taxuu

o6pasou, Ha ocHoBe coBpe-

MeHHbrx

rexHurrecKux Bo3Mo)Kgocreft u

c

yqeroM

Hx

peaJrbHo

nponHo3HpyeMofo

nporpecca Mox{Ho

npeAcTaBHTb TaKyIo

HHrepnperauHn

KoMnJreKca

n3c

Ko-

raHreH

-

n3C Be.nr.rxo6pfiranrr'.

n3C

KoMnJreKca MourHocrsro

50

fBr

sxarcqa-

Jrncb

6u B aHeprocHcreMbil 3anaAHofi

Enponu,

oxBarHBaroulue

rarcKe

Cxas-

AHHaBHro.

B BoAoxpaHuflHulax

ernx

crpaH

aKKyMynHpoBruacb

6ur

qacrb

3HeprHr{ cugxruftHsrx

trpHJIHBoB,

flp€-

Bbruaputas

aHeprHto flSC

npu cpeAHHx

npHJrHBax

(puc.

17.3),

qro

cocraBJlser

ga

5-AuesHbrfi

nepHoA

oKoJIo

I TBrxq.

3ro

aKKyMynHpoBaHHe

He tpe6yer

Mr coorBercrByroulne

f3C

yMeHbluator

cBoro

orAar{y. Muxyn

5

cyr

cpeAHHx

npHnHBoB,

peqHble

f3C

s

[epHoA KBaA-

paryp

Bo3BpaIIIaJIn

6u

B cncreMy

3Hep-

rnto, HaKonneHHyp Bo

BpeMfl

cH3HrHH,

t r|rrrrprJnrrnwg FlrJvTnrrMe('guHvLr IreneR-

"'r--

HoMepnocrb

orAaqH n3C.

t{ro

xacaercfl coBMeIrreHHt BoJIH

npn-

lrHsHofi

3HeprHH

c

BoIIHaMu norpe6.ne-

uun

(aHyrpncyroqHoe peryJIHpoBaHHe),

lu UHU Murlttrr ubrtb uLyulttlr,l€rlu

HL-

noJrb3oBaHHeM

Hac@Horo eQSeKTa

npa

coBMecrHofi

pa6me

c T3C n A3C, a

raK-

xe

ycraHosxoft

AorroJrHHTeJIbHbrx

HJrH

o6parnuux

arperaroB

Ha cyrqecTByro-

urux

FA3C

qacrnrrHo

n cauofi

@pax[nn,

Ho

r"taBHbIM o6paaortr

e

IIIsefiqapHH H

209

roAbr

[oJlHocTbro

noATBepAr{nH

KoHqen-

Iluro,

no,Iox(enHyro

B

ocnoBy

cxeMbl

n3c

Koraureu.

Buecte

c

reM

HccJreAoBaHr{s

Ha

MareMarnqecKrx

u

QusuuecKux

MoAe-

JIrx

noKa3aJrr.r

seo6xoAuuocrr

yqera

R,trttgl.lrr<t na6rrrrrr naa va Earrrrrrturt

rsvvr|J

I

rvv rlq

gLJrnannJ

trpuJrr.rBa,

,4rrfl

yc.nosnft

IISC

KorasreH

eto

rpe6yer yMeHbureHuq

ee

[apaMer-

pon.

fIpuHHMar

sro yMeHbrueHue

(a

sa-

nac

pacqera)

na

30

%

H

yqnrbrBafl

Bo3-

Molr(Hocru

oSteAnsensg

n3C

KoraH-

reH

c ilSC Benuxo6pvraHHH,

tto

coBpe-

MeHHbrM

Hx npoeKral,t

(u,,r.

r.u.

16) Mox(-

HO yCTaHOBraTb,

qTO

napaMeTpb[

TaKoro

KoMnJreKca

6yayr

paBHbr

npex(HHM

no-

Ka3arerrrM

flSC

KoraHreH.

B

orHorueuuu

3Heprerr{rrecKoro

3Ha-

qeHHfl

KoMn.neKca

Koraureu

B

coBpe-

Ancrpuu,

rAe

HMercTcfl

Bo3Molt(Hocrn

cyToqHofo

KoMneHcHpoBaHHs.

-

Tax, npeA.rloxenntrfi

eule

B l96l

r.

[91

rrrottlHufi

KoMnJIeKc

tlSC

s coBpeMeHHbtx

)/enoBnflx

c eur.e 6oauunu

aQQexrcu

pac-

rIABA

I8

NP}4N|-'1F,HA'

3HEPT'19

B CEBEPHOI4

AMEP]4(E

r8.l.

ctlJA

l8.l.l.

l]poexrut

flSC Kaoeer

flpo6.nertra

HcnoJIb3oB

aHufl

'

np

HIHB-

Hofi

aHeprHH

s

CUIA

Ha

nPorf,xeHun

60

.rret HeH3MeHHo

6u;Ia

cBq3aHa

c npo-

eKroM

flSC

fIaccaMaKBoAAH

(KnoaaH).

3ro

o6rqcHqercq

reM,

qro

na

no6epexu-

sx CIIIA

6o.ntruue

npHJIHBbI

Ha6lpAa-

rorcff

ToJrbKo

Ha 3anaAe

(A.nacxa),

rAe

tlpoMbrIuJIeHHoe

pa3BHTHe

6u.tto He3Ha-

qHTeJIbHbrM,

a

B

cucreMe

eanusos

flac-

caMaKBoMu

n

Ko6cxyK,

BnaAapIIrHX

B

gar.

@aH4u

(pr.rc.

l8.l),

Be.rHrIHHa

npu-

JIHBoB

y r. Hctnopta

A"o

:

5,48

u

(A"o

"r"

:

7,50 u;

A"p

*":

3,36

t't;

/,"*"

:7,95

r'r) u

n.ltoqaAn

3aJIHBoB

flaccauaxBoAAu

H

Ko6cryx

cocraBJlfl-

ror coorBercrBeHHo

355-260

H

95

-

67 rrtl2.

KpbrBaer

Bo3MoxHocTH

nprrnnnofi

3HeprHH

A.rrfl

crpaH SanaAHoft

Enponu,

o6ecneqnsa.B

BHAaqy

MoIIlHocrH B

qacbl

nHK H onrnManbHyro

pa6ory

c HeH3MeH-

uofi

naoruHocrbro T3C n AAC.

HHe

npoeKra c

nepaoft oqepe4n

xar,4ayx6ac-

cefixouo!__ycraHoBKn

B

9i{:

Ko6cxyx

(a

npe-

Aenax

CIlnl.

B

cxeue

1935

r.

saa.

Ko6criyr

AonxeH

6ua

ucnoat3oBarbcs

no

o4Ho6accefi-

noeoft cxeMe

oAnocropoHHero

geficrann

(pnc.

18.l). flSC uourHocrbp

210

MBr

H

cneuuaJlbno

nocrpoegnaa

I'A3C

MoulHocrbto

68,5

MBr o6ecneqngaxlr

BbrAaqy

HenpepHB-

Hoft

r*roulHocru 30 MBr c roaosbft

adpiOor-

xofi

264 I'Br.q.

flpoexr,

orKoppeKrrpoeanHufi

npaBH-

TeJrbcrBeHnofi

xouuccnefi OaeunHra,

HaqaJr

ocyqecrBnflrbcn

B

anpene

1935 r.

Bo BpeMs

4oroennofi

Aeflpeccuu

3a cqer

accHrxoBaHnf,

Ha

Hero 37

wrs.

AoJIJI.

Hs

cpeAcrB

$oHla

6opa-

6u

c

6espa6orsqeft.

B

1936

r.

6uln

ony6auroaanbr

.q,aHHHe

o

croHMocrr

crpoflTeJlbcrsa

62 MrH.

AoJIt.

H

croHMocrn

3HeprfiE I

ueHr/(xBr.

'r)

(auecto

30

u.nH.

Aonr.

no npoeKry

1925 r.). floxasa-

TerH

artbTepHarHBHbrx

HcrortHuKoB:

TOC

-

14,9

MtH.

Aonx.

n

0,49

uenr/(rBr.'l),

f3C

-

22

uau.

AotJI.,

0,187

qeHr/(xBr.v)

nDH

cDer,Heft

cronuocrH

sHeprHH

a CIIIA

n

l03o r:

0,63

uenr/(rBr.q)

[61.

flpoexr Bbr3BaJr

pe3Kyro

KpHrHKy.

B roprvefi

noJreM[Ke,

pa3BepHyBruefics

s

AuepnxaHcxol'r

o6ulecrBe fpaxAaHcKxx

uH-

tKpHepoB,

SroT

npoeKT Ha3Ba.tIH

(AoporocTot-

rqnr'r KanpH3oMr

(PUrc

-

npeAceAareau

o6-

u{ecrBa

rpaxAancKHx

HnxeHepon)

n

(aKoHo-

B l92l

r.

A.

Kynep

npeAnoxrn

rBYx-

6acceftHonyrc

cxeMy

no

uuKny Aexepa

c Hc'

noJtb3oBaHHeM

saJI.

flaccaMaxaogH

(Kana-

,qa)

rax BepxoBoro,

a sar!.

Kotcqyx^(C${)

r<eK Hrr.?r'noro nDr{ MorrHocrtr II3C 400

MBr

KaK HH3oBoro

npu

Molr,Hocrll

IISC

400

MBr

r rolosoft nnoa6orxe

3 TBr'q

(pnc.

18,1,6).

Pnc.

18.1.

Eoarruas MexHaqHoHaJIbHas AByx-

6acceftroa4fl cxeua

guepreruqecKoro

nctroJlb-

soBaHHt

3aJIHBoB

flaccanaxsoA,q,H

H

Ko6cxyx

u napnanrH

[9]:

I

-

no4onpouycKgbre

orBepcrrrt

xanoasexnn-40

rur.

It

nrnrco

(npo-exr

1959 r. i

npoexr

Kynepa

l92l r.):

2

-

naornsu

no

npoeKTy 1959

r.:

3

-

naornHu

no

npoeKry

l92l r.; 4-nroruxa

H

ulrrlos

tro npoerTav

l92l

r.;

5

-

50

BoAonpouycrnux

orEepcrafi

no

npo'

exry

1959

r.;

6

-

70 soAoupouycKgux

mnepctnfi

no

npoexry

1959 r.;

7

-

urarcs

no

npoeKry 1959

r.;

I

-

nroruqH n^ nnncr?w IQEQ r. 9-Boront|onvcxt|He

orBepcrnfl

no trpoeKTy l92l r.;

I0

-

rnaros no

npo'

exty

l92l

r.:

I1- nroruna rr

trrtpg no

npoeKry

l4*

MnrrecKHM

6esiuueur

-

1925 r.

npeAtaranocb

Haqarb

ocyulecrBne-

coHoBcKHff

HHCTI{TyT

ryMeHra-

uHr

3Byqa{a BecbMa

y6e,qureauHo.

,lleficrauTeJrbno,

nocKonbxy

AJtc.

nory-

qenHs

o6ecneqennofi

uoutHocrn

30

MBr

no-

rpe6onaaacb

ycraHoBKa

MoulHocrbn

280

MBr,

rpoMaAHbre

nJIorHHbt, IIIJIp3bt,

4au6nr,

t.

e.

npn

saiparax

xa I xBr

o6ecneqeunofi Mourno-

.Tu tOOO no:rr.

+.

erotf Mocrh .aHenrrgt nnr,r

iro"

-"o"rri"t'r'u""iii*g".

ul. iiTo

"p.ili-

KaK

rpu B.lloxeHEH

xa I xBr 550

4oa;1,

a

tou

xe

pafione Morrn 6uru coopyxeHbl

fOC,

gHeprns

Koropbrx

o6ouraacs

6u

s

5

pa3

Ae-

ureBrre

-

0,187

ueHt/(xBr'u).

B

1936

r., KoFAa

Ha

crponreatcrse

6uao

saHsro

5000

qea.,

nocrpoeH

pa6bunfi

nocenor,

BO3BeAeHbI

HeKOTOpHe

nJlOTHllbI,

AHAaHbl

3a-

xasu

$npmaM

Ha 43

uas.

AoJIJI.

H

3arpaqeilo

7 uan,

.{oJr,n.,

crpoHTenbctao

6blao

npeKpa-

ureno

[9].

-

n""""e

o cronMocrfix

no

AoBoeHHbrM

[poeKraM

Kao.q.qn

npHBeAedH I

ueuax

coor-

BercrBypqHx

rer.

2il

210

Kasanocu,

qro

npoeKT 6un

rro,xopo-

HeH.

OAHaxo noA

Bd'rHqHHeM

Qpauuvs-

cKHx

npoeKToB

usoro6acceiiHoeHx cxeN{

tl3C

(cu.

$

l5

l) 6ur.nn

npeAroxeHbr

co-

orBercrBeHHo

B

l94l

u 1959-1961

fr.

HoBbre, TaKlr(e

4nyx6acceiruonsre

H TaK-

)Ke

3KoHoMHqecKH

He

o6ocHosaHHsre

IIpoeKrbr.

Ha ocHose HoBoro

corflaureHHs

MelK-

Ay

CIIIA

H

KaHalofr

BbrAenflrlocb

3,9 u.nu.

AoJIJr.

Ha

ccrcTaBJreHne

npoeK-

Tf,

no

KoTopoMy

npeAycMaTpHBaJrocb

ocyulecTBJIeHHe

npe4lox<eHHofi

eule B

l92l r.

6onuruoft

,qeyx6accefiHoeofi

cxe-

uu.

O,[HaKo nocJre paccMorpeHuq 60

ea-

pHaHTOB

H nepeHoca

cTBopoB

pa3AeJIu-

TeJrbHbrx

n,rornH

(puc.

l8.l,a)

6ur.ra

npeAJrox(eHa

4nyx6accefiHosaq

n3C c

ycraHoBJleHHori

MourHocrbro

345

MBr,

KoMneHcupveuoft

f3C

PeuxHH-PanHAs

MoulHocrbto

460

MBr

H

nupa6orxofi

1,22

TBr.u,'ro4.

Als

cucreuu

rapaH-

THpoBaHHaff

MourHocrb

cocraBllqer

555

I'Br u

nrtpa6orra

3,06

TBr.q.

I-loxaaare.nu

3Tofo

npoexra

(o6uran

croHMocrr

687 MJIH.

,4oJrJI.

H

cronMocrb

I

rBr.q2,62

rreHra

AJlr

CIIIA

H

4,82

qeHTa

A.[q

KaHaAbr

npH croHMocrH

3Hep-

rr.u.r

T3C

coorBercrBeHHo

1,06 u 0,73

ueHra

aa I xBr.q

t96l)

BbTHyAHTIH

o6te-

AHHeHHyro

Arrrepr.rxaHo-KauaAcKyto

Ko-

MHccHro (MOK)

npH npeAcraBreuHn

Ao-

KJraAa

B

npaBurerbcrBa CIIIA

u

KaHa-

Abr

B

arpene

196l

r. cAeJrarb

BbIBoA:

(ocyurecrBJleHue

npoeKTa

nOC

3KoHo-

MHr{ecKH

He

onpaBAauo>

[961.

KnaAa

MOK nporxeJ

Bcero

oAHH

Mect[,

-

c yAHBneHHeM

nHCaJI

rJIaBa

KOMna-

Huu

Boston

Edison Anu.na,-

I(aK

npe-

3HAeHr

KeHHeAu

2O

uas 196l

r.

nopy'{Hr

nepecMoTpeTb

npoeKT

c

yBeIHr{eHHeM

Mrtttrrrrlr.Tu nn I I-Flr nnu unnn nLertFt,|I{Lru

.trvJHr.vv

^

L|JL rrrrr.rvrrve

ee

B

TeqeHue

I

q

nHKoBoro

norpe6aeHua,

c reM

qro6u

cAeJlarb

npoeKT

3KoHoMH-

qecKH

qerecoo6pa3HbtM)

[961.

Conoctas-

JIeHHe

HeKoropbrx

Saxron

no3Borqer

pacKpbrrb

npHrrnHy aroro:

llV l96l

f.

B

KaHaAcKoM

x(ypHare

Canadian

Uon-

sulting

Engineer

6u.na onyfurnxonaHa

cTaTbfl,

H3JIaraBLIraq

KOHqenIlHrc

coBer-

cKoFo

HHx(eHepa

JI.

D.

EepHuner?Ha

no

Hcnorb3oBaHHro

np

HJTHBHoft

auepruH

[9],

H

c

3THx

nosnuufi

noABepraJrcfl

KpHTHKe

npoeKr

Ksogr.r

1959-1961

rr.

Il02l.

2t2

Ha rrpnuepe

3Toro

npoeKTa

6u.na rro-

Ka3alra HeonrHMaJrbHocrb

4nyx6acceli-

rronoir

cxeMbr, npu xoropofi

Ha rroroKe

MoulHocrbrc

2 u.nH. xBr

nplr

nepeKpbrrHH

I I

-xn.nouerpoBbrMH

nJrorHHaMH

npoJrH-

BoB c

r'.ny6r.rHofi

ao

100

M

ycraHaBJrHBa-

JrHcb ryp6nHu

MoulHocrbro

scero

345

MBr. I-lpu arou BMecro

HcnoJrb3oBaHHt

HoBLJx Bo3Mo)KHocrefi

oAuo6accefi

Hoeofi

cxeMbr

no

TpaHcQopMauHH

BpeMeHtr

fe-

HepHpoBaHHq 3HeprHu

I-l3C B

qacbr

nH-

KoBoro norpe6aeuHfl

c floMoulbn

npH-

.rrltBHofo KancyJrbHoro

afpefaTa

B npo-

eKTe Hcnorrb3oBaracb

4nyx6accefi

Hosas

cxeMa,

KoTopaq 3Ty

3aAaqy

He

peuraJra,

HO

JIHurb

nOfJIOUIaJIa

3HepfHlO

H KanH-

TATOBJIO}KEHHq.

He

yBeHr{aracb ycnexoM

nonbrrKa

npeoAoneTb 3TH HeAocTaTKH

B npoeKTe

1963 r.

H oco6eHuo

B

orKoppeKrapo-

BaHHoM npoeKre

1964 r.

[260],

rAe

BMecro BeprHKaJrbHbrx

H rp1'6uarux

ar-

peraroB

6ulu npHMeHeHbr KancyJrbHbre

afperarbr, MoulHocrb

rroBbrtueHa

c

345

MBr

ao

I I'Br H rrpeAycMorpeHa

pa6ora

I-l3C n cucreMe

c

AByMq

f3C

([uxu

u

..,'lusxorrH-Cxya). O6uraq MoulHocrb

KoMnJreKca

AoJrx{Ha

6nua

c@TaBHTb

1,794

[-Br, a

nupa6orxa 3HeprHH

3,6

TBr.q, c

nepeAaqeri ee n

pafioH

Hosofi

Asr.nun

Ha

paccrotHHe

800

xr"r.

O4Haxo

crouMocrb

ycraHoBreHHoro

I

xBr

xortr-

nJreKca npn

3ToM cocraBHJra 610

ao.n.n.

(crouuocrb

rapaHTHpoBaHHoro

I

xBr

840

aon;r.),

r.

g.

e

3-4

pa3a

Aopoxe

3arpar

Ha

aJrbrepHarHBHbre

I-3C. [Io-

croqeHHyro KpHrHKy

[96,

136,

2201.

[IpnuuHu

ebrcoxofi cronMocru

npo-

exta

o6rqcHqrorcff nopoKaMu

4nyx6ac-

cefiHoeoft

cxeMbr:

Heus6exHoe

Arq

I{HK-

fia

!,exepa

Ay6rHpoBaHHe

MourHocrH,

znufrtugg!\ nq2naItJToILu40 nnar, uuq lI

l,

sJAlu. rr

HCNqIIHOC HC[OJIb3OBAHHC TCXHHI{CCKO|O

rroreHrrHara.

Bce

aro

ycyry6.na"nocr

HeaQQexrHBHocrbro nepeAaqH

3HeprHH

Ha

800 KM

npH

npeAerbHo

Bo3MoxHoM

'

rorAa Hanpflx(eHnu

345

xB.

OqegHAuo,

r{To

npHqHHa croJlb

ynop-

Horo npr.rMeHeHH

r He3QQeKrHslrofi

AByx-

6acefinoeofi cxeMbI 3aKJnoqaercr

He

TOJTbKO B

KOHCepBaTH3Me aBTOpOB

npo-

eKTa, HO

H

B

TOM,

qTO

B

TO BpeMfl

SHep-

reruKa

CIIIA eule

He co3pena

ArIfl

npH-

HflTHfl

npHJIHBHofi

eHeprHH 6ee

ee

caMo-

pelyJrHpoBaHHs.

HuesHo no3ToMy

He

MO|JTH

OnpaB,[aTbCs

B Te fo]Ibt

HAeH

AByx

npe3nAeHroB

CIIIA-Py3Be.rrbra

vl

KeHHeAH,

KoropHe

BHAeJru

B pearn3a-

ulIH

npoeKToB

KeoAAH

oAHy

H3 3aMe-

yd

rE,lDnDl,\

JdAdry

LEucl

u

ilultuJleH|4lt

aMepHKaHueB.

18.1

.2.

[lpoexrsr

Manbrx

l-l3C c

3drHae

Ko6cxyx

fIoA

eosAeftcrsHeru

gHep

rernqecKor^o

Kpn3uca

H uHpoKo

pa3BepHyrux

pa6or

no HcnoJrb3oBaHuro

npHJIHBHofi axeprnH

B

ApyrHx

crpaHax e

CIIA

s 70-x roAax

BHOBb

npOHCXOAHT

BO3BpaT K

npOeKTaM

fI3C

H, B

qacrHocrH,

K

n3C

KnotqH.

B

arux

paspa6orKax

cneAyer orMerflTb

orxoA

or

AByx6accefiHoeofi

xoHuenqnu,

KOTOparr

Ha

rrpoTflxeHHH

noJryBeKa

Top-

Mo3HJIa HcnoJrb3oBaHHe npu.nnnHofi

3HeprHH e

CIIA.

B

AoxnaAe

Kopnyca

BoeHHbtx

HHxe-

HepoB

1979 r.

Ha ocHoBaHHH

paccMor-

peHHr

90 crnopon

oAHo-H

,4nyx6ac-

cefiHonsrx

flSC

KeoAAH

orMeqaercs,

r{To

<4nyx6accefi

Hossre

cxeMbr,

o6ecnequsa

-

rouue

BbrAaqy

rapaHTnpoeaHHoft

Mour-

HOCTH,

flBflqrOTCff CJIHTUKOM

AOpOnOCTO-

flIlHMH,

qTO

npeAnoqTHTeJrbHee npoeK-

TnpoBarb n3C

HcxoAfl

H3

nupa6orxu

HMH

MAKCHMAJIbHOTO

KOflHI{CCTBA

3HCP.

tHH,

vr Hau6o.nsurHMu

3KoHoMHqecKHMH

npeHMyqecrBaMH

o6naAaror oAso6ac-

cefiHosure ycraHoBKH>

[2781.

B

AoxlaAe

cAeJaH

BbrBoA,

xoropuft

noKa3blBaer.

r{To

ero

aBTopbr

H3 oAHorl

xpafiHocru

BnaJrH

B

Apynyrc,

cqHTafl HaHoGrree

3Ko-

HouuqHofi

I-l3C c

6onsruori

rJroulaAbro

6accefiHa

H cpaBHHTeJrbHo

r*lalofi

ycra-

HoBJIeHHofi

uou{Hocrrrc.

3Aecb

npoBo3-

fJraulaercfl

Te3Hc,

nporHBope,{au1Hft

onbrry

HccJreAoBauux npo6.neMbr

H

npo-

eKTHpoBaHHq

il3C

-

Ha

MourHoM

noro-

Ke

npu.nnnHofi

3HeprHH

HepauuoHanb-

Ho

craBnrb

MaJryro

nOC.

HeAocraroqH

as

o6ocHosaHHocrb

no-

loxeHHfi

AoKJraAa

1979

r. noArBep-

XlIaeTcs p€3ynbTaTaMH

BbInOr'IHeHHbIX

npn

aroM

paspa6orox.

Ha ocHosaHHH

oro6pauHurx

BapHaH-

roB

Marrbrx tlSC

(puc.

l8.l) c

pa3rnr{-

HbrMH

crBopaMu

AJrHHHbtx

(ao

l0 xrrr) nao-

THH,

orceKarcurHx 6accefin

Ko6cryx,

aBTOpbr

AoKJraAa

npHunH K BbrBQAy,

qTo

BCe

CTBOpbt,

no3BGrtgtoulHe

no.rlyqHTb

or 160

lo

l!0

MBr

!.{oulHocru

u

or

SSg

Ao

338

l-sr.q eupa6orxu,

Aaror

noKa3a-

TeJtH,

HCKJItoqarctUHe

BO3MOX{HOCTb

HX

3KoHoMHr{ecKoro

o6ocHogaHun

(ornoure_

HHe

AoxoAa

K

3arparaM

0,55-0,59

H

croHMocrb

I xBr.u

or

6,3

1o

6,8

ueHra).

HeaxonouHrrHocrb

grux

npoeKToB

ycyny6.nnercn

raKxe

H KoHcepBarHB-

HbrM

oTKa3OM

aBTOpOB

npOeKTa

oT

npH_

MeHeHHfl

HanJraBHori

xoHcrpyKuuu,

Ko-

lopas

B To

BpeMfl

6ula

ocyqecrBJreHa

B

CCCP

H HcnoJrb3oBaHa

B

flpoexrax

I-IOC

OaH,qn

n

CeuepH. Eonee rono,

He

HMefl

Bo3Mox(Hocru

o6ecne,tHrb KoMneHcaunrc

MoulHocrH

Ma.irbrx

nOC,

yAaJrenHbrx

or

cHcTeMbr,

Hx

pervJlHpoBaHHe

npeAJIara-

aocb

ocyruecTBHTb

c noMorrlbro

cTpoH-

TeJrbcrBa

cneuHaJrbnux

I'A3C,

r{To

Bo3-

BpauaerHX

K npoeKry

Kso.[,qu

(1935

n.)

14 Bce-TaKH

Bo3BeAeHHe

o.[Hofi

lra.nofi

n3C

B 3roM

pafioHe

Mo)KHo

6urro

onpaBAarb.

fpynna

xnrenefi

no-

ce.rrKa

(500

anopoa),

o6c.ny)KHBaroulHx

sanoBeAHHK

flneseHr-flofiHr,

MeqraB-

ulHx

MHorHe

AecrrTHfleTHs

o noKope-

HHH npnansHori

sHeprr.ru

gal.

OauAn,

npeAJro)Kr.r.ira,

<noKa

cyA

Aa

Aeflo>,

rrocrponrb

Manyrc ngc

n

6yxre

XaS-

MyH

Koye

(puc.

l8.l

)

[195].

Enpo fIaccarvaKBo.(Ar{,

6asupyro-

uleecfl B

3roM

pafioHe

c

1936

r.,

s l98l r.

cocraBurro

npoeKr

[195,

2771, no

KoropoMy

nepeKpbrrue

BxoAa

a 6yxry

nnorunofi

.q.lruHofi

366 u

o6-

pa3yer

6accefin

nJrouaAbrc

1,2-

3.2

xrra2.

C

vqerou 4".:5.52 u

.ir,Byx

KancyJrbHbrx

arperaTax Motrl-

Hocrbro no

6

MBr

3Aecb

Mo)r(er

6uru

roryrreHo

32

fBr-q/noa

eHeprHH.

Croauocru

IISC cocraBrfler

34 ru.nn.

AO"'IJI.

(n

UeHax

1979

r.),

qTo

Aaer

5700

ao.rn/xBr

rpH

croHMocrn I xBr.q

6

qeuros.

Aflq

cpaBHeHHfl

yKa)KeM,

qTo

aHaJrof HqHbre

noKa3aTeJIH

Kpyn-

nofi

n3C

l(o6exyua

paBHbr

1580

ao;urlxBr

H

2,7

\eurl

(xBr

.

u

)

.

O.q,Haxo, c

yqeroM,

qro

B

,uanHou

pafi-

oHe

.?HepfocHa6xeHue

or MeJrKux-

Ar.r-

3eJrbHbrx

ycTaHoBoK

o6xoAHrcq

B

7,7

{eHV(xBr-v),

croHMocrb

sHep-

rnn [I3C

oKa3brBaereq

npneuleuofi,

xorq

oKynaeMocrb

nOC He

Aocrura-

ercfl (orHorueHue

AoxoAoB

K

pacxo-

AaM

(0,918).

CoeAanue nAC

XaQ-

213

MyH

Koyn

Mo)xer

6urr

onpaBAaHo,

TaK

xe KaK

sro 6ulo

npH coop)r)Ke-

unn

Knc.nony6cxofi

n3C

n

IISC

AH-

HanoJlHc,

ToJIbKO

KaK

SKCneprrMeH-

raluuori

ycraHoBKH.

18.1.3.

flpoexru

l-l3C

xo no6epox<se

Anrcxx

Bnepaure

npeAJroxeHHe

06

HcnoJrb-

3oBaHHH

Ans

crpoHTeJrbcrBa

n3C

3a-

JrHBoB,

oMuBarcuax

no6epe)Kbe

AJrflcKH,

6uao

c,qe.naso

,rl. 5.

Bepnu-rrefiHoM

B

196l

r.

[9,

285].

]ro

npe.i"troxeHHe

6u-

.no

o6ocsoBaHo

pa3MepaMH,

]Ao6Hrrrvr

oqepraHueM

3aJrHBoe

HHx n TepHarefiH,

3Har{HTeJrbHbtMH

npr.rnHBaMH

vr

yBepeH-

HOCTbIO

B

BO3MOXHOCTH

npOTHBOCTOtTb

JIeAoBbrM

eoaAeftcreueM.

3arHs

Kyxa

ry3pnHofi

2l

KM

BAaercq

B

MarepHK

Ha

370

rrtl,

a

6yxra

TepHarefiu,

BnaAarc-

urar

B

ga.n.

Hnx,

HMeer

AnHHy

2l

xu.

O6uaq

aKBaropufl

saJrHBa

c@TaBrser

ql_00

KM2,

np; 3HepronoreHuHarre

Ts

TBr

ne.nuqsni

cpeAHero

np:ailuBa y

rop-

ta

I'pexerr,r

4,39,

y

r.

AuxopuAx

7,65,

B crBope

KycraraH-

Huxnurxa

9,15

rrl

f 1201.

flepnoe

xe

HccneAoBaHHe,

npeAnpH-

Hsroe aHrJlaficxuuH

cneuHaJIHcraMH,

noKa3aJro Bo3MolKHocTb

nolyqeHHt

tcl E lo n t-E- ^---- f6oFr

JAeUb rarl)- lo,u l

E l

MU|.I{H()Lt'H

tzool.

Ha ocHoBaHHH

sccae4onaunfi,

BbrnoJI-

HeHHbtx B 1977-1981 rf.,

AHpeKrop

sHepreru'{ecKoro ynpaBreHHs

I(aHa4sr

IOaa 3affBHJr:

<Haruqne

orpoMHoro

no-

TeHrrHaJra npu.nuaHofi

3HeprHH

3aJr.

Kyxa

He

Bbr3brBaer HHKaKnx

couuesnfi>

t2681.

Kopnopauur

Stone

and

Webster,

xoropofi

6una nopyqeHa

paspa6orra

npoeKroB

I-l3C B

3arr.

Kyxa

a 1977

r.,

paccMorpena

l6

crBopoB,

H3 Koropbrx

6rr.nu

eu6paHul

rpu

uan6oJree

nepcneK-

rHBHbrx

(psc.

18.2)

1891.

llpe4napurerrb-

HHe

pacqerrr

[278]

noKa3aJru,

rrro,

He-

cMorpr

Ha 6olluroe

Ko.rruqecrBo

3Hep-

rHH,

Koropoe

Moxer 6trrl

noJryqeHo

B

arHx

croopax

(Al

u A2-otuo6accefi-

HoBbre

cxeMbr, nupa6orxa

I l,

8 TBr.,{,

MourHocrb 2,35

I'Br;

A3

-

AByx-

6accefiHosafl

cxeMa,

o6reAuusroulaff

aK-

BaropHro

A2 u Becb

3an.

Hur, nupa6or-

Ka 10,5

TBr.rr, MorrlHocrb

2,6 fBr),

aQQexrunHocrb

Hx He

Mox(er 6uru

o6ec-

neqeHa,

a cToHMocTb

ycTaHoBJIeHHOTO

I xBr

AoxoAHr

Ao

2600

lo.nn.,

rorAa

KaK

crponrerrbcrBo

f3C

Epaa.nu n

parl-

oHe f.

Anxopu4xa

B To

BpeMrr

oueHu-

Barrocb

s 700

Aqlrn/xBr.

3ro

o6tscnsercq

c.[ox(HbrMH

reoJro-

nHqecKHMH

H IeAOBbIMH yCJTOBUAMH,

a

TaKxe

Heo6xoAr.rrrrocrbro

npoflycKa

pbr-

obl

r{ep$

crBopbr

llgc.

Kpor',re

Bbrco-

rori

crouuocrH

rJIaBHbrM

npenflTcrBneM

K

OCyIIIeCTBJTeHHIo

H SKOHOMHTTeCKOMy

o6ocHosaHuro

npoexron

flSC

Ha A.ns-

cKe

E 1977

r.6ulo

orcyrcrBHe

raM

co-

orBeTcrByroulero ypoBHfl

norpe6neuua

H 3HeprocncreM,npn

Koropou

no4o6Ho

ceBepo-BocrorrHbrM

ruraraM

CIIIA

H

trpo-

BHHTTHsM

KaHaAu

MoxHo

6urao 6ur

npr.r-

HfTb

H

parIHoHaIbHo

HCnOJIb3OBaTb

npHnHBHyto

3HeprHrc.

B

noeneAytolll.He

roAbr

cHT)/aqHs

crafla

r.r3MeHsrbcs.

Ec.nu s 1977 r.

HMe-

JIHCb Jrr-ilUb

npeAnonox(eHHq

o

pa3BHTHH

3HepreTHKH,

BnJrOTb

AO

CO3AaHHff 3Hep-

roeMKHx

npoH3BoAcTB

aJITOMLIHUfl

H BO-

AopoAa,

ro

s 1980

r.

QaxrNuecKoe

3Hep-

ronorpe6neHue

B

pafioue

r.

AHropu4xa

((xe'te3HoAopoxHufi

noncr)

AocrHfJlo

^^lFnt---,--

2,6

I

ttT.

t{

(K

rUMy

,fie |'HPdudrDrtrdrc-

Mbtx

Ha

rasoryp6uHHblx

ycraHonxax).

Haqaaocr

cTpot{TgltbcrBo

He6onuurux

f3C

N

npoeKrllpoBaHHe

BecbMa

xpynHoli

f3C

na

p.

CycurHa,

BnaAaolueft

n

sar.

Hux,

HanpornB

r. AHxopu,qxa,

MoulHo-

cTblo

1,6 fsr

H

crouMocrblo

oKoJIo

5

unpa.

AoJIJI.,

a

raKxe

6sulo

HaMeqeHo

cTpoHreJlbcrso

I'3C

6pa,nrrn

Ha

paccrofl-

Hvnl

177

KM

or

r.

AHxoPnaxa [196].

VqHrstsaq

aru

o6crofreJlbcrBa,

aA-

MHHHcrpaqHs

lurara

Arqcxa

s

1980

r-

accurHoBa.na

0,5

u;tH.

AoIIJI.

Ha

cocraB-

JreHHe

HoBoro

npoeKra.

B l98l

r'

Qup-

ua

Acres

American

3aHoBo

paccMorpe-

ila

BaptaHrrr

fI3C

B

paHee

npeAnox(eH-

uux

Ctnopax

[268]:

fl3C

a craoPe

.4

/,

xoropuft

npH3Haercs

HaHJIYqUIHM,

orreHHBaercfl

B 3,8

r,alpA.

Ao[r.

H

npH

MoulHocrt{

1,44

fBr

o6ecne'Iut

I'oAoByto

nupa6orxy

4,03

TBr'q,

flSC

B crBope

A3

npu MoulHocrH

1,26

fBr

oKa3blBaer-

cq

Hara6qnee KanuTaJloeuxofi-4,

I trl.npA.

ao.trir.

[89].

Crouuocru

I

xBr3440aom.

HeorrlH-

qaercr

or

noJlyqeuHofi

npacuere

1977r.

(c yuerov nepexoAHoro

xoaQQu_[ueura),

a

3arparbl Ha

crpoureJlbcrBo

fI3C He-

HaMHO|O npeBblluator

3aTparbl

no npo-

exry

f3C

Ha

p.

Cycurua.

flocxo"nrxy

I{HCflO qaCOB

Hcnoflb3oBaHHq

MOUIHOCTH

I-l3C e 2

paza

MeHbIIIe,

qeM

Ha

f3C,

oue-

BHAHo,

r{To

Bonpoc

o

crpoHTeJIbcTBe

n3C

sa

A.nscxe

Moxer

6urr

peuteH

To.[bKo

no6epexue.

B

BepuHHe fyAaoHona

D r, r V-nqpq u dtn^6rrrrran

JqJt.,

D Jqrr.

u rrr

quu

YHvvnuLP

cpeAHffq

BeJrr{r{HHa

rrpHJIHBa

5,8-8,8

r..r

tl20l.

B 3arr.

@asAn,

HMerculeM

nrro-

uaAb

12

850

KM2,^_ArIHHy_

265

xv,

ruH-

pHHy

npH

BXoAe

bb

xu,

onaroAaps

ero

aopoHxoo6paanoft

Qopue

u

penr@y

aHa

Ha6.npAaercs

pe3oHaHc, npH

KoropoM

BeJrHqHHa

npHJIHBa or

0,6-1,5

v Ha

BXOAe

B 3aJIHB

yBe.[Hr{HBaeTCt

AO

HaH-

6orsuefi

B MHpe

(16,2

ul

12721.

I-lpupo.uHule

ycroBzq

cenepHoft

qac-

TH 3aJr.

OaHAU

cxoAHbt c

ycJIoBLrnMH

crBo-

pa

MeseHcxofi

tlSC:

cpeAHHe

qHBap-

cKHe

reMneparyput

-

8"

C, ToJIUTHHa

.nrAa

Ao

4,5,

Bbtcora

BoJIHbI

I

o/o-ttok

o6ecneqessoctn

8

u.

Cauue

BbIcoKHe

Ha nJlaHere npHJIHBbI

yx(e B l9l2

f.

BbBBaJIH

npeAJIoxeHHe

Tepn6y"rr,ra

o

co3AaHHH

ue6oarurofi

4nyx6accefiHonofi

n3C

B

ycrbqx

peK

Mer'rpauxyx

u

flruxoAnax.

I-io npoeKry

3fixpaa

1944

r. MoutHocrb

ee noAHq-

rracb

Ao

200

MBr.

B 1916

r. 6stlo

BbIABHHyTo

npeAJIo-

x<eHue

coopyAr.trb

B MafiHac-6eficuH

fl3C r"rourHocrbro

7,4 MBt

t2721.

He

vHo-

IOTIHCJICHHbIX

NPOCKTOB

COOPY)KCHHq

n3C

s

pafioHe r. Arr,rxepcra,

npeAcraB-

JrrrBuruxcn

HaqHHafi

c 1927

r., 3HeprerH-

qecKaq

KoMHccHfl

Hoeofi

lllor..IasAptt't

nu6pa.na

s

1944

F.

4nyx6accefiHo-

Byro

ycraHoBKy

B

ycrbflx

pex

Maaxan

n Xo6opr

MourHocrbro

39

MBr.

VqHrunaq

orpaHHqeHHocrb

co6cr-

BeHHbrx 3Hep

fopecypcoB,

np aBHTSIIbcTBO

npoBHHIIHH

Hblo-bpaHcyHK

npeAJIo-

xHJro noAroroBHTb

AJIfi

yAOBJIeTBOpeHHS

nepcneKTHBHbIX

norpe6Hocrefi

e 3JIeKT-

posHeprHH

AoKJIaA

O

BO3MOX(HOCTH

CTpO-

HTeJIbcrBa

llSC e ear.

OaHAH

Ha ocHo-

Be BbrrueyKa3aHHbtx

npe,4.noxeuafi

.

B l96l

r. TpeHxo.nrtu,

opHeHrHPY-

qcb

Ha

orpoutHutfi

ganosHfi

aHeprono-

reHrrHaJr aa.n. @asAu

(255

TBr.u),

foBo-

pHn

o

Bo3Mo)KHoft

nepcneKTHBe

co3Aa-

nuq

flSC

n 6yxrax llleno,qn

u

Kar'r6ep-

JreHA

MOUIHOCTbTO

1,8

fBr, a B 6yxre

Mofluan-Rorlnrru - rrrlrtrun/rrr-rr\ 3 I-Rl

arlqalll49-vvlr9flrl

rtrvlr+rrvv^s.v

Atrs

crpoureJlbcrBa

nepeofi n3C

oH

npeAJrox(HJI

BMecro

4eyx6accefinosoft

oAuo6accefinonyn

cxeMy

MourHocrblo

450 MBr c

perynHpoBaHneM

ee

c

no-

Moulbro cneuuaJlbHo

nocrpoeHnoft

fT)'

t2721.

c

yqeToM

pa3MepoB

nepcneKTHBHoI'o

Bafl Bo3Mo)I(Hocrb

npH

AaJlbHeiruleu

npo-

eKTHpOBaHHH

ynyqul,ITb

9KoHoyHtlHOCTb

nOC,

B

r{acrHocrx

nyreM

[pHMeHeHHs

HanJraBHbrx

xoHcrpyxuHfi,

npeA.nara-

nocb npexAe Bcefo

H3yIIHTb_

[epCneKTH-

Bbr 3HeprerHKH

pafrona

t2681.

I8.2.

CTPOI4TENbCTBO

N3C

B 3AJIHBE

oAHAh

1E.2.1.

flpoexr Fl3C Oaxsn,1969

r.

Ha eanaAnou

no6epexbe

KaHaAu

e

EpuraHcxofi

Ko.nyu6uH

seJuqHHbI

npH-

JIHBoB

H3MeHtlorcfl

or

5

u s

llopr.nen-

Ae

Ao

3,5

r'r

n 6yx.

ffepnnc

6nna

Bas-

l(yBepa.

3saqnre.nrHo

6otee

BblcoKHe

npHJIHBbI

ua6uIrcAagrcg

Ha

BocroqHoM

2t5

TeMbt

Anfi

o6ecneqeHHfl

norpe6HocrH

B

nHKoBofi

MourHocrH.

KaHaAcxlte

HH)Ke-

Hepbl

noJrHocTblo

BocnpllHnJItl 3Ty

KoH-

uenuttn.

foAnH, ccburaqcb

ItMeHHo

Ha

Hee,

npeAJro)rcrJl

pqa

fl3c

B 3aJI. VHra-

Ba

MortHocrbro 6,26

fBr

tl67l.

Ho rrae-

Hoe

BHHMaHue

6uao

yAeJIeHo

aa.n. @au-

AH,

rAe

nucoxHfi

gHepronoreHuuaJt

npH-

ilHBa

coqeraercr c

orHocurensHofi

6;ut-

3ocrbro r

pafionav cyurecrBytourero

H

nepcnexTr.rBHoro

eHepronorpe6.neHur

(pnc 18.3) H K

MourHbrM sJteKrpocraH-

uHsM.

B

arov

pet-HoHe

pacnoJloxeHbl:

3HeprocucreMa

npHMopcKHx

nponuHuufi

Maritime

Integrated

System

(MIS),

o6cnyxnoarcurafl

KaHaAcKHe

npoBHH-

uupr

Hrrc-EpaHcyux

H Hosas

[UouaH-

AHr,

o.

flpuuua 3,qyap,qa,

cucreMa

faapo-Kse6ex,

H

cllcreMa

(New

Eng-

land

Power Pool

(NEPOOL),

o6cny-

xHBaroutas

rrrrarbr

Hosofi Aurnuu CIIIA.

B

1965

r. 6srna ony6lnxoBaHa

cxeMa

Bo3Mox(Hbrx crBopoB n3C

[1801,

B Ko-

TOp

brx HcnoJrb3oBaHHe

3Hep

ronoreHLlHa-

Jra 3aJr.

@aH4u npeAJlaraJlocb

Aaxe

B

3HaqHTeJIbtro

6onee uHpoKr.rx

Mactrrra-

a--- - fn I

uax,

qeM

paccMal'plrrraJrocb

ts

lv l.

OrceqeHlre

Bcero

3aJIrrBa

n"toruHofi

A.ruusofi

77 xu (crnop

/) noano"rur.no

6sr

Iloryt.luTt MouIHocTb

77 lBr. fl.noruHa

B

crBope

7

(Maftuac-EeficHH)

A.nuHofi

7 xM

nossoJrHra

6u no.nyunrb

Mou{Hocrb

26 fBr

(puc.

18.4).

flpegnapurerrbHbre

pacr{erbr [oKa3aJrH.

rrro

uau6o.nee

eS-

QexrneuuM

Mo)Ker

sBl4Tbcfl

crBop

3

(rr,r.

CneHcep), rAe

AJTHHa

nflorHHbr

52,2

xu npH Hau6o.nnurefi

r;ry6uHe

73 rrl

no3BoJrfler

pa3Mecrurb

B

3AaHHV

ngc

A.nusofi

l7 xr*,r B nsrb

rpycoB arperarbr

o6urefi

MourHocrbro

64

fBr.

3rH npopa6orxu

npHBenH

Qe4epa;rt-

Hoe npaBHTeJrbcrBo

KasaArr

K

perleuHro

co3Aarb

B

aBrycre 1966 n. BMecre

c npo-

BHHrrHaJrbHbrMH

npaBHTeJIbcrBaMH

Huro-

Epancyux

u Hoeofi lllor.nauAl.rrr

Ar-

JraHTHqecKoe

ynpaBJreHHe

no

npofpaM-

Me npunr.teuofi

eueprulr

(Atlantic

Tidal

Porver

Programming

Board).

Vnpae-

JTeHHe

rrrHpoKo

pa3BepHyJro

HccJreAoBa-

HHfl,

H3brcKaHHfl H

npOeKTHpOBaHHe

Prc.

18.3.

PaccroqHue

or crBoDoB

po-Bocror{Hou

no6epexrc

CIIIA

a

@aH4n

ao

upoMbrtu.rreHHbrx

IleHTpoB

Ha

cege-

IISC

s

sa.r.

Kanaau

^------J

^

HllH

HMeBUHXCS

TOFAa

OrpaHHqeHHbrx

rIHff

npo6neuu,

c@pMynupoBaHHarr

B

ony6nnxoBaHHbrx

s

CCCP

HccJreAoBa-

rrrqflI

[4,9].

Tar,

n

npexHux

npoer(rax

tl3C

s

KaHaAe

npeAJrararrocb

Ha

Mout-

Hbtx

noroKax

npHJrungofi

oHepfHH,

Ha-

npHMep

ts 3aJi.

Mai?Hac-6eficuH,

noroK

Koroporo

o6.naAaer

MorrlHocrbro

l8

fBr,

ycraHoBHrb

Ma"reHbKyro

n3C (0,007

fBr)

H

HcnoJrb3oBarb

ee

H3oJrHpoBaH-

Ho.

B nporuBon_oJro)KHocrb

raKoMy

pe-

IileHHro

B

[4,

9l npe4.nafarocb

BMecro

MaJreHbKHx

;lnyx6accefiHonsrx

ycraHo-

BOK

HCNO.[b3OBATb

MAKCHMAJIbHO

MOIII-

urre

IISC

(Mar?Hac-EericHn

-

18,

[ftlr-

HeKro

-

12

FBr)

r{ BMecre

c auepruefi

aHaflorarrHbrx

n3C

CIIIA

BJrHrb

Hx

3Heprnro

n

o6teAHHeHHbre

3Heprocnc-

AaHHbrx

no

reoJrorHqecr(oMy

cTpoeHHro

pycJra

npeAnolaraJrocb

ycTaHoBHTb

B

nJIorHHe,

orcexarculeft

61'xrrr

lllenoAu

H

Kau6ep.rreu4,

100

arperaroB

o6qefi

MolldHocrbro

900

MBr c Bo3MolKHbrM

yBe-

JIHqeHHeM

MOUIHOCTH

nOCJIe

HCCJTeAOBa_

nufi

Ao

1,8

I'Br.

flonaras,

r{ro

B 20-ner-

Hefi

nepcneKTHBe

norpe6uocrn

pafioua

cocraBrr

20

TBr. u/rog,

a

HccJreAoBa:

,r!,

npoeKTHpOBaHHe

H

CTpOHTeJTbCTBO

3aHMyT

lU

JIeT,

B

AOKJIaAe

npeAJraraJrocb

YTBCPAHTb

ACCHTHOBAHH'I

B

PA3MCPC

2 unH.

AoaJI.

Ha

HccreAoBareJrbcKue

H

npoeKTHo-H3HcKareJrbcKHe

pa6orrr.

npt

paccMorpeHnu

cJreAyrorqux

npo-

eKroB

nOC

B

3aJr.

@an4n

BHAHo,

r{To

Ha

"c

Pxc.

18.4.

Mecronorox(eHue

crBopoB n3C

s

I-7- npoeKr

1965 r.

[80];7.t,7.2,8.1

-npoeKr

ea.r.

OaHas:

1969

r.

[94];

AI-413, Bl-Bl0

-

npoeKr

1977 r.

l229l

10

20

KM

216

217

fl3C n

sar.

OaHAn.

Ha pa6orsr

6sr.no

or-

nvn(eHo 2,5

u.ryg.

Ao-4.r!.,

oHLr 3aKoHrIH-

JtHcb

B

1969

r.

cocraBJreHueM

AoKnaAa

sBosrvroxHocTu

HcnoJr

b3oBaHHfl

npHJIHB-

uofi

sueprHn

sail.

OaHAu>

[g4],

xoropufi

B

AaJ-rbHefirueM

H3Jror(eHHH

s

Hacroqueri

KHHre

Ha3brBaercfl

npoeKToM

l9O9

r.

Eunu

r.r3vqeHbr

23

crnbpa,

a.

TaKlr{e pa-

Hee

npeAllaraBlxHecfl

cTBopbr,

oTceKaB-

uue

Becb

3arrHB (puc.

18.4).

CosAaH-

HbIC

MATCMATI{IICCKHC

MOAEJIH

ATq

ONPE-

AeJreHHfl

EJTHflHHfl

coopyxeHr.rq

n3C Ha

BerHr{HHy

npn.nuna (rl.

l0)

npr.rne.nn

x

Heo6xoglll,rocrH

HcKJrFoqeHHr

He roJrbKo

crBopoB

I-4 (s

roM

rrHcJre

u no

coo6pa-

xeHHflM

vpesuepnofi

uoulHocru),

Ho

tr

nepeABHx(KH

K BepluHHe

3aJTHBOB

Apy-

rux

crBopoe

c

6oree cKpoMHofr

r*loulHo-

crbro. Tar,

pacnoJroxeHae

nJroruHbr

npH

BxoAe

B

3aJr.

Illursexro

(crnop

4

ua

pnc.

l8-4)

yMeHbuHr

BenHqHHy

npurru-

non

Ha

1/,

H cAeJraer

3Tor crBop 3HaqH-

reJIbHo

MeHee

sQ$exrnaHbrM.

B

pesy.rru-

TaTe paccMoTpeHHrr

B npoer{Te

oTAaHo

npeArorrreHue

Il33l

crBopaM 7.1 B

6yxre

IUenoAr.r

(uoulnocru

I-l3C 1,62

lBr),

7.2

a

6yxre

Kar*r6ep.neu4

(r'roq-

Hocrb

nOC

0,97

fBr)

u

8.1

o

6yxre

Ko-

6eryu4 (ruoulnocrr

|ISC

2,17 fBr).

BapuaHrHoe

paccMorpeHHe

noKa3a-

JIo,

qro

oAHocropoHHfffl

pa6ora

npnBo-

Ar.rr

K

yMeHbtueuuto

Bbrpa6orxu

B

grHx

crBopax

ua

22

v

14

o/o.

Kportle

roro,

ABycropoHuaa

pa6ora

HMeer ro npeuMy-

ulecrBo,

rrro

oHa o6ecneqnsaer BbrAaqy

or 4

Ao

70

o/o

gHeprHH

B

qacbr

nnKoBoro

(n3C

rpe6yer

6o.nsruux

KanHraJroBno-

vouuri rr vn^lra F^F^

/rrLrrrrrr

rr,

r\pvtvrL

rLrl

v, no

rtpul 'r-?llgttllu

MHorHx Jrer

Bbrpa6orxa

3HeprHH

B

Jrro-

6ol,r

us

crBopoB

6y4er HaMHoro

npe-

BOCXOAHTb

BO3MOXHOCTH

ee HCnOJIb3OBa-

Hus

o0te4uHeHHofi

cncrenroft

llpnrtaop-

cKHx

nposuHuHfi.

CnegonarerbHo,

AoJrx(Hbr

6urt npeAycMorpeHbr

AonoJr-

HHTeJIbHhre

3aTpaTbr,

H38a

qero

npH-

ilHauafl,

3Heprufl

sar.

OaHAH

craHoBHT-

cfl HeKoHKypeHTocnoco6Hofi

c

npoqH-

MH

HCTOr{HHKaMH

SHeprHH,

AOCTynHbIMH

Arrfl

6y4yu1ux

norpe6ure.nefi>

tl47l.

OqeenAHo

raKx(e,

qro

npHrrusofi

Ao-

poroBn3Hbr

coopyx{eHss

flSC no npo-

exry

1969 r.

ffBHJrcfl

orKa3

or

npHMeHe-

HHfl

Ha[JraBHoro

cnoco6a,

xoropuli

3Aecb

oKa3aJrcfi

Ha

10-14

o/o

Aopoxe,

rreM

TpaAr.rrruossuft

cnoco6 Bo3BeAe-

HHr

coopyxesurf

3a nepeMbrqxauu.

3ro

Mox<er

6uru

o6rqcHeHo

reM,

qro

Bo Bpe-

Mfl

cocraBJreHHfl

npoeKTa

He

6buru ony6-

JIuKoBaHbr

,[aHHbIe

o HanJIaBHofi

roHcr-

pyKuHH

Kncnory6cxofi

I-13C, rrooroMy

6ur.na

npHHsra

KoHcrpyKrtufl

B BHAe

x(e-

.[ego6eroHHoro

ryp6uuuoro BoAoBoAa,

Ha

KOTOpOM

paCrroJIOX(eHa

rUaXTa

AJrf

MoHTaxa

arperara

c

nocJreAyrcqeri

yx-

naArofi

KaMeHHoro

6al"nacra.

Kpoue

TOnO,

npeAycMaTpHBaJIOCb

npHMeHeHHe

HanJraBnofi

xoucrpyKuuH

Ha

yqacrKax

crBopoB,

rpe6oaaaruux

BbInoJIHeHHff

Aoporocroqrqefi

no.ueoAHoir

cxa.ntHofi

BbICMKH.

18.2.2. flpoexr

fl9C

@axeu 1977 r.

12281

no H3yqeHurc

flpuJulsnofi

sHeprHH, no

peKoMeH.qa\uv Koroporo 3/XII 1975 r.

6u.no

noAnncaHo

corJrarreHne o

nepe-

cMorpe

npoeKra 1969 r. Ha

eror

HosHii

npoeKT

ornyueHo 3,6 u.nH.

AonJI.

H co3-

Aaii

aAMriHHcTpariraui,rfi

KoMHTeT Bo

rJraBe

c

K.napxou,

HMff

xoroporo

Ha

npoTflxeHHH

MHOTHX

JreT

OJTHUeTBOpfl-

eT

nnoAoTBopHyro

AeRTeJIbHocTb

Ka-

HaACKHX CneUHaJIHCTOB

nO nOKOpeHHrc

npHJrHBoB

OaH.qu. B

uon6pe 1977

r.

6ur

npeAcraBJreH

npoeKr noA

Ha3Ba-

HHeM

<flepecuorp

npHJrHBHofi

eHepruu

@aHAn>

12281.

Ha ocHose 6onee rurarerbHoro

Hc-

cJreAoBaHun

23 crBopoB 6u.na noArBep-

xAeHa

uau6onnuras eQQexrunHocrb

Tpex

pauee

au6pauHbrx crBopoB, Koro-

pbre renepb

noryr{riJrH HoBoe

o6oauaqe-

Hne

(puc.

18.4): crBop [Ileno,ql.r

-

46,

Kar'r6ep.neuA-

A8 n

Ko6exyu4

-

89.

B ounque or

npoexra 1969 r. npH-

HffTa

ycraHoBKa

roJIbKo

oAHocTopoHHe-

ro

Aeficretfl,rrplt

xoropofi

yAaJrocb

yBe-

B

crBopax

89 n 48.

Kporue

rofo,

H3yqe-

HHe K ToMv BDeMeHH onv6nur<nRqrrs.rF.l

--- -- ----J

-r---------

u

anpo6upoBaHHoro

onbrra

coopyxeHHn

HanJraBHErM

cnoco6ou

Kuc.norv6cxofi

I-l3C

noseoJrHJro r

J-r

oxe' H e n

u

o. *' u' i'fff,

:i

:?;?

J3i#ffi

-

Hocm

groro

cnoco6a,

H,

npHHgB

ero, cy-

UIecTBeHHO

CHH3HTb

CTOHMOCTb

OCy-

ulecrBreHnn npoOxra.

B

npoexre paapa6oraHbr

KoHcrpyK-

qHH

HanflaBHbtx

6toxon 3AaHr{H

n3C

(pnc

18.5)

H BoAonponycxHofi

nrrorn-

nu

(ctrr. puc.

12.4).

E.nox

3AaHHfl

n9C

(Ars

crsop

a

A8) BMer.qaer

ABa

arperara

H

HMeer

pa3Mepbr

54x47

X 41,05

v;

6.nox

c

AByMfl

BOAOnpOnycKHbrMH

oTBepCTHR-

MH

HMeer

pa3Mepbr

50,6 x

38,1

x

38

rr.r

(rax

xe KaK

Ans

3AaHHfl

fl3c, nocJreA-

r-tnfi

pasvep

-

Bbrcora

nepeMeHHafl,

ga-

Bucflurafl

or rny6nHbr B

crBope).

flpn-

HflTbt

KancyJlbHble

arperaTbl,

Ho

nocJle

noryqeHHfl

pe3yJtbTaroB

sKcnnyaTa-

UHH

arperara

CrpaQ.rro Ha flSC

AHna-

noJrHc H nPH

noATBepxAeHHH

ero

npeHMyurecrB,

sarBJreHHbrx

QHprr,roft

(c'r.

$

I1.4),

6yaer

peuren

Bonpoc

o ero

npHMeHeHHH.

Ans

yAeueBJreHHfl

greKTpHrrecKoro

o6opy,uonaHufl B npoeKTe

npHMeHeHbr

ra-

30HanOJrHeHHbre

tuHHOnpOBOAbI

H

BbI-

KJIIOqATEJIH.

B

pesy.nrrare

flpnHsrbrx B npoeKTe

l.rsMeHeHr.rfi

gKoHoMHqecKHe

noKa3areJlH

AByx

nOC cyqecrBeHuo

ynyqtunJrucb,

a

crBop 46 us

4a.nruefturero

paccMorpe-

e6resss.

HHfl

CTOHMOCTH

nponeJrJrepHbrx

arpefa-

ToB H

yMeHbuennr

3arny6nenws

3AaHHfl

npu

HcKJrroqeHHH

sacocHofi

pa6orur

npeAfloqrenHe

or4aHo

o4uocropouuefi

cxeMe.

Hecuorpn

Ha ro,

rrro

B

npoeKTe

-l

obrJrH

npHHflTbr

MOAeJrb

r.rcnoJrb3oBal/.ufl

llSC

n

o6teAuneHnofi

eHeprocncreMe

H

HaIIJlaBHafl

KoHCTpyKUHq,

3KCnepTH3a

npoeKTa,

npoBeAeHHaff

B

1970 r.,

oTMe-

Tvila,

r{To

(npn

conperueuuofi

craBKe

yqerHoro

npo(er{ra

(7

Vo)

SuuaHcu-

nnRelrup nt.rtrrLrrarrl^,r.Elq T-IAf dia-trrr sD-

^

LdrpL

r sq

I rvv x STLAJL trD

JIflCTCf

gKOHOMHITCCKH

HCONPABAAHHbIM,

TaK

KaK npu

srofi

yueruofi

craBKe

cro-

HMocrb

t

i<Br.,r

tlSC'cocraBur

5,6qeu-

Ta, T.

e. nor{Tn

a 2

paza

6ontue croHMo-

crn

3Heprur.r

TOC

ll47l.

B saxrrorreHufi

K npoeKTy

sro

o6tscHflercr

reM,

qro

218

PaspaeHnruuficq

P 1973 r.

3Hepre-

ruqecrnft

KpH3Hc

c Karacrpo$uvecrau

AJIfi

KanHTaIHCTHTTeCKHX

CTpaH

pOCTOM

IIeH

Ha HaQnn

(uena

sa

6appe;rb noAcKo-

quJra

c

2

no

30

aon.n.)

oco6enHo ocrpo

oqyuaJlcfl

B

KaHaAcKHx npoBHHuHrx,

npHMbrKaprllHx

K sar. @aHAH, nocKoJrb-

xy

48

% enexrpo3HeprHH B

3ueprocflc-

rertre

MIS

npoH3BoAHJrocb

Ha

3JreKTpo-

CTAHIIHffX,

T,ICTIOJIb3Y}OUIHX HCQtU

t

I88].

VvHrHsas

grr.r

o6croqrerbcrBa, a

Tqv.va nnnth6^^ b 6dvrrnr^Frrlr ^Fnnrr-

rqt\^v

rryvrpvLL

p

tgAnuJtul nn

utpvn-

TeJrbcrBa,

ryp6ocrpoeHHfl

H

ycoBep-

ureHcTBoBaHHe

MeToAoB

onTHMH3arIHH

sHeprHH

flSC n

cucreMe, npaBHreJrbcrBa

nponHuunfi

Hrro-EpaHcyHK

H Hoeas

IlIornauAnn

u

Se4epanbHoe

npaBHreJrb-

crBo

KaHaArr

co3AaJrH HosHfi KoMHTer

JrHrrnrb

nupa6orxy B n3C

Ko6exyr4

(c

7,56 TBr.q

B npoeKre 1969 r.

,qo

12 TBr.v)

HacroJrbKo,

qro

oHa

oKa3a-

Jracb

paBlaoit

unu

Aaxe

npeauuarculeri

nupa6orry

npn

ABycropoHHefi

pa6ore.

flpu

groM

oKa3aJrocb,

rrro

ABycropoH-

Hnn

pa6ora

cnuxaer

ornorueHne

AoxoAoB

K 3arparaM

AnE

crBopa 89 c

1,07

lo

0,81, a

Mfl

crBopa A8 c 0,93

ao

0,81

lr50l.

Sror

napaAoKc, nporHBope,raqufi

npoeKry

1969

r. u

ApyrHM

npoeKraM

Ha

Meeencxofi

flSC fl BbI.

paoorKa

npeBbr[raeT

oAHocTopoHHroro

Ha

18

,

Ha

ll3C CenepH

-

aa 25

o/o),

pac-

cMorpeH

a

rn.

4

n o6rscusercfl

,

oqeBHA-

HO, OrpaHLIqeHHeM

BO3MOXHOCTH

yBeJIH-

qeHns

pa3Meqenr.rff

afperaros

6es

noA-

aoAHofi

crarrHofi

BbreMKH.

3Aecu orMe-

THM .rrHrrrb,

qTo

aBTopbr

npoeKTa cqHTa-

rcT

peueHHe

o

npHHflTHH

oAHOCTOpOH-

Hefi

pa6orbr

He oKoHrrareJrbHbrM H Hccfle-

AoBaHHe

erofi

npo6JreM[,r

peuHJIH

npoBe-

crx Ha

cJreAyroqefi ctaynu

npoeKlHpo-

BaHHq ll22l.

E.rraro4apr nporpeccy e ryp6ocrpoe-

HHH, a Tapl(e

OnTHMH3aUHH

paCqeTHOrO

Hanopa

H

rracToTbr

BparqeHHn

anpefa-

ToB

H B

pe3ynbTaTe

HccJreAogauufi,

gu-

gBHBIUH

X MeHbUlee CHH)KeHHe BeJIHqHHTTI

npHflHBa,

6H.na noAHrra

MoulHocrb

nOC

HHq

6Hr

HcKruoqeu.

BaxHuu BKJTaAoM n

1977

r.

s

o6ocnosaHue

s@rruaHoro HcnoJlb3o-

BaHHfl

fl3C

asnrcfl

cucreMHufi aHarus

BbrflBJreHHff

eQQerra

yqacrns

llSC

s

o6teAnxenHux

gHeprocHcreMax

npH-

Mopcxr{x

npoeuu[nft

MIS, npoBHH-

uau Kae6ex

(Hydro-Quebec)

H ulraroB

Honofi AHuun

CIXA

(cHcreua

NEPOOL)

[150,

190, 2281.

nns

3roro 6u;ro

paccMorpeHo

yqa-

crue II3C

B

crBope 89

n

cucrerrlax

MIS

n NEPOOL.

flpe4noJraraercr,

qro

B

cH-

ereMe MIS

t<

3ToMy

BpeMeHH

B cryr{ae

or-

cyrcrBHfl tlSC 6yayr pa6oraru

3rexr-

pocraHIIHH

MolIlHocrbro 7,8

I'Br, a rotu

qHcfle

AOC

r*rorqHocrblo

3,4 fBr, a

s

2010 r.

cyMMapHafl

MorrtHocrb cocraBuT

32,5 fBr, B roM

qucJre

A3C

-

20,7

u

fTY

-

4,5 fBr c o6rqefi nupa6orrofi

219

Бернштейн Л.Б. Приливные электростанции

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.